Philip Morris
Effect of 'passive' Smoking on the Physical Load Tolerance of Coronary Heart Disease Patients
Fields
- Author
- Khalfen, E.S.
- Klochkov, V.A.
- Document File
- 2023511660/2023512308/Ets: Heart Disease 930900
- Area
- SCIENTIFIC AFFAIRS/BLACK LATERAL OLD S&T
- Type
- PSCI, PUBLICATION SCIENTIFIC
- BIBL, BIBLIOGRAPHY
- CHAR, CHART, GRAPH, TABLE, MAPS
- BIBL, BIBLIOGRAPHY
- Master ID
- 2023511661/2307
Related Documents:- 2023511661-2307 Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Heart Disease
- 2023511710 the Relationship of Passive Smoking to Various Health Outcomes Among Seventh-Day Adventists in California.
- 2023511714-1718 Passive Smoking and the Risk of Heart Attack or Coronary Death
- 2023511722-1727 Effects of Passive Smoking on Ischemic Heart Disease Mortality of Nonsmokers A Prospective Study
- 2023511728 Erratum
- 2023511729 'effects of Passive Smoking on Ischemic Heart Disease Mortality of Nonsmokers: A Prospective Study'
- 2023511730 the First Author Replies
- 2023511734-1737
- 2023511738-1744 Passive Smoking in Females and Coronary Heart Disease
- 2023511749-1756 Original Contributions Heart Disease Mortality in Nonsmokers Living with Smokers
- 2023511760-1781 Lung Cancer in Japan: Effects of Nutrition and Passive Smoking
- 2023511785-1789 Passive Smoking and Cardiorespiratory Health in A General Population in the West of Scotland
- 2023511790 Passive Smoking and Cardiorespiratory Health in Scotland
- 2023511791-1792 Passive Smoking and Cardiorespiratory Health in Scotland
- 2023511793-1795 Passive Smoking and Cardiorespiratory Health in Scotland
- 2023511800-1802 Public Health Briefs Passive Smoking and 20-Year Cardiovascular Disease Mortality Among Nonsmoking Wives, Evans County, Georgia
- 2023511806-1816 Relationship of Passive Smoking to Risk of Lung Cancer and Other Smoking-Associated Diseases
- 2023511818 Increased Incidence of Heart Attacks in Nonsmoking Women Married to Smokers
- 2023511822-1824 Cvd Epidemiology Newsletter
- 2023511829-1841 Original Contributions Effects of Passive Smoking in the Multiple Risk Factor Intervention Trial
- 2023511842 Re: 'effects of Passive Smoking in the Multiple Risk Factor Intervention Trial'
- 2023511843-1844 Re: 'effects of Passive Smoking in the Multiple Risk Factor Intervention Trial'
- 2023511845 Re: 'effects of Passive Smoking in the Multiple Risk Factor Intervention Trial'
- 2023511846 the Authors Reply
- 2023511849-1853 Smoking As A Risk Factor for Cerebral Ischemia
- 2023511857-1862 Urinary Cotinine Measurement in Patients with Buerger's Disease - Effects of Active and Passive Smoking on the Disease Process
- 2023511865-1881 An Estimate of Adult Mortality in the United States From Passive Smoking
- 2023511882 Editorial Cardiovascular Risks of Environmental Tobacco Smoke
- 2023511883-1887 An Estimate of Adult Mortality in the United States From Passive Smoking: A Response
- 2023511888-1890 An Estimate of Adult Mortality in the United States From Passive Smoking: A Response
- 2023511891-1892 Ischemic Heart Disease: Response to Lee
- 2023511893-1895 Rebuttal to Lee / Katzenstein Commentary on Passive Smoking Risk
- 2023511896-1899 An Estimate of Adult Mortality in the United States From Passive Smoking: A Response
- 2023511900-1906 An Estimate of Adult Mortality in the United States From Passive Smoking: A Response to Criticism
- 2023511908-1911 Deaths From Lung Cancer and Ischemic Heart Disease Due to Passive Smoking in New Zealand
- 2023511912 Deaths From Lung Cancer and Ischemic Heart Disease Due to Passive Smoking in New Zealand
- 2023511913 Passive Smoking in New Zealand
- 2023511914 Passive Smoking in New Zealand
- 2023511915 Passive Smoking in New Zealand
- 2023511916 Passive Smoking and Passive Thinking
- 2023511918-1937 Cardiovascular Diseases and the Work Environment A Critical Review of the Epidemiological Literature on Chemical Factors
- 2023511939-1950 Clinical Progress Series Passive Smoking and Heart Disease Epidemiology, Physiology, and Biochemistry
- 2023511952-1957 Review Passive Smoking and the Risk of Heart Disease
- 2023511958-1961 Aha Medical / Scientific Statement Position Statement Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Cardiovascular Disease A Position Paper From the Council on Cardiopulmonary and Critical Care, American Heart Association
- 2023511965-1983 the Health Consequences of Involuntary Smoking A Report of the Surgeon General
- 2023511985-1998 Environmental Tobacco Smoke Measuring Exposures and Assessing Health Effects
- 2023512000-2015 Environmental Tobacco Smoke Proceedings of the International Symposium at Mcgill University 890000 Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Cardiovascular Disease: A Critique of the Epidemiological Literature and Recommendations for Future Research
- 2023512016-2028 Panel Discussion on Cardiovascular Disease
- 2023512030-2037 Indoor Air Quality and Ventilation Environmental Tobacco Smoke (Ets) and Cardiovascular Disease
- 2023512039-2054 A Critique of the Methods Used to Assess the Toxic Effects on Man of Combustion Products.
- 2023512056-2066 Coronary Heart Disease and Involuntary Smoking
- 2023512068-2077 7. Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Coronary Heart Disease
- 2023512079-2088 Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Coronary Heart Disease
- 2023512090-2091 Editorial Give A Dog-End A Bad Name
- 2023512093-2108 Weaknesses in Recent Risk Assessments of Environmental Tobacco Smoke
- 2023512110-2129 Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Mortality A Detailed Review of Epidemiological Evidence Relating Environmental Tobacco Smoke to the Risk of Cancer, Heart Disease and Other Causes of Death in Adults Who Have Never Smoked - 5 Heart Disease
- 2023512131-2155 Environmental Tobacco Smoke Exposure and Occupational Heart Disease
- 2023512157-2171 Passive Smoking and Coronary Artery Disease. Biological Plausibility and Severity of Effect
- 2023512173-2180 Carbon Monoxide and Cardiovascular Disease: An Analysis of the Weight of Evidence
- 2023512185-2189 the Effects of Passive Inhalation of Cigarette Smoke on Excercise Performance
- 2023512192-2195 Effect of Passive Smoking on Angina Pectoris
- 2023512199-2202
- 2023512216-2220 Indoor Passive Smoking: Its Effect on Cardiac Performance
- 2023512223-2224 Passive Smoking Severely Decreases Platelet Sensitivity to Antiaggregatory Prostaglandins
- 2023512227-2230 Platelet Sensitivity to Prostacyclin in Smokers and Non-Smokers
- 2023512233-2237 Besitzen Passivraucher Ein Erhohtes Thromboserisiko?
- 2023512241-2244 Passive Smoking Affects Endothelium and Platelets
- 2023512247-2253 Lipoprotein and Oxygen Transport Alterations in Passive Smoking Preadolescent Children the Mcv Twin Study
- 2023512256-2257 Abstracts of the 30th Annual Conference on Cardiovascular Disease Epidemiology Children's Hdl-Chol: the Effects of Tobacco: Smoking, Smokeless and Parental Smoking
- 2023512261-2266 Passive Smoking Alters Lipid Profiles in Adolescents
- 2023512269-2274 Serum Lipids & Lipoprotein Profiles of Cigarette Smokers & Passive Smokers
- 2023512278-2279 8th Worldconference on Tobacco or Health Building A Tobacco-Free World 920330 - 920403 Buenos Aires - Argentina Abstracts, Posters and Videos. Serum Lipoproteins in Nonsmokers Chronically Exposed to Tobacco Smoke in the Workplace
- 2023512282 the Association Between Carotid Arterial Wall Thickness and Active and Passive Cigarette Smoking
- 2023512285 Passive Smoking and Carotid Artery Wall Thickness: the Aric Study
- 2023512290-2297 Passive Smoking Increases Experimental Atherosclerosis in Cholesterol-Fed Rabbits
- 2023512300-2301 Supplement to Circulation Abstracts From the 65th Scientific Sessions New Orleans Convention Center New Orleans, Louisiana 921116 - 921119
- 2023512304-2307 Association of Passive Smoking with Increased Coronary Heart Disease Risk Is Not Explained by Elevation of Leucocyte Count
- Characteristic
- EXTR, EXTRA
- TRSL, TRANSLATION
- Named Person
- Khalfen, E.S.
- Litigation
- Okag/Privilege Withdrawn
- Okag/Produced
- Author (Organization)
- Leningrad Scientific Res Inst Cardiology
- Ministry of Health
- Rsfsr
- Ter Arkh
- Ministry of Health
- Site
- R529
- Date Loaded
- 24 May 1999
- UCSF Legacy ID
- djc02a00
Document Images
Ter. Arkh., 1987 (15): 112-115
EFFECT OF "PASSIVE" SI+lO1CIaTG ON THE PHYSICAL LOAD
TOLERANCE OF CORONARY HEART DISEASE PATIENTS
E.Sh. Khalfen and V.A. Klochkov
Saratov Branch of the Leningrad Scientific Research
Institute for Cardiology of the Ministry of Health
of the RSFSR (Director: Prof. E.Sh. Khalfen)
Summary
"Passive" smokin¢ has been shown to produce a marked
negative e(Iet: on, CHD: patients. Short-term airinQ of a
toum does not pre.ent a neQative effect of 'passive'
unokinQ.
Translated from Russian
N O TE:''TF_ r5 ?S 1"T O'!" A

