Philip Morris
Lung Cancer Among Chinese Women
Fields
- Author
- Blot, W.J.
- Ershow, A.G.
- Fraumeni, J.F., J.R.
- Gao, Y.T.
- Hsu, C.W.
- Levin, L.I.
- Zhang, R.
- Zheng, W.
- Ershow, A.G.
- Type
- PSCI, PUBLICATION SCIENTIFIC
- BIBL, BIBLIOGRAPHY
- CHAR, CHART, GRAPH, TABLE, MAPS
- BIBL, BIBLIOGRAPHY
- Area
- PARRISH,STEVE/OFFICE
- Litigation
- Okag/Privilege Withdrawn
- Okag/Produced
- Characteristic
- EXTR, EXTRA
- Site
- N326
- Named Organization
- NCI, Natl Cancer Inst
- Author (Organization)
- Int J Cancer
- NCI, Natl Cancer Inst
- Shanghai Cancer Inst
- Shanghai Chest Hospital
- NCI, Natl Cancer Inst
- Named Person
- Chen, C.
- Henderson, B.
- Parsons, R.
- Stone, B.J.
- Xiaoou, S.
- Henderson, B.
- Master ID
- 2023382094/2668
Related Documents:- 2023382094-2668 Ets Issues Binder Ets and Lung Cancer in Nonsmokersvolume I.
- 2023382123-2125 Non-Smoking Wives of Heavy Smokers Have A Higher Risk of Lung Cancer: A Study From Japan
- 2023382127-2137 Cancer Mortality in Nonsmoking Women with Smoking Husbands Based on A Large-Scale Cohort Study in Japan
- 2023382139 Lung Cancer: Causes and Prevention Proceedings of the International Lung Cancer Update Conference, Held in New Orleans, Louisiana, 830303 - 830305
- 2023382140-2160 Lung Cancer in Japan: Effects of Nutrition and Passive Smoking
- 2023382163-2166 Lung Cancer and Passive Smoking
- 2023382168-2169 Lung Cancer and Passive Smoking: Conclusion of Greek Study
- 2023382172-2177 Time Trends in Lung Cancer Mortality Among Nonsmokers and A Note on Passive Smoking
- 2023382180-2183 Lung Cancer in Non-Smokers in Hong Kong
- 2023382186-2188 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer
- 2023382191-2217 Lung Cancer: Causes and Prevention Chapter 7 the Causes of Lung Cancer in Texas
- 2023382220-2230 Ets - Environmental Tobacco Smoke 3.6 the Effect of Environmental Tobacco Smoke in Two Urban Communities in the West of Scotland
- 2023382232-2236 Passive Smoking and Cardiorespiratory Health in A General Population in the West of Scotland
- 2023382239-2246 Lung Cancer in Nonsmokers
- 2023382249-2255 Involuntary Smoking and Lung Cancer: A Case-Control Study
- 2023382258-2281
- 2023382284-2288 Smoking and Other Risk Factors for Lung Cancer in Women
- 2023382291-2294 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer Among Japanese Women
- 2023382297-2305 Relationship of Passive Smoking to Risk of Lung Cancer and Other Smoking-Associated Diseases
- 2023382308-2318 Risk Factors for Adenocarcinoma of the Lung
- 2023382329-2333 Marriage to A Smoker and Lung Cancer Risk
- 2023382336-2343 Measurements of Passive Smoking and Estimates of Lung Cancer Risk Among Non-Smoking Chinese Females
- 2023382346-2351 Smoking, Passive Smoking and Histological Types in Lung Cancer in Hong Kong Chinese Women
- 2023382354-2361 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer in Swedish Women
- 2023382364-2369 Smoking and Health 870000 Proceedings of the 6th World Conference on Smoking and Health, Tokyo 871109 - 871112 on the Relationship Between Smoking and Female Lung Cancer
- 2023382372-2374 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer in Women
- 2023382377-2385 A Case-Control Study of Lung Cancer in Nonsmoking Women
- 2023382388-2394 Smoking and Passive Smoking in Relation to Lung Cancer in Women
- 2023382397-2401 Lung Cancer and Exposure to Tobacco Smoke in the Household
- 2023382403-2503 Assessment of the Association Between Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer
- 2023382506-2525 Toxicology Forum 900000 Annual Winter Meeting Epidemiologic Studies of the Relationship Between Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer
- 2023382528-2534 Passive Smoking and Diet in the Etiology of Lung Cancer Among Non-Smokers
- 2023382537-2548 Passive Smoking Among Nonsmoking Women and the Relationship Between Indoor Air Pollution and Lung Cancer Incidence - Results of A Multicenter Case Controlled Study
- 2023382551-2556 Lung Cancer Among Women in North-East China
- 2023382559-2564 Smoking and Other Risk Factors for Lung Cancer in Xuanwei, China
- 2023382566-2572 Other Studies Discussing Lung Cancer
- 2023382574-2583 Passive Smoking As A Causative Factor of Lung Cancer in Nonsmoking Women
- 2023382584-2588 Passivrauchen Als Lungenkrebs-Urache Bei Nichtraucherinnen
- 2023382589 Lung Cancer and Passive Smoking
- 2023382591-2602 Passive Smoking in Adulthood and Cancer Risk
- 2023382603-2608 Cancer Risk in Adulthood From Early Life Exposure to Parents' Smoking
- 2023382609-2611 Cumulative Effects of Lifetime Passive Smoking on Cancer Risk
- 2023382612-2613 Lifetime Passive Smoking and Cancer Risk
- 2023382614 Lifetime Passive Smoking and Cancer Risk
- 2023382615-2618 Letters to the Editor 'passive Smoking in Adulthood and Cancer Risk'
- 2023382620-2623 the Relation of Passive Smoking to Lung Cancer
- 2023382625-2631 Respiratory Cancer in A Scottish Industrial Community: A Retrospective Case-Control Study
- 2023382633-2647 Effect of Passive Smoking in Lung Cancer Development in Women in the Nara Region
- 2023382649-2651 Passive Smoking Is A Risk Factor for Lung Cancer in Never Smoking Women in Hong Kong
- 2023382653-2658 Epidemiologic Characteristics and Multiple Risk Factors of Lung Cancer in Taiwan
- 2023382660-2667 the Impact of Passive Smoking: Cancer Deaths Among Nonsmoking Women
- Date Loaded
- 24 May 1999
- UCSF Legacy ID
- mxb02a00
Document Images
.. 1''. ~.+ ? . L "
TRIs tnctori5l tr;iy be
protscted by, coDYri0
Int. J Cancer: 40. 604-GQ9 (1987) /gW (~ttle 17 U:S. COd4
= 1987 Alan:R. Liss. Inc.
