Philip Morris
Nasopharyngeal Carcinoma in Malaysian Chinese: Occupational Exposures to Particles Formaldehyde and Heat
Fields
- Author
- Armstrong, M.J.
- Armstrong, R.W.
- Imrey, P.B.
- Lye, M.S.
- Sani, S.
- Yu, M.C.
- Armstrong, R.W.
- Document File
- 2505587211/2505587290/Missing
- Type
- PSCI, PUBLICATION SCIENTIFIC
- ABST, ABSTRACT
- BIBL, BIBLIOGRAPHY
- ABST, ABSTRACT
- Area
- BADSTUBER,ANDRE/OFFICE
- Named Organization
- Cancer Treatment Centre
- Computer Radionics Centre
- General Hospital
- Inst for Medical Research
- Inst for Radiotherapy + Nuclear Medicine
- NCI, Natl Cancer Inst
- Pantai Medical Centre
- Tung Shin Hospital
- Computer Radionics Centre
- Site
- E16
- Named Person
- Chiew, K.H.
- Chow, P.F.
- Chua, K.E.
- Davis, L.
- Ganesan, S.
- Grammenos, D.
- Lim, A.
- Lim, C.M.
- Loke, H.C.
- Moorman, R.
- Narasimha, S.
- Ng, P.L.
- Ong, K.C.
- Tan, M.K.
- Wu, K.S.
- Chow, P.F.
- Author (Organization)
- Inst for Medical Research
- Intl Epidemiological Assn
- Intl Journal of Epidemiology
- Univ of Il Champaign
- Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia
- Usc, Univ. Of Southern Ca
- Intl Epidemiological Assn
- Master ID
- 2505587212/7289
Related Documents:- 2505587212-7213 Untitled document 2505587212/7213
- 2505587214-7216 Review 1137 Subject Ref 8b "Breast Cancer, Passive and Active Cigarette Smoking and N-Acetyltransferase 2 Genotype" R J Delfino Et Al Pharmacogenetics (20000000), 10, 461-469
- 2505587217-7225 Breast Cancer, Passive and Active Cigarette Smoking and N-Acetyltransferase 2 Genotype
- 2505587226 Smoking During Pregnancy and Breast Cancer Risk in Young Women.
- 2505587227-7230 Review 1134 Subject Ref 8b "Lung Cancer and Environmental Tobacco Smoke in a Non-Industrial Area of China" L Wang Et Al International Journal of Cancer (20000000), 88, 139-145
- 2505587231-7237 Lung Cancer and Environmental Tobacco Smoke in A Non-Industrial Area of China
- 2505587238-7240 Review 1135 Subject Ref 8b "Nasopharyngeal Carcinoma in Malaysian Chinese: Occupational Exposures to Particles, Formaldehyde and Heat R W Armstrong Et Al International Journal of Epidemiology (20000000), 29, 991-998
- 2505587249-7252 "Environmental Tobacco Smoking, Mutagens Sensitivity, and Head and Neck Squamous Cell Carcinoma" Z-F Zhang Et Al Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers & Prevention (20000000), 9, 1043 - 1049
- 2505587253-7259 Environmental Tobacco Smoking, Mutagen Sensitivity, and Head and Neck Squamous Cell Carcinoma
- 2505587260 "Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Non-Fatal Myocardial Infarction Among Never-Smokers" M Rosenlund Et Al Epidemiology (20000000), 11, S103
- 2505587261 Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Non-Fatal Myocardial Infarction Among Never-Smokers
- 2505587262-7264 "Prospective Study of Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Dysmenorrhea" C Chen Et Al Environmental Health Perspectives (20000000), 108, 1019 - 1022
- 2505587265-7273 Prospective Study of Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Dysmenorrhea
- 2505587274-7276 "Prenatal Active or Passive Tobacco Smoke Exposure and the Risk of Preterm Delivery or Low Birth Weight" Gc Windham Et Al Epidemiology (20000000), 11, 427 - 433
- 2505587277-7283 Prenatal Active or Passive Tobacco Smoke Exposure and the Risk of Preterm Delivery or Low Birth Weight
- 2505587284-7285 "A Prospective Study of Smoking During Pregnancy and Sids" K Wisborg Et Al Archives of Diseases in Childhood ( 20000000), 83, 203 - 206
- 2505587286-7289 A Prospective Study of Smoking During Pregnancy and Sids
- Litigation
- Feda/Produced
- Date Loaded
- 11 Sep 2002
- UCSF Legacy ID
- aee19c00
Document Images
o Im.ruaunnal CliiJcm~olop¢al n....uznun 2000 riimnl 1n U1c n Ihnam e.ran.rn..uel ..... n..,r.y
Fr~.nnirak..n' 2ooo.2V 9of
Nasopharyngeal carcinoma in Malaysian
Chinese: occupational exposures to particles,
formaldehyde and heat
R Warwick-Armstrong,a Peter B Itnrey,b Munn Sann Lyc,c M Jocelyn Armstrong,a Mimi C Yud
and Sham Sanie
Background During 1990-1992, 282 Chinese residents of Selangor and the Federal Territory,
Malaysia with histologically confirmed nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPC) were
interviewed about occupational history, diet, alcohol consurrmption, and tobacco
use, as were an equal number of Malaysian Chinese population controls, pair-
matched to cases by age and sex-
Methods Exposures to 20 kinds of workplace substances, solar and industrial heat, and
cigarette smoke, were analysed by univariate and multivariate methods. .
Results Nasopharyngeal carcinoma was associated with occupational exposures to con-
struction, metal and wood dusts: motor fuel and oil; paints and varnishes: certain
other chemicals; industrial heat; solar heat from outdoor occupauons: certain smokes:
cigarette smoking; and childhood exposure to parental smoking. After adjustrnent
for risk from diet and cigarette smoke, only wood dust (OR = 2.36; 95% CI : L33-
419), and industrial heat (OR = Z21; 95% CI : 1.12-4.33) remained clearly asso-
dated- wood dust remained statistically significant after further adjustment for
social class. No significant crude or adjusted association was found between NPC
and formaldehyde (adjusted OR = 0.71: 95% CI : 0.34-1.43).
Conclusions This study supports previous findings that some occupational inhalants are risk
factors for NPC. The statistical effect of wood dust remained substantial after
adjustment for diet, cigarette smoke, and social class. Intense industrial heat
emerged as a previously unreported risk factor, statistically significant even after
adjustment for diet and cigarette smoke. No association was found between NPC
and formaldehyde.
