Philip Morris
Transcript of Proceedings Hearing on Deterring Childhood Smoking
Fields
- Author
- Adams, M.
- Chafee
- Evans, R.I.
- Foege, W.H.
- Griffith, C.
- Kennedy, E.M.
- Omalley, M.
- Pinney, J.
- Reilley, M.
- Schweiker
- Valeo, J.
- Wolff, T.
- Chafee
- Area
- LEGAL DEPT/CARLSTADT
- Type
- TRAN, TRANSCRIPT
- Site
- N28
- Request
- Stmn/R1-095
- Stmn/R1-096
- Stmn/R1-097
- Stmn/R1-096
- Recipient (Organization)
- Comm on Human Resources
- Senate
- Subcomm on Health + Scientific Research
- Senate
- Document File
- 2024955945/2024956148/Teenage Smoking
- Named Person
- Adams, M.
- Banzhaf, J.S. III
- Califano
- Chafee
- Daugherty, R.M., J.R.
- Debakke
- Dirksen
- Evans, R.I.
- Foege, W.H.
- Ford, W.H.
- Green, P.
- Griffith, C.
- Kennedy, E.M.
- Kretchmer, N.
- Leffall, L.D., J.R.
- Mcluhan, M.
- Omalley, M.
- Pinney, J.
- Reilley, M.
- Schweiker
- Surgeon General
- Swinehart, J.W.
- Valeo, J.
- Wolff, T.
- Young, D.
- Banzhaf, J.S. III
- Litigation
- Stmn/Produced
- Characteristic
- MARG, MARGINALIA
- MISS, MISSING PAGES
- Named Organization
- American Cancer Society
- American Heart Assn
- American Lung Assn
- American Thoracic Society
- Ash, Action on Smoking & Health
- Baylor College of Medicine
- Bethesda Chevy Chase High School
- Centers for Disease Control
- Congress
- Gonzaga College High School
- Green Dolmatch Advertising
- Hew, Dept of Health Education and Welfare
- House
- Immaculata High School
- Natl Inst of Child Health
- Natl Inst of Child Health + Human Develo
- Office of Smoking + Health
- Princeton
- Public Communications Center
- Subcomm on Smoking
- Univ of Houston
- Wv Wesleyan
- American Heart Assn
- Date Loaded
- 05 Jun 1998
- UCSF Legacy ID
- jlc46e00
Document Images
11
2
3
4
5
8
10
11
12'
13
14
15
16
17
1 £3
19
20
21
24
25
54'
and why she is, bccause peear group p=os.sa:: e aQc= to have
worked in completely contrary r®alms, and yow are obviously
geared to that, so that woiaad be part of your survey. I would
assuQO.
One of my questions is--stxcncturally, with your new of-
fico in HEw1' that Mr. Pinney is going to head up, is that cor-
rect?
Mr. Pir.rsy. Yes, sfr.
Senator Schcaoikor. I3ow will you integrat+e, though, with
tha National In:-tifiutc of ChiZd~ mca.l.th, because they have
very s,opa:rdte procedures on pa--r rev::gws of pro j3cts like
this, and I am, all for the io v-ogrztioa--bu : isn't that a prob-
lem? ~
Mr. Pinnoy. It is not a p*_'ob}.em, Senator. The phiZosophon w;aS.^tn thos office is based ia oae of
projQct m.amagemant. In
I
esseQca, tha Secretany felt that thQro was not enaugh atten-
tion at his level on tlld prcb3.aza of sm king and health. Thara
waa a lotgoing on in each of ttter Institutes, but the ques`cion
was : aral we directing what reWou:Fons we havato tho best
possible meann and ends? Ard, for examplo, with the National
~
.~
Institute of Child Health arrd'. Humaa Dsvelopimz:nt, my role woul~
ba c~n3: ofd~iscus~~aa.rnc~ with Dr. Fra~:~ch-n2r ~thatri~s pr~ogr~*~
_a1-s:~oun.^,c~~Gn t,c~~Gnt would say in tW~s of ®licitcing! good sound rQ--
sva.rch in Lhe r~rea~s tha-~ c~v have idontified as top priority.
The actLa~l corat~n~: of tho reseExc b p_-oposa.x s and the pa:

56
2'
3
6
7
10
11
1z
13'
14
15'
16
18'
19
20
21
22.
23
24
25'
Si7R1EAM?1~"TS', OF A PAiaE,Z!, OF IiI''nE SCHOOL SstTD-WT'S:
sI3EP;RSts WOLFF AND 2r:0IR& Bt£I1LEY, TMCriF:'CtJLATA
$ICE SCHOOL; MARTIId OrbiA.LT EY. MART SDLM.'S, AND'
CI3AR3aE'S *G.~FFI's"B, GONZAGA COLLEGE HIGH SCHOOL;
AItD XAH5S VAI.EO , HETMESDA-CHEVY CI3AM SIG,1i
SCHOOL
SQ!nator Kennedy. Wa~ will have a paaell of high school
stucLast-3 from Gonsaga Col2rsge High School, Immacula:a School
aad tha Bethesda--Ch^vy Chase High School. Thxoughan over-
sight, the Tra.T,aculata as:d Bnvhcsda-Clbestry Chase High Schools
ware aou mentionod', on the formal w;tnQss list, but they have
II.mea: euormous2y cooFarative as the young students have.
We want to uc3 c=3 you to th6 C:ai :tea. I think tha
Congress of the Dn:{ted Statss galZc its iaform.::iom f>om a
vartet:y of' sosces. We have iui this hegisLatfou that we have
.
before us aow--Fre are trc:ig!g to deal with an issue wnichI
than1; ia of enormoL3 coLcorn to pare.^.ts all over this country,
perhaps all avur tre r.rorld--parouts whoss pearhaDs first in-
tereat is tho good hralth of their childrea, parants who are
ia,^rzasingZ.r concorned! about t..:L ^:ip3osion in torms of thao
co:sumption of cigaratt-es. As so many scicntiiats aud ressasGh-
cr.s and fa..~:a:3'y doctors ha'vca poia:ed' out-, Whc scle;ztific i..°~for-
maticn is very clzar that wc, axa rc.ay l:y hcaded for a typa of
hcA3ich carastropre in t`,':is tatvir,,n if tha kinds of projections
rt~?ur~ havw Wa kssn p..~ce r:.: k-%B: a 3.Q68 a:^d 1974, amo ng young ceoplQ.
Am

8
9
i0
20
21
22.
23
24
57
moog tsenag4srs, in smo!sing continues. I think all of you
must have bean impressed by what some.of our_distinguis:hed
researchars and doctors have pointed'out to th.is Committss.
And' wo are frying, as wra should, to fi:nd' ways and maaas
of working with local co;=unitios and working with you and
your aasbciatss in the schools ~to try ar.d' find' out if th®re
ia some way wE can work in paricnQrship to ro2ivve this g,onora-
tion, this younger g~ta~~eration, of theburd.6n of smoJ.itsg. We
realiza it's complexj o,a realize it involves a vari©ty of
difrcreat guastio3s thati affect young peop1e--and wa want
vroz-y much this morning to hear from youi, w2&y 'yoa think iss
the nature of the prablemanca thra srays and means that we can
tes : deal with it.
So cve are very, very grateful to have you' join us hmrss
l
t3As morrning.
Howtaany of you havo ever testific3 boforo3 W011, it's ~
aoth3ng to bc concarue3 about, uno wa.u : just to hear from you inl
yo2.r owr, words.
I draw your a utcint:+.on to tho charts that we have over
P:ero that show im t.,':oss four disfe_~:a ::a: segmen:.o3 arcas th3
vexy si.gai {i cant growth in the numb,;:rs of regular smokers
u2twcaa 196& and 1974 by caTious ago categoriQs. And we can
sse #:rs tha youragest age, from 12, 13, and 14 year old, an
eightfold incroaEO;' corresponding incrc!a.ses, Forhaps aot
parcentage,eisc, bt^t cor"uainly' from the nlr.mbers dramatically