LUNG CANCER AMONG CHINESE WOMEN
--~
PuDM'Cit Wn 01'}tN 1n1rn1'tK1n11 Un,O-iQt,^tt CMCf. P,IO/.c!{i0n of I'UA.On IOif~nftiOnfK COntrt If
C1nct,
Yu-Tang GAOi. VWilljam I. BLOT'. Wei'ZHENG1, Abby G. ERSHOwzCheng Wen Hsu3'. LytmI. Ll:vtN=, Rong
ZHAt.G' and
Joseph F. Ftz~t.Hevt. 1R.'-
tShanghai Cancer Instirure. Shanghai. People's Republic ojChina: =Nattonal Cancer Institure,
Berhesda, MD 20892, US.1; and
3Sluinghai Chest'Hospiial. Shanghai. People's 1?epublic ojCluna.
A case-controt study involving intor+riYws with &72 female
k+ns cancer patients and 735 poputatior*bas.d contsols was
conductad to investigate the hish rates of hft cancer, norablr
adenocarcinoma, among women In Shanthai ~ Cigarette smok
ing was a strong risk factor, but accmunted for only about one-
fourth of, all newly diagnosed cases of lung cancer. Most pa-
tients, particularly with adenocarclnoma, were IHabng non-
smokers. The risks of lung cancer were higher among wanen
reporting tuberculosis and other preixistin= lung diseases.
Hormonal factors were suggested by an Mcr.wd risk associ-
at.d with late menopause and by a gradiint In Me r(sk of
adenocarcinwma with decreasing menstrual'''cYcle ksngth. with
a 3-fold'exceu among woman who had shorter qrNes: Perhaps
most intriguing were associations found between lung cancer
and maasures of sxposure to cooking oil vaport. Rltks In-
creased with the numbers of m.als cooked by either stir
frying, deep frying or tioitinj;,widi the frequency of smokiness
during cooking; and with the frequency of eye i'ritstion dur-
in= cooking. Use of rapess.d oil, whose volatiles following
hi:h-cemperature cooking may be rnuta=enic, was also re-
ported more often by the cancer patients. The fkndin=s thus
confirm that factors other than smoking are r.sponsible for
the high risk of lung cancer among CJwnese women and pro
vide clues for further research, {nchidn'g the assessment of
cooking practice&
The age-adjusted annual lung cancer incidence rate among
females in Shan¢hai during the 1970's and 1980's has been
about 20 per 100.000 population, one of'the highest rates im
China and'in the world (National CancerControl!Office, 1980;
Gao. 1982: Waterhouse et al., 1982: Shanghai Cancer Regis-
try. 1983)1 Elevated lung cancer death tates have also been
observed among Chinese women in other parts of the world,
including Hong Kong (Kung er al:- 1984: Koo a' al,, 1985),.
Singapore (MacLennan ec al.. 1977) and the United States
(Fraumeni' and' Mason. 1974: Hinds er al,, 1981; Green and
Brophy. 1982). The high rates of this cancer are surprising
since few Chinese women smoke cigarettes (Deng and! Gao.
1985). Funhermore. in Shanghai (Zheng and Gao. 1986) and
elsewhere, hospital records have indicated that most of the
lung tumors are adenocarcinomas, a type of lung cancer less
strongly relbted to smoking (Lubin and 81ot 1984). To explore
reasons for the high rates of lung car,cer among women in
Shanghai, the Shanghai Cancer Institute, in collaboration with
the US National Cancer Institute, carried out a population-
based case-control investigation. Herein we report the results
of this study: quantifying the role of smoking and evaluating a
variety of suspected risk factors.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
All newly diagnosed cases of primary lung cancer (9th
Revision ICD 162) during the 2-year period February I984-
Febtuary 1986 among female residents of urban Shanghai aged
35-69 years were identified by a rapid' repotting system for
lung cancer estublished~ for this study. The system was built
upon the existing Shanghai' Cancer Registry, the oidest in
China (Gao, 1982). Trained staff contacted medical facilities
in Shanghai to ascertain new cases, so that interviews could
be rapidly scheduled (typically within 2 weeks of dvagrasi's).
The staff reviewed relevant medical records, abstracting data
on the basis of diagnosis. histologic type. and the site of'the
tumor within the lung. Two senior pathologists and 4 senior
clinicians were appointed to review the diagnostic information
from,all cases collected in the study. including X-ray films.
cytologic and histologic slides.
Female controls were randomly selected within 5-year age
strata from the general population of the Shanghai urban area.
The number and age distribution of the controls were deter-
mined in advance from the number and age distribution of
lung cancer cases reported to the Shanghai Cancer Registry
during the period 1980-81. The selection procedure invoived
randomly choosing' a neighborhood committee from among
the approximately 1.300 committees in urbamShanghai, then
randomly choosing a household group within the comminee
and ascertaining from existing rosters the names of all females
in the appropriate age range. Among these persons. 2 were
randomly selected. If the first was absent during the period of
study or could not be interviewed, the second was accepted as
a control. Tables of random numbers were used in the random
sampling.