EFFECT OF "PASSIVE" SMOKING ON THE'PH'YSICAL LOAD TOLERANCE OF
CORONARY HEART DISEASE PATIENTS
By E. Sh. Khalfen and V'.A. Klochkov
There is no doubt at the present time that smoking can
promote the development of coronary heart disease (CH!D) [1,2,4,5].
The risk of CHD i~s doubled or tripled in people who smoke more
than one pack of cigarettes per day [i3,10]. The incidence of a
myocardial infarction an& sudden death has been linked directly to
smoking [5,7]. Furthermore, the risk of a second myocardial
infarction and sudden~death is reduced 20~to 50% (11,12] if the
smoker stops smoking.
A negative correlation between cigarette smoking and
tolerance to physical loa& has been found in bicycle ergometry
tests [1]. A spasm confirmed by coronary angiography in~the
coronary arteries and intensification of thrombocyte aggreation
have beem linked with smoking [9].
However, the overwhelming maj;ority of investigations have
been carried out on smokers. Nevertheless, it has been shown
[8',11] that even "passive" smoking, i.e., just being present i'n a
smoky environment and breathing tobacco, has a strong negative
effect on the state of the cardiovascular system. D. Makkenzi [S1
believes that about a thousand English people die every year from
the effects of "passive" smoking.
"Passive" smoking has not yet been investigated adequately.
We have therefore performed'a study aimed at evalubti~ng the effect
of "passive"' smoking on the indices obtained' in the bicycle
ergometer test on CHD patients.
, ~-*~u"-;a`~;

