Philip Morris
Lung Cancer Among Chinese Women
Fields
- Author
- Blot, W.J.
- Ershow, A.G.
- Fraumeni, J.F.
- Gao, Y.T.
- Hsu, C.W.
- Levin, L.I.
- Zhang, R.
- Zheng, W.
- Ershow, A.G.
- Type
- PSCI, PUBLICATION SCIENTIFIC
- BIBL, BIBLIOGRAPHY
- CHAR, CHART, GRAPH, TABLE, MAPS
- BIBL, BIBLIOGRAPHY
- Area
- SCIENTIFIC AFFAIRS/BLACK LATERAL OLD S&T
- Document File
- 2023512516/2023513116/Ets: Lung Cancer Volume I 930900
- Litigation
- Okag/Privilege Withdrawn
- Okag/Produced
- Characteristic
- EXTR, EXTRA
- MARG, MARGINALIA
- Site
- R529
- Named Organization
- NCI, Natl Cancer Inst
- Author (Organization)
- Intl Journal of Cancer
- NCI, Natl Cancer Inst
- Shanghai Cancer Inst
- Shanghai Chest Hospital
- NCI, Natl Cancer Inst
- Named Person
- Blot, W.J.
- Chen, C.
- Gao, Y.T.
- Henderson, B.
- Parsons, R.
- Stone, B.J.
- Xiaoou, S.
- Chen, C.
- Master ID
- 2023512517/3115
Related Documents:- 2023512517-3115 This Issue Binder Is Intended to Provide A Basic, Comprehensive Review of the Scientific Literature Regarding A Specific Topic on Ets and the Health of Nonsmokers
- 2023512525-2557 Primary Epidemiologic Studies on Spousal Smoking and Lung Cancer
- 2023512559 Non-Smoking Wives of Heavy Smokers Have A Higher Risk of Lung Cancer
- 2023512560-2562 Non-Smoking Wives of Heavy Smokers Have A Higher Risk of Lung Cancer: A Study From Japan
- 2023512563 Cancer Mortality in Nonsmoking Women with Smoking Husbands Based on A Large-Scale Cohort Study in Japan
- 2023512564-2574 Cancer Mortality in Nonsmoking Women with Smoking Husbands Based on A Large-Scale Cohort Study in Japan
- 2023512575 Lung Cancer in Japan: Effects of Nutrition and Passive Smoking
- 2023512576-2597 Lung Cancer in Japan: Effects of Nutrition and Passive Smoking
- 2023512599 Lung Cancer and Passive Smoking
- 2023512600-2603 Lung Cancer and Passive Smoking
- 2023512604 Lung Cancer and Passive Smoking: Conclusions of Greek Study
- 2023512605-2606 Lung Cancer and Passive Smoking: Conclusions of Greek Study
- 2023512608-2613 Time Trends in Lung Cancer Mortality Among Nonsmokers and A Note on Passive Smoking
- 2023512614 Time Trends in Lung Cancer Mortality Among Nonsmokers and A Note on Passive Smoking
- 2023512616 Lung Cancer in Non-Smokers in Hong Kong
- 2023512617-2620 Lung Cancer in Non-Smokers in Hong Kong
- 2023512622 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer
- 2023512623-2625 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer
- 2023512627 the Causes of Lung Cancer in Texas
- 2023512628-2654 the Causes of Lung Cancer in Texas
- 2023512656 the Effect of Environmental Tobacco Smoke in Two Urban Communities in the West of Scotland
- 2023512657-2667 the Effect of Environmental Tobacco Smoke in Two Urban Communities in the West of Scotland
- 2023512668 Passive Smoking and Cardiorespiratory Health in A General Population in the West of Scotland
- 2023512669-2673 Passive Smoking and Cardiorespiratory Health in A General Population in West of Scotland
- 2023512675 Lung Cancer in Nonsmokers
- 2023512676-2683 Lung Cancer in Nonsmokers
- 2023512685 Involuntary Smoking and Lung Cancer: A Case-Control Study
- 2023512686-2692 Involuntary Smoking and Lung Cancer: A Case-Control Study
- 2023512694 A Clinical and Epidemiological Study of Carcinoma of Lung in Hong Kong
- 2023512695-2718 Chapter 7 Case-Control Study of Passive Smoking, Kerosene Stove Usage and Home Incense Burning in Relation to Lung Cancer in Non-Smoker Females
- 2023512719 Passive Smoking Is A Risk Factor for Lung Cancer in Never Smoking Women in Hong Kong
- 2023512720-2722 Passive Smoking Is A Risk Factor for Lung Cancer in Never Smoking Women in Hong Kong
- 2023512724 Smoking and Other Risk Factors for Lung Cancer in Women
- 2023512725-2729 Smoking and Other Risk Factors for Lung Cancer in Women
- 2023512731 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer Among Japanese Women
- 2023512732-2735 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer Among Japanese Women
- 2023512737 Relationship of Passive Smoking to Risk of Lung Cancer and Other Smoking - Associated Diseases
- 2023512738-2746 Relationship of Passive Smoking to Risk of Lung Cancer and Other Smoking - Associated Diseases
- 2023512748 Risk Factors for Adenocarcinoma of the Lung
- 2023512749-2759 Risk Factors for Adenocarcinoma of the Lung
- 2023512761 Lung Cancer Among Chinese Women
- 2023512769 Marriage to A Smoker and Lung Cancer Risk
- 2023512770-2774 Marriage to A Smoker and Lung Cancer Risk
- 2023512776 Measurements of Passive Smoking and Estimates of Lung Cancer Risk Among Non-Smoking Chinese Females
- 2023512777-2784 Measurements of Passive Smoking and Estimates of Lung Cancer Risk Among Non-Smoking Chinese Females
- 2023512785 Is Passive Smoking An Added Risk Factor for Lung Cancer in Chinese Women
- 2023512786-2792 Is Passive Smoking An Added Risk Factor for Lung Cancer in Chinese Women
- 2023512794 Smoking, Passive Smoking and Histological Types in Lung Cancer in Hong Kong Chinese Women
- 2023512795-2800 Smoking, Passive Smoking and Histological Types in Lung Cancer in Hong Kong Chinese Women
- 2023512802 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer in Swedish Women
- 2023512803-2810 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer in Swedish Women
- 2023512812 on the Relationship Between Smoking and Female Lung Cancer
- 2023512813-2818 on the Relationship Between Smoking and Female Lung Cancer
- 2023512820 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer in Women
- 2023512821-2823 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer in Women
- 2023512825 A Case-Control Study of Lung Cancer in Nonsmoking Women
- 2023512826-2834 A Case-Control Study of Lung Cancer in Nonsmoking Women
- 2023512836 Smoking and Passive Smoking in Relation to Lung Cancer in Women
- 2023512837-2843 Smoking and Passive Smoking in Relation to Lung Cancer in Women
- 2023512845 Lung Cancer and Exposure to Tobacco Smoke in the Household
- 2023512846-2850 Lung Cancer and Exposure to Tobacco Smoke in the Household
- 2023512851 Assessment of the Association Between Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer
