Philip Morris
'secondhand Cigarette Smoke Affects Blood Platelets, in A Way Which Increases the Likelihood of A Thrombus.' (Page 10)
Fields
- Author
- O, K.H.
- O, M.W.
- Type
- REPT, REPORT, OTHER
- BIBL, BIBLIOGRAPHY
- Site
- R530
- Characteristic
- EXTR, EXTRA
- ILLE, ILLEGIBLE
- MARG, MARGINALIA
- ILLE, ILLEGIBLE
- Named Organization
- Epa, Environmental Protection Agency
- Paf
- Litigation
- Iwoh/Produced
- Master ID
- 2063633034/3485
Related Documents:- 2063633034-3485 Book 6 Tabs 1 - 39
- 2063633036-3041 Environment and Cancer: Who Are Susceptible ?
- 2063633043-3050 Risk Factors for Primary Lung Cancer Among Non-Smoking Women in Taiwan
- 2063633052-3058 Air Pollution and Respiratory Health Among Children with Asthmatic or Cough Symptoms
- 2063633060-3067 Human Cancer Syndromes: Clues to the Origin and Nature of Cancer
- 2063633069-3073 Genetic Testing for Cancer Risk
- 2063633075-3080 Oncogenic Transcription Factors in the Human Acute Leukemias
- 2063633082-3086 Nucleic Acid-Based Methods of the Detection of Cancer
- 2063633088-3093 Original Paper Vegetable and Fruit Intake and the Risk of Lung Cancer in Women in Ain Barcelona, Spain
- 2063633095-3098 P53 Mutations in Human Head and Neck Cancer Cell Lines
- 2063633100-3109 People, Places and Coronary Heart Disease Risk Factors: A Multilevel Analysis of the Scottish Heart Health Study Archive
- 2063633111-3116 Sex Differences in Up-Regulation of Nicotinic Acetylcholine Receptors in Rat Brain
- 2063633118-3125 Risk Factors and Sex Differential in Coronary Artery Disease
- 2063633127-3135 the Causes and Prevention of Cancer Gaining Perspective
- 2063633137-3141 Socioeconomic Status, Number of Siblings, and Respiratory Infections in Early Life As Determinants of Atopy in Children
- 2063633143-3153 Biomonitoring Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke (Ets) : A Critical Reappraisal
- 2063633249-3258 A Case-Control Study of Cytochrome P450 1a1, Glutathione S-Transferase M1, Cigarette Smoking and Lung Cancer Susceptibility (Massachusetts, United States)
- 2063633260-3266 Is Meta-Analysis A Valid Approach to the Evaluation of Small Effects in Observational Studies?
- 2063633268-3277 Childhood Asthma in Four Regions in Scandinavia: Risk Factors and Avoidance Effects
- 2063633279-3291 Lung Cancer
- 2063633293-3303 National Incidence of Smoking and Misclassification Among the U.S. Married Female Population
- 2063633305-3311 Fatty Foods and the Risk of Lung Cancer: A Case-Control Study From Uruguay
- 2063633313-3351 Tobacco Smoking
- 2063633353-3362 Smoking and Lung Cancer: Risk As A Function of Cigarette Tar Content
- 2063633364-3372 Tar Content of Cigarettes in Relation to Lung Cancer
- 2063633374-3378 Comments on : Law, M.R. Et Al., (970000) << Environmental Tobacco Smoke Exposure and Ischaemic Heart Disease: An Evaluation of the Evidence. >> Bmj, 970000, 315(7114) :980
- 2063633379
- 2063633380-3381 Comments on the Paper: 'environmental Tobacco Smoke Exposure and Ischaemic Heart Disease: An Evaluation of the Evidence'
- 2063633390-3392 Stanton Glantz Claims
- 2063633393-3425 'environmental Tobacco Smoke Exposure and Ischaemic Heart Disease: An Evaluation of the Evidence'
- 2063633426-3433 Environmental Tobacco Smoke Exposure and Ischaemic Heart Disease: An Evaluation of the Evidence. The Accumulated Evidence on Lung Cancer and Environmental Tobacco Smoke
- 2063633435-3471 Placental Toxicology
- 2063633472-3474 Placental Toxicology
- 2063633476-3484 Lung Carcinoma Trends by Histologic Type in Vaud and Neuchatel, Switzerland, 740000 - 790000
- Named Person
- Benviste
- Burghuber
- Davis
- Feuerstein
- Humphrey
- Imaizumi
- Jackson
- Kenzora
- Levi
- Mehta
- Miyaura
- Ostermann
- Piper
- Pittilio
- Saeki
- Sinzinger
- Stahl
- Steinberg
- Sun
- Zhu
- Liesy, T.
