Philip Morris
Philip Morris Magazine
Fields
- Type
- MAGA, MAGAZINE ARTICLE
- Area
- RAMSAY,JIM/CARLSTADT
- Master ID
- 2040235185/5222
Related Documents: - Request
- Stmn/R2-039
- Site
- N334
- Litigation
- Stmn/Produced
- Author (Organization)
- Hearst Professional Magazine
- Philip Morris Magazine
- PM, Philip Morris
- Philip Morris Magazine
- Date Loaded
- 05 Jun 1998
- UCSF Legacy ID
- pag04e00
Document Images
A Letter From the P'ublisher
elcome to the
first issue of
Philip Morris
Magazine, the
colorful quarterly that puts you in touch with
the world of Philip Morris.
You may be wondering just what this "world"
encompasses, and the answer is not a simple
one. As Philip Morris has grown over the past
century, so too has its commitment to its
consumers and to the community at large.
The company's commitments are reflected in
the vast array of programs Philip Morris
supports, ranging from large-scale art exhibits
to ground-breaking support for women's sports
to dozens of smaller-scale community projects
across the country. But perhaps most important
is Philip Morris's commitment to the tobacco
industry and to the 55 million Americans who
enjoy tobacco products. This magazine is
designed to share these programs with you and
to encourage your participation and enjoyment.
Philip Morris Magazine will cover both
countryside and cityscape: in this inaugural issue
we'll take you down to Randolph County, North
Carolina, and a tobacco farm where the work is
truly a family affair. Then we'll head north for a
walk down New York City's fabulous 42nd
Street. Our tour of this famous thoroughfare
will explain its glittering past, highlight the
architectural delights of its present (including
Philip Morris headquarters, the lobby of which
houses a branch of the Whitney Museum of
Art), and fill you in on plans for 42nd Street's
future.
Also in this issue, we'Il provide you with some
food for thought on the subject of smokers' rights,
including legislative threats that we believe will
affect all Americans' liberties. We'll look, for
example, at the regressive nature of excise taxes
by interviewing distinguished economist Ingo
Walter on the subject.
We'll also ramble through Marlboro Country,
America's great Southwest, a rugged region with
its own brand of beauty. Then, moving from
wide-open spaces to sophisticated places, we'll
give you a behind-the-scenes look at the
blockbuster exhibit "The Vatican Collections:
The Papacy and Art." We'11 show you a side of
this extraordinarily successful show that few out-
siders saw: that of the men and women who
actually cleaned, packed, shipped, and arranged
the priceless works of art-the people who really
made it happen.
Then we'll take you behind the scenes to an
entirely different kind of "happening": the filming
of the celebrity-studded Lite Beer from Miller
commercials. You'll read about how this super-
successful ad campaign got its start, meet some
of the former sportsmen who star-and share
some of the on-the-set high jinks.
If you enjoy tennis-either on the courts or
from the stands-you'll want to read our guide
to the newest names on the Virginia Slims Circuit,
the young women to watch in 1985. You'll meet
Pam Casale, 21 and already working on a
comeback; six-foot-one-and-a-half-inch Helena
Sukova; and Zina Garrison, the first black
woman to hold a top-ten ranking since Althea
Gibson reigned in the 1950s.
We'll also share with you the story of Johnny,
the little fellow with the big voice who "called
for Philip Morris;" and offer a calendar of the
summer's coming events.
But, busy as these pages are, they represent
only a glimpse of the world of Philip Morris-a
world we hope you'll continue to explore with
us in future issues of Philip Morris Magazine.
Guy L. Smith
Publisher

VOL. 1 NO. 1
Editorial Director
STEPHEN BIRNBAUM
Editor
TOM PASSAVANT
Art Director
HORST WEBER
Senior Editor
THERESA KUMP
Managing Editor
VICTORIA W. SMITH
Contributing Editors
ANN PLESHETTE MURPHY
MICHELLE STACEY
DAVID WALKER
Assistant Art Director
JOE GIORDANO
Editorial Coordinator
EMILY SIREFMAN
Copy Chief
NATALIE S. DE VOE
Production Manager
JEAN BLOCK
CONTENTS
2
GREAT DRIVES THROUGH
THE SOUTHWEST by Karen Evans
Visiting Marlboro Country.
7
SHIPPING THE SHOW by Eleanor Berman
Behind the Vatican exhibit wall, a different kind of
show took place.
12
THE FUTURE OF 42ND STREET by Phil Patton
The ongoing renaissance of
one of America's best-known urban byways.
16
PM NOTEBOOK
A look at San Francisco's controversial new smoking law,
Seattle's Pike Place Market,
economist Ingo Walter on tobacco taxes,
Good News, letters to PM.
22
Publisher
GUY L. SMITH
Associate Publisher
MARY A. TAYLOR
Correspondents
Senior Correspondents: V. Buccellato,
L. Glennie, J. Gillis, G. Powell, D.
Nelson, H. Mize.
Correspondents: Atlanta: E. Glanz, K.
Saas; Baltimore: F. Swartz; Boston: J.
Ruotolo; Charlotte: H. Johnson, J.
Jones, F. Rhodes; Chicago: L. Scanlon,
E. Van Dyke; Cleveland: C. Miller;
Dallas: C. Finch, W. Lott; Denver: J.
Gibson, Ray Phillips; Detroit: B.
Hopkins; Hartford: A. Glaeberman;
Houston: J. Love; Jacksonville: G.
Wren; Kansas City: D. Alford; Los
Angeles: M. Maitino, T. O'Hirok;
Louisville: R. Badler, B. Kohl, C.
Johnson; Miami:G. Burgess; Minneap-
olis: P Bainter, Nashville: R. Martindale;
New York: M. Faulk, S. Gen, N. Gold,
D. Florio, M. Irish, J. Kochevar, A. Miller,
J. Nelson, S. Puder, B. Quinby, A.
Roberts, S. Strausser, S. Ross, K.
Thompson; New Orleans: J. Paddock;
Patterson: P Gregorio; Philadelphia: J.
Chang, J. Chaump; Richmond: G.
Choate, J. Frye, R. Moore; San Diego:
C. Evarkiou; San Francisco: C. Rose-
land; Seattle: J. Henry; St. Louis: J.
Petroski; Syracuse: J. Bartek.
THE YOUNG STARS TO WATCH IN
WOMEN'S TENNIS by Mary Witherell
A guide to the up-and-comers on the Virginia Slims Circuit.
25
A GROWING CONCERN by Rick Mashburn
This tobacco farming family combines business savvy with
a love of the land.
29
THE LITE STUFF by John Tarkov
Behind the scenes with the celebrity sportsmen
who've made Lite Beer from Miller number one.
32
A PIECE OF THE PM PAST by Theodore Fischer
Remember Johnny?
Cover: Tobacco harvest time in North Carolina,
photographed by Clyde H. Smith/ The Stock Shop.
SUMMER 1985
Philip Morris Magazine is published quarterly by Hearst Professional Magazines, Inc. for Philip
Morris U.S.A.; 120 Park Avenue; New York, New York; 10017. Editorial offices at
Hearst Professional Magazines, Inc.; 60 East 42nd Street; New York, New York 10165. Copyright c 1985
Philip Morris U.S.A. All rights reserved Reproduction in whole or part
without written permission is prohibited. Publisher reserves the right to accept or reject any
editorial or advertising matter Publisher assumes no responsibility for the return of
unsolicited manuscripts or art. The material in this magazine is provided for the readers
information and enjoyment only. Philip Morris U.S.A. does not endorse or assume liability
for its contents.

Visiting Marlboro Country
GREAT DRIVESTHROUGH
THE ScXJTHWEST
BY KAREN EVANS
arlboro Country
could be called a
state of mind: a
mythical landscape
of endless horizons,
unlimited possibili-
ties, and frontier
dreams. The phrase
conjures up a timeless though specific vision of
the rugged frontier West, one that, at first glance,
may seem impossible to experience in the
1980s. After all, much of the American West is
now paved over, the rangeland stitched with
fences, the watering holes surrounded by cities.
But that country of the heart is still out there,
where tumbleweed rolls and the sky looms large,
where a lone man on a horse is still etched
against the sunset. It exists off the beaten path,
in corners of the Southwest like Monument
Valley, where the landscape that served as back-
drop for so many classic western films is as
untouched as it was when John Ford spotted it
in the late 1930s. It still lives out near the OK
Corral, and in the hometown of Bi11y the Kid.
UTAH'
eo
Fl1Rl:~,~nl
~~--
V
COLORADO
NEW ~
Nha9uetGue
ME ICO
ROUTE #2
10 . .~.-:
10
MEXICO
54
25
70
ROUTE #3
EI Paso
\~EXAS
The Old West defined:
Route 1, Monument
Valley; Route 2, Wyatt
Earp territory; Route 3,
Billy the Kid country.
The Old West is waiting, and all it
takes to explore it is a car and a sense
of adventure. The routes that follow
show the best of that land and of the
West's rich history, along trails where
buffalo roam even now.
MONUMENT VALLEY
If there is a single stretch of American
landscape that is etched on the
national consciousness as the physical
personification of the legendary West,
it is Monument Valley. In large part,
that's because this magnificent red-
rock country, lying on Navajo land in
northeastern Arizona and south-
eastern Utah, is where director John
Ford shot such classic western films
as Stagecoach and The Searchers. The
vast, Technicolor landscape of star-
tling hues and clear-blue sky showed
generations what the West should
look like.
Technically speaking
Monument
,
~
~ Valley is a part of the great prehistoric
~ Colorado Plateau, uplifted from
seabeds during the Mesozoic era some
225 million years ago. Made of
ancient Permian and Triassic rock, the buttes
and pinnacles were created by erosive cycles of
wind and water. But its appeal is as much
emotional as geological. The rocky outcrop-
pings, some of them jutting to 2,000 feet, are
as curious and memorable as their names-The
Mittens, Three Sisters, Camel Butte, Totem Pole,
The Thumb. And to the Navajo, this sacred
place of magentas and pinks and mysterious
forms is known as "The Land of the Sleeping
Rainbow:"
WHERE THE WEST WAS WON
John Ford shot his first western here in 1939.
Based on a short story called "Stage to
Lordsburg;" the film Stagecoach launched the
career of a young, relatively unknown actor
named John Wayne. But Ford insisted that "the
real star of my westerns has always been the
land;" and his favorite landscape was Monument
Valley. "It has rivers, mountains, plains, desert;"
he said. "I have been all over the world, but I
consider this the most complete, beautiful, and
peaceful place on earth:'
It was the late Harry Goulding, whose in-
triguing old lodge is still open for business here,
Y
0
~
R
N

who sold Monument Valley to Hollywood. He
marched into United Artists studios in 1939 with
a handful of photographs taken by the renowned
regional photographer Josef Muench. Goulding's
timing was perfect, and three days later John
Ford was scouting locations in the valley for
Stagecoach. In all, Ford filmed here for 25 years,
ending in 1964 with Cheyenne Autumn. The
Duke and many other stars-among them Ward
Bond, Maureen O'Hara, and Henry Fonda-
said their lines against The Mittens and Merrick
Butte, and along the way Ford made such classics
as She Wore a Yellow Ribbon and the film that
made a hero of the landscape like no other: The
Searchers.
Monument Valley has not exactly been
ignored by more recent filmmakers. It has
appeared in The Eiger Sanction, Superman, and
Koyanisquaatsi and was extraterrestrial enough
for a few scenes in 2001. Unsurprisingly, parts
of How the West Was Won were shot here as
well,
TOURING THE SET
Monument Valley is located roughly 175 miles
northeast of Flagstaff, Arizona. It can be reached
from the north, out of Moab, Utah, via U.S.
191, or from the south through Flagstaff and
Tuba City on U.S. 160. From Tuba City take
Navajo Route 1 through Kayenta, then head
north on Navajo Route 18 to the entrance of
the Navajo Tribal Park.
The best drive through the most spectacular
sections of Monument Valley is a 14-mile loop
around the valley floor. The Visitors Center at
~ the Tribal Park, which is near the entrance, four
0
C) miles off U.S. 163, is the place to begin (Navajo
~ Tribal Park Headquarters; Box 93; Monument
~ Valley UT 84536 ; 801-727-3287) Going off
The rich variety of plant life the road at all requires an Indian guide, and
in Arizona's Sonora Desert (above) includes
yellow-flowered prickly pear cactus (right, top). arrangements can be made here; maps for self-
Cowboys (right, bottom) are still part of the guided tours on the main route are also avail-
scenery as we11. able. This route passes by The Mittens, which
the Navajo believe were left behind by the gods,
and other formations with names like Elephant
Butte, Rain God Mesa, and Thunder Bird Mesa.
PHILIP MORRIS MAGAZINEiSUMMER 1085 3

Another drive, on U.S. 160 south-
west from Kayenta, Arizona, passes
through sheepherding country and
several Navajo trading posts. Along
the way, the ancient Anasazi Indian
ruins of Betatakin offer a silent re-
minder of the vanished tribe that
flourished here over 700 years ago.
Tours leave from the Visitors Center
of Navajo National Monument (HC
63 Box 3, Tonalea, AZ 86044-9704;
602-672-2366).
Goulding's Lodge, just over the
Utah border on U.S. 163, is the place
to stay (Box 1; Monument Valley,
UT 84536; 801-727-3231). The
walls are hung with call sheets from
old films and still photographs of the stars and
the action. The people at Goulding's can point
to the cabin where John Wayne used to stay, as
well as provide general tour information.
Off-the-road four-wheel-drive tours to more
remote areas may be booked from here, too.
Goulding's season runs from March 15 to Oc-
tober 31. For those who would rather rough it,
there are camping facilities in the Tribal Park
4 PHILIP MORRIS MAGAZINE/SUMMER 1985
David Muench Photography
In Monument Valley:
The Mittens are sil-
houetted against the
sunset (top) and
Navajo children play
among the ancient
rocks (above).
(ask at the Visitors Center), as well
as in Kayenta.
WYATT EARP TERRITORY
If Monument Valley was a western
stage set, Tombstone, Arizona, was
the real thing: a rugged town where
Sheriff Wyatt Earp fought the fa-
mous gunfight at the OK Corral,
and where Geronimo surrendered
to end the Apache Wars.
Known as "the town too tough
to die;" Tombstone survives today
in the high, beautiful desert coun-
try of southern Arizona, just 67
miles from Tucson. The drive east
from Tucson on Interstate 10 to
Benson, then south to Tombstone on U.S. 80
and on into the historic mining town of Bisbee,
passes through glorious stretches of scenic
landscape.
Roguishly handsome Wyatt Earp served in
Tombstone's more troubled times as the deputy
sheriff, with his brother Virgil as the chief of
police. All five Earp brothers had sideline
occupations as land speculators, saloon keepers,