- 2023512852-2952 Assessment of the Association Between Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer A Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of Yale University in Candidacy for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy
- 2023512854 Epidemiologic Studies of the Relationship Between Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer
- 2023512955-2974 Epidemiologic Studies of the Relationship Between Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer
- 2023512976 Passive Smoking and Diet in the Etiology of Lung Cancer Among Non-Smokers
- 2023512977-2983 Passive Smoking and Diet in the Etiology of Lung Cancer Among Non-Smokers
- 2023512985 Passive Smoking Among Nonsmoking Women and the Relationship Between Indoor Air Pollution and Lung Cancer Incidence - Results of A Multicenter Case Controlled Study
- 2023512986-2997 Passive Smoking Among Nonsmoking Women and the Relationship Between Indoor Air Pollution and Lung Cancer Incidence - Results of A Multicenter Case Controlled Study
- 2023512998 Association of Indoor Air Pollution and Lifestyle with Lung Cancer in Osaka, Japan
- 2023512999-3003 Association of Indoor Air Pollution and Lifestyle with Lung Cancer in Osaka, Japan
- 2023513005-3006 Lung Cancer Among Women in North-East China
- 2023513007-3012 Lung Cancer Among Women in North-East China
- 2023513014 Smoking and Other Risk Factors for Lung Cancer in Xuanwei, China
- 2023513015-3020 Smoking and Other Risk Factors for Lung Cancer in Xuanwei, China
- 2023513022 the Relationship of Passive Smoking to Various Health Outcomes Among Seventh-Day Adventists in California
- 2023513023-3059 the Relationship of Passive Smoking to Various Health Outcomes Among Seventh-Day Adventists in California A Dissertation Submitted in Panal Satisfaction of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Public Health
- 2023513060 Passive Smoking and Cancer Among Female Seventh-Day Adventists in California
- 2023513061 Passive Smoking and Cancer Among Female Seventh-Day Adventists in California / Health Studies of Seventh-Day Adventists A Review
- 2023513063-3064 Lung Cancer in Nonsmoking Women: A Multicenter Case-Control Study
- 2023513065-3073 Lung Cancer in Nonsmoking Women: A Multicenter Case-Control Study
- 2023513074 Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Lung Cancer
- 2023513075-3077 Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Lung Cancer
- 2023513078-3079 Lung Cancer in Nonsmoking Women: A Multicenter Case-Control Study
- 2023513080-3083 Correspondence Re: E. T. H. Fontham Et Al., Lung Cancer in Nonsmoking Women: A Multicenter Case-Study. Cancer Epidemiol., Biomarkers & Prev., 1: 35-43, 910000
- 2023513085-3086 Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Lung Cancer Risk in Nonsmoking Women
- 2023513087-3092 Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Lung Cancer Risk in Nonsmoking Women
- 2023513093 Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Lung Cancer in Never Smoking Women
- 2023513094 Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Lung Cancer in Never Smoking Women
- 2023513095-3096 Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Lung Cancer Risk in Non-Smoking Women
- 2023513097-3100 Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Lung Cancer Risk in Non-Smoking Women
- 2023513102-3103 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer in Nonsmoking Women
- 2023513104-3110 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer in Nonsmoking Women
- 2023513111 Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Female Lung Cancer in Guangzhou, China
- 2023513112-3115 Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Female Lung Cancer in Guangzhou, China
- Date Loaded
- 24 May 1999
- UCSF Legacy ID
- qlc02a00
Document Images
i
»y,
Inr, J' Cunc-era0, 6pa-609'11987)
198? Alan R. Liss. lnc.
. N c ' : E
R1s ~;,tori3l tr'3`J bE
protected by w)Bm
Iaw IfiUt 17 , U.S. Cod.1.
P.D!rc.trorps rnt ~^tenst~or~~ unro~aq:~.~s+~~^ce
PuD!.catror- atr.Unrdn imitrn~t0n~r[ ..JnOrr~t.l.anc,tr.
LUNG CANCER AMONG CHINESE WOMEN
Yu-Tanp GAO'. William 1.,BLOr'. Wei ZHENG!. Abby G. ERSHOw", Cheng Wen HSU3 . Lynn l,. LEvfs'. Rong
ZHr+nGl and
Joseph F. FRrcLaENL. 1R.'
1 Shanghai Cancer Insriiure. Shanghai, People's Republic of Chirw: 'Narional Cancer lnsrirure,
Berliesda MD 20892, US.1: and
3Shanghar Chest Hospital. Shangliai, People's Republic of Chirta.
A case-control study involving int.rviews witlr f72 fomalW
lung cancer patients and 73S population-based contTOti was
conducted to invcsti=ate the high rates of litng canc*r, notably
adenocarcinoma, among women in Shanghai. CiSarette srnott-
in= was a strong risk factor, but accounted for only about on.-
fourth of all newly diagnosed nses of lung canca.. Most pa-
tients, particularly with adlnocarcinonu. were life-tong nor+-
smokers.. The risks of lung cancer were hijher among women
reporting tubcrcukasis and other pre-a:istinj lung diseass.
liormonal factors were suuested by an increasad risk associ-
ated with late menopause and by a gradient in the risk of
adenourcinoma with decreasin= menstrual cycle l.n=th, with
a 3-fold excess among women who had shorter qrc/es_Perhaps
most intriguing werc associations found between lung cancer
and measures of exposure to cooking oil vapors. Risks in-
creased with the numbers of meals cooked by efther stir
frying, deep frying or bo:Gnj; wiM tlie frequency of smokiness
during cooking; and with the frequency of,eye irritation dur-
in= cookinj. Use of rapeseed oil, whose volatikts following
hi=h-temperature cooking may be mutagenic. was also r.-
ported more often by the cancer patients. The findings thus
confirm that factors other than smoking are responsible for
the hiYh, risk of, lung cancer amon= t.hinese woman, and pro-
vide clues for further researcti, inciud"g tdie assessment of
cooking practices-
The age-adjusted annual lung cancer incidence rate amongg
females in Shanghai during the 1970's and 1980's has been
about 20 per 100.000 population. one of the highest rates in
China and in the world (National Cancer Control:Office, 1980;
Gao. 1982; Waterhouse er al., 1982: Shanghai Cancer Regis-
try: 1983). Eievated' lung cancer death rates have also been
observed among Chinese wotnrn in other parts of the world.
including Hong Kong (Kung et al., 1984; Koo er al., 1985).
