Tobacco Documents Online

2~.20052~3 • -- .. S'ubje~'t Co-Claims of-Pr[~il.ege.and Confidentiality: Produced Pursuant to Court Orders in State of Minnesota, et al. ~. Philip l~Iorris,

~5-~, 107: • WI~Z, vl I:l one o~ a n~be: o~ :~anAes An ~he Lndus~:y ~ac ¢cn~:Lbu~es ~o ere ?Z~, so ~a¢ o~ ~ok~nq a~ be~ and Z ~eve Ln ce~aced a:eas. and ~ £s, ~csonal~y, ~sn'~ A go. Z'm noc ~-mi'.!~c vic.~ "~e ~i'.!ts ~nd so ~or~.~ ~hece. Co /nvesCAga~Lon Ln ~y o~e: ceseac:~ gcoups ~ac you kn~ o~ vi~ resp~ to, as ~ puc L:, s:o~aq and o~hec ~ ~e T~ ~ you ~ave any o~e: ceseacch A And rJm ftnaZ report on it vas pu*~X/sbed b~ D~S.. Bang and lariat,, the ictuaA cesearca havLng been 2..~200S2~4 Subject to Claims of Privilege and Confidentiality: Produce~l Pursuant to Court O~'ders in State of Minnesota, et al. v. Philip Morris, et al.

~n~ol~ed ou: o~ personnel. K ~. ~ha~'s • been eve:ZooMed La ~Re vel~e= o~ ~i~Agare~=e pc~eg~da. ,ev~ape:s ~ k Pe=sanne~ of ~a~ t£ad, yes. ~ ?Re ~e:i~ ~ha~ vas publish~ i~ ~ese ~ings vas ~: appcov~ ~ ~e o~e: ~:s? A ge~, ~RLs vas Lade~naen~ o~ ~e T~, ~ :Re Scten~A2Le ~viso:y ~:4. ?ba~ Ls, ~e Se~en:A~c ~e~Jory ~d o~ ~e Q Yes. pcLn~ ~ u~ne & X don'~ belLeve so, no. ~ .. Subject to Claims'of ~'rivil~e"and Confidentiality: " Produced Pursuant to Court Orders in State Of Minnesota, et al. v. Philip Morris, et al.

& T~ey ¢o~8 be connec~e~ v~'..~ t:he TZRC. ~ 4on': know. Q TXRC is ~be To~a¢:o Za~-us'..-y Reseac_-b A Yes. Q ~:. ¢:~e, :his ":obac:o and Sealer° pamphle~ - : am no,, cedar:Lag to Vol~e Z, No. 1, o~ t~is pamp~le: -- ~as a heading: "A'bLs issue o~ ?oOacco and |ea2th ptesen~s • o~e ~an one side to existing scientific opinion on ~be possible e~ec~s o~ tobacco use on bti~h." ZS20052ti~5 -- . -. • Subject to Claims of Privilege and Con~dentlality: • Produced-Pursuant to.Court Orders In State of Minnesota, et al. ~;. Philip Moiris, et al.

goes on ~o say: and one o! ~hose ~eo~le, ~o you: Xnov!e~e? A Z cannot aasve: ~oc ~s teas©n: ! am no~ ac:~ve ~an~es, bu~ -- O By ~he cosl~en£es, you mean ~he ~o~a¢co compan£es? Such as the ~e=ican Tobacco C~pany? A JU~d o~s:s, ~o~, Q X undo:stand. & PcssLbly grevecs. I'x no~ su:e. As ~e I~ad o~7 2~2005267 Subject to Claims of Privilege and Confidentiality: - Proiluc~d" Pursuant to Cdurt Orders in State-of Minnesota, et al. v: Philip Morris,-et at.

Q s~eting and smoking and ~eal~. A X. L~ag~ne ~ey a~o, cer:aAn~. Subject to Claims of Privilege and Confidentiality: Produced Pursuant to Court Orders in State of Minnesota, et al. v. Philip Morris, et al..

A Z.don'C k~ov. Q 3ave ~..~ey cepoc~ed ~.o anyone Ln C~e c=m~4ny ~ ~e ~.bey e~1oyed My you Ln any way, oc ~ave ~ey been? A Z ~An~ m. A well, em ~Ango ~bey ~oLne4 ~:he ~a~. uas one o£ ~.he r..~Anga. Subject to Claims of Privilege and Confidentiality: Pursuant to Court Orde'rg in State of Minnesota, et al. v. PhUip Morris;.et al.

