Philip Morris
Arterial Endothelial Dysfunction Related to Passive Smoking Is Potentially Reversible in Healthy Young Adults
Fields
- Author
- Adams, M.R.
- Celermajer, D.S.
- Griffiths, K.A.
- Mccredie, R.J.
- Raitakari, O.T.
- Celermajer, D.S.
- Area
- BADSTUBER,ANDRE/OFFICE
- Type
- PSCI, PUBLICATION SCIENTIFIC
- ABST, ABSTRACT
- BIBL, BIBLIOGRAPHY
- ABST, ABSTRACT
- Master ID
- 2505585973/6055
Related Documents:- 2505585973-5974 Untitled Document 2505585973/5974
- 2505585975-5980 "Smoking Cessation and Mortality Trends Among 118,000 Californians, 600000 - 970000" J E Enstrom and C W Heath Jr Epidemiology (990000), 10, 500-512
- 2505585981-5993 Smoking Cessation and Mortality Trends Among 118,000 Californians, 600000 - 970000
- 2505585994-5996 Variance and Dissent Dissent Rebuttal to the Paper by Enstrom
- 2505585997-5999 Response to Kuller's Dissent
- 2505586000-6001 Rejoinder to Enstrom's Response
- 2505586002-6004 Review 1069 "The Influence of Smoking on the Risk of Alzheimer's Disease" C Merchant Et Al Neurology (990000), 52, 1408 - 1412
- 2505586005-6009 The Influence of Smoking on the Risk of Alzheimer's Disease
- 2505586010-6012 Review 1070 "Arterial Endothelial Dysfunction Related to Passive Smoking Is Potentially Reversible in Healthy Young Adults" O T Raitakari Et Al Annals of Internal Medicine ( 990000), 130, 578 - 581
- 2505586017-6020 Review 1071 "Childhood Passive Smoking, Race, and Coronary Artery Disease Risk. The Mcv Twin Study" W B Moskowitz Et Al Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med (990000), 153, 446 - 453
- 2505586021-6028 Childhood Passive Smoking, Race, and Coronary Artery Disease Risk the Mcv Twin Study
- 2505586029-6031 Review 1072 "The Effects of Environmental Tobacco Smoke Exposure on Lung Function in A Longitudinal Study of British Adults" I M Carey Et Al Epidemiology (990000), 10, 319 - 326
- 2505586032-6039 The Effects of Environmental Tobacco Smoke Exposure on Lung Function in A Longitudinal Study of British Adults
- 2505586040-6042 "Maternal Cigarette Smoking and Invasive Meningococcal Disease: A Cohort Study Among Young Children in Metropolitan Atlanta, 890000 - 960000"
- 2505586043-6048 Maternal Cigarette Smoking and Invasive Meningococcal Disease: A Cohort Study Among Young Children in Metropolitan Atlanta, 890000 - 960000
- 2505586049-6050 "Parental Smoking and Infection with Helicobacter Pylori Among Preschool Children in Southern Germany"
- 2505586051-6055 Parental Smoking and Infection with Helicobacter Pylori Among Preschool Children in Southern Germany
- Document File
- 2505585888/2505586502/D. Lee 1053 -
- Characteristic
- MARG, MARGINALIA
- Litigation
- Feda/Produced
- Named Organization
- American Society of Internal Medicine
- Author (Organization)
- American College of Physicians
- Annals of Internal Medicine
- Hri, Health Research Inst,Roswell Park
- Royal Prince Alfred Hospital
- Univ of Sydney
- Univ of Turku
- Annals of Internal Medicine
- Site
- E16
- Date Loaded
- 11 Sep 2002
- UCSF Legacy ID
- ocf19c00
Document Images
BRIEF cOMMUNICAT1O1V5
J
Arterial Endothelial Dysfanction
Related to Passive Smoking Is
Potentially Reversible in. Healthy
Young Adults
Olli T. Raitakari, MD, PhD; .
Mark R. -Adams, MB, BS, PhD, FRACP;
Robyn 1. McCredie, BSc; Kaye A. t'irifiiths, DMU;
and David S. Cefermajer, MB, BS, PhD, FRACP
Background: Passive smoking is associated with early ar-
terial damage, but the potential for reversibility of this
damage is unknown. . . .
Objective: To assess the reversibility of arterial endothe-
fial dysfunction, a key marker of early atherosclerosis.
Design: Cross-sectional study.
Setting: Academic medical center.
