Philip Morris
the Role of Volatile and Nonvolatile N-Nitrosamines in Tobacco Carcinogenesis
Fields
- Author
- Chen, C.B.
- Hecht, S.S.
- Hoffmann, D.
- Hecht, S.S.
- Type
- PSCI, PUBLICATION SCIENTIFIC
- BIBL, BIBLIOGRAPHY
- CHAR, CHART, GRAPH, TABLE, MAPS
- DRAW, DRAWING
- BIBL, BIBLIOGRAPHY
- Site
- R107
- Document File
- 2021604909/2021605106/Dietrich Hoffmann Papers
- 2021604910/2021605105/Dietrich Hoffmann Papers
- Request
- Stmn/R1-078
- Author (Organization)
- Ahf, American Health Foundation
- Banbury Report 3 A Safe Cigarette
- Characteristic
- MARG, MARGINALIA
- Litigation
- Stmn/Produced
- Area
- CENTRAL FILES/PRE-DB WAREHOUSE
- Date Loaded
- 05 Jun 1998
- UCSF Legacy ID
- xvf58e00
Document Images
122! D. Hoffmannl C.B. Chen, and,S:S. Heoht
the methylaarboniumi ion may be responsible for the occurrence of liver, tumors.
Currently; we are studying this concept with, ["4C]NNQC Iabeled, at the methyl
group or at the carbonyl gnoup..
In addition to «-hydroxylation, we detected other metabolites of NNN that
are )3-hydroxylated. Pyridine-N-oxides were also identified as metabolites of
both NNN' and NNK. At present, we are detenmining, the biological signifi-
cance of these N-oxides in bioassays. Furthermore, we are exploring methods
of chemoprevention by inhibiting, metabolic activation of tobacco carcinogens
and'by increasing the :detoxificatiom
TOBACCO-SPECIFI6!N-MITROSA'MINES IN THE SAL'IVA OF'TO'BACCIO
CHEWERS
The study of the metabolic activation of the tobacco~specific carcinogens is na
merely of acadenua interest to us. It gives us the opportunity to examine fluids
of smokers and chewers for metabolites of NNN and NNK and, thus, too
evaluate whether the metabolism of these carcinogens in man is similar to that
in theexperi'mentale animal. ft is also important to, explore why the degree ofmetabol'ic activation
of these tobacco carcinogens differs widely in individual
chewers and smokers.
In vitro experiments have shown tha N-nitrosamines can be formed from
the : tobacco alkaloids by incubation of snuff wit'h~ saliva (Hecht et al'. 19°75). We
therefore investigated'tihis phenomenon in tobacco chewers and& smokers. In a
preliminary study, we were also able to show that concentrations of nonvolatile
N-nitrosamines in the saliiva of individual tobacco chewers vary signifiaantNy.
This supports the concept that in vivo nitrosation of the tobacco: alkaloids is
involved in the formation of these nitrosamines; We have initiated a large-scale
controtledl study on the formation ofINNN, NNK, and NAtB in the oral cavityofl chewers and smokers,
including analysis of saliva for metabolites of NNN
and NNK.,
SUMMARY
Chemical-analyt'ical studies have shown that tobacco smoke contains small
amounts of volatile N-nitrosamines. In the mainstream smoke of' ai cigarette,
theseearcinogenscan be reduced significantly by utilization of tobacco lonvin
nitrate content and especially by filtration through cellulose acetate filter tipsthat~ selectively
, retain volatile: N-nitrosamines.
Cured and fermented tobacco and tobacebsmoke contain three majQr
nonvolatile N-nitrosamines. These:are formed from nicotine, nornicotiine, and
anatabine. In mice, rats, and Syrian golden hamsters, NNN' and NNIfK are
proven carcinogens. They are organ-specific carcinogens, burtmay also be
contact carcinogens. NIAtB', the third identified totiacconitrosamine, is cuo-
rentlybe:ing bi~~oassaye~d, for its carcinogenic activity.
