Philip Morris
An Epidemiological Investigation of Risk Factors for Lung Cancer in Guangzhou, China
Fields
- Author
- Cha, Q.
- Chen, X.
- Chen, Y.
- Du, Y.
- Feng, Z.
- Huang, L.
- Wu, X.
- Type
- SCRT, REPORT, SCIENTIFIC
- ABST, ABSTRACT
- BIBL, BIBLIOGRAPHY
- CHAR, CHART, GRAPH, TABLE, MAPS
- Area
- CENTRAL FILES/STORED FILES
- Litigation
- Mile/Produced
- Characteristic
- EXTR, EXTRA
- Site
- R100
- Named Organization
- Guangzhou Environmental Monitoring Cente
- Guangzhou Health + Antiepidemic Station
- Intl Agency for Research on Cancer
- Intl Atmospheric Pollution Centers
- Natl Bureau of Public Health
- Who, World Health Org
- Author (Organization)
- Guangzhou Medical College
- Guangzhou Municipal Health + Anticeptic
- Named Person
- Ames
- Dai
- Du
- Gao
- Guan
- Haenszel
- He
- Heinonen, O.P.
- Hench
- Kapitulnik
- Li
- Liang
- Mantel
- Wang
- Wu
- Yu
- Master ID
- 2081782960/3432
- 2081782960-3432 International Symposium on Lifestyle Factors and Human Lung Cancer 941212 - 941216 Guangzhou, People's Republic of China
- 2081783003-3029 Aspects of the Epidemiology of Lung Cancer in Smokers and Nonsmokers in the United States
- 2081783031-3037 Risk Factors for Lung Cancer Among Nonsmokers With Emphasis on Lifestyle Factors
- 2081783039-3051 Attributable Risk of Lung Cancer in Nonsmoking Women
- 2081783053-3058 The Etiology of Lung Cancer in Nonsmoking Females in Harbin, China
- 2081783060-3066 Lung Cancer in Nonsmoking Chinese Women: a Case-Control Study
- 2081783068-3076 Lung Cancer, Smoking and Diet Among Swedish Men
- 2081783078-3083 A Study of Association of Female Squamous Cell Carcinoma and Adenocarcinoma in the Lung and History of Menstruation
- 2081783085-3086 Combined Analysis of Case-Control Studies of Smoking and Lung Cancer in China
- 2081783088-3089 A Case-Control Study of Childhood and Adolescent Household Passive Smoking (Ps) and the Risk of Female Lung Cancer
- 2081783091-3099 A Comparative Study of the Risk Factors for Lung Cancer in Guangdong, China
- 2081783101-3106 Analysis and Estimates of Attributable Risk Factors for Lung Cancer in Nanjing, China
- 2081783108-3122 Diet as a Confounder of the Association Between Air Pollution and Female Lung Cancer: Hong Kong Studies on Exposures to Environmental Tobacco Smoke, Incense, and Cooking Fumes as Examples
- 2081783124-3132 Indoor Burning Coal Air Pollution and Lung Cancer - a Case-Control Study in Fuzhou, China
- 2081783134-3139 The Effect of Beta-Carotene on Lung Cancer
- 2081783141-3143 A Matched Case-Control Study of the Relationship Between Beta-Carotene Intake and Lung Cancer
- 2081783145-3150 Modulation of Molecular Mechanisms by Dietary Restriction in Rats
- 2081783152-3156 Transformation of Tracheal Epithelial Cells and the Role of Transforming Growth Factor (Tgf) and P53 in the Lung Cancer Progression
- 2081783158-3166 Biossays of Benzo(A)Pyrene and Lung Cancer
- 2081783168-3174 The Study of Correlation Between Gst Gene Deletion and Susceptibility to Lung Cancer
- 2081783175-3185 A Retrospective Lung Cancer Mortality Study of People Exposed to Insoluble Arsenic Salts and Radon
- 2081783186 Lifestyle, Environmental Pollution and Lung Cancer in Cities of Liaoning in Northeastern China
- 2081783188-3207 Determination of Personal Exposure of Nonsmokers to Environmental Tobacco Smoke in the United States
- 2081783208-3234 Bayesian Meta-Analysis, With Application to Studies of Ets and Lung Cancer
- 2081783236-3243 The Relationship Between Smoking and Lung Cancer in Humans
- 2081783245-3263 Some Lifestyle Factors in Human Lung Cancer: a Case-Control Study of 792 Lung Cancer Cases
- 2081783265-3266 Health Impacts by Lifestyle and Behavioral Factors in Guangdong, China
- 2081783268-3276 Low Risk Epidemiology and Good Epidemiological Practice
- 2081783279-3285 Recent Developments in the Epidemiology of Lung Cancer
- 2081783287-3297 Recent Progress in the Epidemiology of Lung Cancer in Humans
- 2081783299-3309 Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke and the Incidence of Lung Cancer - a Review
- 2081783311-3316 Etiology of Lung Cancer in Women
- 2081783318-3331 Indoor and Outdoor Air Pollution and Lung Cancer
- 2081783333-3340 Study of the Relation Between Smoking as a Lifestyle Factor and Lung Cancer in Beijing Area of China
- 2081783342-3347 Analyses of Sex Differentials in Risk Factors for Primary Lung Adenocarcinoma
