Product Design
Qualitative Analysis: Consumer Reactions, Attitudes and Perceptions Generated by Exposure to Various M2 Sustaining Advertising Approaches
Abstract
Describes and analyzes focus group data and comments related to Reynold's planned introduction of "M2," a new brand of 100mm menthol light cigarettes "targeted specifically at 'younger' female smokers." Indicates advertising must "reinforce the original 'message' and be compatible - at least to some degree - with the overall M2 parent brand (i.e. Salem) at the same time." Includes handwritten comments in marginalia. Omits Appendix.
Fields
- Notes
Research report prepared by: Abby Ellison Qualitative Research, Inc. Brand: M2; Benson & Hedges Menthol Lights; Benson & Hedges Lights; Eve Menthol Lights.
- Author
- Abbey Ellison Qualitative Research, Inc
- Recipient
- R.J Teynolds Tobacco Company
- Hypothesis
- Women TargetingCigarettes designed to target women
- Keyword
- Consumer acceptability (Consumer preference)
- Market (B&W marketing term)
- Satisfaction
- Social psychologyCoping/stress management, image, and personality
- Additive
- Menthol (dl- Menthol or l-Menthol)
- Named Organization
- *R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company (Cigarette manufacturer (Camel, Winston, Doral brands))Cigarette manufacturer (Camel, Winston, Doral brands)
- William Esty Company Incorporated (Prepared study on underage smoking in 1959)
- Abby Ellison Qualitative Research, Inc.
- Brand
- Kent Golden Lights
- Kool (BW (1933-2003)/RJR (2003-present))First Menthol cigarette line, released in 1933. Premium priced brand.
- Newport (Lorillard)
- Salem (RJR)
- SALEM LIGHTS
- Salem Ultra Lights
- Virginia Slims Lights
- Virginia Slims Lights Menthol (PM)
- Subject
- advertising effectiveness
- advertising message
- marketing research
- marketing strategy
- Menthol (Additives)
- Target/Women (Target Groups)
- Target/Young Adults (Target Groups)
- Test/Consumer Preference (Testing)
Document Images
4.
A CAUTIONARY NOTE
Before proceeding to read further, it is of the utmost
importance to bear in mind the qualitative nature of the
research. Specifically, the study included approximately
62 respondents and was conducted in one geographic lo-
cation.
Because of this, all "findings" herein contained are..
hypothetical. They should be utilized to help guide
advertising, marketing and follow-up marketing research
issues to be considered. These hypotheses, however, should
not be looked upon as definitive indicators..
Wherever possible, information considered particularly
meaningful to the success of the M2 brand should be veri-
fied further using quantitative, projectable testing
methodologies.
CAbby ~;FFison . ~~~nFifative tResecu~ch. ,9na

TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page No:
BACKGROUN D AND OBJECTIVES' 1
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY 2
A CAUTION ARY NOTE 4
AN OVERVI
A. EW OF KEY HYPOTHESES
Current Smoking Behavior, Attitudes
and Perceptions
5
B. Primary M2 Introductory Advertising
-- Reactions, Perceptions, Associations
6
C.
D. Alternative M2 Introductory (i.e.,
Close-Up) Advertising -- Reactions,
Perceptions and Associations
M2 Versus Potential Competitive
Brands -- Perceptions, Attitudes and
Associations
1
E. "Fantasies" Relating to the M2 User's
Lifestyle, Appearance, Priorities
12
F. M2 Packaging -- Attitudes, Perceptions
and Reactions
19
IMPLICATIONS AND INDICATED ACTIONS 21
APPENDIX
Select Sustaining Advertising Visuals
Screening Questionnaire
(-Abby 80tson . QuoQtfotive 'Pcseaeck 9ne.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES
RJR Tobacco will shortly be introducing a new brand of
100mm menthol light cigarettes -- designated as M2 in this
analysis. The brand is being targeted specifically at
"younger" female smokers -- i.e., the primary target being
in the 18-24 year old age range, possibly extending to
include female smokers in their thirties as well.
Introductory advertising for M2 has essentially been final-
ized to the extent that a decision has been made to focus
on particular personalities (i.e., facial close-ups of
models) utilized in tandem with the headline "One Beautiful
Menthol."
The question being raised by the Brand Group at this point
in time relates to the advertising approach which would be
most viable for M2 sustaining advertising. That is, once
the brand is introduced, what must the sustaining adver-
tising communicate in order to both reinforce the original
"message" and be compatible -- at least to some degree --
with the overall M2 parent brand (i.e., Salem) at the
same time.
In order to explore possible alternative approaches for
M2 sustaining advertising, the Agency (William Esty) put
together a series of somewhat diverse materials. The
purpose of so doing was to expose these materials to
female smokers in the MZ target audience in order to
gain some understanding of how the various alternatives
would impact on their attitudes toward and perceptions of
M2. To elicit the sought-after insights, a decision was
made to implement a diagnostic consumer research ex-
ploratory.
,Abby 0 eison . QUnQifAfidf. (PCSC(LhCIL ,9nc.