- Burghuber
- Area
- CARCHMAN,RICHARD/OFFICE
- Date Loaded
- 07 Jun 1999
Document Images
3,1110 '97 14:48 "~+49 2203 303362 INBIF0 Koeln
~ FTR S&T
15.$ep,g˘ KHO/MWO X:\MWO\MISC\GLANKHO.DOC PAGE 1
~004
"Secondhand c/garotte smoke affects blood platelets, in a way which increases the
likelihood of a thrombus." (page 1 O)
This statement refers to Davis et el. (1989) who found a statistical significant decrease
for the platelet aggregate ratio before and after ETS exposure which led to 2,8 ng/ml
plasma nicotine concentration and an increase of 0.4 % in the carboxyhemoglobin
level. According to Davis et al "a decrease in the platelet aggregate ratio reflects an
increased formation of platelet aggregates". Burghuber et el. (1986) and Sinzinger et
el. (1982) exposed volunteers to 20 rain and 60 rain, respectively, in an 18-m~ room
where 30 heavy brand cigarettes (Gitanes, 1.5 mg nicotine, 25 mg tar) had been
smoked just p,~i~,r_~ the exposure period. They found a significantly lowered platelet
sensitivity to t~e'~,~gregatory effect of prostacyclln. They concluded that "this finding at
least suggests that platelets of nonsmokers passively exposed to tobacco smoke might
also exhibit a higher tendency to aggregate".
Corn lent:
These are findings with unclear biological significance.
Davis et el. (1989): "The significance of enhanced platelet aggregate formation .... in.
blood after passive smoking is not known".
Burghuber et el. (1986): "Further investigation is needed to elucidate whether this
finding (lowered platelet sensitivity) is important with respect to a possible increased
incidence of thromboembolic disease among non-smokers passively exposed to
cigarette smoke."
References:
Davis, J.W., Shelton, L., Watanabe, I.S., Arnold, J., Passive smoking affects
gndothelium and platelets, Arch Intern Med, 149, 386-389, 1989
Burghuber, O.C., Punzengruber, Ch., Sinzinger, H., Haber, P., Silberbauer, K., Platelet
sensitivity to prostacyclln in smokers and non-smokers, Chest 90,1, 34-38, 1986
Sinzinger, H., Kefalides, A., Passive smoking severely decreases platelet sensitivity to
antiaggregatory prostaglandines, Lancet 2, 392-398, 1982

31/10 '97 14:48
~'+49 2203 303362 INBIFO Koeln -~- FTR S&T
15.Sep.94 KHO/MWO X:\MWO\MI$~GI.ANKHO.DOC PAGI= 2
"The platelet activation factor itseff can damage the lining of the coronary arteries and
"facilitate the development of atherosclerotic lesions." (page 10)
and
"The toxins in the cigarette smoke increase platelet activation factor by interfering with
the activity of the plasma enzyme platelet activating factor acetylhydrolase PAF-AH."
(page 12)
The coronary effects of PAF are described to be complex (Feuerstein et el,, 1989;
Benviste et el., 1983; Kenzora et el., 1984; Levi et el., 1984; Saeki et el., 1984; Stahlet
el., 1987; Piper et el., 1986; Piper st el., 1987; Feuerstein eta[., 1984; Mshta st el.,
1986; Jackson st el., 1986) and include the beneficial effect of vasodilation. Direct
damage by PAF to endothelial ceils is construed by disruption of endothelial
Junctions and vacuolization (Humphrey et el., 1984).