The cases and controls were interviewed by trained inter-
viewers. A structured questionnaire was used to obtain infor-
mation on demographic charaeteristics. exposure to tobacco-
dietary and cooking practices. medical conditions. family his-
tory of lung cancer, menstrual artd'reproductive factors. job
history and other variables. All completed questionnaires and
medical abstracts were checked by a field supervisor. and'the
information was then abstracted on coding sheets for key-
punching and cotnputeri.zation in the United States.
Statisticalianalyses of the collected data were based on mul-
tivariate techniques for case-control data (Breslow and Day;.
1980). Logistic regression analyses were used to estimate
summary relative risks (RR) of lung cancer associated with
various facton, after adjusting for age (,<55; 55-59, 60-64.
65-69), smoking (non-smoker; smoked less than 20 years or
less than 10 cigarettes/day; smoked 20 or more years and 10-
19 cigarettes/day; smoked 20 or more years and 20 or more
cigarettes/day). education (no formal education, primary
school, secondary school and higher) and other variables. and
to evaluate statistical significance. Poptdation' attributable risk
(PAR) estimates for smoking. adjttsted for age, were also
derived (Whittemore, 1983).
RESULTs
A total of 765 lung cancer patients were identified during
the 2-year period and interviews conducted with 672 (88%).
We excluded the 93 patients who died, including 38 ascer-
tained by death certif~ate only: There were no patients who
refused interview. Forty-three percent of the cases were diag-
nosed by tissue biopsy. 3896 by cytology, and 1'996 by repeated
Addnessre~n ot nequests from China to Dr, Geo and frorn oMer coun-
aies to Dr. Blor.
Received: March 30~ 1987 and in revised form May 29. 1987.

l
LUNG CANCER IN CHINESE WOMEN
605
TABt.E1- RELATIVE R1SKS OF LU1:G.CANCER ASSOC'IATEDwTTH.KUMBt7t OF CIGARETTES SMOKED PER'.DMAND
DLRAT7O+. OF: SMOKING
" tArnwn otaeotunr
Vumflcrof'cipnrncs
smNtd
er da <.30 Yurs > 30.Tur,
~ .
p
Cue~
Camroe
RR'
9!Sf CI
Casc
Conrrol.
RR
95:Q;
< 10 36 45 1.4 0.9-2.2 34 29 2.4 1.4-1 1'
10-i9 19 17' 2.6 1.2-5.7 56 33 3.2 2.0-51
20+ 13 2 8.9 2.0-40:2 78 10 14 1 7 1~.28 0
'Ad)usred fa aEc rd ehbcawn Nansmoicen ur wed :asdr. rekrencs rroap..
TiAaI.E 11 -RELATIVE RISKS OF LUNG CANCF'll AMOwG IqN-SMOKING
M'OME.tiASSOCIATED WTTHYEARS LIVED wITH'A.SMOKINGHUSBAND
YeanIrvd .nrA.mot,rq l.se.W Cua Cavds RR' "7F C7
<20 57' 99 1.0 -
20-29 63 93 1'.I 0;7-1'.8
30-39 78 107 1.3 0;8-2:1
;t 40 48 76 1.7 1.0-2.9
' hcymsted 4a "c and edWCauoe
X-ray films, Among the 542 interviewed cases pathologically
or eytological}v diagnosed. adenocarcinoma was the predomi,
nant cell, type accounting for 61 % of'all cases. 22 % were
squamous carcinomas. 6% were oat-cell (or small-cell undif-
ferentiated) cancers. and' 114E were miztures and other cell
types.
A total of 735 controls were interviewed. Among these 71
(9.7 %) were "second" controls, chosen, mainly because the
first selected'control1 had moved from the Shanghai urban area
or was found to be outside the eligible age range. The distri-
butions by age, education and' maritali status were generally
similar between,cases and controls. More controls than cases
(32 S( vs., 204E ). however. were in the oldest age group of 65-
69 years. but all subsequent analyses were age-adjusted.
Cigarette smoking
Cigarette srnoking was associated with a signnificantly in-
creased risk of lung cancer. even though only 35% of the lung
,ancer patients (compared to 18 % of the controls) had ever
smoked. There was a 33-fold excess risk (95% CI = 2.5-
4.2) of lung cancer among smokers, but risks were higher for
squamous-cell carcinoma (RR = 7:2, 95 % CI' = 4.6-11.1)
and oat-cell cancer (RR = 7.2, 95% Cx - 3.6-17.0) than for
adenocarcinorna (RR = 1.5, 95 % CI = l.0-2.1). The RR for
all lung cancers combined tended to rise with increasing num-
bers of cigarettes smoked per day'and with increasing duration
of smoking (Table I). The excess reached 14-fold for females
who srrtoked 20 or more cigarettes per day for more than 30
Yws. Si;milar trendt existed for adenocareiaonu and' for squa-
motu/oat-cell cancers, but the magnitude of the increase was
coauidenbly greater for the latter (not shown).
We calculated population-atttibvubk rislt (PAR) estimates
for smoking in each age group. The PAR rose with age, from
8% to 27% to 28% to 40% at'ages <55, 55-59, 60-64, and
65-69. respectively, primarily because the prc valence of
sawking rose with age. In total, we estimated that 2496 of all
female lung cancers in Shanghai were due to smoking..