Keywords Nasopharyngeaf carcinoma, occupations, air particles, formaldehyde, heat, Malaysia
Accepted 10 May 2000
Although comparatively rare worldwide, nasopharyngeal
carcinoma (NPC) has substantial incidence and mortality in
populations of southern Chinese ancestry in China and
Southeast Asia. Nasopharyngeal carcinoma in southern Chinese
is believed to result from a combination of genetic susceptibiliry.
" Departmenr of Communiry Healih, Unlversiry of flllnms. Champaign,
IL 61820, USA.
° Departmenr ot Srzrisria, and Depanmeni af Mediczl Infofmaiion Sciener.
Universiry of Illinois. Champaign. f461820. USn.
` Institute fue Medical Research, Kuala Lumpur. 50588 Malaysia.
5 Dcpartmeni of Prevenrive Mcdi<ine. Univcrsiry of Southern CaGfornia
School ol Mcdidnc. Los Angclcs. CA 90031. USA.
` Department of Geography. Univcrsiii Kebangsaan Malaysia. 8angi. 43600
Malaysia
infection with Epstein-Barr virus, and regular consumption of
salted fish beginning in childhood.f Nasopharyngeal carcinoma
has been associated with salted foods.2-7 with alcohol coruump-
tion.3'a cigarette smoking.8 and occupational exposures Z'4.7'9-IZ
The epidemiology of NPC has been reviewed by Yu and
Henderson.13 We report a case-control study of NPC in Chinese
of the Federal Territory (Kuala Lumpur), and State of Selangor.
Malaysia. The primary objective was to pursue indications from
smaller studies of this population,2'14 and of others, that NPC
risk dses with work-site inhalation of dust and smoke particles.
formaldehyde, and certain aromatic hydrocarbons. We exam-
ined associations of NPC with occupational exposure histories,
active and passive cigarette smoking, and consumption of alcohol
and various dietary components. Results on dietary exposures
including alcohol have been reported.3 Here we focus on asso-
dations with occupational exposures and cigarette smoke.
991

996 INTERNATIONAI. IOURNAI. r1F LPIUEMI(1LOGY
Table 9 Logisric rcgressou odds rauu. :URi fur Icn(nW c_vposurc Increare nuh an.l snlli~ul
adlu<linrcnl lur dficl and dgarcne slnokr indiccs
Agent Unadjusted OR
(95°/u Ctt Adjusted OR
(95 % Cl)
------~- -- P fnr diet and cigarcar
smoke adjusted OR"
Dusts
ConsVUCtion 1.14 (1 02 1 26) 195 (0.93-1 '0I 0.57
Fe[Iilizer 098 (0 64-I 19) 0A 2 t0 51-1 31~ 041 1
Mctal I.IS(102 1.3]) 1.14109a 1 ~. 011
Talc 1 14 10 96-1.511 (LA6(0G1-1'I. 0 19
Tin 1.19 (o.9n-15G) L16 (0.R3-I G 1, p 37
Textilc 1.14(0.96-1_36) 1 .I1) 10.94 142) 016
Wood 1 29 (1 13-I 46) I 29 il 07-I 41, 00018
Othere 1.09 I1 00-1.20) 1 U7 I(I_96-1 1 1l 0.23
Fumes
Cooking
I t)9 (0.91-L31I
0 117 9 10 ?M-I 21)
0 80
Engtneexhaust 1.o1 (0.91-L12) LUlI/q3N-I 1.1, 096
Wood I 20 (0 97-1.49) 1 0 10.84-I 3il 0.54°
Other° 1 22 (I n2-1.45) 1 12 i0 .91 1.59i 0 27
Chemicals
nloddes
0A8(0.80-1.20)
09310J41.17~
0.40
Dyes L13 (0.801.58) 1 07 IOJ3-1.5F) 071
Formaldehyde 1.04 (0 8G-1 27/ 0.E8 10 70-I 121 0.2.9
Glues I.16 (0 97-1.38) 1.09 I!1.88-I 341 0 40
OOtrr, chemicalsd I 24 (0.99-1.55) 1.20 (0.92-1 561 0.15
Motnrfuelandoil I 1511D2-1_30) 1.05 (p.vl 12_'1 0.50
Paintsandvzrnishes 1.19(1-03-1.38) 1.08(091-I29i 0.35
Resins 0_8410.65-1_08) 074 i(1 54-I.0:) 0.047
Heat
Solar
1_1411_01-1.29)
1 0210 89-11 8;
074
Industrial 1.33 (1_13 1.56/ I 21 I I 01-I 4S) 0025
' n°a See Table I[nr dermilions.
` Statistically signlficanc quadralic rffen. .~. iexr
confidence intervals for formaldehyde OR from these two
studies overlap substantially, so Ihc apparent differences may
not be matenal_ Considerably more data are needed to resolve
the formaldehyde question.
In I991-1992, we carried out baccline sampling of ambient
air in 42 work sites in 10 industries in the study area. The
industries were selected on the basis of occupatiunal histories
of NPC cases recorded in this arld Iwo previous Malaysian
studies.2,14 Air particle sampling confirmed the presence of
high-risk pollution for the nasnpharynx of particles with dia-
meter <10 µm in adhesives, metahvorking, ricemills, sawmill-
ing. and shoemaking, with mean values exceeding [ 50 µg/rrti
which is the US Environmental Prolection Agency's33 24-hour
ambient air quality standard for PM10. Formaldehyde levels
exceeded the American Conference of Governntental Industrial
Hygienists (ACGIH)34 threshold linllt value (TLV-Cetling) of
0.37 mg1m3 in only the adhcsivcs industry but all others had
mean 8-hour mncemrations betwec, 0.16 and 0.35 mghn3_
To our knowledge, intense indlulrial heat has not previously
been examined in relation to NPC. Dry heat [rom suurres such
as furnaces, welding machines, and rolling ntills, combined with
the tropical Malaysian climate, yields high working temperatures
that may intensity the vulnerabilily of thc nasopharyna to
inspired dusts and lomes. The strrngth uf the Olt, and the
persistent associauon after adjustment for other nsk factors.
indicate that this exposure warrants further investigation.
Analyses oI uur data by lateney time frames of 5, 10, 15 and
20 years prior Io diagnosis showed little difference in OR from
those based on all exho.ure at least one year prior to diagnosis.
