Philip Morris
Smoking and Other Risk Factors for Lung Cancer in Women
Fields
- Author
- Henderson, B.E.
- Pike, M.C.
- Wu, A.H.
- Yu, M.C.
- Pike, M.C.
- Area
- DEMPSEY,RUTH/OFFICE
- Type
- PSCI, PUBLICATION SCIENTIFIC
- ABST, ABSTRACT
- BIBL, BIBLIOGRAPHY
- CHAR, CHART, GRAPH, TABLE, MAPS
- ABST, ABSTRACT
- Litigation
- Stmn/Produced
- Site
- E12
- Master ID
- 2026223571/3912
Related Documents:- 2026223571-3590 Ets and Lung Cancer Scoth Review 940000 (Volume 1)
- 2026223591-3596 Time Trends in Lung Cancer Mortality Among Nonsmokers and A Note on Passive Smoking
- 2026223597-3600 Lung Cancer in Non-Smokers in Hong Kong
- 2026223601-3603 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer
- 2026223604-3605 Lung Cancer and Passive Smoking: Conclusion of Greek Study
- 2026223606-3622 the Causes of Lung Cancer in Texas
- 2026223623-3643 Lung Cancer in Japan: Effects of Nutrition and Passive Smoking
- 2026223644-3656 Lung Cancer in Nonsmokers
- 2026223657-3663 Involuntary Smoking and Lung Cancer: A Case-Control Study
- 2026223669-3672 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer Among Japanese Women
- 2026223673-3681 Relationship of Passive Smoking to Risk of Lung Cancer and Other Smoking-Associated Diseases
- 2026223682-3691 Risk Factors for Adenocarcinoma of the Lung
- 2026223692
- 2026223693-3703 Lung Cancer Among Chinese Women
- 2026223704-3713 Marriage to A Smoker and Lung Cancer Risk
- 2026223714-3721 Measurements of Passive Smoking and Estimates of Lung Cancer Risk Among Non-Smoking Chinese Females
- 2026223722-3728 Is Passive Smoking and Added Risk Factor for Lung Cancer in Chinese Women?
- 2026223729-3734 Smoking, Passive Smoking and Histological Types in Lung Cancer in Hong Kong Chinese Women
- 2026223735-3742 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer in Swedish Women
- 2026223743-3769 the Relationship of Passive Smoking to Various Health Outcomes Among Seventh-Day Adventists in California
- 2026223770-3773 on the Relationship Between Smoking and Female Lung Cancer
- 2026223774-3776 Passive Smoking Is A Risk Factor for Lung Cancer in Never Smoking Women in Hong Kong
- 2026223777-3779 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer in Women
- 2026223780-3788 A Case-Control Study of Lung Cancer in Nonsmoking Women
- 2026223789-3793 Passive Smoking and Cardiorespiratory Health in A General Population in the West of Scotland
- 2026223794-3800 Smoking and Passive Smoking in Relation to Lung Cancer in Women
- 2026223801-3805 Lung Cancer and Exposure to Tobacco Smoke in the Household
- 2026223806-3818 Epidemiology Studies of the Relationship Between Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer
- 2026223819-3825 Passive Smoking and Diet in the Etiology of Lung Cancer Among Non-Smokers
- 2026223826-3830 Association of Indoor Air Pollution and Lifestyle with Lung Cancer in Osaka, Japan
- 2026223831-3836 Lung Cancer Among Women in North-East China
- 2026223837-3842 Smoking and Other Risk Factors for Lung Cancer in Xuanwei, China
- 2026223843-3859 Carcinogenic Substances in the Environment Origin Measurement Risk Minimization
- 2026223860-3865 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer in Nonsmoking Women
- 2026223866-3871 Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Lung Cancer Risk in Nonsmoking Women
- 2026223872-3881 Indoor Air Pollution and Lung Cancer in Guangzhou, People's Republic of China
- 2026223882-3885 Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Female Lung Cancer in Guangzhou,China
- 2026223886-3893 Childhood and Adolescent Passive Smoking and the Risk of Female Lung Cancer
- 2026223894-3901 Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Lung Cancer in Nonsmoking Women A Multicenter Study
- 2026223902-3912 Kommissoin Reinhaltung Der Luft Im Vdi Und Din Krebserzeugende Stoffe in Der Umwelt Herkunft Messung Risiko Minimierung
- Named Organization
- American Cancer Society
- Request
- Stmn/R1-037
- Author (Organization)
- Jnci
- Oxford Univ
- Usc, Univ. Of Southern Ca
- Oxford Univ
- Date Loaded
- 05 Jun 1998
- UCSF Legacy ID
- jfe46e00
Document Images
Ill
W
orrnen
:f;n1.6Ktng arnd Other Risk FactM for L.u~n9 CanUer in
Anna H. Wu, Ph.D.,3 Brian E. Henderson, M.D.,3 Malcolm C. Pike, Ph.D.,34 and'Mitni C. Yur Ph.D.3.5
ABSTRACT-A case-control study among white women in Los
qngales County was conducted~to investigate the role of smoking
and other factors in the etiology of lung cancer in women. A total of
149 patients' with adenocarcfnoma (AD'C)' and 71 patients with
squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) of the lung andltheir age- and
iex-matchedcontrotswere intervievved. Personal cigarette smoking
accournted for almost all of SCC and about hatf of ADC in this study
population. Among nonsmokers, slightty elevated relative risk(s)
(RR) for AtK were observed for passive smoke exposure from
spouse(s) [RR=12; 95% confidence interval (CI)=0.5: 3.3J and'at
work (RR=1.3; 95%C1=0.5, 3:3). Childhood pneumonia (RR=2.7;
953rCt=111, 6.7) and chitdhotad exposure to coal burning (RR =7:3;
95x CIr1.6, 5.5) were additional risk factors for ADC. For both
ADC andi SCC, inereased1 risks were associatedl with decreased
intake offi-carotene foods but not for totalpreformed vitamin A
foods and vitamin supplements.-JNCI 1985; 74:747-751.
