Philip Morris
Prospective Study of Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Dysmenorrhea
Fields
- Author
- Chen, C.
- Chen, D.
- Cho, S.
- Damokosh, A.I.
- Li, G.
- Wang, X.
- Xu, X.
- Chen, D.
- Document File
- 2505587211/2505587290/Missing
- Area
- BADSTUBER,ANDRE/OFFICE
- Type
- WSIT, INTERNET WEB SITE
- ABST, ABSTRACT
- BIBL, BIBLIOGRAPHY
- PSCI, PUBLICATION SCIENTIFIC
- ABST, ABSTRACT
- Litigation
- Feda/Produced
- Site
- E16
- Master ID
- 2505587212/7289
Related Documents:- 2505587212-7213 Untitled document 2505587212/7213
- 2505587214-7216 Review 1137 Subject Ref 8b "Breast Cancer, Passive and Active Cigarette Smoking and N-Acetyltransferase 2 Genotype" R J Delfino Et Al Pharmacogenetics (20000000), 10, 461-469
- 2505587217-7225 Breast Cancer, Passive and Active Cigarette Smoking and N-Acetyltransferase 2 Genotype
- 2505587226 Smoking During Pregnancy and Breast Cancer Risk in Young Women.
- 2505587227-7230 Review 1134 Subject Ref 8b "Lung Cancer and Environmental Tobacco Smoke in a Non-Industrial Area of China" L Wang Et Al International Journal of Cancer (20000000), 88, 139-145
- 2505587231-7237 Lung Cancer and Environmental Tobacco Smoke in A Non-Industrial Area of China
- 2505587238-7240 Review 1135 Subject Ref 8b "Nasopharyngeal Carcinoma in Malaysian Chinese: Occupational Exposures to Particles, Formaldehyde and Heat R W Armstrong Et Al International Journal of Epidemiology (20000000), 29, 991-998
- 2505587241-7248 Nasopharyngeal Carcinoma in Malaysian Chinese: Occupational Exposures to Particles Formaldehyde and Heat
- 2505587249-7252 "Environmental Tobacco Smoking, Mutagens Sensitivity, and Head and Neck Squamous Cell Carcinoma" Z-F Zhang Et Al Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers & Prevention (20000000), 9, 1043 - 1049
- 2505587253-7259 Environmental Tobacco Smoking, Mutagen Sensitivity, and Head and Neck Squamous Cell Carcinoma
- 2505587260 "Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Non-Fatal Myocardial Infarction Among Never-Smokers" M Rosenlund Et Al Epidemiology (20000000), 11, S103
- 2505587261 Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Non-Fatal Myocardial Infarction Among Never-Smokers
- 2505587262-7264 "Prospective Study of Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Dysmenorrhea" C Chen Et Al Environmental Health Perspectives (20000000), 108, 1019 - 1022
- 2505587274-7276 "Prenatal Active or Passive Tobacco Smoke Exposure and the Risk of Preterm Delivery or Low Birth Weight" Gc Windham Et Al Epidemiology (20000000), 11, 427 - 433
- 2505587277-7283 Prenatal Active or Passive Tobacco Smoke Exposure and the Risk of Preterm Delivery or Low Birth Weight
- 2505587284-7285 "A Prospective Study of Smoking During Pregnancy and Sids" K Wisborg Et Al Archives of Diseases in Childhood ( 20000000), 83, 203 - 206
- 2505587286-7289 A Prospective Study of Smoking During Pregnancy and Sids
- Named Organization
- Ehpnet1 Niehs NIH Gov Docs 2000 108p1019
- Ehpnet1 Niehs NIH Gov Members 2000 108p1
- Author (Organization)
- Beijing Medical Univ
- Boston Univ
- Center for Ecogenetics
- Environmental Health Perspectives
- Harvard
- Liaoning Antiepidemic Station
- Boston Univ
- Date Loaded
- 11 Sep 2002
- UCSF Legacy ID
- rsd19c00
Document Images
Prospective Study of Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Dysmenorrhea Page 8 of 8
12. Wang X, Tager IB, Van Vunakis H. SpeizerFE, Hanrahan JP. Maternal smoking during pregnancy,
urine
cotinine concentrations, and birth outcomes. A prospective cohort study. Int J Epidemiol 26:978-988
(1997).