and gamblers; in fact, they didn't take up their
calling as lawmen until after the other enforcers
had been scared out of town by a ruthless gang
of stagecoach robbers and rustlers. The climax
was the famous "Gunfight at the OK Corral"
in October 1881. It lasted less than a minute,
left three young outlaws dead, and resulted in
instant fame for the Earps and Doc Holliday-
all of whom went on to clean up the rest of
Cochise County in their own flamboyant fashion.
Today the OK Corral, located right on the main
street, is open to visitors, marked with a sign
that says, WALK WHERE THEY FELL. Just around
the corner are the offices of the Tombstone
Epitaph-a real media force in its day-and on
the other end of town is the old Bird Cage
Theatre, both open to the public. On Toughnut
Street the old Tombstone Courthouse Museum
stands, not far from the Wells Fargo Museum.
Nearby are the Lucky Cuss and Crystal Palace
saloons, and even today when you walk through
their swinging doors it's hard not to imagine
Wyatt Earp standing there, ready to reach for
his six-shooter.
In fact, in and around Tombstone most of
the points of interest are riddled with violent
legends and bullet holes. Going west out of
Tombstone on Route 82 there is Drew's Station,
where the stagecoach robbery that led to the
famous gunfight occurred. The most notorious
of the outlaws killed by Earp, John Ringo, is
buried on the banks of Turkey Creek, and just
north of Tombstone on U.S. 80 is Boothill Cem-
etery, with grave markers bearing the names of
a number of outlaws stopped in their tracks by
the Earps.
he territory south of Tomb
stone, leading to Bisbee on
U.S. 80, is rough-and-tumble
cowboy country, rugged high
desert reddened by mesquite
and softened by rolling grass-
lands. A mile high in eleva-
tion, Bisbee perches precari-
ously on the Mule Mountains, near the Ari-
zona-Mexico border. Once the queen of the
Arizona mining towns, Bisbee saw $2 billion
worth of copper mined from the surrounding
mountains, as well as turquoise of a quality so
fine that it had its own appellation: Bisbee Blue.
At its peak the town had 35,000 inhabitants-
and even an opera house.
In its prime, Bisbee was a company town,
owned by Phelps Dodge right down to the com-
pany store, the company hotel, and the com-
pany newspaper. Today, it's a community filled
with historic preservationists, bent on keeping
its authentic turn-of-the-century flavor.
The reigning hotel here is still the lavish old
Copper Queen, where the "slept-here" register
lists Theodore Roosevelt, who strolled through
the Victorian lobby during his Rough Rider
days, and General John "Black Jack" Pershing,
who stopped to rest on his way to Mexico to
pursue Pancho Villa. It's still open for business,
and the dining room still serves up first-rate fare
(Box CQ; Bisbee, AZ 85603; 602-432-2216).
From Bisbee, the routes leading to other
near-vanished parts of the West point in every
direction. State routes 92 and 90 ramble back
to Tucson, passing through Fort Huachuca on
Looking toward New
Mexico's San Andreas
Mountains.
the way, an active army post with buildings
from the 1800s. Just west of Tucson is the
Arizona-Sonora Desert Museum, a stunning
place to see the native plant life of Arizona; in
spring, when the desert flowers bloom, it is
extraordinary. To the east, it's just a few hours'
drive into New Mexico-and Billy the Kid's old
turf.
The small New Mexico town of Lincoln, about
190 miles southeast of Albuquerque at the base
of the Capitan Mountains, seems sleepy and
humble. But a little more than a hundred years
ago Lincoln County was major cattle country,
as wild and woolly as the West could get. Then
the largest county in the United States, with
27,000 square miles of rolling terrain, it attracted
numerous ambitious cattlemen and their wan-
dering longhorn herds. Eventually, thanks to
the Lincoln County Range Wars and a former
New Yorker known as Billy the Kid, it also
attracted considerable notoriety.
onument Valley showed
what the West should look like.
PHILIP MORRIS MAGAZINE/SUMMER 1955 5

Tombstone,
Arizona (left and
right, top)-the
site of the famous
gunfight at the
OK Corral-was
called the "town
too tough to die:'
In Billy the Kid
country the
Tunstall Store at
Lincoln, New
Mexico (right,
bottom), has
been preserved
as a museum.
Today, through the auspices of New Mexico
State Monuments and the Lincoln County Heri-
tage Trust, the tiny town of Lincoln has been
painstakingly restored. Tourists can visit the
courthouse where Billy the Kid shot it out and
escaped from custody in 1881, and the old
Wortley Hotel, a charming one-story inn with
chairs lining its long front porch, is open once
again, offering home-cooked meals and lodging
(Lincoln, NM 88388; 505-653-4381).
The town's greatest claim to fame, though,
is still William Bonney, aka Billy the Kid,
whose relatively short five-year career spawned
hundreds of articles and books, a number of
movies, a television series, and an annual pag-
eant, Old Lincoln Days. On the first weekend
in August about half of Lincoln's 100 residents
produce a rowdy version of "The Last Escape
of Billy the Kid;" as well as a Pony Express race,
an old-time fiddler's contest, a western parade,
and a concert performed on the porch of the
Wortley.
The object of all this celebration was a
dubious celebrity at best, a man some called
"nothing but a juvenile delinquent." Billy played
a leading role in the Lincoln County Range Wars,
a bloody series of power struggles between
cattlemen and merchants, outlaws and outraged
citizenry, that began in 1876. In the last battle
of the war, Billy's band of outlaws was
entrenched for two days in the McSween home,
exchanging gunfire with a rival gang that was
barricaded in the surrounding buildings. Billy
the Kid was eventually caught and jailed in the
courthouse, but one of his jailers made the
grievous error of going across the street to the
Wortley for dinner. Billy killed the guard who
stayed behind, shot the second as he came back
across the street from his dinner, and rode out
of town, evidently with the tacit approval of
most of the population.
The old courthouse is a museum now, marked
with the spots where Billy fired his fatal shots.
There are other historic points, including the
old Tunstall Store, which has been renovated
into a museum, complete with merchandise
from bygone days. Down the street is the old
stone torreon-the tower that the early settlers
built to defend themselves from the Apache
raiders.
The Wortley Hotel is still the only place to
stay or eat in Lincoln, and in the summer it is
the town gathering place. It has only nine rooms,
though, so reserve in advance-especially
around Old Lincoln Days. There's lots of food
and lodging available west on U.S. 70 in Ruidoso.
Thirteen miles east on 70 in Tinnie, the old
Tinnie Mercantile Co. has been restored with
1800s furnishings and turned into a good res-
taurant and local watering hole called Tinnie's
Silver Dollar.
Information about Old Lincoln Days (sched-
uled this year for August 2 to 4) and the town's
sights can be had by calling 505-653-4372.
A few miles northwest of Lincoln, just north
of the junction of U.S. 380 and state route 349, is
another piece of the West's past: the ghost town
of White Oaks. In its prime, White Oaks was
overrun with prospectors, and the nearby
Homestake mine eventually yielded half-a-
million dollars' worth of gold. Another mine,
Old Abe, yielded gold worth $3 million. White
lhe town of Lincoln's best claim to fame
is William Bonney, aka Billy the Kid.
Oaks became known as "the
liveliest town in the territory,"
complete with an opera house and
a mansion (still standing) known
as Hoyle's Castle that, the story
goes, was built for a young bride
who refused to come West. Legend
has it that the heartbroken builder
simply disappeared. Conrad Hilton
even considered building a hotel
here, and Billy the Kid hung out in
town until Sheriff Pat Garrett
caught up with him at Stinking
Springs, near Fort Sumner.
The end came for White Oaks
when the ore was exhausted and
the railroad bypassed the town, but
the remains of the old town still
stand. Today a few residents
remain, trying to spruce up the old
Exchange Bank Building and fix up
the Little Casino, where Madame
Varnish-named for her slippery
ways-once dealt the cards.
Down U.S. 70 is the Mescalero
Apache Indian Reservation and a
luxury resort hotel, the Inn of the
Mountain Gods, run by the Mesca-
lero Apaches (Box 269; Mescalero,
NM 88340; 505-257-5141). It
offers lodging, shopping, dining,
repose-and a chance to contem-
plate the endless and unchanging
horizons of the West. 11
Karen Evans is a writer based in
Santa Fe, New Mexico.

Behind-the-scenes at the presentation
of precious papal art.
SIIPPING THE SHOW
BY ELEANOR BERMAN
t was an art event with-
out precedent. Not since
Napoleon's invading
armies looted Rome had
the treasures of the Vat-
ican been away "on
loan." Now, two centu-
ries later in 1983, 237
priceless pieces were on view at
New York City's Metropolitan
Museum of Art, part of the Philip
Morris-sponsored exhibition "The
Vatican Collections: The Papacy
and Art"
But few of the 855,939 viewers
who flocked to the Metropolitan
that year ever knew the saga-
almost as remarkable as the show
itself-of four years of negotia-
tion, preparation, restoration, and
hard work that preceded the
opening of the exhibit.
Every special museum exhibit
requires long and painstaking
planning behind the scenes, but
this became the most expensive
exhibit in history. Though Philip
Morris has been underwriting
museum shows for 20 years, the
$3 million grant given for the
Vatican spectacular was the
largest corporate grant in museum
history. The backstage endeavors
are still vivid in the minds of
everyone at the Met, from the
telephone operators to the
museum's director, Philippe de
Montebello.
To hear de Montebello tell it,
all it took to launch this historic
project was a call to New York's
late Archbishop, Terence Cardi-
nal Cooke, a member of the
museum's board of directors.
Wouldn't it be nice, de Montebello
suggested, if Pope John Paul II's
visit here in 1979 were to include
the announcement of a major ex-
hibition of Vatican art to tour the
United States.
Such an exhibition had been the
dream of almost every major
museum director for years, but
the Vatican had long banned
loans of its priceless collection.
Even with the pontiff's blessing,
the most diplomatic negotiations
were required first to convince
skeptics in Rome that a traveling
exhibit was a good idea, and
second to coax individual cura-
tors to lend their prize pieces for
the show. De Montebello's trump
card: the promise to use a large
part of the exhibit endowment for
much-needed restoration of the
Vatican collections, work that
would bring many of the objects
back to their finest condition in
centuries.
Agreement came, but with a
proviso. The Vatican would deal
with only one party in the United
States. The Metropolitan was put
in the touchy position of assum-
ing responsibility for the show
when it traveled to two other
major U.S. museums, the Art
Institute of Chicago and the M.H.
de Young Memorial Museum in
San Francisco.
Even harder bargaining ensued
when de Montebello, curator
Olga Raggio, and exhibit coordi-
nator Margaret Frazer went to
Rome with their
"wish list" and got
down to negotiat-
ing with Vatican
museum heads
about which ob-
jects would be al-
lowed to travel.
De Montebello
had asked seven
of his department
heads to submit
proposals for an
exhibition theme.
Raggio's winning
idea was to show
the powerful in-
fluence of the
popes' collections
on the develop-
ment of Western
art; that theme de-
termined the cri-
teria for selecting
what would be
shown. Each piece
had to answer two
questions: Which
pope had commis-
sioned or collect-
ed it? And why?
De Montebello smiles, remem-
bering his chronic bad back that
forced the urbane director to
conduct some of the most crucial
negotiations in Rome while lying
flat on his back on the Vatican
floor, a posture that seemed to
break the ice and actually re-
solved some wrangles: "A couple
of major pieces were agreed upon
at that time."
ut not all of the
museum's wishes
came true. Some
pieces were
deemed too frag-
ile to travel; others did not mea-
sure up because no one knew what
they meant to the pope who
acquired them. But there were tri-
umphs as well, such as the in-
clusion of Caravaggio's The
Deposition, believed by many to
be the artist's greatest work,
Raphael's tapestries, and, after
significant initial reluctance, the
glorious statue of the Apollo
Belvedere.
Fragment of
a Greek grave
relief, or stele
(ca. 430 B.C.),
brought to
Venice as war
booty in 1687.
It was acquired
by the Holy See
in 1823.
N
PHILIP MORRIS MAGAZINE/SUMMER 1985 7

Behind the
scenes (top, left
to right):
Curators select
pieces for the
show, then over-
see their re-
moval from the
Vatican and the
careful packing
process. The
works were also
cleaned and
restored (right,
top)underthe
watchful eye of
Biagio Cascone
(right, bottom).
R estoration of ex-
hibit items is part
of any show, but
in this case a few
miracles occur-
red. The Apollo
Belvedere was li-
terally taken apart
-into 13 pieces-and put back
together, repair work that enabled
the statue to stand on its own two
feet for the first time in centuries,
its rusting iron insides replaced
with stainless steel rods. Accord-
ing to Olga Raggio, five terra-
cotta sculptural studies, stripped
of their black paint, were found
to be authentic Berninis with a
surface of "enormous freshness:'
The cleaning of 16th-century
vestments and the removal of
centuries of tarnish from gold
candlesticks were also a revela-
tion, she says.
SETTING THE TONE
As curator, one of Raggio's pri-
mary tasks was to work with ex-
hibit designer Stuart Sil-
ver in developing an aes-
thetic design that would
do justice to the art and
also evoke some of the
feeling of the Roman
backdrop that is so in-
tegral a part of the Vati-
can collections.
A master of the
"blockbuster" show and
designer of the Met's
highly successful "The
Treasures of Tutankh-
amen" exhibit, Silver
had left the museum to
become vice-president of design
communications at Knoll Asso-
ciates. But when de Montebello
called, he took the time to return
for this exhibit. He remembers
traveling to Rome to sit in on the
final selection process, then re-
turning to his hotel and sketching
out a basic design for the show of
the century in a couple of hours.
Among its features were a palette
8 PHILIP MORRIS MAGAZINE/SUMMER 1955
of earthy Roman colors and
repeated use of Italianesque
arches.
His design transformed 2,200
square feet of space, the largest
ever allotted for a Metropolitan
exhibit; it took more than 100
people six months to construct
and cost over $1 million.
While Stuart Silver was puz-
zling over how to display the art,
registrar John Buchanan was
worrying about shipping, insur-
ance negotiations, and the securi-
ty of exhibitions in transit. It's a
job he calls "nuts and bolts," but
still one fraught with potential
complications. He is expected to
be something of a seer, submitting
estimates on costs for shipping
shows as long as four years in
advance of the actual exhibition.
"I know a little bit how the
Pentagon feels," he comments
wryly.
The Vatican show presented
challenges even for a man accus-
tomed to the complicated. "We
were fortunate to have one official
carrier, Pan Am, and they did a
superb job," Buchanan says. "But
normally items are crated, trans-
ported to an airport, and then tied
onto large pallets to be loaded
into the plane. It was decided to
minimize handling by packing
these pallets right at the Vatican:'
That meant building a covered
platform and installing rollers so
that completed pallets could be
rolled onto trucks that took them
directly to the planes. Rollers were
installed at the Metropolitan to
repeat the procedure and again at
the other two stops on the Ameri-
can tour. Chicago's loading dock
needed structural changes to han-
dle the task, and a platform had
to be built from scratch in San
Francisco.
The double packing boxes used
for the delicate objects-specially
built in Rome from aged poplar,
enormous slabs of polyurethane
foam, and yards of mollettone, a
thick cotton flannel-were works
of art in themselves.
Richard E. Stone, a
Metropolitan conserva-
tor, was one of those in-
volved in another of the
important packing op-
erations, ensuring that
fragile exhibits would
not be affected by tem-
perature and humidity
changes en route or dur-
ing the exhibit. Paintings
on wood are particu-
larly susceptible, Stone
says, because wood pan-
els flex, causing prob-
lems in paint adhesion.
An environmental chamber
was built where delicate objects
slowly changed (over a period of
ten days) from the climate of
Rome to the temperature and
humidity of American museums.
Then they were rapidly packed
and shipped.
"In conservation, the simplest
devices often prove the best,"