I,ungcancer is now the fiourth most common cancer in,
women (1)land has been projected to be the lead'ingcause
of cancer mortalityamongwomen by the mid11980ts (2).
Causes of'lktng,cancer, other than cigarette smoking,(3),
have not been clearly identified, but associations with
exposure to passive smoking (4-6), exposure to combus-
tiom products of heating and cooking fuels (7); and
occupationali exposures (8-10) have been suggested. In
addircion, lung "scarring" (11) andia liow dietary intake of
)'3,carotene (12-14) and preformed vitamin A (15-17) may
increase the risk of lung cancer.
This paper reports a, case-control study of ADC and
SCC of the lung in white females in L'.os Angeles County.
Each of the above-mentioned factors was investigated.
METHODS
Female patients diagnosed with primary ADC or SCC
or' tic lung were prospectively identifviediby the CSP, the
pt.r,ulation-based1umor registryfor Los Angeles County
(18), between April 1, 1981, and August3!1i, 11987. On the
basis ofinformation collected routinely by the CSP, we
Ii ::ittcd ciitg-tbtlilty tn'wfnl'de l..CSsAngt'les County residents,
with no history of cancer (other than non-melanoma skin
cancer) and under age 76 at diagnosis; we verified these
variables atinterview. W-ealso excluded cases if they were
born outside the United States, Canada, or Europe; were
not English-speaking; or were not residents of Los
angeles County at the date of diagnosis.
A total of490 eligible cases were identified. Of these
Patients. 190Iiad'died orweretoo ill to participate by the
time we contacted tiheir, attending physician. Permission
was granted to contact 272 ofthe remaining300 patients.
Eight patients were not located, and, 44 refused to be
interviewed so that we obtained completed question-
naires on 220. On the basis of information on the CSP
abstract, no significant, differences were noted between
those interviewed and thosenot interviewed in terms of
age, marital status, religion,and smoking status recorded
on medical records. Hoavever, those who were not
interviewed were more likelytohaved'istant metastases at
the timeofd'iagnosis (58%) compared to those who were
interviewed (111%). Comparable percentages of eligible
SCC (43%) and ADC (16%) patients were interviewed.
We selected one individually matched neighborhood
controli for each intemiewed case. The control had to
fulfill ald''thecriteria given above for cases (with reference
date taken to be the same as that of the matching,case)
and, in addition, was matched with the case on date of
birth (±5 yr of birth date). Our control selection
algorithm, defined a specified sequence of houses to be
visited in the neighborhood where the case lived at date of
diagnosis. Our goal was to interview the first eligible
resident in this sequence. If no one was home at the time
of the visit, we lefu, ani explanatory lptter and made a
follow-up visit after several days. For any patient, 80
housingunits were visited and 3retuirn visits were made
before failure to secure a m'atched'control was conceded.
In 150 instances the first eligible person agreed to
participate, in 55 instancesthe second eligible control in,
the sequence was intcrviewed, and' in, 15 instances the
thirdeligib9k' control was initerviewedl
Cases and controls were initerviewed on the telephone
with the use of a, structured questionnaire designed to
elicit information on personal smoking habits, exposure
to passive tobacco smoke, lung diseases, dietary intake of
vitamin A, types of heating and cookingfuels cVer used,
and reproductive history. We also obtained, ai lifetime
historyof all jpbs(jpb title, activities, and exposure)iof at
least 6 months' diuration:
For childhood passive smoking exposurt we asked
about the smoking habits (i!e:, amount and years of
smoking) of father, mothcror, oother householkd'members
AenrtEt'tHTI©Ns Ust:n: AiDC=adcnocarcinnma; Cl =c,onbidenrc inrrrval;
CSP=Univeraity of Southern CaI'ifornia/t:os Angeles County C:anccr
Surveillance Program; RR=rolative risk'(s): SCC=squamous cell car-
cinoma.