13. Zeger SL, Liang KY. Longitudinal data analysis for discrete and continuous outcomes. Biometrics
42:121-130
(1986).
14. Brown S, Vessey M. Stratton 1. The influence of method of contraception and cigarette smoking on
menstrual
patterns. Br J Obstet Gynaccol 95:905-910 (1988).
15. Xu X, Li B. Wang L. Gender difference in smoking effects on adult pulmonary function. Eur Respir
J 7:477-483
(1994).
16. Baron JA, La Vecchia C, Levi F. The anuestrogenic effect of cigarette smoking in women. Am J
Obstet Gynecol
162:502-514 (1990).
17. Khaw KT, Tazuke S. Batrett-Connor E. Cigarette smoking and levels of adrenal androgens in
posnoenopausal
women. N Engt J Med 318:1705-1709 (1988).
( Articles Online First )
Last Updated: October 5, 2000
http://ehpnet I.niehs.nih.gov/members/20(R)/ 108p I 019-1022chen/chen-full. html 15.1 l.2000

Prospective Study of Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Dysmenorrhea Page 4 of 8
you were exposed?" For each menstrual cycle, we calculated an average number of cigarettes
smoked per day at home over the entire cycle. This summary variable of ETS exposure at home
was used to predict the occurrence of dysmenorrhea during the following menstrual period. It was
evaluated as both a continuous and a categorical variable in the subsequent analysis. Exposure to
ETS at the workplace was recorded as a binary variable (yes or no).
Data analysis. The major question of interest is whether ETS exposure at home independently
affects the incidence of dysmenorrhea among women who did not have a history of dysmenorrhea,
and whether the relation is modified by the population characteristics and various occupational
factors. All data were double entered with Epi-Info (version 6.0; Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention, Atlanta, GA, USA). The standard computer program SAS (version 6.12; Cary, NC,
USA) was used for data analysis.
We first compared the population characteristics by ETS exposure status. We then computed the
incidence of dysmenorrhea among prospectively followed menstrual cycles by four ETS exposure
subgroups: no exposure and low, medium, and high tertiles of exposure. We also used local
regression smoothing scatter plots (S-PLUS, version 3.4, MathSoft Inc., Cambridge, MA, USA)
to examine the dose-response relationship between ETS exposure and dysmenorrhea and logistic
regression to estimate odds ratios (ORs) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) of dysmenorrhea
associated with "low," "middle," and "high" ETS exposure, adjusting for age, body mass index,
education, season, area of residence, occupation, shift work, perceived stress, passive smoking at
work, and occupational exposure to chemical hazards, dust, and noise. Generalized estimating
equations (GEEs) were then used to account for autocorrelations as a result of multiple cycles per
subject (!3). Finally, because the number of observed menstrual cycles varies by subject, we
repeated the above analysis with restriction to the first available cycle for each subject.
Results
This report is based on 165 women, who contributed 625 prospectively followed menstrual cycles
with complete baseline and diary infonnation. ETS exposure was reported in 77% of cycles, and
the average daily exposures throughout the cycle ranged from 0.02 to 10.3 cigarettes. The
incidence of dysmenorrhea was 9.7% and 13.3% among nonexposed and exposed cycles,
respectively. Table 1 shows the characteristics of the women by ETS exposure status at the first
cycle. The ETS exposed and nonexposed women were similar in terms of the various covariates
examined. In this population, the most common method of contraception before enrollment was
the use of a condom. At the time of starting the diary collection, 39% of all women reported
having used a condom. Only 1.2% of women reported use of oral contraceptives and 7.190 of
women ever used an intrauterine or intravaginal device.
h ttp://ehpnet t. n iehs.nih. gov/mem be rs/200O/10Sp 1(119- I 022chen/chen-fulI. html 15.1 1.2000

Prospective Study of Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Dysmenorrhea Page 1 of 8
Articles
. .
