Philip Morris
Relationship Between Acetylator Status, Smoking, Diet and Colorectal Cancer Risk in the North-East of England
Fields
- Author
- Bassendine, M.F.
- Cooper, J.
- Daly, A.K.
- Welfare, M.R.
- Cooper, J.
- Type
- PSCI, PUBLICATION SCIENTIFIC
- BIBL, BIBLIOGRAPHY
- Master ID
- 2063633486/4072
Related Documents:- 2063633486-4072 Book 7 Tabs 1-68
- 2063633488-3498 Predicting Rodent Carcinogenicity From Mutagenic Potency Measured in the Ames Salmonella Assay
- 2063633500-3505 Workplace Conditions, Socioeconomic Status, and the Risk of Mortality and Acute Myocardial Infarction: the Kuopio Ischaemic Heart Disease Risk Factor Study
- 2063633507-3510 Environmental Exposure to Gasoline and Leukemia in Children and Young Adults - An Ecology Study
- 2063633512-3530 Behavioral Functions of Nucleus Accumbens Dopamine: Empirical and Conceptual Problems with the Anhedonia Hypothesis
- 2063633532-3543 the Use of A Urine Mutagenicity Assay in the Monitoring of Environmental Exposure to Genotoxins
- 2063633545-3553 Smoking and Relative Body Weight: An International Perspective From the Who Monica Project
- 2063633555-3562 Aromatic Amine Dna Adduct Formation in Chronically-Exposed Mice: Considerations for Human Comparison
- 2063633564-3570 Life-Style Factors and Female Infertility
- 2063633571 Sensitivity of the Relation Between Cumulative Magnetic Field Exposure and Brain Cancer Mortality to Choice of Monitoring Data Grouping Scheme
- 2063633573-3584 Genetic Risk Factors for Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease
- 2063633586-3593 Risk Factors Associated with the Development of Peripheral Arterial Disease in Smokers: A Case-Control Study
- 2063633595-3609 Self-Regulation and Mortality From Cancer, Coronary Heart Disease, and Other Causes: A Prospective Study
- 2063633611-3620 Dna Damage in Nasal Respiratory Epithelium From Children Exposed to Urban Pollution
- 2063633622-3630 Co-Carcinogenic Effects of Various Agents in Rats Following Exposure to Radon and Radon Daughters
- 2063633632-3638 Genetics and the Origin of Species: An Introduction
- 2063633640-3647 Subjective Indoor Air Quality in Schools in Relation to Exposure
- 2063633649-3662 the Nurses' Health Study: 20-Year Contribution to the Understanding of Health Among Women
- 2063633664-3671 Polymorphisms of Cyp1a1 and Gstm1 Influence the in Vivo Function of Cyp1a2
- 2063633673-3677 Quantitative Evaluation of Multiplicity in Epidemiology and Public Health Research
- 2063633679-3681 Abc of Allergies Asthma and Allergy
- 2063633683-3684 Inflammatory Responses and Coronary Heart Disease the 'dirty Chicken' Hypothesis of Cardiovascular Risk Factors
- 2063633685 Consultant Suspended for Not Getting Consent for Cardiac Procedure. Mmr Vaccine Policy Is Backed
- 2063633687-3690 When Can Odds Ratios Mislead?
- 2063633692-3699 Increased Responsiveness of Ventral Tegmental Area Dopamine Neurons to Glutamate After Repeated Administration of Cocaine or Amphetamine Is Transient and Selectively Involves Ampa Receptors
- 2063633701-3703 Association Between Cigarette Smoking and Fhit Gene Alterations in Lung Cancer
- 2063633705-3712 Genetic Testing for Susceptibility to Adult - Onset Cancer the Process and Content of Informed Consent
- 2063633714-3721 Release of Carbon Granules From Cigarettes with Charcoal Filters
- 2063633723-3731 Detection of Low - Fraction K-Ras Mutations in Primary Lung Tumors Using A Sensitive Method
- 2063633733-3740 Socioeconomic Level, Sedentary Lifestyle, and Wine Consumption As Possible Explanations for Geographic Distribution of Cerebrovascular Disease Mortality in Spain
- 2063633742-3750 Air Pollution and Daily Admissions for Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease in 6 European Cities: Results From the Aphea Project
- 2063633751 Airway Obstruction and Rheumatoid Arthritis
- 2063633758-3763 Cardiovascular Risk Factor Profile in Subjects with Familial Predisposition to Myocardial Infarction in Denmark
- 2063633765-3770 Effect of Fresh Fruit Consumption on Lung Function and Wheeze in Children