- 2081783349-3355 The Relationship Between Histologic Types of Lung Cancer and Cigarette Smoking
- 2081783357-3360 Progressive Changes in the Relative Distribution of Different Histological Types of Lung Cancer in Guangzhou
- 2081783362-3369 Induction of Dna-Protein Crosslink in Rat Lung and Blood by the Carcinogen Nickel
- 2081783371-3379 Molecular Epidemiology Study of Coal Smoke-Generated Environmental Carcinogens and Lung Cancer in Humans
- 2081783381 A Study of the Relationship Between P53 Mutation and Smoking in Human Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer
- 2081783384 Analysis of Lung Cancer Risk Factors in Guangzhou City, China
- 2081783386 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer Among Nonsmoking Women in Harbin, China
- 2081783388 Analysis of the Relationship Between Smoking and Lung Cancer
- 2081783390-3391 The Trend of Lung Cancer Death Rates in Guangdong Province, China
- 2081783393 Mortality Trend From Lung Cancer From 760000 to 920000 in Guangzhou, China
- 2081783395-3396 Analysis of the Correlation Between Atmospheric Pollution and Lung Cancer in Guangzhou, China
- 2081783398 Relationship Between Lifestyle Factors and Lung Cancer in Human Based on Trend Analysis of Lung Cancer Incidence in Xuanwei, China
- 2081783400 Psychological Factors and Lung Cancer
- 2081783402 Environmental Factors and Lung Cancer
- 2081783404 Analyses of Relationship Between Smoking, Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer Cell Type
- 2081783406 Amplification and Point Mutation of the Ha-Ras Oncogene in Lung Cancer
- 2081783408-3409 Amplification of C-Myc, C-Ha-Ra and C-Sis Oncogenes in Human Lung Cancer
- 2081783411 Expression of P53 and C-Myc in Mouse Lung Cancer Induced by Coal Burning
- 2081783413 Point Mutation at Codon 11 and 12 of H-Ras and K-Ras Oncogenes in Human Fetal Epithelial Cells Treated With Benzo(A)Pyrene Trans-7,8-Diol- Anti-9,10-Epoxide
- 2081783415 Analysis of P53 and K-Ras Mutational Patterns in Lung Cancer
- 2081783417 Methylation Profile and Amplification of Proto-Oncogenes in Caloric Restriction Bnf Rat Pancreas
- 2081783419 An Analysis of Seven Metal Elements in Lung Cancer Tissues in Guangzhou, China Population
- 2081783421 Point Mutations of Ha-Ras and Ki-Ras Oncogenes in Sputum Specimens From Lung Cancer Patients
- 2081783423 Effect of Dietary Restriction on Benzo(A)Pyrene (B(A)P) Metabolic Activation and Pulmonary B(A)P-Dna Adduct Formation in Mice
- 2081783425 Natural Killer (Nk) Cell Activity Assessment and Nk Cell Activation by Rhil-2 in Patients With Lung Cancer
- 2081783427-3430 A Retrospective Cohort Study of Proportional Cancer Mortality Among Chinese Tar Fleet Workers
- 2081783432 Environmental Risk Factors for Lung Cancer Among Swedish Men
Related Documents:
Document Images
a
I
I
I
I
t
I
I
I
I
I
I
1
W
I
1
AN EPIDEMIOLOGICAL INVESTIGATION OF RISK FACTORS
FOR LUNG CANCER IN GUANGZHOU, CHINA
Du Yine-xiu*, Cha Qing*, Chen Xiao-wei*, Chen Yong-zhong*
Huang Lan-fang**, Feng Zhen-zhi** and Wu Xia-fen**
* Department of Hygiene, Guangzhou Medical College, Guangzhou, China
** The Municipal Health & Antiepidemic Station of Guangzhou, Guangzhou, China
Abstract
Lung cancer is one of the five leading tumors in the city of Guangzhou and has been increasing
steadily in both males and females since the 1970s. In this report, more than 6,000 cases of lung
cancer
deaths, accumulated over the past nine years, were analyzed. Significant differences were found
between
males and females with respect to lung cancer risk factors. In a case-control study, 849 cases (571
males
and 278 females) and a conditional logistic regression analysis of 120 nonsmokers (28 males, 92
females)
were studied on the relative contributions of smoking, occupational exposure and indoor air
pollution as
risk factors for the rising incidence of lung cancer. The conclusions were as follows: In females,
indoor
air pollution, derived primarily from burning coal, is a highly significant risk factor for lung
cancer. In
males, however, cigarette smoking and occupational exposure play a more important role. Diet,
especially
vegetable intake, afforded positive protection for lung cancer. Estrogen changes are suggested to be
significantly involved in the increased incidence of female adenocarcinoma.