-2-
We made observations on 81 people, 10 of whocm were
practically healthy and range& from 25 to 48 years of age (average
age 38) and 71 patients with angina of effort ramging from 31 to
63 years (average age 49'). All the subjects were men.
The angina patients included 33'smokers (who smoked an
average oF one pack of cigarettes per day) and 38'nonsmokere. The
healthy group included 5 smokErs and 5 nonsmokers.
Thirty-nine CHD patients hod functional class I and II
angina of effort and 32 had class III and IV angina of effort.
Fifteen had undergone a transmural myocartial infarct±on in the
past and 10 suffered from stage II hypertensive disease.
All the smokers abstained from smoking for two hours before
taking the bi~cycle ergometer test. All the patients refrained
from using antianginal agemts several days before the t-.sts,
except for nitroglycerine tablets.
The bicycle ergometer test was carried outt with the subjects
in cA sitting positi~on on a Simens-E1ema bicycle ergometer,
registering the EKG with three Nebo leads on a:fiingography-82
current polygraph. A continuous load was employed lasting 3
minutes, increasing by consecutive steps of 25 W. The bicycle
z!rgometer test was stopped when a submaximum pulse rate was
cnached, when the ST segment shifted horizontally or slanting
down ward 1 mm or more below the isolines, when a typical angina
attack occurred, which was arrested by administration of
ni'troglycerine, or when the T wave was inver ted in two or more of
the traces.
In evaluating the bilcqcle ergometer test, we considered the
I