- 2063633772-3777 Interactive Effect of the P53 Gene and Cigarette Smoking on Coronary Artery Disease
- 2063633779-3784 P53 Gene Aberrations in Non-Small-Cell Lung Carcinomas From A Smoking Population
- 2063633786-3794 Interlaboratory Comparison of Pm10 and Black Smoke Measurements in the Peace Study
- 2063633796-3799 Statistical Significance - A Misconstrued Notion in Medical Research
- 2063633801-3808 Urinary 1-Hydroxypyrene As A Marker of Exposure to Pyrene: An Epidemiological Survey on A General Population Group
- 2063633810-3813 Genetic Polymorphism of Cytochrome P450 As A Biomarker of Susceptibility to Environmental Toxicity
- 2063633815-3824 Smoking Among Psychiatric Patients
- 2063633826-3831 Evaluation of Certain Risk Factors for Lung Cancer in Cracow (Poland)
- 2063633833-3840 Prevalence and Predictive Value of P53 Mutation in Patients with Oesophageal Squamous Cell Carcinomas: A Prospective Clinico-Pathological Study and Survival Analysis of 70 Patients
- 2063633842-3848 Ki-Ras Mutations in Exocrine Pancreatic Cancer: Association with Clinico-Pathological Characteristics and with Tobacco and Alcohol Consumption
- 2063633850-3859 Risk Factors for Raynaud's Phenomenon Among Workers in Poultry Slaughterhouses and Canning Factories
- 2063633861-3880 Molecular Events in Lung Carcinogenesis
- 2063633882-3885 Cyp1a1, Cyp2e1 and Gstm Polymorphisms Are Not Associated with Susceptibility to Squamous - Cell Carcinoma of the Esophagus
- 2063633887-3891 the P53 Tumor Suppressor Targets A Novel Regulator of G Protein Signaling
- 2063633893-3896 New Tumor Suppressor Found - Twice. Prepaper Publicity Ignites Race to Publish. Shape- Changing Crystals Get Shiftier
- 2063633898-3899 Who Reform and Global Health
- 2063633901-3903 Showdown Over Clear Air Science. Puzzling Over A Potential Killer's Modus Operandi
- 2063633905-3910 Polymorphisms in the Glutathione S-Transferase Class Mu and Theta Genes Interact and Increase Susceptibility to Lung Cancer in Minority Populations (Texas, United States)
- 2063633912-3927 Plant Foods and Colon Cancer: An Assessment of Specific Foods and Their Related Nutrients (United States)
- 2063633929 Smoking, Alcohol and Coffee Consumption, and H Pylori Infection
- 2063633931-3934 Grand Rounds at the Clinical Center of the National Institutes of Health Evaluating Coronary Heart Disease Risk Tiles in the Mosaic
- 2063633936-3939 New Clues to Asthma Therapies. Why the Rise in Asthma Cases? New Lead to Safer Marrow Transplants
- 2063633941-3946 Cancer Undefeated
- 2063633948-3964 Lung Tissue Responses and Sites of Particle Retention Differ Between Rats and Cyanomolgus Monkeys Exposed Chronically to Diesel Exhaust and Coal Dust
- 2063633966-3986 Implementation on Epa Revised Cancer Assessment Guidelines: Incorporation of Mechanistic and Pharmacokinetic Data
- 2063633988-3999 Particle Pollution and Sudden Infant Death Syndrome in the United States Policy Memorandum
- 2063634001-4007 Neighborhood Social Environments and the Distribution of Low Birthweight in Chicago
- 2063634009-4014 the Effects of Cigarette Smoking and Gestational Weight Change on Birth Outcomes in Obese and Normal-Weight Women
- 2063634016-4017 Annotation: Cigarette Smoking, Nutrition, and Birthweight
- 2063634019-4020 Helicobacter Pylori Infection and Coagulation in Healthy People
- 2063634022-4023 Prospective Study of Helicobacter Pylori Seropositivity and Cardiovascular Diseases in A General Elderly Population
- 2063634025-4027 Age Specific Trends in Asthma Mortality in England and Wales, 830000 - 950000: Results of An Observational Study
- 2063634029-4036 Childhood Leukemia and Electromagnetic Fields: Results of A Population - Based Case - Control Study in Germany
- 2063634038-4047 Association of Smoking, Body Mass, and Physical Activity with Risk of Prostate Cancer in the Iowa 65+ Rural Health Study (United States)
- 2063634049-4056 Tobacco and Non-Hodgkin's Lymphoma: Combined Analysis of Three Case-Control Studies (United States)
- 2063634058-4063 How Much Pain for Cardiac Gain?