:<x>SSss ~ is.{it~ti9a~"'

Nitrosamines in Tobacco Products /123
~;~t!$?dtSt#~3y3Y?iif f~3'r?t h'~ii' ~3?i
NNN and NNK are metabolically activated by a-hydroxylation. The
a-hydroxynitrosamines are unstable and decompose with formation of car-
bonium ions, the probable ultimate carcinogenic form of these tiobacco,speci'fic
compounds. N-nitrosation of the alkaloids occurs during the processing of
tobacco and ditring, smoking, but may also take place in vivo. This has been
demonstrated by evidence for the formation of NNN, NNK and NAtB' during
tobacco chewing,. Detailed studies on the in, vivo formation of these tobacco
carcinogens in chewers and smokers has begun. These studies will be folltnwed
by the development of methods that inhibit the formation of these compounds.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Our studies are supported, in part, by Public Health Service contract NO
1-CP' 55666 and by grant CA-21393 from the Divisioni of Cancer Cause and
Prevention of the National Cancer Institute andl by American! Cancer Society
research grant BC-56. S. S. H. is a recipient of National Cancer Institute
research career development awardl 5K04CA00124. C. B. C. is recipient of
National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences development award no:
ESO12236.
REFERENCES
Boyland, E., F.J.C. Roe, and J.W. Gortod. 1964. [nductioni of pulmonary tumors in
mice by nitrosonornicotine, a possible constituent! of tobacco smoke. Nature
2a2:111z6_
Brunnemann, K.D. and D. Hoffmann. 197$' Analysis of volatile nitrosamines in
tobacco smoke and polluted'indoor environments. /nt: Agency Sci. Publ. 9:3431
Brunnemann K.D., L. Yu, and D. Hoffmann. 11977 Assessment of carcinogenic
volatdlo N=nitrosamines in tobacco and in mainstreamiand sidestream smoke from
cigarettes. CancerRes., 37:3218.
Chen, B.C., SS. Hecht, and D! Hoffmann. 1978. Metabolic a-hydroxylatiorr of the
tobacco-specific N-nitrosonornicotine. Cancer Res. 36:3639.
ChenB.C., S.S. Hecht, R. Young, T. Ohmori, and D: Hoffmann 1979. Comparative
carcinogenicity and metabolism of the tobacco-specific caricinogens, NNN and
NNK. Pkoc. Am. Assoc. Cancer Res. 20:81.
Dtuckrey, H. and R. Preussmann. 1'962. Zur Entstehung karzinogener N8trosamine am
Beispielldes Tabakrauches. Naturwissenschaften 49:498.
Enzell, C.R., I. Wahlberg, and AS. Aasen. 1977. lsoprenoids and alkaloids of
tobacco. Fortschr. Chem, Org. Naturst: 34:1.
Fine, D.H., F. Rufeh, D. Lieb, and D.P. Rbunbehlcr. 1975. Description of the
thermad energy analyzer (TEA)fartrace determination of volatile and narnvolatileN-nitroso compounds.
AhaP. Chem. 47c l L88.
Hecht, S.S., R.M. Ornaf, and D. Hoflfmann. 1975. N-nitrosonornicotine in tobacco;
analysis of possible contributing factors andlbioloQic implications.1. Natl. Cancer
Liant. 54i 12-37:
Hechti, S.S., 1. Schmeltz, andl D; Hoffmann. 1977. Ni'trogenouscompounds in cigarette
smoke and their precursors. Recent Adt'. Tobacco Sd,. 3:59!
vrr ~ fa:t.i~ii?! "i i~,i::}t;

1'24l D. Hoffmann, C.B. Chen, and S.S. Hecht
li.'tisfirt~t?~slt3}i;?i~ s~n, rY;~
Hecht, S.S., C:B. Chen, and D! Hoffmann. 1979. Tobacco-specific nitrosamines:
Occurrence, formation, carcinogenicity and metabolism. Acc. Chem, Res. 12:92'.