Passivt smok'ing
No significant increase in risk was observed for overall
exposure to environmental tobacco smoke during childhood
(RR = 1.1. 95% Cl - 0.7-1.7) or adult life (RR - 0.9. 95%
CI = 0.6-1.4). For these calculations, exposure was said to
Occur if the subject had ever lived with a smoker. When
exposure was defined in tertns of husband's turtokittg, bow=
ever, ltmg cancer risks among non-smoking women tended to
ibcrease with the number of years a woman lived with a
husband who smoked: the RR reaching 1.7 among those with
40 or more compared to less than 20 years' exposure (Table
11). The risk in this heavily exposed group was even higher
(RR = 2.9 95 %' CI = 1.0-8.9) for squamous- and oat-cell
carcinoma..
Previous lung diseases
Since lung cancer in its early stages may be confused with
other lung diseases, we excluded non.rrtalignant lung diseases
occurring withimthe 3 years preceding interview in evaluating
the effect of prior lung disease upon lung cancer risk. Table
III shows that previous tuberculosis. pneumonia and emphy-
sema were significantly' associated with lung cancer risk even
after adjusting for smoking. Although, some individuals re-
ported having 2 or more of these diseases. the excesses for
each persisted when those with, multiple conditions were ex-
cluded. Further analysis (not shown) indicated that' the effectt
of tuberculosis was not related to the use of isoniazid or
streptomycin. While tuberculosis and pneumonia were related~
to, both squamousioat-cell carcinoma and adenocarcinoma of
the lung. emphysema and chronic bronchitis were associated~
only with the squamous- and oat-cell types.
Cooking pranices
Soybean and rapeseed oils were the oils used mosr often for
cooking in Shanghai, with over 95% of women reporting the
use of both products. Rapeseed oil, however, was reported as
the most often used cooking oil by 52 % of the cases compared
to 45 % of the controls. The overall increase in risk associated'
with rapeseed compared to soybean as the most often used oil
was 1.4 (95% CI = 1.1-1.8). Table IV'shows that the excess
lung cancer risk associated with use of rapeseed oil existed at
each level of reported frequency of eye irritation when eook-
ing, a subjective variable representing sever'ity of exposure too
cooking vapors. The calculations for this Table excluded~ the
few women who never cooked, and employed as the reference
group women who most often used soybean' oil'1 but never or
rarely reported eye itriiation. Table IV also shows that risks
of lung cancer were independently related to eye imtation,
with the highest risks (RR - 2.8, 95% CI - 1.g4.3) among
those using rapeseed oil and' fr+squendy reporting irritation.
The patterns were similar for squamous/oat-cell cancer and ~
adenocarcinoma. We also observed, after adjusting for eye
irritation, a 60% higher risk for lung eancer among womeno who reponed considerable or somewhat
smoky cottditions ln
their homes when cooking. another rough measure of exposure
to cooking vapors and to house ventilation (Table V). in,
addition, the risk ratios increased with the number of differentt
dishes per week prepated by stir frying. deep frying, or boiling
(Table VI). In contrast. no significant case/control differences
were associated with the type of fuel used for cooking- The
RR and 95% CI associated with coal. gas and wood as the
usual, fuels were 0.9 (0.7-1~.3). 1.1 (0.7-1.5). and'1.0 (0.6-
1',.8) respectively. There was no trend in risk with increasing
years of use of coa1L the most cominon cooking fuel in Shang-

606
GAO ET AL.
TAiLE nI.- RELATIVE RISKS OF LUNG CANCER.ASSOCIATED WITH PREVIOUS LUNG DISEASES
Putlunl
d/seasn . Carrols All
pus RR~ 9S'R Ct .. ~v
aa<eH RR' %T Ct '"°
orclroma RR' 4S4
None 554 418 1.0 80 1.0 - 229 1.0 -
Tuberculosis 61 80: 1.7 1.1-2.4 20 2.0 1.1-3.7 42 1.6 1.0-2.5
Pneumonh 35 65 1.9 1.2-3.0 16 1.8 0.9-3.8 26 1.5 0.9-2.7
Emphysema 18 37 2.0 1.0-3.7. 19 4.5 2.0-10.3 6 0.7 0.3-2.0
Chronic bronchitis 86 112 1.2 0.8-1.77 35 1.4 0.8-2.5 33 0.8 0.5-1.3
wit110W emr)hvSema
Others
30
30
1.3
0.7-2.2
8
1.7
0.7-4.2
13
1.0
0.5-2.0
1 All nslu ad)uutd foe .ge. Rduanon atd >n"AS and Maove so wamrn wph w reponed pux lunR dueau. hrwes
wuA ewse IAan oar Np 14 durase am included
w acii lung dusase cregory.
TAiLE rV - RELATIVE RiSKS OF LUNG CANCER ASSOCIATED WITH
COOKJNG OIL USED M06T OFTEN AND FREOUENCY OF EYE nIRJTATION
WHEN COOKING
TAiLE V - RELATIVE RlSKS OF LUNG CANCER ASSOCIATED wtTH~
FREQUENCY OF EYE IRRITATION AND HOUSE SMOKINESS WHEV COOKING
Eye mw.oon
when cnotie
Oil Wd
Miss otw-
Cars
Cooo4
RRI
9S* CI Eye
lrrrrso.. Mwse
.nroklKu
Ca.n
Canols~
RR'
954 Cl I
g
Never or rarely Soybean 140 214 1.0 - Neverharely None/slight 244 380 1.0 -
Rapeseed 145 193 1.2 0.9-1.7. Somewhat/ 55 55 1.6 1.0-2.5
Sometimes
Soybean
70
72
1.5
1.0-2.3 considerable
Rapeseed 87 63 2.0 1.3-3.0 Sometitnest' hitme/ilight 212 200 1.6 1.2-2.1
Frequently
Soybean
59
56
1.4
0.9-2.3' frequently
SomewhaU '
109
60
2.6
1.8-3
7
Rapeseed 90 50 2.9 1.8-4.3 considerable .
Total Soybean 269 342 1.0 -
'
Rapeseed
322
306
1.4
1.1-1.8 Adpuated for afe..d"we a.d unolunR.