PAF acetylhydrolase PAF-AH may regulate PAF concentration by catalyzing PAF
degradation, The inhibition of PAF-AH activity by cigarette smoke extract in a dose
dependent manner was demonstrated by M[yaura et el, (1992) in an in vitro
experiment. This finding is discussed by the authors as a possible explanation for the
increase of PAF in the plasma of smokers (imaizumi et el.1, 1989). In athercacleroti˘
patients, however, PAF-AH activity was increased (Ostermann et el., 1987).
Commer~t;
The significance of the observed changes in PAF and PAF-AH actMty for
atherosclerotic changes and cardiovascular disease remains to be clarified. There are
no data on ETS exposure and blood levels of PAF and PAF-AH in the literature to
substantiate a possible link.
R_e_ferences:
Feuerstein, G.Z., PAF and the cardiovascular system from Platelet activating factor and
human disease ed. by P.J. Bames, C.P. Page & P.M. Hanson, Blackwel[ S˘ientlfic
Publications, Oxford, 1989
Benviste, J., Boullet, C., Brink, C., Labat, C., The action of PAF-acether (platelet
activating factor) on guinea pig isolated heart preparations, Br J Pharmacol, 80, 81-83,
1983
Kenzora, J.L., Perez, J.E., Bermann, S.R., Large, L., Effects of ace~ylglycerylether-
phosporylcholine (platelet activating factor) on ventricular preload, afterload and
contractility in dogs, J Clin Invest, 74, 1193-1203, 1984

~1110 '97 14:~9 '~+49 2203 30~62 INBIFO Koeln ~
FTR S&T
15.$ep.94 KHO/MWO X:\MWO\MISC\GLANKHO.DOC
PA~315 3
~006
Levi, R., Burke, J.A., Guo, Z.G. et el., Acetylglyceryletherphosporylcholine (AGEPC). A
putative mediator of a cardiac anaphylaxis in the guinea pig, Ciro. Res. 54, 117-124,
1984
Saeki, S., Masugi, F., Ogihara, R. et el., Effects of 1-O-alkyl-acetyl-glycero-3-
phosphorcholine (platelet activating factor) on cardiac function in perfused guinea pig
heart, Life S˘i., 37, 325-330, 1985
Stahl, G.L., Lefer, D.J., Lefer, A.M., PAF-aether induced cardiac dysfunction in the
isolated perfused guinea pig heart, Arch Pharma˘ol 336, 459, 1987
Piper, P., Stewart, A.G., Coronary vasoconstriction in the rat isolated perfused heart
induced b.y platelet-activating factor is mediated by leukotriene C,, Br J Pharmacol,
881,595-605, 1986
Feuerstein, G., Boyd, L.H., Azra, D., Goldstein, R.E., Effects of platelet activating factor
on coronary circulation of the domestic pig, Am J Physiol, 246, H466-H471, 1984
Mehta, J., Wargovich, T., Nichols, W.W., Biphasic effects of platetet-activating facor on
coronary blood flow in the anesthetized dog, Prostaglandins Leukotdenes Med, 21, 87-
95, 1986
Jackson, C.V., Sohumacher, W.A., Kunket, S.L., Ddsoll, E.M., Pope, T.K., Lucchesi,
B.P., Platelet activating factor release of a platelet-derived coronary artery vasodilator
substance in the canine, Cric Res 58, 218-229, 1986
Humphrey, D.M., McManus, I_M., Hanahan, D.J., Pinckard, R.N., Morphological basis
of Increased vascular permeability induced by acetyl-glyceryl ether phosphoryloholine,
Lab Invest, 50, 16-25, 1984
Mlyaura, S., Eguchi, H,, Johnston, J.M., Effect of a cigarette smoke extract on
themetabolism of the proinflammatory autocoid, platelet-activating factor, Circulation
Research 70, 341-347, 1992
lmaizumi, T., lntravascular release of platelet-activating factor.like lipid (PAF-LL)
