Philip Morris
Smoking and Other Risk Factors for Lung Cancer in Women
Fields
- Author
- Henderson, B.E.
- Pike, M.C.
- Wu, A.H.
- Yu, M.C.
- Pike, M.C.
- Type
- PSCI, PUBLICATION SCIENTIFIC
- ABST, ABSTRACT
- BIBL, BIBLIOGRAPHY
- CHAR, CHART, GRAPH, TABLE, MAPS
- ABST, ABSTRACT
- Master ID
- 2023382094/2668
Related Documents:- 2023382094-2668 Ets Issues Binder Ets and Lung Cancer in Nonsmokersvolume I.
- 2023382123-2125 Non-Smoking Wives of Heavy Smokers Have A Higher Risk of Lung Cancer: A Study From Japan
- 2023382127-2137 Cancer Mortality in Nonsmoking Women with Smoking Husbands Based on A Large-Scale Cohort Study in Japan
- 2023382139 Lung Cancer: Causes and Prevention Proceedings of the International Lung Cancer Update Conference, Held in New Orleans, Louisiana, 830303 - 830305
- 2023382140-2160 Lung Cancer in Japan: Effects of Nutrition and Passive Smoking
- 2023382163-2166 Lung Cancer and Passive Smoking
- 2023382168-2169 Lung Cancer and Passive Smoking: Conclusion of Greek Study
- 2023382172-2177 Time Trends in Lung Cancer Mortality Among Nonsmokers and A Note on Passive Smoking
- 2023382180-2183 Lung Cancer in Non-Smokers in Hong Kong
- 2023382186-2188 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer
- 2023382191-2217 Lung Cancer: Causes and Prevention Chapter 7 the Causes of Lung Cancer in Texas
- 2023382220-2230 Ets - Environmental Tobacco Smoke 3.6 the Effect of Environmental Tobacco Smoke in Two Urban Communities in the West of Scotland
- 2023382232-2236 Passive Smoking and Cardiorespiratory Health in A General Population in the West of Scotland
- 2023382239-2246 Lung Cancer in Nonsmokers
- 2023382249-2255 Involuntary Smoking and Lung Cancer: A Case-Control Study
- 2023382258-2281
- 2023382291-2294 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer Among Japanese Women
- 2023382297-2305 Relationship of Passive Smoking to Risk of Lung Cancer and Other Smoking-Associated Diseases
- 2023382308-2318 Risk Factors for Adenocarcinoma of the Lung
- 2023382321-2326 Lung Cancer Among Chinese Women
- 2023382329-2333 Marriage to A Smoker and Lung Cancer Risk
- 2023382336-2343 Measurements of Passive Smoking and Estimates of Lung Cancer Risk Among Non-Smoking Chinese Females
- 2023382346-2351 Smoking, Passive Smoking and Histological Types in Lung Cancer in Hong Kong Chinese Women
- 2023382354-2361 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer in Swedish Women
- 2023382364-2369 Smoking and Health 870000 Proceedings of the 6th World Conference on Smoking and Health, Tokyo 871109 - 871112 on the Relationship Between Smoking and Female Lung Cancer
- 2023382372-2374 Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer in Women
- 2023382377-2385 A Case-Control Study of Lung Cancer in Nonsmoking Women
- 2023382388-2394 Smoking and Passive Smoking in Relation to Lung Cancer in Women
- 2023382397-2401 Lung Cancer and Exposure to Tobacco Smoke in the Household
- 2023382403-2503 Assessment of the Association Between Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer
- 2023382506-2525 Toxicology Forum 900000 Annual Winter Meeting Epidemiologic Studies of the Relationship Between Passive Smoking and Lung Cancer
- 2023382528-2534 Passive Smoking and Diet in the Etiology of Lung Cancer Among Non-Smokers
- 2023382537-2548 Passive Smoking Among Nonsmoking Women and the Relationship Between Indoor Air Pollution and Lung Cancer Incidence - Results of A Multicenter Case Controlled Study
- 2023382551-2556 Lung Cancer Among Women in North-East China
- 2023382559-2564 Smoking and Other Risk Factors for Lung Cancer in Xuanwei, China
- 2023382566-2572 Other Studies Discussing Lung Cancer
- 2023382574-2583 Passive Smoking As A Causative Factor of Lung Cancer in Nonsmoking Women
- 2023382584-2588 Passivrauchen Als Lungenkrebs-Urache Bei Nichtraucherinnen
- 2023382589 Lung Cancer and Passive Smoking
- 2023382591-2602 Passive Smoking in Adulthood and Cancer Risk
- 2023382603-2608 Cancer Risk in Adulthood From Early Life Exposure to Parents' Smoking