-3-
following indices: tolerance to load (in Watts), the double
product of DP (in arbitrary units) and the ratio of the DP to the
power load (DP/W).
The bicycle ergometer was installed and the test conducted
in a 24-m2 room, 3.2 m high. The test was performed on the
subjects at first under the usual conditions in eccordance with
the procedure described above. Than eight cigarettes were smoked
in the room over a two-hour period (one cigarette every 15
minu~tes):. The subjects were in the room for this entire period,
si~tting in a chair, reading magazines, talking, or playing
checkers. A second bicycle ergometer test was performed after
this two-hour period im the smoky room.
The test was modified for 15 of the subjects by ventilating
the smoky room for 10 minutes through a 0.5.-m~2 transome twice ..
during their two-hour stay (at the end of each hour).
In order to determine whether or not the first bicycle
ergometer test affected the indices of the second test two hours
later, tolerance to load tests were made on class II and IV angima
of effort patients (average age 48')~twice two hours epart, after
they had been in the room described above but without any smoke.
The original tolerance to load averaged, 62.5 + 1.4 W and tolerance
in: the second test after two hours was 70 + 2.0 W(threP angi~na of
effort patients showed tolerances in the second; test that were one
step higher, by 25 W).
The tests confirmed the validity of using paired bicycle
ergometer lioads. The validity of such a test has been
demonstrated by extensive experience in our country and abroad inn
grading patients who take antiangimal preparations.

-4-
The tests have shown that the t;olerance to load in a group
of practicall'y healthy people before a stay in a smoky room
averaged 192 + 5.5 W, DP averaQed 246 + 7.2 arbitrary units, and
the DP'/W' index was 1.3' + 0.04. Af ter "passive" smoking, the
tolerance to load in this group was 197 + 5.7 W, DP was 238 + 7.1
arbitrary units, and DP'/W' was 1.2 + 0.03. Thus, there were no
statisticaLly significant differences in the bicycle ergometer
indices in healthy people and after "passive" smoking.
We made a separate analysis of the results of the "passive"
smoking test in the CHD1 patients without room ventilation
(Group 1) and in those with a short period of ventilation
(Group 2).
The average tolerance to load in the Group 1 angina o.f
effort patients was 8'7'± 2.6 W' before the "passive" smoking test in
the unventilated room and 63 + 1.8 W after the test (p < 0.01).
The n,ain reasons for stopping the bicyclie ergometer teat both
bo ~ore and, after smoking were an attack of angina of effort in 21
people, ashift in the ST segmient 1 mm or more below the isoline
in 18, inversion of the T waves in four, and achieving a
submaximal heart contraction rate in three.
"Passive" smoking in anigina of effort patients results i~n a
losrer tolerance to load a lower DP and a higher DP/W ratio
(Table 1). These changes were much more pronounced in class III
and IV angine of effort patients than i'n class I
and II angina
puticnts. Thlus, smokers who were class I and LI nngina of effort
~ patieats shoued a 17% decrease in tolerarce to load, whereas class
III, and' IV angina patienits showed a d'ecrease of 47%.

Functional
cl~ass of
angina of
effQlrt
-S-
T.1BLE 1. Bilcyle ergcmeter test indices in patients with
angina of ef'fort: A), before the 2-hour scay in the unventilated
smoke-filled room; B) after the 2-hour stay (M+m).
, Nonsmokers Smo kers
Ind,_x
I A I B . A
B i
o ~era»r:r to
load, V
I09f3,9
90t 2.8
<0.01
125 f 3.8
116t Z;s
<a0s
DP, arlii% .*ur its191t5,7 182_-t S.5 >0.03 18a=5+/ l77t5.3 >0.05
1.8t0.06 2.0d.-0.06 >0.05 1i.5t040S I.St 0.05 >0.03
Ialiit'alic:! to
load, W
57t 1.6
30tt 1.0
<0.01
50:t: 1.5
28t0.8
<0,01
D"', art it. u 1tS1<8t1.3 12G:L0+6 <0.01 129:tJ,5 115*1.5 <0,01
Di jiT 2,6:t 0;07 4,2tt1:I <0.01 2.6_0.07 1.0*0.07 <O.W
*srb-.trary units