Participantsr-60 healthy persons 15 to 39 years of age: 20 with no exposure to active or passive
smoking, 20 non-
smoking passive smokers (exposure to environmental to-
bacco smoke for z1 hour per day for ?2 years), and 20
former passive smokers.
. .
Measurements: Arteriall endothelial function measured
by noninvasive ultrasonography. Results: Endothelium-dependent dilatation was signifi-
cant/y better In former passive smokers (5.1%±-4.1%
[range, -1.2% to 15.6°/a)) than in current passive-smokers
(Z.3%:t 2.1% [range, -0.2%to.6.7°k]) (P= 0.01), al-though both groups were significantly impaired
compared
with nonsmoking controls (8.9% t3.246 [range, 2.1% to
16:7%])(Ps0:01forbothcomparisons). .
Conclusions: In healthy young adults, arterial endothe-
lial dysfunction related to passive smoking..seems too be
partially reversible.
This paper is also available at httpJ/vrnw.acponliae.org.
.4nn Inton Med 1999;130578-581.
From Royal Prince Alfred Hospitai, The Heart Research insti-
mte, and University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia; aad University
of TVrku, Turku, Finland. For current author addresses, see end
of text.
vtdence from several clinical, laboratory, and
epidemiologic studies conducted over the past
decade has clearly shown that regular exposure to
environmental tobacco smoke is associated with
early arterial injury (1, 2) and increases the risk for
coronary disease in nonsmokers (3). The question
of reversibility of the deleterious cardiovascular ef-
fects of passive smoking may have important public
health implications both for individuals and for in-
stitutions determining policies for smoke-free envi-
ronments (4). . We therefore compared arterial en-
doth'elial responses in three matched groups of
healthy young adults (nonsmokers, passive smokers,
and former passive smokers).
Methods
Participants
We studied 60 young adults 15 to 39 years of age
(24 male participants and 36 female participants).
Every participant had a blood pressure of 160/90
mm Hg or less, no history of dyslipidemia or dia-
betes mellitus, and no family history of premature
vascular disease. None was taking any regular car-
diovascular or antioxidant medications. All partici-
pants gave informed consent, and the study was
approved by our institutional committee on ethical
practice.
The controls were 20 lifelong nonsmokers who
had never been regularly exposed to tobacco smoke
at home or in the workplace (self-reported). The
passive smoking group consisted of 20 lifelong non-
smokersw]th histories of exposureto envirotunental_
tobacco smoke at home, work, or both for at least 1
hour per day for 2 or more years. The former
passive smoking group consisted of 20 consecutively
studied nonsmokers who had been exposed to envi-
ronmental tobacco smoke for at least 1 hour,per
day for 2 or more years, and this exposure had
ceased at least 1 year before their study visit. The
duration and the average intensity of exposure to
environmental tobacco smoke were assessed by
questionnaire. The scale for the intensity score was
1= light (1 to 3 hours per day), 2 = moderate (4 to
6 hours per day), and 3 = heavy (>6 hours per day).
The former passive smoking group and the passive
smoking group were matched for the average inten-
sity and lifetime duration of smoke exposure.
578 6 April 1999 .4nuals of Intema! Medicine Volume 130 Number7
2505586013

Table. Baseline Characteristics and Arterial Reactivity Results`
Variable Contmis Former Passive Smokers Passive Smokers P Valuet
A9e,Y 22±4 2656 24±5 0.09
Males4emales, n/n 8/12 8/12 8/12
Environmental tobacco smoke intensity scores 0 2.420.7 2.2±0.8 >0.2§
Duration of exposure to environmental tobacco smoke, y 0 17;4 15}9 >01§
Blood pressure, mm Hg 85 m 7 89a9 85 7 7 >0.2
Total cholesterol level, mmol/L 469 z 0.75 4.37 031 1 4.92!0.76 0.09
Vessel size at rest, mm 337 w 0.53 3.63 x 0.43 - 3.46 i 0.59 >0.2
Blood flow at rest, mUmin 51 ~ 55 39 s 22 45 ~ 29 >0.2
Endothelium-dependent dilatation, % 8_9 ~ 3.2 5.1 -4.1 2.322.1 <0.001
Nitroglycerin-mediated dilatation, % 19.8 - 4.9 17.7 3 5 6 16.4 '_ 5.9 0.15
Hyperemia, % 578 t 228 590 S 232 437 ± 139 0.06
Values with plue/minus signs are the mean z S0.
t P values are for comparison of the three groups by analysis ot variance, except as noted belav.