- 2063634065-4071 A Prospective Study of Body Mass Index, Weight Change, and Risk of Stroke in Women
- Area
- CARCHMAN,RICHARD/OFFICE
- Named Organization
- North of England Cancer Research Campaig
- Author (Organization)
- Carcinogenesis
- North Tyneside General Hospital
- Oxford Univ Press
- Univ of Newcastle
- North Tyneside General Hospital
- Litigation
- Iwoh/Produced
- Characteristic
- EXTR, EXTRA
- MARG, MARGINALIA
- Site
- R530
- Date Loaded
- 07 Jun 1999
Document Images
Relationship between acetylator status, smoking, diet and
colorectal cancer risk in the north-east of England
Mark R.Welfare~,2J, Jane Cooper2,
Margaret F.BassendineI and Ann K.Dalyz
Departments of IMedicin¢ and 2Pharmacological Science, University of
Newcastle, Ne~vcastle-upon-Tyn¢ HE2 4HH, UK
~To whom correspondence should be addressed at: Academic Department,
North Tyneside General Hospital, Rake Lane, North Shield¢ NE30 8NH,
UK
Some previous studies have suggested that the fast pheno-
type of the N-acetyltransferase NAT2 may confer suscepti-
bility to colorectal cancer because of greater activation of
dietary heterocycHc amines, particularly in individuals who
also consume well-done red meat, but other studies have
not supported this. We describe a large case-control study
examining the interaction between dietary, smoking and
drinking habits, and acetylation genotype in relation to
susceptibility to colorectal cancer. One-hundred-and-
seventy-four incident cases and 174 matched controls were
recruited. Genotyping for polymorphisms in NAT2 was
performed using a method that detects >95% of slow
alleles and data on personal habits were collected using a
standardized questionnaire. We found no difference in the
frequency of the fast acetylator genotype bet~veen cases
and controls [odds ratio = 0.95 (95% CI 0.61-1.49)], and
analysis by sex, age and site also revealed no difference in
acetylator genotype. There was, however, considerable
heterogeneity in dietary risk factors between fast and slow
acetylators. Analysis by acetylator type shows that recent
smoking was more frequent in slow acetylator cases than
matched controls [OR = 2.31 (1.16-4~6)] and that heavy
alcohol consumption was also more frequent in the slow
acetylator cases than controls [OR = 2.5 (1.02-7.29)].
In contrast, frequent fried meat intake was seen more
frequently in fast acetylator cases than matched controls
[OR = 6.0 (1.34-55)]. The odds ratio for the combination
of fast acetylator status and frequent fried meat consump-
tion in cases was 6.04 (1.6-26). Our study suggests that
there may be different risk factors for colorectal cancer in
slow and fast acetylators, and reveals a new observation
that slow acetylators may be at risk of colon cancer from
smoking. In our community, the overall effect of acetylator
status on colorectal cancer risk is neutral.
Introduction
Colorectal cancer is a major cause of death in many Western
countries including the UK and USA. While up to 5% of cases
are due to inherited forms of the disease, in particular familial
adenomatous polyposis (FAP*) and hereditary non-polyposis
colon cancer (HNPCC), the aetiology of the sporadic form of
*Abbreviations: FAP, familial adenomatou$ polyposis; }-INPCC, hereditary
non-polyposis colon cancer; MelQX, 2-amino-3,8-dimethylimidazo[4,5-
.t]quinoxaline; Phi:P, 2-amino-l-methyl-6-phenylimid,azo[4,5-b]pyfidine; ABP,
4-aminobiphenyl.
Oxford University Press
the disease has proved difficult to determine although some
evidence for increased relative risk for certain dietary, environ-
mental and genetic factors have been reported (for review see
reference 1). Of these factors, diet has been the most widely
studied. Red meat intake has been shown to be associated with
increased risk of the disease in a number of different studies,
including case-control, cohort and migration (2-4). In addition,
method and extent of cooking may affect risk of the disease
with well-caoked, barbecued meat intake associated with the
highest risk (5). An association between alcohol consumption
and susceptibility to rectal cancer has also been reported in
some, but not all studies (6), and the relationship between
smo "king and colorectal cancer is also not clear (7).
The increased risk of colorectaI cancer development associ-
ated with eating well-done meat may reflect an important role
for heteroeyclic amines as chemical carcinogens in this disease.
Heterocyclic amines are formed as pyrolysis products during
coo'king at high temperature and have been demonstrated to
be both mutagenic and carcinogenic (8). I-Iigh concentrations of
hetarocyclic amines such as 2-amino-3,8-dimethylimidazo[4,5-
fJquinoxaline (MeIQX) and 2-amino-l-methyl-6-phenylimid-
azo[4,5-b]pyridine (PhIP) have been demonstrated in grilled
meat and fish and levels in the drippings and pan scrapings,
which are often used for preparation of gravy, are particularly
high (9-11). In the average US diet, the heterocyclie amine
consumed at the highest concentration appears to be PhIP
which has recently been demonstrated to give a specific
signature mutation in the APC turnout suppressor gene when
fed to rats (i2,I3). It is not -known whether the particular
mutation also occurs in humans exposed to PhlP, but the APC
gene is mutated in ~60% of human coloreetal tumours and
mutation of this gene appears to be an important step in the
carcinogenic process (14).
There is also evidence that polymorphisms in genes encoding
xenobiotic activating and metabolizing enzymes, particularly
the cytochrome P450 CYPIA2, the N-acetyltransferases and the
glutathione-S-transferases modulate risk of coIorectal cancer
development. This relationship may be due to the role of these
enzymes in heterocyclic amine activation and detoxication.
In particular, it is known that heterocyclic amines undergo
activation to mutageas in a series of reactions initiated by N-
oxidation by CYP1A2 (15). The oxidized metabolite undergoes
O-acetylation, either by the hepatic N-acetyltransferases NAT1
and NAT2 directly or it may first be glucuronidated, excreted
in the bile, deconjugated by colonic bacteria and then finally
undergo O-acetylation by colonic NAT's (16). Olutathione-S-
transferases have been shown to prevent the formation of
DNA-adduets in vitro, but whether this is relevant to the
in vivo situation is not yet known (17).