ss
to
16
17
ii3
19
20
21
2 33
ZA
25
. ,
continue intha 15 aand'16 a.ra~ 27 to18-and this is, asvte
can see in thG*chart that ict just behind it, at this point
the gir3.s are viz~-~ay ly evmm with thca boys in terms of' use
ofcfJgaacattes.,
8ut nonntltulomit has be= doscribed as asa explosion
in torms of the use of cigare9:tes, aad've would likr$ to try
an&sort of gain yourvicws about the i!esucs.
Wa would I3:ka to h,,.ar from you your own views about emn-
kingm r-m are not trying to make any moral judgmen+ts obvious-
ly, but we zro, fctyxnq to find out abryut--you can s`art off
with your naraas, your ages, ann' wharm you go to school, and
then we would like to ask you about -%r,hathar you sm-oko and
whe:z did ycw sta .~ znd sc-ma other questions.
I think we w3.'s1 gat started maybe over hmro with Thoa®ss.
Ta1 k is~t c o the -- mi;~,-,s, if you wQuld, and 9 ivQ us X our r~amop ag~.
~ _ r
and where you go to scliacl, justt ini_ia13:y wa will intrcduca
GYurs:12vGs. I am '1od', ..~fi~:3'9.y fT.oi3 bi8.3A,2chuf3e!:L'"''.S~ S,£.'"n.'12.to'r
Caafea from Mods Isla.nd, and Senator Sch-~3i.k+Qr frnm PQZn!syl-
van3a., and we arn zll fr°_*,~rs of t'_hv HeaLth Subccmmittee that
is coacd rned witi^.thislegi,slation,.
.S© juct give us your name, your age, your F,chcoZ, a
titrer. wo wil.,l con:e to -'raz. of' tTMa~ questions.
Niss t7al.ff. I am Th-ereee 'Rolff, I am 17' years old, and
% plan on goicg to Y:3st tTirgia{'r. Fashyaz next yaa:r.
.
L~cra L~~~r>a?
Scnater Chafe3. I,--d you jtst graduated

59
Riss Wolff . Iuanaculata.
Miss RaiLl®y., My name `ie. Xoira Reilley, I' am17 g and
I have just gra,duuated from h¢mactasata Sigh School.
Mr. 0'i4a.lZay. I am Martin 0'Mallvy, 15', I am a frashmaa
7
10
11
12
13
14
15
17
18
19
20
22
24
25
at Gonzaga College &igh School.
Mr. Adams. I am Mark Adams, I' sm.15, I am also a fre:sh-
man at Gotnzaga.
Mr. Grf:ffitr. I an Ch!arZos Griffith, I am 17, I ama
rt2uic+r at GQ3zzgz.
Mr. Vaiwo. I am James Vaa na and I am graduating from
Hathiesda-Clwsvy Cbaso High School.
Senator Ef..mr_ady. Could you te11 us, mayb; by just & show
of hc.uds, how many of yuu szmQ1:e?
Mayba we could start wiY.h you, Tharese and Moira--wha.n
did you start?
Miss wOlff. fi.ror.c3 14 or 15.
SArsator Zeaaedy. E'.~hat about you, Moira?
F"Uss P-3i'3lEy. I5.
Se,:a4:or Ja:n s?
a)
I
f~~ . ['a3.oc. YCs, s
rras 13 . Senator Yaauedy. t+';ar}.?
rx. Adams. I was 13.
Soaator Xehnad y. I know tliat `'s a tesy ycars ago, but do
you think you could try aad vaybe tell us about why you. de-
C::d:d to s4:~ ~ y to smoke or not to smoko? Was it sort of a

60
11
12
13
16
17
18
1'9
20
21
22
23'
24
conscious decisioa?
Mis,s Pteilley. we2:l, basically when people start smol,ingg
ci'garettes, it is iecauso of peer p_sssurs: your friends start
to smokc. A:od then it ia a choice of whether you want to- be,
sort of' left out, you know, by peoplc of yo~.tx owa age lif you
don t start s~aok.irg, you kaow, thay sori of look downou you.
Senator Chafse. What perce.utageof the girls in your
class smoke, arould you say?
A
Miss R,:131sy.ZAl my class I would' say about 8!5 percent.
Sc:,ator Kcnnady. tihat F-bouL you, Theresse, when you
starte :' to mo3Wr??'
Kis;a cFo? st. .i staar:ea s:acking mostly because I like it.
I wo:.ald' say 1 sta::.tad smoking probably to fit in with the,
crowd.
Se, ator i:a.~zedw. Let me zsY, tY:e oo:css who do smol:e--
couzid I j sst sac yo s:.r hac;as again? How nany -of your parents
smoko? E3ih yomr p~~.ra2ts siaokc?"
Mr . valco. onci of mine.
Sanator Keunz-e5.y. Gns of your parents. Howabout tha
oocs that dou ` z sno;tQ, do your parents gmol::e or not muoY.a?
Fri;x":iu, what, abQut that?
Kv. O° iFmllcy . Or:c of rix pareut:s smoltes, bst ho ±'s not
a c'.7z'Sisw;';3t ri::ok.aT_'i he ]us~``. has sflL'1w C:'wary onCa in a Whl ilfBl.
Mr. Criffiti..`:. Eauh of -mize smoko.
SL,!tELtor Md you ciozlt smobe. Flar;:, cto.lat about