Introduction
Statistics published by the National Bureau of Public Health in China show that the overall
population death rate in the sixteen largest cities from 1982 to 1988 remained relatively constant
at
565/100,000 (regression coefficient b=0.001, p> 0.05), while the mortality rate attributable to all
forms
of cancer has steadily increased from 100/100,000 in 1982 to 125/100,000 in 1988 (b=0.0117, p<0.05).
Of particular note is the change in the lung cancer death rate, having increased from 25/100,000 in
1982
to 32/100,000 in 1988 (b=0.0151, p<0.001), which accounts for 25-26% of all cancer-related deaths.
Lung cancer deaths in the city of Guangzhou rank as the third highest in the nation, behind the
cities of Chungking and Shanghai. Since the early 1970s, lung cancer has been the foremost cause of
death among the leading tumor-induced deaths. In 1989, the world standardized mortality rate (per
100,000) for the five leading tumors ranked, respectively, as follows: lung cancer (39.79), liver
cancer
(24.12), stomach cancer (9.67), nasopharynx cancer (6.07) and esophageal cancer (5.00), with lung
cancer deaths amounting to almost the total of those originating from the liver, the stomach, and
the
nasopharynx.
' Cigarette smoking, occupational exposure, and air pollution (indoor and outdoor) are generally
believed to be the three major risk factors for lung cancer. The relative importance of each of
these N
I factors, however, is known to vary with sex as well as with region and location. For example, in
the city pC)p
of Guangzhou, the ratio of the incidence of lung cancer in males and females is approximately 2.1:1;
~
however, cigarette smoking is much more prevalent among males (43 % of males, age 15 and above, are
OVo
` smokers) compared to females (only 4%).(1) Forty percent (40%) of female lung cancer deaths were ~
! V
W
I

I
found to be never smokers, suggesting that, in females, factors other than smoking must exist and
contribute significantly to lung cancer deaths. In an occupational analysis involving 5546 cases of
lung
cancer deaths, it was found that the percentage attributable to occupational exposure is small and
can
account for no more than 15 % of the cases in both males and females.(2) In an earlier
investigation, Du
et al.(3) concluded that in the various city districts of Guangzhou in which significantly different
lung
cancer death rates exist (ranging from a low of 20/100,000 to a high of 48/100,000), lung cancer
incidence was correlated with the severity of atmospheric pollution. These findings show that even
within
the same city, the incidence of lung cancer can be influenced by the complex interaction of numerous
known and unknown factors.
Our previous studies have also revealed an association between indoor air pollution and the
incidence of female lung cancer deaths.(4) Similar results have been obtained in other cities in
China. In
a case-control study on the prevalence of female lung cancer in the city of Shanghai, Gao, etal.(5)
suggested that indoor air pollution and the related use of rapeseed oil in cooking may significantly
contribute to the recent pronounced increase in lung cancer cases. Similarly, in a case-control
study in
Harbin, Dai eta l.(6) observed that the risk for adenocarcinoma was correlated with lower
I3-carotene
consumption and the use of coal for heating. Risk was also related to the generation of smoky
conditions
during heating. In the same study, it was reported that the frequency of squamous cell carcinoma was
significantly associated with smoking, a history of bronchitis, and a prevailing smoky environment
during
heating. In Xuanwei county, Yunnan Province (documented to have the highest national female lung
cancer mortality of 121/100,000 based on statistics published in 1973-1975), He et al.(7) reported
in a
case-control study that extremely high lung cancer mortality was caused by indoor air pollution and
by
"smoky" coal combustion.
Substantial differences exist regarding the nature of indoor air pollution between a still
developing
country such as China and developed countries. Since cooking in industrialized nations primarily
uses
electricity or gas and seldom involves deep or stir frying over high heat, insignificant levels of
respirable
particulate matter and B(a)P are generated during cooking. Consequently, cooking is not considered a
significant source of indoor air pollution. On the other hand, there are substantial particulates
liberated
from carpets, walls, ceilings and other types of indoor decorations, which would constitute the bulk
of
indoor air pollutants in families of developed countries and which are rarely encountered in China.