On present evidence, the polymorphism in N-acetyltrans-
ferase 2 (NAT2) is the best candidate for a metabolic poly-
morphism likely to modulate risk of colorectaI cancer
developmem. At least seven different alleles resulting from
single base-changes cause almost complete loss of enzyme
1351
This article is for individual use only and may not be further reproduced or stored electronically
without wdtten
permission from the copyright holder. Unauthorized reproduction may result in financial and other
penalties.
(c) OXFORD UNIV PRESS ENGLAND

M.R.Welfare et aL
activity and possession of two mutant alleles restflts in the
slow acetylator phenotype whereas possession of one or two
wild-type alleles results in the fast acetylator type (18). The
fast acetylator type is seen in between I0 and 90% of
individuals, depending on ethnic origin. In Caucasians, -:45%
of individuals are fast acetylators. Unlike some of the other
polymorphisms suggested to be relevant to colorectal cancer,
for which there is no mechanistic explanation, it is clear that
NAT2 has a role in heterocyclic amine metabolism. The
other human N-acetyitransferase NAT1 has also now been
demonstrated to exhibit polymorphism (19) with the NAT!*IO
allele encoding rapid metabolism. The one study reported so
far suggests that the NATI*IO allele confers susceptibility to
colorectal cancer with an odds ratio of 1.9 (20).
There have been a number of previous studies on the
NAT2 polymorphism in relation to colorectal cancer or polyp
sasceptibiIity which have yielded conflicting results (21-30).
Part of this inconsistency in results may have arisen from
heterogeneity in risk between individuals or populations. For
example, some of the negative studies have been carded out
in countries with a high rate of fast acetylators and/or a low
incidence of colorectal cancer, where factors other than meat
may be important, such as Japan (21). Several of the positive
studies in areas of high incidence have used phenotyping
methods to determine acetylator status and there is some
evidence that these methods may be influenced by disease or
surgery (31). It seems noteworthy that all of the studies
showing a positive association between fast acetylator status
and colorectal cancer (22,23,25) have used phenotyping
methods, whereas the four genotyping studies (21,24,27,28)
and the three studies on polyps (25,29.30) have revealed no
association.
The study of interactions between dietary intakes and
acetylator slams provides a more powerful method of analysis
and allows dissection of heterogeneity in risk factors between
individuals, Two recent phenotyping studies from the US and
Australia (25,30) have indicated that the combination of the
fast acetylator phenotype and high red meat intake is a
particularly strong risk factor with an odds ratio of 3 (I.0-
13.1) found for consumption of meat in the highest fertile and
fast acetylator status in one study (30). We have investigated
the interaction between diet and acetylator status in a British
population which has a similar genetic background to the US
and Australian patients, but is I/kely to consume a diet with a
lower heterocyctic amine content. We carried out a matched
case-control study relating NAT2 genotype to diet, lifestyle
and other factors, using larger numbers of cases and controls
than in the previous studies.
Materials and methods
Cases
We conducted a pmspectlv¢ case-conu'ol study in the Newcastle and Norda
T~eside health disWicts over a 9 month perind. Two-hundred-and-thi~y-four
incident cases were identified and 33 wer~ excluded because of concurrent
colitis t4). inability to give consent of death before recrakment (9) or
umvilling~ess to pa~icipate (20), 1~aving a total of 201 subjects. Age range
was 38-91 years (median 69) and 58.5% were male. Of the total, 31.5% of
the mmours were in the proximal coina. 37.9% ~ver~ in the distal colon and
30.5% were ia the r~ctum. There was no difference in the median a~ for any
of the three sites or for eider sex. Amongst the female cases a higher
propo~on wer~ proximal (44%) than in the ra~e cases (22%) log ffi 2.78
¢ I.gl-5.53), P = 0.002]. A prior power calculatinn had detemdaed that ia a
matched study design 170 cases were required to detect a 20% difference ia
the NAT2 potymo~phism at the P < 0.0,5 ie~d with 90% confidence.
I352
Controls
Controls (n ffi 174) were individually matched to each ease lbr age and sex,
and were recruited from the eonwaudity by choosing from the patient-llst of
the general practitioner which their matebed ease attended. This method of
recmitment was used to control fur social class and differences in diet between
different sub-popuIadon~ in our area. Ninety-nine per earn of cases and
controls were of Caucasian origin.
Dietary and personal factors
Diet in the year before interview was assessed by a food fmquancy questinn-
nalre which focused on focd~ known to have a Idgh hetetocyelic atone
content, The principaI food items assessed were the frequency of consump~on
of red meal bacon, sausages, chicken, fish, brown gravy, fried, gtilIed or
masted meat of my kind, and whether animal or vegetable fat was used for
cooking. Questions on other food item~ were ineinded to obscure the hypothesis
being t~sted, but the questionnaire was not subjected to_fofmal validation
procedures. Cigarette smok.e~ were classified as ex-smokers of more or less
than 5 years or as current smokers in the categories. 1-t0, tl-20 and >20
per day. Pipe and cigar smokers were classtfiad separately.