S Scale for intensity score: 1 = light, 2 = moderate, and 3= heavy.
4 P values for environmental oobaccv smoke exposure (intensity and duration) refer to the
comparisons between former and current passive smokers.
Study Design
Each participant had one study visit, during -
which a history was taken, supine resting blood
pressure was measured, salivary cotinine was col-
lected (for later analysis by rapid gas-liquid chro-
matography) (5), and reactivity of the right brachial
artery was analyzed. The ultrasonographic method
for measuring arterial reactivity and flows, described
elsewhere (1), relies on precise measurement of ar-
terial diameter at rest, during reactive hyperemia
(with increased flow producing endothelium-depen-
dent dilatation), and after sublingual administration
of nitroglycerin (leading to endothelium-indepen-
dent~ dilatation). In the passive smoking group, time
since last exposure to passive smoking was less than
24 hours in every case. Total cholesterol levels were
measured in 55 of 60 participants (consent for vene-
section was not obtained from the other 5 partici-
pants) at the same time as or within 12 months of
the arterial studies. A Hitachi 747 autoanalyzer was
used for all cholesterol measurements (Hitachi In-
struments, Inc., Tokyo, Japan).
Data Analysis
Vessel diameter was measured in every,case by
two independent observers, as described elsewhere
(1). Observers were blinded to the smoking status of
each participant and the stage of the experiment.
We have previously shown that this measurement
method is accurate and reproducible for detection
of small changes in arterial diameter (6), with low
interobseiver error for measurement of flow-medi-
ated endothelium-dependent dilatation (6, 7),
Statistical Analysis
Descriptive data are expressed as means t SDs.
An analysis of variance for the three groups was
performed, followed by the Scheffe method to allow
pairwise significance testing. The duration and in-
tensity of passive smoking were compared by using
the Mann-Whitney U test. The determinants of endo-
thelial function were assessed by multiple linear re-
gression analysis, with age, sex, mean blood pres-
sure, total cholesterol levels, vessel size, and the
passive smoking group as the independent variables.
Statistical significance was inferred at a two-tailed P
value of 0.05 or less.
Results
The characteristics of the study groups are shown
in the Table. The salivary cotinine level was less
than 250 nmol/L in every participant, indicating no
recent active smoking (8). In the former passive
smoking group, exposure tq passive smoking had
ceased 6:t 5 years before the study visit.
Endothelium-dependent dilatation was signifi-
cantly better in the former passive smokers than in
the passive smokers (P = 0.01), although both
groups were impaired compared with nonsmoking
controls (P ~ 0.01 for both comparisons) (Table,
Figure). The results remained essentially the samee
e
20,
~
15
0
5
0
w e
I
I
P <0.01
P<0.001
I
P=0.01
I
_
Nonsmokers Former Passive Smokers Passive Smokers
Figure. Flow-mediated, endotheltum-dependent dilatation in 20
nonsmokers, 20 former passive smokers, and 20 passlve smokers.
For each study group, the box represents the interquartile range (between
the 25th and 75th percentiles), with the median value shovm as a horizontal
bar within each box. The bars outside each box show the range of 95% of
values.
6 Apri1 1999 - Annals of Internal Medicine Volume 130 - Number 7 579

\,w
when the sexes were analyzed separately. On mul- tivariate analysis, endothelium-dependent
dilatation
was related to current passive smoking (P < 0.001)
and was inversely related to total cholesterol level
(P :s 0.05). Nitroglycerin-induced vasodilatation was
similar in all three groups.,,In the former passive
smoking group, endothelial function was most se-
verely impaired in participants whose last exposure
to environmental tobacco smoke was 2 years beforee
the study visit or less (1.2% - 1.7%) compared with
those whose exposure ended 2 or more years before
the study visit (5.8% ±4.0%) (P s 0.05).
Discussion
In the current study, we have shown that endo-
thelial function, a marker of arterial health, is sig-
nificantly better in young adults who have.with-
drawn from regular exposure to environmental
tobacco smoke than in continuing passive smokers;
despite a similar lifetime duration and intensity of
smoke exposure. The maximum improvement in
vascular function was only observed more than 2
years after cessation of passive smoking. Neither
tobacco smoke-exposed group, however, had nor-
mal endothelial function (as measured in a control
group of persons who neither actively nor passively
smoked), suggesting only partial-reversibility of pas-
sive smoke-related arterial injury.