Singapore (MacLennan er af.. 1977) and the United States
(Fraumeni~ and Mason. 1974. Hinds er al:, 1981; Green and
Broph., 1982). The high rates of this cancer are surprising
since few Chinese women smoke cigarettes (Deng and Gao,
1985). Funhermore, in Shanghai (Zheng and Gao. 1986) and
elsewhere. hospital records have indicated that most of the
lung tumors are adenocarcinomas. a type of lung cancer less
stronglv related to smoking (Lubin and Rlot 1984): To explore
rt:asons for the high rates of lung carr:er among women in
Shanghai. the Shanghai Cancer lnstitute, in collaboration with
the US National Cancer lnstitute, carried out a population-
based case-control investigation. Herein we report the results
of this study. quantifying the role of smoking and evaluating a
variety of suspected risk factors.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
All newly diagnosed cases of primary lung cancer (9th
Revision 1CD 162) during the 2-year period February 1984-
Fcbruary 1996 among female residents of urban.Shanghai aged
35-69 years were identified by a rapid reporting system for
lung cancer established for this study. The system was built
upon the existing Shanghai Cancer Registry, the oldest in.
China: (Gao, 1982). Trained staff contacted medical' facilitiess
in Shanghai' to ascertain new eases: so that interviews could
be rapidly scheduled (typically within; 2 weeks of diagnosis).
The staff reviewed~ relevant medical records, abstracting data
on the basis of diagnosis. histologic type, and the site of the
tumor within the lung. Two senior pathologists and 4 senmonr
clinicians were appointed to review the diagnostic information
from alll cases collected in the study. including X-ray films,
cytologic and histologic slides.
Female controls were randomly selected within 5-year age
strata from~the general population of the Shanghai urban area.
The number and age distribution of the controls were deter-
mined in advance from the number and age distribution, of
lung cancer cases reported to the Shanghai' Cancer Registry
during the period 1980-81. The selection procedure involved
randomly choosing a neighborhood' committee from among
the approximately 1,300 committees in urban Shanghai, then
randomly choosing a household group within the committee
and ascertaining fromtxisting rosters the names of all'.females
in the appropriate age range. Among these persons. 2 were
randomly selected. If the first was absent during the period of
study or could not be interviewed. the second was accepted as
a control. Tables of random numbers were used' in the random
sampling.
The cases and: controls were interviewed; by trained inter-
viewers. A structured questionnaire was used to obtain infor-
matiomon demographic characteristics. exposure to tobacco:
dietary and'cooking practices. medical conditions. familw his-
tory of lung cancer. menstrual and reproductive factors. job
history andlother variables A1l'completedquestionnaires and
medical abstracts were checked by a field~ supervisor% and the
information was then abstracted on coding sheets for kc.-
punching and computerization in the United States.
Statistical' analvses of the collected data were based on mul-
tivariate techniques for case-control data (Breslow and' Day.
1980). Logistic regression analyses were use& to ~ estimate
summary relative risks (RR) of lung cancer associated with
various factors, after adjusting for age (<55, 55-59, 60-64.
65-69). smoking (non-smoker; smoked less than 20 years or
less than 10 cigarenes/day; smoked 20 or more years and 10-
19 cigaretteslday; smoked 20 or more years and 20 or more
cigarettes/day). education (no forrrta) educacion. primary
school, secondary school and higher) and other variables. artd
to evaluate statistical significance. Population attributable risk
(PAR) estimates for stnoking, adjusted for age, were also
derived (Whittemore. 1983).
RESULTS
A total of 765 lung cancer patients were identified' dunng
the 2-year period' and interviews conducted with 672 ('88 % ).
We excluded the 93 patients who died, including 3$ ascer-
tained by death certificate only.. There were no patients who ~i
refused interview. Forty, three percent of the cases were diag- Q
nosed by tissue biopsy. 38 % by cytoiogy, and 19 % by repeated N
.
CJ
Addn:ss repnnt requests from China to Dr.. Gro and from other coun- u
trxs to Dr. Bloc .
Recetved March 30. 1987 and in rrvised:form May 29. 1987.

LUNG CANCER 1% CHINESE WOMEN 605,
TABLE 1- RELATIPE RJSKS'OF LU%G CANCER ASSOCtATEDW'iTH NUMBER OF CIGARETTESSMOKED PER DAIAND
DLRATIO% Or SMUKI~GDuni,m ol'm~np
- -- -
Vumber of~.arucnef.
snqYee ptr~.d+~
eX9.YesrS~.
> }G ltu.
Cur, Corwrob RR' 9SR,CI Casr Convol RR v'~ CI
< 10 36 45 1.4 0.9-2.2 34' 29 2 4' F4-4 1
10-i9 19 11 2.6 1.2-5.7 56 33 3.2 2 0-5 1
20- 13 2 8.9 2.0-40.2 78 10 14.1 7 1-.B 0;
'Adlusred fm are r.dedwcauon !:or.smoken art used;u th rekrercr Itroup.