Hecht, S.S., C.B: Chen,, T. Ohmori, andl D. Hoffmann. 1!980. Comparative carcino-
genicity in F~34k1 rats of the tobacco-specific nittnsamines N'-nitrosonomicotine
and 4-(iN-methyl-N-nitrosamino)-1-(3-pyridyl)-1-butanone. Cancer Res, (in
press):
Hecht, S,S:,, C.B:. Chen, R.M. Ornaf, E. Jacobs, J.D. Adams, and' D: Hbffmanm
1978a. Reaction of nicotine and sodium initrite: Formation,of' nitrosamines and
fragmentation of the pyrrplidine ring. J. Org. Chem. 43:72.
Hecht, S'.S., C.B. Chen, N. Hirota, R.M. Onnaf; T.C. Tso, and!D, Hoffmann. 1978b
Tobacoo>specific nitrosamines: Formation from nicotine in vitro and during to-
bacco curing and1 carcinogenicity in1 strain A mice. J. Natl: Cancer Inst. 60:819.
Hilfiich J., S.S, Hecht,, and D. Hbffimann. 1977. Effects of N'-nittosonornicotine and
N'-nitrosoanabasine in Syrian golden hamsters. Cancer Lett,. 2:1169.
Hoffrnann, D., 0. Dong, andl S:S'. Hecht. 1977. Origin in tobacco smoke of N'-
nitrosonornicotinea tobacco-specific carcinogen. J. Nat1: Cancer Ivrsr. 58i l'84L.
Hoffmann, D., S.S. Hecht, R.M. Ornaf, and E:L. Wynderi. 1'976; N'-nitrosonor-
nicotine in tobacco: Formation and careinogenicity. Intern. Agency Sci: Publ..
14:307.
Hoffmann, D:,, 1 Schmeltz, S.S~: Hecht, and E.L. Wynder. 1978. Tobacco car-
cinogenesis. In Polycyclic hydrocarbons and cancer (ed. H. V. Gelboin and
P. O. P. Ts'o),, vol. 1, p:85 L Academic Pness, New York.
Hoffmann, D., R. Raineri, S.SI Hecht, R. Maronpot, and E.L. Wynder: 1975. Effects
of N'-nitrosonomicotine and N'-nitrosoanabasine in rats. J. Natl. Cancer Inst:
55:977:
Hoffmann, D., J.C. Adams, K.D. Brunnemann, and S.S. Hecht. 1979. Assessment of
tobacco-specific N-nirtrosamines in tobacco products. Cancer Res. 39:2505.
Jasko, W.J. 1'979! Influence of' cigarette smoking, on drug metabolism in man. Drug
Metab. Rev: 9:22.
Magee, P.N., R'. Mbntesano, and R. Preussmann. 1'976: N-Nitroso compounds and
related carcinogens. Avn: Chem. Soc. Monogr. 173:491.
Royal College of: Physicians. 1977. Smoking and h'ealth. Pitman Medical Publishing
Co., Ltd., London.
Public Health Service 1979. , SSmoking and, health: A report to the Surgeon GeneraL
DHEW publication number 79-50066. Government Printing Office; Washington,
ID.C:
Schmeltz, I: and D. Hoffmann. 1977. Nitrogen-containing compounds in,tobacco and
tobacco smoke. Chem: Rev. 71:295.
Singer, G,.[vt. and H.W. Taylor. 1976. Carcinogenicity of N'-nitrosonomicotine in
Snrasue-Dawley rats: J. NatL Cancer Inst. 57:1275.
Wynder; E. L. and L.J: Bross. 19611. A study of etiological factors in cancer of the
esophagus. Cancer 14:385:
Wynder, E:,L. and R. Goldsmith. 1977. The epidemiology of bladder cancer. A second''
look. Cancer 40:1246.
Wynderi, E.L., I.J. Bross, and K.ML Feldman., 1957. A: study, of etiological factors in
cancer ofl the mouth. Cancer 10:13I00,
Wynderi, E. L.:, K. Mabuchi, N. MaruQhi, and J. G. Fortner. 19731 Epidemiology of cancer of the
pancreas: J: Nat. Cancer Inst. 50:50.