I Rvccived' June 11, 1984; revised November 28. 11984. accoNted'
December 11, 19841
2Supported by grant S163 from the American Cancer Society.
3Dtpartment of Family and Preventive Medicine. University of
Southern California School of 1ledicine, P3rkti-iew Medical Ruilding B.
2025 Zonal Ave., Los Angeles. ('.A 90033.
4 Prrscnr add-e.ts: lmtterial C.ancerRrsearch Fund's Cancer Epide-
miology Unit, Radcliffe lnfirmarll, Oxford Universitr, Oxford O?C2
6HE, Englandi
S We thank the word-processing pool for preparation ofthe manw
script.
747
J,VC:I. Vt)t_ 71. NO. 4. APRIL 19zf3

n
a*{7l'!!rr5"::; .
~
"1/tI, Hiendenon, Pike, and Yu
when they lived, with the respondent during her child-
hood l and teenage years. For passive smoke exposure
during adult life, we asked about, the smoking habits of
spouse(s)'and other household members when they lived
with the respondent. Passive srnokeexposure at work was
assessed'only in terms of the average number of hours per
day to which the respondent believed she was exposed at
each job.
The questions on vitamin A intake specifiical'ly asked
about, average frequencies of consumption of 211, vegeta-
bles and fruits that are high in fl-carotene and 7 foods
that containedI preformed vitamin A during the calendar
year 3 years before diagnosis of the case (19). Pattern of
use of' vitamin supplements was also assessed for the
sarne periodl On, the basis of U.S. Department of
Agriculture tables of'food values for standard portion size
(common household measure) of each item, (20), we
estimated, average daily intake of B-carotene (or vitarnin.
A) by summing, the product of the ~-carotene (or
vitamin A) content of each food item and' its reported'
frequency of consumption. Quartiles of consurnption'
w, ° constructed'on the basis of the intake pattern of the
2t,, controls.
All cases were diagnosed' microscopically. Their rou-
tine patltology, reports were reviewed for mention of lung
scarring.
Statisticali analysis was conducted with the us'e of
multivariate logistic regression methods for individually
rnatched case-control studies (21): RR were estimated by
odds ratios. A case-control pair was excluded from any
gi'vcnanalysi~siftheinformation forei'ther the case or the
control was not known for, the relevant variable(s). Since
personal smoking will often, i'fl not always, confound
other associationsRR for other factors were always given
after adjustment was made for personal smoking.
For ADC, R'AC for certain factors were given separately
for nonsmokers, ex-smokers, and current smokers; this
was not done for SCC because the numbers of non-
smokers and ex-smokers were too few.
RESULTS
c iin'terviewed 14'9 ADC and 71 SCC cases and their
matiched' controls~. The mean age at diagnosis was 59.7
years for ADC cases and 61.4' years for SCC cases. The
meaniages (atdate of diagnosis of'the index case) for the
respective control groups were 59.5 and' 6'T.1 years.
Prrsonal~ cigareltr smoking.-For both ADC and SCC,
there was a significant trend in risk associated' with
increasing number oLcigarettes smoked per day and'with
decreasing age at which smoking began (table 1). Both
aspects of smoking remained significant after adjvstrrnent
was made for the other.
Passive srnoking:-Families tended to share similar
smoking, behavior. Controls whose father, mother, or
spouse(s)'smoked were m ore likely to smoke, to be heavy
smokers, and to start at a younger age than controls
whose family members did not smoke. For ADC and
SCC, after adjustment was made for personal' smoking
habits, there were no signilfica'ntly increasedl risks .for
having a mother, a father, or spouse(s) who smokedlor for
being exposed at work ('table 2).
For nonsrnoking, ADC cases, we did not observe any
elevated' risk associated' with' passive smoke exposure
frorn either parents (RR=0.6I 9'5%' CI=0.2,, 1.7), from'
spouse(s) (RR=1.2; 95% CI=0.5, 3.3), or ar work
(RR=1.3; 95% CI=0.5, 3.3). Increasing RR (RR=1.0,
1.2, 2.0) were found with increasing years (0 1-30, ?3'P)
of' passive smoke exposure during adult life from
spouse(s)' andl at work, but the results were not sta-
tisticall} significant. Since the exposur~esrmayhaveoccurred concurrently, the years of exposure
represent
units rather than chronologic time of exposure.