........ .............
Environmental Health Perspectives Volume 108, Number 11, November 2000
Prospective Study of Exposure to Environmental Tobacco
Smoke and Dysmenorrhea
Changzhong Chen,t Sung-I1 Cho,t Andrew 1. Damokosh,t Dafang Chen,t'z Guang Li,3
Xiaobin Wang,4 and Xiping Xut
tDepartment of Environmental Health, Harvard School of Public Health, Boston, Massachusetts,
USA
ZCenter for Ecogenetics, Beijing Medical University, Beijing, China
3Liaoning Antiepidemic Station, Liaoning, China
4Department of Pediatrics, Boston University School of Medicine, Boston, Massachusetts, USA
tc:rndu:tion
.
...................
blethod~
~~'4CtfYSton
Abstract
Dysmenorrhea is a common gynecologic disorder in women of reproductive age. Previous studies
have found an association between current cigarette smoking and prevalence of dysmenorrhea.
This study investigated the association between exposure to environmental tobacco smoke (ETS)
and the occurrence of dysmenorrhea among women without a history of this disorder. The study
population consisted of 165 newly wed, nonsmoking Chinese women (in Shenyang, China), who
intended to get pregnant and who had no past history of dysmenonhea at the time of enrollment.
These women completed a baseline questionnaire interview upon enrollment and were
prospectively followed by daily diary. Dysmenorrhea was defined as a diary recording of abdominal
pain or low back pain for at least 2 days during a menstrual period. A subject's ETS exposure was
defined as the mean number of cigarettes smoked per day at home by household members over an
entire menstrual cycle before the menstrual period. A logistic regression model was used to assess
the effect of ETS on the risk of dysmenorrhea, with adjustment for age, body mass index,
education, season, area of residence, occupation, shift work, perceived stress, passive smoking at
work, and occupational exposure to chemical hazards, dust, and noise. Generalized estimating
equations were used to account for autocorrelations as a result of multiple cycles per subject_ This
report is based on 625 prospectively followed menstrual cycles with complete baseline and diary
data. ETS exposure was reported in 77% of cycles, within which average daily exposures
throughout the cycle ranged from 0.02 to 10.3 cigarettes. The incidence of dysmenorrhea was
9.7% and 13.3%o among nonexposed and exposed cycles, respectively. Among ETS-exposed
cycles, there was a positive dose-response relationship between the numbers of cigarettes smoked
and the relative risk of dysmenorrhea. The adjusted odds ratios of dysmenorrhea associated with
"low," "middle," and "high" tertiles of ETS exposure versus no exposure were I.1 [95%
confidence interval (CI), 0.5-2.6], 2.5 (Cl, 0.9-6.7), and 3.1 (CI, 1.2-8.3), respectively. The
findings were consistent with those of analyses limited to the first follow-up menstrual cycle from
each woman. These data suggest a significant dose-responsc relationship between exposure to
ETS and an increased incidence of dysmenorncea in this cohort of young wnmenKey words:
daily diary, dose-response tclationship, dysmenorrhea, environmental tobacco smoke, prospective
study. Environ Health Perspect lOR:I(119-1(722 (2000). [Online 5 October2(7t)U]
http://ehpnet I.niehs.nih.gov/members/2U00/ lOBp 1019-1(122chen/chen-full.html 15.1 L200t1

Prospective Study of Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Dysmenorrhea Page 7 of 8
The biological mechanisms by which cigarette smoke may affect dysmenorrhea are not well
understood. Some researchers have suggested that because nicotine is a vasoconstrictor, it can
result in reduced endometrial blood flow, which is common in women with dysmenorrhea5o. It is
suggested that cigarette smoke may have an antiestrogenic effect (16,17).
