Philip Morris
Indoor Environmental Quality in Non-Industrial Work Environments
Fields
- Area
- PATSKAN,GEORGE/OFFICE
- Type
- REGU, REGULATION
- Named Organization
- American Natl Standards Inst
- Ashrae, American Society of Heating, Refrigerating + Air-Conditioning Engineers
- Centers for Disease Control
- Niosh, Natl Inst for Occupational Safety & Health
- OSHA, Occupational Safety & Health Administration
- US Dept of Labor
- Ashrae, American Society of Heating, Refrigerating + Air-Conditioning Engineers
- Request
- Stmn/R1-048
- Master ID
- 2023714085/4177
Related Documents:- 2023714085
- 2023714086
- 2023714087 Index
- 2023714088 Table of Contents
- 2023714089 1
- 2023714090-4091 Summary of Published Reports Concerning OSHA Studies of Workplace Exposure to Determine Lung Cancer, Heart Disease Risks
- 2023714092-4103 Indoor Air Power Over Indoor Air May Shift From Epa to OSHA, Industry Says Indoor Air Proposal Begins Grueling Journey Washington, Maryland Set Pace Nationwide in Efforts to Establish Policy on Indoor Air. Three Health Groups Push for More Indoor Air Action
- 2023714104-4105 OSHA Plans 000300 Publication of Notice Addressing Broad Air Quality Health Concerns
- 2023714131 2
- 2023714132 Summary of Information on Kenny S. Crump, Ph.D.
- 2023714147-4149
- 2023714150 Explanation of Codes
- 2023714151 Dissertation Abstracts International (Brs)
- 2023714152 3
- 2023714153-4155 Summary of Information on Kenneth G. Brown, Ph.D.
- 2023714156 Brown, Kenneth Gerard
- 2023714157-4176 Health Effects of Passive Smoking: Lung Cancer in Adults and Respiratory Disorders in Children Science Advisory Board Meeting 901204 and 901205
- 2023714177 Passive Smoking and Risk of Lung Cancer: the Epidemiologic Evidence
- Litigation
- Stmn/Produced
- Characteristic
- BLAN, BLANK
- DRFT, DRAFT
- Site
- R589
- Date Loaded
- 05 Jun 1998
- UCSF Legacy ID
- aps34e00
Document Images
DRAFT February 5, 1993
INDOOR ENVIRONrSENTAL QUALITY IN NON-INDUSTRIAL WORK ENVIRONM:'P1TS
Authority and 8ignatitre
This document was prepared under the direction of
. Pursuant to sections 6(b) and 8(c): and 8(g)(2)~ of
the Act, OSFiAhereby amends 29 CFR part 1910 by adding a new S
1910. as set forth below.
List of 8ubjects in 29 C?R Part 1930
Sndoor Environmental Quality, Occupational Safety and
Health.
is hereby amended as follo-as:
pA1RT
1. The authority citation for is amended by adding
the following citation at the end. (Cit-' ation which precedes
asterisk indicates .) i+tldorliY
2. .
5 1910. Indoor Enviroamental Quality.
[a) ScoFe =and anoLication. (1) This sectiorn shall apply
to all employers and gmployees under oSry:A jurisdiction. :'his
standar3 applies to all building owners and employers with non-
industrial work environments. This includes public and private
buildings, schools, healthcare facilities, offices and commercial
establishsents. The scope of this standard includes non-
'industrial vork environments that are part of industrial
worksites (i.e., an office, cafeteria, or break room located at a
manufacturing facility). [Adopted in part from Washington State
FAQ draft].
DRAFT: DO NOT CITE OR QUOTE
i
7

DRAFT
sbl Def_initions --
February 5, 1993
Merican Society of Hea ~~j'r g. Retriaeratina and Air-
ccnditioninc Envineers iASH'RAE) means the corisensus standard of
the society which is a professional organization composed of
national and international members, associated societies, and
public views. The standard concerning the ventilation for
acceptable indoor air quality is ASIRAE 62-1989 and the standard
concerning environmental conditions for human occupancy is
A*1SIjASHRAE 55-1981.
AuthorizedPersae means any person authorized by the
building owner and required by work duties to be present in a
non-industrial work environment. ga~ means the employer creating a smokefree work environment
by banning all indoor smoking of tobacco products.
guildina otmer means the person(s) who has legal rights and
obligations for any public or private building. The building
owner may delegate responsibilityfor building operation and
maintenance activities, in writing, to an agent (e.g., property
manager, facility manager), lease holder, or other person(s) who
have control of the worksite.
Desia ated smflkina azea means an area separated from common
work and congregation areas that has dedicated exhaust
ventilation.
High-efficiency particulate air (AEPA!. filter means a filter
capable of trapping and retaining at least 99.97 percent of 0.3
DRAFT: DO NOT CITE OR QUOTE N 2
C
W
. '".~