NA~2 geno~Ttng
Venous blood was taken t~om each subject and DNA was prepared by standard
methodology. Geno~ype for HAT2 was detera~ed by a PCR-restric~on digest
method that detec~ ~ 97% of slo~v acetylators in Caucasia~ pol:~Iations. PC~
was performed using primers NatHnI# and Haft-In 16 as described by t-Iickmaa
and Sire (32). The a~eles NAT2*SA a~d NAT2*$B were detected ~y digest of
this PCR product with the ms~ctio~ enzyme KpnL NAT*6A was detected
by digest with TaqL and NAT~TB was detected ~vith BamI~. Digas~on was
performed for >3 h at 37~C for Kpl~rl and BamHI, and at 65~C for ~-qI. ~'he
prodnc~s of the three separate digests were run on 2.5% agaruse gels.., stained
with ethidi~m bron~de and visnaJ.ized on a UV tra~illua~aator.
Stattsttcol analysis
l~ast acetylators are defined as havin~ one or two wild-type "alleles, and slow
ecetylators as having none. All dietary and genotype data were diehtomlzad.
and the proportions between cases and eontm/s were compared by McNemers
test for comparison of matched p~2rs. Comparison~ between sub-groups of
c~es uti~ chl-squa~d testing.
Results
NAT2 results
Analysis by McNemars test showed that there was no signific-
ant difference between" eases and matched controls in the
proportion of individuals with the fast acetylator status. The
fast acetylator genotype was present in 42% of cases and
42.5% of controls [OR = 0.95 (95% CI 0.61-1.49)3 (Table I).
No significant differences in the proportions of fast acetylators
was found when cases and individually matched controls were
compared by McNemars test for each of the three age groups,
when each sex was examined alone or when the location of
the tumours was divided into proximal and distal colon and
rectum. Data are given in TabIe I. There was no difference in
the proportion of fast aeetylators between patients with Dukes
stage A or B (43.5%) and patients with Dukes C and "D'
(35.7%) [OR = 1.38 (0.72-2.66)].
Dietary data
Dietary data were converted to binary variables in two categor-
ies to enable testing by McNemars test. The categories were
consumption more than twice a week or tess than twice a
3yeek, and consumption once or more a week or less than once
a week. Seventeen variables were examined, but overall the
only statistically significant variables W_e_re_ the consumption
• of fried meat more than twice a week [OR = 3.0 (1.37-~7.25)],
the regular use of animal fat products in cooking [OR. -- 1.68
(1.0-2.88)] and smoking cigarettes within the Iast 5 years
[OR = 1.77 (1.03-3.I4)]. Comparison between eases at each
site with their individually matched controls revealed some
heterogeneity in risk factors for each site (see TabIe II). For
....... the proximal colon consumption of roast meat [OR --" 3.0
This article is for individual use only and may not be further reproduced or stored electronically
without written
permission from the copyright holder. Unauthorized reproduction may result in financial and other
penalties.
(c) OXFORD UNIV PRESS ENGLAND

Susceptibility to colorectal cancer
Table L Distribution of the fast acetylator status in cases and thdr
individually matched controls overall, in three age groups, by gender and by
site
Age Cases Controls Odds ratio
Overall 731174 (42%) 75/174 (42.5%) 0.95 (0.61-1.~9)
<65 years 21/45 (46.7%) 19/45 (42.35) 1.22 (0,46-334)
6~-75 3~82 (41..5%) 40/82 (48.8%) 0.78 (0.42-1.43)
>75 18/47 (38.3%) 16/47 (34%) 1.25 (0.44-3.6)
Men 41/102 (40.2%) 41/I02 (41.2%) I (0.54-1.7)
Women 3~72 (44A%) 33/72 (45.8%) I (0.43-2.02)
Proximal 21151 (41,2%) 27151 (52.9%) 0.66 (0.29-1.47)
Distal 25162 (40.3%) 27162 (43.6%) 0.85 (0.36-2.0)
Rectal 20/48 (41.(5%) 16/48 (33%) 1.4 (0.58-3.5)
Odds ratios and confidence intervals calculated by McNemar~ test.
The site w~ not available for all cases.
(1.14-9.23)] or gravy at least once a week [OR = 2.83 (1.07-
8.78)] and gravy at least twice a week [OR -- 3.2 (1.11-
1t.2)], and regular use of animal fat in cooking [OR = 3.0
(1.14-10.5)] were all significant risk factors, but there were
no significant differences in any of the dietary factors, alcohol
intake or smoking status between the distal cases or rectal
cases and their individually matched controls. Comparison of
each sex with their individually matched controls gave similar
results to the overall dietary analysis.
Comparison of dietary data by acetylator status in cases
against controls
There was considerable heterogeneity in risk factors between
fast acetylator cases and slow acetylator cases (see Table H)
when analysed by McNemars test. Cigarette smoking within
the last 5 years was found more frequently in the slow
acetylator cases (31/98, 31,8%) than in their individually
matched controls (17/98, 17.3%) [OR -- 2.31 (1.I6-4.6)] as
was drinking >20 units of alcohol a week [OR ~ 2.5 (1.02-
7.29)], but no dietary variables reached significance. In contrast,
fried meat consumption more than twice a week was found
more in the fast acetylator cases (13/72, 18.3%) than in theLr
matched controls (3/72, 4%) [OR -- 6.0 (1.34-55)]. There was
no relationship in fast ac¢tylators with recent smoking. Because
of the small numbers in some of "these sub-groups the confid-
ence intervals are wide.