Nitrosamines in Tobacco Productsl125
CO'MMEN1rS'
GORi: Have you foundi any compounds that may be inhibitory of the car-
cinogenic activity of nitrosamines?
HOFFMANN: We have no data on the in vivo inhibition of the formation of
tobacco-specific N-nitrosamines. We have found the opposite. This aspect
was already suggested by Boyland et al. (19Cn4) many years ago. Thiocyan+
ate catalytically increases,tihe in vivo nitrosamine formationiduring chewing
andl smoking. We found the thiocyanate concentration in the saliva, to be
correlated witbi the q}iantity of tobacco smoked. This was expected, since
thiocyanate is the major detoxification product of' HCN, a major smoke
constituentL
As discussed before, N-nitrosamines are procarcinogens and, thus, they
have to be activatedl metabolically. Thus far our bioassay data are not
completed, however, in vitro studies by Chen and Hiecht'. (1978) from our
group have shown t'hatone can inhibit the metabolic activation of
N-nitrosonornicotine.
The best approach towards reduction of the nitrosamines in smoke wouldd
obviously be to use low-nitrate tobacco. However, when, we reduce the
nitrate content of tobacco, we have increased formation of carcinogenic
polycyclic hydrocarbons. At this moment we regard selective filtration as
the best approach towards reducing volatile and tobacco-specific N-
nitrosarnines in the smoke.
WYNDER 11 wonder whether you could comment on those experiments which
again support our interplay between epidemiological observation and ex-
perimental stWdies. Hurnandatalhave shown that high alcohol consumption
increases the risk of cancer of the esophagus, and the experimental work
done at our institute by McCoy et al. (1i979) showed that the metabolicc
activation of nit'rosamines via a-hydroxylation is increasedL
HOFFMANN: Yes, one of our studies has shown that Syrian golden hamsters
maintainedion anialcoholic diet had increased a-hydroxylatiionin the liver
and cheek pouch of N-nirtrosonornicotine, compared to the a-hydroxylation
occurring,inthe same organs of hamsters oni a standard diet.
Human studies, especially in France and the U.S., have documented that
drinking, in additioni to smoking, increases the risk for cancer of the
esophagus andloral cavity over that for nondrinking,smokers (Tuyns 1970;
Kissin et al, 1973; Wynder et all 1977). Therefore, model studies with the
Syrianigolden hamster were: initiated limourinstitute. As mentfioned before,
Dr. McCoyhasshown~that whenihamsters, wereonanalcoholicdiet,,themetabolic activation of the
carcinogenic nitrosamines was significantly
increased in both the liver and the hamster pouch.
We have an ongoing experiment in which: weapplytobacco-s~pecificn'itrosamines by swab
totheoratcavity;of hamsters. Onegpoup of hamsters
i,

1261 @. FHoffmann, C.B. Chen, and S:S, Mecht
1 i~ll~t~4iitn~s?fti?!?£ it~'r=S 3'~?1i1 ° > ~~.~;'
is on ainormal dietand the second group on an alcoholic diet. The technique
of painting the hamster pouch is relatively simple and by simple manipuba-
tionione can readily observe the treated tissue.
There is no questioni that! alcohol andl nitrosamine together induce more
tumors ini the hamster pouch than the nitrosamine in conjunction with the
standkrd alcohol-free diet. At present, however, these results arebasedlon
macroscopic observations only. Upon histopathological confirmationof the
macroscopic observation, we expect this study to fully support the
epidemiological data, namely that smoking andldrinking together represent a
high risk for cancer of'the oral cavity and esophagus.
BATTISTA: Over the years we have been talking about nitrates; an increase in,
nitrates results in the decrease of the carcinogenicity of tobacco smoke
(when applied to the skin): You were finding that increasing the level of
nitrate increases the nitrosamine levels, which one wouldI expect, to give a
higher incidence ofl cancer.
Now, in none of the data presented here have we looked directly at effects
of nitrosamines in smoke on the lung. We apparently have two diametrically
opposite effects to nitrate. Would you like to clarify this point?'