IAdjyaaed (ar.R .Oucluom aed makwa.
TAaLE % 7- RELATIVE RISKS OF LUNGCAYCER ASSOCIATED WITH NUMBER
OF DIFFERENT DISHES PER WEEK.rRE1ARED BY DIFFERE!tT METNODSQF
COOKING
NYIIIisR Jf QlSilef
per .xeh
Caca
Cartrol,
RR'
95% CI
Sdir fning
42 0
336
408
1.0
-
20-24 1,98 211 1.2 0.9-1.5
25-29 48 47 1.2 0.8-1.9
~t 30 34 15 2.6 1.3-5.0
Dtep f-ing
0
502
594
1.0
-
I 85 68 1.5 1.0-2.1
2 2li 15 1.6 0.8-3.2
> 3 8 4 1.9 0,5-6.8
Boiling
<3
96
124
1.0
-
4-7 390 483 1.0 0.7-1.3
8-11 63 40 1.8 1.t-3.0
;a 12 67 33 2.2 1.3-3.7
'Adrrwed ioe ape..duano. +.d e.mkft.
hai. Exposures to coW: an ©ther fuel fitntes were generally
associated only with cooking. since nearly aU homes inShang-
hai were unheated.
Diet
The women were asked about their usual frequency of con-
sumption during adulthood of 32 commonly eaten foods, in-
cliiding the major contributors of vitamin A. Using Chinese
food composition tables to estimate the rttinol and carotene
content of each food and applying these escfatates to its fre-
quency of intake. an index of vttamtn A consumption in ret-
inol-equivalent units was eonstructed. The risks for lung cancer
R:nded to be lower among Blose with low values of this index
TAiLE V71- RELATIVE RISKS OF LUNG CANCER ASSOCIATED WTTH
DIETARY'INTAKE OF VITAMIN A
V..mm Qu.ruk k.el d consumpan~
eiPOlYIL
vanaple
I IH11A/
0
nt
1%,
Vitamin A 1.0 0.6 0.8 0.5
index (0.5-0M (0j6-1.1) (0.4-0.7)
RetinDl-rich 1.0 0.9 l'>0 0.9
foods (0.7-1.3) (0.:7-1.3) (0.7-1.2)
Caraene-rich 1.0 0.6 0.5 0.5
foods (0.5-0:8) (0:4-0:7) (0.3-0.6)
IRak edativa to lufheu quamk of eonwmpqwn aud adjusted for ap. .ducuan
aed smoWng. 95S C(m R.r<ndscses.
(Table VII). This association was accounted for mainly by a
lower risk among those with a neduced' consumption of earo-
tene-rich foods (the dominant source being dark green vegeta-
bles). No effect on risk was found for consumptton of the
nttinol-rich foods (mainly fish. eggs and liver). The paaerlt5
were generally similar for squamous/oattelt cancer and ade-
tsocarcinoma. and for smokers and non-srtakers.
Mensnrool and rrproductive fiteTors
The risks of lung cancer were higher among women with
shorter metsstrud' cyck kngths (Table WI). The association
was primarily seen for adenocarcinoma. which showed a strong
dose-response relationship. Among women aged 55 years and
over with a natural menopatse. tfie risk of adenocarcinoma
tended to increase with the total number of inenstnnl cycles
aver their lifetime. Some increased risk of adenocarcinoma
was seett when natural menopause occurred at age 30 or later
(RR - 1.3. 95Ae CI = 0.9-1.7, after adjusting for mettstrual
cycle length). No associations were seen with age at menarehe.
age at first pregnsn<y or parity.

LUNG CANCER IN CHINESE wOMEN
TARt.E Y711-RELATR'E RlSKSOF LUNG CANCER ASSOCIATEDWIT11 LENGTH OFMEySTRUAL CYCLE
607
ceartA ul
mnsrrual
ccck
Idn,,
AII ~.
csxs
Cnrrols
RR'
4S'4 CI
~f
RR'
951 CI~
~~I
RR'
9~V CI'~
> 33 43' 60 1.0 - 12 1.0 - 18 1.0 -
30-33 272 327 1.6 1.0-2.6 62 0.9 0.4-2.0 124 1.9 1.0-3.5
26-29 241 268 1.6 1.0-2.7 51 0.8 0.4-1.9 127 2.1 1.1-3.9
< 26 98 78 2.2 1'.3-3.7 23 1.6 0.7-3.9 54 2.9 IL5-5.7
'AdPuned r« aae. .euc>Mroe. smak" .nd ntipsi" a aiasrnuswn.
TABU IX - RELATIVE RtSKS OF LUNG CANCER FOR WOMEN EVER EMPLOYED IN M AlOIt OCCUPATIONAL GROUPS
ottypn= pnpn . , Ca+es Ca.rols RR= 9~..L CI
1-Il Professiosvls and tnchnicians: leaders of 113 116 1.0 0.7- L4
QI-IV state organizxions. party and mass orp-
niiations and enterprise units
Office and rslated personnel: sales workers
75
96
0.7
0.5-1.0
v' Service workers 1159 160 1.0 0.8-1.4.
VI Agricvltural.,forestry. arutnal!husbandry 24 21 1.1 0 6-?.:1
YII-lX and fishery workers
Production. tratuportation and other
436
471
1. C
0.9-1.4
0 related workers
Never worked
61
75
I_ I
0.7-1.6
'Women emplarod in more tAan one occvp.noiul!caleEon in` included in each pit(oM1 1111vtIKl1 ltle)'
wo/ke4 The LVi1inE KIKTe wL bKCO On Me symem rsed in the
.