We also compared the proportions of eases and controls
with combinations of risk factors using chi-squared tested, as
opposed to the use of McNemars test above. This showed that
the combination of fast acetyIator status and fried meat
consumption more than twice a week was found in 7.4% of
cases and 1.7% of controls giving an odds ratio of 6.04 (1.6-
26, P = 0.001) and that the combination of recent smok.ing
and slow acetylator status was found in 17.8% of cases and
7.9% of controls giving an odds ratio of 1.86 (1.0-3.49).
Discussion
In our study, acetylator status alone was not found to be a
risk factor for colorectal cancer. Overall, the most important
environmental factors were frequent consumption of fried meat
and smoking within the last 5 years. Analysis of acetyIator
type revealed heterogeneity in risk factors between slow
acetylators, who appear to be at risk from smoking cigarettes
and high alcohol consumption, and fast acetylators, who we
confirmed to be at risk from frequent meat consumption,
particularly fried.
'lhble II. Dietary risk factors in various sub-groups of cases compared to
individually matched controls using MeNem~rs test
Sub-group Cases Controls Odds ratio (CI)
Proximal colon cancer
Gr~.vy weekly or more 34148 26/48 2.83 (L07-8.8)
Gravy > twice a week 19148 8/48 3.2 (1.11-11.2)
Roast meat weekly or more 38/48 26/48 3.0 (1.14-9.23)
Slow acetylators
Cigarette smoking in past 5 years 31/98 17/98 2,31 (1,16-4.6)
>20 units of alcohol a week 25192 15/92 2.5 (1.02-7,29)
Fast acetylators
Fried meat > twice a week 13/72 3/72 6,0 (1.34-55)
The first two studies which examined the relationship
between fast acetylator status and colorectal cancer found
.highly significant associations (22,23), but both of these studies
were very small, and in both the frequency of the fast acetylator
type in the control group was below that expected in Caucasian
communities, so they are perhaps best regarded as pilot
studies. Two larger studies from America and Australia (25,30),
involving both patients w~th colorectal adenomas and cancers,
have shown a significant interaction between meat intake
and the fast acetylator phenotype as risk factors for disease
susceptibility. However, several studies that have only analysed
acetylator type have proved negative, both in countries with a
high incidence of colorectal adenomas and cancer (27,29) and
those with a low incidence (21,26).
Our study reveals some other possible confounding factors
in the analysis of dietary/moleeular-epidemiological studies of
colorectal cancer. In particular, our finding that smoking was
a risk factor in slow acetylators is a new and potentially
important finding as there is a possible mechanistic explanation
and because a recent study has shown that slow acetylators
who smoke are at increased risk of breast cancer (33).
Arylamines in tobacco smoke, such as 4-aminobiphenyl (ABP),
have been recognized as occupational bladder carcinogens for
many years. Unlike heterocyclic amines, which undergo O-
acet~lation to a more active carcinogen, ABP is detoxicated
by N-acetylation, and it is known that slow acetylators are at
greater risk of both occupational and smoking-related bladder
cancer (34). There has been conflicting evidence for the role
of smoking as a risk factor for colorectal cancer previously
(7) and our study may help to explain some of the heterogeneity
in risk factors between populations. In addition, recent cohort
studies have suggested that there is increased risk of small
adenomatous poIyps after 20 years, of large polyps after 20-
30 ~/6ars and of cancer after only 35 years of smoking (35).
There is, therefore, increasing evidence for the aetiological
role of smoking in some cases of eolorectal cancer.
Our study suggests that some of the population may be at
risk of colorectal cancer if they smoke or drink heavily, and
conffmas that the rest are at an even greater risk from eating
fried meat. Most importantiy, however, our study has shown
that in the population of the north-east of England the overall
effect of acetylator status is neutral.
Acknowledgement
This work was supported by a grant from the North of E~gland Cancer
Research Campaign.
1353
This article is for individual use only and may not be further reproduced or stored electronically
without written
permission from the copyright holder..Unauthorized reproduction may result in financial and other
penalties.
(c) OXFORD UNIV PRESS ENGLAND

M.R.'~Vell'are et al.
References
l.Potterj.D.. Slattery, M., Bosfick,R.M. and Gapsmr, S.M. 0993) Colon
c~ncer: a review of the epidemiology. Ep[demial. Re~:. 15, 499-545.
2. Haesnzel,W., Berg,L, Segi,M. and Lee,tLK.C. (1973) Large bowel cancer
in Hawaiian Japanese. 3". Nail Cancer Inst.. 51, 1765-1779.
3.Armstrong,B. and Dofi,R. (1975) Env/roamentol factors and cancer
incidence and mortafity in different countries, with speclal reference to
dietary practices. Int. J. Cancer. l& 617-63I.