- 2023382609-2611 Cumulative Effects of Lifetime Passive Smoking on Cancer Risk
- 2023382612-2613 Lifetime Passive Smoking and Cancer Risk
- 2023382614 Lifetime Passive Smoking and Cancer Risk
- 2023382615-2618 Letters to the Editor 'passive Smoking in Adulthood and Cancer Risk'
- 2023382620-2623 the Relation of Passive Smoking to Lung Cancer
- 2023382625-2631 Respiratory Cancer in A Scottish Industrial Community: A Retrospective Case-Control Study
- 2023382633-2647 Effect of Passive Smoking in Lung Cancer Development in Women in the Nara Region
- 2023382649-2651 Passive Smoking Is A Risk Factor for Lung Cancer in Never Smoking Women in Hong Kong
- 2023382653-2658 Epidemiologic Characteristics and Multiple Risk Factors of Lung Cancer in Taiwan
- 2023382660-2667 the Impact of Passive Smoking: Cancer Deaths Among Nonsmoking Women
- Area
- PARRISH,STEVE/OFFICE
- Named Organization
- American Cancer Society
- Author (Organization)
- Jnci
- Oxford Univ
- Usc, Univ. Of Southern Ca
- Oxford Univ
- Litigation
- Okag/Privilege Withdrawn
- Okag/Produced
- Characteristic
- EXTR, EXTRA
- Site
- N326
- Date Loaded
- 24 May 1999
- UCSF Legacy ID
- ixb02a00
Document Images
Smoking and Other Risk Factors for Lung Cancer In Women ''z
Anna H. Wu, Ph.D., 3 Brian E. Handtrson, M.D., 3 Malcolm C. Pike, Ph.D:, 3.' and Mimi C. Yu, Ph.D.
3'
ABSTRACT-A case-control study among white women in Los
Angeles County was conductisd to investiyate the rote of smoking
and other factors in the etiology of lung cancer in women. A total lof
149 patients with adenocarcinoma (ADC) and 71 patients with
satumous c.U carcinoma (SCC) of the lung and their al and
sex-matched controls were interviewed. Personal ciparena smoking
accounted for almost all of SCC and abouthalf of ADC in tha study
population. Among nonsmokers, slightly elevated relative risk(s)
(RR) for ADC were observed for passive smoke exposure from
spouse(s) (RR=1.2; 45% ' confidence interval (CI)=0.5, 3.3Jiand at
work (RR=1.3;,95% C1=0.5, 3.3). Childhood pneumonia (RR=2.7,
95% C1=1.1. 6.7) and childhood exposure to coal Iburninp (RR=2.3;
95% CI=1.0. 5.5) were additionall risk factors for ADC. For both
ADC and SCC, increased'.risks were associated with decreased
intake of $-urotene foods but not for total preformed'vitamin A
foods and vitamimsupplements.-JNCI 1985; 74:747 751.
Lung cancer is now the fourth most common cancer in
women (1) and has been projecaed to be the leading cause
of cancer mortality among women by the mid-1980's (2):
Causes of lung cancer, other than cigarette smoking (3),
have not been, clearly identified, but associations with
exposure to passive smoking (4-6), exposure to combus-
tion products of heating and cooking fuels (7), and
occupational exposures (8-10), have been suggested. In
addition, lung "scarring" (11) and a low dietary intake of
,6-carotene (12-14) and preformed vitamin A(15-17) may
increase the risk of lung cancer.
This paper reports a case-control study of ADC and
SCC of the lung in white females in Los Angeles County.
Each of the above-mentioned factors was investigated.
METHODS
Female patients diagnosed'with primary ADC or SCC
of the lung were prospectively identified by the CSP, the
population-based tumor registry for Los Angeles County
(18), between April 1, 19811, and August 31, 1982. On the
basis of information collected routinely by the CSP, we
limiledeligibility to white Los Angeles County residents,
with no history of cancer (other than non-melanoma skin
ancer), andd under age 76 at diagnosis; we verified these
variables at interview. We also excluded cases if they were
born outside the United States, Canada, or Europe; were
not English-speaking; or were not residents of Los
Angeles County at the date of diagnosis.
A total of 490 eligible cases were identified. Of these
patients, 190 had died or were too ill to participate by the
time we contacted their attending physician. Permission
was granted to contact 272 of the remaining 300 patients.