Hio,FFMAIwN: Nios we: have done it. I'have not ment'ionedI it because of our time
limits today. We have painted NNN together withitobacco tar on the skin of
mice. This resulted in an increase of lung adenomasbut not of skin tumors,,
again suggesting that N-nitrosamines are organ-specific carcinogens. Obvi'-
ously, one goal in tobaccocarcinogenesis is to develop low-tar, low niicotine
cigarettes. Tobacco which is high in nittatehas increased combustibility andl
the nitrogen oxides generated from, the nitrate dL+ring smoking serve as
scavengers of C,H-radicals and thus, inhibit the pyrosynthesis of the
carcinogenic pollycyclic hydrocarbons. This is, of course, desirable since
reductionof polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in the smoke leads to reduced
tumorigenic activity as measured on mouseskim Inhalation experiments
with hamsters by Dontenwill et al. (1973) have shown; thatsrnoke fromnitrate-rich cigarette tobaccos
is also less, tumorigeniic i~nthe larynx. Thus,
we believe that the use :of nitrate-rich tobacco has been and is a step forward
inithe directioniof the less harmful cigarette. What we have to try now is to
reduce the nitrosamines in the smoke of these cigarettes. In the case of the
volatile nitrosamines, this has already been accomplished in the smoke of
U.S. cigarettes.
Ninety percent of all U.S. cigarettes have celQuloseaaetate filter tips.
These are capable ofseiecti'velyrernovingt'~he volatile nitrosamines in the
smoke up to: 85%. In that respect there wouldl be two ways to reducetobaeco-specific carcinoge~ns~
First! is selective fiiltratiion, and preliminary
data in this area appear quite promising. A second approach would be to
keep:the alkaloids low in the tobacco, because without the alkaloids, these
nitrosamines cannot be formedl. That is why we are very much opposed to
hssk`s:

Mitrosamines in Tobacco Products / 127
the introduction of low-tarhigh-niicotine cigarettes. One thing we are sure
of is when you have a high alkaloid content in tobacco, youi have : a high
yield ofl tobacco-specific carcinogens in the tobacco and in the smoke. Thus,
the suggcstion;of low-tar, high-nicotine cigarettes as discussed inithe United
Kingdom,, is counterproductive because the higher levels of nicotine in the
smoke will continue to support habituation of smokers and will also result in
higher nitrosamine content ofthesrnoke, unless methods for their selective
filtration are found.
References
Bioyland'4 E., F.J.C. Roe, and J.W. Gorrod. 1'964. Inductionof pulmonary tumors in mice
by nitrosonornicotine, a possible constituent of tobacco smoke. Nature 202:1126.
Chen, B.C:, S.S. Hecht, and D. Hoflfrttann. 1978. Metabolic a-hydroxylationi of the
tobacco-specific N'-nitrosonomicotine. Cancer Res. 36:3639:
Dontenwill, W., H. Chevalier, H. Harke, U. Lafrenz, G'. Reckzeh, and B. Schreider.
1973. Investigatinnion the effects of chronic cigarette-smoke inhalation in Syrian
golden hamsters. J. Natl: Cancer Inst. 51i:17$'1.
Kissins B., M.M. Kaley, W.H. Su, and R. Lermer: 1!973. Head and neck cancer ini
alcoholics. The relationshipof drinking, smoking and dietary patterns. J. Am. Med.
Assoc. 224:1174,
McCoy, G.D., C-h. B. Chens S:S: Hecht, and E.C. McCoy. 1979. Enhancement of
metabolismiand mutagenesis of nitrosopyrrolidine in liver fractions isolated from
chronic ethanol-consuming hamsters. Cancer Res. 39:793.
Tuyns, A.J. 1'970. Cancer of the esophagus. Further evidence of the relation of drinking
habits inFrance. Intl. J. Cancer 5: 1I52'.
Wynder, E. L. ,, IVI_ Mushinski, and J,C. Spivak. 1977. Tobacco and alcohol consumption
in relationito the development of multiple primary cancers. Cancer 40:1872.
ki<.uxN>oooSka ~~;p~,ysyM.+