When the results of this study are interpreted, several methodological limitations should be taken
into account. We did not have biochemical measurements of ECS exposure. Our sample size was
relatively small and did not allow further analysis of subgroups with recurrent/severe dysmenorrhea
or of the timing of ETS exposure within a specific menstrual cycle in relation to the risk of
dysmenorrhea. We did not have detailed information on exposure to ETS at work and could not
fully assess the joint effect of ETS exposure at home and at the workplace. Our measurement of
potential confounders was based on self-report rather than objective measurements, which may
have limited our ability to control some confounders. Finally, although we excluded women with a
history of dysmenorrhea, we did not have clinical information of unrecognized gynecological
disorders that may produce new dysmenorrhea symptoms- Although our findings from
observational study are biologically plausible and highly consistent, they are only suggestive, not
conclusive. Further studies are needed to corroborate our findings.
From a public health perspective, dysmenorrhea is a highly prevalent gynecological morbidity
accounting for significant medical cost, absenteeism, lost working time, and reduced quality of
life.
Identification of modifiable risk factors of dysmenorrhea has important implications for women's
reproductive health. Our study findings reiterate that preventing both active and passive smoking
among women of reproductive age is likely to have a significant beneficial impact on their
reproductive health.
References and Notes
1. Ylikorkala 0, Dawood MY. New concepts in dysmenorrhea. Am J Obstet Gynecol 130:833-847 (1978).
2. Andersch B, Milsotn 1. An epidemiologic study of young women with dysmenorshea Am I Obstet
Gynecol
144:655-660 (1982).
3. Klein JR, Liu ff'. Epidemiology of adolescent dysmenorrhea Pediatrics 68:661-664 (1981).
4. Harlow SD, Park M. A longitudinal study of risk factors for the occurrence, duration and severity
of menstrual
cramps in a cohort of college women. Br J Obsmt Gynaecol 103:1 134-1142 (1996).
5. Dawood MY. Dysmenorrhea. I Reprod Med 30:154-167 (1985).
6. Friederich MA. Dysmenorrhea. Women Health 8:91-106 (1983).
7. Kennedy S. Primary dysmenorrhoea. Lancet 349:1116 (1997).
8. Hornsby PP, Wilcox AJ, Weinberg CR. Cigarette smoking and disturbance of inensuual funetion.
Epidemiology
9:193-198 (1998).
9. Parazzini F, Toui L, Merzopane R, Luchini L, Marchini M, Fedele L. Cigarette smoking, alcohol
consumption,
and risk of primary dysmenorrhea Epidemiology 5:469-472 (1994).
10. Sundell G. Milson 1, Andersch B. Factors influencing the prevalence and severity of dysmenorthea
in young
women. Br J Obstet Gynecol 97:588-594 (1990).
11. Sloss EM, Frerichs RR. Smoking and menstrual disorders. Int J Epidemiol 12~ 107-109 (1983).
http J/chpnet 1. n iehs.nih. gov/members/2 W0/ l O8p 10 19- I(122che n/chen-ful l. html 15.1 1.2OOU

Prospective Study of Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Dysmenorrhea Page 3 of 8
pain (8-l0). Nulliparous women were reported to have a higher prevalence of dysmenorrhea than
multiparous women. In our study, all the subjects were newly wed, nulliparous, nonsmokers who
intended to conceive (thus, they used no contraceptives during the follow-up menstrual cycles).
These characteristics minimize the confounding effects of contraceptive use, parity, and active
smoking. This study also adjusted for a number of occupational exposures that may be associated
with dysmenorrhea.
Methods
Study population. Beginning in July 1996, we established a cohort of newly wed couples in two
districts (Tiexi and Dadong) in Shenyang, China. These couples were recruited to participate in a
comprehensive prospective study designed to investigate the effects of various environmental and
occupational exposures on reproductive outcomes. Newly wed couples were enrolled when they
had obtained permission to become pregnant. Using daily diaries, these couples were followed until
occurrence of clinical pregnancy or for up to 1 year. Women who had a prior marriage or a
medically diagnosed gynecologic or endocrine disease were ineligible. Eligible subjects were
recruited upon their consent and participated at a rate of > 90%. In total, 472 women have
enrolled, and among these; 274 reported having history of dysmenorrhea (58.1%). For the current
analysis, we defined the ETS exposure for each complete menstrual cycle according to the diary,
which was used to link with the occurrence of menstrual pain in the next followed up menstrual
period. Therefore we only included 388 (82.2%) women who had been followed for at least one
complete menstrual cycle. Of the 388 women, 223 reported having history of dysmenorrhea
(57.5%) and were excluded from the analysis for the purpose of examinining the effect of ETS
exposure on the incidence of dysmenorrhea. The final analysis was based on 165 women who did
not report a history of dysmenorrhea at baseline interview and who had at least one complete
menstrual cycle. This study was approved by Institutional Review Boards at Harvard School of
Public Health and Beijing Medical University.