A ~'eS. s~me ~iJe L.q ~.~|4, vu L~o oc ~S57 Scmevflece L.~ Q And acco:4ing ~o you= in.~oc=a~iono ~e~e k T~a~ is 2 20052'70 Subject to Claims of Privilege and Confidentiality: Produced Pursuant to Court Orders in State or" Minnesota, et al. v. Philip Morris, et al.

3. Sa:es ~iq~:ts he.'e and ab:oad sugges'. an~agcnls~ic cha=~es agains~ s~klng a:e be:rig v~eved d~IL~ o~ ci~a:e~:e ~ns~p~en.-~ ce:~a~n ciga:e::es ~s :~r:ed :o have :!sea su~s:ancla~IF In 19S4. dog~a'.Ac ~_~eo-.ies abou¢ sno~Ang and bea~Cb. do noc endocse o= v~o ~o~ ~.~e va~,Ad~y o~ ~.~ese ~heoc/es h~ve ~een :eceLv£ng ~o:e a~:tn~£on. Cm~osl~e I}r~. ...... . Subject to Claims of Privilege and Confidentiality: Produced Pursuant to (~our~ Orders in State of Minnesota, et at. v. Philip Morris, et al.

ccn~isues to sup~cC c~e objective, Longocanqe cesea::~ ace =ado u~n ce~enda~Aon o~ an ~dv~so~y noacd o~ Aade~enden: scien~As~s, d~:ocs and ed~a~ocs; o~ g~s a:e assu:ed c~npleme scientA~ic ~ceed~ ~a ces~:s. $. 1~0 kn~ua! Repoc~ aC 11, 12-13 [2S]* octet tobacco saau~ac~u:e:s La c:ea~iag be~=e~ kaovledge and ~nde~s~andlag On D~e~ P~es~deacy e~ The Tobacco :ns~Atu~e. ~. ~Aen res£5ned las~ ~e~ ~:~ govec~enC secv~ce a~ec a dAs:LnguAs~ed as Us/stlnt ~ as OA:~ac e~ ~e ~L~ed S~a:es Xa~e~Aon ~ency. ...... Subject to Claims of Priv.ilege and Confidentiality: Produced Pursuant to Court Orders in State of Minnesota, et aL v. Philip Morris, et al.

o~ ~e ~oOa©co ~ad~s~:y ~eseacch C:mmA~:ee, nov Aa ~e a:ea o~ mklag an~ ~eal~, ~As :e~ea:c~ ~bea. ~e :esea:c~ prog:~ As a~An~s~e:ed ~y a Sc~en- ~1~£c Advisory ~ea:d vhose meUe:s are no~ c=nnec:ed .' "... pec~aps t~ :cs~ s~gnA~Acan: develop aen~ has been C~e gene.aA cec~nA~i~n ~at ~e do no~ ~ung can:a: does .... 12-13 Company continues ~o su~:~ ob~ec~Ave a~.d Lndepen- lesea==R C~mmAt:ee. S~not £~s Eec~at~on Ln I~$4~ T.Z.I.C. ho~C~s, ~d~l sch~s ~d cesea:=~ Ans:~cucA~ns xecen~Ay ~e ~,ai~aaa oE t~e Tobacco ~oughou~ ~be ~rld. T~a~, -bAle ~he b~eses age J~1~ ~A-e, ~hey re~ a~sC v~o1~y on 8ssaci- a~i~ deriv~ ~c~ s~acis:ical studies ~a~ did not g£~e campacabZe consAdecac£on ~o o~be: faccocs. 2 20052'73" Subject to Claims of Privilege and Confidentiality: Produced Pursuant to Court Orders in State of Mianesota, et al. v. Philip Morris, et al:

"'.he yea: ~.9t2 say :u:~..~e: mepetA:~on o~ As ~Re ~ac~r :es~nsA~Ae ~o~ ~e ~t~:=ed Lnc:ease La L~g c~ct: L~c~ence. ?~e:e Ls, of ~se, :A~ on vhi~ :~ey a:e based, ha~t ~t~ v~ ~s s~dAed." II. i~65 Annual The preg:m o~ ~e Council to: Tobacco Reseemc.~ - ~/.S.&., As ~ An L~ ~A:~c~ yea:; s~s~=Aal s~s be~ app=opc~a~ ~oc a v~de range o~ on mo~L~ ~d bea~. Xeseac~ g~ ace :mende4 ~ ~he mAaen: sea o~ science c~pcLs£ag ~viso~y ~ara, ~d g~aa~ees 8co glen ~p~e~e ~d-L~e~nely. The ~ul~ ~s ~a~ ~ec a vtde facts ~ba~ need to ~e ~novn. The PoeL:Leet ~aken by •. Subject to Claims of Privilege and Confidentiality: Pr.odu~ed .P.urs.uant to Court Orders in State of Minnesota, et al. v. philip Morris, et-al:

13. bu~ i~ scientific ~aDoca~o~!es ~ ~o: 8 v~de :~e o~ :esea::~ s~d/e~ on heaZ~ t~rougb ~e 2:unciZ. Resea=c~ 8ead~ by ~Anen~ xen o~ science c~p~LsL~ ~e ~o ~:s~e ~eL= ~:~ and publ~s~ ~e ~es~s i~d ~ndependan~y. T~e p~o~ro of .-be C=~n¢~ fo~ Toba¢:o RtseI~c~'~.S.A., su1~poc:ed by :he Company and ac~e:s In ~e /ndus::y, Ls n~ An L~ sAzCeen:~ yea:. Since L~ LnctpcAon mo:e ~aa SI~,O00,O00 has been appcopclaC~ ~y ~e ~oc a vide r~ge of research s~udAes ~r~ ~e~unci~. Xesea:~ g:~ are rec~ended by ~Anen~ men o~ c~r~s~ng ~e ScLen~A~Lc ~visory l~=~ of ~e ~d gran~s ire ~ve~ complete ~re~ co pu=sue ~ei: ~ 4~d puo~s~ ~t ~tsu~s ob~ecmAvel~ a~ /ndependen:~y. scientific research £n ere ~eLd o~ smo~A.~ and beal:~ The Council fo: Tobacco ~esescch a.S.&., v~Ac~ IS. 1~73 ~mua~ Repec~ a~ 5 f4~J" In the field of mklng and hea1~h The American Tobacco Company con~Aaues co supper: c~e ~n¢£1 fo~ ?obec~ • eseac~-O.S.A. S~nce ~:s LncepcAon twenty yeats ago, 2520052"?5 Subject to Claims of Privilege and Confidentiality: ...... Produced Pursuant to Court Orders in State of Minnesota, etal. v. Philip Mot:rim, et.al..

o~ec~Ave sclen~£c =tsea=e~ £n ~£s conc:ove~s~a~ con~Laues :o suFpor: ?he C:unc~l ~=C ?obac=o ~esea:=h- ~.S,A. S~nco ~ vas founded £n 1954 CYR ~as p:ov~ded Weavs.._....~.r (4/9/69) a: S, 7: 40-4Z. ~e~endan~'s ~hen p~es~en~, Paul N. Hahn, ~he ?onacco Zndus~:y Rssear:~ C~A~ee. The ¢emsA:~ee ,.~:y ~o ~£nd ul:Ama=e fac~, ~d ~o c~Aca~e 4~. De~end~ vas a se~e~ e~ ~e 43. Yes. 43-48. ~endan~ his no~ had anyone ~A~ ~duc~A~ ceseacc~ CoacernAag ~he any. o~ ciga=e~:e ~otLnq on ~e hei~h o~ _ h~e~, E. R. Ea~ec and R. E. Sei~ conducted -- 8t~ ~ ~esu~ud in ~e attaches 1As~ 13 2 2005Z7 . - - Subject to Cl~ims of Privilege a.nd Confidentiality: Produced Pursuant to Court Orders in State of 54mnesota, et al. v. Philip Morris, et al.

?obac=o :ndus:=Y ~esea::~ ~A::ee sLace t~s ~e.~a- 19. ~esS Release: P. 8ahn (2/23/55) a: 2: Ee adds :~&: ~ha ~:bac:o ~adus~:~ ~sea:cR ~A~ee, ~oa:~ o~ ~ea ~Anenc scien~Ascs, !cadets ~a ~he ~e CcmaL~ae, H:. ~ahn concAnues, has Ln¢:aased ~o $1,000,000 L:s ~uad ~o: Lndepen~en: scAen~.AfL¢ casea::b, and Ls mak/ag g:sa~S fo~ Lndapendan~ sc£en~Af~: :•sea:oh 14 2. 200527 Subject to Claims of Privilege and Confidentiality: Produced Pursuant to Court Orders in State of Minnesota, et al. v. philip Morris, et al.