I
I
Stone observes. Silica gel, which
absorbs moisture in damp condi-
tions and gives it off in dry, was
used. Individual works of, art were
placed in inner cribs lined with
strips of silica gel. The cribs were
topped with porous plastic sheets
tacked down on both sides, then
placed in protective outer crates.
The actual exhibit cases in New
York were lined with silica gel pa-
per and, in addition, there was a
hydrometer in each case to report
any harmful change in the atmo-
spheric conditions.
At every airport and every des-
tination point there were repre-
sentatives from the Met and from
the Vatican. Pictures were taken
as the crates were unpacked and
a condition report was filed.
Since insurance indemnity is
limited to $10 million on any one
shipment, 11 separate shipments
were required. No two primary
masterpieces traveled on the same
plane and, as an extra precaution,
plaster casts were made of all the
sculptures in the show before they
left Rome.
Insurance, which can run as
much as a third of the cost of an
exhibit, turned out to be the least
of Buchanan's problems for the
Vatican art. The bulk of it was
picked up by the U.S. government,
which, under the Arts and Arti-
facts Indemnity Act passed by
Congress in 1975, helps many
museums by indemnifying impor-
tant shows up to $50 million.
With that amount covered, get-
ting supplementary insurance
rarely poses a problem and costs
relatively little, Buchanan says.
How_to evaluate art that is
beyond price? It is done simply
by what the items might bring at
auction, with curators and experts
verifying estimated prices. There
are knowledgeable companies
that specialize in this type of cov-
erage, according to Buchanan.
The sums involved, while large,
aren't always the greatest risks for
an insurance company: "An oil
tanker can cost $30 million."
Among those who played a
critical role in unloading the
treasures were the riggers, part of
the staff of Richard R. Morsches,
the Metropolitan's vice-president
for operations. The Vatican show
involved some of the heaviest
classical sculpture ever moved, a
total shipping weight of 54.7
gross tons. It took all the skill of
the Met's ten-man rigging crew
using such machinery as gantries,
tiering machines, forklifts, and
special electric hydraulic platform
lifts to gently set a 6,000-pound
m
0
~
0
U
.c
w
The Apollo Belvedere
(top), a Roman marble
copy of a Greek orig-
inal thought to date
from the late 4th cen-
tury, stands over
seven feet tall. Work-
men (right) guide
another piece through
the halls of the
Vatican.
PHILIP MORRIS MAGAZINE/SUMMER 1985 9

10 PHILIP MORRIS MAGAZINE/SUMMER 1985
At left and
center, the un-
packing and
installation of
the Vatican trea-
sures. Stuart
Silver's design
for the galleries
(bottom) incor-
porated Roman-
style arches and
earthy colors.
Facing page:
The Rest on the
Flight Into Egypt
(ca. 1570-1573)
by Barocci.
statue like the Apollo Belvedere
on its feet. Neither out-of-town
museum had a rigging crew, so
Morsches lost his men each time
the exhibit had to be reinstalled.
He and his staff made two pre-
liminary trips to each city, mea-
suring corridors and elevators to
guard against potential disasters.
Also in the operations domain
were the carpenters who built the
cabinets and pedestals, metal-
smiths who made every picture
hook, and painters who not only
decorated the galleries but nightly
touched up every smudge or
fingerprint left by the huge
crowds. The signs to the rest-
rooms, outdoor awnings and
banners, 185,000 light bulbs,
printing and mailing, purchasing,
and training of guards were all
the responsibility of Morsches
and his able managers, who
supervise 750 of the museum's
1,600 employees. Morsches, a
21-year Met veteran, compares his
job to running an army. Then he
grins and admits, "It's fun. No
two days are alike."
One particularly sensitive
province belongs to Kathleen
Arffmann, director of admissions.
Each time a show is planned,
estimates are made as to how
many people can visit the galleries
comfortably at one time, and how
long it will take them to walk
through the exhibit. Arffmann
issues tickets accordingly. Then a
major part of her job is to train
the temporary assistants hired to
handle busy phones, staff desks,
and say no tactfully to disap-
pointed callers.
There were many of the latter
for the Vatican show, especially
on weekends, when 20,000 re-
quests were common for 5,500
places. An important show brings
an average of 37 calls per min-
ute, and most want personal
attention after they hear a record-
ed message. Nine special lines are
needed for a typical big exhibit.
Was it worth it? Almost every-
one at the Metropolitan, remem-
bering the final triumph of the ex-
hibit, says yes-but they say it
on the run. After all, major
exhibits are what a great museum
is all about. And though the
Vatican show was a landmark,
that was yesterday. Tomorrow it
will be another show, and there
are still cases to build, planes to
meet, crates to unpack, lectures
to be given-and all those phones
to answer. 0
Eleanor Berman is the author of
the Away for the Weekend guides
(Clarkson N. Potter).
i

/
J
;.;
Art Ilasourcr.
,
,
®
.
L6 L5EZ0l7Oz
4X
,
wr
\
0
r-
,
rr
. ;fu
,
a
v

®
®
®
©
®
L111111
®
®
®
®
r=r-# _t 4 1
W
i s~.w.-1
®
D
0
10
ti
Ll
i
l
i
A
#h
~ 3.. _
Courtesy of John Burgee Architects with Philip Johnson
N
O
-p
O
W
U1
~
! ~ CO
' } t
~i
Scenes of 42nd
Street today
against a backdrop
of plans for its future
(clockwise from left):
ornate grillworK
in the outer lobby
of the Chanin
Building; rush-hour
traffic; a detail of
Grand Central Terminal;
an artist's rendering of
the office towers pro-
posed for Times Square

One of America's most
famous thoroughfares is about
to get a facelift.
Courtesy of John Burgee Architects with Philip Johnson
~
BY PHIL PATTON
Nothing in recent years has
done more for the reputation
of New York's 42nd Street
than the musical of the same
name. But the show gets one
thing wrong: the song about
dancing feet refers to the
"avenue they're taking us to'."
That's fine for rhyme-it may
be allowed as poetic license-
but it completely misses the
point. Because 42nd Street is
definitely not anything as
highfalutin' as an avenue-it's
a plain old street-wise street
that's worked its way up.
Its appeal lies in the fact that
it cuts across the avenues,
from the gritty to the grand.
The street is literally as wide
as Manhattan, stretching from
the East River to the Hudson,
and it's a cross section of the
whole island, a core sample of
all its varied strata, from
polished marble to rough
brownstone.
Today, 42nd Street also
offers a microcosm of the
debate over strategies pro-
posed for a better urban
future. Recent improvements
have provided hope for an end
to 42nd Street's persistent
problems and a reaffirmation
of its traditional worth. Glis-
tening new buildings, from the
Grand Hyatt and Harley
hotels to the dignified Philip
Morris and (newly reclad)
Home Box Office headquar-
ters, now rub elbows with
monuments of the skyscraper
era. And a pending Times
Square renewal plan is about
to contribute the most dra-
matic change ever in a street
that has seen many changes.
That scheme, directed by
New York State's Urban De-
velopment Corporation, in-
cludes plans to build a series
of towers, designed by such
architects as Philip Johnson
and John Burgee, that will
range up to 56 stories tall and
include office, retail, and hotel
space. Plans for the restoration
to theatrical use of nine once-
grand theaters between Se-
venth and Eighth Avenues are
also part of the project. The
price tag for the whole regener-
ation approaches $2 billion.
Theater helped build 42nd
Street. As New York City grew,
it moved north from its water-
front origins; 42nd Street was
a frontier, the edge of uptown,
when a few daring theater own-
ers, beginning with Charles
Frohman (in 1893) and Oscar
Hammerstein (in 1895) lo-
cated there. Swanky restau-
rants, watering holes, and
hotels soon followed.
Before that, 42nd Street had
been considered a wilderness.
When Grand Central Depot
went up in 1871, on the same
site of the current incarnation,
in the direction of either river-
RM
u~fllft
aa..~r~~c~i
...:
,~
L
sira
~
:H
~
~ fiiTa:L'X .
i.n
..GL"IL~et
.a~~~3...
ud.:~;..u
rskFE:.1.u.
12
....
;.E..~~....
:Ci G?
a~tEvW :`
a~3l16d~:~[ ;
'n1.ILA YWWl1.'(
aYYWYYYu
Fam
6
0
~
4
®
l
EQ
Q
Is
I
[A
0
0
®
M
0
©
ME
a
~
at~._ - `
tiffi.1'll ".---1- .::..
",
front were only tenements,
gasworks, rail yards, and what
were then regularly referred to
as "dens of hooliganism;" sup-
porting their own cast of
"French ladies" This was New
York's own tenderloin. There
were, to be sure, new buildings
uptown around Central Park,
but they retained an almost sub-
urban air through the 1880s.
To the west, 42nd Street ran
through the heart of what was
called "Hell's Kitchen;" home
of freight yards, stock pens,
and tenements, and an area
that had been home to gang
wars since the Civil War. It was
often the site of thievery and
strong-arm tactics aimed at the
freight industry, and of fights
for turf between gangs with
colorful-now quaint-names:
the original "Hell's Kitchen
Gang;" the "Hudson Dusters;"
the "Gophers." The wars be-
tween the hoodlums were not
stopped until the early years of
the present century, when the
New York Central Railroad

.
ae
~~
~
m~
~
~~
~
~~1.0
~: ~i~.aa~
. the Ford Founda-
tiori s indoor garden
(above), inside the
Automat (below).
used its own gang of toughs to
break the hold on the then-
dominant Gophers. The famous
priest, Father Francis Duffy, who
is honored today by a statue in
Times Square, earned his reputa-
tion as a sort of missionary to
these wild tribes, an almost
storybook figure blending tough-
ness and kindness. Duffy, who
was also the chaplain of the famed
69th Regiment (raised mostly
from the Hell's Kitchen area), was
pastor of the Church of the Holy
Cross, on 42nd between Eighth
d Ni
th A
m an
n
venues.
~ It was the presence of Grand
Central Terminal that led, indi-
rectly, to the birth of the modern
42nd Street. The city's first sub-
way line-previous rail lines had
been trolleys or "els"-was the
IRT, running from City Hall to
Grand Central, then west along
42nd Street before turning up
Broadway. This transit innova-
tion helped Adolph Ochs of The
New York Times decide to locate
his paper's new building at the
subway juncture. The paper
moved into its terra-cotta sheathed
tower on New Year's Eve 1904.
(The celebration, complete with
fireworks, marked the beginning
of an annual New Year's cere-
mony.) Before long, Ochs had
persuaded the city to formally
name the square-actually a set
of triangles-at 42nd and Broad-
way "Times Square" Over the
years the building itself has
changed much, becoming One
Times Square after the paper's of-
fices moved to 43rd Street and
then, in 1966, the Allied Chemi-
cal Tower (shortly thereafter it
was fitted with a new, modern,
marble skin).
Times Square became a place
of legend less through plays and
shows than through another form
of theater-outdoor advertising
0
I
I
M
!I-
0
t
U
®
hotel buildings that make up the Times Square Center.
and the drama of its enormous
billboards. Even Broadway's
nickname-"the Great White
Way"-was invented by an
advertising man, O. J. Gude, an
early champion of the electric sign.
The signs are specifically pro-
tected by the 1916 Zoning Act.
Times Square has been a na-
tional as well as municipal stage.
In how many minds is the end of
World War II represented by the
lingering memory of Alfred Eisen-
stadt's famous photograph of a
sailor kissing a nurse?
Currently there is concern that
the plans for rehabilitating Times
Square might endanger this public
role. In particular, several citizens
and arts groups have criticized the
proposal to remove the old Times
Tower. After the plans to raze the
tower were announced, New
York's Municipal Art Society
sponsored a competition to
suggest ways the building could
be saved and the uses to which it
could be put. Almost all the pro-
posals featured some form of
giant television screens, to am-
plify and expand the building's
place as the greatest sign among
a forest of supersigns.
As varied as the denizens of
42nd Street's sidewalks are the
personalities of the buildings that
rise above them. A walking tour
of the street's great skyscrapers
should start at its eastern extreme,
where 42nd Street seems to begin
in the most universal way possi-
ble, with the headquarters of the
United Nations. But the original
design of the UN complex (by
an international committee of
architects headed by New Yorker
Wallace K. Harrison) inspired as
much bickering as occurs at the
Security Council. The basic plan,
by Le Corbusier, somehow man-
aged to retain its formal power
through all the adjustments and
modifications.
The UN's neighbor, the huge
Tudor City apartment complex,
turns in on its courtyards, entirely
understandable since it once was
surrounded solely by warehouses,
tenements, and slaughterhouses
(six acres of the latter were razed
to make way for the UN). The
Ford Foundation headquarters sits
just across the street from Tudor
City, and its atrium echoes the
residential complex's park and
courts. Designed by the architec-
tural firm of Kevin Roche and
John Dinkeloo, the Ford Founda-
tion building represents what is
best about the often-maligned
urban architecture of the 1960s:
its shapes are powerful, but
humane, concrete and steel beams
softened by weathered surfaces of
Cor-ten steel. But its most attrac-
tive feature is the interior garden,
which is as much a gift to the
street as to the floors of offices
tiered around it.
Farther along, a trio of sky-
scrapers-the nearby Daily News
Building, the original McGraw-
Hill Building far to the west, and
the American Radiator Building
just about in the middle (behind
the Public Library)-make 42nd
Street a showcase for the work
of one of America's greatest
architects, Raymond Hood.
Hood, along with John Mead
Howells, won the famous Chicago
Tribune Tower competition that
did so much to define skyscraper
architecture. His American Radia-
tor Building, (actually on 40th
Street but best seen from 42nd
across from Bryant Park) is a
miniature black-and-gold version
of the Tribune Tower, a Gothic
cathedral of business.
The Daily News Building,
completed in 1930, is distin-
guished for having broken away
from the rigidity of setbacks
2040235200 1
A
Above, drawings detail the office, retail, and
\\1v\~\~,\l. 'r :"3c~: ~
0
~
s1
A ~, asr
\~
0