2
3
4
6
14
1'5
16
61
you..
Mr . Adams. Neithar of my pa:rcnts smokes. My mofi2ier used
to, but sho qu.tt..
Se.naltor F,emedy. Do your friaads thtnst at all, about tb0
2tealtii implications of smokizig, or doI you sort of think about
it and think it is not going to happen to me? What kind of
-a sensedoyou or any of your,frierds have about whetherit,
really is goi no, to make much of a differauco in terns of' your
heal'th or no w? Both your oLm view and wh3ti you bflar some of
your friandQtalk abrsLt~.
Mr .©"2.aZ1ey. 'np11, I would say that kids my age ar en''t
really conceraed, with th& health issues, youi know; they ta11Ck
about it may be. But th* main tha;_~g that they are doing it
for is, you know, jiusr to fit in with the crowd. Smoking
is somethlng that most a.du?'ts do:. So I P.h.ink the reason why
the kids do it is just so t3z3y can get a feeling of, you know,
17
:-l:isu Feilley. l1arurity.
18' It
I
19
20
21
22
24
2S
1ir. fl1i:-:41J.'0y. Yes, m3furi.ty. But I c?ou`t t.izir-k they aro
rsa3.iy co: caru;,~d th:;.i: u:u.ch with the health { rauos.
Sr--:ac: tor P'anr.edy. h'hat a,boca it, Jim?
Ni .Valeo. Wa11, t:=hcn I fiFt startod to szao Ae, you know,
I ia.scd' to think it cokl:dh't Qzpp": u to mo. I cotaldn"t got ill
from it, ?' FTas imusZo to it or, sonsthiug. But now that I am
Ilf
' old3:, I have be= thimling--T_
~.
caz: sSG how it has affected

62
my a;cility to run any length of' diBt.Gncp, you know, my wind.
Senator Kennedy. Are you an athlete?'
Mr. Valeo. Well, I used to run track, I usal to sprint.
When I' sprrintad, it didn't make a dyffarence, because, youu
17
know, a hundred, yards--that's. nothing. But I am talking about
doasn't vTorY, because th-sre ar+s too many times wbsn a cigarette
tasS:es good--that's what i:, boils down to. But I amjust going
going to quit amoJting, b,3causo I can sse th-- effect t3lat it
has had on se as far as thal.; gooes.
Sanator SchFraik+er. A:~e you going to guiw cold tcurkey,
or, ho: a: e you go{ ng to quit, Jim?
hs. Valao. k'ell, I hava tried Wo cut doten, a,nd it just
going out to raa twolor threo miles--I 'don't know vDothar I
couUdo it anymor+s without .huffing and puffing at the end off
it.
But aow, you know, I have made a vow to myself that I am
to go all ths way, quit~ cold turkuy u.rith it, rLern. I quit.
Senator Charee. Chsxles, InoticQ that you don't smoke
18'
13 and h:~th your parents smoke. Nov, are you involved inathi®-
20 , tics or what particula:r raason do you not ssaoke?
21
22
.
mr. Griff3th. I didh't saoha--a lot of my friends startle
C+
to smot,e back in 7th a:ad' 3~,.°~, grauos, anr1' my parents emokcd, IV i
t4 be% i"3~pemrtdrdMt.~~~
aL3 I just tr`a~zt~ '~0 1,_~
.
1
23' ~'1
I
~ t~ stitiLudE of ~
i
T
bo
S^
t
F
a
3:
,t
you a
u
X._
ua
Wr
a':
m
~
~ ~a
H
24
C!1
thw sc'-,oo1s arout th,3 smoking. Do your schools: cr3rn:.t it, doGW
25