Nor were dlete impnrl.ant differences by length of exposure
(<10 vcrnus =111 ycars), by age of worker (quaniles, and <45
versus a45 years), or by Chinese subethnidty. This may indicate
short latency aud thal acute high-level exposures are more
dangerous than chronic low-level exposures. Alternatively, this
could be due to sntall numbers of participating pairs in stratified
cnmpansons, or to measurement problems.
Cigarette sntoke has been associated with cancers of the oral
cavity, respiralory tract, and distant organs_ Our data add to an
accumulalion of evidence associating cigarettes with NPC, and
confirm the finding of Yu u a1.5 that exposure to parental smok-
ing ducing childhood p;ays a role. Social class has previously
been associated with NPC_IS In this study. social class does not
substannally ~nnfournd I he diet/smoking adjusted relationships
lo NPC of any of the occupational exposures examined.
Our study, as earlier case-control studies in high-risk NPC
populations, is limiled by the fairly small numbers of cases
and conlrols reporting various uncommon occupational
cxposures.
2505587246

OCCUPATIONAI. IiXI'OSURES AND NPC IN MALAVSIA 995
Table 3 Estimatcd odds ratios tor anp vcrvtrs n0 histnry of
22 occupational exposures with and wilhuuo ad)uament for diet
and cigarette smoke indices
Substances
Unadjusted Ingistic regression
adjusted
Dusts
Constructlon I 71 (1 07-2.761 1 31 (0.77-2-24)
Fertilizer I 00 (0.18-5. 371 t).52 (0-I0-2 71)
Metal 1.90 (1 .07-3.45I 1.62 (0 90-3.08)
Talc 1.431049JlA3i 0.49 (0-14-1.66)
Tin 1.8010.54-6.84) 1 69 (0.45-6.30)
Textile 1 _66 (077 374) 1 77 (0.76-1 .11)
Wood 264(1 58-453) 2.36 (1.3" .19)
Other6 1.53 (1.03-2.29J 1.39 (0.88-2.16)
Fumes
Cooking
1.50 (0.68-3.421
0.93 (0.38-2.27)
Engine exhaust 1.08 (0.67-1 71 1 1.05 (0.61-1.79)
Wood 2.20 (0.99-5-211 I 65 t069-3 92)
Otherr 2.00 ( I 01 -i . I I I 1 46 (0.6(-3.23)
Chemicals Biocides 1.00 /0.49-2.09) 091 (0.42-1.98)
Dyes 1.2010_30--4.98) 1 03 (0.26-1 .02)
Formaldehyde 1 24 (0.67-2 32) 0.71 (0.34-I_43)
Glues 1 ]5 (0.91-347) 1.30 (0.61-2J6)
Other chemlcalsd 2 37 (0.99~ 28) 2.36 (0.92-6.08)
Motor fuel and oil 1.79 (L1~2.82) 1.33 (0.81-2.20)
Paintsandvarntshes 2.00(t.lo-3J4/ 1.32 10.67-2.571
Resins 0.62 (0.22-1.611 0.41 10-14-1.211
Heat
Solar
1.83 (1.09-3.16
1 .20 (0.67-2-14)
Industrial 3.u5 1 1.64-6.08) 2.21 (1.12-1.33)
u r A Sec Tablc I for dehmuons,
in results In particular, wood dust results were essentially
unaffected (OR = 1.22. P= 0.0057, 95% Ci : 1.05-1.42). while
the estimated effect size for industrial heat was slightly attenu-
ated, with concomitant increase in P-value to a conventionally
suggestive level (OR = 1.18, P=0.07[, 95% CI : 0.98-1.41)-
Discussion
Since the nasopharynx serves to trap primarily medium
size particles (5-lO pm) in inspired air25 and absorbs soluble
chemicals, inhaled carcinogens are biologically plausible risk
factors for NPC. Dust particles from wood, metal, construction
sites, tin mining, talc, and textiles, and smoke particles from
incomplete combustion of wood and other materials, all occur
frequently in Malaysian occupational environments and are of
sizes and weights deposited mostly in the nasopharynx. Several
studies13 have associated wood dust with adenocarcinoma of
the nasal cavities and paranasal sinuses, and in 1994 the Inter-
national Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC)26 classified
wood dust as a human carcinogen. Demers er a(.27 performed a
pooled analysis of data from one UK and four US cohort studies
on wood dust, and found excess NPC among furniture and plywood workers. But evidence relating NPC to
other occupational
risk factors has remained less clcar. Irt California, Henderson
et a/9 found NPC significantly associated wnh fumcs. smoke.
and chemicals, but nut wilh dusts. In A1alaysia, Armstrungetrt/.2
found dose-response relationships of NPC to dust and sntukc,
but not to chemicals. In China. Ning er a1.2 associated NPC with
smoke, dust, and chemical tumes, as did Yu eral-4 in Hong Kong
residenls ¢35 years of aga Chen er aLlo tound an associalion in
Taiwan with sntoke bttl not dust, as did Yu et rrLll in China-
West er al.12 found an association in the Philippines with dust
and engine exhaust. Dnmestic exposure5 to snwke from burning
wood, incense, or anti-mosquito coils are suggested risk factors
for which case-control studics provide little supporr13 An exception is the finding by vVest er
al.12 in the Philippines of an
assocLattnn with anlt-ritoCqntttl cndG-
Our results confirm earlier observations that NPC in Malaysia
is crudely associated with occupational exposures to chemical
fumes, smoke and dusts, particularly fronl wood and metals-
The persistence of the association with wood dust after adjusl-
ment for cigarette smoke, diet, and social class, strengthens the
epidemiologic plausibility of a causal pathway involving that ex-
posure. Howcver, cigareuc smoke and diet partially confounded
the relationships of NPC to other inhalants. We did not find
dose-response effects of other inhalants with substantial explan-
atory power beyond that of presence or absence. This leaves
open the question of whether these inhalanls are biologically
active contributors or simply comnron companions of other active
agents.
Formaldehyde has been suggested as a possible cause of
NPC since 1980, when animal studies showed that high doses
cause nasal and paranasal cancers in rats. Epidemiological
studies have since sought associations between occupational
exposure to fonnaldehyde artd various canccrs in low-risk NPC
populations in Europe and Noah America. Most of these found
an elevated risk for NPC in association with lotmaldehyde,le.2g-3n
but not all.S1 The evidence for an association between NPC and
formaldehyde has recently been rcvicwed by the US Agency
for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry_32 In 1987, the US
Environmental Protectinn Agency,32 and in 1995 the IARC.26
classified formaldehyde as probably carcinogenic for humans.