In
China, families in rural villages use wood and straw for cooking and heating, while in cities, coal
is the
primary fuel source for cooking. Cities in northern China are additionally dependent on burning coal
for
heating. These social habits, coupled with China's population density and, hence, small-size living
area,
have compounded the severity of indoor air pollution.
Although many of the published case-control epidemiologic studies investigating the relationship
between indoor air pollution and the incidence of female lung cancer have suggested a causal
relationship,
it is important to emphasize that such information is merely a clue and must be complemented by
laboratory investigations in order to definitively demonstrate the biological plausibility of a
causal
relationship. For example, the notion that indoor coal burning is a major factor for female lung
cancer
would require studies showing that: 1) coal consumption indoors can generate significant levels of
potentially carcinogenic substances and 2) such materials are also found to be present in exposed
subjects
at concentrations sufficiently high for cancer to be induced. In addition, because the development
of lung
cancer is likely to involve multiple factors and has a relatively long latency, and since factors
being
2
I
I
I
1
I
I
I
I
I
i
I
I
I
I

I
I
I
I
I
~
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
investigated may be causal as well as consequential, due consideration must be given to confounding
in
connection with attempting to elucidate the effects of a single agent (or event) on the development
of lung
cancer. For example, the real impact of indoor air pollution on female lung cancer should be
addressed
in the context of confounding due to occupational exposure and cigarette smoking.
Because the cell-types in male and female lung cancer are distinctly different, with squamous cell
carcinoma being most predominant in males and adenocarcinoma prevailing in females, and because
numerous studies have already concluded that unique lung cancer cell-types are caused by different
carcinogenic factors, it is of interest to determine the cell-type in lung cancer cases that are
attributed to
indoor air pollutants.
In this report, we have systematically analyzed the risk factors for female lung cancer deaths and
have compared the associated risk factors between males and females.
Materials and Methods
Because of the long latency of lung cancer, and since the three factors (air pollution, occupational
exposure, and cigarette smoking) being investigated in relation to lung cancer deaths may have
complex
interactive effects, a broad database, collected over a long period of time, is required for
reaching
meaningful conclusions.
1. Case History.
In Guangzhou (population 2,000,000), there are four districts with 63 local police stations. Each
station has a complete registry, containing information on age, sex, occupation, residence, and
time/cause
of death. In 1976, we began a detailed analysis of the registry, concentrating on cases in which
death was
caused by cancers of the lung, liver, nasopharynx, stomach, and esophagus. The annual crude and age-
adjusted death rate, as well as the wotld age-adjusted death rate, was calculated yearly in order to
ascertain the trend of deaths attributed to the five cancers. Beginning in 1980, every case of death
from
lung cancer was further analyzed using a standardized questionnaire containing 31 questions.
Information
was obtained retrospectively from relatives and verified by comparison with hospital records. The
questionnaires were administered by trained medical personnel, and the data were entered into a
computer. Because all deaths in China, including time and cause, must be reported to the local
police
station, and the report must agree with information provided to cremation centers, the data
generated
were considered to be highly reliable and accurate.
2. Analysis of Outdoor and Indoor Air Pollutants.
~ The city of Guangzhou, with an area of 55 square kilometers, can be divided into the four
districts of Liwan, Yuexiu, Dongshan, and Haizhu. Atmospheric pollution status was systematically
' monitored by the Guangzhou Health and Antiepidemic Station(8), by the Guangzhou Environmental
Monitoring Center(9), and by International Atmospheric Pollution Centers(8) established and managed
by the World Health Organization. The information collected over the past two decades was used to
~ calculate the Air Pollution Index according to the following equations(10): p
W
i
V
~ 00
3- N
cc
V
N
I

1 n Ci
API = E where:
Ci -- Measured concentration of pollutants
Si -- Permissible level of pollutants
To assess the effects of indoor air pollution, two investigations were conducted in 1984 and 1985
as follows: Five families were randomly selected in each of the four districts. Samples were
obtained over
a 5-day period at each of the four seasons during the year. Daily samples were collected as follows:
SO2
and NOx samples were obtained every 2 hours from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. for a total of 7 samples per day;
TSP and B(a)P were determined daily. To compare the levels of indoor and outdoor pollution, samples
of SO2, NOx, TSP and B(a)P were also collected in the immediate outdoor vicinity of the selected
families.(11) The levels of indoor and outdoor radioactivity in Guangzhou were measured by Wu(11) as
follows: ten families were randomly selected in each of the four districts in July of 1984 and in
February
of 1985. Radon, thoron, and their daughters were measured. To determine whether the measurements
may be affected by the construction material and by the type of cooking fuel used, houses
constructed
with different materials and homes using either coal or liquified petroleum for cooking were used.