DgAYT February 5, 1993
micrometer diameter mono-disperse particles.
RyAE system means the collective components of t.he heating,
ventilation and air-conditioning system.
Mainstream smoke means the smoke breathed in by a person
actively smoking a tobacco product.
Nonindustria vork environment means an indoor or enclosed
occupied space such as, but not limited to, offices, educational
facilities, commercial establishments, and heaithcare facilities.
It does not include areas such as manufacturing and product'.on
facilities, residences, vehicles, building construction worY.sites
(where the building is not occupied by employees covered under
this standard), agricultural operations, and offices where
employees are directly involved in production or manufacturing
processes (e.g., small quality control office where employees
move frequently in and out to production areas). oif ice areas,
cafeterias, and break rooms located at a manufacturinq or
production facility where employees are nct directly involved in
production or manufacturing processes are included in the scope
of this standard.
gassive tobacco smoke means the product of tobacco
combustion, including sidestrean smoke, exhaled mainstream smoke,
vapors that escape through the cigarette or eiqar wrapping, and
exhaled mainstream smoke. Zt is commonly referred to as
environmental tobacco smoke, secondary smoks, or.involuntary
smoke.
~
DRAFT: DO NOT CITE OR QUOTE ~ 3
C4

DRAFI, Februaz'X 5, 1993
si'de tream smoke means the smoke emitted from the burning
end of the tobacco product.
DRAFT: DO NOT CITE OR QUOTE
(0

DRAFT February 5, 1993
(Preliminary gross provisions for IAQ standard: ]
(c). System Do umentation. The building owner shall
provide the following HVAC system information upon request to the
employer or the
(1). The latest HVAC design, operation and maintenance
documentation if available, including dates of building
construction, HVAe system installation, commissioning, or most
recent HVAC modification.
(2). A description of the HVAC system including type of
HVAC system (VAV, dual duct, multi-zone, heat pump, etc...),
major components, current total air capacity (in C:M), current
and minimum outside air supply rates to occupied areas (in CFM),
design occupant density loads, air filter system, filter
efficiency, temperature and humidity design criteria, operation
and m3intenance procedure, and any mechanical systems desiqned
for local exhaust.
[d1 Svstetn Oceration.
(1) The HVAC system shall be maintaiaed and operated to
provide at +east the outdoor air ventilation rate (based on
actual occupancy) required by the applicable building code,
mechanical code, or ventilation and indoor air quality code in
effect at the time the permit covering the building AvAC system
was issued.
(2) Heating systems shall be operated to maintain the
following conditions:
DRAFT: DO NOT CITE OR QUOTE O 5
0
W
0

DRAFT February 5, 1993
i) Temperatures no lower than 68°F and tio higher than 74°F
in winter.
ii) Where mechanical cooling is provide, these systems
shall be oped ated to maintain temperatures no higher than
8o°F and no lower than 73°F in summer.
iii) Relative humidity shall be maintained below so8 in
buildings with mechanical cooling systems to prevent growth
of biological contamihants.
(3) The KVAC system must be operated continuously during
all scheduled work shifts (except during emergency reprirs) and
during scheduled naintenance and calibration.
(4) HVAC operation specifications and detailed maintenance
guidance shall be provide to the HVAC operation and maintenance
personnel or contractor by the building os,rner. IIp-to-date HvAC
system operation procedures shall be posted cn or near the
equipment, or in a procedural manual/central record located at
the facility. '
(5)~ Buildings without AvAC systems shall maintain proper
operation of operable exterior openirg areas (if allowed.ir. lieu
of mechanical ventilation) required by the applicable building
code in effect at the time the building permit was issued.
(6) Zmployers shall maintain physical equipment-rooms in
clean condition, especially if rooms are part of the air exchange
plenum of the HV'A:C system.
i) No storage of chemicals or other aqents that could, if
DRAFT: Do NOT CITE OR QUOTE © 6
. N
tt