In moderate-risk populations, to date the only case-control
study to report an association between NPC and formaldehyde
is that by west et a(.,12 in a non-Chinese Filipino population.
Using occupational histories of 257 subjeets, of whom 60
(23-3%) were exposed to formaldehyde, they found OR of 3.5
for cases first exposed 25 or more years prior to NPC diagnosis,
and 3.2 for cases tirst exposed before the age of 25, relativc
to those never exposed. These analyses incorporatcd a 10-year
latency period. In contrast, our study in Malaysia is the largest
case-control investigation of the formaldehyde-NPC relation-
ship in a high-risk population, and conveys no suggestion that
occupational exposure confers NPC risk. Other differences
between our data and those of West er al., c.gc regarding con-
sumption of salted and fresh fish, suggest that these populations
may indeed differ with respect to NPC risk factors. Ifowever, we
identified formaldehyde exposure in only 51 of 564 subjects
(9.0 %) of our Malaysian Chmesc sample, of whom only eight
had accumulated ~ 10 years of exposure outside a 1 O-year latenp?
period. The Malaysian occupations included those where ex-
posure to formaldehyde would be expcc7ed, namely: adhesives,
foundoes, latex processing, metalworking and welding, plywood
manufacture, rubber (ire manufacture, sawmilling, shoe making
(glues), and textiles (permanent Press fabrics/. Funhcrmore.

998 INTLRNATIONAL JOt112NAL OF CPIDHMIOLOGY
2binternational Agency for Rrzesr.h un Cancer- Wood Dusr mrd
Farmaldelrl'de. ManograPlu arr r)rr Sraivurrmr ef rlre Curcrnogaur Rsk in
Hnurnns. Yal 62. Lyon' IARC, 199s.
2l Demers PA, Boffetta P. Kogevinas M rr al Pooled rranalysis of cancer
mortality anrong five cohons of wnrkrrs in woodrelated indusrrivs.
Scand J Work Environ HealJe 1995,21: 179 -90.
28 Hardcli L. Johansson B. Axeisou C) Fpdemlologlcal study of nasal
and nasoplrarynReal cancer and iheir relanon to phenoxy acid
chlorophrnul expnsure. Am J lnd Mud 1982;3:247-57.
39ROUSh GC, Walrurh J, Stayner 1.]'. ICaplan SA, Flannery JT. Blair A
Nasopharyngeal cancer. sinonasal rancer, and occupations related to
formaldehyde' a case-conrrnl srudy. J Vnrl Can.erlrsst 1987:99:1221-24.
snBlair A, Sacaca R. Stewan PA. Hayrs RB. Shy C. Epidemiologic
evidence on the rclauonshrp hawerrn formaldrhyde cxposure and
cancer Scand J v/ork Environ Healu. 1990,16:381-93.
Appendix
In the context of this paper, a couditional logistic regression
model adjusting for diet and cigarette smoke, while
incorporating exposure time quantitatively, employs a linear
predictor (3DzD+ fiGZ,+(fsx, where x is an exposure measure
f,e.g., IogID(l+I), as used for Tablc 3)- Such a model has
likelihood function
L(A)=11it+exp(f)n(r,lu-zioD) r (k:lrrlC-ziocl+IJx(xil-xra)~-
for matched pairs i= I to n(hcr n- 282). whcrc i indcxcs the
matched pairs, and I or 0 in the snbscript distinguishes cases
from controls.15 Statistical interence for this model is based on
the permutation distribution ol f,(#) obtained from joint
exchanges, within cach of the 3" possible subsets of pairs, of
observed values of the predictor values zdN, zd, and xd for a case
ir Purchasc IPIi. Paddlr CM. Docs Inrrnaldchydc cauar nasopharynGCal
cancer in man] Cmrrer LeH 19F9:4609-R5.
)zUS Dcpanmenr of lieabh and Human Scrvicrs. Public Hcald) Servicc,
Agency for Toxic Substances and Disrase Registry. Toxirnlogrra! Profile
for FannalJeLydn Atlantz, 19977
rsUS Envuonm<ntal P:n:c.unn Agency. National Ambient Air Qual-
rty Standard>. IOn-lu cl (hup-//wwsv-epa.gnv/airs/criterla.htmll
1999
oAnrerican Conferencr uf Goremmcntal Industrml Hygremsts.
L)ocumrnrauon of rlee Tlvesdald f inrle va[ua and Rlologiml Exposurr Indicu.
6rlr Edn. Washmgton, DC. 1994.
350rrzlnw Nr, Dey VIl Sra[urrral Mcrhodr m Can¢r Researdr. Ynl l:
T/re Anc/:ars o(Case r:m:rel Smdiar [ynm Imernational Ageny for
Research on Cancer 1930. p.253
with d)c predictor values zio, z/oo and xio for the
corresponding malched contrnl- The adjusted sign test is
obtained by simply replacing f)r(xl -xr0) In L(fi) by (1rsi, where
si=s(gn(xg _.rio), and vgn(xrl-x[o1 = I if x, >xio,=0 ifxtl=xro,
and =-I if sry < xi) - Note then that if L(P) is the correct
specificatlorr <d the conditional likelihood, then fix = 0 implies
that (3r=0 in ihe modiFied likelihood
/. +cx3r r_ ~-t
'(91- R I I do'd~ 'ron) i Pcadc-~iacl+Rrsl .
which then is identical to 1.(fl). Thus. a test of (3r=0 in L'(,?) is
also a test of /3r=0 in L(p). The usual null large-sample chi-
square distribution (if the likelihood ratio statistic applies
because its derivaor)n is conditional on Ihc values of the
predictors, and docs not dcpend on the manner of their
azsigmrn-ul-

994 INTERNATIONAI. IOUI2SA:. OF EPIDEMIOLOGV
Table I Associarions of nasophar) ngcal camcF with historics of 22 oc<-upatiunal cxpo un,.