The major source of indoor pollution came from cooking. This is especially evident when burning
coal was used. Thus, a comparative study was conducted in 1986-1987 in which total suspended
particulate (TSP), TSP-B(a)P, sedimentary dust (SD), SD-B(a)P and B(a)P in the urine of housewives
were determined. To avoid contamination from industrial sources, only families located far from
factories
and highways were used. The age of housewives ranged from 40-70. They were nonsmokers and had
been working at home for at least 1 year.
3. Occupation Analysis.
The majority of the participants were males with steady, well-defined jobs. To be eligible, a
person must have worked in the same job for a minimum of 10 years. To determine the true risk
potential
of the different occupations, Hench's method was used to calculate the Standard Mortality Rate (SMR)
and the Population Attributable Risk (PAR). The relationship between lung cancer deaths and
occupation
was ranked as "None," "Probable." and "Obvious." Such a ranking system permits a systematic
comparison of the relative contribution of occupation on the incidence of lung cancer deaths.
4. Active Smoking.
Smoking history includes age at which smoking began, number of cigarettes smoked per day,
number of years smoked, and the type of tobacco consumed. A smoking index was obtained by
multiplying the number of cigarettes smoked per day by the number of years smoked.
In addition to case-control studies, we further analyzed whether smoking is a confounding factor
for the effects of occupational exposure. Since it was not possible to obtain the rate of smoking
for every
case in each occupation, the effects of smoking on the standard mortality rate (generated from
occupational exposure) were determined by rank correlation.
4
N
0
~
~
V
Co
N
tD
V
rn
I
11
I
I
t
M
l
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I

I
I
I
I
I
S
1
I
I
I
I
The effect of smoking on lung cancer cell-type was also investigated by correlating the smoking
status and the smoking index.
5. Case-Control Studies.
(a) Effects of Smoking and Coal Fume Exposure.
In 1985, there were 849 lung cancer deaths (571 males and 298 females). They were matched
for sex, age ( t 2 years), and residence with nonlung cancer-related deaths. They were analyzed
according to Mantel-Haenszel and by the stratification method, from which the relative risks
associated
with smoking status and contact with smoke from burning coal were obtained.
(b) Effects of Other Risk Factors: Study Involving Nonsmokers.
In the 849 lung cancer death cases, 120 cases (28 males and 92 females) were never-smokers.
To investigate the effects of risk factors other than smoking, a separate case-control study,
matched 1:2
for sex, age, and residence, was performed using two groups of controls. The first group consisted
of
120 cases of never smokers who died from nonrespiratory illnesses. The second group consisted of
never
smokers whose deaths were caused by tumors outside of the respiratory system. Items investigated
include: X1-history of respiratory disease; X2-consumption of fresh vegetables; X3-history of
contact with
toxic substances prior to death; X4-ETS exposure; X5-indoor air pollution; X6-size of living
quarters;
X7-size of kitchen; X8-cooking fuel; X9-participation in cooking; X10-family history of cancer. The
contribution of each of these items was analyzed using conditional logistic regression.
6. Factors Affecting the Distribution of Lung Cancer Cell Tvnes
In this study, we examined the influence of active and passive smoking, air pollution (indoor and
outdoor), and occupational exposures on lung cancer cell types in both males and females. Eight
cell-
types of lung cancer were identified. These include squamous cell, small cell, adeno, large cell,
epi-
adeno, carcinoid, bronchial gland, and others. Over 80% of the total cases can be classified into
squamous cell carcinoma and adenocarcinoma. The occurrence of these cell types shows a significant
difference between males and females.
Results
1. Deaths Attributed to Five Leading Cancers in Guangzhou From 1976 to 1989
Table 1 shows the results of the regression analysis of deaths due to the five leading tumors. In
the case of lung cancer, a significant increase was observed in both males and females (p<0.01).
Little
change was found in liver and stomach cancers (p>0.05). Deaths due to nasopharynx and esophageal
cancers show a decline (p<0.05) in the same period.
O
~
~
v
00
~ v
N
I

2. Analysis of Lung Cancer Death Records.
Between 1980 and 1989, 6,812 cases of lung cancer deaths, with 4,615 males and 2,197 females
(sex ratio of 2.1:1), were recorded. For the present study, the following death cases were excluded:
1)
those not involving primary lung cancer and 2) those residing for less than 10 years in Guangzhou. A
total of 5,546 cases (3,760 males and 1,786 females) were included in the analysis (sex ratio
2.1:1). The
youngest subject was 25 years old and the oldest was 98 years of age. The average death age was 64
in
males and 65 in females. There were more cases of death due to cancer of the right lung, and the
majority of these cases had central rather than peripheral foci. Metastasis was observed in 60% of
the
cases.