DRAPT February 5, _993
spilled, be taken up by the air system and transported to
the rest of the building.
ii) Asbestos, if friable, should be encapsulated so as not
to be taken up by the air stream and-distributed to the
of f ices down stream.
(7) Carbon dioxide (CO=) levels i+ill be kept below 6S0 ppm
(e.g., used as an indicator of adequate ventilation).
(8) When the supply of air is reduccd during times the
space is occupied (e.g., in variable air volume systens),
provision shall be made to maintain acceptable indoor air quality
throughout the occupied zone through:
Source reduction, ii) Maintenance of CO2 levels at or below 6SO ppm, and
iii) Expeditious use of maintenance and housekeeping
chemicals. '
(9) i) Fuel-burning appliances, including fireplaces
located indoors, shall be provided with suyficient air for
combustion and adequate removal of combustion products.
ii) when infiltration supplies all or part of the
.
combustion air, the supply rate of air shall be
demonstrable.
iii) The operatiors of clothes dryers and exhaust fans may
require introduction of additional makeup air to avoid
interference with fuel-burning appliances.
iv) Combustion system, kitchen, bathroom, and clothes dryer
DRA!'T: DO NOT CITE OR QUOTE
7

DRAFT February 5, 1993
vents shall not be exhausted into attics, crawlspaces, or
basements.
(10) To remove particulate contaminants, air filters or
dust collectors shall be used.
i) Dust collec~tors, not air filters, should be used where
the dust loading equals or exceeds 10 mg/ms (4 qrains/l000
ft=) .
ii) Air filters and dust collectors shall be selected for
the particle size and loading encountered.
iii) When utilized, these filters must be maintained
acccrdinq to manufacturer's specifications.
(1].) Relative humidity in habitable spaces preferably
should be maintained between 30% and 60% relative humidity to
minimize growth of allergenic or pathogenic organisms.
(12) Air-handling unit conder.sata pans shall be maintained
for self-drainage to preclude the buildup of microbial slime.
'i) Periodic in-situ cleaning of cooling coils and
condensate pans shall be conducted.
ii): Air-handlinq and fan coil units shall be easily
accessible for inspection and preventive mainter.ance.
(sh
?SR~'~ ANCE.
a
(1) The building owner shall identify a person(s) (e.g.,
individual, contractor, company, aqency, or department) to be
responsible for the operation and maintenance of.the AVAC system.
The person(s) identified for these tasks shall be knowledgeable
DRAFT: DO NOT CITE OR QUOTE . ~
N
W
~
N
. ~
8

DRAFT February 5, 1993
in the principles of HvAC system operation and maintenance, HVAC
testing procedures, the requirements of this standard, and the
specific xVAC system service the building or office.
[nonmandatory appendix outlining levels of knowledqe required,
-
courses available.]
(2) The building owner shall cause (ensure that) the HVAC
system components (are) to be inspected, adjnsted, cleaned,
calibrated, or replaced as ipecified in the guidance required in
section d4. These components include, but are not limited to,
air filters and f ilter seals, drip pans and drainage piping,
heatin,q and cooling coils, supply/exhaust vents and louvers,
dampers and damper actuators, fan motor belts, humidifiers, air
cleaners, thermostats, control devices, and scnsors.
i) In addition, the employer shall cause (ensure that)
adequate ventilation system inspection and subsequent
maintenance shall include system balancing once a year and
semiannual RvAC inspection and cleaning.
(3) The building owner shall ensure that inspections and
maintenance of the HVAC system are performed by the designated
person(s) as specified in sections ei and e2.
i) The building owner shall ensure that maintenance system
inspections and repairs are documentsd in a log and retained
for at least three years.
ii) The inspection and maintenance log shall include the
specific actions taken, the name and affiliation of the
DRAFT: DO NOT CITF OR QUOTE
9
9