3.
Reactions to M2 packaging -- to explore extent
to which it goes along with/supports the imagery
associated with the brand and the brand user
created by both introductory and sustaining ads.
All respondents' verbatim comments were audiotaped.
A one-way observation mirror was utilized in order that
Bran d, MRD and Agency personnel could both monitor and
impact on the focused groups as the research was being
conducted.
LAby Okon . QuAtattve cpescatch. 9nc.

CONFIDENTIAL
THIS REPORT IS NUMBER
OF COPIES. IT HAS
BEEN ISSUED TO:
QUALITATIVE ANALYSIS
CONSUMER REACTIONS, ATTITUDES AND PERCEPTIONS
GENERATED BY EXPOSURE TO VARIOUS M2
SUSTAINING ADVERTISING APPROACHES
Prepared for: Prepared by:
R. J. REYNOLDS ABBY ELLISON QUALITATIVE
TOBACCO COMPANY RESEARCH, INC.
EQR #81-M-870 April, 1981
,lbby PjCison . QuatiEattrc TcseaA9nc.
~
0
w
Ln
N
aN
w
0
~

AN OVERVIEW OF KEY HYPOTHESES
A. Current Smoking Behavior, Attitudes and Perceptions
Virtually all the women talked of their current
behavior and attitudes in fairly positive terms.
They claimed to "enjoy" smoking because:
It relaxes ne. .
It's sorrething to do when I'm
talking to people.
Among their "circles of friends," smoking seemed
to be "quite popular" -- i.e., .
All my friends smoke ... We
enjoy it ... We snbke most when
we're out having a good tirre ..
Dancing and drinking is when we
sm?ke the most.
In that all were menthol "long"'smokers -- the
vast majority of whom were smoking a "light" '
variety of this type of cigarette -- they tended
to refer to specific characteristics of such
cigarettes in a highly favorable manner. That
is:
I like a light menthol ... It's
a srroother smoke than the stronger
brands.
I get more out of a long cigarette
... I feel I'm getting more of my
nt-)ney' s worth.
A long cigarette is milder than the
shorter ones.
I prefer the way a long cigarette
feels.
I like a thin cigarette ... It's nicer
to hold ... I feel clumsy if I smoke
a regular cigarette.
'Abby ec('ison . QNnPttntim (Pescaacb. 9nc.