3. Atmospheric Pollution
Between 1972 and 1990, 3 large-scale samplings of atmospheric pollutants were conducted. The
results were transformed into an Atmospheric Pollution Index (API), which measured the
concentrations
of S02 and TSP. The TSP were further checked for their mutagenic activity using the Ames test (TA98,
S9-) as described by Li et al.(12) Results in Table 2 show that atmospheric pollution was most
severe in
Liwan and was also correlated with the greatest incidence of lung cancer deaths. Likewise, TSP in
Liwan
demonstrated the most pronounced mutagenic activity (Table 2.
4. Indoor Air Pollution
An investigation into indoor air pollution over a two year period shows that the level of pollutants
is higher indoors than outdoors (Table 3, due to the fact that most of the factories are located in
the
outskirts of the city and because of the infrequent automobile use in Guangzhou in the year
1984-1985.
Three daily peaks (7:00 a.m., 11:00 a.m., and 7:00 p.m.) in the levels of SO2 and NOx were
observed. The levels were higher in winter and spring (when the windows were usually closed) than in
summer and autumn (when the windows were open), suggesting that the major source of indoor air
pollution came from cooking (Table 4.
In Guangzhou, the traditional use of wood for cooking in the 1950s was replaced by coal in the
1960s, Beginning in 1980, some of the families began using liquefied petroleum. In 1992, about 50%
of
the families used gas for cooking. Table 5 compares the levels of indoor air pollutants and B(a)P in
the
urine of housewives among families using burning coal and those using gas. The levels are
significantly
higher in coal-buming families. The presence of B(a)P in the urine suggests that the amounts
generated
during cooking are readily taken up by the body.
Table 6 illustrates the levels of radon and thoron (and their daughters) inside and outside of the
home. The levels are correlated with the type of construction materials Table 7 and cooking fuel
used
(Table 8. Specifically, houses constructed with green and red bricks emit more radon and thoron than
houses constructed with concrete. Moreover, thoron and radon levels were further elevated by the
presence of burning coal, although never exceeding the National Standards (GB 4792-84).
-6-
i
1
11
I
I
R
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
^
1

a
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
5. The Effects of Occupational Exposure
In the 5,546 cases of lung cancer, 6,167 personal occupation files were found. Approximately
600 people spent 10 years in 2 or more different professions. Occupation distribution is illustrated
in
Table 9 and Table 10. About 15 % of the cases may have exposure to job-related pollutants.
To correlate occupational exposure and incidence of lung cancer deaths, a Standardized Mortality
Ratio (SMR) was calculated for 434 cases of lung cancer deaths in the year, 1982 (Table 11). The
Population Attributable Risks (PAR) for the 12 occupations are shown in Table 12. Chemists have the
highest SMR in males, whereas homemakers have the highest SMR in females. Homemakers also have
the highest PAR.
6. Active Smoking
About 93% and 59% of the 3,755 and 1,784 cases of male and female lung cancer deaths,
respectively, had a smoking history record. 95.3%, 2.8%, 1.4% and 0.5% of the smokers smoked
cigarettes, water pipes, pipes, and cigars, respectively. The smoking history in the 5,539 cases of
male/female lung cancer deaths is illustrated in Table 13. About 70% of the smokers began smoking
before age 20. Cigarette consumption is higher in males (25 per day) than in females (20 per day).
The
smoking index is also higher in males (670) compared to females (630). The longer duration of
smoking
in females is probably due to their longer life expectancy.
Using a rank correlation method, the contribution of smoking as a confounding factor on
"Occupation-SMR" was studied and is illustrated in Table 14. In subjects with identical occupation,
female "Occupation-SMR" was not affected by smoking, whereas in males, smoking did significantly
influence "Occupation-SMR".
Cigarette sales (packs/person/year) in Guangzhou between the years 1961-1974 were correlated
with lung cancer death rates between the years 1976-1989. The coefficient of correlation (r) was
0.86
(p<0.01) in males and 0.71 (p>0.05) in females, showing that cigarette consumption is more closely
associated with male lung cancer deaths.
7. Case-Control Studies
The 849 (571 males and 278 females) lung cancer deaths in 1985 were further analyzed in two
case-control studies. In the first study, in addition to evaluating the relative risks associated
with cigarette
smoke and contact with burning coal, the estimated annual death rate, the attributable death rate,
and
attributable risk were also evaluated and are listed in Table 15.