Eight patients were not located, and 44 refused to be
interviewed so that we obtained completed question=
naires on 220. On the basis of information on the CSP
abstract, no significant differences were noil between
those interviewed and those not interviewed in terms of
age, marital status, religionand smoking status recorded
on medical records. However, those who were not
interviewe&were more likely to have distant metastases att
the time of diagnosis (58%) compared to those who were
interviewe& (Il%):, Comparable percentages of eligible
SCC (43%) and ADC (46%), patients were interviewed..
We selected one individually matched neighborhood
control for each interviewed case. The control had to
fulfill all the criteria given above for cases (with reference
date taken to be the same as that of the matching case)
and; in addition, was matched with the case on date of
birth (t5 yr of birth date): Our control seltction
algorithm defined a specified sequence of houses to be
visited in the neighborhood where the case lived at date of
diagnosis. Our goal was to interview the firsn eligible
resident in this sequence., If no one was home at the time
of the visit, we left an explanatory letter and made a
follow-up visitt after several days. For any patient, 80
housing units were 'visited and 3 return visits were made
before failure to secure a matched control was conceded.
In 150 instances the first eligible person agreed to
paiticipate, in,55 instances the second eligible control in
the sequence was interviewed, and in 15 instances the
third eligible control was interviewed.
Cases and controls were interviewed on the telephone
with the use of a structured questionnaire designed to
elicit information on personal smoking habits, exposure
to passive tobacco smoke, lung diseases, dietary intake of
vitamin A, types of heating an&cooking fuels ever used,
and reproductive history. We also obtained a lifetime
history of all jobs (job title, activities, and exposure) of at
leaso 6 months' duration.
For childhood passive smoking exposure, we asked
about the smoking habits (i.e., amount and years of
smoking) of father, mother, or other household members
AssREvlAnows VSED: ADC=adenovrdnoma; CI=confidence intenvali
CSP=University of Southern CGlitoania/I,u. Angeles County Cancer
Surveillance Program; RR=relative ruk(s); SCC-.quamous cell ar-
dnoma.
1 Receivcd June 11, 1981: revixed November 28, 1984: accepted!
December 11. 1984.
=5upponed by, gram 5163 from the American Cancer Society,
3Depanment of Family and Preventive Medicine, University, of
Southern California School of Medicine, Pukview Medinl Building B;.
2025 Zonal Ave.. Los Angeles. CA 9Ul)33.
4Present addreu: Imperial CGncer Rewarch Fund's Cancer Epide-
miology Unit, Radcliffe lnfirmary, Otdord' University, Oxford OX2'
6HE. England.
S Wc thank the word-processing pool for preparation of the manu-
saipc.
747
JNCI. VOL 74:..NO..4. APR1L~1985

748 Wu, Henderson, Piktf, and Yu
4
when they lived with the respondent during her child-
hood and teenage years. For passive smoke exposure
during adult life, we asked about the smoking habits of
spouse(s) and other household members when they lived
with the respondent. Passive smoke exposure at work was
assessed only in terms of the average number of hours per
day to which the respondent believed she was exposed at
each job.
The questions on vitamin A intake specifically asked
about average frequencies of consumption of 21 vegeta-
bles and fruits that are high in S-carotene and 7 foods
that connined preformed vitamin A during the calendar
year 3 years before diagnosis of the case (19). Pattern of
use of vitamin supplements was also assessed for the
same period. On the basis of U.S. Department of
Agriculture tables of food values for standard portion size
(common household measure) of each item (20), we
estimated average daily intake of 0-carotene (or vitamin
A) by summing the product of the 0-carotene (or
vitamin A) content of each food item and its reported
frequency of consumption. Quartiles of consumption
were constructed on the basis of the intake pattern of the
220 controls.
All cases were diagnosed microscopically. Their rou-
tine pathology reports were reviewed for mention of lung
scarring.
Statistical analysis was conducted with the use of
multivariate logistic regression methods for individuallyy
matched case-control studies (21). RR were estimated by
odds ratios. A case-control pair was excluded from any
given analysis if the information for either the case or the
control was not known for the relevant variable(s). Since
personal smoking will often; if not always, confound
other associations, RR for other factors were always given
after adjustment was made for personal smoking.
For ADC, RR for certain factors were given separately
for nonsmokers, ex-smokers, and current smokers; this
was not done for SCC because the numbers of non-
smokers and ex-smokers were too few.
RESULTS
We interviewed 149' ADC and 71 SCC cases and their
matched controls. The mean age at diagnosis was 59.7
years for ADC cases and 61.4 years for SCC cases. The
mean ages (at date of diagnosis of the index case) for the
respective control groups were 59.5 and 61.1 years.