DRAFT February 5, 1993
individual performing the work, and the date of the
inspection or maintenance activity.
iii) The inspection and maintenance log shall be available
on request to -the employer, employee representative, and the
(4) Personal Protective Equipment required to safely
perform maintenance procedures [Construction Industry 1926;
Subpart E--Personal Protective and Life Saving Equipment]:
i) Head Protection (1926.100 Read Protection) Employees
working in areas where there is a possible danger of head
injury from impact, or from falling or flying objects, or
from electrical shock and burns, shall be protected by
protective helmets.
(a) Helmets for the protection of employees against
impact and penetration of falling and flying objects
shall meet the specifications contained in American
Nation4l Standards Instituto, Z89.1-1969, Safety
Requir aments for Industrial Health Protection.
(b) Helmets for the head protection of employees
exposed to high voltage electrical shock and burns
; shall meet the specifications contained in American
Itational Standards Institute, Z89.2-1971.
ii) Hearing Protection. Wherever it is not feasible to
reduce the noise levels or duration of exposures to those
specified in Table D-2, Permissible Noise Exposures, i~S
O
DRA,FT : DO NOT CITE OR QUOTE 2V'
W
10
9

DRAFT February 5,.199]
1926.52, ear protective devices shall be provided and used.
(a) Ear protective devices inserted in the ear
shall be fitted or determined individaally by
competent persons.
(b) Plain cotton is not an acceptable device.
iii) Eye and Face Protection: General: Employees shall be
provided with eye and face protection equipment when
machines or operations present- potential eye or face injury
from physical, chemical, or radidtion agents.
(a) Eye and face protection equipment required by this
Part shall meet the requirements specified in American
National Standards Institute, Z87.1-1968, Practice for
Occupational and Educational Eye and Face Protection.
(b) Employees whose vision requires the use of
corrective lenses in spectacles when required by this
regulation to wear eye protection, shall be protected
by goggles or spectacles of one of the following types:
(1) Specttcles whose protective lenses provide
optical correction;
(2) Goggles that can be worn over corrective
spectacles without disturbing the adjustment of
the spectacles;
,
(3) Goggles that incorporate corrective lenses
mounted behind the protective lenses.
(c) Face and eye protection equipment shall be kept
DRAYT: DO NOT CITE oR @L1oTE 11

DRAF'T February
clean and in good repair. The use of this type
1993
equipment with structural or optical defects shall be
prohibited.
iv) Respiratory Protection: General: In normal
maintenance activity, appropriate respiratory protective
devices shall be provided by the employer and shall be used.
(a) Respiratory protective devices shall be approved
by the Centers for Disease Control or acceptable to the
U.S. Department of Labor for the specific
contaminantls) to which the employee may be exposed.
(b) The nature and extent of the hazard, work
re4v.irements, and conditions, as well as the
limitations*and characteristics of the available
respirators, shall also be factors considered in taking
the proper selection.
(c) The group of respirators required are one of the
folloWing:
O
~
(1): Dust mist, W
~
(2) Dust-mist fume, ~
(3) Air-purifyinq, half-mask or mouthpiece N
N
respirator with chemical cartridge
filter.
(d)
protective equipment shall be instructed in the
and appropriateJ
Selection, issuance, use and care of respirators.
(1) Ebployees required to use respiratory
DRAFT: DO NOT CITE OR QUOTE 12

DRAFT February 5, 1993
use and limitations of such equipment, with
special emphasis on the importance of proper fit.
(2) Respiratory protective equipment shall be
inspected regularly and maintained in good
condition. chemical cartridges shall be replaced
as necessary so as to provide complete protection.
Mechanical filters shall be cleaned or replaced as
necessary so as to avoid undue resistance to
breathing.
(3) Respiratory protective equipment which has
been previously used shall be cleaned and
3isintected before it is issued by the employer to
another employee.
(v) occupational foot protection. Safety-toe footwear
for employees shall meet the requirements and
specifications in American National Standard for Ments
Safety-Toe Footwear, 241.1-1967 (1910.136).
(5) The employer (lessee) shall be notified at time of
lease what the design occupancy level is for the space being
leased.
: i) The employer (lessee) shall notify the building owner to
have the RYAC system evaluated when design occupancy levels
are exceeded.
ii) Alterations of the HVAG system (e.g., increase of
outdoor air supply, exhaust air, change of air distribution
DRAFT: DO NOT CITE OR QQOTE V 13
k
V