Exposure (%)
- P-value (diet and
Substance
<:ases
Controls F,spused
pairs Median di0erence in
hours exposed (toos) P-value
(sign test) cigarette smoke
adjusted sign tesqa
Dusts
Construction 22.0 14 2 93 -1 5 0_012 0.30
Fenrlizer 1.4 1.4 8 --~ 1 00 044
Metal 16.0 9 6 65 1 1 0 0025 0.06
Talc 3.6 2.5 17 eJ 0.65 0_26
Tin 3_2 1.8 14 /6 6 041 0.41
Tezllle 7 .8 5_0 34 4/, ' 0.12 0_12
Wood 24.8 12.1 92 lo I 0000014 U.0028
Otherb 39.7 31.2 157 , 1 5 0.07 0. 31
Fumes
Cooking
67
4_6
31
G10 7
0.47
0_82
Engine exhaust 211.9 199 98 61 0.92 072
Wood 9.6 5_3 37 3 5 00.099 0.54
Othere 10.3 5.3 43 1.5 5 0.031 0.27
Chemlcals
Riocides
6 7
67
37
04
1.00
0.63
Uyes 2 1 1.A I I '_ 3 1.00 0 97
Formaldehyde 99 8.2 49 0 o 0.5] 025
Glues I I 0 6.7 47 i x 0.09 0.43
Other chemicakd 51 32 28 Io~ 0.036 0.05
Motor fuel and oil 29.4 199 117 4 0 0_0053 0}6
Parnts and vamishes 16.0 9.6 63 17 .1 0.023 0.46
Resins 11 8 4.6 21 -]C.2 38 0.1(1
Heat
Solar
18 1
11.0
75
39.N
0.037
0 75
Industrial 170 6.7 62 174 0.00050 0.027
a Adjusted for diet usrng xn=0 n6 x Ifi r t. -IS) t 0_23 x (f4-ts) _ 086 x fa . 0.29 x 17, where fl
- -1 Ci I a~ording to whether subjecl .....sumed sahed
fish less than monthly, monlhly bur Irss ihen weekly. or at least weekly 5 years pnoi to dragnoyis
ol Jir arc_ f_u defined similarly to fl, bui fnr pork and/ur
beef livee IS = 0, 1 or 2 acmrdfing to whrYner Chinese Oowering cabbage was cnnvumed Icss Ihan
.veckip bn!h 5 ycars prior to diagnosis and au age 10, ar
least weekly at one of thosc umes. anI ai Irasr weekly a1 botb of rhose timer, ly = fa i + 1yi. whue
f~ i n ecflucd as II for salted eggs 5 years prior to diagnosis
nd f6z is de[ined similarly ar age 10, fs is dehned as fa, but for Iresh shrimp; fa = I or 0
according io wheibr o: oranges and/or tangerlnes were ronsumed
at least monthly at either nme: and f- - 1. 5 depending on frequency and amoum of beer coruumpris
ears prior ro diagnosis of rhe c s dascobed
m Armstrnng rral.l Adjusted [or ciga~vuo s n0ke usmg z,- = I if subjca ever smnked for ai Iean 6
munih oi s.as exposed lu parunal smaking rn ~he homc
during childhood, and 0 other.vise
I' Includes cemenL nce. Rour. fenilrznr .and gyhum dusts.
` Includes smokes from oiL tarsm grass a:rd otLcr non-metalGc soumes, excludes smokes [rom wun,f
bunmir ~nd cooking. engine exlsaust, and cigarene srnokee
d tntludes a variety of acids, bases. solvcnis, detergcnes and soaps_
Table 2 Unadjusted and diet-adjustcd simdtaneously estimated odds rarlos (Ott) for smuking au. i
p,vemal smoking among snrokcrs and
non-smokers, with P-values and 95% O
Exposed pairs ..
Cigarette smoking history >6 months
Parental smoking for smokersa
Parental smoking for non-smokersa __
Unadjusted for dietary Index Adjusted for dietary index
OR P 95% CI OR P 95% CI
2.86 0.002 1.92-5J6 1.82 0 16 0.78-1 .23
0.88 0.70 0A7-1.65 0.74 043 0.34-1.59
2.27 0 002 1.32--3.88 2 28 0.008 L21-1 28
a Ovcrall P-values [or rhe hill mdels mnlaming smoking, parental smoking and Iheir mmranlou n~e un I
and a 040In Ihe unadjusrcd ar:d ad)uaed mudnlk
respeaively, with corresponding P valur. for mierzaion leftea rnndificaUOn of anukmg and poonial si~
o. ngl of 0.018 and 0025.
absolute dose. It does nol rcmain significant altcr [9onferrnni by wood drrsl, dieta-s' . and
cigarette smoke exposures. Only
correction for multiple comparisons industrial heat relamed a statisticaliy significant adjusted
Dose-response effects of indusfrial heat and other chemicals, dose-response effecl /OR - 1.23, P =
0.021). Simultaneous
metal, tin and textile dusts, and wnod smoke were further adjustment of all dusr n~sponse effects
lor dietary and cigarette
adjusted to account for posslble snnultaneous confoundiog smoke risks, and .urrenl sncial class
pruduced little change
250LJ.872'T4

A dietary and cigaret[c risk-adjusted OR and asymptutic 95% CI
were obtained from [he conditional logistic rcgreSsiun model
with linear predictor (iozD +(fca, +OSS, where s = l or 0
depending on whether the subject was ever or never exposed.
To examine possible doseresponse rclanonships, (Iccupational
exposure was represented by x= logt,t(f +/(. where t= estimaled
hours exposed, since f is a surrogate for cumulative dose of an
hypothetically toxic agent. and the logistic tolerance distribu-
tion is typically more successful in descrihing quantal responses
to log rather than absolute doses of toxic agcnts.24 Logistic
regression models were then fit using x, with and without the
dietary index zp and cigarette smokee index _r as covariates.
Non-linearity was examined by sequential addition of quadratic
and, as necessary, cubic terms in x to the modcl. Likelihood ratio
tests were used for these and other logistic model curnparisons.
Upon choice of a doseresponse curve of order k= I, 2 or 3 as
described. effect modification by diet and cigarette smoke were
examined by separate sequential addition of imeraction terms
z,cI and zc-s~, i= 1....k. until the first non-significant interaction
term of each type was reached. In these models, a one unit
increase in the exposure measure x= fogfp(t+ 1) represents, to a
very close approximation. a tenfold increase in the estimated h
exposed. and estimated OR from logistic regressions are presented
corresponding to this exposure ratio.
Because an association uf wood dust with NPC has previously
been reported and is supported by our data. othcr uccupational
exposures with OR > 1.5 after adjustment for diet and cigarette
smoke were also simultaneously adjusted for diet, ngarette smoke,
and wood dust. This was done by adding zty, the log-transformed
hours of exposure to wood dust to the models derived above.
We also checked for confounding of each occupational exposure
by social class by adding three dummy variables for social class
to the diet and cigarette adjustment models.
