Product Design
Smoke Chemistry
Abstract
Details operation of an environmentally controlled sidestream smoke chamber designed to replace the Borgwaldt smoker for static smoke runs. Investigates a procedure for the analysis of acrolein. Discusses ongoing methods for collecting and analyzing components of sidestream smoke.
Fields
- Author
- *Comes, R. A. (use Comes, Roger A.)Research Professional
- Hypothesis
- Sidestream constituent yieldsModification of selected sidestream smoke constituents in response to health concerns.
- Keyword
- Sidestream smoke
- Sidestream visibility
- Total particulate matter (TPM or Tar)
- Smoke Constituent
- acrolein
- Total particulate matter
- Gas phase constituents
- Operation/Project
- Project Tomorrow (Fire Safe Cigarette)
- Named Organization
- BCR
- Coresta (Industry-affiliated Int'l scientific/research group)An international organization whose objective is "to improve cooperation in scientific research and tobacco." Consists of 186 member companies/institute from 54 countries, including tobacco, paper and filter companies, and universities engaged in tobacco research.
- SEPPAK
- TENAX
- Technology/Method
- Borgwaldt smoking machine
- Subject
- @smoke_constituents_measures
- Test/Smoke Machine (Testing)
Document Images
CONFIDENTIAL
PROJECT IVUMBER : 2501
PROJECT TITLE : Smoke Chemistry
PROJECT LEADER : R. A. Comes
PERIOD COVERED : May, 1991
I. SIDESTREAM SMOKE CHAMBER
A. Objective: Operate an environmentally controlled chamber to measure selected
components of sidestream smoke.
B. Results: Normal thirty cigarette chamber runs and five cigarette aerosol runs have
been compl'eted on the cigarettes in the sidestn;am analytical-subjective series. The
run data is cwrently being tablulated and a report will be written. The hardware for
the chamber modifications has been fabricated and will be installed when static
smoke nms are completed. These static experiments are currently in progress. A
new chamber smoking procedure had to be devised to conduct these experiments
since the Borgwaldt smoker is designed to only operate under puffing conditions.
The gc procedure in use for the analysis of nicotine requires a run time of thirty five
minutes. This is quite long considering the number of nicotine samples analyzed for
a set of chamber runs. Modi~fications to the procedure have now reduced that time to
approximately ten minutes per gc run. Studies were conducted to insure that no loss
of precision or accuracy was involved with this procedural change.
Personnel of CAD are in process of optimizing several RS/1 procedures to reduce the
manual effort required in generating reports, calculating results and file management
of chamber data base files. These changes should be implemented within this next
reporting period.
Initial studies have begun directed at the incorporation of a procedure for the analysis
of acrolein into the chamber analytical procedures. Acrolein is rarely seen using the
current DNPH SepPak trapping procedure. Tests have shown that acrolein (as the
DNPH derivative) placed on a clean SepPak cartridge or on one impregnated with
acidified DNPH solution is recovered when flushed with acetonitn7e in the manner
described in the standard chamber procedure. This indicates that acrolein is not
being collected during smoke runs. A bubbler procedure will be investigated.
Procedures for the collection of sidestream particulate during normal chamber runs in
sufficient quantity for separation and further analysis are being investigated. An
impaction trapping system incorporating the small vials used for neutron activation
analysis work is being studied with some initial success obvious.
C. Plans: Chamber runs will continue as required. Work will continue on chamber
modifications to allow for the sidestream analytical-subjective study. A procedure for
the analysis of acrolein will continue to be investigated. Procedures for collection of
sid'estream TPM during normal chamber operation will continue.
C91-02637

2501-2
H. SIDESTREAM SMOKE
A. Objective: Conduct studies on sidestreant smoke including: development of methods
for collection and analysis of sidestream semivolatiles and gas phase; visibility
determinations; analysis of selected materials relating to sidestream odor and
irritation; development of proprietary products.
B. Results: Optimization of the operation of the headspace-gc-ms system continues.
Successful automation of the method was accomplished during this period.
Previously, it was possible to make only one desorption-gc-ms run at a time due to
built in constraints imposed by the total system. Following the successful
automation, multiple runs were made to simultaneously study several method
variables. Information was gathered on nm-to-run variability, breakthrough of the
sample components during collection onto the air tube adsorbent, comparison of
Tenax -Carbopack traps with Carbopack only traps, comparison of runs with different
desorb times and comparison of runs with different purge times. This work
continues and results will be detailed at a later date.
Work has been completed on the method to account for the smoke escaping from~ the
ventilation holes of cigarettes. A prototype apparatus was designed that seems to be
effective in accounting for all of the escaping smoke. Requested cigarette models
were evaluated and the data reported in memo format. A video of the smokings was
also supplied. This work has stopped at this time.
C. Plans: The O.l: H.P. system will continue to be vigorously studied to determine its
overall utility as a new instrument for conducting sidestream chamber analytical
studies, particularly as they may relate to the new sidestream analytical-subjective
work. CORESTA smokings will continue as required.
IIL MISCELLANEOUS
1. Infrared camera - New software for analyzing the IR camera images has been
received. The image processor computer used with the IR camera is experiencing
disk problems so the new software has not been loaded. A request to repair the
computer has been submitted.
2. Neutron radiography - The buildup of condensibles during smoking has been
measured in the cigarettes from the sidestream analytical-subjective series (X8Ta1WG
- WK) and in banded cigarettes from Project Tomorrow under both static and puffing
conditions. Data analysis is in progress..
Requested modifications to the smoking machine are in progress that will allow the
taking of one puff followed by the remainder of the smoking under smolder
conditions. A manually operated solenoid' has been placed in the line from the
smoking machine to the cigarette. The operator can turn the solenoid on to take one
puff and then turn it off. The smoking machine will continue to take puffs, keeping
data collection properly timed, but no air will be drawn through the cigarette.
2

2501-3
A second request was to investigate a change in the method of data reporting from a
"change in density-thickness (mg/cm~" to a percent mass loss value. One method
attempted was to calculate the scattering cross section of tobacco from the elemental
composition of the tobacco. This effort is continuing. A second was to devise a
calibration method using tobacco. Cigarettes were cut into sections with several
different lengths. The sections were weighed, measured for size so the tobacco
density could be calculated and placed in the neutron beam head on. Thus, the
attenuation of the neutron beam could be measured as a function of the amount of
tobacco it passed througlL This provides a calibration curve relating the change in
the neutron beam intensity with the actual amount of tobacco present. From this
work came the suggestion by a Physical Research Division co-investigator to look at
the sum of the density-thiclaRess changes for all twenty of the measurement zones in
the experiments. This gave a density-thickness change curve that was linear with
time for a smoldering cigarette and is the curve shape obtained when the mass loss of
a smoldering cigarette is measured using a balance. Initial data comparisons have
given quite good agreement and these studies will continue. The major valiue to this
technique is that it can be used to measure mass loss for puffed cigarettes which
cannot be done using the balance technique.
3. Pyrolysis gclms analyses were conducted in support of the menthol release and
potential new product materials programs. Memos were issued, in support of these
studies.
4. Assistance was provided to personnel of the BCR division in the attempted gc/ms
analysis of N-methylputrescine and related products. Additional support will be
provided when instrumental probl'ems are resolved.
3