Personal cigarette smoking.-For both ADC and' SCC,
rhere was a significant trend in risk aissociated wittv
.
iocreasing number of cigareues smoked per day and with
decreasing age at which smoking began (table II). Both
aspects of smoking remained significant after adjustment
was made for the other.
Passive srnoking.-Families tended to share similar
smoking behavior. Controls whose father, mother. or
spouse(s) smoked were more likely to smoke, to be heavy
smokers, and to stan at a younger, age than controls
whose family members did not smoke. For ADC and
SCC, after adjustment was made for personal smoking
habits, there were no significantly increased risks for
having a mother, a father, or spouse(s) who smoked or for
being exposed at work (table 2).
For nonsmoking ADC cases, we did not observe anyy
elevated risk associated with passive smoke exposure
from either parerlts (RR=0.6; 95% CI=0.2, 1.7), from
spouse(s) (RR=l.2; 95% C1=0.5, 3.3), or at work
(RR=1.3; 95% CI=0.5, 3.3). Increasing RR (RR=1.0,,+
1.2, 2.0) were found with increasing years (0, 1-30, ?31')
oL..passive- smoke 'expostue ~ during"adult Iife froin
}pouse(s) and at work,,6ut the results were not sta-
usucally significant. Since the exposures may have
occurred concurrently, the years of exposure represent
units rather than chronologic time of exposure.
Childhood exposures.-For both ADC and SCC, no
significant association was found with history of htng
diseases (specifically, asthma, bronchitis, pneumonia,
tuberculosis, fungal diseases, emphysema, and lung
abscess) diagnosed by a physician at least 5 years before
diagnosis of the case. When the analysis was restricted to
lung diseases that occurred before age 16 (childhood), a
significantly elevated RR for pneumonia was observed
for ADC after adjustment was made for personal smoking
habits (,RR=2.7; 95% C1=1,1, 6.7); and the RR for SCC
(RR=2.9; 95% CI=0.5, 17.4) was in the same direcuon...
Parental smoking did not explain this effect. Table 3
shows that for ADC, the effect of childhood pneumonia
was most apparent among nonsmoken: Of the 2S
TABLE 1.-Persowal swro+liep Aabife of eases awd towtrole
Smoking status ADC SCC
RR 95% CI Case/eontrol RR 95% CI Case/control
Nonsmoker 1.0 29/62 1.0 2/30
Ex-smoker" 1.2 0.6.2.3 21/37 7.7 0.8.70.3 8/18
rEurrent smoker 4.1" 2.3.7.5 99/50 35.3" 4.7:267.3 61/23
Current smoker. Na ciQaeettes/day N
1-20 2.7 1.4.5.4 38/28 17.7 2.3.138.2 19/14
t21 6.5" 3.1. 13.9 61122 94.4" 9.9, 904.6 42/9 ~
Current smokerr age started to smoke. yr .
>_25 1.1 0.4.3.2 8/14 7.8 0.8. 73.7 6/5 CJ
19-24 2.5 1.0.5.8 22/15 47.1 4.4. 3,98.5 18/7
518 8.0" 3.6. 17.9 69/21 115.7" 9.8. 1371.2 37111 CJ
' Had stopped smoking at least 3 yr before diagnosis year of case.
~ P (linear trend) G001.
JNCI. VOL 74. NO. 4. APRIL 1965 - M'
N
w

i
TABLE 2.-Etposrn to passiror nnokinp ia cwu and eontroia ILunp Cancer In Wonien 749
Smoking ssatu ADC SCC
Adjusted RR' 95% CI Adjusted RIi° 95% CI
Mother smoked 1.7 0.8. 3.5 0.2 0.0, 1.5
Father smoked 1.3 0.7, 2.3 0.9 0.3, 2.9
Spouse(s) smokedM 1.2 0.6.2.5 1.0 0.17:6
Exposure at the workplace 12 0.8. 22 2.3 0.7, 7:9
' Adjusted for number of cigarettes smoked per day and age at starting to smoke.
We eliminated from the analysis 15 pairs of ADC and 4 pairs of SCC in which either the case or
the control was never married.
nonsmoking ADC cases, 8 (28%): gave a history of
childhood' pneumonia.