N6: Popula~wn Census of Me People's Reput,irc of Chm (Populatan Ceews Office. I48i I: =Adjuwed (o6
age. educauwn and +molung
Oecuparior; bined (81ot and Fraumeni. 1986). an overall 30% excess of
Most women reported working outside the hotne, but ease/ lung cancer (RR= 1.3. 9596 C1 = 1'.1-1.5)
was found among
to major occupational categories non-smoking women tnarried to smokers. with the RR reach-
cont
s accordin
l diff
e
c
g
ro
er
n
e
ations were associated ing 17 among those most heavily exposed:
No rnajar occu
were sma11 (Table IX)
p
.
with increased risk of lung cancer. A decreased risk. however,
was observed for women ever employed in the cotton textile
indtutry, the largest employer of women in Shanghai. There
was a slight increase in the relative risk of lung cancer among
women ever employed as cooks (RR = 1.2. 95% CI = 0.6-
2.1), but few worked longer than 20 years.
Fmnils hisron
Although the causal significance of the relation of'prior lung
disease to lung cancer remains to be clarified. the high preva-
lenee of'previous pulmonary infections may have contributed
in part to the high incidence of lung cancer among Shanghai'
women. Earlier in this century; non-malignant lung disease
was one of the leading causes of death in China (Kan: 1981).
With the advent of antibiotics and improved living conditions,
the incidence and mortality of chronic lung diseases. panicu
The cancer patients reported about the same frcquency of larly tubercuiosis, declined. Nevertheless,
a substantial por-
lung cancer in their mothers (1.09fc ) and fathers (1.7 Yi ) as dte tion (38 9E ) of the women with
lung cancer in this study reported
controls (1.0% and 1.596, respectively). The RR, adjusted for prior lung disease. including 12% who
were long-term survi-
age. education and smoking, associated with having a parent vors of tuberculosis. whereas
significantly lower percentages
with lung cancer was 1.1 (95% CI = 0.6-2.3). More stbs of controls reported these diseases. To some
extent it is posst-
were reported to have lung cancer, but the numbers affected ble that recall or ascertainmenr bias
may contribute to the
were small (6 cases. 3 eontrols: RR - 3.0. 95% CI - 0.7- associations observed with prior lung
diseases. The elevated
12.5): Only one child, of a cantrol, had lung eancer, risk of lung cancer following tuberculosis,
however, is consis-
tent with recent studies in other countries. and is not explained
~~ by cigarette smoking or treatment with isottiazid. apulrttorury
carcinogen in laboratory animals (Howe er al.. 1979: Hinds sr
The high incidence of lung cancer among women in Shang- al.. 1982: Bakris er al'.. 1983).
hai, together with the low prevaknce of srnoking in the general F,mphysenu was also' signifMcantly
related to lung cancer.
Population. led us to consider a number of possible etiologic aflter adjustment for smoking habits,
with the excess limited to
factors. .N+hik eiprette smoking was aa inVortant cattse of~- squamous- and oat-cell carcinomas.
This finding adds to the
~bing cancer. showinE a cleardote-retponse tread, the majority evidence that chronic obstructive
pulmonary disease enhances
of lung ttunors, particularlr adenacircinonws, occurred among the risk of lung cancer (Skil)rud er
a/.. 1q86). even when
"on-smokers. controlling for smoking practices. Also noteworthy is the ele-
Lnvironmental tobacrn smoke nt:y accottnt for sotne. but vated risk associated with prior pneumonia.
especially since
Probably few, of the cancers among non-smokers. sina tiyere an usociation with lung adenocarcmoma
has previously been
was little or no association with ever having lived with a>eported among, women in Los Angeles (Wu
er al:. 1985).
smoker. Among non-smokin women rrurried to smokers. While pneumonia typically occurred during
adulthood in our
liowever. there was an upward trend in risk associated with smdy. the finding in Los Angeles
primarily'concerned child-
~neuing years of exposure. This latter finding is eonsistetn bood tnfection:
n
IvIth early~zen studies euatin~ tNvtksmokinn i~ n~un~~ conicate sisteet w~findings from
B Pass smoking were corn- for cookin8 gcancer risk

608
GAO ET A11..
Hong Kong (Koo er al., 1983). The risks of lung cancer among
Shanghai women increased, however, with vanous measures
of exposure to cooking oil vapors. These included the number
of different dishes prepared per week by either stir frying,
deep frying. or boiling;, the frequency of eye irritation when
cooking: and the smokiness of the house when cooking. ln
Chinese wok cooking. regardless of the method used oil is
usually poured into a wok and heated to high temperatures
before meat or vegetables are added. Even boiling may entail
some exposure to cooking oil vapors, since oil is often added
to the water before heating. ConseQuentty, the living quarters
may become smoky during cooking, wRh oppotmnity for
exposure to inhalabie cooking oil vapors.
The plausibility of the hypothesis that lung cancer may be
related to cooking oil vapors. partucularly from rapeseed oils
used in Shanghai. is enhanced by recent experimental ~ investi -
gations. Ln one study the mutagenicity of products from cook-
ing oil was assayed by the Ames test (Qu er al,, 1986). The
extracts of condensed volatiles of rapeseed oil, refined rape-
seed oil, and soybean oil heated at about 270°C were all
positive in tester strain TA98 activated with S9. The mutage-
nicity of the extract from rapeseed oil volatiles was stronger
than that from soybean oil volatiles. There was no evidence of
mutagenicity in the oils themselves, either heated or unheated.