induced by cigarette smoking, in Proceedings of the Third International Conference on
PIatelet-Activating Factor and Structurally Related Alkyl Upids. Tokyo 1989, 78
Ostermann, G., Ruhllng, K., Zabel-Langhennig, R., Winkler, L., 8chlage, B., Till, U,,
Plasma from atherosclerotic patients exerts an increased degradation of ptatelet-
activating factor, Thromb Res 47, 279-285, 1987

.31/10 '97 14:49 ~+49 220~ ~0~62 INBIFO Koeln ~ FTR $&T
1&Sep.94 KHO/MWO X:\MWO\MISC\GLANKHO.DOC
PAGE;
[~007
"ET$ can increase p/ate/et aggregability to leve/s approaching those observed in
smokers." (page 10)
This statement refers to "several studies in which nonsmokers ar exposed to realistic
levels of environmental tobacco smoke". Corresponding studies are Davis et el., 1989;
Sinzinger et el., 1982; Burghuber et el., 1986, and Sinzinger et el., 1989. In those
studies no explicit platelet aggregabllity, but vadous parameters suitable to
characterize the activity of platelet function were measured. The platelet aggreate ratio
change between pre- and post a 20-min ETS exposure pedod was measured by Davis
et el. (1989) to be about 10 %. However, that result [s dominated by the data of one
individual (with a platelet aggregate ratio change of about 40 %~lf that outlier is
removed the remaining shift will be about 7 % and of less stati~ical significance, in this
experiment the exposed subjects had plasma nicotine levels of 2.8 ng/ml. In another
study (Davis et el., 1986) habitual smokers had a 17 % reduction in platelet aggregate
ratio after having smoked 2 tobacco cigarettes within 20 minutes. They had plasma
nicotine levels of 19.6 ng/ml, Non-smokers with the same exposure had a 11%
reduction in platelet aggregate ratio and 4.1 ng/ml plasma nicotine.
Comment:
In relation to the plasma nicotine concentration non-smokers showed comparable
platelet aggregate ratio reduction after ETS exposure and after active smoking. In this
single acute exposure experiment they were about 3 times as sensitive as habitual
smokers after active smoking.
R.,eferenqes;
Davis, J.W., She!ton, L., Watanabe, 1.S., Arnold, J., Passive smoking affects
endothelium and platelets, Arch Intern Med, 149, 386-389, 1989
Burghuber, O.C., Punzengruber, Ch., Sinzinger, H., Haber, P., Silberbauer, K., Platelet
sensitivity to prostacyclIn in smokers and non-smokers, Chest 90,1,34-38, 1986
Sinzinger, H., Virgolini, I., Besitzen Passivraucher sin erhShtes Thromboserisiko?,
Wiener klin Wochenschrfft, 101, 20, 694-698, 1989
Davis, J.W., Shelton, L, Hartman, C.R., Eigenberg, D.A., Ruttinger, H.A., Smoking-
induced changes in endothelium and platelets are not affected by
hydroxyethylrutosides, Br J exp Path 67, 765-771, 1986

31/10 '97 14:~0 "~+49 2203 30~362 INBIFO Koeln
~ FTR S&T
15.Sep.9,~ KHO/MWO X:\MWO\MISC\GLANKHO,DOC PAGE 4
~008
"Both active and passive smoking increase the aggregation of platelets and thus the
likelihood of thrombus formation at myocardial infarction and, through platelet activation,
they increase the chances of developing atherosclero$i@. (page 10)
This statement summarizes the first passage on page 10 and refers to the findings of
Pittil[o et el., 1982; Davis et el, 1989; Sinzinger et el., 1982; Burghuber et el., 1986, and
Steinberg et el., 1989.