r
(dictated under the 1916 zoning
laws) to create a solid shape that
left much of the site free. In this,
as in the dramatic contrast of its
dark and light bands of siding, it
set a precedent. It also expressed
a certain vision of the 1930s city,
the Metropolis of the "Superman"
strips. The comic strip's Daily
Planet was modeled on the Daily
News, and the incestuous relation-
ship came full circle when the
Daily News Building was actually
used in the "Superman" films as
Daily Planet headquarters.
By way of the Daily News
Building, Hood moved from the
delicate detail of the Radiator
Building to the stripped-down
McGraw-Hill Building, conclud-
ing in the process that "this beau-
ty stuff is all bunk" But McGraw-
Hill-built far to the west (330
W. 42nd St.) because of zoning
requirements for the firm's
presses-is beautiful nonetheless.
With its ocean-liner-like top
stories and green terra-cotta
paneling, it suggests some great
conning tower or superstructure;
a captain's bridge from which the
whole island of Manhattan might
be steered.
From the sidewalks of 42nd
Street, one could easily miss its
greatest skyscraper, the Chrysler
Building. It is so tall and dramatic
-especially at night, with its arc
of V-shaped lights installed a cou-
ple of years ago-that it needs to
be seen from a distance.
A pedestrian in too much of a
hurry is also likely to neglect
other, less-famous skyscrapers,
many of whose upper reaches
have been blocked from easy view
by later development. For ex-
ample, the Chanin Building (122
E. 42nd St.) has wonderful art
deco work. And, although the ski-
jump form of the Grace Building,
near Sixth Avenue, has been criti-
cized as too showy, it is not hard
to muster a bit of fondness for
its dramatics. In a few years, we
are likely to appreciate the sculp-
tural melodrama of such build-
ings, just as-half a century after
their construction-we appreci-
ate the ornamental melodrama of
art deco.
The grand aspirations of 42nd
Street's towers can grow wearing.
But scattered among them, for-
tunately, are a few places of refuge
that permit quiet observation.
Moving back across town to
East 42nd Street, a tour of these
spots should start at Grand Cen-
tral Terminal, whose admirers
recently defeated a threatened
plan to develop an office tower
above its columns. This building
offers public space in the grand
tradition, serving as a kind of
living room for 42nd Street and
an appropriate gateway to the city.
The Automat, on the southeast
corner of Third Avenue, is the last
of its kind: an art deco styled re-
minder (it was actually built in
1958) of the days when a cup of
coffee cost 5q. At the other end
of the culinary scale, The Sun
Garden Lounge, a restaurant-bar
at the new Grand Hyatt hotel, is
cantilevered out over the street
next to Grand Central, providing
a perfect vantage point for
regarding the traffic rush. The
Whitney Museum has a branch
in the lobby of Ulrich Franzen's
Philip Morris Building just up the
block. With its open court and
espresso bar, this space is an oasis
from the frantic pace of the street.
Designed with the assistance of
William Whyte, an expert on
small urban spaces, it is one of
the most humane spots along
42nd Street.
Moving across Fifth Avenue,
the Public Library, designed at the
turn of the century by Carrere
and Hastings, mixes grand spaces
with the smaller ones of its spe-
cial collections. The library has
recently installed a computerized
card catalogue system, and the
terminals-with their green
glow-sit in odd juxtaposition to
the dramatic ceilings and acres
of bookshelves.
Bryant Park, behind the Public
Library, has so far been unsuccess-
ful in its attempt to function as
42nd Street's belt buckle of
greenery. Once the site of the
city's drinking water reservoir, it
has never quite lived up to its
promise as a park. New plans call
for its restoration and the addi-
tion of a glassed-in, 1,000-seat
restaurant, backed up to the great
beaux arts library.
The history of 42nd Street is
the history of New York theater
and, moving west, the street itself
is a linear stage, as much for the
street performers-the break-
dancers or mimes at the corner
of Sixth Avenue-as for the
aspiring stars living in Manhattan
Plaza, the subsidized housing
complex constructed for those in
the performing arts.
In the redeveloped area be-
tween Ninth and Tenth Avenues,
are six theaters, and in what was
once the West Side Airlines
Terminal, video and film facilities
thrive. Even the entrances to the
Lincoln Tunnel have been given
a touch of theater: trompe l'oeil
murals by painter Richard Haas
suggest fanciful stage backdrops.
Critics worry about the new
towers in Times Square-will
they turn Times Square into just
another part of midtown office-
dom, an imitation of Rockefeller
Center? Can they coexist with
billboards and glitzy signs? And
with Broadway's economy in a
crunch, will the area be able to
support nine new theaters? Can
42nd Street lose its rougher edges
without losing its spirit?
No one knows for sure, but at
least the debate is finally being
joined on a solid premise: the best
hope for achieving a happy
medium between the old, often
coarse-but undeniably human-
elements of the street and slick
new development lies in the fact
that we have begun to view 42nd
Street not just as part of Times
Square, not just as a connector
of grand avenues, but as a land-
scape and legend in itself. 11
Phil Patton is a Brooklyn-based
writer interested in architecture
and design.
The McGraw-Hill
Building.
Trompe 1'oeil murals
near the Lincoln
Tunnel entrance.
listening new
buildings now rub
elbows with
monuments of the
skyscraper era.
Plans to revitalize Bryant Park include reland-
scaping (above) to encourage new uses (below).

PM NOT
COMMUNITIES ACT
S eattle's colorful
Pike Place Market
sits on a steep hill
above Elliott Bay,
a remnant of the
city's past that has recently
become a catalyst for its
future. Just 20 years ago the
turn-of-the-century market,
now filled with farmer's stalls,
restaurants; and shops, was
scheduled for the wrecker's
ball. The fact that it has
survived-and prospered-
since then is a tribute to a
phenomenon that is quintes-
sentially American: ordinary
citizens acting together to
preserve and utilize their
shared environment. Commu-
nity action has a long history
in this country, and the story
of the Pike Place Market is a
shining example of how it can
work.
The market was founded in
1907, when Seattle's rapid
Saving a Piece of Seattle's Past
~ growth and status
~ as the gateway to
oa the Yukon had
~ created a demand
°
2 for inexpensive
3 produce. Other
food shops sprang
m up nearby, and by
the 1930s there
were as many as
600 farmers rent-
ing stalls there
each day to sell
their fruits and
vegetables. But
World War II
brought disaster:
almost half the
farmers were of
Japanese descent,
and their intern-
ment decimated
the market. After
the war, changing
life-styles-migra-
tion to the sub-
urbs, the advent
of supermarkets
and of frozen
foods-contrib-
uted to the mar-
ket's continued
decline. By 1963
the run-down buildings that
made up Pike Place Market
were slated for demolition
and replacement by a parking
lot and assorted high-rise
buildings.
That was when some mem-
bers of the community de-
cided to take action. The late
Victor Steinbrueck, then a
professor of architecture at the
University of Washington,
denounced the city's proposal
as a "major catastrophe:' A
community group, Friends of
the Market, was formed in the
summer of 1964. Battle lines
were drawn.
For the next seven years the
Friends and other groups
worked to educate fellow
citizens and to oppose the
city's plans for redevelopment.
They staged fund-raising
events, such as auctions, tours,
and parties, and collected
more than 50,000 signatures
16 PHILIP iv1ORRIS MAGAZINE/SUMMER 1985
on a "Let's Keep the Market"
petition to present to Seattle's
City Council. Despite these
efforts, the City Council voted
against the preservationists but
fate intervened: federal funds
for urban renewal were frozen,
giving the Friends time to have
the market area declared a
historic district.
The Friends faced defeat
again in the spring of 1971,
when federal grant money was
awarded for the city's rede-
velopment project; they
countered by gathering the
signatures needed to put the
issue to a vote. As election day
neared, national attention
focused on Seattle: The New
York Times, Newsweek, and
Harper's were among the
publications that covered the
controversy. "You can't fight
progress. Or can you? Seattle
has just enough of the old
The bounty of Seattle's
Pike Place Market-
from produce to parking
lot-dazzles the eye.
frontier spunk to try," wrote
Donald Aspinwall Allan in
Gourmet. In November 1971
the citizens of Seattle voted
76,369 to 53,264 to preserve
the market.
Community involvement
didn't end with this victory. A
nonprofit agency was formed
to oversee the market's restora-
tion, and today-almost 14
years after the saving ballots
were cast-it is a vibrant part
of the city's center. Virginia
Felton, administrative director
of the Pike Place Market
Preservation and Develop-
ment Authority (which con-
tinues to manage the market),
says that Pike Place has been
"a catalyst for redevelopment"
in adjacent neighborhoods.
The market now provides
affordable space for Seattle's
farmers, craftsmen, and small
entrepreneurs, employing
some 2,000 people and attract-
ing 25,000 visitors each day.
Food has always been the
soul of Pike Place Market;
Felton says that "80 percent of
the revenues come from the
food stalls and restaurants"
About 80 farmers rent day-
stall spaces, among them a
new wave of Indo-Chinese
immigrants (from Vietnam,
China, Cambodia, and Tibet).
Food consultant, columnist,
and cookbook author Barbara
Kafka recently visited the
market and noted in an article
in Vogue that, like past waves
of immigrants, they have
brought with them "the
ingredients necessary for their
own food. Tiny white-green
bok choy with flourishes of
dark-green, ruffled leaves and
aromatic chrysanthemum
leaves for sushi flirt with
next-door bunches of basil and
rosemary." Kafka concluded
that "this nontourist market is
the best possible kind of urban
renewal, founded on a solid
link with the past." And, she
might have added, firmly
rooted in the hearts of Seattle's
citizens. p

olvement
victory. A
as formed
et's restora-
almost 14
ing ballots
ibrant part
r. Virginia
ve director
e Market
Develop-
hich con-
e market),
e has been
elopment"
orhoods.
provides
r Seattle's
and small
mploying
snd attract-
each day.
3 been the
e Market;
percent of
from the
;taurants:'
rent day-
g them a
-Chinese
Vietnam,
d Tibet).
lumnist,
r Barbara
Psited the
an article
ast waves
ey have
m "the
for their
ite-green
ishes of
aves and
hemum
irt with
basil and
ncluded
arket is
of urban
a solid
d, she
firmly
Seattle's
13
STUDY FINDS SMOKERS
MORE PRODUCTIVE
A Minnesota study of 55
bank executives found that
those who smoke are slightly
more productive than their
counterparts who don't. Ac-
cording to Tor Dahl, a health
economist at the University of
Minnesota, smokers were
found to utilize their produc-
tivity potential "slightly more
than nonsmokers" The study
also demonstrated that regular
exercise and age are factors
that increase productivity as
«.ep
ARTS IN AMERICA ON
THE RISE
Though Americans report
that their leisure time is shrink-
-_'ing, they are using this de-
creased time more carefully
and, as a result, the arts are
flourishing. According to a
Louis Harris study conducted
for Philip Morris, Americans
have less leisure time (time
spent other than working,
going to and from work, doing
chores, shopping, going to
school, or sleeping), a decrease
attributed to the lengthening
of the workweek and the
growing number of women
who now work outside the
home.
Americans are, however,
spending more of their valu-
able free time on the arts: the
study reported increased at-
tendance over 1975 figures
for movies (up 8 percent),
theater (up 14 percent), and
pop music concerts (up 14
percent). Participation in
KEE%WT'aucH
~ Dear Philin Mn-c
=.= If a city or county passes air pollution control
laws to "p: ;tect" nonsmokers from smokers, why
can't a class-action suit be filed forcing the city or
~-county to pass a law "protecting" non-car owners
from the Pollution caused by car owners?
Don Hale
Santa Rosa, CA
;°Philip Morris MaAazine replies: Laws that restrict smoking in
public places are inefficient. Differences between smokers and
nonsmokers are best handled through common courtesy.
Dear Philip Morris Magazine:
I am writing to inquire about organizations that
might have been established to combat the many
restrictions being imposed upon smokers. As a
smoker I am becoming more and more concerned
over the many rules, regulations, and laws
governing where an individual can and cannot
smoke.
Sue Jones
San Diego, CA
arts-related activities is also
up, most notably in the field
of photography, which has
grown phenomenally (from 19
percent participation in 1975
to 47 percent in 1984).
SMOKER FIGHTS
FOR RIGHTS
A Milwaukee tax collector
filed suit to protest his office's
no-smoking rule-and won. In
April 1984 a Wisconsin state
law took effect that restricts
smoking to designated areas in
government offices and other
public places (hospitals, the-
aters, elevators, stores, schools,
and large restaurants). Richard
Rossie's workplace, the De-
partment of Revenue, banned
smoking and Rossie sued,
claiming that the ban was
unconstitutional and would
cause him "extreme hardship
and irreparable injury:' Ac-
cording to his attorney, Rossie
risked discipline and dismissal
if he smoked on the job.
Circuit Judge P. Charles
Jones issued a temporary in-
junction against the Depart-
ment of Revenue in October
1984, following it with a
permanent injunction in Feb-
ruary 1985 that prohibits the
agency from disciplining
workers who smoke. Jones
told Associated Press that he
did not consider the constitu-
tional questions Rossie raised
but focused instead on the fact
that, since the state law does
not penalize violators, the
Department of Revenue's
no-smoking rule exceeded the
authority granted by the state
legislature. 11
Dear Philip Morris Magazine:
I heard that a pro-smoking organization is under
way and I would like to know more about it. Even
though I do not smoke myself, I am very interested
in supporting all such organizations. I feel every-
one should have the right to smoke if they so
choose. There are more and more places that are
banning smoking, and I feel that smokers are being
discriminated against.
In this day and age when everyone is fighting
discrimination, the tobacco industry seems to be
getting the blunt end of the deal. I would appreci-
ate any information you could send me.
Maynard P. Wright 111
Quinton, VA
Philip Morris Magazine replies: Thank you both for your inter-
est in smokers' rights. To help our message be heard above the
static of the antismoking hysteria, we urge you to write to your
elected representatives and tell them how you feel about laws
prohibitingsrnoking. Some organizations that might be of inter-
est to you are:
The Tobacco Institute; 1875 I St., NW; Washington, DC 20006
Smokers United; James Steward, President; 301 East 69th St.;
New York, NY 10021
Smokers Club; Bob Carli, President; 506 Ohio St., Apt. 8; Terre
Haute, IN 47807
National Smokers Rights; Ronald Flynt, President; Box 1773;
Goldsboro, NC 27503
Freedom Organization for the Right to Enjoy Smoking Tobacco
(FOREST); Sir Christopher Foxley-Norris, President; Bond
Way House; 3/9 Bond Way; London SW8 1SJ England.
PHILIP MORRIS MAGAZINE/SUMMER 1985 17