In another siudy: the extracts of condensed volatiles of rape-
seed oil enhanced the yield of micronuclei in polychromatic
erythrocytes of the bone marrow of mice, with a clear dose-
response relationship. reflecting datnage of'chrvmosomes and
cell genotoxicity by rapeseed oil volatiles (Chen. 1987). Al-
though these tests often correlate with carcinogenic potential,
no bioassay studies have yet been carried out, to our knowl-
edge. If the effect of rapeseed oil smoke on lung cancer
incidence is real. the problem is of great importance to popu-
lations of eastern central China and other areas of the world
where the oil is often used for cooking. Chinese rapeseed oil,
which, is pressed from seeds of Brassica campesrris contains
about 50% erucic acid (Chinese Academy of Medical Sci,
ences. 1981). in conLrast to rapeseed'oil with <2% erucic acid
(Canbra oil). which was rectntiy approved for sale in the
United States (Federal Register. 1985):
Several studies have shown that the risk of lung cancer is
elevated by a low intake of foods containing vitamin A, partic-
ularly as its precursor beta-carotene (Colditz et a(., 1987).
Although reported mainly in Western countries, this associa-
tion has also been noted among Chinese women in Singapore
(MacLennan eral:, 1977): However, we found no evidence of'
a protective effect among women in Shanghai, where intake
of fresh. carotene-rich, dark green vegetables is high by worid
standards. In fact. a positive association was observed between
carotene intake and lung cattcer, risk in females (in contrast to
no association in males): We have no ready, explanation for
this unusual finding in females, which was observed also in a
case-control study of lung cancen in, Hawaii (Hinds et al.,
1984). However. the protective effect of carotene-rich, foods
was mainly confined to current smokers in one large-scale
study (Ziegler tr a/., 1986), and thus the effect may be less
evident in Shanghai where few women smoke.
A clue to hormonal factors was suggested by an association
between menstrual cycle kngth and1ung adenocarcinoma. A
3-fold difference in adenocarcinotna risk was found among
Shanghai women reporting short (<26 days) compared to long
(>33 days) mensrrual cycles, with only a weak trend for
squamous- and oat-cell cancers. A relation of short menstrual
cycles to breast cancer risk has been suggested in data from
Sweden (Ulsson et al., 1983) and, to a lesser extent, the United'
States (Sherman et al.. 1982). Some increases in lung adeno-
carcinoma risk were also associated with late menopause and
with a high estimated total number of rnenstrual! cycies among
women aged 55 and over having a natural menopause. A role
of hormonal factors is also suggested by the observation that
among non-smokers adenocarcinotna affecu proportionately
more females than males (Lubin and Blot. 1984), and by the
findings of' estrogen and progesterone receptors in some lung
adenocarcinomas of women (Chaudhuri et a1., 1982). We
discovered no relation to oral contraceptives or replacement
estrogen therapy: but use of these compounds among worrten
in the study group was rare in Shanghai. It seems unlikely that
the menstruallpatterns of Chinese women contribute greatly to
their high lung cancer risk, but the internal consistency of the
trends suggests that future studies of lung cancer in China and
elsewhere should examine endocrine hypotheses in more detail.
This large population-based case-control study of lung can-
cer in urban Shanghai has confirrned'tltat cigarette smoking is
a strong risk factor among Chinese women, but only accountss
for about one-fourth of all, newly diagnosed cases. Causes of
the remainder are utxlear, but occupational factors did not
appear to be important. nor did familial tendency to lung
cancer. Our data suggest, however, that prior lung diseascs,.
hormonali factors, and cooking practices may be involved..
Most provocative are the associations with cooking oil vola-
tiles, and further investigations are needed to evaluate their
contribution to the high lung cancer rates among Chinese
women in various parts of the world.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This work was supported in pan by the NCI. We thank Dr.
BJ. Stone. Dr. Slm Xiao-ou and Ms. R. Parsons for comput-
ing support. Ms. C. Chen for computational and~ translation
assistance, and Dr. B. Henderson for advice and helpful
suggestions.
tt;tcFFAENCFs
BAiuus. G.. MuLOnnns, G:P., KnRCxac. It.. Emnru. E., Ro. J'., and
YboN. B.. Pulmonary scar carcinoma. Cawer. 32. 493-497 (1983).
Bwr. W.J.. and FRAUwem. J.F.. JR.. Passive stnotinj and lung aancer..
J. nar. Cancer Gur.. Tf, 993-1000 (1986):
BRECLaw:,N.E.. and DAY. N,E.. SuvisrioaJ xeelsodr in cancer research..
The anahsis of case-aonrrol sr.idies. L4RC Seiewrific P>iNicwion, 31. pp.
192-246. IARC. Lyon (1980),
CNkutHnnu; P.K.. TnowAs. P.A.. WkuRFa. M.J.. BatELE. H.A.. GurrA.
T:D.. and BeArnE. C.W.. Steroid >ecepors in human lung c.rcer cyto-
sols. Cawer Jtrt.. 16, 327-332 (19B2).
CNEN: T.D.. Micrawtclau test of condensed votatiks of rapeseed oil.
Tirwwr, 1987 (in pras).
CHtNESE ACADEMY OfMEDICAL SCIENCFS . Food cowpositlOq A7Mes. POo-
p,ie's Health Publiihin` Co.. Beijing (1981).
Cot.txrz, G.A.. StAwrsea MJ., and WnLES, W.C., Diet and lung
C2 tWrtWls. Arch. uUrrn.
caattr[ a rtWeY+of tht evidta i~
Med, 147, 157-160 (1991).
DENG. J., aed Gn.o, Y.T.. Prevakm of smoking arrnn~ 110.0f)0 adulh
residents in ShanBhai urban uer. C7lrtsex J: pnetir: Med:. tf, 271-274
(1985).
FeDERAL REatsrt>:. Vol. !1. No. I8. US Governmeen Prinrina Office.
Washin8ton, DC (1983).
FRAUStfnt, J.F.. and MASo++. T.JS. Crmeer mona)iry, uffwna Chinese
Amoticans. 1930-19'69. J. not: Cawcer Inst:. 52, 659-b63 (1974).
GAo;, Y.T.., Cancer incidence in Shanahai' during 1973-77. Naa: Cancer
hsu. Mtusalr.. 62, 43-46 (1982):
GREEn, J.P.. and BRO.wY. P.. Carcinortu of the lung in non-smoa'in`
Chinese women. West. J. Med.t><, 291,294 (1982).