7A6LE 11.-RF1.ATtvE RlSKS OF LUNG.CANCER,AMOHG WON-SMOKING
WOMEN ASSOCIATED WiTH:.YEARS LJVEt).wt7W A.SMORINGHUSBAND
Yea 1.ed,,.,,
,,,,i,fti,~p,,,a
C,.n
C=.,*:
ta
+s. CI
<20 57 qg 1 0 _
20.29 63 93 1.1' 0.7-t.8
30-39' 78 107, 1.3 0.8-2.1
~t 40 48 76 1.7 1.0-2.9
'AAlustedfor aRe ud eduacwn ~
X-ray films. Among the 542 interviewed cases pathologically'
or cytologicalh- diagnosed. adenocarcinoma was the predomi-
nant celll npe acccwnting for 611% of all cases. 22% were
squamous carcinomas, 6% wese oat-cell (or small-cell undif-
ferentiated ) cancers. and I1. % were mixtures and other cell i
types.
A total of 735 controls were interviewed. Among these 71
(9.79<) were "second" controls. chosen mainly because the
firsnselected control had moved from the Shanghai urban area
or was found1o be outside the eligible age range. The distri-
butions by age. education and rnarital status were generally
similar between cases and controls_ More controls than cases
(32 % vs. 20 % ). however, were in the oldest age group of 65-
69 years. but all subsequent analyses were age-adjusted.
Cigarette srrtoking,
Cigarette smoking was associated with a significarttly in-
~ariskoLlung~cec:0vea,dtpttgils.oNy3S,% .of't3te lung
c~ncer paiien), , (camp.Md;ats~18%w of the controls) had ever
srnoked. Therc was a 3.3-fold excess risk (95% Cl - 2:5-
4.2) of lung cancer among smokers, but risks were higher for
squamous-cell carcinoma (RR = 7.2, 95% CI = 4.6-11.1)
and oat-cell cancer (RR = 7.2. 95 % CI = 3.6-17:0) than for
adenocarcinoma (RR = 1.5, 95% CI = 1.0-2.1). The RR for
all lung cancers combined tended to rise with increasing num-
bers of cigarettes smoked per day and with increasing duration
of smoking (Table 1). The excess reached 14-fold for females
who smoked 20 or more cigarettes per day for more than 30
Years. Similar trends existed for adenocarcinoma and for squa-
mous/oat-cell cancers, but the magnitude of ttte increase was
coruidenbly greater for the latter (not shown)..
We calculated population-attribuubk risk (PAR) estimates
for amoking in each agcgroup : The PAR rose with age, from
8% to 27% to 28% to 40% at ages <55, 55-59, 60-64, and
65.-69. respeccively, primarily because the prevalence of
smoking rose with age. In total, we estimated that 24% of all
female lung cancers in Shanghai were due to smoking.
Passive smoking
No significant increase in risk was observed for overall
exposure to environmental tobacco smoke during childhood
(RR = 1.1, 95% CI = 0.7-1.7)~or adult life (RR = 0.9, 95%
Cl = 0.6-1.4). For these calculations, exposure was sai& to
Occur if the subject had' ever lived with a smoker. When
exposure was defined in terms of husband's smoking, . how-
ever, lung cancer risks among non-smoking women tended to
increase with the number of years a woman lived with a
husband:who stnokedr the RR r aching 1.7 among those with
40 or more compared to kss than 20 years' exposure (Table
D). The risk in this heavily exposed group was even higher
(RR= 2.9. 95 % Cl = 1.0-8.9) for squamous- and oat-ce11
carcinoma
Previous lung diseases
Since lung cancer in its early stages may be confused with
other lung diseases, we excluded non-mallgnanr lung diseases
occurring within the 3 years preceding interview'in evaluating
the effect of prior lung disease upon lung cancer risk. Table
III shows that previous tuberculosi's. pneumonia and emphy-
sema were significantly associated with lung cancer risk even
after adjusting for smoking. Although some individuals re-
ported having 2 or more of these diseases. the excesses for
each persisted when those with multiple conditions were ex-
cluded. Further analysis (not shown) indicated thar the effect
of tuberculosis was not related to the use of isoniazi& or
streptomycin. While tuberculosis artd pneumonia were related
to both squamous/oat.-cell carcinoma and adenocarcinoma ofi
the lung. emphysema and chronic bronchitis were associated
only with the squamous- and oat-cell types.
CodJng practices
Soybean and rapeseed oils were the oils used~ most often for
cooking in Shanghai. with over 95% of women reporting the
use of both products. Rapeseed oil. however, was reported as
the most often used cooking oil by 52% of the cases compared'
to 45 % of the controls. The overall increase in risk associated
with ~ rapeseed compared to soybean as the most often used' oil
was 1.4 (95% Cl = Table IV shows that the excess
lung cancer risk associated~ with use of rapeseed oil existed at
each level of reported frequency of eye irritation when cook-
ing, a subjective variable representing severity'of exposure to
cooking vapors. The calculations for this Table excluded the
few women who never cooked, and employed as the reference
group women who most often used soybean oil but never or
rarely reported eye iiritation. Table IV also shows that risks
of lung cancer were independently related' to eye irritation
with the highest risks (RR = 2.8, 95% Cl - 1.".3) among
those using rapeseed oil and frequently reporting irritation.
The patterns were similar for squamous/oat-cell, cancer and'
adenocarcinoma. We also observed, after adjusting for eye
iiTitation, a 60% higher risk for lung cancer among women
who reported considerable or somewhat smoky conditions inn
their homes when cooking. another rough measure of exposure
to cooking vapors and to house ventilation (Table V ), !n
addition, the risk ratios increased with the number of different
dishes per week prepared by stir frying. deep frying. or boiling
(Table VI). In contrast. no significant case/control differences
were associated with the type of fuel used for cooking. The
RR and 95% Cl associated with coal., gas and wood' as the
usual fuels were 0~9 (0.7-1.3). 1.1 (0.7-1.5). and 1.0 (0:6-
1.8) respectively. There was tw trerd in, risk with increasing
years of use of coal. the most common cooking fuel in Shang-
iA

606
GAO ET AL
TABLE 11I - RELATIVE R.tSKSOF LL'wG CANCER:ASSOCIATED1MiT.H PREVIOUS:LCNG DISEASES'
Pau 16nr
dncaxs.