4.Willet't,W.C.. Stamp(oriel J., Colditz.G.A.o RosnanB.A. and Sperzer, F.E.
(1990) Relation of meat and fiber intake to the risk of colon cancer in a
prospective study among women. N. EngL J. Med., 323, 1664-1672.
5.Gerhardason de Verdier.M., I.-Iagman.U., Peters,R.K., Steineck,G. and
Overik,E. (1991) Meat, cooking methods and coloreetai cancer:, a case-
referent study in Stockbolm. Int. Z Cancer. 49, 520-525.
6.Longaeeker.M.P. 0990) A case-control study of alcoholic beverage
consumption in relation to risk of colon cancer and the recv.mL Cancer
Ceases Control, 1, 5-14.
7.Newcomb,P.A., Storer, B.E. and Marcus.P.M. ¢ t995) Cigarette smoking in
relation to risk of large bowel cancer in women. Cancer Res., 55,
4906-4909.
8.Gross,G.A., Taresky, RJ., Fay,LB., Stlilweli,W.G., Skipper.P2_. and
Tannenbaum.S.R. (I993) Heterocyclie aromatic amine formation in grilled
bacon, beef and fish and in grill scrapings. Cawinogenesis, 14, 2313-2318.
9.Sugimu.ra,T., Sato,S. and Wakabasl~,K. (1988) Mutageas/carcinogens in
pyrolysates of amino acids and proteins in cooked foods: heterocyclic
amines. In Woo, Y.T.. Lai,D.Y, Areosd.C. and Arg~s,M.F. (eds), Chemical
Acetylalion phenotype in colorectai carcinoma. Cancer Res., 47, 1466-
t469.
2.3.Langdq.P.. Chu.D.Z.J., Hunter, C.F., Kendall.D.C.. Flammang,TJ. and
Kadinbar, F.F. (1986) Role of aromatic amine acetyl~'ansferase in human
colorectai cancer. Arch. Sm~.. 121, I259-'[26I.
24.Rodriguez,LW., K.h-IIn0W.G., Ferguson,RJ., DolI.M.A., Gray,K,
Rnstan,T.D., Lee.M.E., Kemp.K., Urso,P. and HeimD.W. (1993) He.man
acetylator genotype: relationship to eolorectai qance.r_, incidence and
atylamine N-acetyltransfemse expression in colon eytosol. Arcl~ ToxicoL,
67, 445~.5 I.
25. Robexts-Thomson.L C.. RyamP.. Khoo,K.K., Harl.Wj., MeMiehael,AJ. and
Bntler, R.N. (1996) Die~. acetylator phenotype, and risk of eolorectal
neoplasia. Lancet. 347. i1372-1374.
26, Laderoj.M., GonzaiezJ.F., Beaiter.~., Vargas,F-, Femandez,M.2., Baki,W.
and Diaz-Rubio,M. O991) Acetylator polymorphism in human coloreeml
carcinoma. Cancer Res.,.~l, 2098-2100.
27.Spm'r2,LK.. Gough,A.C., Chinegwundoh,EL and Dale-Smith,C.A. (1995)
PoIymorphisms in drug.metabolizing enzymes as modifiers of ~mcer risk.
Clin. Chem.. 41. 1864-1869.
28. Oda,~ Tanaka,M. and Nakm'~hi,L (/994) Relation between the occa~rence
of K-ras gone point mutations and genotypes of polymorpb2c N-
acetyltransferase in human coloreetal carcinomas. Carcinogotes'.ts, 15.
1365-1369.
29.Probst-Hensch,N.M., Haile,R.W., Ingles,S.A. et al. (I995) A.eetylation
pelymoxphisra and prevalence of colorectal adenomas. Cancer Res., 55.
2017-2020.
30.Lang,N.P., Butier, M.A.. MassengiIl,L, Lawson,M, Stotts~R.C., Honer-
Induction of Cahoot; StT~wtaral Basis attd Biological Mechcmisms.
Jensen,M. and Kadluber, EE gI994) Rapid metabolic phenotypes for
Aeaderaic Press, New York, N'Y, pp. 681-710 ............
aeetyltransferase and cytocbxome P450IA2 and putative exposure ~o food-
10.Ito, N., Hasegawa,.R., Sano,M.0 Tamano,S., Esumi,H~, Takff~ama,S. and
Sugimara,T. (1991) A new eolon and mammaxy earoinogea in cooked
food. ~ CarchmgeneMs, 12, I503-1506.
ll.Skog.K., SteinecLG., Angnstssonor~L and Jagerstad,M. (1995) Effect of
cooking temperatures on the formation ot" heteroq~elic amines in fried
meat products and pan residues. Carctno&enesis, 16, 861-867.
12.Gooderham,NJ., Murray, S., Ly~ch,A. et aL (1996) Heteroeyelie amines:
evaluation of theh" role in diet associated human cancer. Bn J. Cl~n.
PhmvnacoL. -12. 91-98.