Baseline survey. We used the Chinese marriage registration system to identify newly wed couples
and those planning a first pregnancy. Upon enrollment, physical examination was performed, and
height and weight were measured according to a standard protocol. A structured baseline
questionnaire was administered by a trained interviewer to all the women and their husbands at
enrollment to collect information concerning occupational exposures, personal habits such as
cigarette smoking and alcohol consumption, living environment, exposure to passive smoking,
dietary intake, menstrual and reproductive history, and contraceptive use.
Daily diary. The current analysis is a part of longitudinal study to examine reproductive outcomes
including fecundity. Each woman was followed monthly by the field staff. When a woman decided
to stop contraception in order to become pregnant, she began recording a daily diary on menstrual
bleeding and associated symptoms and exposure to tobacco smoke and other occupational
exposures. Daily diary collection was terminated if a woman became clinically pregnant, dropped
out of the study, or did not become pregnant within I year of cessation of contraception.
Assessment of dysmenorrhea A menstrual cycle was defined from the first day of menstrual
bleeding to the day immediately before the next menstrual bleeding. Menstrual pain was defined as
abdominal pain or low back pain during menstrual bleeding. In this report, dysmenotrhea was
defined as 2 or more days of menstrual pain during menstrual bleeding. From the baseline
questionnaire, a positive history of dysmenorrhea was defined as any menstrual pain during the
previous 12 months.
Assessment of environmental tobacco smoke Each woman recorded in her daily diary the
number of cigarettes smok0d by the regular household members. The specific question in the diary
t'orm was, "What is the number of cigarettes someone smoked indoors at home yesterday while
http://chpnet t .niehs.nih.gov/members/200O/108p 1019-I022chen/chen-full.html 15.11.2000

Page 1 of I
Table 1. Characterlstics of 155 women by pesslva smokln0 status at Vte first follow-up menstrual
cycle,
Sheiqaiq. China.
Pauivesmnldn athane
Cheracteristlcs No n asin= 1321 p-Value
Physisal
Apebeers)
25.912.3
26.112.6
0686
Heiple(m) 162,1001 1 1.601016 0.046
WaqN p.y) 54.116.6 54.0 17.4 0.943
00 mass Index (kp/rrP) 20.6s 2.8 21.0125 8465
Arje at Mmnylo Nears) 14.1413 141111 1.4 p.627
Eorcatlon
Mildleschoolorlrnvei
212
235
0.911
H4hahwal 42.4 43.9
Collape ar abrr2 38.4 32.6
Oaupetlou
Tatrdckn
51.5
47.0
0.092
Adminhpafne saff 242 273
factaywarker 249 257
llccupatbrtal ezposufe
Toth
3.7
8.5
8400
Ndso 14.8 184 0.120
Oid 00 6.5 0.449
Shiflwork 27.3 280 8882
Perceipetl stress 9.1 13.7 0.725
Pastbosmdcingalwork 3'i3 45.4 0.250
Soasan tollowup sfa r1ed
SptlnO
394
288
0.8;ip
Summar 12.1 189
rdl 30.3 32B
Winter 182 19.7
No. ot pcies lolowed
1
24.3
23.5
0.961
24 515 47.7
5-7 12.1 13.6
>0 12.1 152
Bcropt m romQ el vaWat ara pxcart ot tiel aubJactx otrarvaWar are maen t SB
p-Vduas forphylicrl charactwislin aro dcrind byffrst;ae ethuraero dqirad bydrl-tqurra ba[
69Z189S05Z
http://ehpnetl.niehs.nih.gov/members/2000/ 108p 1019-1022chen/chentab 1 B.GIF 15.11.2000

Prospective Study of Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Dysmenorrhea
eGr.C.a o .. a.w P.Wr e. rr sl... r nl Lir ln.non.
iM1.,.rq~
~M1sw Y. rl~.r.