PM NOiEB00K
AT ISSUE:
Why Excise Taxes Don't Work
An interview with economist Ingo Walter
Professor Ingo Walter is chair-
man of finance at New York
University's Graduate School
of Business Administration.
He has also served as a consul-
tant to various U.S. govern-
ment agencies, including the
Department of Commerce and
the Environmental Protection
Agency. Prof. Walter recently
spoke with Philip Morris
Magazine about the impact
of increased tobacco excise
taxes on the national economy.
PM: How does an excise tax
function?
Prof. Walter: An excise tax is
basically a sales tax on a
particular product, as opposed
to a general sales tax that
applies to all products or to
broad groups of products. The
purpose of the excise tax is to
target one specific product that
the government feels is rela-
tively insensitive to price, so
that not much less of the
product will be bought at a
higher price than at a lower
price. It's a good revenue-
raising device.
PM: Some people have termed
excises on cigarettes or alcohol
"sin taxes:' Is there a history
of that kind of taxation in this
country?
Prof. Walter: We've really not
had a history of that in the
United States. The whole
purpose of taxation is to raise
revenue for the government,
but very often the revenue-
raising function is altered to
achieve some other social
goals. The very fact, though,
that products like cigarettes are
relatively insensitive to price
increases, as I explained be-
fore, tends to make the "sin"
dimension self-defeating. And
whenever you tax a specific
product you make it more
valuable and expensive, and
you effectively place a pre-
mium on it. So it may have
the opposite effect in terms of
consumption.
PM: So, in a sense, when a
product like tobacco becomes
more expensive, it also be-
comes more attractive?
Prof. Walter: You're increasing
its value in the eyes of the
consumer. Exorbitant prices
also encourage smuggling and
other corrupt behavior... it
creates criminal activity, law
enforcement costs, and so on.
PM: How do increased excise
taxes affect the economy?
,Prof. Walter: Taxes applied to
a particular product distort
consumer purchasing patterns,
so that people buy less of the
taxed product and more of
untaxed products. If we tax
cigarettes, you get fewer
resources allocated to the
manufacturing and sale and
advertising of tobacco prod-
ucts on the production side,
and more allocations of re-
sources to other things. If you
tax cigarettes more than shoes,
let's say, you may end up
diverting labor and capital
into the shoe business with the
result that resources are mis-
allocated. Labor, for example,
goes from a higher level of
productivity to a lower level
of productivity. The result is
a drop in the efficiency with
which labor is used in the
national economy.
PM: How does this redirection
of consuming patterns ulti-
mately lower national revenue?
Prof. Walter: In a capitalist,
market-oriented system like
ours, without distortions that
favor one particular industry
over another, you tend to get
the flow of both capital and
labor into those areas in which
they're most productively
used. Whenever you put a
distortion in markets, such as
rent controls or excise taxes,
you shift the pattern of labor
and capital allocation, so you
divert these resources from
more productive to less pro-
ductive uses. As a result, real
income and output drops, and
18 PHILIP MORRIS MAGAZINE/SUMMER 1985
the real rate of economic
growth may decline as well,
because we're not just talking
about efficiency in using
resources today, but also how
they expand and get allocated
over time.
PM: So increasing excise taxes
could mean that there could
actually be less revenue for the
federal or the state govern-
ment down the line?
Prof. Walter: Well, besides the
distortive effect I've just
described, when you raise
taxes beyond a certain point,
the product may no longer be
quite as insensitive to price
increases as it was before.
Demand may fall off. Con-
sumers may say, 'Hey, ciga-
rettes are now $9 a pack and
I'm going to quit smoking, or
I'm going to cut down and
spend more of my money on
something else: At very high
prices, in other words, product
demand may be more sensitive
to further tax hikes than it is
at very low prices. Up to now
cigarette consumption has not
been all that sensitive to price
increases, but that may not be
true forever. When you think
about cigarettes costing, say,
$10 or $20 a pack compared
to today's prices, it would
make sense that sooner or later
a consumption drop-off is
going to lead to a reduction
in actual tax revenues. But we
haven't experienced that yet,
which is one reason the gov-
ernment is continually encour-
aged to raise taxes. But eventu-
ally it could kill the goose that
lays the golden eggs.
PM: So the problem with
trying to keep these types of
taxes within reasonable
bounds is that so far they have
been profitable?
Prof. Walter: That's right, but
you know, there's more than
one issue at stake here. There
is a philosophical question of
whether it is correct to tax
individual products: Is it
correct to punish the consum-
ers of pipe tobacco or cognac
compared with the consumers
of ice cream or salmon, for
example? I think you can
argue on pretty strong grounds
that excise taxes are really not
a particularly good way to
raise government revenues
because of their distortive
effect on the market and
production, which we dis-
cussed earlier, and because of
the punitive effect on certain
consumers.
PM: When are excise taxes
justifiable, if ever?
Prof. Walter: When they
become a use tax, like the
highway toll and tunnel toll I
pay each morning. I'm paying
for the use of a public facility.
I may not be paying exactly
what the resource is worth,
but, by and large, use taxes are
simply an attempt at pricing
a public service. So economists
would generally defend use
taxes, especially if they can be
tailored to the user's marginal
benefit.
PM: What does that mean?
Prof. Walter: Well, for exam-
ple, in tunnel tolls, if you can

h
have different tolls at different
times of day, so that during
rush hour it costs, say, $12 to
go across the Hudson, and
during non-rush hour it costs
504. The tax is aligned with
the demand patterns and the
marginal benefit the user gets
from crossing the Hudson. Just
as when you fly first-class you
pay a higher ticket tax than if
you fly economy.
PM: Have excise taxes on
cigarettes gone up in recent
years in response to federal,
state, and local budgetary
problems, so that excises are
being used to fill in the gaps?
Prof. Walter: I think that's
probably true. When the
Reagan administration reduced
effective personal income and
business taxes, the government
had to look for other tax
resources. There have also
been substantial budget cuts
and restraints put on federal
outlays, and part of that's hit
the states and municipalities,
there s no doubt about that.
The states and municipalities
also have received a smaller
share of the federal revenue
pie, so they too have to
compensate by trying to raise
more revenues on their own.
So if municipal and state
governments want to increase
spending, or even maintain
spending, for education or
other socially useful purposes,
they have to turn to their own
indirect or direct taxes. But
people are fed up with rising
property taxes and income
taxes and municipality taxes,
and the states can't pass the
increase in budget outlays on
to the feds because Washing-
ton is reducing its support,
such as revenue sharing. So,
you know, a lot of governors
and mayors are behind the
eight ball. They've got budget
problems that need to be
addressed. So an indirect tax
on a product that is politically
vulnerable is a fairly attractive
way to raise additional state
and local revenues. One place
to look is indirect taxes, like
the cigarette tax.
PM: So, in effect, people who
consume alcohol or cigarettes
-targets for excise increases-
are taking up the slack for the
whole community?
Prof. Walter: Yes, they are
being discriminated against in
a revenue sense because of
their preferred consumption
patterns. When there is tre-
mendous pressure on the part
of government t.-, raise money,
it's going to turn to the easiest
and most politically vulnera-
ble areas to target. How are
people going to defend them-
selves against a discriminatory
tax increase of this kind when
smokers and drinkers don't like
to identify themselves as such?
It's sort of a tyranny of the
majority.
PM: What would be a less
discriminatory way to raise
revenue to fill in those gaps?
Prof. Walter: Well, I think a
good nondiscriminatory way
is to increase general sales
taxes. And one way that hasn't
been tried in the United States
is a value-added tax.
PM: What is that?
Prof. Walter: Let's say you
own a retail drugstore, and to
purchase the goods you sell
costs you $100,000 per week,
and then you sell them for
$120,000, so $20,000 is your
markup. That $20,000 is
considered the value that you
add in the selling process.
Taxing that amount by, say,
20 percent would mean con-
sumers would pay $4,000
specifically on that $20,000 of
added value. For example, the
consumer would pay "1.20 for
a toothbrush, plus 54 value-
added tax. This is a good tax
because it's very difficult to
evade. It taxes consumption
rather than savings, so it
encourages the latter. And it's
very broadly based so it
doesn't distort production or
consumption patterns, as we
discussed earlier. The only
disadvantage is that it tends
to hit poor people harder than
rich people because they have
to spend [proportionally]
more of their income, so more
of their income is subject to
the value-added tax. On the
other hand, if you think that's
a problem, then you could
couple the tax with increased
financial assistance to truly
needy people. Most countries
have a value-added tax; the
United States doesn't. Another
good thing about it is that
exports are not subject to the
tax (while imports are), so
your domestic producers are
not subject to competitive
distortions.
PM: Are there any other ways
in which the government
could increase its revenue
without raising excise taxes?
Prof. Walter: The government
could simplify the income tax
system we have, which is
probably the most
complex in the world,
and close some of the
tax loopholes that
give the impression
the tax system is high-
ly unfair. Some people
simply feel they pay
more than their fair
share of taxes. I feel
that way; you prob-
ably feel that way
too when you read
about somebody
who's got a $2 million
annual income and
doesn't pay a penny [in
taxes]. So these are two
possibilities -closing
off some of the loop-
holes and reforming
the direct tax system,
plus a value-added
tax or other broad-based tax
on consumption. This would
be much superior to the sys-
tem we have now and to rely-
ing more intensively on excise
taxes.
PM: Why are user-specific
taxes, like the taxes on ciga-
rettes, often called "hidden
taxes"?
Prof. Walter: If you go to the
supermarket and buy a basket-
ful of groceries, you know
exactly what your tax is
because it is stated on the sales
slip, and you can decide
whether you want to get upset
about it or not. With ciga-
rettes, it does not say on the
pack how much of the price is
federal tax or how much is
state tax. It is all included in
the purchase price, so you
don't really know the tax
incidence. This means you, as
a voter, canndt react intelli-
gently to the tax.
PM: What can people do
about it?
Prof. Walter: The public has
not yet reacted to this kind of
hidden tax. The politicians like
that. They can probably get
away with having a higher
total tax burden by hiding it.
Smokers haven't organized
themselves very well for
political action; until they do,
these types of taxes will remain
hidden and probably keep on
rising. E3
PHILIP MORRIS MAGAZINE/SUMMER 1985 19

PM NOi
AT ISSUE:
Living With San Francisco's No-Smoking Law
n November 8, 1983,
San Francisco voters
narrowly approved (by
just 80,798 to 79,541
votes) an ordinance gov-
erning smoking in the work-
place-one of the nation's
toughest. The law requires em-
ployers to accommodate the
needs of both their smoking
and nonsmoking employees,
but the law is biased toward
nonsmokers: if no accom-
modation can be reached,
the employer must ban smok-
ing in his or her workplace
altogether.
San Francisco's health de-
partment is responsible for
enforcing the law. When a
complaint is lodged by an
employee, the offending em-
ployer is supposed to be cited
and then granted a hearing. If
the employer is deemed to be
violating the law, the law
requires him to pay a civil
penalty of $100 per day per
nonsmoking worker (whose
rights are supposedly being
violated) up to a maximum of
$500 a day.
Today, over a year after the
new law took effect, there have
been skirmishes but there is no
smoking war. Yet the law's
apparent success raises a
question: was this law really
needed?
A spokesman for the To-
bacco Institute in Washington,
D.C., says that the very fact
that the law is working proves
that it is unnecessary. He says
the low number of complaints-
only 115 have been filed since
March 1984 -demonstrates
that people have a tendency
to work these kinds of dis-
agreements out by themselves.
"The last time I talked to some-
one about the San Francisco
law, he said it was working
beautifutly," he says. "What
this tells me, however, is that
San Francisco didn't need a
law like that in the first place.
Nonsmokers aren't going to
call the police on a coworker.
People worked out disagree-
ments among themselves
before the law was passed;
they're still working things
out. And anyway," he adds,
posing a rhetorical question,
"are you going to tell me that
in San Francisco, a city of
individuals, people are going
to be afraid to express their
preferences [without a law]?"
Office Politics
The San Francisco Chronicle
employs some 300 workers,
most crowded into large news-
rooms, and a fair number of
them are vociferous defenders
of what they see as one's right
to smoke undisturbed. It may
be the law, they say, but it's a
bad law.
The Chronicle's manage-
ment considered, but rejected,
the option of segregating
smokers from nonsmokers.
Instead, a five-by-ten-foot area
near the company coffee pot
was designated as the official
smoking area for the entire
editorial floor, with individual
rooms becoming "off limits" to
smokers as soon as single
employees filed a formal
complaint with management
(the complainant is allowed to
remain anonymous). This
arrangement has pleased
nonsmokers but smokers
complain of the inconvenience
of getting up to go to the coffee
machine whenever they feel
like enjoying a cigarette. And
some department heads feel
their workers are absent from
their desks more often than
they should be.
One reporter says that she
resents the way the law has
made her a pariah in the
workplace. "Being asked to
smoke somewhere else is not a
personal thing," she says, "but
20 PHILIP MORRIS MAGAZINE/SUMMER 1985
no matter how nicely someone
asks you, it's devastating:"
Elson Snow, a printer at the
San Francisco Chronicle and
the San Francisco Examiner
and a member of the Interna-
tional Typographical Union,
feels cheated by the non-
smoking law. He says his
problem with the law is that
the newspapers' managements
unilaterally changed the con-
ditions of his employment-
declaring that those who dis-
obeyed would be fired-with-
out working out any agreement
with his union. He feels that
San Francisco's citizens had
no right to enact a law that
in such situations, the law is
unenforceable.
According to Bruce Tsutsui,
the city health inspector
charged with enforcing the
ordinance, 115 complaints
have been filed by employees
since the law took effect, and
all but a dozen still pending
have been resolved. Only one
company has been cited for
noncompliance, and that
complaint was settled before
the case went to any formal
hearing.
That citation was filed
against a small repair office of
Pacific Bell, and a no-smoking
notice was posted there the
"No matter how nicely
someone asks you [not to smoke],
it's still devastating:"
changed his conditions of em-
ployment, and he believes that
smoking rules should be set by
individual employers, not by
the health department. In fact,
the principle behind the law
sets his teeth on edge: "Do you
want Big Brother watching
you?" he asks.
An Unenforceable Law
In some workplaces the ordi-
nance is ignored by consensus.
A small magazine publisher,
The Hagen Group, employs
25 people in one large, win-
dowless room divided only by
partitions. Only five of the 25
coworkers are smokers but
none of the nonsmokers have
filed a formal complaint. In
offices like this-and there are
many in the city-the fear of
antagonizing colleagues and a
reluctance to "rock the boat"
have canceled out any "pro-
tection" the ordinance is
supposed to offer nonsmokers;
same day the citation arrived
from the health department.
But the complaint spawned
hard feelings in Pacific Bell's
Sales Development Center.
Patrick Woodridge, a tempo-
rary assistant manager, told
the San Francisco Chronicle
last September that "a few
people resent the fact that the
issue was not brought out into
the open and discussed in the
office" before the complaint
was filed. "There are still deeply
harbored ill feelings;" he said,
adding that the unpleasantness
is "no longer a topic of dis-
cussion"
Sneaking Around
For a Smoke
The Chronicle reported that
smokers in that Pacific Bell
office are now required to
retire to a small conference
room when they want a smoke.
"It's like sneaking from your
mommy and daddy," com-
lU VnILIr 1vL-.....,