DRArT February 5, 1993
patterns, rebalancing, or addition of local exhaust systems)
shall be made to meet the minimum requirements specif ied in
sections dl and d2.
(6) ventilatinq ducts and plenums shall be maintained to
minimize the opportuhity for growth and dissemination of
microorganisms through the ventilation system.
ffl CONTROLS FCR SPECIFIC A R CONTAMIN7ANT SOURCES.
(1) Smoking. smokinq'shall either be prohibited or
permitted only in designated smoking break roosns.
i) Designated smoking rooms shall be prohibited in common
areas such as rest rooms, wash rooms, hallways, and
stairways and cafeterias or snack rooms; as vell as in
private offices.
ii) Rooms designated as smoking areas shall have a
ventilation system exhausted directly outside, to prevent
smoke-contaminated air from being recirculated through the
work envir.onment.
iii) Designated smoking rooms shall be clearly posted and
operated at a negative pressure compared to surrounding
spaces including ceiling plenums and/'or cavities.
iv) All the airtrom the dedicated smokirq area shall be
exhausted directly to the outside.
(2) Other indoor air contaminants.
i) Air contaminants from specitic outdoor sources such as
cooling towers, sanitary vents, vehicular exhaust from
DRAFTs DO NOT CITE OR QUOTE
14

DRAFT February 5, 1993
parking garages, loading docks, and street traffic vehicle
or odors from trash storage shall, insofar as is feasible,
be prevented from entering the building through air intakes,
entryways, or other openings.
ii) Indoor levels of combustion products (especially in
areas of high combustion product production, such as parking
garages) not exceed National Primary Ambient-Air Quality
Standards for Outdoor Air?
(3) HvAC systems shall incorporate a minimum air filtration
efficiency of 30% (by the ASHRAE atmospheric dust spot test,
ASHRAE 52-76) if the system capacity allovs it.
(4) The employer shall ensure that the operation and maintenance of equipment and processes that
have the potential to
produce indoor air pollutants are b~inq operated and maintained
according to manufacturers recommendations.
(5) Reduction of factors that can lead to Bioaerosoi
Generation.
i) The building owner and employer shall control biological
contamination in the building by repairing known water leaks
as soon as is feasible.
ii) The building owner and employer shall control
bioloqical contamination in the building by drying,
replacing, removing, or cleaning porous materials (e.g.
carpet, upholstery, ceiling tiles, etc.)that have become
wet within two vorking days-.
DRAFT: 'DO NOT CITr OR QUOTE
0
15
i

DRAFT February 5, 1993
In addition, visible moss, mold, or algae shall be
prevented from growing in ductwork, humidifiers, other HVAC
system components, or on building surfaces within
conditioned spaces.
(6) Use of cleaning and maintenance chemicals, pesticides,
and other hazardous chemicals in the workplace:
i) Use and application of pesticides shall be used
according to manufacturers' recommendations.
ii) Persons working in areas to be treated shall be
informed of the type of chemicals intended to be applied
within 48 hours of application.
(7) Contaminants from stationary local sources within the
space shall be controlled by collection and removal as close to
the source as practicable. (See "Industrial ventilation--2ianual
of Recommended Practice".)
Sgl ENVIRONMENTAL OUALSTY II1 RENOYATED BUILDINGS AND
ItEXODELED OFFICES ._
(1) The buildinq owner and employer shall ensure that
procedures, engineering controls and other appropriate controls
are utilized to prevent degradation of indoor environmental
.quality for building occupants during remodeling, reroofing,
painting and similar activities.
(2) Modification of HvAC system.
iy The building owner or employer shall ensure that the
HVAC system is evaluated as. an integral part of remodeling
DRAFT: DO NOT CITE OR QIIOTE

DRAFT February 5, 1993
activities involving changes to the HVAC system or changes
affecting air distribution from the RoAC systent (e.g., new
Walls) .
ii) Alterations of the H'VAC system (e.g., increase out
outdoor air supply, exhaust air, change of air distribution
patterns, rebalancing, or addition of local exhaust systems)~
shall be made to meet the minimum requirements specified in
section dl and d2.
(3) Work plan development.
i) Before remodeling or similar activities are begun, the
contractor or individual(s) performing the work shall meet
with the.building owner, or the employer representative and
shall agree to a vork plan designed to prevent degradation
of indoor environmental quality durinq and after the work.
ii) The work plan shall consider all of the follovinq where
applicable:
1) Requirements of this standard.
2): Curtailment, and/or supplemental, or auxiliary
workplace ventilation as necessary to.control
contaminants, odors, Qte...during remodeling and to
control residual contaminants, odors, etc...after
remodeling.
3) Isolation of Trork areas and appropriate pressure
containment.
4) Fume, dust, and odor suppression and/or auxiliary
DRAF'T : DO NOT CITE OR QUOTE
f
~ 17
N
W
;2
~
N
Is
0