Chulditaod' expestrrrs:-For both' ADC and SCC, no
significant association was found with history of lung,
diseases (specifically, a'sthma; bronch'itis, pneumonia
tuberculosis, funigal' diseases, emphysema and lung,
abscess) diagnosed by a physician at least 5 years before
diagnosis of'the case. When th'e analysis was res'tricted'to
lungd6sea'srs thati occtrrredibeforeage16 (childhood) ai
signi'ficantlyelevatcd RR for pneumonia was observed
for ADGafteradjustmcnt was made for personal smoking
habits (RR=2.7; 95% C1=1.1, 6.7), and the RR for SCC
(RR=2.9; 95% C1=0.5, 17.4) was in the same direction.
Parental smoking did not explain' this effect. Table 3'
shows that for ADC, the effect of chilldhood pneumonia
was most apparent arnong nonsrnokers: Of the 29
TA'IILE 1.-!'r+', orrnl'~nroA'iurg nairiie ofawsre und ci;rr.ro,'s
S
ki
t ADC' SCC
mo
ng sta
us
RIR'
95% Cl'
CCase/control
RR
95% CI
Case/eontrol.
Nonsmoker 1.01 29/62' 1.0 2/30
Ex-smoker' 1.2' 0.6.2.3 21/37' 7:7 0.8.70:3 8118
Current smoker 4.1'6 2.3.7.5' 99/50 35.3" 4.7:267:3 61/23'
Current smoker: No. cigarettes/day
1-20
2.7'
1.4.5:4
38/28'
17.7
2.3. 1'38.2
19/14
>_2!1' 6:5" 3.1. 13.9 61/22' 94.4' ' 9.9, 904.6 4'2/9'
Current smoker: age started to smoke. y r
>_25
1.1
0.4.3.2
8114,
7.8
0.8'. 7317,
6/5
19-24 2.5 1.0.5.8 22/15I 47.1 4.4, 498.6 18,/T'
518 8,01, 3.6. 17.9 69/21 1T5.7+' 9.8. 1375.2' 37r11
" Had'st,oppedlsmoking at least 3 yrbefarre diagnosis year of case.
~ P'(1'inear trend) <.00'1_
JN(;l. t"O;t-,74. KQ: 1. A'PRtL 1985

- ~W,uy ..~cwac uu nromen
.
., TASUt: 2: Esposurre to passive tmoking in cases and controls
status
Smokin ADC'
g Adjusted RR° 95% CI
Mother smoked 1.7, 0.8.3.5
Father smoked 1.3 0.7,2:3
Spouse(s) smokedP 1.2 0.6.2.5
Exposure at the workplace 1.2 0.8. 2:2
SCC'
Adjusted R'R° 95% CI
02' 0.0: 1.5
0.9 0.3.2.9
1501 0.1.7.6
2.3 0.7, 7:9
' Adjusted for number of cigarettes smoked per day and age at starting to smoke:
'We eliminated from the analysis: 15 pairs of, A'DC and 4 pairs of SCC'in which either the case or
the control was never married.
ncrosmnking ADC cases, 8' (28%) gave a, history of'
c-hulKihood pneumonia.
Fahwated RR, adjusted for personal smoking habits,
wc*nt. observed for exposure to burning coal used for
hrating or cooking in a stove or fireplace during the
majprity of'rhildHood'and teenage years (ADC: RR='2:3;
cl:,;~Gf=1.0, 5:5: SCC: RR=1.9, 95% CI=0.5; 6:5)'. For
:11)C:. elevated RR were observed, in each personal.
au0i: ing habit category (tabJe 3')'.
T.vnt.t: I-RR and 95e6~cor{fidvue inttrcnls o/ADCof the
~ nceorcl'iueg to childhood pneumonia androal burning by
personal smokinS7habit.i
RR (9596CI) among:
E.xlxrsure
Nonsmoker
Ex-smoker
Current smoker
Childhood
pneumonia`
No
1.0
1.4 (0:6, 2.4)
5.1(2.5, 10:3)
Yes 3.1(1.0. 9.9) 1.5 (0.2; 10.8) 10.9 (2.1 5'T:9)
t'hildhoodlcoal
burning"
No
1.0
1.5 (0.6; 3:5)
6!3 (3:0, 1'33)
Yes 3.2(0.9.11.8), 4!3(1.0,17.8)~ 9:5(2;1,41.9)
i{,fore age 16. The,analysis was based on 149 case-control',pairs
:11)t.:
lncludes heating or cooking with coal burned in a stove or
firrplacc during childhood and teenage years. The analysis «as
ha<cd on 143 case-control pairs of ADG.