Comrolf. All
ca~ses
RR'
95111 CI' Squamwi
uace~~
RR"
9S* CI Adrno-
urcanortu
RR'
u54
None 554 418 1.0 80 1.0 - 229 1.0 -
Tuberculosis 61 80 1.7 1.1-2.4' 20 2.0 1.1-3.7 42 1.6 1.0 2 5
Pneumonla
Emphysema 35
18 65
37, 1.9
2.0 1.2-3:0
1.0-3.7 16
19 1 8
4.5 0.9-3'.8
2.0-10.3 26
6 1.5
07 09i27
0.3-'-.0
Chronic bronchitis 86 112 1.2 0.8'-1.7 35 1.4 0.8-2.5 33 0.8 05-1.3
M ithout emph~ sema
Others
30
30
1.3
0.7-2.2
8'
1.7
0.7-4.2
13
1.0
0.5-2 0
I All r,sEk diuued for ape. educatan ad srtqYtn{ ard''rdanve to .ornenWtth.non reported
pnorlunR'dueaae. Persorss wph moce.dun one past lung diaease areincluded
tn eacti lungdisease cateForr..
TA1t-EtV - RELATIVE RLSKS.OF LUNG CANCER,ASSOCIATED ~w1TN
COOX1wG OIL USED MMOST OFTEN AND FREQUENCY OF EYE IRRlTATION
WHEN COOKING.
TABLE V - RELATIVE RISKSOF LUNG CANCER ASSOCIATED wITH
FREQUENCY OF EYE [RR)TATIONAND HOUSE SMOKIyFSS'wHEV COOKI%G
Eye nrwoon
Wien cooLmg
OQI ueC
moa un-
Caaa
Coccaia
RR'
V71t CI Eye
ir.wuon Houae
amotln<ss
Ca.es
Ce.urdtRR'
95% CI.
Never or rarely Soybean 140 214 1.0 - Neverrrarely None/slight 244 380 1',0 -
Rapeseed 145 193 1.2 0.9-1.7 SomewhaU
considerable 55 55 11.6 L 0-2.5
Sometimcs Soybean 70 72 1.5 1.0-2'.3
Rapeseed 87 63 2.0 1.3-3.0 Sometimes/'
frequently None/slight 212 200 11.6 1.2-2.1
Frequently Soybean 59 56 1.4 0.9-2.3 SortxwhaV' 109 60 2.6 7
1
8-3
Rapeseed 90 30 2.8 1.".3 considerable .
.
Total Soybean 269 342 1.0 -
'
Rapeseed
322
306
1.4
1.1-1.8 Ad)usted for afe. educnan and smo/nng .
'A4)uxod for age. aduratwn an:14molUna.
TABLE.%I- RELATIVE RISKS.OF LUNG CA14CER IkSSOCIATED WITH NCMBER.
OF DIFFERENT DISHES PER wEEK. PREPARED BY DIFFERENT NfT~HODS OF
COOKING ~
`YmMtr .N d14heS'
Per wee6.
Caata Cnncrol,' RR' 9S4 Cl
Srir fn-)ng
1~ 20
336
408
1.0
-
20-24 198' 211 1.2' 0.9-1.5
25-29' 48 47' 1.2' 0.8-1.9
;~ 30 34 15 2.6 1.3-5.0
Deep fning
0
502
594
1.0
-
1 85 68 1.5 1.0-2,1,
2 21 15 1.6 0.8-3.2
;- 3 8 4 1.9 0.5-6.8
Boiling
43
96
124
1'.0
-
4-7 390 483 1.0 0.7-1.3
8-11 63 40 1.8 1.1-3'.0
.;Ir 12 67 33 2.2 1.3-3.7
' Ad)y.ud ror aEe. educauon awd ~nokmR2
hai. Exposures to coal' or other fuel fumes were generally
associated only with cooking, since nearly all homes in Shang-
hai were unheated.
Diet
The women were asked about their usual' frequency of con-
sumption ~ during adulthood of 32 commonly eaten foods, in-
cluding the major contributors of vitamin A. Using Chinese
food composition tables to estimate the retinol and carotene
content of each food and applying these estimates to its fre-
quency of intake, an index of'vitamin A consumption in m-
inol~equivalent units was cotLstructed: The risks for lung cancer
tended to be lower among those with low va]ues of this index
TABLE VII - RELATIVE RISKS OF LUNG CANKER.ASSOCIATED w.7TH
DIETARY INTAKE OF vITAMINA
Vitammn, Quaruk k.el ofrnnsumpiion~
elPoSUR
varuBlc
I I H,Fh) 11 [I] 1%
Viumin A 1.0 0.6 0.8 0:5
.
index (0:5-0.9) (0.6-1.1,) (0.4-0.7)
Retinol-rich 1.0 0.9 1.0 0.9
foods (0.7=1.3) (0.7-1.3) (0.7-1 ?)
Caraene-rich 1.0 0.6 0:5 0:5
foods (0.5-0.8) (0.4-0.71 (0.3-0.61:
'Rulknelawve to h,gheslquartile.ofcoesurnp[son and d)usted for age. education
atd smoiung. 95% CI in parentheses.
(Table VII). This association was accounted' for mainly' by a
lower risk among those with a reduced consumption of caro-
tene-richfoods (the dominant source being dark green vegeta-
bles). No effect on risk was found for consumption of the
retinol-rich foods (mainly fisfi, eggs and Gver)i The patterns
were generally similar for squamousJoat-cell cancer and ade-
nocarcirloma, and for smokers and rton-smokers.
Menstrual and reproductive fanors
The risks of lung cancer were higher among women with ~
shorter menstrual cycle lengths (Table VIII).,T'he association,
was primarily seen for adenocarcinoma. which showed a strong
dose-response relationship. Among women.aged 55 years and'
over with a natural menopause, the risk of adenocarcinoma
tended to increase with the total number of inenstrual' cycles
over their lifetime. Some increased risk of aderlocareinoma
was seen when natural menopause occurred at age 50 or later
(RR = 1.3, 95% CI = 0:9-1.7, after adjusting for menstrual
cycle length). No associations were seemwith age at menarche.
age at first pregnancy, or parity.

lkntilm oi
mewrwl All
cwleasen
Ll!.NGCANCER IN~.CHINESE WOMEN~
TADLE 1.711 - RELATT'E R1SKS OF LUNG CAVCER ASSOCIATED W'rrH LE VGTH OF MEvSTRL.AL. CICLE.