20. ~gTO 21. ?ee)e~her, as an indus=ry, since ISS4, cLgaret:e pro~ects of T~e Counc~1 ~o= To~•cco The Council •lone has ava:~ millions in p~s, ~nive~si~es and research erg~Aza~ons. Scien:1~Ac Advlso:7 Soard datelines ~ese g:anms.A grin: csclpien:z. 22. ~any people have asked us wha~ ve are doing to iee~ |err is the aasvec: i. We ale pledging ei4 and assis~ance rases:oh effor~ into all phases o! tobacco ass and health. This Joint ~Inancial aid viii of course b~ in idd~on panic•. 2. .Per this purpose ve are es=abXlshing • ~oin: lnd~st=y group consisting ini~la~l~ of the mtde:signed. This group vi~ be kaevn as ~|~CC~ :X~S~ ~~ 3. Xn ci~•rge of the rases:oh activilles of the C!ittee viii be • scieniis~ o~ ~n/speac.~a~le lnteg- ILl-# lnd aationaA repute. In addition r.hece viii ~e Subject to Claims of Privilege and Confidentiality: Produced Pursuant to (~ourt Orders iu State of Minnesllta, et al. v. Philip Morris, et al_.

23. "S~a~emen= Conct=nAng ~.~e Ot~gln and ?.~ltC', Sa~ (1/25/$4) at 4, 8: 2 2( 052"79 Subject to Claims of Privilege and Confidentiality: Produced Pursuant to Court Orders in State of Minnesota, et al. v. Philip Morris, et al.

24. Z ~ ~us: noC ~A~Lac vt=~ eA=~ec ~e ocgan- Yes, s~:. Z ~sve seen ~c. ?obac¢o Zn~or:a~:n ~A::ee c~pcesen=ing co~¢:o :anu- ~ac~e=s, g~e:s, and Q ?he Tobacco Zndus~ Resea=c~ ~i~=ee is ¢onC:/bu~ ~o ~y c~e ~ecican ~obacco ¢~pany, A ~es, Z .ZOOS .qo Subject to Claims of Privilege a.nd Confidentiality: Produced Pursuant to Court Orders in State of Minnesota, et al. v. Philip Morris, et al~

25. 0~, yes. And ~o was :eAng c:aaec:ed vic.~ 4Asease, ~a: L: vas e~ g:ave con- cern, of ~eep concecn, Co o~ company aad cbe :es: ef ~e ~nd~s::~. So ve :or~ed ~be ?:~acco :ad~sm:.v Resea::.~ ~ic:~ co spcnsoc ctsea~¢b f.aco c.~e acea of smo~4ng aad ~eal~. ~a respect you bad cec:aAa do¢Cocs, 18 Subject to Claims of Privilege and Confidentiality: Produced "Pursuant t(~ Court Orders in State of Minnesota, et al. v. Philip Morris, et al.

t • t ouc v~c c~e ~se o~ ~nc~c ~j. O~ ~ucse, ~dy Xn~ vhac the ¢a~e o~ cancer ~s yec. we 4o noc ~ 26. Dep~sic£on o~ ~ber~ ¢. RackeC". £n "~ceen v. A.m & Z he,Sere that's cocsecc. Q And vt~ ~s. Paul Saba the pecso,t vho ~L~sc o~ganAz~d or /rwtAgaced ~e ocganAzamAon 0£ the com~t~cee? 2 20052 2 .- Subject to Claims of Privilege and Confidentiality:. Produced Pursuant to Court Orders in State of" ~Tinnesota, et al. v. Philip l~[orris, e.t

X Z belAeve be -as. $cAen~i!Ic Advlsccy ~oac~, does noc do ~o~ ~u~ g~ve money ~oc cesea::~, and L= As noc necessac~y Ln ~e ~le!~ o~ smokin~ an~cance=? no. ~oC necessaci~y. & ~e!l, ~e genecal sca~e~enc As Cha~ Lc s~ou~4 be :elated ~o cobac=o ~se and beaA~. see. spor.8o~ed. you have gLvea ~ney ~o7 A ~'ha~'S CLgh~. & Eev. ~A~:ee? 2O • 2 20052S3 Subject to Claims of Privilege and Confidentiality: Produced Pursuant to Court Orders in State of Minnesota, et al. v. Philip Morris, et al.

and 8ea~r-~ -- ~.~ey vece pu~ ou~ ~nde: ~e ?oOacco :adus~:y Itesea:c.~ su~-c~A::ee called ..... . Subject to Claims of Privilege and Confidentiality: Produced Pursuant to Court Orders in State of Minnesota, et al. v.Philip Morris,-et al.