A
plained Jewel Johnson, a
company service representa-
tive, to the Chronicle. "I feel
that in the time I spend coming
in here to take a smoke I could
be taking another call at my
desk" Indeed, Denise Lyons,
a service representative who
is no longer a smoker herself,
told the Chronicle that she
thought the new rule had
made the office less efficient.
"Anytime you're going in one
direction and have to stop, it
puts a break in productivity,"
she explained.
So the no-smoking law-a
law that is, in many situations,
unenforceable-has compli-
cated the lives of San Francisco
office workers. Where once the
choice belonged to individual
workers, today the choice of
a slim majority has been
forced on all citizens. Where
once the choice to smoke was
governed by common cour-
tesy, today the choice is dic-
tated by a law that makes no
accommodations for special
situations. Where once smok-
ing was a choice that fit into
the normal pattern of a work
day, today smoking means
disrupting productivity. And
some critics worry that the no-
smoking law represents a trend
toward intolerance. "If the
time has come ... to ask gov-
ernment to keep people who
smoke away from people who
don't, why stop there?" asked
writer Frank Robertson in Cal-
ifornia magazine. "I know
experts right now who will
swear that even the briefest
exposure to lacto-vegetarians,
followers of Rajneesh, preppies,
tort lawyers, rock critics, wine
snobs, restaurateurs who serve
cuisine, men who wear ear-
rings, people who read Run-
ner's World magazine, the
Grateful Dead, enema thera-
pists, Rolfers, leafleteers, sup-
porters of Proposition P and
anyone dressed in camouflage
army fatigues can cause drug
use in lab rats and may pose a
measurable hazard to human
health. I know they won't go
away, so I just hope we can
construct enough corrals,
cubicles, or glassed-in places
for them..." 0
Courtesy Calls
When humorist Fran Lebo-
witz (author of Metropolitan
Life and Social Studies) ap-
peared on the television show
Face the Nation, she was inter-
viewed by Leslie Stahl on the
subject of smoking in public.
"I think the notion that you
have the right to go around
telling other people what to do
is a very weird notion of what
public means," she said. "To
me, being offended is a na-
tural consequence of leaving
one's home. Other people of-
fend me all the time, but I
don't feel it necessary to make
a law against them:'
Increasingly, smokers are
being confronted by zealous
nonsmokers eager to ban the
right to smoke in public places.
Dr. Robert London, director of
the short-term psychotherapy
unit at New York University
Medical Center, says that
militant nonsmokers some-
times go out of their way to
be rude to smokers: "Many of
them don't understand that
they're not on a crusade for
all of humanity, and that it is
not their job to deliberately sit
around waiting for somebody
to light up just so they can
enter into an extended dia-
logue about the public health,"
he says. In an effort to clear
the air and revive plain old
manners, London recently
conducted a Nonsmokers'
Etiquette Clinic at a branch of
Manhattan's popular New
York Health & Racquet Club.
"I'm really against confronta-
tional techniques, because
people have the right to
smoke;" says London. "Smok-
ing is a habit for many people,
part of a life-style for many
people.... You can't beat on
people for smoking because
they're not doing something
wrong, they're doing some-
thing that they want to do"
In his seminar London cited
specific situations to illustrate
his point. Take, for example,
the nonsmoker who is stand-
ing in line for movie tickets
and begins to harass the smok-
er in front of him. London
has no sympathy for non-
smokers who act rudely in
such a temporary situation:
"There's no need to ask some-
one to put out their cigarette
if it's not bothering you," he
says. "As long as the smoker is
not deliberately blowing
smoke in the nonsmoker's
face, there's no need for con-
frontation:'
Other situations-the di-
lemma of the nonsmoking of-
fice worker whose boss is a
chain-smoker, for example, or
the nonsmoker who finds
himself on a blind date with a
smoker-require more tact
and, says London, "class." In
both cases he advises that the
nonsmoker politely ask the
smoker not to light up. Then,
if the request is denied, he
suggests retreat: transfer to
another part of the office or
company; end the date. In the
case of married couples in
conflict over smoking, how-
ever, London does not suggest
divorce. "You can establish a
smoking area in the house," he
says, "or agree not to smoke
around your spouse."
What guidelines does Lon-
don suggest for good etiquette
on the part of smokers? First,
he says, always ask, "Do you
mind if I smoke?" before
lighting up. "It's only right;"
says London. "After all, we ask
people, 'Do you mind if I use
your phone?' or if we're hun-
gry, 'Do you mind if I go to
your refrigerator?"' If the an-
swer to this question is yes,
London advises the polite
smoker to ask, "Do you have
a place where I can smoke?"
and then to graciously retreat
to the suggested spot.
Perhaps the real answer,
then, is simply etiquette-and
that old American custom of
respecting others ' rights. O
Militant nonsmokers
sometimes go out of their way
to be rude to smokers.
PHILIP MORRIS MAGAZINE/SUMMER 1985 21
I

Martina and Chris are still on top, but these eager new players are on their way up. ~-
1NE
IO Wa1CH IN WOMEN'S IENN4S
22 PHILIP MORRIS MAGAZINEJSUMMER 1985
BY MARY WITHERELL
To the majority of American
tennis fans, the women's com-
petition thus far in the 1980s
can easily be summarized as
"Martina, Chris, and every-
body else"
Even though it's a bit pre-
mature to predict the end of
the stranglehold that number-
one ranked Martina Navratil-
ova and number-two ranked
Chris Evert Lloyd have on the
top rankings of the Women's
Tennis Association, there are
still more than just a couple
of good reasons to watch
women's tennis in 1985.
The six players profiled here
are by no means the only
promising young athletes
around, but they are represen-
tative of the whole-a strong
nucleus of young women who
believe deeply in the coming
of a day when they will con-
sistently battle the two titans
on even terms. A few have
already pulled such an upset:
Manuela Maleeva won her
Italian Open title last May at
the expense of Evert Lloyd,
and Helena Sukova shocked
Navratilova in the semifinals
of last December's Australian
Open. With the smack of an
unhesitant forehand volley
and the thud of a crosscourt
backhand landing just inside
the line, women's tennis moves
into the middle of this decade
led by the promise of its
champions-to-be.
MANUELA MALEEVA
In two and a half years on the
Virginia Slims tour, Manuela
Maleeva has gone from being
number 154, and a complete
unknown, to number four and
a worldwide media celebrity.
In one two-week span this
January, Maleeva received 150
interview requests from the
American press. Does she get
this much attention back home
in Sofia, Bulgaria? "Yeah, they
know;" she says, slightly
embarrassed.
In short, the world has gone
bonkers for Maleeva, a soft=
spoken, intelligent, and ex:
tremely modest 18-year-oldf
with tremendous shot-making-"
ability. Maleeva's baseline;.
game is so solid and is played+
with such organization andt
control that she evokes coml
parisons with Evert Lloyd-}
only with the qualifier that;
Maleeva may prove to have aJ
much wider arsenal of weap-
ons. ons. Her serve and drop shoti
already are way above aver-;
age for a player who generally ;
stays back at the baseline, and'
her net game is what she prac- `
tices most these days.
Although Maleeva's fame '.
had begun growing in 1982
when she improved her com-
puter ranking 84 places in
seven months, 1984 was the
year that fixed her name in
everybody's minds, as she won
the first five tournaments of
her career plus the mixed
doubles championship (with
Tom Gullikson) at the U.S.
Open. Along the way she
knocked off virtually every-
one-except Navratilova-
and were it not for the Sovie~
bloc boycott of the Los
Angeles Olympics, she prob-
ably would have won the
Olympic tennis championship
as well.
Perhaps not so coincidental-
ly, Bulgaria's last great tennis
player was Maleeva's mother,
Yulia Berberian, a nine-time `
national champion, and its
next great player may be _
Manuela's younger sister, `
15-year-old Katerina, who is `
already a professional. (Nine-
year-old Magdalena plays a '
mean game, too.) As for the '
two older sisters forming a
doubles team, it seems just a'
matter of time.
HELENA SUKOVA
Like Manuela Maleeva, 20-
year-old Helena Sukova of
Prague,Czechoslovakia, had a
good teacher. Vera Sukova,
Helena's mother and a 1962
Wimbledon finalist, was also
her coach until she died in
1982. As the former Czech
national team coach, however,
2040235208

E
A
she has left behind a legacy of
serve-and-volley artists includ-
ing not only her daughter but
also Navratilova and Hana
Mandlikova. But Vera Suko-
va's youngest pupil may turn
out to be her greatest.
At 6 feet, 1~/z inches (she's
the tallest player on the wom-
en's tour) and with an explo-
sive serve, Helena has all the
tools already at her disposal.
Even before she upset Navra-
tilova at the Australian Open,
her talent was showing. She
won her first tournament, the
National Panasonic Classic in
Brisbane,Australia , and made
it to the quarterfinals or be-
yond in a dozen other events.
Near the end of the year,
Sukova joined forces with
number-six ranked Claudia
Kohde-Kilsch to become the
tallest (Kohde-Kilsch is just
over six feet tall) and most
powerful women's doubles
team in the world.
Since her defeat of Navra-
tilova, which ended Martina's
bid to win the calendar Grand
Slam, Sukova has now been
"discovered" by the media and
may now be ready to begin
comparing notes on the sub-
ject of fame with Maleeva.
Nevertheless, this shy but
friendly woman insists that the
sport that has brought her
$485,000 in barely two years
as a pro is only "a hobby;" and
she plans to attend law school
after she completes her second-
ary education.
ZINA GARRISON
Talk about basic success stories
naturally leads to the subject
of number-nine ranked Zina
Garrison. Consider the fact
that, unlike the vast majority
of pros, Garrison learned to
play tennis in a public parks
program in an inner-city neigh-
borhood in Houston, Texas.
No private courts or tennis
academies for her, only the
park at which she still prac-
tices, which is near the house
where she grew up and still
lives with her six brothers and
sisters. She is only the second
~ black woman ever to hold a
top-ten ranking (the first was
i Althea Gibson in the late
1950s).
Garrison began her athletic
career as a softball player, but
switched sports at the age of
ten when brother Rodney
brought her to MacGregor
Park and the pro there put a
racket in her hand. In eight
years the compact (5 feet, 41/z
inches), powerfully built
woman became the number-
one junior in the world and de-
buted as a pro in the number
29 slot in 1982. Now 21 years
old, Garrison has only one
victory, the European Indoor
Championships, to her credit,
but a slew of quarter- and
semifinal appearances and
three runner-up finishes in two
and a half years on tour.
One of Zina's greatest assets
is her ability to play an all-
court game that is easily
adaptable to different surfaces.
She can rally from the baseline
or win points at the net if the
situation calls for it. That same
style serves her well off the
court, too, where her endorse-
ments (for Carnation Instant
Breakfast and Breakfast Bars)
call for lots of personal ap-
pearances. At one recent
appearance at a Brooklyn
public school, students had
learned her life story and
strung the halls with banners
bearing her name. For Zina
Garrison, it could be that the
kids can see her future.
PAM CASALE
On the surface, Pam Casale's
career sounds like it has the
makings of a great Hollywood
"happy ending" film. Within
six months of turning profes-
sional at age 17, she had
achieved a ranking of number
16 in the world. Pretty heady
stuff for a teenager, even one
who has come up through the
highly regarded Nick Bollet-
tieri tennis academy in Florida
and won five national titles
before she was 15.
But, as Casale says, it was
a case of too much, too soon.
By the middle of 1983, she had
fallen into the number 60 po-
sition and was completely
disheartened. She, like so
many other young players,
had not been able to handle
success and was considering
giving up the sport. The happy
ending is that this hard-hitting
baseliner didn't quit, but
instead resolved to go back to
basics and now has returned
to a prominent position (num-
ber 15) on the computer.
"I feel very fortunate," says
the 21-year-old Fairfield, New
Jersey, native in retrospect. "It
was a hard time, but I learned
Over six feet
tall, Helena
Sukova
(facing
page) is the
tallest
player on
the women's
tour. This
page, Zina
Garrison
(top) learned
her game in
a public
parks pro-
gram in
Houston,
while
Manuela
Maleeva
(center)
was coach-
ed by her
mother, one
of Bulgaria s
greatest
tennis play-
ers. Pam
Casale (bot-
tom),a grad-
uate of the
famed Nick
Bollettieri
academy,
won five
national
titles before
she was 75.

Concentra-
tion shows
on the
faces of
Alycia "Tex"
Moulton
(left) and
17-year-old
Michelle
Torres
(below).
Moulton, a
graduate of
Stanford,
plans to
enter law
school
eventually;
Torres is a
recent high
school
graduate.
a lot from it, too, and I certain-
ly don't want to go through it
again. Now I know what I
have to do:'
Despite the fact that she did
not reach a singles final in
1984, something she had done
several times before, the
tenacious Casale calls this past
season the highlight of her
career because it was a truly
consistent year, filled with
regular trips to the quarter-
finals and semifinals and no
first-round upsets. Consis-
tency, she says, is what will
decide who succeeds Navrati-
lova and Lloyd at the top, and
getting there would be the
happiest ending of all.
ALYCIA MOULTON
Twenty-four-year-old Alycia
Moulton is a tall (5 feet, 10~j2
inches), striking woman who
honed her skills at Stanford,
where she also got a degree in
political science, just in case
she goes to law school when
she retires from the tour. The
decision to either stay in
college or turn pro is a very
hard one for many players.
Only about one-third of all
the players in the top 150 who
attended college now have
their degrees, so, obviously,
the trend is to turn pro. How-
ever, Moulton's game was not
as well developed as it is now
and so she didn't think she was
ready either for the rigors of
tour life or the challenge of
playing against the best in the
world. "Had I been much
better than I was when I
entered college," Moulton
says, "there would have been
some element of indecision,
but I value education and I still
think I probably would have
ended up going to school."
Moulton, who was born in
Sacramento, California, and
now resides a stone's throw
from her alma mater in Palo
Alto (facts that do nothing to
explain her nickname of "Tex"),
has no reason to regret her
decision. Her ranking has
improved since her graduation
in 1983, with her current
standing-number 18-a
notch higher than in previous
rankings. In 1984 she had
great success in doubles,
winning two titles and being
runner-up in another-with
two different partners. She
also made the singles finals at
the Canadian Open and the
quarters at the Virginia Slim
of Boston.
"I think that right now I'n
capable of doing very grea
things and very poor things;
says Moulton with a laugh,
"and what I'm working towarc
is narrowing the gap"
MICHELLE TORRES
Although 17-year-old Michelle
Torres has been a professional
only since last September's
U.S. Open, she has already
earned $48,500. Her ranking
is number 21, despite her
infrequent tour travel. She
was named Tennis magazine's
Rookie of the Year in 1984 on
the strength of an incredible
month of October, during
which she won one tourna-
ment, the Florida Federal
Open, and finished second in
another, the Lynda Carter-
Maybelline Classic. On top of
this, Torres maintained an A
average at New Trier West
High School near her home-
town of Northfield, Illinois
(she graduated in June).
It's rare that a young player
does so well as a pro, but given
the fact that education, not
tennis, is her priority, her rec-
ord is downright amazing.
(Although she will not immedi-
ately proceed to college, she
says it is definitely in her
future,)
Like Maleeva, the dark-
haired, soft-spoken Torres ex-
presses surprise over how well
she has done; unlike Maleeva,
Torres did not just turn pro
and begin tearing up the
circuit. Torres spent each
summer from 1982 to 1984 on
tour and in that span was a
two-time semifinalist and
five-time quarterfinalist while
also maintaining a top-ten
world ranking as a junior.
Patience and a low-key style
extends to her personal life as
well; Torres, whose father is a
neurosurgeon, is taking her
time deciding on any product
endorsements. One oft-told
story recounts how, with the
$29,000 winning check in
hand from her first pro vic-
tory, she went out and bought
a car. Only instead of driving
home a BMW or Porsche,
Torres decided on a more
practical Toyota Supra. L]
Mary Witherell is a writer
who specializes in women's
svorts.
2040235210
24 PHILIP MORRIS MAGAZINE/SUMMER 1985

PROFILES
AGROWING CONCERN
For this North Carolina farmer
raising tobacco is a family tradition
BY RICK MASHBURN
W hen Richard
Whitaker was
growing up on a
tobacco farm in
Randolph Coun-
ty, in the Pied-
mont area of
central North
Carolina, he couldn't wait to finish school so
he could leave tobacco farming behind. "Never
would I do that, I thought. Tobacco farming
was too much hard work;" he remembers.
"He didn't like it because he couldn't play
ball, that's why," chimes in Richard's wife,
Faylene. She gives him a big smile.
He goes on, pretending to ignore her: "But
then I spent one summer installing Sheetrock,
and I decided tobacco wasn't that bad"
TRADITIONAL PURSUIT
Today, Richard Whitaker and his family-
Faylene and sons Travis and Shane-live and
work on a 37-acre tobacco farm just a few miles
from his childhood home, near the county seat
of Asheboro. Their spacious two-story frame
house, a comfortable blend of the modern and
the old-fashioned, is testament to the success
of the farm. And the good humor that
accompanies a conversation with the family
attests to their contentment with their life.
"I really do enjoy raising tobacco now," he
"Tobacco has been real good to us;'
says farmer Richard Whitaker
(above). At right, a field of leafy
tobacco plants.