LUNG CANCER IN'CHINESE WOMEN 609
p1.r~ r/ W. CoNES. H,I..~nK A,~ .r ~~~Tubercnlis and l778
ancer ru1: in tnn-snwkini sp.
. Ia8_ I
W.m. M W:., Kot.o~rtt.. L.N.. HANtctx. LH.. 1ad Lt6. I.. Dietary
.aantn A. caroaene. vwmin C and risk of lunj cower in Hawaii: Amer.
! Lprdr'"'td.'. 119. 227-237, (1964).
Ht.m. M' W. STeMMe1tMA.. G.N.. YANG. H.Y:. KaoNn. L-N., aad
Lt i. 1. DdfernKes m hmg cower risk from sawkiat atno.~ Japanese.
(~,nc,e. and Hati+.aiian women in Hawaii. 6u., J. Ca~nrr, 37, 297-30Q
1191t1 t
Wwt. G. 1.Ut.vsAV. 1.. CoPPoCK. E.. asd MnLE7t. A.B., hooisid'
e.p..urc m relation ro cower iacidence and mortal' ~ty m a odson of
wtenvknss p.uems. Mu. J. Ep(deedd.. f, 3QS-312 (1979):
K.. G. Trbercylosis asd ils conuol ia Beijing. OIiR.,wed. J., !4, 6!S-
6a11t1981i
K, ... L C. ikt. J.H. aad L¢e. N.. Anana1ysu of aome risk factors for
h,y ca.m at Hoej Kon;. hu. J. Cawcn, 3S, 149-1SS (1985):
K..,: L C. Lu.. N.. and Ho: )'.. Do cookSnB fuels poae a riak for >MV1
an<n' A cau-caNtol sad} of women iu Hong Kong. EcoJ. Dis.. 2,
:S~-2eSt1983t
Ki K,. 1. Sn K.. and LASt. T.. Lung cower in HM Koe~ Chitkse:
..Wit,, and hts,olopctypes 1973-1982. Brii: J. Cancer, 6Y, 381-388
tw/N,
Lt u. I. rtdi BLoT. W.1.. Assessment of lung cower risk facton by
Ynx*.la cateFor.. J. ear, Cancer Jdst..,73, 383-398 (1984).
Mv 1.U...%. R. D, CorrA.1.. DAY. N.E.. LAw; C.H.. NG: Y:K., ard
S--f-e.TAM, K.. Rtsk factors for lun; cancer in Singapore Chinese.
a prywlsuan .nh hiEh female incidence rates. Inr. J: Cmtcer. 20, 834-
IEUr14771
K.n-u C+.csN Co.-rnoL OFFlCE. Arlas of Cancer Afonnlirn, in dte
"r , RrprAliC of Chtna. China Map Press. Beijing (1980);
N+t t:MIt. Ctsus OFFxE. 10 Percent Sampltn4 Tabularion 08 the 1982
Population Cettsus of the People's Republic of China. China Sutisttca),
PublisM»t8 House. Beijtng (1985),,
OLSsoN: H.. LA!+Dn:-0Lssor:. M.. and Gn.i.aFxa. B.. Retrospective as-
aessment of inensuval cycle length in patients with bre:sr cancer. in
paientc with bsnigo bnrast disease. and in women witlsout:breast dutase.
!: twt. Concer /nu.. 70, 17-21 (1983 ):
Qu. Y.H., Xu, G:X.. HUANG. F., FATw- LC.. and GAO, Y:L. AeAmes
sest on the Ey-produces of the heating of oookinp oils. T.onor. 4, 58-60
(1986):
SNAN6lIA] CANCv . R6GiSfRY. AMIYOI Reporu 011 CatlCer J71(7deNfe and
WOrfdlh': DxR fn. S10/1gIIN (1rb0/( Area, SlYnjhii ~ CGOttr Jnfiitu4e.
sao8haf (19d3).
SNptMAN, B.M., WAS.uce. R.B.. and BeAN. l.A.. CyCIK ovarian func-
tion and brtat cancer. Cancer Res. (Sarppl.l; 42, 3286-3288 (1982).
SaXSLLatro. D.M.. OFPoRD:,K.P.. and MtLLER. R.D.. Higher risk of lung
cancer in chronic obstrssetivepu lmonary disease: a prospecuve matched
controlled smdy. Ahn. inrern: Aled.,. 105, 503-507'(198d).
WArFx+ovss, l.. Mtmt. C:, S+uNMUCAnA'n+ASa. K.. and Powui. 1..
Q'ascer iwcidena fr Jfve caiuiaenrs, Vol: 1V, IAAC. Lyon (1982) ,
WtttrrEwonE, A.S.. Eairnaun~ amibunbk risks from case-control
sad-
ies. Mter. J.,Epidenuol.. 117, 76-85 (1983).
Wv. A.. HENDEtsoN. B.E.. PncF. M.C.. and Yc. M.C.. Smoking and
odier risk faeron for lunt cancer in women, J. ear. Cancen Inn.. 74
747-731(1983).
Zxewo. W.. and GAO. Y.T.. A hapiul-b.sed casc-comrol study on asso-
ttiasion ofsquantous cell carcinoma end adeewcarcisartu with stnokin8.
Tantor.l.l -7 2O(198b).
7mcttx. R.G., MASON. T.I.. SraHAGeN: A.. HoavEa. R.. ScNoeNmG.
I.. GuDt.an. G.. Vmeo. P.W.. and Fa,.uMaNt. I.F:. la.. Caraenoid
iraake, re=etables. and the risk of lung cancer amon8 white men in New
lertey. Amer. J. Epidtntiol:, 123, 1080-1093 (1986).