Elevated RR,- adjusted for personal smoking habits,
were observed for exposure to burning coal used for
heating or cooking in a stove or fireplace during the
majority of childhood and teenage years (ADC: RR=2.3;
95% CI=1.0, 5.5. SCC: RR=1.9; 95% CI=0.5, 6.5): For
ADC, elevated RR were observed in each personal
smoking habit category, (table 3):
TABLE 3.-RR and 95%conlidenee tinterroala oJADC oJW
tanp according to childhood pneu+nonia and coal burninp by
prraoxal nnokinp Aabitr
Exposure
RR (95% CI) amona:
Nonsmoker Ez-smoker Current smoker
Childhood
pnsnrlmnia
No 1.0 1.4 (0.6, 2.4) 5.1(2.5,10:3)
Yes 3.1(1.0, 9:9) 1.5 (02,10.8), 10.9 (2.1, 57:9)
Childhcod coal
burninab
No 1.0 1.6 (0:6. 3.5) 6.3 (3.0,13.3)
Yes 8.2 (0.9.11.8) 4.3 (1.0.17.8), 9.5 (2.1, 41.9)
' Before age 16. The analysis was based on 149 caee-control!psirs
of ADC.
"Includes heating or cooking with coal burned'in a stove or
fireplace during childhood and teenage yesrs. The analysis was
based on 143 cax-control pairs of ADC.
Dietary vitamin A.-Table 4 presents RR for ADC,
adjusted for personal smoking habits, by quartiles of
indices of vitamin A consumption. Because of the smaller
sample size of SCC cases, the indices were dichotomized.
For ADC, a significantly increased risk was observed only
for those in the lowest quartile of 0-carotene consump-
tion (<2,000 IU/day) compared to those in the highest
quartile (>4,000 IU/day), but no appreciably ina^tased'risks were observed for those in the
intermediate groups.
For SCC, an elevated, but not statistically signifinnt. RR
was observed' for women wiCh iB-nrotene intake below
the median: When those in the lowest quartile of A-
arotene consumption, i.e., less than 2,000 IU/day; were
compared to those consuming more than 2.000 IU/day,
the unadjusted RR was increased to 1.7 (from 1.3), but
after adjustment the RR was not greater than compari-
sons above and below the median (both RR=l.5).
There was no association with an index of total
preformed vitamin A (i.e., dairy products, eggs, liver, and
vitamin supplements) for either cell type. However, for
ADC and SCC, an association was observed for dairy
products and eggs (table 4).
Other jactors.-W'e could find no association between
any occupation or occupational category and risk of ADC
or SCC, but there was an excess number of cooks (4 cases
and 2 controls) and beauticians (8 cases and 5 controls)
among nses; both occupations have been suggested in
previous studies. Elevated RR adjusted for personal
TABLE 4.-Dietary intake of )learotsnsc totat prr.Iorvned ritamiw A, and dairy prodticts and eggs
a+nonp cases and eowtrota
A-Carotene
il Total preformed vitamin Ai' Dairy products and egs'
Quart
e
Adjusted Re 96% Cl
Adjusted RR'
96% CI
Adjusted RR'
95% Cl
ADC
1(hish), 1.0 1.0 1.0
2 0.8 0.3,2.0 0.6 0.8,1A 1.7 0.8,3.9 ~,
E 1.3 0.6,27 11 06 26 22 1A,48
4 2.6 1.1,6:7 1.2 0.6.F.8 !.7 1.2,6.8 ~
scC N
W
land2 1.0 1.0 1.0
Sand4 1.5 0.6.3.8 1.0 0.4.2.4 1.6 0.7,&9
. W
~
' Includes 21 vegetables and fruits: leafy )ettvee, other leafy sreen, broccoli, nrrota, tomatoes,
green peas, green beans, lima beans. r J
aspara4ua. summer sqnash, winter squash, sweet potatoes and/or yams. green pepper, red pepper, hot
red chili pepper, nntdoupe.
wuermekm he. nectari and tomato and/or VB 'uice Ansl is was based on 147 pairs of ADC and 68 paits
of SCC
~ apnaob na 1 ri
~
eggs, cheese, butter and/or margarine, cream, milk, b.ef and/or calf l iver. chicken and/or turkey
liver, and vitamin supplements.
~Includa
'Analysis was based an 147 pairs of ADC and 71 pairs of SCC,
d i
~
Adjusted for number of ciaarettes smoked per day.
JNQ. VOL 74, NO. 4. AlRn. 19s5

TSO W'u, H.nd.rsart, Plk., and Yu
smoking habits were observed for a history of hysterec-
torny (RR=l.7; 95% CI=0.9, 3.2) and nulliparity
(RR=L7; 95% CI=0.8, 3.7) among ADC cases and a
history of miscarriage (1R.R=1.5; 95%CI=0.5, 4.9yamong
SCC cases.