C, omment: (in addition to the points already made on page 1 to 3):
The postulated link of platelet activation and myocardial infarction or atherosclerosis is
discussed in the cited literature in terms of a biological rationale to be clarified by future
experiments, in particular there are no data in the cited literature to underline a causal
relationship between ETS exposure, ptatelet activation, and myocardial infarction or
R~fer.e..nces:
Pi~lio, R.M., Mackle, l.J., Rowle-~, P.M., Machine, S.J., Wootf, N., Effects of cigarette
smoking on the ultrastructure of rat thoracic aorta and its ability to produce
prostacyolin, Thromb. Haemostas. 48, 173-176, 1982
Davis, J.W., Shelton, L., Watanabe, I.S., Arnold, J., Passive smoking affects
endothel[um and platelets, Arch Intern Mad, 149, 386-389, 1989
Sinzlnger, H., Kefalides, A., Passive smoking severely decreases piatelet sensitivity to
anttaggregatory prostaglandines, Lancet 2, 392-393, 1982
Burghuber, O.C., Punzengruber, Ch., Sinzinger, H., Haber, P., Silberbauer, K., Platelet
sensitivity to prostacyclin in smokers and non-smokers, Chest 90,1,34-38, 1986
Sinzinger, H., Virgolini, I,, Besitzen Passivraucher ein erhShtes Thromboserisiko?,
Wiener klin Wochenschrift, 101, 20, 694-698, 1989
Steinberg, D., Parthasarathy, S., Carew, T.E., Khoo, J.C., Witztum, J.L., Beyond
cholesterol: Modifications of low.density lipoprotein that increase its atherogenicity, N.
Engl. J. Meal. 320, 915-942, 1989

31/10 '97 14:51 "~+49 2203 303362 IIVBIFO Koeln ~
FTR S&T
15.Sep.94 KHO/MWO X:\MWO\MISC\GLANKHO.DOC PAGE 6
~009
"Nonsmokers are much more sensitive to secondhand smoke than smokers and very
low levels of ETS exposure can have major Impact on nonsmokers' p/atelet activity."
(page 11)
and
"Dose-based extrapolations from smokers to nonsmokers using cigarette equivalents
will grossly underestimate the risks to nonsmokers of breathing secondhand smoke."
(page 11)
These statements refer to results of Davis et el. (1985a, 1985b, 1986, 1987, 1989) and
Burghuber et aL (1986).
Sinzinger et el. (1989) reported effects on platelet function parameters in smokers and
non-smokers after a single 60-mtn exposure in a 18-m= room, where 30 heavy brand
cigarettes (Gitanes, 1.5 mg nicotine, 2.5 mg tar) had been smoked. In this situation most
platelet function parameters showed a change of about one third which in non-smokers
had disappeared after 6 hours. In contrast to the group of smokers, who had already
pathologically shifted basal values for platelet sensitivity prior to exposure, in non-
smokers the influence of a single ETS exposure on platelet sensitivity was much
higher. After 5 days of repeated exposure, however, in non-smokers the basal values
for platelet aggregability already were pathologically disturbed and the basal values for
platelet sensitivity approached those valid for smokers.
00mment:
The postulated higher sensitivity of non-smokers to ETS can only be found in the
magnitude of transient changes in platelet activity and the prostaglandin system after
s~ngular exposures ,of about 1 hour duration. This certainly is not relevant for any
postulated health effect of chronic exposure to ET8. For these situations the data
indicate that there is no difference in sensitivity and thus no reason to discard dose-
based extrapolations from smokers to non-smokers with respect to the interpretation of
their f~ndings Sinzinger et al. (1989) doubt that, because of possible interindividual
differences of tolerance and defense capacity of the platelet function and the
prostaglandin system, a direct proof of a causal relationship between adverse effects
and passive smoking will ever be scientifically possible.