z 1 zSEC.,Ot, Z
FW
r 7
"~~~
ur.
~r.
%
r
4
OL
Aa
>r
er . , ~Wf~~
r
r
>
. .. ~:r - ...
~
....OVAM
a
0
®
..
,w.
i

says, "and I have to say that tobacco has been
real good to us"
Richard and Faylene have prospered in
tobacco for all of the 12 years of their marriage.
For several years they worked land that they
leased, then in 1977 they bought their farm and
settled in.
Maybe tobacco-growing gets in the blood:
not only was Richard's father a tobacco farmer,
but his grandfathers and their fathers were,
too. One of Richard's grandfathers, now in his
eighties and retired, still plants a single tobacco
plant at the end of his vegetable garden and
carefully tends it throughout the summer. "It
always comes out the prettiest of all;" says
seven-year-old Travis.
Yet heredity isn't the only means by which
the fever is transmitted: Faylene grew up in
nearby Asheboro, knew nothing about farming,
and never dreamed of living on a farm until
she married Richard. Now she is a full partner
in the operation, both keeping the books and
working in the fields. Much to her surprise, she
says, she likes it,
"When we got married;"
Richard recalls wryly, "my
grandfather told me I ought to
have more sense than to marry
somebody from town'."
"But after that first summer,"
says Faylene, "he came up to
me and said, 'I owe you an
apology."' And she adds, "At
first I thought it was super just
because I could be with Richard
all the time. I still think one of
the best things about tobacco
farming is that it keeps the
whole family together."
HELPING HANDS
Because tobacco is a labor-
intensive crop, requiring long
hours of handwork in the
fields, tobacco farms tend to
be relatively small, and farm-
ers usually rely on the help of
their wives, children, and ex-
tended family. "If we were
growing corn out in the Mid-
west, I could be working thirty
miles down the road and never
see my wife all day."
Richard and his father help
each other at different stages
of the operation, especially
during the preparation of the
fields and at planting and har-
vesting (which tobacco farm-
ers call "priming"). In addition
to the Whitakers' two full-time
employees, Faylene recruits
her sisters to help out during
the summer, and Richard's
mother and aunt work, too.
Travis and nine-year-old
Shane have a wide range of
duties on the farm, including
driving the tractor.
Every member of the
Whitaker family pit-
ches in at harvesttime
(left); their up-to-
date equipment and
modern methods con-
trast with the old-
fashioned processes
of decades past
(below).
"The kids are learning responsibility," Faylene
says. "They don't have to work if they don't
want to, but they don't get paid if they don't.
Shane worked two summers and bought a
motorbike.. "
"Not a motorbike, a motorcycle;' Shane cor-
rects her.
"... and Travis discovered that he'd have to
work if he wanted one too. And the boys love
living out here;' she continues. "We are close
enough to town-only fourteen miles-that they
can go swimming at the Y or bring their friends
home after school. They roam all over the place
and we don't have to worry about them'."
When they were newly married, Richard and
Faylene lived for a while in Asheboro, a town
of 15,000 that Richard found not at all to his
liking. "I'm like Daniel Boone; I want elbow-
room. It's even getting too crowded out here:"
One measure of Richard's passion for the land
is how much he likes to see it. The Whitakers'
house is set in a grove of trees on a slight hill
surrounded by their land; nearly every window
offers a lovely view of their gently undulating
fields, which stretch to meet
woods in every direction. "I
told my help I built the house
like this so I could lie in bed
upstairs and watch what they
were doing out in the fields;"
Richard laughs. He won't let
anyone else sit in his place at
the dinner table, Faylene says,
because it affords him the best
view of the pond, which lies at
the bottom of a slight slope
near the house.
"We owned this land for
three years before we built the
house and moved out here;"
says Richard. "When we fi-
nally moved in I felt like we
were really home"
KEEPING UP, DOING IT
RIGHT
Just as important as living on
the land, he says, is doing a
good job of farming that land:
"I value my know-how. I do
know how to grow that crop"
In fact, he normally takes
about 80,000 pounds of to-
bacco to market each fall.
The growing season begins
as early as February, when
seedling beds are planted and
promptly covered as protec-
tion from hard freezes. Fields
are prepared as weather allows
in the spring, and transplants
are set out in early April.
Throughout the summer the
tobacco farmer is busy culti-
vating (keeping the soil around
the plants loose); spraying with
herbicides and pesticides;
"topping" the plants, which
means cutting the blossoms off
PHILIP MORRIS MAGAZINE/SUMMER 1985 2 7

!
to encourage larger leaves; and "suckering;" re-
moving the shoots between the leaf and stem.
Priming and curing begin in late summer and
usually continue for six weeks. A tobacco plant
may be picked several times in the course of
priming, starting with the mature bottom leaves
and moving up the plant as successive groups
of leaves mature.
The first intensive work comes in the spring
when seedling plants are set into the fields. "It's
especially hectic if the weather has been wet
and you haven t been able to get your land ready
for planting;" says Richard. "Plants need to be
about six inches tall to transplant right, and
they grow pretty rapidly in the warm and moist
weather. If you let them go three days too long,
they're gonna be too big to set"
"Planting is my favorite part about tobacco;"
says Faylene. "It's fun when the weather is nice
and you get to be outside after being cooped
up all winter. By the time priming comes in the
fall you've been through a long, hot summer
and you're ready for it to be over."
Faylene says she enjoys the handwork that
other tobacco farmers find
tedious: "I like topping because
I can look back at a field and
see what I did. I even enjoy
suckering tobacco, and no-
body in their right mind likes
that"
"Kinda tells you something
about her, doesn't it?" Richard
deadpans.
"I'm just like that. I can't help
it;" says Faylene. "I just like
having everything right'."
Often during the growing
season, Faylene will get up at
4:30 A.M. to do her housework
and make sandwiches for the
workers before she heads out
to the field herself. "I'll make
fifty or sixty sandwiches in the
morning. Then I'll be doing the
bookwork at night. Everybody wants their
check right on time"
"A lot of times in the summer, when things
are getting bad, we talk to God;" Richard says.
"If it wasn't for that it would be a lot harder to
be a tobacco farmer."
Richard works to improve his knowledge of
farming by regularly participating in the
workshops offered by North Carolina's
Agricultural Extension Service. Recently he took
a course on production practices that was
sponsored by Philip Morris at North Carolina
State University. "There are always new vari-
eties of tobacco that are being developed, new
chemicals to use in the fields, and new
information on curing;" he explains.
For example, the process of curing tobacco
has changed greatly in the last few decades. Bulk
28 PHILIP MORRIS MAGAZINE/SUMMER 1985
The Whitakers-
Richard, Faylene,
Travis, and Shane-
gather for a family
portrait (top). A
view of curing barns
and farmland (above).
curing-clumping tobacco leaves in metal
frames to be dried in large barns-has replaced
the old-fashioned process of tying uncured
tobacco to long sticks by hand, a few leaves at
a time. And gas burners have replaced wood
fires as the method of curing. Though the labor
involved has been reduced, the farmer still needs
great knowledge, intuition, or luck, to achieve
the best product.
Tending a barn of tobacco is a lot like taking
care of a newborn baby; it's nonstop, around-
the-clock work. "It takes anywhere from five
to seven days to cure a barn of tobacco, on
average. And you have to watch it all the time.
This year's crop won't cure like last year's. In
fact, this week's won't cure like the one two
weeks from now. You got to look at it and see
what it needs:"
"People say you can just read a book and
learn to cure tobacco, but I don't believe that;"
says Faylene. "I learned a lot about tobacco from
reading books, but not that part" Moreover,
while the tobacco in the barns is being cured,
more tobacco must be harvested. "And that's
when the stuff is coming in
from your vegetable garden
too;" Richard says. "You're usu-
ally priming and curing for
about six weeks, and for three
weeks there things are really
rushed" As many as 14 peo-
ple will be working the Whi-
takers' fields during priming.
Although automation and
s improved farming practices
have made things easier for the
m tobacco farmer, Richard has
E enough nostalgia for the old
L ways to have hung in his house
t a framed picture of a farmer
~ behind a plow and a mule.
mber ve
we11 the
~ "I r
m
ry
e
e
; first time I cultivated with a
N mule. I was in the fourth
grade. I thought I was really
doing something;' he recalls. "For some reason
Daddy was not there but had told me to do it.
It didn't look too good to my Granddad, so
he made me do it over."
Richard has had more success in running his
own tobacco farm. Out of 12 seasons, only one
has failed to show a profit.
"You know, what bothers me is that a
lot of people have got the wrong impres-
sion of a tobacco farmer," he says. "They
think he's somebody on the dumb side, who
goes around in dirty overalls all the time.
Today, and in the future, a farmer is going
to have to be a smart businessman to be in
tobacco'." 11
Rick Mashburn is associate editor at Spectator
magazine in Greensboro, North Carolina.

Everything you always wanted to know about these commercials
-and less.
t
THE LITE STUFF
BY JOHN TARKOV
hen it comes to
"Lite Beer from
Miller" com-
mercials, Marv
Throneberry
doesn't often get
to speak first.
Instead he gets
the tag lines, going all the way back to his first
Lite Beer from Miller spot in 1976, when he
closed the commercial by saying "If I do for Lite
what I did for baseball, I'm afraid their sales
might go down"
Nine years and eight appearances later, he still
gets the tag line, most recently in The First Lite
Beer Open, the 100th commercial in the series.
Perhaps it's time, then, for Marv Throneberry-
a.k.a. "Marvelous Marv" of the 1962 "Amazin'
Mets" and one of the most popular Lite All-Stars
ever-to talk first.
"There's a lot of people in the world;" he says,
"that the average person couldn't sit down and
be comfortable with. Miller picks guys for the
commercials who are willing to laugh at
themselves-who the average person could go
into a bar and sit down and be comfortable
with" Marv Throneberry fits that bill, as do
his 60 colleagues on the Lite All-Star roster. And
therein lies the key to understanding one of the
most successful advertising campaigns in history.
"The people in the ads are the kind of people
you'd enjoy having a beer with;" says Miller
spokesman Bob Bertini. "They may be famous,
but that's not the main reason you'd want to
sit down with them. The main reason is that
they're likable."
Variations on that theme echo through the
halls of Miller Brewing and Backer & Spielvogel,
the New York ad agency that has held the Miller
account for the last six years. But in 1973, when
the first Lite Beer from Miller spot was aired on
a test-market basis, the notion that such echoes
would be heard a dozen years later might have
tested the optimism-even the credulity-of the
people behind the campaign.
Bob Meury, chief of copy at B&S and a man
who has been part of the creative side of the
campaign virtually since its inception, says:
"When the ads hit the air, we knew very quickly
and clearly that something good was happening.
But no one back then knew just how good"
Mickey Spillane and
Lee Meredith-two
of the Lite All-Stars-
go for a hole in one.
No one might ever have known anything
had it not been for the beer-drinking, basketball-
crazy town of Anderson, Indiana. In the early
1970s, while the rest of the nation was taking
to low-calorie beer with all the enthusiasm of a
duck caught in an oil spill, the clock-punching,
hardworking townsmen of Anderson were
quaffing it down with singular enthusiasm.

The folks at McCann-Erick-
son, the advertising agency
that had the Miller Brewing
account back then, were most
intrigued.
In 1972 Miller had acquired
a Chicago-based light beer
named Meister Brau Lite (the
same beverage that cascaded
from Anderson s taps when the
factory whistles blew), and
Miller was strongly inclined to
have the rest of America share
in Anderson's enlightenment.
Given the dismal track record
of earlier campaigns for other
light beers, McCann-Erickson
was placed in the almost im-
possibly difficult position of
trying to sell the stuff.
And so McCann-Erickson
mounted an expedition to
Anderson, Indiana, there to
study-beerwise-the ways of
the freethinking natives. The
expedition was led by Bob
Lenz, the head of a McCann-
Erickson creative group, and
the man now acknowledged as
standing in relation to the Lite
Beer from Miller campaign the
way George Washington stands
in relation to-well, you know.
What Lenz and his research-
ers learned from their field-
work came down to this:
regular beer-loving guys will
gladly drink low-calorie beer
-provided it tastes like beer-
because it doesn't leave you
feeling all filled up.
Armed with this insight,
Lenz and his team returned to
New York and set to work on
new ads; in Milwaukee, Clem Mein, head of
Miller's Master Brewing Department, and his
team set to work on producing a product that
would make good on the pitch. Initially, all con-
cerned had to endure the grapeshot of a skeptical
Madison Avenue, which regarded light beers as
specialty products unsuited to the mass market.
Once, that may have been so.
THE BEER FACTS
Among other things, history teaches us that in
1970, Miller was the seventh-largest brewer in
the United States. Today, it is second only to
Anheuser-Busch. Lite Beer from Miller has risen
from humble beginnings to become the second-
largest-selling beer-not just light beer, but any
beer-in the nation. Seen another way, if Lite Beer
from Miller was an independent company, it
would be America s fourth-largest brewer. Over
60 brands of light beers from other breweries
have followed in Lite Beer from Miller's wake.
All this has come to pass because of a basic
truth of American life: 30 percent of all beer
drinkers consume 80 percent of the available
beer. And, as Miller's advertising people were
clever enough to realize, most of those 30 percent
are just regular guys.
On the set with Lite Beer
from Miller's All-Stars:
Meredith and Spillane
rehearse a scene (top);
director Bob Giraldi,
the man behind Michael
Jackson's super-
successful music videos
(center); Dick Butkus
and Bubba Smith in
a huddle (bottom).
O
From the beginning Lite Beer
from Miller's advertising cam-
paign has been targeted to ap-
peal to that critical 30 percent
of regular guys, and its bedrock
philosophy has remained un-
changed to this day: ex-jocks,
with only a few exceptions such
as Mickey Spillane, Frank De-
ford, and Rodney Dangerfield,
conveying the message that,
hey, beer-drinking is a good-
natured pastime conducive to
good fellowship. They don't en-
dorse Lite Beer from Miller.
They just have a good time. And
part of the good time is Lite
Beer from Miller.
As the numbers bear out, a
lot of regular beer drinkers
took them up on the implicit
invitation: Lite, laughs, male
bonding, loud and friendly bar
debate ("Tastes great!" "Less
filling!"), and the company of
former ballplayers who are just
regular guys themselves.
The featured performers
then, are a linchpin to the suc-
cess of the whole campaign.
And these Lite All-Stars
are not chosen casually.
(Though legend has it that Bob
Lenz picked ex-New York Jet
running back Matt Snell for
the inaugural spot in 1973 be-
cause he was taken by Snell's
masculine visage on an Off-
Track Betting ad.)
ALL ABOUT ALL-STARS
These days, it's a very tough
casting call. "Every time I get to
a sporting event and meet some
of the active and retired players;" says Ralph
Kytan, Miller's assistant brand manager for Lite,
"they're constantly asking, 'Hey, how can I be
a Lite All-Star?"' The athletes aren't alone in
clamoring for a seat on the Lite beerwagon.
"We hear from their agents, their wives, their
barbers, what have you;" says Jeff Palmer, a
senior vice-president at Backer & Spielvogel and
the management representative on the Lite Beer
from Miller account. The agency retains a general
agent to constantly scout the talent among newly
retired athletes. A ball-park estimate of any
would-be All-Star's chances: 50-1, against.
Star quality alone, in other words, won't do
the trick. Lite All-Star quality-easygoing, self-
effacingly funny, affable, down-to-earth-is
what the candidates must possess. But the
winnowing doesn't stop there. The road from
screen test to TV screen can be a long one: the
enormously popular Bob Uecker, for example,
had to wait a year and a half for the right script
to happen.
According to Jeff Palmer, it takes "five to ten
scripts to get one to take to the creative directors
of the agency." Out of every five scripts presented
to the creative directors, maybe one or two is
selected. "And of those, only 40 percent to 50
:
i
~
1<
C
t
30 PHILIP MORRIS MAGAZINE/SUIvIMER 1985