Multiple logistic regression analysis was condutted to
'assess the possible confounding effects of personal
smoking habits, childhood pneumonia, childhood coal
burning, and P-carotene intake. The results were similar
to those when each factor was adjusted for personal
smoking habits alone.
DISCUSSION
This case-control' study examined risk factors for the
two main cell types of lung cancer in women-ADC and
SCC. Although histologic typing was done by the
individual pathologist at each participating hospital,
studies comparing interobserver and intraobserver varia-
bility in cliassification of lung cell types reported a high
concordance rate for cell types other than large cell
carcinoma, which was excluded in this study (22, 23).
In this study population, about half of ADC and alntost `
all of SCC can be attributed to personal smoking habits; _
the amount smoked and the age at which smoking began
were strong determinants of risk of disease. However,
there are marked' differences in the strength of association
between smoking and cell type of lung cancer, as has
been noted previously (21, 2S).
The role of passive smoking in the etiology of ADC
among nonsmokers is not clear. Our data are not
consistent with the findings with regard to nonsmokers
obtained by Hirayama (4) and Trichopoulos et al. (5)
who reported a twofold to threefold increased risk due to
passive smoking. However, the histology of the cases in
these studies is not clear, and their data suggest that any
effect of passive smoking is larger for SCC cases (3, 6), Of
our 29 nonsmoking ADCtxses, 12 were bronchoalveolar
cell carcinomas, and this cell type is specifically men-
tioned by Correa et al. (6) to have a weaker association
with passive smoking. The effect of passive smoking by
cell type of lung cancer needs to be investigated f urther in
studies with much: larger numbers of nonsmokers.
Childhood lung disease may have a role in lung cancer
etiology: Certain features of the lung of a child (e.g.,
susceptibility to airway closure and high peripheral
resistance) might make it more vulnerable to residual
abnormalities from respiratory illness (26). This notion
is supported by observations that both smokers and
nonsmokers with childhood respiratory diseases have
impaired lung function capacity, that their rate of decline
in ventilatory function capacity with age is more rapid
than that in individuals without childhood respiratory
problems, and that they have higher rates of clinical~
diagnosis of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (27,
28). Women with childhood respiratory probltrms may
have incurred epithelial damage to the airway resulting
in airway hypenrcactivity and are more susceptible to
other insults to the lung. We cannot rule out the
possibility of a chance finding or of preferential recall of
JNCt. VOL 74, NO. 4: AMUL I995
childhood pneumonia by cases. However, our data
appear to be internally consistent, since we found a
significantly higher frequency of' lung scarring men-
tioned in the pathology reports among cases with
previous childhood pneumonia (12/30=40%) compared
to those without (39/1'89=2i%):
The association of lung cancer risk with exposure to
coal heating or cooking warrants further investigation.
Although coal was identified as the major heating or
cooking fuel used' during childhood and; teenage years off
a significantly higher proportion of cases, we did noi
have detailed information on the years of use. Excess risk<
of lung cancer have been reported for coke oven workers
(29, 30) and British gas workers (31) who were heavih
exposed to products of coal : carbonization.
Studies of men suggest that their lung cancer risk i~
lowered by greater dietary P-carotene (12-1'!, 32, 33) ane
vitamin A intake (15, 17, 32; 33), but the evidence fo:
women is less clear (12, 13, 32, 33). We observed i
significantly increased risk for ADC with the lowest leve
of $-carotene consumption and a similar association fo.
SCC These results are consistent with findings fo
females in Singapore (d2) and in Japan (13), but they ar
not supportive of data for females in Hawaii (32) anc
England (33). Our observation of no association with at
index of total preformed vitamin A(i.e., dairy products
eggs, liver, and vitamin supplements) and no associatiot
with total vitamin A intake (preformed vitamin A ant
$-carotene-data not shown due to domination b
preformed vitamin A) is consistent with findings fo
females in Hawaii (32). Conflicting findings have ben
reported for subgroups of preformed vitamin A foods an
supplements. A higher consumption of liver and vitami:
supplements has been reported' previously for fernal
cases as compared to controls, but the opposite result
have been observed for males (33, 34). Our data shoa
no case-control difference in the intake pattern c
vitamin supplements and a higher consumption of live
among cases. Our finding of an elevated lung cancer ris
associated with low levels of intake of dairy products hz
not been reported for females, although similar resul
have been observed for males (15-17). Our results on tF.
role of P-carotene and preformed vitamin A were sirnih
for ADC and SCC. despite suggestions that vitamin A(c
P-carotene)is more strongly protective against SCC tha
against ADC (17):
Initial reports of an inverse relationship between bloc
retinol levels andaubsequent risk of cancer at all sites (3
36) have not been supported by recent studies (37, 36
This situation emphasizes the need to reexamine even tl
consistently observed association of vitamin A (or
,
carotene) intake with male lung cancer.