Dietary vitamin A'.-Table 4 presents RR for ADC,
adjusted for personal' srnoking, habits, by quartiles of
indices of vitamin A consumption. Because of the smaliler
sample size of'SCC cases, the indices wered'ichqtomized.
For ADC, a significantly increased risk was observed only
for those in the lowest qiuartile of .8-carotene consump-
tion (<2,000 IUJday)' compared to those in the highest
quartile (>4,000 IU;/day), but no appreciably increased',
risks were observed'for those in:the intermediate groups.
For SCC, an elevated, but not statisticallysigniificant, RRR
was observed for wornen with fl-carotene intake below
the median: When those in the lowest quartile of Q-
carotene consumption, i.e., less than 2,000 IU/day, were
compared to those consuming more than 2,0001IUXday,
the unadjustied RR was increased to 1_7' (from 1.3), but
afteradjustment the RR was not greater than comipari-
sons above and below the median, (both, R'R=1.5):
There was no association with an; index of totat
preformed vitamin A(i.e., dairy products, eggs, liver, and'i
vitamin supplements) fbr either cell type. However, fbr
ADC and, SCC; an association was observed' for dairy
products and eggs (table 4).
Other jactors.-Wc couldi find no association between
a~ny occtnpationior occupational category and risk of ADC'
or SCC, but there was an excess number of cooks (4' cases
and, 2 controls) andi beauticians (8 cases and 5 controls)
among cases: both occupations have been suggested in
previous studirs. Eleva.ed RR ad'justed'. for pe; sonral
TAHt.t: 4.-Dicttzry intake oJS-carotcne, total preformed citnmimA', avrdidaiiry prroducta and eggs
among eaxes and controls
Quartile B-Canotiene' Total preformed vitamin Ab` Dairy products and eggs''
Adjusted RR'c 95% Cl Adju;;ted RRd 9596 Cl Adjusted RK4' 95% CI
ADC'
I (high) 1'.01 1.0 1.0
2' 0.8 0.3.2.0 0.6 0.3. 1.4 1.7 0:8: 3.9.
3 1.3 0.6. 2.7 1.1 0:5, 2.5 2.2' 1.0; 4.8
4 2.5 1.1, 5:7 1.2 0,5: 2:8 2.7 1.2.5.8
SCC
1 and 2 1.0 1.0 1.0
3and4 1.5' 0:6;,3.8' 1.0 0.4,2.4 1.6 0.7,3:9
'lncludes 21 vegetables and fruits: leafy lettuce, other leafy greeni broccoli, carrots, tomatoca,
green peas, green beans, lirna besna,
uparaRus, summer aquash, winter squash, sweet potatoes and/or yams, green pepper, redlpepper, hot
red chili pepper; cantaloupe,
+atermelon, peaches, aprieots; nectacrines, and tomato andy,or V8 juice. Analysis was based on 147
paira of'ADC and'.69 pairs of SCC:
' 1 noludes eggs; cheese;,butter and/or margarine, cream, mi Ik, beef andJor cai fliven, ch icken
and/or turkey /iver,,and vitamin supplements .
~.Anaiyais waa ba.sed on L47'pairs of, ADC'and 71 pairs of'SCC.
Adjusted for number of cigarettes smoked per day.
JfnCt. VOL 74. NO. 4. APRIL t985
Ion i I //~.~.r~~~`~~ ~a

smokutg; habits were observed' for a history of hysterec-
'tomy_. (RR =167; 95% CI=Q.9, 3.2) and nulliparity
(fLR=1:7; 95',K' CI=0.8, 3:7)l ambng, ADC cases and' aa
history of miscarri;age (RR=1.5; 95% CT-0.5, 4:9) among.
SCC cases.
Multiple logistic regression analysis was conductedito
assess the possible confounding effects of personal
smoking, habits, childhood pneumonia, childhood, coal
burning, and'P-carotene intake. The results weresirnilar
to those when each factor was adjusted for personal
smoking habits alone.
DIS CUSSirDN I
This case-control study examined risk factors for the
two main cell types of lung cancer in women-ADC and
SCC. Although histologic typing was done by the
individual' pathologist ae each participating hospital,
studies cornparing,interobserver and inrcraobserver varia-
bility ini classification of lung cell types reported a high
concordance rate for cell types other than large cell'
carcinoma, which was excl'uded, in this study (22, 23).
In this study population, abouchallf'of ADC and almosr
all of SCC can be attributed to personal smoking habirts;
1amount smoked and the age at which smokiingbegan
were strong determinants of' risk of disease. However,
there are rrnarkedldiifferences in the strengph of'association
between smoking, and cell type of lung cancer, as has
been noted previously (24; 25).