Cnrroks. RR' 9'SS Cl:
spumw5
oa-ceil arrinoms
>33 43 60 1.0 - 12
30-33 272 3271.6 1.0-2.6 62
26-29 241 268 1.6 1.0-2.7 51
<26 98 78 2.2 1.3-3.7 23 1.0
0.9
0.8
1.6 - 18
0.4-2 0 124
0.4-1.9 127
0.7-3 9 54 I.0
1,9
21!
2'9 -
II.0-3.5
1 1-3_9
1.5-5 7
'Adjuued.fow aPe. e0ucauou. smotinF and reRutanny of inenuruanon.
TAiLE IX - RF1aT1VE RISKS OF LUNGLAwCER FOR wOMEN,EVER.EMPLOYED IN MAIOR OCCUPATIONAL GROUPS.
OccvRaan~.caterorn' Cases Controls~ RR~=~ 951 S CI
1-11 Professionals and technicians: leaders of 113 116 1.0' 0.7-1 4
UI-1V state organizatans, party and rnass, orga-
nizations and enterprise units
Office and related personnell sales workers
75
96
0!7'
0.5-1.0
V Service workers 1'39 160 1.0 0.8-1 4
Vl1 Agricultural. forestry, animal husbandry 24 21 1.1 0 6-2.1
VU-1X and fisher) workers
Production.,.transportation and other
436
4711
1.1
0.9-1.4'.
0 related workers
Never worked
61
75
1.11
0:7=1.6
'wbnoen empld+.ed In,monr than one occupalonal~.ntegonaRIncluded rntach aeeron in wAKh the% worked~
TAecoding uAeme wa, basedon.the s.uem usedin the
l98:. Populairon Censw of the Peoplt's Rep+blic of China (Pop+linonCensus Office. 1985) ,-=Adjiuued
for.aEer education and smoking
Occuparrort
.
Most women reported working outside the home. but case/
control differences according to major occupational categories
were small (Table IX). No major occupations were associated
with increased risk ofl lung cancer. A decreased risk, however.
was observed for women ever employed in the cotton textile
industry. the largest employer of women in Shanghai. There
was a slight increase in the relative risk of lung cancer among
women ever employed as cooks (RR = 1.2. 95% CI = 0.6-
2. J). but few worked longer than,20 years.
Family, history
The cancer patients reported about the same frequency of
lung cancer in their mothers (1.09E ) land fathers (1.7 %) as the
controls (1.0% and 1.5%. respectively). The RR. adjusted for
age. education and smoking, associated with having a parent
with lung cancer was 1.1 (95 % Cl = 0:6-2.3). Mort: sibs
were reported to have lung cancer, bur the numbers affected
were small'(6 c:ses, 3 controls; RR = 3:0 9596 CI - 0.7-
12:5): Only one child, of a control, had' lung cancer.,
DISCUSSION
The high incidertce of lung cancer among wornen in Shang-
hai. together with the low prevalence of smoking in the general
Population, led us to consider a number of possible etiologic
factors. qlNk rigarlotte smoking was an important cause of
ancer. showing a clear dose-response trend, the majonty
Mg tumors, particularly adeno':arcinomas, occurred among
non-smokers.
Environmental tobacco smoke may account for some. but
Probably few, of the cancers among non-smokers. since there
was little or no association with' ever having lived with a
smoker. Among non-smoking women married to smokers,
however. there was an upward trend in risk associated with
mcreasing years of exposure. This latter finding is consistent
with reports in other parts of the world. When data from
nearly a dozen studies evaluating passive smoking were com-
bined (Blot and Fraumeni. 1986)., an overall 30`< excess of
lung cancer (RR= 1.3. 95% C1 = l. l-1.5)was found among
non-smoking women rnarried to smokers. with the RR reach-
ing 1.7 among those most heavily, exposed'.
Although the causal significance ofi the relation of prior, lung
disease ro lung cancer remains to be clarified. the high preva-
lence of previous pulmonary infections may have contributed
in part to the high, incidence of lung cancer among Shanghai
women. Earlier in this century. non-malignant lirng disease
was one of the leading causes of death in China (Kan. 1981).
With the advent of antibiotics and improved living conditions,
the incidence and mortality of chronic litng diseases. patticu-
larl) tuberculosis, declined. Nt:vertheless. a substantial por-
tion (38%) of'the women with lung cancer in this study reported
prior lung disease. including 12 % who were long-term survi-
vors of tuberculosis. whereas signiffcantl'y lower percentages
of controls reported these disaases.. To some extent it is possi-
ble that recall or ascertainment bias may contribute to the
associations observed~ with prior lung diseases. The elevated
risk of lung cancer following tuberculosis. however. is consis-
tent with recent studies in other countnesd and is not explained
by cigarette smoking or treatment with isoniazid. a pulmonary
prcinogen in laboratory animals (Howe er al.. 1979: Hinds rr
al., 1982: Bakns e>' al., 1983);
Emphysema was also significantly related to lung cancer.
after adjustment for smoking habits- with the excess limited to
squamous- and oat-cell carcinomas. This finding adds to the
evidence that chronic obstructive pulmonary disease enhances
the risk of lung cancer (Skillrud' er al.. 1986). even when
controlling for smoking practices. Also rtotewortha is the ele-
vated risk associated with, prior pneumonia. especially since
an association with lung adenocarcinoma has previously been
reported' among women in Los Angeles (Wu er, al:. 1985).
While pneumonia typically occurred during adulthood in our
study, the finding in Los Angeles pnmaril~ concerned child-
hood infection.
Little evidence was found to implicate the type of fuels used
for cooking'in lung cancer risk. consistent with findingsfrom
607
RR' 951 CI 'b"- ~ RR' a4 Cl
*0

608
GAO ET AL.
Hong Kong (Koo ei aL 1983). The risks of lung cancer among
Shanghai, women irtcrcased, however, with vartous measures
of exposure to cooking oil vapors.,These included the number
of different dishes prepared per week by either stir frying,
deep frying, or boiling, the frequency of eye irritation when
cooking: and the smokiness of the house when cooking. In
Chinese wok cooking. regardless of the method tued, oil is
usually poured into a wok and heated to high temperatures
before meat or vegetables are added. Even boiling may entail'
some exposure to cooking oil vapors. since oil is often added'
to the water before heating Consequently. the living quarters
may become smoky during cooking,, with opportuniry for
exposure to intialable cooking oil vapors..