DRAFT February 5, 1993
air filtration/cleaning.
5) Preventing contaminant entry into KVAC system,
including outside air intakes, return/recirculation air
streams or plenums.
(4) Prior notification of employees.
i) The building owner or employer shall notify employees at
least 2.4 hours in advance, when feasible, of work to be
performed on the building (in their workarea].
ii) Notification shall also include anticipated adverse
impacts on indoor air quality or workplace conditions.
(h) Eanlovee infoz,~nation and traininqi The employer shall
provide maintenance employees with information and training to
ensure that they are aware of this standard.
(1) Training of maintenance workers in AvAC system
operation and maintenance.
i) The availability and training in the use of personal
protective'equipment (PPE) needed in operating and
maintaining HVAC systems (e.g., cleaning out air handlers
and ducts that are seriously contaminated aith mold and
other potentially dangerous substances), as vell as in
regular maintenance of the building (e.g., painting,
application of pesticides, ete.).
ii) During building cleaning and maintenance maintain
adequate ventilation to exhaust fvmes.
iii) Train maintenance personnel in the use and disposal
of
DRAFT: DO NOT CITE OR QUOTE O' 18
N
Cj
~
~
N
. W

DRAFT February 5, 1993
chemicals and other agents used to maintain the interior and
exterior of the building (e.g., paints, floor stripping
chemicals, carpet cleaning, regular cleaning--vacuuming
causes an increase in particulates).
(2) Employees_shall be informed of:
(i) The contents of this standard and its appendices which
shall be made available to employees;
(ii) The location and'availability of the system
documentation '(section c) and system operation (section d),
(iii) Signs and symptoms associated with poor indoor
environmental quality;
(iv) The location and availability of known re=erence-
'
material on the health hazards and remediation for exposure;
and
(v) The disciplinary actions taken by the company in
situations of noncompliance.
(3) Employee training shall include:
(i) Methods and observations that may be used to detect the
presence of poor indoor air quality;
(ii) The measures employees can take to protect themselves'
from this hazard, including speaific procedures the employer
has implemented to protect employeei from poor indoor air
qua2.ity, such as appropriate work practices, designation of
smoking areas, etc.; and
(iii) The employee shall be trained on the applicable
DRAFT: DO'NOT CITE OR QUOTE ry 19
. ~.
N
Ca
~
~
~
. ~

DRAFT February 5, 1993
details of the employer's indoor environmental program.
(i) Area Desi ~~q,~ati_on. (1) With respect to siqr:s and
dEsiqnated smoking areas: .
(i) Employers shall provide and place signs in appropriate
locations identifying designated smoking areas.
(ii) Employers shall ensure that signs are clearly legible.
(i) Recordkeepina_._ (1) Requirements under this provision.
i) The 'employershall establish, maintain, and make
~.
. ~. ,
available to all employees an accurate record of operation
and maintenance schedules, as well as any investigations
pertaining to poor indoor environmental quality.
ii) The inspection and maintenance record or log shall include the specific actions taken, the name
and affiliation
of the individual performing the work, and the date of the
inspection or maintenance activity.
iii) The inspection and maintenance log shall be available
on request to the employer, employee representative, and the
(2) The employer shall assure that such records are kept,
transferred, and made available in accordance with 29 CFR
1910.20.
Ski Dates--(i1 Effective date. This section shall become
effective LTaruary 1. 199?.
2.
Start-uD*dates.
(i) Employers shall have developed and implemented an
20
NDR#FT: DO NOT CITE OR QVOTE N