The role of' passive smoking in the etiology of ADC
among, nonsmokers is not clear. Our data are not
consistent with the findings with regard to nonsmokers
obtained by Hirayamal (9) and Trichopoulos et al. (5)
who reported'a twofold to threefold'increased risk due to
passive smoking. However, the histology of'the cases inn
these studiies is not clear, and their data, suggest that any
effect of passive smoking is larger for SCC cases (5; 6)i Of
our 29 nonsmoking ADC cases, 12 were bronchoalveolar
cell carcinomas, and, this cell type is specifically menl-
tioned by Correa et al. (6) to have a weaker association
with Nassive sm-)king: The cffect of passive smoking by
.
cell type of lung cancer needs to be investig;tted'furtlier in
studies wiith, much larger numbers of nonsmokers.
"hiildhood lung,disease may have a role in lung cancer
et..,lbgy. Certain features of the lung of a child! (e.g..
susceptibility to airway, elosure and high peripheral
resistance) might make it more vulnerable to residual
abnormalities from respiratory illness (26): This notion
is supported' by observations that both smokers and
nonsmokers with childhood respiratory diseases have
irnpai'red'lung function capacity, that their rate of decline
in ventilatory function capacity with age is more rapid
thani that in individuals without childhaod' respiratory
problems, and' that, they have higher nates of clinical
diagnosis of' chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (27,
28). Women with childhood respiratory problems may
have incurred epithelial damage to the airway resulting
in airway hyperreactivity and are more susceptible to
ouhrr insults to the lung. We cannot rule oun the
pcussibilityof a chanceffnding or of preferential recall of'
JNCti VXYI_ 74. NO. 4. A'I'RiII. 19d5
childhood' pneumonia by cases. However, ouir dita:
appear to be internally consistent, since we found" a
significantly higher frequency of lung scarring rnen-
tioned in the pathology reports among cases with
previous childhood pneumonia (12/30=40%) compared
to those without (39j/189^21%').
The association of' lung cancer risk with exposure to
coal heating or cooking warrants further investigation.
Although coal was identified as the major heating or
cooking fuel used during childhood and teenage years of
a significantly higher proportion of cases, we did not
have detailed information on the years of use. Excess risks
of lung,cancer have been reported for coke oven workers
(29, 30) and British gas workers (31) who were heavily
exposed' to products of coal carbonization.
Studies of men suggest that their lung cancer risk is
lowered by greater dietary Q-carotene (12=14, 32, 33) an&
vitamin A intake (15, 17, 32, 33)j but the evidence for
women is less clear (12,, 13, 32, 33). We observed a
significantly increased risk for ADC ~with the lowest leve'l'of fl-carotene consumption and a
similar association for
SCC. These results are consistent with findings for
females in Singapore (12),and in Japan (13'), but tiheyare
not supporitive of data for females in Hawaii (32) and
England (33!). Our observation of no association with an
index of total preformed vitamin A(ii.e:, dairy products,
eggs, liver, and vitamin supplements) and no association,
with total vitamin A intake (preformed vitamin A and
Q-carotene-data not s otvn due to domination by
preformed' vitamin A) is consistent with findings for
femalesinHia.vaii (32): Conflictiutgfindings have been
reported for subgroups of preformed virtatrtin A foods andi
supplements. A higlnerconsumptiionlof liver and vitarniin,
supplements has been reported previously for female
cases as comparell to controls, but the opposite results
have been observed' for malcs (33, 34). Our data, show
no case-control difference in, the intake pattern of
vitamin supplements and a higher consumption of liver
aniong cases. Our finding of an elevated lung cancer risk
associated with lionv levels of intake of dairy products hass
leot been reportedl for fcmales; ailthough, similar results
have been observed'for males (15-17'): Our results on thee
role of /3-carottne and preformed vitamin A were similar
for ADC and'SCC: despite sttggestions that vitamin A (or
,ld-carrotrne) ismnrn strronvlv, prntarrive amainc_ SC'~ than
against ADC (17').
Initial reports of an inverse relationship between blood -
retinol levels andlsubsequenit-risk oEcancer at all sites (35',
36) have not been supported by recent studies (37, 38).
This situatiionemhhasixes the need to reexamiineeven the
consistently observed association of vitamin A (or /3.
carotene) intake with male lung cancer.
Possible sources of bias in our data must be considered.