The plausibility off the hypothesis that lung cancer may be
related to cooking oil vapors. particularly' from rapeseed oils
used in Shanghat. i5,enhanced by , trrent.experimental investi-
gations. In one study the mutagenlctt} ofipnoduets from cook-
ing oil was assayed by the Ames test (Qu ct aL. 1986). The
extracts of condensed~ volatiles of rapeseed oil, refined rape-
seed oil, and soybean oil heated at about 270°C were all
positive in tester strain TA98 activated with S9. The mutage-
nicity of the extract from rapeseed oil' volatiles was stronger
than that from soybean oil volatiles. There was no evidence of
mutagenicity in the oils themselves, either, heated or unheated.
In another study. the extracts of condensed'volatiles of rape-
seed oil enhanced the yield of micronuclei' in polychromatic
erythrocytes of'the bone marrow of'mice, with a clear dose-
response relationship: reflecting damage of chromosomes and
cell genocoxicity by rapesetd oil volatiles (Chen. 1987)( Al-
though these tests often conelate with carcinogenic potential,
no bioassay studies have yet been carried out, to our knowl-
edge. if the effect of rapeseed oil smoke on lung cancer
incidence is real. the problem is of great importance to popu-
lations of eastern central China and other areas of the world
where the oil is often used for cooking. Chinese rapeseed oil
which is pressed from seeds of Brassica campcsrris, contains
about 50% erucic acid (Chinese Academy of Medical Sci-
ences. 1981). in contrast to rapeseed oil with <296 erucic acid
(Canbra oil): which was Tecently approved for sale in the
United States (Federal Register. 1985).
Several studies have shown that the risk of lung cancer is
elevated by a low intake of foods cotttaining vitamimA, partic-
ularly as its precursor be'ta-carotene (Colditz et al., 1987).
Although reported mainly in Western countries, this associa-
tion has also been noted among Chinese women in Singapore
(MacLennan cr al., 1977). However, we found no evidence of
a protective effect among women in Shanghai. where iittake
of fresh, carotene-rich, dark green vegetables is high by world
standards. In fact. a positive association was observed between
carotene intake and lung cancer risk in females (in contrast to
no association in males). We have no ready explanation for
this unusual finding in females. which was observed~ also in a
case-control study of lung cancer in Hawaii (Hindscr a1:.
1984). However. the prntective effect of carotene-rich foods
was mainly confined to current, smokers in one large-scale
study (Ziegler cr al., 1986), and~ tHus the effect may be less
evident in Shanghai ~ where few women smoke.
A clue to hormonal factors was suggested by an association
between menstrual cycle length and lung adenocarcinoma. A
3-fold difference in adenocarcinoma risk was found among.
Shanghai women reporting short (<26 days)~compared to long
(>33 days) menstrual cycles, with only' a weak trend for
squamous- and oat-cell cancers. A relation of short menstrual
cycles to breast cancer risk has been suggested in data from,
Sweden (Olsson et al., 1983) and, to a Itrsser extent, the United
States (Sherman er af., 1982)'. Some increases in lung ad'eno-
carcitwma risk were also associated with late menopause an&
with a high.estimated total number of menstrual cycli:s among
women aged 55 and over having a natural menopause. A role
of hormonal factors is also suggested by the observation, that
among tton-smokers adertocarcinoma affecu proportionately
tnore females than males (Lubin and Blot, 1984); and by the
findings of'estrogen and progesterone receptors in some lung
adenocarcinomas of women (Chaudhuri cr a1:, 1982). We
discovered no relation to oral contraceptives or replacement
estrogen therapy, but use of these compounds among women,
in the study group was rare in Shanghai. I't seems unlikely that
the menstrual patterns of Chinese women contribute greatly to
their high lung cancer risk, but the internal consistency of the
trends suggests that future studies of lung cancer in China and
elsewhere should examine endocrine hypotheses in more detail.
This large population-based case-control study of lung can-
cer in urban Shanghai has confirmed that cigarette smoking is
a strong risk factor among Chinese women., but only accounts
for about one-fourth of all newly diagnosed cases. Causes of
the remainder are unclear, but occupational factors did not
appear to be important. nor did familial tendency to lung
cancer. Our data suggest, however, that prior lung diseases
hormonal factors, and cooking practices may be involved.
Most provocative are the associations with cooking oil vola-
tiles, and further investigations are needed to evaluate their
contribution to the high lung cancer rates among Chinese
worrxn in various parts of the world.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This work was supported in part by the NCI. We thank Dr.
BJ: Stooe. Dr.,Shu Xiao-ou and Ms. R. Parsons for comput-
ing support, Ms. C. Chen for computational and translation
assistance, and Dr. B. Henderson for advice and helpful
suggestions.
REFERENCES
BAKms. G.. Mut.onnns, G.P., KoRctmc: R.. Ezov+u. E., Ro: 1..,and
Yoov, B.. Pultnowy, war carcinotna. Cancer.,52, 493J97 (l983):
BLOT. W.1.. and FRAUMEM. J:F.. JR_. Passive smoking and lung caocer.
J. nar. Cancer Inst.. 77, 993-1Q00 (1986).
BRESt.ow. N'.E.. and DAY. N:E.. S+atistinaJ tnencodrin eaneer nrsearch:
The anal±sis of case-co.urol sudies. lARC Scientt'fic Psebdcanon32, pp.
192-246. LARC. Lyon t 1980/.
CxsuDHuRi. P.K.. TMoMAs. P.A.. WAtxEn. M.J!. BuES.l:. H.A.. Guru,
T.D:, and BEArnE.,C:W..,Steroid raeptors in human lung wtcer cyto-
tols Cancer Jttt,. 16, 327-332 (19g2).
CHEN, T.D . Micronucleus test of condcnsed volatiles of rapeseed oil.
Tuw.or, 1987 (in prtss)-
CHINESE ACADEMY OF MEINCAL SCIENCES . Food contposltion tabits..POO
ple's Health Publishing Co.. Beijing 11981)
CotDtrz. G.A., SrAMPFEtt. IK.J., and Wttt.er. W.C., Diet and lung
cancer: a review of theeptdemiototic evidence in humans. Arch. inrern.
Meat.. W7, 157-160Q1987).