13. Kalduchi,H.. War ansbe,M., UsMjima,T., Toyota,M, Imai,I,L.
WeisburgerJ.H., Sugimara,T. and Nagao,M. (1995) Spe¢i~c 5'-GGGA-3'
to 5'..C, GA-3' mutation of the Ape gone in rat colon tumors induced by
2-amino-l-methyl-6-phenylimldazo[4,5-b]pyridine. Prec. Natl Aca~ Sol.
USA, 94, 910-914.
14.PowelLS.M., Zilz,N.. Beaz~'-Barelay, Y., Bryan,TdVl., H.amiltan,$.R.,
Thibodeau,S.N., Vogelstdn,B. and Kinzler, K.W. (1992) APC mutations
occur early daring eoloreetal carcinogenesis. Nature. 3S9, 235-237.
IS.Turesky, RJ., Lang24.P., Bufler, M.A., T~itol,C.I-I. and Kadinbar,F.F. (199I)
Metabolic activation of eareinoganic heteroeyclic aromatic amines by
human liver and colon. Carcinogenesis, 13, I307-1314.
I6.MinehinoR.F., Reeves,P.T., Teitel,Cd-L, Memanns,M.E., Mojarrabi,B.,
lllet,K.E and Kadlubat, EE (1992) N- and O-acetylation of aromatio and
heteroeyelte amine carcinogens by haman monomorphie and ~Iymorpttic
acetyltransferases expressed in COS-I ceils. Blochem. Biophys. Res.
Comnnm., 18~, 839-844.
17. LimD., Meyer, DJ, Ketterer, B., Lang,N.P. and Kadlubar, F.F. (1994) Effects
of httman and rat glutati~one S-transferases on the covalent binding of
the N-acetoxy derivatives of heteroeyeHc araine careinogans in vitro: a
possible meohantsm of organ specificity ia their carcinogenesis. Cancer
Res,. ~4, 4920-4926.
18.Vetsisd(.R, ~,hrtetl,K2. and Weber, W.W. (1991) Diverse point mutations
tn the ~uman gone fox polymoxphio N-acetyltransferase. Proc. Natl Acad.
SoL USA, 88, 6333-6337.
lg.BelLD.A.. Badawi,A.F., Lang,N.P.o Ilett.K.F., Kadhtbar~EE and
Hirvonan,A. (1995) Polymorphism in the N-acetylwansferase 1 (NAT1)
polyadanylation signal: assoaiation of NAT*t0 allele ¢.~.th higl~er N-
acetylation activity in bladder and colon tissue. Cancer Res., ~o 59,26-
5229.
20.BelI,D.A., Stepliens,lE.A., Castriano,T., Umbach,D.M., Watson~M.o
D~lkindV[., Elder, J,, Hen&ickse,C., Dunean0H. and Strang~R.C. (1995)
Polyadenylation polyraorphism in the acetyltransferase i gone (NATI)
increases risk of eoloreetai cancer. Cancer Res., 5& 3537-3542.
21.Shibu~a,K.. Nakashlma,T., Abe,M., Mashimo,M.. Mori,M., Ueo,H.,
Akiyoshi,T., Sugimachi,K. and Sttzuki,T. (I994) Molecular genotyping for
NAg polymoxphism in Japanese patients with colore~tal cancer. Cancer,
74. 3108-3112.
22.tlett,K.E, Beverley, M.D., Detehon,P., Cestieden,W.M. and Kwa, R. (1987)
borne heterncyclic araines increase the dsk of coiorectal,canc~ ox polyps,
Cancer Epldemlol. Biami~r~brs Prevent., 3, 6752-682.
31 .Welfare.M.R., Bassendine,M.l::. and Daly, A.K. (1996) Caffeine p/~anotyping
-- in patients with familial adenonmtous polyposis may shed l~ght on sporadic
colon cancer and aeetylator slams. Gut. 38, 153.
32.Hiekman,D. and Sim.E. (1990) N-ac~tyl~ransfemse polymo~phism:
comparison of phenotype and genot'Yl~ in humans. Biochem. PharmacoL,
42, 1007-1014.
33.Ambrosons,C.B.. Frenderheimd.L., Graham,S" et al. (1996) C~arette
smoking, N-acetyltransferase 2 genetic polymmpMsm~ and breast cancer
ris'L J. Am. Med. Assoc, 276, 1494--I501.
34.Risch,A., Waiinoe.D.M..g.~ "Bather~,S. and Sim.E. (t995) Slow N-
acetylation is a risk factor in occapaflonal and smoking-related btadder
cancer. Hton. MoL Goner., 4, 231-236.
35.Giovannucei,E., Coldtiz,O.A.. Stampfer, M.l., I~anter.D.. Rosne'~B.A..
W'dlett,W.C. and Speizer,F.E. (I994) A prospective study of cigarette
smoking and risk of colorectal adenoma and cancer in U.S. women. J. Natt
Cancer Inst., 86, 192-199.
Receh,ed January 16. 1997: revised on March 3, 1997. accepted on
March 14. 1997
1354
This article is for individual use only and may not be further reproduced or stored electronically
without wdtten
permission from the copyright holder. Unauthorized reproduction may result in financial and other
penalties.
(c) OXFORD UNIV PRESS ENGLAND