To account for a possible long NPC latency, cumulative ex-
posures were restricted to each of five time frames: > 1, 5, 10,
15 and 20 years prior to NPC diagnosis- We also classified par-
ticipan[s by exposures above each of three thresholds: 10+ years
of exposure, 5+ years of high level exposure, and.20+ years of
low level exposure, at any time in working lifc The impacts of
latency and exposure thresholds were examined by calculating
unadjusted OR for NPC using each of the eight risk dichotomies
implied by the five latency periods and three thresholds defined
above, and screening for trends with time frame or exposure
threshold.
Results
All 282 NPC cases were squamous cell carcinomas. Cases
included 195 males aged 19-72 years (mean 45 6 versus 45.1
for controls), and 87 females aged 24-74 (mean 44.6 versus 44_2
for controls). Case and control groups had similar distlibutions of
binhplace and marital status, but differed in social class, Chinese
subethnicity, and education. Twenty per cent of cases and 8%
of controls belonged to the 'poor' social class /P < 0.00005(,
reflecting among other factors fewer years of education among
cases ( P= (A 1 1). The NPC OR for poor versus al l others was 4.1
(P < 0,01). Childhood social class was not significantly related
to NPC after adjustment for current social class. Hokkien Chinese
were underrepresented among cases (23%) as compared to con-
trols (32%). with Khek and smaller subethnicilies tnoderately
PCCUPATIONAI- 12XPOSUR[5 ANL) NPC IN MALAYSIA 993
overrepresen[ed (P = 0 U5), bttt the assnciation of sube[Irnicity
with NPC vanished after adjustment for diet.t
Table I compares cases with controls for each occupational
exposttre. including resolts of crude and diet-adjusled sign tests
for statistically significant association. Although 282 case-control
pairs were studicd, Ihe numbcr of informative pairs relativc
to each individual expusurc (pairs with at least one exposed
subject), varicd widely from a low of I I (dyes) to a high of 157
(other fumes), with ntedian of 45 pairs. The power to delccl
existing associations with NPC thus varied substantially among
the exposun-s. Exposures to construcrlon, metal and wood dusa,
solar heal from outdoor occupations, industrial heat (from
furnaces, rolling nrills, welding machines, etc.), motor fucl
and oil, paints and varnishes, other chemicals (primarily acids.
bases, solvents, de[ergents, and soaps), and other smoke (from
oil, tars, grass and other non-metallic sources), show statistically
significant (a = 517,) excesses among cases. The median hourly
case-control differences in exposure were betwcen 1000 and
8000, with the exccpGon of mo[or fuel and oil where the differ-
ence was 460 hours. Ifowever, only wood dust, other chemicals,
and industrial Iteat rernain statistically significant (ce = 5%) after
adjustment for risk from diet and cigarette smoke.
History of active cigarette smoking (>6 monrhs) was asso-
ciated with NPC (OR = 1.66. P = 0.012). After adjustment for
such history. exposure to passive parental smoking during child-
hood was associated with NPC as well (OR = 1.54, P= 0-0401-
fn this multiple logistic regression model, non-smokers exposed
to parental smoking in childhood exhibited similar excess risk of
NPC as did active smokers, whether the latter were passively
exposed in childhood or not- Table 2 shows these results with
and without adjustment for die[. Passive exposure to smoke
from spouse or other household member shosved no association
with NPC after adjustment for active smoking. Models including
estimated pack-ycars of active smoking and years of exposure to
parental smoking (not reported) added no significant predictive
power to the models in Table 2.
Table 3 shows crude and diet/smoking-adjusted OR for any
versus no history of each occupational exposure. Wood dust
(OR = 2.36), other chemicals (OR = 2.36), and industrial heat.
(OR = 2.21) have the highest apparent diet-adjusted OR,
followed by mctal, textile, and tin dusts. and wood smoke, with
essentially equal OR between 1-65 and 1.77. Only wood dust and
industrial heat achieve statistical significance after adjustment_
Table 4 represents dose-response relationships in terms of
OR associated with a tenfold ratio of hours exposed. Wood dust,
industrial heat, and other chemicals again have the highest
crude and diet/smoking-adjusted OR. Adjusted OR for metal,
tin, and textile dusts, and for other smoke. form a lower tier.
Based on adjusted dose-response relationship, only wood dust
(observed median case-control difference of 4610 h) and in-
dustrial heat (observed median difference of 3740 h) retain stat-
istically significant positive associations with NPC. Exposure to
resins was moderately negatively associated with NPC (OR =
074(, with a marginally statistically significant P-value- Neither
effect modification by diet or cigarette smoke nor non-linear
dose-response relationships were found for these variables- A
quadratic effect nf exposure to wood smoke was found in ex-
ploratory analysis. This is likely anifaaual, as it occurs without
a statistically significant linear trend and suggests a biologically
implausible decline in impact ot progressively larger increases in

992 INTERNATIONAL JOLiRNAL OF EPIDGMLOLO(.1'
Methods
Cases were ascenained through records of NPC diagnosis and/or
treatuunt at four centres with radiotherapy in the study area
of Selangor and the Federal Territory General Hospital, 'Nng
Shin Hospital, Pantai Medical Ccnue( and Compuler Radionicti
Centre, Kuala Luntpur.
6etween l July 1990 and 30 June 1992 wc identified 530
Chinese cases with histologically confirnrcd NPC who had
resided in the study area for at Ieast 5 years, and been diagnosed
between I January 1987 and 30 June 1992-Of these. 121 (23 %)
had died, 63 (12%) could not be located. 4(t%I were too ill
for interview, and 60 (11 %) declined partiripation, leaving 282
cases (53%) for study. Of the 530 eligible cases, 282 were
prevalent (diagnosed before 1990) and 245 were incident cases
(1990 to mid-1992). The 282 NPC cases for study comprised
119 (42%) prevalent and 163 (58 %) incident cases. The modest
pantdpation rate was largely due to the attempt to obtain a
population-based sample, mdudtng non-hnspitalized cases
and prevalent cases with onset as much as 3.5 years prior to
initiation of data collection. Specifically, of the 125 cases who
could not be interviewed because they were too ill or had died.
104 (83 %) were prevalent cases when ascertained. So were
41 (65 %) of those who could not be located, some of whom
may also have died.