Possible sources of bias in our data must be considere
Both lung cancer cases and controls were derived fro
population-based samples. However, because this disea
is debilitating and rapidly, fatal 190 patients had died
were too ill to participate by the time of initial contw~
We did not conduct proxy interviews because questio
on childhood exposures and dietary history could not
assessed adequately. As expected, the group who was n
~o~338228'7

0
inten'iewed was mote likely to have metastatic disease at
diagnosis but was similar in all demographic variables
measured. In addititsn, information abstracted' from
medical records showed similar smoking status for those
interviewed and those not interviewed. If cases who were
not iinteniewed because of' poor survival, differed from
those who survivect longer and were interviewed in terms
of the other risk factors under ;tudy, this could have
' biased our results. However, this appears unlikely since
our data showed that histories of childtiood' pneumonia
and exposure to coal fires were similar among cases
regardless of stage of disease at diagnosis. There is also no
evidence that cancer survival is associated with dietaryy
vitamin A intake.
The etiology of SCC can be explained almost enurelyy
by cigarette smoking. Cigarette smoking, however, ex-
plaiits only about half of the ADC cases. On the basis of
this study, childhood' lung disease and exposure to coal
fires in childhood explain at least another 22% of ADC
cases. Passive smoking and vitamin A may be involved,
but more research is needed to clarify their roles in lung
cancer etlol,ogy:.
REFERENCES
(1) SILVERtERG E:,Cancer statistics, 1982. CA 1982 32:15-31,.
(2) HENDERSON BE. Descriptive epidrmiologyy andd geographic
pRthology. In: Burchenal JH. Oettgen HF eds. Cancer
achievements, challenges and prospecu for the 1980's. Vol 1.,
New York: Grune. 1981:51-69.
(d) U.S. Public Health Service. The health consequences of smoking:.
Cancer. Washington DC: U.S. Govt Print Off, 1982 [DHEW'
publication No. (PHS)82-50179).
(,I) HttuYAStA T. Non-smoking wives of heavy smokers have a higher
risk of lung cancer: A study from Japan. Br Med, J 1981;
282:183-185.
(5) , Ta1QHOtOULOs D, KALANDIDI A. . SrARR05L, M.ACMAHOtC, B.
Lung cancer and passive smoking. Int J Cancer 1981; 27:1'-4.
'/6). CORREA. P. PICK12 LW, FOh'THAM E. L1N Y,.HAENSZEL W. Passive
smoking and lung cancer. Laneet 1983; ,2:595-597:
(i.)' Xu ZY. XtAO HP. Li G. Air pollution and lung cancer in
Lisoning Province. Nat1 Cancen lnst Monogr. In press.
(8)BRESLOw L,. HoAGUN.L,. RASMUSSEN '('i. AlRAMS HK.Occupa-
tions and cigarette smoking as risk factors in lung cancer. Am J
Public Health 1954: 44:1'71'-181.
(9)'. WYNDER EL, BERG JW. CJnetr of the lung arrl0rfg r10f1-mlOk.lri-
t special reference to histologic pauerns.. Cancer 1967:
' Z0:9161-1172.
I 110) MENct HR, PtstE MC, HENDERSON BE, JtNG JS: Lung cancer risk
( among beauticians and other femak worke»: drieJ consnsMnic.-
tion. J Natl Cancer hnst 1977: 39:142l-142S.
t(1'1) AvERtuM O, GARmNaEL L. PARRS VR. Sor cancer of the lung-
iiseease over a 21 year period Cancer 1979; 43:636-642:
t(12). MACLENNAN R. DA C06TA J, DAy NE. LAw CH., Ne YK. SHAN
: MUGARATNAM IL Riskfjttork for lung nncerr in Singapore
Chinese, a population with high female incadena rates. Int J
Cancer 1977; 20:SS4-860.
113) HtRAYAMA T. Diet and cancer. Nutr CGnce 1979; 1:67-811
(!+) SHERELLE RBLErrER M. L1u S, et a1: Dietary vitamin A and risk
Lung Cancer In Women 751
ofl cancer in the Western Electric study. Lancet 1981; 2:
1185-1190.
(15) BIELrcE E. Dieury vitamin A and human lung ancer. Int JlGncer
1975,15561,565.