Crr.cv.wc[
reF-iR ~~
1rN-li}
4V.Yw
I1.,aN
+tpYr.) m.n 21,1.21 lol
4VI1N 151,11" 110,11% lrG
W.ylnyl Gll.Gr Sal.]a 9113
h,l1i 2114,211 ALIS rsc
~y.n~..rh.... 111.13 uo.1a om
.r.
YY/Yn/./rYmsr Al ]1f Glll
~sdwl Ra 111
C.r1u.W 314 221
yAr
Tr~ Glc ue Iw1
wr;rr.~w,. xs As
G.eryrb Mf Xl
wyf,nl.n.,n
x : 37 al rm
r.. lu ua ua
b r./ II ~rl
srl..n aI A/ I Ire
..w,.r. u ui otc
xnYff, rvM A] Ka IiGI
.,n 41.rq nr./
J'iq 1i1 ]Ir rl]I
d.m- 111 111
rM a1 ul
Mrm lz I]
ael clzrfirwr
]u 239 im
2-l nS l1]
6..} 12.1 11e
1 111 IG]
~arl.rnua~~orrm o:w.r....~aa
vwnr www.r.,rn..rrr rwrar.rnr .w i..rY.
Page 5 of 8
The overall incidence of dysmenorrhea was 12% among T.61e 2. Crude incidence rate of tlysmenorrhea
In
all ros ectivel observed menstrual c cles. However, as the 625 fohow-up menstrual cl cles by pasefve
P P Y Y smoldnp ststus.
shown in Table 2, the incidence differed significantly by
the four ETS exposure categories, with the lowest rate
(9.7%) in the nonexposed group and the highest rate
(16.9%) in the high ETS exposure group. Among ETS-
exposed cycles, there was a positive dose-response
gradient between the number of cigarettes smoked and the
incidence as well as the relative risk of dysmenorrhea.
Table 3 presents the crude and adjusted ORs of
dysmenorrhea in relation to ETS exposure. Compared
with cycles without ETS exposure, the adjusted ORs of
dysmenorrhea associated with low, middle, and high
PaseivesmaldnU Total Drstnenorrhea
(ciparettestaay) cycles No. Percent
All qdes
Nole
145
14
9.7
tow(<6e) 160 15 9.a
Mitltlle (O.B-2.5) 160 zt 13.8
H iy h[> 2.15) 166 27 169
Fist tycls alq
None
33
2
6.1
mw (< 0.8) 44 5 11.4
Mldtlle (0 &.2 7) 44 7 15.9
Hlgh (>2.0) 44 17 29.6
tertiles of ETS exposure were 1.1 (Cl; 0.5-2.6), 2.5 (CI, 0.9-6.7), and 3.1 (Cl, 1.2-8.3),
respectively. The findings were again consistent when the analysis was limited to the first
menstrual
cycle from each woman. Three variables as a group--namely age, body mass index, and
occupational category--explained most of the difference between the crude and adjusted results.
When these three variables were excluded from the full model, the ORs for the exposure categories
were 1.08, 2.20, and 2.46, respectively, leading to results similar to the unadjusted effect
estimates.
However, exclusion of any single variable from the model did not lead to such a change from the
full model. When ETS exposure was treated as a continuous variable, the estimated OR of
dysmenorrhea was 1.3 (Cl, L0-1.8) for exposure to two cigarettes per tiay; that is, the risk of
dysmenorrhea increased by 30% for each two cigarettes smoked at home.
Finally, we performed several subset analyses to exclude the possibility of potential confounding.