The effect of cigarette smoke on lung cancer is much less important in females than males. By
] contrast, indoor air pollution is a highly significant risk factor for female lung cancer deaths
but had no
' effect in males. The estimated death rate in males attributable to cigarette smoking is 31 %
higher than
the standardized death rate (68.5 compared to 52.2), while that attributable to contact with burning
coal N
~ is much lower (38%, 19.9/52.2). In the case of females, the corresponding percentages are 49% p~p
_L
ti
co
7_ y
~ M
tc
1

i
(12.3/24.7) and 77.7% (19.2/24.7), further showing that smoking is a more important risk factor for
males, while contact with burning coal is a highly significant risk factor for females. ~
i
In the second study, conditional logistic regression analysis was performed on the 120 cases of
nonsmokers (28 males and 92 females) matched 1:2 with controls.
~
When lung cancer cases were matched with nonrespiratory cancer, we obtained results that are
described by the following equations:
~
Males: logit Pi= ai + 0.045X3
11
Females: logit Pi= ai - 0.663X2 + 0.129X5 - 0.217X7
When lung cancers were matched with deaths not involving the respiratory system, the observed
results were shown to fit the following equations:
Males: logit Pi= ai - 1.330X2 + 0.0481X3
Females: Logit Pi = ai - 0.796X2 + 0.032X3 + 0.216X5 - 0.548X7
These results suggest that the consumption of fresh vegetables (X2) was a protective factor for
lung cancer, whereas contact with toxic substances (X3) increases the risk for lung cancer.
It is worth noting that in nonsmoking females, indoor air pollution (X5) and size of kitchen (X7)
are risk factors for lung cancer, whereas ETS exposure (X4), respiratory disease history (Xl),
familial
history of cancer (X10), living conditions (X6), use of cooking fuel (X8), and participation in
cooking
(X9) had no effect whatsoever on female lung cancer deaths. The exclusion of X8 and X9 in the
regression equations suggest that cooking fuel use and the degree of cooking participation may have
been
quite similar between the lung cancer cases and the matched controls. In the case of nonsmoking
males,
the major risk factors were contact with toxic substances and occupational exposure.
8. Factors Affecting the Distribution of Lung Cancer Cell Types
(a) Effects of Gender, 1,093 of the 5,546 lung cancer death cases (804 males and 289
females) contain information on lung cancer cell type (19.7%). In males, the most common cell type
is
squamous cell carcinoma (58%) followed by adenocarcinoma (24%). In females, the converse was
observed, with 48% adenocarcinoma and 29% squamous cell carcinoma (Table 16 .
(b) Contribution of Cigarette Smoking. These results are shown in Table 16. In addition, the
relationship between smoking index and lung cancer cell types was also studied (Table 17 . A
significant
difference between the ratio of the various lung cancer cell types was shown to exist between
smokers
and nonsmokers (males, X2=15.74, p<0.01; females, X2=8.55, p<0.05). In males, the smoking index
is proportional to the percentage of squamous cell carcinoma (p <0.01) and inversely proportional to
the
percentage of adenocarcinoma (p<0.0001). The smoking index did not affect the lung cancer cell type
in females (p>0.05). In both males and females, the incidence of squamous cell carcinoma is higher
in
smokers than in nonsmokers, whereas the frequency of adenocarcinoma is lower in smokers than in
-8-
I
I
I
I

t
I
I
I
I
nonsmokers. These results suggest that smoking may be correlated with an increased incidence of
squamous cell carcinoma.
(c) Occupational Exposure and Lung Cancer Cell TjMe. These results are shown in Table
18. In males, occupations requiring significant exposure to toxic substances showed a greater
proportion
of squamous cell carcinoma lung cancer than adenocarcinoma. No difference was observed between the
two cell types in occupations lacking such exposures. Such effects were not observed in females.
(d) The Relationship between Lung Cancer Cell Type and Indoor (coal fume exposure) or
Outdoor (houses surrounded with pollution sources) Air Pollution. These results are shown in Table
19.
No difference in cell types was observed between the "exposed" and "nonexposed" groups in both males
and females, except that an increasing trend of squamous cell carcinoma was noted in females exposed
to coal fumes (p<0.05).
Table 20 provides a comparison and a summary of the lung cancer associated risk factors in males
and females.
Discussion
I
1
I
I
Our studies clearly show that major differences exist between males and females with respect to
risk factors for lung cancer. In males, cigarette smoking and occupational exposure are important
considerations, whereas in females, indoor air pollution appears to be most significant. A similar
conclusion has been reached in numerous epidemiological investigations carried out in China.
Although
these studies have provided important leads with respect to factors that could play a significant
role in
the etiology of lung cancer, it is necessary to emphasize that the epidemiological clues must be
supplemented with laboratory investigations in order to unequivocally confirm their biological
plausibility
and to further show that they are at least mechanistically compatible with the pathogenesis of lung
cancer.