2.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The M2 research conducted was qualitative in nature. It
consisted of a total of six focused group sessions conducted
in the Tampa, Florida area on March 11, 12 and 13, 1981.
The respondents who took, part in the research were all
females recruited according to the following specifications:*
All were current smokers of "longer"
menthol cigarettes.
The majority in each group had to be
currently smoking low tar brands.
Two of the groups contained 18-20 year
olds; two contained 21-24 year olds; two
contained 25-34 year olds.
During the course of each of the groups, the following
broad areas of inquiry were explored:
Brief exploration into past and current
smoking behavior and related attitudes
Reactions to primary introductory M2
advertising (i.e., "Denise - Green Scarf")
-- perceptions, associations and expectations
engendered by both visual and copy
Reactions to alternative introductory M2
advertising (i.e., "Long Dark Hair" and
"Blond Short Hair - Black Sweater").
Perceptual and attitudinal similarities/
differences between M2 versus Virginia Slims
Menthol Lights and Benson & Hedges Menthol' Lights
Open-ended "fantasizing" regarding the po-
tential M2 user -- i.e., anticipated lifestyle;
career/job; activities; wardrobe
Reactions to sustaining advertising pool-out
alternatives -- the extent to which they "fit"
open-ended fantasies as previously articulated
by respondents
* The Screening Questionnaire used for recruitment purposes is
appended.
L166y f;QCtson . QuAtatioe TESCQ1Ch. ,gnc.

APPENDIX
vLbby ~('Cison . n~nQiEntiue ~12eseanc~. 9nc

7.
Sort of young, but not very young ...
In her twenties, I guess ... A free
spirit twenty-five-year-old, I guess.
An all-around woiran -- attractive,
active,, can do anything she sets her
mind to.
A woman of the 80's ... She probably
has a job she really likes ... She
enjoys all different kinds of sports
... I'm sure she has good relationships
with rren ... She's sexy but not in an
obnoxious way.
She looks like the type that gets on
great with men and women ... She looks
sort of rich but not like a snob ...
She probably dresses really stylishly
... She wears all kinds of different
things depending on the situation but
one thing for sure - she always looks
right up to the minute -- the latest
look.
When probed briefly as to what they expected to
see the "Green Scarf" M2 woman looking like/doing
if we'd had other pictures to look at of her,
responses were as follows: '
I can see her hiking in the rtpuntains
... She looks like she really likes
the outdoors.
Horseback riding ... Maybe fishing ...
Definitely not alone though -- with
sorreone.
I expect her to be doing something
kind of outdoorsy, dressed in very
sporty clothing but not sloppily
dressed.
(Would she wear jeans?)
(Aby 8fNon . nuaE~fatiue Teseatd1, 9ne.
Un
0
w
Ln
N
0
W
~
~

Respondents made particular reference to the
"image"/"personality" of an individual as it .
was communicated by the brand of cigarette they
tended to prefer. It seems extremely worthwhile
noting that virtually all the respondents seemed
to be placing a good deal of importance on how they
were perceived by others based on their brand of
cigarette. That .-is : ----
-
The majority of these menthol-smoking group par-
ticipants were currently purchasing Virginia Slims
Lights, Benson & Hedges Lights, Salem Lights.
There were a few smoking the full-flavor versions
of these three brands. The only other brands
which appeared at the groups included Eve Menthol
Lights, Kent Golden Lights, Salem Ultra Lights and
Kool full-flavor.
Primary_M2 Introductory Advertising -- Reactions,
Perce tions and Associations
- The "Green Scarf" (i.e., Denise) execution seems
to be extremely on target. Without any.specific
probing whatever, the focus group respondents
in each of the groups consistently made comments
such as:
She's cute, feminine but very
alive-looking.
,I---
rough or masculine ... I prefer to
snroke a long, thin cigarette because
i t' s a lot irore feminine..
-`/ I don't want to be considered
.~; ,
v4bby OQtson . nunEtEatire Tesea+ch. 9nc_
I think wo:ren who srroke shorter
cigarettes are trying to act kind
of tough ... Srroking is sort of
masculine to begin with ... At least
if you siroke a very feminine cigar-
ette -- Virginia Slims - there's
no question of where your head is at.
I like to be thought of as feminine,
womanly ... I think I srroke a long,
thin-looking cigarette partly for that
reason ... I really like the way it
looks -- it's sexy-looking.
6.