Each case was matched by iex and age (within 3 years) to one
control partieipant in good health with no history of cancer of
the head, neck, or respiratory system, selected front the general
Chinese population of the study area using a standard procedurc
of multistage area sampling- For each case, an interviewer began
at a randomly chosen house in a randomly selected postal code
district of a Chinese neighbourhood, and proceeded house-to-
house by a standard algorithm15 until a qualified control, also
resident in the study area for at least 5 years, was found. The
overall refusal rate among eligible controls was 10%, but in
affluent neighbourhoods it was 20%. Data were collected from
each participant during two 40-50-ntinute in-home, structured
interviews by specially trained full-time Chinese interviewers
fluent in all local dialects. The interviews requested complete
residential and occupational history, information on use of
alcohol and tobacco, and frequencies of consumption of 55 food
items at age 10 and at 5 years prior to diagnosis of [YPC for
the case (for matched controls, same calendar year as the index
case). For each job in the occupational history, the interview
covered job description, work performed, calendar time,
machines, tools and substanccs use4 size and type of work-
place, exposure to dusts, smoke, gases and chemicals. Exposures
to 20 inhalants and heat from two sources were recorded by
trade or profession with calendar years. frequency (days per
week), and duration (hours per day) of exposure. Questions foi-
Iowed the format of Germ er a! 16 and Gerin and Siemiatycki. 17
Inhalant selection was limited to those dusts, smoke, and gascs
associated with deposition or absorption in the nasopharynx,
with special attention to fotmaldehyde-
Exposure to inhalants was suhsequently coded by one of us
(RWA) who is familiar with Malaysian industries and hygiene.
Coding was conducted blind to case-control status. Codes
were adapted from Hoar er al.,t 8 Gerin cr af.16 and Gedn er al 19
Jobs were classified using official Malaysian occupational codes-zo
Lcvcl of exposure to inhalants (cvcr/never: low, mediurn. high)
was a.scssed .+ath referutce to kind of jub, work perfuretede mode of coniact (respiratory and/ur
cutaneous), respondcnt'~
reporting of exposure to paniadar inhalants, years of exposure.
frequency, aud duralion.
Parlicipants were asked about history of active smoking and
expusurc w cigareuc smoke from spause and other family ment-
bcrs, and from parents while growing up. They were also asked
about cducational ievcl, occupation, job status (employed, retircd,
etc.), spouse's and parental occupation, and house type as a
basis fur establishing social class.
Data analysis
Consistenl with nwv other sludies, we focus on duration nf
exposure. Estimated hours of each work-site exposure was
calculaied by subject Cry suntming 52 x (calendar years in job) r.
(workdays pet week) x (hours per day) over jobs where tht
exposure .vas prrsent.
Stausncal sigmficance of each exposure's crude association
with NPC was examined by sign test of estimated hours ex-
posed, cxduding tied pairs. The sign test was used because of ils
robustness and good performance with heavy-tailed distribu-
tions.21,'2 Cigarette smoking was studied by multiple logistic
regression- Cigarette smoking history was defined as present if
the subject reported ever having smoked for a period of 6 months
or more, and abscnl otherwise. For subjects with smoking
historirs, .umulative pack-vears were estimated as reported
years of srnoking multipFied by scores of 025, 0.75, 1.25, and
2.00 for sutokers, respectively, averaging <10, 11-20, 21-30 and
>30 dgarettes dail}. Sve examined models using dichotomous
variables for cigarette smoking history >6 months, exposure to
parental cigarette smoking in chlidhood, and exposure to cigar-
ette smoking by spouse or other household ntember. We con-
sidered estimated accumulated pack-years of smoking, years of
living with smoking parents, and years of living with smoking
spouse or other household member as crude indices of dose,
and these were also evaluated as quaruitative predicYors. Social
class categurnes (poorr lower middle, upper middle, high) based
on t,iberatos et aL23 were constructed for each partieipant I'or
time of tnterview. and childhood (age 10). Social class coding
was blind In case-control status.
To account for possible confounding, a dietary and cigarette
risk-adjustcd sign test (Appendix) was obtained from a con-
ditional logistic regtession model with linear predictor (fi~Zp+
J3,zc+ (3ss), whcre z/, is a dietary risk index derived previously
from these data3 which summarizes past consumption of salted
fish, salted egg, purk or beef liver, shrimp, Chinese flowering
cabbage, oranges or tangerines, and beer; zC is a cigarette smoke
risk index, where :, = I if the case or control had smoked
cigarettes for >6 rnunths andlor had been exposed to parental
smoking, a:id zr = 0 if ncither: and s= L or 0 is an indicator
variable tdeutifyumg the member of each matehed pair with
highest eslimatcd hours of past exposure. The likelihood ratio
test of No: J3s = 0 Lrom thc model-based conditional likelihood
gives the adj:utcd tesl-
To mdirate the svength of observed statistical relationships,
the medtan case-<'ontrol difference in hourly exposures was
calculated after excloding unexposed pairs. The maximum
(condiiionall likelihood point estimate of the odds ratio (Oli)
for any expusurr versus none, with exact 95% CI, was obtainrd
fronr tho subsci of I,airc wlth cxanly one exposed subject
2505587242

Combined with random exposure nteasurement and occasional
misclassification errors, this otay have produced low power to
detect statistically significant dose-response relationships- Also,
in view of limited power, we did not adjust our significance
testing for multiple comparisons; thus, occasional Type I errors
would not be surprising. (However, the resuh for wood dus( in
Table 4 persists even after Bonferroni adjustntent.) On the other
hand, although standardized interviews were carried out by
trained professional interviewers using stmaured questionnaires,
recall and exposure-suspicion biases may have contributed to
the predominance of posirive over negative associations in our
results. In addition, it should be noted that h is relatively easy
to assess wood dust exposure in populalion-based casecontrol
studies whtle it is much more diffintlt to asscss formaldehyde
exposure, and this may be a factor in our negative findings for
the latter. Finally, 24% of the cases we ascertained had died or
were too ill for interview at time of contact, most of these being
prevalent cases, contributing to a 47% non-participation
rate among diagnosed cases. Therefore, we cannot exclude the
possibility of prevalence-incidence (Neyman) or other selection
biases, though we are unaware of any specific presumptive
rationale or evidence for their presence.
In summary, our data support previous findings that some
occupational inhalants are risk factors for NPC. Tlte statistical
effect of wood dust remained substantial after adjustment for
diet, cigarette smoke, and social class. Intense industrial heat
emerged as a previously unreported risk facaor. statistically significant even after adjustment for
diet and cigarette smoke. No
association was found between NPC and formaldehyde. Base-
line sampling of ambient air conditions in Malaysian worksites
confirms the presence of potentially high-risk particle pollution.