We tirst excluded the women who had used either oral contraceptives or an intrauterine device
before the study. The ORs of dysmenorrhea for women with low, middle, and high exposure to
ETS were 1.I (Cl, 0.5-2.6), 2.6 (CI, 0.9-7 1), and 3.1 (Cl, 1.2-8.2), respectively, which were
consistent with those from the total sample.
http Jleh pnet 1. niehs.nih. gov/members/2000/ 108p I(119-1022che nlchen-f ull- h(ml 15.1 1.2000

Prospective Study of Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Dysmenorrhea Page 6 of 8
Table 3. Crude and adjusted odds ratios af dysmenorrhea associntotl with passive smoking from 625
fdlaw-up cyGas.
Passivesmotlng Unadlusletl Iidjusted
(dgarettssdayry N ~%CI p-Value OR 96%CI )tYaue
Moda I
ntone
1.0
-
-
1.0
-
-
(nw(<0.8) . 1.1 0.5-2.5 0.041 1.1 OS-2.6 0.801
Middkl.0.B-25) 2.1 0."6 0.150 2.5 0.9-8.7 0.079
Hiph(>1.8) 2.4 -0.8-6.1 0.072 3.1 1.2-8.3 0-024
Mode1 11
Tsw riparettra/dar
1.3
1.0-1.6
0.088
1.3
1.0-1.8
0.030
'rha IogNgc nnroasioo modal adju.iad far dizarict (Timd va Oadnegj, ega tartNa (21.5-21.8, tt7-7B.5,
28S31.1t hody
maf. indox tat4ht fti4-19.0.198-7 t.9, 23A-91 it eW cation fmiddle achml or Iowvr, high schaol,
rollago ur ehwej, eroa
of roeidann, occupation (tacMkien, admlNatratka etaf( hu:tmy workeu), apiftwodc, parcgkad ma.;
occupauatd
afcpesua tn cluniral hamFda, imw and dutt pafafw emokfng at warQ and tlho aanaon twkdaraM eprYg ee,
sumwr
and [sp) of Lu stem.g c9cle. Ganarallad aaimetingaplatlanswera uaadta accuumfurmulipb qckatparwoman.
The number of available cycles varied by each individual woman. Moreover, both dysmenorrhea
and ETS have a high intraclass correlation coefficient within cycles (0.44 and 0.67, respectively),
and therefore women with fewer cycles will have smaller weight in the evaluation of passive
smoking effect. We addressed this potential bias by only including each woman's first menstrual
cycle in the analysis. As shown in Table 2, the results were similar to those of the analysis that
included all available cycles.
Exposure to ETS at work was another potential confounder. Because we did not have detailed
information on workplace exposure, we could only include it as a binary variable (yes, no) in the
regression analysis. ETS at work may also be considered as a component of exposure. To address
this concern, we first restricted our analysis to women who did not report exposure to ETS at
work at the baseline interview. The results remained consistent; the ORs of dysmenorrhea for low,
middle, and high passive smoking were 1.1 (CI, 0.4-3.5), 1.9 (CI, 0.6-6.3), and 2.0 (CI, 0.6-6.7),
respectively. Second, we combined ETS at home (no, low, middle, high) with ETS at work (no,
yes), creating eight categories of exposure. Compared to the group with neither exposure, the ORs
for the groups were 1.3 (low, no), 0.9 (low, yes), 2.5 (middle, no), 2.4 (middle, yes), 3.0 (high,
no), and 3.1 (high, yes).
Discussion
Previous studies demonstrated the adverse effects of current smoking on menstrual cycle (S,8-
10,14). Few studies are available on ETS exposure in relation to the risk of dysmenorrhea. In this
report, we found a significant dose-response relation between ETS exposure and the risk of
dysmenorrhea, even after adjustment for important covariates. It is noted that our study reported
the incidence rate of dysmenorrhea among those who did not have a history of dysmenorrhea at
enrollment Most previous studies reported prevalence. According to the baseline questionnaire,
the prevalence of dysmenorrhea in our population was 58.1%, which is comparable to the
prevalence reported in the previous studies (47-72%). The effect of passive smoking on
dysmenorrhea observed in this study appears stronger than that in a longitudinal study by Hornsby
et al. (8), in which the authors observed a 30% increase in the mean number of days with
dysmenorrhea. Some features of our study may contribute to a stronger effect compared to the
previous studies. Our study population was younger than those included by Hornsby et al., who
included women 37-39 years of age. We measured the amount of ETS by estimating the number of
cigarettes smoked in the women's presence, whereas Hornsby et al. defined ETS as living or
sharing a workplace with a smoker. In addition, our study focused on new occurrence of
dysmenorrhea, excluding women who reported a history of dysmenorrhea. All the women in our
study were nonsmokers and thus current smoking was not a confounder here.