The arterial endotheHum plays an important role
in cardiovascular homeostasis, and the role of endo-
thelium-derived nitric oxide seems pivotal in promot-
ing vasodilatation and inhibiting platelet aggregation,
monocyte adhesion, and smooth-muscle prolifera-
tion (9). For these reasons, the observed recovery of
the arteries' ability to produce nitric oxide after
cessation of passive smoking (as assessed by our
noninvasive method) (10) might have important
pathophysiologic implications in terms of disease
reversibility.
Because our study examined the effects of passive
smoking.cessation on arterial reactivity in a cross-
sectional setting, the r0sults should be interpreted
with caution. A more ideal approach would be serial
prospective study of persons before and after they
have withdrawn from environmental tobacco smoke
exposure. Such a longitudinal study, however, would
be logistically difficult because cessation of passive
smoking at home or in the workplace often cannot
be controlled voluntarily by the exposed person (for
example, teenagers who continue to live at home
with actively smoking parents). In the current study,
the participants were carefully matched for the ab-
sence of other potentially confounding vascular risk
factors, for sex, and for the duration and intensity of
exposure to passive smoking. Self-reporting of expo-
sure to environmental tobacco smoke by question-
naire was used because no methods are available to
objectively quantify previous exposuree to tobacco
smoke.
Environmental tobacco smoke has numerous ad-
verse effects on vascular biology; this may explain its
relation to the increased risk for atherosclerotic
events. Sidestream cigarette smoke (from the burn-
ing ends of cigarettes) contains more than 4000
chemicals, many toxic or carcinogenic (11). Passive
smoking reduces oxygen affinity for hemoglobin and
decreases mitochondrial respiration; these effects in-
crease the likelihood of ischemic episodes in per-sons with existing coronary artery disease (12).
En-
vironmental tobacco smoke in doses that are routinely
encountered by persons in smoke-filled environments
increases the percentage of the aorta covered by
atheroma in cholesterol-fed rabbits (13), is.associ-
ated with an increase in the size of aortic atheroma
plaques in cockerels (14), and . may also increase
platelet aggregation and thereby'predispose to acute
thrombus formation (15). Passive smoke-related ar-
terial damage may also be the consequence of en-
hanced degradation of nitric oxide secondary to the
formation of oxygen-derived free radicals (16).
The potential for reversibility of these early pas-
sive smoke-related changes is unknown. We previ-
ously documented that active smoking-related endo-
thelial dysfunction may be reversible with smoking
cessation, but in this earlier study (17), no correla-
tion was seen between time since cessation and
endothelium-dependent dilatation. In the current
study, most improvement in the former passive
smokers was evident after 2 years of cessation of
passive smoking. Epidemiologic studies of disease
reversibility have also suggested that the risk for
cardiovascular events is significantly lower in active .
smokers who give up smoking (18) than in continu-
ing smokers. This reduction in risk may be mediated
by reversible effects of smoking on thrombogenesis
with or without concomitant changes in. vascular
..
structure or function. Whether similar clinical ben-
efit from passive smoke withdrawal will be obtained
requires further prospective study. .
Passive smoking has been consistently linked to
an increased risk for coronary heart disease and
may be responsible for more than 30 cardiovascular
deaths annually in the United States alone_ (19). In
healthy young adults, we have now demonstrated
that cessation of exposure to environmental tobacco
smoke for more than 2 years is associated with
improved arterial function. These data support in-
dividual and public health policy initiatives to allow
nonsmokers to avoid smoke-filled environments at
home or in the workplace.
580 6 April 1999 - Annals of Internal Medicene - Volume 130 - Number 7
2505586015

Gmnr Supporr: By thc Academy of Finland and Turku Univcrsity
Central Hospital, Finland (Dr. Raitakari); the Medical Founda-
iion of Sydney University, Australia (Ms. McCredie and Dr.
Cclermajer); and the National Heart Foundation of Australia
(Ms. Griffiths)-
Requetf for Reprin[s.' David S. Celermajer, MB, BS, PhD,
FRACP, Department of Cardiology, Royal Prince Alfred Hospi-
tal, Missenden Road, Camperdown NSW 2050, Sydney, Australia.
Cruren( Author Address: Drs. Raitakari, Adams, and Celermajer,
Ms. Griffiths, and Ms. McCredie: Department of Cardiology,
Royal Prince Alfred Hospital, Missenden Road, Camperdown
NSW 2050, Sydney, Australia.