(16) M.ETTLIN.C, GRAHAM S, SMANSOK M~:..Viumin A and lungnncer..
JNCI 1979;, 62i 1435-1438.
(17) KtALE G. BJEt.RE E. GART JJ. Dieury, habits and lung nncerrisk.,
Int J Cancer 1983; 31:397-405,
(18/ MAc.t. TM. Cancer Surveillance Program in Los Angeles County.
Nail Cancer lnst Monogr 1977; 47:99=101.
(14). GRAHAM S,.METTUN C. Fiber andother.corlstituentL of vegC:'tabltsin cancer epidemiology. 1!n:
Newell GR, Ellison NM', eds.
Nutrition and cancer etiology and treatrnenL New York: Raven
Press, 1981:189=215..
(20) ADAMS C. Nutritive value of American foods in eommon units
U.S. Departmenrof Agriculture Handbook No. 456. Washing-
ton, DC: U.S. Depanmenrof Agriculture, 1975.
(21) BaEtit.ow' NE. DAY NE. Statistical Imethods in oncer research: Vol
I-The analysis of case-control studies. IARC Sci Publ 1980;
32:5-338:
(22)I YESNER.. R_ GERST B, AL'ERBACH O. Application of the World
Health Organiration classification of lung carcinoma to biopsy
muerial. Ann Thorac Surg 1965; It33-49.
(23) YESNER R, CARTER D. Pathology of carcinoma o('the lung. Clin
Chest Med 1982; 3:257-289.
(2I) DOLL R, HILL AB. KREYaER6 L Thrsignificance of cellltype in
relation to the aetiology, of lung cancer. Br J Cancer 1957;
11:43-4B:
(2S) WYNnER EL, CorEYLS, MASUCHt K. Lung cancerr in women:
Present and future trends. J Nail Cancer Inst 1973; 51:391-401.
(26) KArrAN M. Long-term sequel0e of,respiratory illness in infancry,
and childhood. Pediatr C1in North Am 1979; 26:525-535.
(27) Buaaows B, KNUtnoN RJ, LEt,owrrt MD. The relationships of'
childhood respiratory'il lness to adult obstructive airway disease.
Am Rev Respir Dis 1977; 115:751-759.
(28) SAMET JM; TAGER IB SPEtgR FE. The relationship between
rcspiratory illhess in childhood and chronic airflow obstruction
in adulthoodj Am Rev Respir Dis 1983; 127:508-523.
(z9), REDMOND CK, GOCCO A, LLOYD JW, RUSH'HW;. Long-term
mortality study of steel workers. VI. Mortality from malignant
neoplasms among coke oven workers. JI Occup Med 1972.
14:621-629:
(30) LLOYD JW: Longterrn mortality study of steelworkers. V.
Respiratory cancer in coke plant workers. J'Occup Med 1971:
.
13:53-68.
(31) DoLL R, FIxHER EJ, GAMMON W. et al. Mortality of gasworkers
w ith special reference to o ncen ot the iung and blsdtltr, chronic
bronchitis, and'pneumoconiosis. Br J lnd Med 1965; 22:1-12.
(32) HINns MW. Kot.oNEL LN. HANRw JH. Dietary vitamin A.
carotene, vitamin C and risk of lung cancer in H'awaii. Am J
Epidemiol 1984; ,I 19:227-237:.
(3)) GREcoa A. LEE PN; ROE FJ, WttsoN MJ, MELTON A. Compari-
son of dietary histories in lung cancer cases and controls with
specialirrferrnce to vitamin A. Nutr Cancer 1980; 2:93-97.
(34) SMtTit PG, Jtot H. Cancers among users of preprratioeu oostuin-
ing vitaminA CGncer 1978;,42:808-811.
(35) [ARR JD,SMmi AH, SwtTSEa BR, HAMES CG. Serum vitamin A
(rxinol) and cancer incidence in Evans County, Gewgia. JNCI
1981;',66:7-16.
(36) WALD N, IDLE M. BOREHAM J. Low serum vitamin A and aubfe-
quentriak of cancer. Lancrt 1980; 2:813-815.
(37) WtLLErr WC, PoLtt BF, UNDUtwooD BA, et al. Relation of serum
vitamin A and E and carotenoids to thrrisk of cancer. N Eng) J
Med 1984;310:430-434.
()8). STAHEUN HB, BVESSE, ROSEL F. WIDMER LK, BRAlAQ1ER B.
Vitamin A, cardiovascular risk tacton, and morulity. hncrt
1982; 1:394-395.
JNCI. VOL 74. NO. 4. APR1L 1985