httpl/ehpnetl.niehs.nih.gov/membersl2(7(X)/108p1019-1022chen/chen-full.html (5.11.20(X)

Prospective Study of Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Dysmenorrhea Page 2 of 8
Address correspondence to X. Xa Department of Environmental Health, Harvard School of Public
Health. 665 Huntington .4venue, Boston, MA 02115 USA. Telephone: (617) 432-2959. Fax: (617)
432-2956. E-mail: zu@bsph harvard edu
This study was supported in part by grants 1R01 ES08337 from the National Institute of
Environmental Health Sciences and IROI HD32505 from the National Institute of Child Health and
Human Development. 1). Chen was supported in part by a Fogarty International Center training grant
(TW00828).
Received 24 Apri12000; accepted 13 June 2000.
Introduction
Dysmenorrhea, or painful menses, is a common gynecologic disorder in women of reproductive
age. Reported prevalence ranges from 47 to 72% for various age groups (1-3). This condition
accounts for significant school absenteeism, lost working time, and reduced quality of life¢6). In
the United States it is estimated that 600 million working hours are lost annually as a result of
primary dysmenorrhea (5), and it is now recognized as an important women's health issue Q).
A growing body of evidence demonstrates an association between environmental and occupational
exposures and adverse reproductive outcomes. Although limited data are available for
dysmenorrhea, epidemiological studies have shown a link between dysmenorrhea and several
environmental risk factors, including current cigarette smoking #-//). An even greater proportion
of women are exposed passively to environmental tobacco smoke (ETS). The question of whether
exposure to ETS also increases the risk of dysmenorrhea has been studied only to a limited extent.
In a study by Hornsby et al. (8), women exposed to ETS reported more days with dysmenorrhea
on average (2.6 days) compared to unexposed women (2.0 days), adjusting for duration of menses
and other confounders. There are a number of methodologic challenges in studying the health
effects of ETS exposure. First, quantification of ETS exposure has been problematic, in part
because such exposure takes place in multiple locations. The contribution of each environment to
total personal exposure varies with the amount of time spent and the concentration of ETS. Most
studies are retrospective or cross-sectional in nature, so that the validity of these data depends
on
the accuracy of a subject's recall. Furthermore, a temporal relation cannot be established, and thus
causal inference cannot be made. As estimated by a previous study (2) using urine cotirtine as a
biomarker of cigarette smoke exposure, current smoking may result in urine cotinine levels 30- to
100-fold higher than ETS. It is likely that the magnitude of effect from ETS is small and more
difficult to detect than that of current smoking. Among smoking women who are also exposed to
ETS, it is difficult to sort out the independent contribution of current and passive smoking.
The purpose of this report is to examine the association of ETS exposure with dysmenorrhea
among a cohort of newly wed, nonsmoking women who had no history of dysmenorrhea in
Shenyang, China. Our study has several unique features. Dysmenorrhea and exposure to ETS were
defined by the use of a daily diary. This prospective study design eliminates potential recall bias,
a
common drawback of retrospective or cross-sectional studies. In China, few women smoke
cigarettes, but exposure to ETS is very high because of the high prevalence of smoking among
men (I5). This setting provides a good opportunity to study the effect of ETS exposure on
dysmenorrhea. Oral contraceptives were sometimes used clinically to alleviate menstrual pain, thus
introducing a potential confounder (/0). Parity was also suggested to be associated with menstrual
http://chpnet I. nich s n ih _ g ov/inembc rs/2000/ l ORp 1 O I 9-1022che n/chen-full. h tm l 15.1
1.20(X)