1. Cigarette Smoking
Cigarette smoking is widely accepted as a major risk factor for lung cancer in males. In our
studies, 93% of the males have a history of smoking. The calculated relative risk (RR) of smoking
for
male lung cancer was 3.54(95% CI=2.44-5.11) (p<0.001). In females, the RR was 1.93 (95%
CI =1.30-2.87)(p < 0.01).
Numerous studies have focussed on the chemical composition of mainstream and sidestream
tobacco smoke.(13) Among the 108 chemicals that have been identified, 2-naphthylamine and 4-
aminobiphenyl are considered by IARC (International Agency for Research on Cancer) to be human
carcinogens.(14) Benzo(a)pyrene, N-nitrosodimethylamine, formaldehyde, and acetamide are suggested
to be probable carcinogens, while 1,3-butadiene, nitrosonornicotine, N-nitrosopyrrolidine and
indino(1,2,3-cd)pyrene are listed as possible carcinogens. Benzo(a)pyrene has been studied most
extensively. A number of studies have shown the concentrations of benzo(a)pyrene to be elevated in
the
urine of smokers.
N
O
00
~
V
9- 00
N
CO
00
s
I

As a pro-carcinogen, benzo(a)pyrene is actively metabolized to phenols, quinones, and
dihydrodiols by microsotttal enzymes. While no carcinogenic effects have been associated with
phenols
and quinones, some of the dihydrodiols have been demonstrated to be highly reactive with DNA. We
have treated human fetal tracheal epithelial cells (HFTE) with four different dihydrodiols (i.e.,
anti-
BPDE, syn-BPDE, 3-hydroxy-BP, and 9-hydro-BP) and found that cells exposed to anti-BPDE are
accompanied by an increase in micronuclei content, an induction of unscheduled DNA synthesis, and
point mutations in codon 12 of the H-ras gene.(15, 16) These results are similar to the findings of
Kapitulnik et al.,(17) showing that anti-BPDE was capable of inducing lung tumors in mice. Mutations
in codon 12 of the H-ras gene have been similarly established in squamous cell carcinoma and
adenocarcinoma of the lung.
Squamous cell carcinoma and adenocarcinoma constitute 58 % and 23 % of lung cancer in males,
whereas in females, the most commonly observed lung cancer is adenocarcinoma (48 %), with squamous
cell carcinoma constituting only 29 %. Insofar as the incidence of squamous cell carcinoma is
concerned,
the 59% and 36% observed in male and female smokers are significantly higher than that observed in
nonsmokers (40% in males and 22% in females, p<0.01), suggesting that cigarette smoking is mainly
associated with an increased incidence of squamous cell carcinoma. In addition, we observed that the
ratio
of squamous cell carcinoma to adenocarcinoma in male smokers and nonsmokers is 2.57:1 and 1.14:1,
respectively. In females, the ratio of squamous cell carcinoma to adenocarcinoma is 0.89:1 in
smokers
and 0.39:1 in nonsmokers. Thus, no significant difference can be observed in the incidence of
squamous
cell carcinoma to adenocarcinoma in nonsmokers (p>0.05), further supporting the role of cigarette
smoking in inducing an increase in the incidence of squamous cell carcinoma. In female nonsmokers,
56% of the lung cancer is of the adenocarcinoma type. The incidence of squamous cell carcinoma in
smoking females (36%) is slightly higher than the average 29% observed in the general female
population, but is still lower than the observed 40% adenocarcinoma in nonsmoking females,
suggesting
that other factors must account for the high incidence of adenocarcinoma and that the same factor(s)
must
also somehow counteract the effects of cigarette smoking in inducing squamous cell carcinoma.
Analysis of cell types in 1,048 cases of lung cancer deaths show that in males, squamous cell
carcinoma is the most prevalent, followed by adenocarcinoma. In females, adenocarcinoma is more
prevalent than squamous cell carcinoma.
2. Air Pollution
Unlike other tumors, lung cancer is mainly caused by inhalation of carcinogenic substances. In
our studies, areas with the highest air pollution index have the most cases of lung cancer deaths,
clearly
pointing to atmospheric pollution being associated with lung cancer deaths. A similar conclusion was
reached by Yu et al.(18) in their studies on mutagenicity of size-fractionated air particles. It is
necessary
to point out that, although the magnitude of air pollution in an urban setting can be influenced by
factors
such as population density; the degree of industrialization and development; the source of energy;
the
quality and quantity of traffic; the geographical location of city and its design; etc., the major
source of
atmospheric pollution in Chinese cities comes from coal burning in connection with home heating and
cooking. Because females stay indoors longer than males, indoor air pollution has been established
as a
major risk factor for female lung cancer deaths. Such a conclusion has been reached by numerous
studies
carried out in different parts of China.
-10-
a
I
I
I
I
I