Both lung, cancer cases and controls were derived from
population-based samples. However, because this disease
is debilitating andlrapidlly fatal, 190 patients had died or
were too ill to particijpatebythe, time ofinitiall ciontact:.,
N'Ve did not conduct proxy interviews because questions
on chiildhood exposures and dietary history could not be
assessed adequately. As expected, the group wholwas not
. 1 .:`,,::',yw~~'y
i ~ 11 lom i ii~ ~~~

;~-'ttAtt?rY[CI~R l1r'a3 Q 1 i.Cll~alO naVCntelaS[au QlseidSe'dt. iOCcCantpCr`ut ytnc: ..caacau
cac~ uw.aauul ~;a ~r
ra
vwa:
3u' tn ~ll dem
ht
osu
n
i
og
p
m~
c
,
ag
d
U
s+ ~ , (VY) $)ta.tttl:DietazyvttnrtttnAandhumanlungpnt:er lntJdrr
measuttl: ~ddtuen;~tiiformatM1O'n~abstrartrd; from *~~,: ", y; t97s: ts 5s1-ss5: '~
riiedical'rYCOids ihotived similar srn oking status for tliose h[rrrt.trr'C, GRaMAxt S. SwANSON M.
Vitamin A and lung aiscer:
interviewed and'thost no"t interviewed. If cases who wete JNCt 191s; s2 t435-143s ;
not interviewed beaause' of pbor surviival diffeied from ,.,' (17) KvALE. G. B1EUE E. CARr JJ:
Dietary habits and lung cancer risk,
those who survived longer and were interviewed in-t~crrns ` :` Int J'Cancer 1983: 3!1:397rl05. ~
of the other ri3k fat tots under study, this "cti haNe= (18) MACK TM. Cancer Surveillance Program in
Los Angeles Cflttntq.
Natl Canccrlnst Monogr 1977; 47:99-101.
biased our rt?SUlts.' Howe'ver,~this appears tonl'iikely sinice ` (19) CRAtt;ut S,,MertruNC Fiber
and otherconstituenu of vegetables
our data showed'that histories of childhood pneumonia in cancer epidemiology. 1n: Newell GR
Ellison NiM; :eds:.
and' exPosurC'_tt)`:Cma~i. fires Weie' similar among GasGS Nutritionandcanceretioiogyand treatment.
Mew York. Raven
regardless of stagebf disease at diagnosis. There is also no ' Press. 19st;t89-215:. ,.
:(?D) MAats C. Nutritive value o[ American foods:in common unitaL
evidence that eantxi' survival' is associated with dtetary .. U.S. Department o[ Agriculture
Handbook No. 456. Washing,
vit3tnin' A intake. tonDC: U.S. Depanment'of Agriculture. 1975.
The etiology of SCC can be explained' alffiost `entirely :r (+21), Bwt.ow hIE, DAY 'ME. Statisti
cal methods in ant:er rescarch. Vol
by eigaretttt:smokutg ~Cigarette stYlbking, itowever;'ex I-The analysis o[ ase~ontrol studies.
IA'RC Sci Publ I980;
Plains.onlY about half `of the ADC cases On the basis of (22) YrsrrEtt R;, GEms B;.AtJnRaAtat O.
Application of ~the World.
this study, childhOod' lung disease and1 exposure to coal` Health Organization classification of
lung carcinoma to biopsy
fires in childhood explain at least another 2296 of ADC material. Ann'Tt~orat: Surg 1965;1~3-49.
cases. Passivasmokin and vitamin A ma be involwed ''. " (~)` Yr.snrER R C`RrER' D. Pathology
of~arcinoma of the lung Clin
~' Y ~ Chest Med 1992; 3:257-289 : ,
but more research is needed to clarify their roles in, lung" `' ~Z4) Dou. R, 1tttL AB,'KREYaERG LL
Thrsignifidnt:e of cell type in
cancer etiology. relation to the aetiology of lung cancer. Bt J' Cancer 1957:.
1'J:43-48.
(2S)'SYITDER EL;'CosJY LS, Atxtsutttt tC Lung cancer in xromen:
Presenrand future trends. JINatI Cancer Inst 1973; 51:39'I'~l01.
(26) KA-r-rAN M. Long-term sequelae of respiratory, iillness in'infancy
REFERENCES and'childhood. Pediatr Clin North Am 1979; 26:525-535.
(27) BuRRows B, Pie;uDSOK RJ. LEdowrr[ MD. The relationships of
W), Stt.VERBERG E. Cancer statistics, 1982. CA 1982: 32c15-31... .chiidhood respiratony illness to
adult obstructive airway disease.
(2), HENDEttsott BE- Descriptive epidemiology andi gemgraphic, , Am Rev Respir Dis 1977,
115:7511~-759.
pathology. In: Burchenal JH, Oettgen HF, eds., Cancer (28) S,tstET JM, TACER I8, SPErzt:R FE. The
relationship between
achievements, challenges and prospecu for the 1980's. Vol 1. respiratory, illness in childhood and
chroni'cai'rflow obstntction
New Yotia- Grune, 1'981:51-69. in adulthood. Am Rev Respir Dis 1983; 127308-523. ~
(B)', U.S. Public Health Service. The health consequences of smnking: (29) REDMOND CK., Ciocco A,
Lt.oi'n JW. Rtatt H'I1, Long-term
Z. Cancer. Washington DC: U.S. Govt Print Off, 1982 [DHEtiY: mortality study of steel workers. V1.
Mortality from malignant'
publiationMo.,(PHS)t32-50179] neoplasms among,eoke oven workers. J Occup-Med' 1972;
(4), litnutYAatA ' T. Non-smoking wives of heavy smokers have a higher 14:621-629,
risk of lung eaneere A study from Japan. Br Mcd' JI 198!1, (30) LtAYD JM1Y, Long.-term mortality
study o[' steelworkers. V.