2
3
7
63
ttaay'diiscourag+s it? Does ttat sai:e any differencQ? What
about it, Moira?
Miss Reill.ey. Most Catholic high schools, I would say,
allow it for saniors. Our high school didn't all'ota smoking
at all. Ganara:lly, most public high schools,' there's so muchh
s:2oI:ing tharo is nothi'ng you can do about it.- But I would
generally say that most schools allow it; thcre's hot much
you caa do, so many Faorlc,isa;ak6.
SGnator Rc3um-dy. What about this health issura, Th,"resra?
110
il
12
14
15
1 °'
19
20
211
2?
23
24
Do you thir.k that many of the yoUUg:sr people that get started
givQ that very mjch attenticsa or much t.hough~.:, or d+o you:
find cut when they got a little o1d= that tzl~qy begin to give
{ t more and then ara they hoo3:ed' on it, or whaQ?
Miss Wolff. When you f'ir:.t start smoki.zig, it doesn'fi--
zt least sv'~th a--, ifc didn't take ®ffect unti2 lik® a couple
of yssxs a,ftar, like.aow I canse3 that I can't ruaas raur.hh
or parwicipz,,,c~ as much i'n activi:::.vs. I doa rt thizik they
raz.33:y icolr into la, thra health coacaiticas: of ft.
Senwtor Koanuz2'1. PfarI:, what do you think? Do you think
t?:ce v think much a.txout th~:, hea:.th factors in tha s:.'~pkiag?
W"
Psp. P:riam3. VLh41, I first W:arte~H, yes, 1: thoua4t about' ~.
0l
:~at. b=zt I fiaraT.--d, j oL know,, that i wotil3n''t be smUl:iug iayNwholc Ii;es Z figured
l<il:e cthe.z I' turnad 3.8 I would stop or
~,
~
som-ething z'ikra that. 0
G't'
But now, as tima goes by, you know. A
25'

64
I
3
4
5
6
£anator PCsnnedy. You are thinking more about it, about
trhsthiii to stop?
Wh~.:t do any of you t'hia1: would ba---laave some of you
thought about stopping smoking? I.at me saa a sbowof bands.
How many of you thought about stopping smoking? Jirs, you
thought about it.
Sanator Schciaf.ker. Hra's going to do it..
Sonato, Fennc-lw. 1ttG's going to do it. What do you think
7
are :roa11y «t~e factors t'.at vrould make a diff~ncs in wh!sther
you ca3 stop or not? Is it ag;zin what is laappening with your
fri~,r~d~~, your colleagu~,s? Or do you think tho fact that you
o
a
o
Y * b' a t~ h 1'tU i~ t'' ti ? D* tti '~ h 1
91
10
11
v n
rc ~
~~. ~~ 6a p zca ot~ cws a,L e p you
i2 r
~
13 or a,`~coaYage you to stop sSnokisag?
= a do
the m
FJ1-
cu tl~N n: a:~= th!s `-Mn r s that ca~ heZ'
~ost
.
y
p
14 m
1]
rs to stop?
in f.arms of ae:cting tEx:znaga
,1.
15
!f
.
Hy ss P.!:,il1ev 2~fost 4r~nagc,,s azGn't rc, ~ 2y weZI in~`ormr~d
._
16 f~ _. c. .. _
11
about thehealti pro'~lc~^_~. You see co=3rci&.'1a ard ads that
I]
17
f1'
in twenty years you mR ght deve2op lunv cancnr,
°'`y vou know
,
I" _
18
!1
you start
or somatkifng 1'ike that. But when yot~ ora young and
m
i
3;i
of th
?
do
'hj
t
;
ff
o
-
:
t
~
you
nc,
.,
g
n
r
:
ong
Uc
~
s: y
ci C
r
u ara 0
20 II ~
N
~u`=t t?~~n.ki:~g, aroLt now and you a.rc th3.nl:ing abou~--I will wp~
21 1II' CD
22
24
just try smoring fbr a uhi:Ie and then quitc. ~
But you would havc tc s;:art at tho schools probably, ber- Col
CJI
cause t-hat is wh: r6 i^.ost people start. And if you caa stop
peop:!3 from smoking at Echocl, th~-n i:hay are 'Just not going to
25