The tol!erance to physical load and the DP after staying in
the smoky room dropped distinctLy whether or not the patient was a
smoker. However,
the drop in bicycle ergometer indices induced by
"psssive" smoking was somewhat Lower in smokers than in
nonsmoktrs. It should be pointed out that such a difference was
detecte& in, patients with more moderate an,gina of effort, whereas
class III and IV angina of effort patients reacted almost
identically to "'passive" smoking whether they were smokers or not.
Patient E. A'ge 47. Diagnosis: CHD, functional, class III
'
angina of effort. Pressing chest. pains radiating to the left
shoulder appeared daily when walking or ascendi~ng a stairway.
Pains Lasted 2 to 3' minutes af ter he stopped movinig or took
nitroglycerine. The coronary angiographly indicated 90% stenosis
of the right coronary artery and 507 stenosis of the c:ircumflex
branch of the left coronary artery. A bicycle ergometer test was
performed on June 27, 1985. No pathological changes in the EKG
were detecte& at rest before the ergometer test.
The bicycl!e ergometer test before "passive" smoking gave a
tolerance to load of 75 W, o DP'of 220 arbitrary units, and a DP/W'
ratio of 2.9. The test was stopped because of an angina attack
and a shift of the ST segment 1 mm below the isolines om two
traces (see Figure 1).
A second ergometer test was performed after he had spent two
hours in the smoke-filled room. This time tolerance to load was
50 W, DP 200 3rbitrary, units, and DP/W 4.0. The test was stoppe&
because of an ansi;na attack and a shif t in the ST se-ment 1.5 mm
below the isolines om the two~traces.

R
B
a
b
Figure 1. Dynamics of the EKG in patient E, age 47, during
bicycle ergometer test: A) before 2-hour stay in unventillated,
smoke-filled room; B) after the 2-two stay. a) EKG at rest;
b) EKG during the bicycle ergometer test. Explanation in
text.

-8-
Thus, load tolerance droppe&, DP dezreased, and' DP/WW
increased in a patient suffering from class III angina of effort
after "passive" smoking.
When the test was conducted by ventilating the room for a
short time during the "passive" smoking period, the load tolerance
of group 2 angina patients was 89 + 2.5 W before "passive" smoking
and 63 + 1.7 W' thereafter (p < 0.01). The bicycle ergometer tests
were stopped because of an attack of angina of effort in 7
patients, followed by nitroglycerine administration; because of a
shift in the ST segment 1 mm below the isolines in 6; and because
The rather large room used in this stu~dy was not very smoky,
since only 8 cigarettes were smoked in two hours. In reality, we
often encounter a much higher concentration of tobacco smoke in
rooms. However, "passive" smoking in a rooL. with a relatively loww
smoke concentration had a pronounced negative effect on all the
subjects who were CHD patients, lowering tolerance to physical
load, decreasing DP, and raising the DP/W ratio. A short
ventilation period through a transom (which is usually typical of
residential and service rooms) did not prevent "passive"'smoking
of inversion of the T wave in 2.
A marked decrease in load tolerance and DP' and an increase
in DP/W were found'in the patients. Two 10-minute ventilation
periods in two hours did not prevent the effect of "passive"'
smoking (Table 2).
from exnrting its effect.
.

,.
Functional
class of
angi~na of
Ffllort
-9-
TABLE 2. Bicycle ergometer test indices in patients with
angina of effort: A) before 2-hour stay in smoke-filled
room ventilated for short time; B) after the 2-hour
stay (M+m).
Index
Tolerance to
load, W
DP, arbit. uni
j~P [W
l~o~ierance to
loaid, W
DP arbit. uni
DP)W
Nonsmoicers
A I B I
0
A
Smokers
B I' .
120t: 3,3
105t 3.1 i
<0.01
113.t 3.5
110f3.3
>0,05
S 196f 5,7 183*5,5 >0.05 1'90!t 5.4 1d8*5.2 >0;05
1 ,6:t0,05 1.8:L-0.06 >0.05 ;'.7=0106 1:9 :L-0.06 >0,05
5u.-!: 1.4 25t 0,7 <0:01 50f L4 25t ae <0.01.
s 143:L- 4,2 118:t 3.6 <0.01 137f3;4 . 110-29 <0A L
2a* 0,08 1.7t0.1 <0,01 Z8* 0.07 4.0Z- a09 <o,on