282c183-185. ~ Respiratory, canccr_in coke plant workers. ji Occup Mtyd 197];
(S) TRtCHotouLOs':D., ICALANDIDI'A, SPAItR¢)s L, MACMAHON B1 ` 13:53-68.
;
Lung cancer and passive smoking. Int J'Cancer 1981; 27:1-4: (31) Dot.t. R.,FIsttER Ej, C.~:uuit)N W,
et al. Mortality of gasworker:
(6) CflRREA P;,Ptcatt.E LW, F6NTttAst E, Lr; YHaEnrs¢EL NJ Passive with special reference
tocancen of the lung,and bladder, chronic
smoking:and7ung,eancer. Lancet 1983; 2:595-597: bronchitis, and pneumoconiosis. Br J Ind Med
1!963;!22r1=17.
(7) Xu ZY, XuoHP.' Lt G. Air pollution and lung cancer in (32), HInDS MW, KouoNEt-LN; HAnctN'JIH:
Dietary vitamin, A.
Liaoning Province. Nat1 Cancer Inst Monoga. In press. carotene, vitamin C and risk of lung cancer
in,Hawaoi. Ant J
(8s BREStAw I:, HoAct1N L, RA:satussEt; C: AnRxats HK. Occupa Epidemiol 1934; 119:227-237:
tionsartdcigzrette snioking as risk factors in Jung,cancer. Am J (3)) GREGOR A, LEE PN, ROE FJi
1NdtsoN MJ1 IvYELTOr:' A. Cornpari=
Publit Health 1954; 44:I7I-181L son of dietary histories in lung: cancer cases and controls with
('a) Wt'rrDEtt Ely, BcRO ji1r. Carictr of the l:rr.g=t :ong non-sr:okers- spccial',iefoncnce
to vi tamin A. Nutr Cancer 1980; 2:93-97.
special referetiee:,. to histologic patterns:-, Cancer, 1967; ,(i)4) Saterti PG; Juex Ii. Cancers
among users of'preparations contain-
20 I 16t-1172 . ° : Ing vitamin A. Cancer 1978; 52:808=8'f 11, .~ '
(10) MENqt HRpttee MC, HEx~t~,rt BE, Jrtnc jS Lungancerrisk ~(,t5) ~ 1Gi;iux JD: SutTrt'AH, Stt
trtzER BR; Hiutrs CG. Serum.vitarmin A
among beauticians and other female.rorkera: BrirJcor:Imunica= L
:(netinml) and cancer tncidencre.in Evans County. Geotgsa. JNCI
tioru J Natl,Canaer tnst 1977:'59:1423-1425. ": . 1981; 66:7-I6 ,. . _
(11) AUER>fYtCH O,GARFWBEi. L, PAINCS VR. ScatYancer of the lung- Q6) SYALD'N, IDt.E l[; BbREHAM
J. Low serum vitamin A and subse-
incrraRe orei a 2/syear petdod Cancer 1479; 4bi636-6t2 ," quent risk of cancer. Lancet 1980;
2:813-815.
(t2) MAGLLA1IfAl1 R. DA',COSTA'J.;DAr NE: LAw CH. MG YK:'SttAN. .: .(37) WttiErr.WCPot.F.
BF.UNDERWooD BA,etial. Relationo[,serum
MUGytItA4'tt1W B:' Risk'factors for lung cancer in Singapore' - vitamioA and E',and carotenoids to
Qie risk of cancer. N'Eng1 J
Chinart, a population with high female incidence ntes:.. Int Ji '' Mcd 1984t 310:430-434.
Cancer 197r<; 40:854-a60. . (38) STAEUn HB, Burss 4 RosEt. FtiVanatER I l., BRAaACItER B.
(13) HtaArumA T~Dkt and ~'canc~r. Nutr fartcer 1979; 1:67-8I : ~ +, Vttamtn;ll, cardaszscular;,n:k
facton, and mortaliiy Iinaot .
(1~) Sttu[t,ix RB`,',I.[sr~t4"~t;"Ltw S, et al. Dietary vitamtn A'and ruk :~' M,r ',1982;
1:39l-393..'~; ~ ;- ~ ~
~'
l