percent will get approved.Then
you'll have fallout of 10 per-
cent: the guy can't do it; he's not
available. You're down to 30
percent:' In other words, for ev-
ery 50 to 100 scripts conceived,
roughly one will be shot.
America expects Lite Beer
from Miller to do something
different in its commercials, to
have fun with them, and so the
people connected with the Lite
campaign have little choice but
to follow-and top, and follow
-their own hard act. Humor
has a quick half-life, and so the
Lite series requires 10 to 12 new
episodes per year.
Once a script is selected, it's
up to the cast-and crew-to
make it as appealing as possi-
ble. A lot has been written
about the atmosphere of merri-
ment on the set, says Palmer,
perhaps to the point of over-
looking the discipline involved.
"There's a basic script;" he says.
"We're there to shoot that. It
could get modified on the set.
The client's there, and if there
are changes, we'll talk them
over. It's an extraordinary
client-agency relationship.
Miller is very constructive.
They have marvelous senses
of humor."
When the basic script is shot
and wrapped, Palmer contin-
ues, the next step is to free-
wheel and ex-
periment and
improve on
what exists. "We
can break it off
at two o'clock;"
people on the set, and 55 didn't
know what was coming. When
Billy said that line, the whole
room broke up. I think they
ruined the take from laughing.
We had to do it again:'
Work and play and continual
inventiveness, then, find their
balance at the individual
shoots (sportswriter Frank
Deford, himself an All-Star,
chronicled the antics and hu-
mor of it all in his book Lite
Reading, Penguin Books,
1984). The truly major fun,
though, is found at the Lite All-
Star reunion commercials, of
which the new centennial Golf
Outing is one. Ask around
about the reunion commer-
cials, and you begin to under-
stand more fully what makes
the Lite All-Stars-and the un-
seen All-Stars behind the All-
Stars, like Bob Lenz, Bob
Meury, director Bob Giraldi,
and so many more-tick.
Marv Throneberry again
gets the first word. "I've gotten
to know these guys-Boog
Powell, Jim Shoulders, Mickey
Spillane;" he says. "The guys
save up their funniest stuff for
the reunions. A lot of us, we
haven't seen each other in a
year. It really is a reunion. It's
kind of one big family." Or, as
former Chicago Bears line-
backer Dick Butkus once told
Bob Meury: "You know, I've
been playing on teams since
I was six. This is like being on
a team again:"
saysPalmerQno~ 1 he truly major fun, though, is found at
another$600on the Lite All-Star reunion commercials of
film and keep
shootingtillfive which the Golf Outing is one.
had Martin turning around and asking Shoul- lines-is that they've transcended the ordinary
ders defensively, "Why would anybody want to At the First Lite Beer boundaries of itch and-sell and
made a lot of
punch a doggie?" That's the ending America ~ kes,a cue f om h s fa- people chuckle. That is
something they feel good
neversaw. vorite sport (top); about, and perhaps not so coincidentally, so
"It wasn't working;" Meury recalls. "People Meredith and Spillane do we. C
wereri t laughing. So we cut it down a bit, so Billy puzzle (centerj Rodney
would just say 'I didn't punch that doggie: Dangerfield shows how John Tarkov is a writer and editor
living in
We didn't tell anyone else.There were maybe 60 to drive in style (bottom). New York City.
or six. Let's
shoot:'
What'll happen 30 percent or 40 percent of
the time, estimates Bob Meury, is modification
and improvement. A striking example can be
found in the now-classic "Drugstore Cowboy"
spot, featuring on-again, off-again Yankees man-
ager Billy Martin and ex-rodeo star Jim Shoul-
ders. "I can tell a real cowboy from the drugstore
kind clear across Texas;" says Shoulders, as
Mexican music plays. "You see, you don't want
to be filled up when you're out there punchin'
doggies. Right, cowboy?" The original ending
"That's one of the real secrets;" says Bob Ber-
tini. "The camaraderie. People really look
forward to seeing each other at the reunions."
And, adds Jeff Palmer, "Why not? Hey, it's fun:'
So what we have, in the end, is a piece of
advertising history, a slice of Americana,
and-perhaps best of all-a good ongoing
source of laughs. Talk to the people who've been
associated with the campaign over the years
and you detect a universally shared pride in
the achievement. What they're saying-
sometimes up front, sometimes between the
PHILIP MORRIS MAGAZINE/SUMMER 1985 31
...~

"CALL FOR PHILIP MORRIS"
BY THEODORE FISCHER
L ong before there
was a Ronald Mc-
Donald, and well
before Colonel San-
ders had ever licked
so much as a pinky,
Philip Morris had a
guy named Johnny.
Johnny (for those who may
have arrived in this world a bit
late) was the cheerful 43-inch-tall
midget, clad in a bellman's
brass-buttoned red jacket and
pillbox cap, who cried "Call for
Philip Morris!" to the rhythmic
strains of Ferde Grofe's Grand
Canyon Suite in Philip Morris
commercials. In a 41-year career
spanning the golden age of radio
and the pioneer days of TV,
Johnny became, arguably, the
first and most famous living
trademark of a major American
product.
The Johnny saga began in 1933
with an advertising problem: how
to create a quality image for a
154-a-pack brand of cigarettes in
a market where the then major
competition (Camel, Chesterfield,
Old Gold) sold for 114. Inspired
by an illustration on an old Philip
Morris display piece, advertising
agency head Milton Biow con-
ceived a radio campaign that
featured a bellboy paging Philip
Morris. But instead of hiring an
actor to play a bellboy, Biow con-
sulted an employment agency
specializing in hotel help, and
they immediately recommended
Johnny Roventini, "The World's
Smallest Bellhop;" of the New
Yorker Hotel.
"I simply went to the New
Yorker, found Johnny, and asked
him, quite innocently, to page a
Mr. Philip Morris," writes Biow in
his autobiography Butting In...
An Adman Speaks Out. "He went
through the lobby and called.
That was the voice!"
At first Johnny held on to his
day job and popped over to the
studio to call for Philip Morris
on live radio programs that
included "It Pays To Be Ignorant"
and "Philip Morris Playhouse."
But as Johnny's popularity grew,
the company hired him as a full-
time announcer and traveling
spokesman.
Johnny represented Philip
Morris at supermarket openings,
and appeared at musical and
sporting events. Cheerful, gregar-
ious, and ceaselessly energetic,
Johnny shook hands, distributed
samples, and, inevitably, sum-
moned local bigwigs in the same
piercing tone with which he called
for Philip Morris.
Johnny mania peaked in the
late 1930s when demands for him
became so great that Philip
Morris decided to create a troop
of five regionally located "Johnny
Juniors" in bellhop outfits to
appear in his place. Johnny and
Philip Morris also scored a coup
in the early 1950s when the com-
pany became the original sponsor
of the nation's highest-rated TV
show, "I Love Lucy."
Johnny's eventual retirement
resulted more from changes in
cigarette styles than any loss of
energy or appeal. From 1954 on,
Philip Morris focused its promo-
tional efforts on newly popular
filter brands such as Virginia
Slims, Parliament, Merit, and
particularly Marlboro; the popu-
larity of the filterless Philip
Morris brand was on the wane.
According to Buck Peters, corpo-
rate photographer and house
spokesman for all things relating
to Johnny, "I like to tell people
that Johnny carried the company
until he handed the baton to the
Marlboro Man!'
Johnny made his final official
appearance in 1974 at the opening
of a factory in Richmond, Virginia.
Never married, Johnny Roven-
tini lives today with his brother-
in-law in his old neighborhood in
the Sheepshead Bay section of
Brooklyn, no longer granting
interviews or making personal
appearances. He has come out of
retirement only twice: to lay a
cornerstone at the opening of
Philip Morris world headquarters
in 1983 and to appear at a salute
to Lucille Ball in 1984.
But Johnny is hardly forgotten;
in 1984 a bellhop uniform worn
by one of the regional "Johnny
Juniors" became part of the
Smithsonian's permanent display.
"Whenever somebody puts on
something about nostalgia they
show the bobby-soxers and Frank
Sinatra and then Johnny," says
Peters. "But I think that if it wasn't
for Johnny's own personality, the
Johnny program would never
have made it. Johnny would really
extend himself: he could talk, he
could greet, he could walk into
a roomful of strangers and make
everybody feel like an old friend'."
Indeed, adds Peters, "Everybody
remembers Johnny. Whenever I
see new kids in the company I tell
them, 'Go home and say you're
working for Philip Morris. Then
come back and tell me if your
father or mother or uncle doesn't
say, "How about that little guy?
You ever see him over there?" "' [I
Theodore Fischer, a writer living
in New York, remembers Johnny
well. 2040235218
32 PHILIP MORRIS MAGAZINE/SUMMER 1985

Do you have a friend?
We hope you enjoy reading Phili Morris Magazine.
If you have a friend or relative who would enjoy
reading this publication, please provide us with his
or her name and address in the space below.
Name:
Address:
City: State: Zip:
O Please remove my name from your mailing list.

NO POSTAGE
NECESSARY
IF MAILED
IN THE
UNITED STATES
BUSINESS REPLY CARD
FIRST CLASS PERMIT NO. 5380 NEW YORK, NY
Postage will be paid by addressee:
Philip Morris Magazine
P. O. Box 2870
New York, NY 10116

On theAQenda
A
NEWS AND NOTES ON ITEMS OF SPECIAL INTEREST THIS SUMMER
May 15 through August 25
SOUTHERN FOLK ART
The rich diversity of folk art
in the American South is the
focus of a new exhibition
which opened at the Museum
of American Folk Art in New
York City on May 15. More
than 85 works, including
paintings, quilts, furniture, and
pottery, have been selected to
represent the scope of southern
cultural traditions. The ob-
jects, all produced between
1743 and 1915, include the
distinctive brown cotton
textiles of Louisiana's Cajuns,
the richly colored silks pro-
duced by the Shakers of Ken-
tucky, and the slip-decorated
redware created by North
Carolina's Moravians. The
exhibition is scheduled to
travel throughout the South
between October 1985 and
November 1986.
June 10
through August 24
THE TWELVE MONTHS
OF TOBACCO
This series of paintings was
commissioned by Philip Mor-
ris to capture on canvas the
role of burley tobacco farming
in American culture. Artist
Toss Chandler, who grew up
on a Kentucky tobacco farm,
has created a 34-by-28-inch
painting for each month of the
year, reflecting the year-round
work this crop requires. Her
work focuses on each step of
the process, from preparation
and planning through harvest
and auctioning. The paintings
will be on display at the Horse
Cave Theater in Horse Cave,
Kentucky, through July 20,
then at the Kentucky State Fair
in Louisville August 15
through 24.
June 23 through
September 1
PRIMITIVISM IN
20TH-CENTURY ART
This ground-breaking exhibit
juxtaposes modern art with
tribal objects to underscore the
parallels that exist between the
two. Western artists first
focused on primitive art around
1906-1907, as they shifted
away from the perceptual
(imitating what the eye sees)
and toward more conceptual,
or idea-oriented, styles; this
show explores the influence of
tribal art from Africa, Oce-
ania, and the Americas upon
modern painters and sculptors.
Approximately 150 modern
works, including pieces by
Gauguin, Picasso, Modigliani,
and Klee, are shown alongside
some 200 carved figures,
masks, and textiles. Among
the primitive works are items
from the personal collections
of such artists as Picasso,
Matisse, Braque, and Ernst.
"Primitivism" will be on
display at the Dallas Museum
of Art in Dallas, Texas, through
September 1.
July 27 through
September 1
MERIT HARBOR LIGHTS
The Merit Harbor Lights show
is a kaleidoscope of colorful
firework patterns and effects
set to music by the world-
famous Gruccis, the "First
Family o f Fireworks." In keep-
ing with Merit's nautically-
themed advertising, this half-
hour-long fireworks extrava-
ganza is choreographed to
water-related tunes (from
Richard Rodgers's "Victory at
Sea" to Prince's "Purple Rain")
and will be presented this sum-
mer at four waterfront festivals.
Each show will be supervised
by the Gruccis-best known
for their pyrotechnic produc-
tions at President Reagan's
Inaugurals and the 1984 Sum-
mer Olympics-and fired from
two floating barges. There is
no admission charge. Merit
Harbor Lights will be presented
at the Harbor Festival in Phil-
adelphia, Pennsylvania, on
July 27 at 9:30 PM.; the Three
Rivers Regatta in Pittsburgh,
Pennsylvania, on August 3 at
9:45 P.M.; the Ist Annual St.
Louis Riverfront Picnic and
International Barbecue Com-
petition in St. Louis, Missouri,
on August 24 at 9:30 PM.; and
the Stermuheel Regatta Festival
in Charleston, West Virginia,
on September I at dusk.
July through September
VIRGINIA SLIMS
The Virginia Slims World's
Championship Series contin-
ues: Virginia Slims of Newport
is scheduled for Newport
Casino, Newport, Rhode
Island, July 15-21; Virginia
Slims of Los Angeles, Manhat-
tan Beach Country Club,
Manhattan Beach, California,
July 29-August 4; Virginia
Slims of Utah, Sports Mall,
Salt Lake City, Utah, Septem-
ber 9-15; Virginia Slims of
Chicago, University of Illinois
Circle Campus Pavilion, Chi-
cago, Illinois, September 16-
22; Virginia Slims of Rich-
mond, Raintree Swim and
Racquet Club, Richmond,
Virginia, September 16-22;
and Virginia Slims of New
Orleans, University of New
Orleans, New Orleans, Louisi-
ana, September 23-29.
September 14
7UP-GREATFORESTPARK
BALLOON RACE
Forest Park in St. Louis is
America's third-largest city'
park (its popular zoo is run
by well-known naturalist
Marlin Perkins o f"Wild King-
dom"fame) and the site of the
third annual 7LIP-Great Forest
Park Balloon Race. Open to
the public-there's no admis-
sion charge-the day will
begin with skydiving demon-
strations, music, and refresh-
ments (including 7UP, Like,
and Miller, of course). Then
licensed professional pilots will
navigate the 50 colorful bal-
loons entered in the "hare and
hounds" race: around 4:30 the
balloon designated as the "hare"
will take off first, with the
"hounds" following ten min-
utes later. A cash prize and
trophy will be awarded to the
hound landing closest to the
hare. Pack a picnic and enjoy
the day-a beautiful way to
wrap up summer.
PHILIP MORRIS MAGAZINE/SUMMER 1985 33

---