DENO. l., and GAO. Y.T, Ptevalence of smoking .nart~ 110.000 adult
nesidenu in Shanghai urb.n arn. Clunese !J prrv. Mad.. 19, 271-274
(1983):
FEt>exwu Rr:etsrEx. Vol. ?0 No. 19. US Government Prumng' Office.
Washington. DC (1985).
FtuuMEN1. 1:F., and MASON. T.1., Cancer mortality among: Chinese
Asnerncans. I950-19G9: 1.' nas: Cancerfnit:. 52, 639-665 (1974).
GAO. Y.T.. Cancer incidence in Shanghu during 1973-77. h'ar. Cancer
Gut. Mowgr.. 62, 4 3-16 (1992).
GREEN. J'.P.. and BROmY, P.. Cartlnorru of the lung in non-smoking
Chinese women. Wesr. !. Med.. 136, 291-294 (1982).
2o23s127ss

LUNG CANCER'1N CHINESE M'OM'E/:
HL,,, k1 W. CoHE H.1 Amer. Rtti nsp. Du.. 6-18
77
car~-rr nsl In non-smolung wornen. .
'19R_I
Hi,n. 4t N' . Kouo~EU. L.N.. HAtrutn. J.H., and LEE. l.. Dietary
.,tamin n, earotene, vnutun C and nsk of lung cancer in Hawau. Amer.
1 ~rrn,nl . 119,'-27-237 (198d):
b( W. STfNwE.wA.. G.N.. YAnG. H.Y.,,KoWt+E1., L.N:. and
LII. J. D,fferences In, iung cancer nsk from stnoking artang Jispenese.
CAme,c and Hawuun women in Hawaii, hu. J. Canetr, 27+ 297-3M
11pMll
Hr'wt, G. UwDs+s. 1.. COrsoCK., E.. and MIt1;ESt. A.B.. lsoniazid
etpwrr tn relrtvon to cancer; incidence u+d: monality in a cotion of
rfrrcvMsu p.tretns Int 1 f-0idnnioJ.. 11, 345-312 (1979).
A.. G. Tuberculosts and iu control in Beijing. C71in. Ilr,e,d: l. ,}t, 685-
y7ft I 141110
li,. -. L C. Ho. l H and LEE. N.. An msaly' sis of sonr risk fectors for
Wq cancer in Hong Kong Jar l. Caaetr. 33, 149-155 (1985):
Kr. - L C . LEt:. t<.. and'Ho. 1.. Do cooking fuels pae a risk for hmg
car.rrt A case-control sntdN of; women in Hong Kong. EcoL Dis:. 2,
:~~-:e~/1a831
K; w,. I' Srl K.. and LAM. T.. Lung cancer in Hong Kong Chihese:
a.rtalln and htstoloElc types 1973-1982. Brn. J. Cancer, 50, 381-388'
1,Vlu~
Ltu.. P. and BLOT. >,4':1!. Assessrrcnt of lung cancer risk fanon by
vwrk1w caegor. J. nor Cuncrrhisr.. 73, 383-398 (1984).
M.c Lr .... R . D. CosrA. l.. DAY: N:E.. LAw. C.H.. Nc, Y.K., and
SM.'MI 1.,a.TM; K . Risk factorS for lung cancer in Singapore Chinesz.
a p+qulanon ath htgfiifemalb incidence rates. Mt: J. Cuncer, 20, 854-
IIEI/ ~, I9'71
,\TM I\.I C+KEN. Co%Ta04 OFtiCE... Ar/as oJ' Cancer Mortality in the
Pr ph , Rrpwhdrr oJ'Chlnn. China Map Press. Beijing (1980):
Pm ...TU/ CEUL 5 OFFICE 10'Percent Sampling Tabulation on the 1982'
609
Population Census of the People's Republic of Chtna. China Stausncal
PublisAing House. BelJtng (19851.
OESSOr;.,H~. LANDn:-0ESSOrc. M.. and Gt'L.ueeac. B. Retrospective as-
aessment of rnertstrual cvele length in patnents with breast uneer. in
patients wtth benign tireast disesse, and tn womenwtthout bteast disease
J: nau, Cancer Insa, 70, 17-21 (1983).
QE:. Y.H;. Xu. G.?L.. Ht:Aroe. F.. FANG. 1.C.. and GAO. Y.T.. An Ames
test on the by-producu oflthe beattng of:cooking oils. T~r.,6, 5g-60
(1986).
SHAroaHArCArom RF.cJmrr. .twsual Reports on Caectr Incidence on&
Mortnlin. Uata in Shcngha' Urban Ano: Slianghu Cancet lasutute.
Shangliai d 19831 i
SHERMAN. B.M.. WAUwcE. R.B'.. and BEA4, J.A.. Cyclic ovanan func-
oon and breast canttr. Cancer Res. (SuppJ.1,:42, 32g6-3288'(d982)j
SvuuLatm, D.M.. OvFortD. K.P.. and MIU:EU. R.D., Higher risk of lung
eancen, in chronic obstnrctive pulrranarv disease a prospecuve matched
sonnolledarudy: Ann. inttrn. Med..,lOs, 503-507 (1986).
WArEStNovsE, J., Mtm, C.,, SxAN.wucAruTt+Aw: K.,, and PowEu. 1...
Cancer uicidrnce in five toruinnus. Yol. IS', IARC. Lyon 11982),
WHrriESaoltE, A.S., Euimatingaetribuuble risks from use-conaol stud-
ies. Mter. J. Epidtntio(:, 117, /6-85 (1983).
Wo, A., HENDERSOr:. B.E., PIICE.,M.C.. and YL, M.C., Snakrng and
odier risk f.ctors for lung cancer, in,wornen. J: nar. Cancer lnsr.,,74,
747-751 (19851:
ZxEyG,,W., and GAO. Y.T.. A hospitalbased case-eoettrolistady on asso-
ciauon ofsquatrwtts cell carcinotna and:adlenocarcinonm with smoking
Tumor. 6, ] -7 20 (d986),.
LECLEx. R.G:, MAso%. T.l.. SrEwwAGEw. A.. HooveR. R.. SCHOENeEaG.
J., GtuDUET., G.. V®eo, P. W., and FnALMENI, J.F.. Ja., Carotenoid
intake. vegeubles. and the risk of lung cancec among white men in New
Jt:rsey. Amer. J. Epidtmiol., 123, 1080-1093 (1986)ij