Z?. ~.~e~ go Lato ~ha~ ~A:ectAon. ~adus~:~ Research C~t~oe, and ezec~mAve the TX~C? & ~e TX~C. v~ bcl~ging abo~t a high l~ci~ance o5 ~ng ~ancec? 22 • .. Subject to Claims of Privilege and Confidentiality: Produced Pursuant to Court Orders in State ~f Minnesota, et al. v. Philip Morris, et al.

28. & HOo and ~e c~A~cee aa~es the ~a~s available s=a~en~ o5 |c~s~n ~cay a~ ~38: ... Rese~:h-g.S.A. ~ ~o ~inaace research in ma~ecs cela~Ing ~o co~ac~o and heaJ.~. Y.~oug~ i~s s¢ien~i~i~ advisory boar~, c~upcised o£ minenc ~d indep~de~ aedica~ scientists, gr~cs ~oc ~uelcc~ have been ~ade co~a~ing s~e S? si~on. 29. C~ic~ee on C~mmecce (L~$), scacmeac o~ ]o~an ~ray 245: aenCAng gravers o~ ~e~ tobacco, ~o~ed the Industry lesea:~ C~i~ee -0 nou n~ed The Cou~¢i~ Tobacco |e~ea~¢ls,-Q.S.&. -- co ~inance research Ln nent ~d L~e~nden~ m~ sclencLs~, gc~cs -.=ese~ch ~ ~n ~de ~o~ing over S7 million ~o s~e 240 sci~is~ in a~e ~a 100 h~pi~als, univac- Subject to Claims of Privilege a.nd Confidentiality: Pr(~duced Pursuant to Court Orders in State of Minnesota, et al. v. Philip Morris, et al."

=~e ¢~A~:ee ~o~ To~o hseat=h, ~acili=ies In ~I ~ia~ o~ ~uca~ion~ ~ ~edical sci~u~io~ C~ougbo~C ~he a scien~L~Ac advisory ~d c~e~ o~ p~pLe ~oc 9cancs ~d aa~e ~be gcan~, ~d ove~ a ~tiod o~ ~£nance Lndependen~ research cela~ing co tobacco and o~ ~Anen~ ~d Lade~ndea~ ~LcaZ 8¢/en~As~, ~s ude Subject to Claims of Privilege and Confidentiality: ProdUced P~rsuant to Court Orders in State of Minnesota, et al. v. Philip Morris, et al.

33. 29-36 : of scLen~ls~ v~ have done ~c~ foc ¢.T.R. and ~ an -vL~ ~e ~o me u vo ~ ~g. Subject to Claims of Privilege and Couf'tdentiality: Produced "Pursuant to Cou~'t Orders in State of ~VIinnesota, et al. v. Philip ~4orris, et ~I.

& X can'~ re~all aay ~a~ ~Ld, no. Q Do ~u cromer L-" any o~ .~se s~Les ~d ~ ~here vaJ no re~a~LonJhLp or usoc~a~Lon baleen c~ga~e~o.e ~oK~-nq ~d lung csnce~ Ln ~L~eZs? p~od~ced Ln aniaaAs by toha~o smoke or L~ de~Lvs-.Lves. & $1sce ~54? Q 1Lgh~. & T~y did. TheAc aces enc~npaeaes s~oc~, Z ~ ~bey have ~DZLshed selves vt~ ~s ~cy a~u~ ~oK~ ~d La ~a~Lee ~veen mokA~g a~d l~ng caactr Ln hutans? 2~20052~9 ...... Subject to Claims of Privilege.and Confidentiality: • Produced Pursuant to Court Orders in ~St, a, te of ~[inneso~s, et al. v. Philip ~orris, et al: --

:be broad :snge o~ 8edLcal kaovledge, and :hese set ~:L~caIZy to cev~ t~e grant ap~AcatAo~ an4 to ~d.g:~ ~ t~e ~o~s~ c~:~ers ~n the ~ea oE ~tLag ~d le~th ~at ~hey ~uLdeced 8~ ~4 a scLen~s~ go a~u~ ge~ng o~e o~ k J~t ~ iddcessLng a teresa, vt~ i descr~ ~ of ~ ~t ~u u~ ~o ~, to ~ o=tgLna~ly 2S20052 0 ..... "" - " Subject to Claims of Privilege a~nd Confidentiality: P~odti~:'e~'Pursuant to Court Orders" in State of Minnesota, et al. v. Philip Mot~ri~'et'al. "

Z 2005291. Subject to Claims of Privilege and Confidentiality: Pr~)duccd Pursuant to Court Orders in State of ~[innesota, et al. v. Philip IV[orris, et al.-