Acknowledgements
We thank, in Kuala Lumpur, Mr KIi Chiew, Mrs PF Chow,
Miss CM Lim, Mr HC Loke, Mr KC Ong, and Mr KS Wu for
interviewing; Miss KE Chua and Mrs PL Ng for secretarial
support; the Director, Institute for Medical Research for admin-
istrative support; Drs A Lim, Chief, Institute for Radiotherapy
and Nuclear Medicine. General Hospital, MR Tan. Cancer
Treatment Centre, Tung Shin Hospital. S Narasimha, Computer
Radionics Centre, and S Ganesan, Pantai Medical Centre for
case referral; and in Champaign, Miss L Davis, Mr D Grammenos,
and Miss R Moorman for assistance In data preparation. This
work was supported by the US Nationa] Cancer Institute; Grant
number: R01-CA46567.
References
I Ho lHC- Nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPCI. Adr Cancer Res 1972;
15:54-]-82.
2 Armstrong RW. Armstrong MJ, Yu MC, lienderson BE. Salted fish and
inhalants as risk factors for nasopharyngeal rarnnuma in Malaysian
Chinese. Cancer Res 1983;43:2962-T0.
tArmstrong RW, Imrey PB, Lye MS, Armstrong MJ. Yu MC, Sani S.
Nasopharyngeal carcinoma in Malaysian Chinesre salted fish and
other dietary exposures. fnt J Cancer 1998;Y7:22A-15.
4 Yu MC, Ho IHC, Li S-H, Henderson BE Cantonese-srvle salted fish as
a cause of nasopharyngeal carcinoma- report of a case-control study
in Hong Kong. Cancer Res 1986.46:956-61
OCCUI'ATIONAL E%POSURL'S AND NPC IN MALA1'SIA 997
5 Yu MC. Mo C-C. Chong W-X. Ych F-S. Hendersun BE Preserved foods
and nasupharyngeal carcimm. a: a case-convol study in Guangxi,
China. Canro Res 1988;48:1954-59.
6 Yu MC. Huang TB, Henderson BE. Diet and nasopharyngeal caninoma:
a case-control study in Guangzhou. China. Inr J Canar 19A9;43:
I0]2-82
7Ning lP, Yu MC, WangQS. Henderson BE. Consumption of sahed fish
and other risk factors for nasnpharyngeal carcinoma in Tianjin, a lowrisk reglon fur NPC in the
People's Republic of China l NarlCancofnst
1990;82:291-96.
BNam JM, Mclzughlin JK, Blot WJ. Cigarette smoking, alcohol. arrd
nasopharyngeal carcinoma: a case-comrol study among US Whites
J Nml C'aucer lusE 1992;84:619-22
9Henderson BE. Louie E, ling lS, Buell P Gardner MB Risk factors
associated with nasopharyngeal carcinoma. N Deg! J Med 1976,
295:I101-06.
I0Chen C-J. Wang YP Shieh T. Chen l-1', Lio M-Y. Multifacturial
etiology of nasopharyngeal carcinoma. EpsteinBarr virus, familial
lendency and enviromnental cofaanrs. InWulf GT. CareY TE /edsl
Head and Neck Onmlogy Research. Amsterdam: Kugler 1988, pp.
469-'/6
11 Yu MC, Garabranr DH, Huaug TB, Henderson BE. Occupational and
other non-dietary risk factors for nasopharyngeal carcinoma in
Guangzhou, China. Inr J Cancer 1990:45:1033-39.
12 West S. Hildesheim A, Dosemeci M. Nonviral risk facmrs for naso-
pharyngeal carcinoma in the Philippines: results from a case-control
smdv. fnr J Cmrcrr 1993:55:]22-27.
11Yn MC, Henderson BE. Nasopharyngeal cancer In: Schottenfeld D,
Fraurneol JF (eds) . Cancer Epidemiology and Prevention. 2nd Edn. New
York: Oxford Universiry Press, 1996, pp.603-18.
taArmstrong RW, Kannan Kutty M, Armstrong MJ. Self-specific
environments associated with nasopharyngeal carcinoma in Selangor,
Malaysia. .Soc Sri Med 19J8;12D:149-56.
Is Kelsey JL, Douglas Thompson W, Evans AS. Methods in Observarional
Epidemiology New Yurk Oxford University Press. 1986. pp.264-,s5.
t6Gerin M. Siemiatycki J. Kemper H, Begin D. Obtaining occupauonal
exposure histur(rs in epidemiologic case-control srudies. l OcruP Med
1985;27:420-26.
t7 Germ M, Siemiatycki 1 The occupational questionnaire in rerro-
spective epidemiologi< studies: recent approaches in community-
based studies. APplOrcup Environ Hyg 1991;6:495--501.
taHoar SK. Morrison AS, Cole P Silverman UT. An occupation and
exposure linkage system for the study of occupational caranugenesis.
J Ouup Med 1980:22:7 22-26.
19Gerin M. Siemiatycki l, Nadon L Dewar R, Krewski D. Cancer risk
due to occupational exposure to formaldehyde: results from a multi-
site case-conrrol srudy in Monveall lnt l Cancer 1989.44:53-58.
20Malaysia Kementerian Buruh dan Tenaga Rakyat. TerjemahnnTajuk-
Tajuk Pnrke jaan Dagi Kamus Pengke/usun Peke jaan (Occupational Titles
for the Dictionary of Occupational Classification). Kuala Lumpur,
1988.
~t Pratt JW, Gibbons JD. Concepts of Nonparamerric Theory. New York:
Springer-Verlag, 1981. P.384.
12Randles RH. Wolle DA. Inrroduaicn to tlte Theory oJ Nonparametrir
Smtisua. New Ynrk: Wilry, 1979, p.116.
23 Ltberatos P. Link BO, Kclsey JL. The measurement of social class in
epidemiology. Epidemio! Rev 1988;10:8T-1 21
24Gaylor DW. Dose-respome models in risk analysis In: Armitage P
Calton T(eds). Eoryclopedia of Riostatisucs. l o7. 2. Chichester'. Wilcy.
1998,pp.1219-23.
25 Menzel OB. Amdur MO. Toxic responses of the respiratory sysrem. In.
Klaassen CD. Amdur MO, Duull J(edsl. Casarerr and Do.dl s Taximlogy.
9rd Edn. New York. Macmillan, 1986, Pp33t}58