DRAFT February 5, 1993
Indoor Environmental Quality Policy no later than July 1,
199?.
Provisions of such a policy shall include one of the following a)
establishment of separately ventilated designated smoking areas
or b) the banning of -smoking in all indoor work areas.
Em) ADAendices_ The information contained in the appendices
is not intended, by itself, to create any additional obligations
not otherwise imposed or to detract- from any existing obligation.
Appendiz A to S 1s1o~. ---Carbon Dioxide xeasurement Protocol
(Non-Kandatory)
Carbon dioxide measurements are surrogate measurements for
outdoor air ventilation rates in buildings. Elevated carbon
dioxide levels, a byproduct of huznan respiration, are indicative
of an inadequate supply of fresh outdoor air. Carbon dioxide
concentrations below 8o0 ppm in the occupant's breathing zone
generally indichte that the ventilation is adequate. However, in
some cases, indoor air problems could still occur in buildings
where measured carbon dioxide concentrations are below 800 ppm.
,, .
Examples would include situations where a strong source of air
contaminant is present.
Use colorometric detector tubes or a calibrated direct-reading
instrnffient according to manufacturer's instructions for operation
DRAFT: DO NOT CITE OR QUOTE rJ 21
~

DRAFT February 5, 1993
and calibration.
If detector tubes are used to obtain carbon dioxide measurements,
at least two measurements at each location should be performed
and their results av4raged to reduce the uncertainty associated
With this measurement technique.
Measure carbon dioxide late in the morning before people go to
lung (e.g., 11 am.) and late in the afternoon before people leave
for home (e.g., 3:30 g.m.). At these times carbon dioxide levels
should generally be closest to the equilibrium value and best
indicate outdoor air ventilation rates.
Measure 4-5 feet above floor and vithin the occupant's breathing
zone, but away from an individuals exhaled breath which could
directly influence the reading.
Measure during normal building and NVAC system operating
conditions.
.::Measure outdoor carbon dioxide level for comparison to indoor
levels. (Average carbon dioxide level outdoor is 300-500 ppm).
Measure during normal building and NVAC system operating
conditions.
DRAFT: DO NOT CITE OR QUOTE CN 22
N
~
~A
FP~
~

DRAFT February 5, 1993
Appendiz B to 5 1910- --smoking-Control Policies that vili
Result in a Smoke-pree Workplace (Non-Handatory)
----------------------------------- ------------- ----------------
(Questions Related to ventilation provisions that may be included
in Options Memorandum:
1) Renovation and maintenance: During these procedures
increased ventilation will be provided (Question: Is negative
pressure needed, especially in renovation, tio prohibit the
movement of particulates and fumes from the renovation area to '
surrounding office space?; If so, is any CFX appropriate? Can
ventilation systems, in general, provide increased air to
sections of floors that are undergoing routine maintenance, such
as carpet cleaning and painting? If so,'is any CFM appropriate;
or is it dependent upon the maintenance that is being done? It
is necessary, and if so, is it sufficient to reference related
standards in protection renovation workers under our existi:zq
standards, i.e.; construction and asbestos standards.
2) Air Exchange versus Air Delivery: Is there an acceptable;
feasible, procedure for assuring that air, whether recirculated
or fresh, is getting to the Breathing zone of the workers? This
question has to do with buildings that are run on nearly 100%
DRAFT: DO NOT CITE OR QVOTE r= 23
0

DRAFT February 5, 1993
recirculated air. Did ASHRAE assume in 62-1989 that there was
100t outside air coming into a building to determine their cfm
requirements (Table 2 and Section 6.1.3.2)?
3) Balancing of Ventilation System: Is it necessary and
feasible to balance a system every so many years...tor example,
every 3 or 5 years? what.would happen if the building could not
be balanced?
4) Maintenance of HVAC system: How often should the system be
inspected? How'often should filters be checked, and if needed,
replaced? Quarterly, yearly? Is there any Personal Protective'
Equipment required to insure the safety of workers entering air
handlers and other parts of the system to protect them from
bioaerosols and other contaminants? Should the workers who
actually work on the system, or just building managers receive
training in maintaining thesystem? What should this training
consist of? [Are there set procedures that could be followed by
most of the buildings in this country to assure adequate
maintenance of the HVAC system, regardless of system makeup and '
climatic conditions?] Are there any procedures that should not
be allowed, not matter what? For example, I am aware that ozone
air cleaners ate not well thought of, especially by our comrades
at NIOSH, are there some procedures that are bogus, covering up
or making problems worse, instead of curing them?
DRAFT: DO NOT CITE OR QUOTE 24

D?ZAF2+ Februa_-y 5, 1993
5) Temperature/humidity ranges: Control of temperature of
summer/ ainter ranges (76/68). Zs this feasible? Is the range of
humidity attainable in all regions of the country (30-601) ?
DRAFT: IDO NOT CITE OR 4VCTE 25