References
1. Celermajer 05. Adams MR. Clarkson P, Rabinson J, McCredie R,
Donald A, et a]. Passlve smoking and impaired endotheliumdependent
arterial dilatation in healthy young adults. N Engl / Med. 1996;334:150-4.
2. 5tefanadis C, Vlachopoulas C. Tsiamis E, Diamantapoulos L, Toutou-
zas R, Giatrakos N, at al. Unfavorable eHects of passive smoking on aortic
function in men. Ann Intern Med. 1998;128:426-34.
3. Glaniz SA, Parrnley W W. Passive smoking and heart disease. Mechanisms
and dsk. JAMA. 1995;273:1047-53.
4. Brownson RC. Eriksen MP, Davis RM, Wanrer KE Environmental tobacco
smoke: health effects and polides to reduce eaposure. Annu Re+ Public
Health. 1997:18:163-85.
5. Peyerabend C, Russel MA. A rapid gas-liquid dlrtxnatographic method for
the determination of cotinine and nrcotine in biological fluids. I Pham, Phar-
maco1.1990;42:450-2. 6. Sorensen KE, Celennajer DS, Splegelhaher DJ, Georgakopoulos D,
Robinson l. Thomas Q, et al. Non-invasive measurement of endothelium-
dependent arterial responsesaccuracy and reproducibility. Br Heart 1. 1995;
74247-53 '
7. Celermajer D5, Sorensen KE. Gooch VM. Spiegelhalter D1, Miller OL
Sullivan ID, at al. Norvlnvaslve detenlon of endothellal dysfunction in chil-
dren and adults at risk of atherosckrosu. Lancec 1992;340:1111-5.
8. Pierce JP. Dwyer T, DiGiusta E. Carpenter T, Hannam C Amin A, ei al.
Cotinine validation of self-reported smoking in commercially run communiry
surveys. I Chronic Ois. 1987;40:689-95.
A Celermajer O5. Endothelial dysfunction: does it matter? Is it resyrgble? I Gio
Coll Cardiol. 1997;30:325-33.
10. loxnnides R, Haefeli WE, Linder L Richard V, Bakkati EH. Thuillez C et
at Nitric oxitle is responsible for Flax-dependent dilatation ot human periph-
eral conduit aatenes in vivo. CirculaGon. 1995;91:13i4-9.
11. Taylor AE, Johnson DC, Kazerni H. Envlromental tobacco smoke and
cardiovascular disease. A position paper from the Council of Cardloputmonary
and Cdtical Care, American Neart Attodation. Circulation, 1992;86:699-7g2.
12. Dwyer EM lr, Turino GM.'Carbon monodde and card'wvascnlar disease
(Editoriap- N Engl l Med_ 1989;321:1474-5.
13. Zhu BQ, Sun YP, Sievers RE, Isenberg WM, Gfantz SA, Parmley WW-
Passive smoking increases experimental athe.osderosis in cholesterol-fed rab-
bits. I Am Coll Cardiol. 1993;21:225-32.
14. Penn A, Snyder CA. Inhalation of sidestream cigarette smoke accelerates
development of zrteriosderotic plaques. Circulation. 1993;88(4 Pt 1):1820-5.
15. Steinberg D, Parthasarathy 5, Carew TE, Khoo IC, Wit¢tum IL Beyond
chohsteroi. Modifications of Iow-densiry lipoprotein that increase its athero-
genicity N Engl J Med. 1989;320:915-24.
16. Duthie GG, Arthur JR, James WP. Effects of smoking and vitamin E on
blood antioxidant status. Am J Clin Nutr, 1991:53(4 SuppIk10615-3S.
17, Celermajer O5, Sorensen KE, Georgakopoulos D, Bull C Thomas o,
Robinson l, et al. Ci9arette smoking is associated with tlose-related and
potentially re.essibk impairment of endothelium-dependent dilauon in healthy
young adults. Circulation. 1993;88:2149-55_
18. Rosenberg L Kaufmann DW, Helmrich SP, Shapiro S. The risk of myo-
-cardiat infarction after quittin9 smoking in men under 55 years of age. N Engl
I Med. 1985:313:15I t~.
19. Giant¢ SA. Parmley WW. Passive smoking and heart disease. Epidemiotogy,
physiology, and biochemistry. Circolation. 1991;83'1-12.
® 1999 American College of Physicians-American Sodety of Interna)
Medieine
6 April 1999 Annals of Internal Medicine Volume 130 Number 7 581
/