Reference.8:
Davis, J.W., Shelton, L., Eigenberg, D.A., Hignite, C,E., Watanabe, l.S., Effects of
tobacco and non-tobacco cigarette smoking on endothslium and platelets, Clin
Pharmacol Thor, 37, 5, .529-533, 1985
Davis, J.W., Hartman, C.R., Lewis, H.D., Shelton, L., Eigenberg, D.A., Hassanein,
K.M., Hignite, C.E., Rutt~nger, H.A., Cigarette smoking - induced enhancement of
p]atelet function: Lack of prevention by aspirin in men with coronary artery disease, J
Lab Clin Med 105, 479-483, 1985

31/10 '97 14:el '~'+49 2203 303362 INBIFO ~oeln
~ FTR S&T
15.Sep.94 KHO/MWO X:\MWO\MISC\GLANKHO.D OC PAGE 7
~ OlO
Davis, J.W., Shelton, L. Zucker, M.L., A comparison of some acute effects of smoking
and smokeless tobacco on platelets and endothellum, J Vascular Med Biol, 2, 6, 289-
293, 1990
Davis, J.W., Shelton, L., Watanabe, I.S., Arnold, J., Passive smoking affects
endothel[um and platelets, Arch Intern Med, 149, 386-389, 1989
Davis, J.W., Shelton, L, Hartman, C.R., Eigenberg, D.A., Ruttinger, H.A., Smoking-
induced changes in endothelium and platelets are not affected by
hydroxyethylrutosides, Br J exp Path 67, 765-771, 1986
Burghuber, O.C., Punzengruber, Ch., Slnz[nger, H., Haber, P., Siiberbauer, K., Platelet
sensitivity to prcstacyclin in smokers and non-smokers, Chest 90,1, 34-38, 1986
Sinzinger, H., Virgolini, I., Besitz.en Passivraucher ein erhShtes Thromboserisiko?,
Wiener kiln Wochenschrift, 101, 20, 694-698, 1989

220.3 303362
INBIFO Koeln -*~ FTR $&T
1 &Sop.94- KHO/MWO X:\MWO\MISC~GLANKHO.DOC
PAGE 8
Bleeding time is significantly shortened in both rabbits and rats exposed at even the
lowest doses of secondhand smoke. (page i 1)
This study refers to both MS, SS exposure studies with rabbits of ,Sun et al. (1994) and
Zhu et al. (199,3) and with rats (Z.hu et al., 1994). In the rabbit studies in the high dose
group total particulate concentrations was about 30 mg/m3 and in the low dose group
4 mg/m~, In both studies there was a statistical significant shortening of bleeding time.
However, in the same studies platelet aggregate ratio did not show any statistical
significant difference between exposed and control group. According to Zhu etal.
(1993) "platelet aggregate ratio at week 12 in the high ETS group was borderline_ lower
than the control level (p ,, 0.07).
In rats exposure RSP concentration were 18 mg/mz. Also in this experiment there was a
statistical significant difference in bleeding time between exposed and control groups.
However, this was independent of duration of ETS exposure (Zhu et al., 1994). In this
study, there was also no r.~rrelation between infarct size and bleeding time.
Com.m~_ent:
Even the lowest dose of 4 rag/n1~ TPM was about 80 times above the U,S, National
Ambient Air Quality Standard and 40 times above EPA's claimed maximum average
ETS concentration in homes and offices. The limited significance of changes in the
platelet aggregate ratio makes mediation of effects via altered platelet function
questionable. The finding that there is no correlation between, infarct size and bleeding
time reduces the biological significances of this parameter.
References:
Sun, Y., Zhu, B., Sievers, R.E., Glantz, S.A., Parmley, W.W., Metoprolol does not
attenuate atherosclerosis in lipid-fed rabbits exposed to environmental tobacco smoke,
Circulation, 89, 2260-2265, 1994
Zhu, B., Sun, Y., Sievers, R.E., Isenberg, W.M., Glantz_, S.A., Parrnley, W.W., Passive
smoking increases experimental atherosclerosis in cholesterol-fed rabbits, J Am Coil •
Cardiol 21,225-232, 1993
Zhu, B., Sun, Y., Sievers, R.E., Glantz, S.A., Parmley, W.W., Wolfe, C.L., Exposure to
environmental tobacco smoke increases myocardial infarct size in rats, Circulation, 89,
1282-1290, 1994
