Philip Morris
Smoking Controversy
Fields
- Author
- Carter, T.L.
- Area
- LEGAL DEPT/CARLSTADT QRSA
- Type
- PUBL, OTHER PUBLICATION
- Site
- N28
- Request
- Stmn/R1-004
- Stmn/R1-039
- Stmn/R1-053
- Stmn/R1-133
- Stmn/R1-039
- Named Organization
- American Cancer Society
- College of American Pathologists
- St Joseph Hospital
- College of American Pathologists
- Named Person
- Buhler, V.
- Carter, T.L.
- Document File
- 1005091663/1005091855/703 Position Papers. Bw 971
- Litigation
- Stmn/Produced
- Author (Organization)
- Congressional Record
- Master ID
- 1005091669/1855
Related Documents:- 1005091669-1855 'smoking Dogs' -- Case History of An Attack on Advertising That Failed
- 1005091676 the Truth Seems A Little Twisted
- 1005091677 'all Advertising Should Be Truthful'
- 1005091678 the Voice of the Advertiser Cancer Society, Heart Assn., Admen Voice Opinions About Aa 'honesty in Anti- Smoking Ads' Editorial
- 1005091679-1683 Backgrounder 'the Effects of Cigarette Smoking Upon Dogs'
- 1005091684-1685 12 Dogs Develop Lung Cancer in Group of 86 Taught to Smoke
- 1005091686 Smoking and Cancer
- 1005091687
- 1005091688
- 1005091689-1690 Last Gasp for Cigarettes?
- 1005091691
- 1005091693
- 1005091694 Tony 'iq' Curtis Pays $120 Pot Fine in London
- 1005091695
- 1005091696
- 1005091697-1711 Remarks of Joseph F, Cullman 3rd Chairman of the Executive Committee the Tobacco Institute, Inc,
- 1005091712-1713
- 1005091714 Tobacco Institute Ads Challenge Cancer Society
- 1005091715 the Tobacco Institute Believes the American Public Is Entitled to Complete, Authenticated Information About Cigarette Smoking and Health, the American Cancer Society Does Not Seem to Agree.
- 1005091716
- 1005091716A
- 1005091716B
- 1005091717 the Cigarette - Cancer Dispute
- 1005091718 Study Data on Cancer
- 1005091719 Smoking Beagles Draw Fire
- 1005091720 Question Validity of Smoking Dog Slides
- 1005091721-1722
- 1005091723 Smoking - Cancer Study Action Rejected by Surgeon General
- 1005091724 Correspondence Between the Tobacco Institute and the American Cancer Society 700227 - 700429
- 1005091725
- 1005091726 the Tobacco Institute Believes the American Public Is Entitled to Complete Authenticated Information About Cigarette Smoking and Health, the American Cancer Society Does Not Seem to Agree.
- 1005091727
- 1005091728
- 1005091729
- 1005091730
- 1005091731
- 1005091732-1733
- 1005091734-1735
- 1005091736-1738
- 1005091739-1741 Report Relates Cancer and Smoking. Auerbach - Hammod Smoking Beagles.
- 1005091742-1753
- 1005091754 Cancer Report Disputed Eject Tobacco Men for Row Wth A.M.A.
- 1005091755 Research Plea Smoking Dog Test Repeat Is Urged
- 1005091756 Tobacco Group Challenges Cancer Study
- 1005091757-1759 No Smoking
- 1005091760-1794 Effects of Cigarette Smoking Upon Dogs I. Design of Experiment; Mortality; Findings in Lung Parenchyma,
- 1005091795-1818 Effects of Cigarette Smoking Upon Dogs II. Pulmonary Neopl
- 1005091819 Why Stifle Debate on Smoking?
- 1005091820-1821 Tobacco Institute Vs American Cancer Society
- 1005091822
- 1005091823-1824
- 1005091825 Ama Journal Decides to Withhold Reports on Dogs and Smoking
- 1005091826 Tobacco Spokesman Says Dog Tests May Be Greatest 'scientific Hoax'
- 1005091827 Ama Journal Rejects Paper on Acs' Smoking-Dog Study Evidence of Cancer Found Lacking
- 1005091828-1829 Acs Researchers Retreat on Claims for Beagle Study Now Say Only Two Dogs Got Cancer
- 1005091830-1831 An Editorial
- 1005091832 Reports Linking Cigarets and Smoking 'not Rejected'
- 1005091833 Voltairean Principle
- 1005091834 Lung Cancer Makes Strange Bedfellows
- 1005091835-1836 Study on Dogs and Smoking
- 1005091837 What Became of 'landmark' Cancer Study?
- 1005091838 Beagles, Smoking Article to Be Printed
- 1005091839-1845 of Beagles, Smoking, and Cancer Cigarette Smoking Canines Answer the Demand for Laboratory Confirmation of the Statistical Cancer Link by Developing Invasive Lung Tumors
- 1005091846-1847
- 1005091848-1849 Study on Dogs and Smoking
- 1005091850 Cancer Society's Test on Dogs Looks Like A Hoax, Tobacco Industry Says
- 1005091851 Hoax, Institute Suggests Smoking Dog Cancer Test Challenged
- 1005091852 Cancer Society Was Wrong
- Characteristic
- EXTR, EXTRA
- MARG, MARGINALIA
- Date Loaded
- 24 May 1999
- UCSF Legacy ID
- fye91a00
Document Images
e'~)lYUCit' '(il f:iU' rS(~ iCI1:7~~1UN:,, l ~t1\.()D.i)---1 t 1lsivuS O! ' i1[lur/S'
S\401C1 'r Ir.c+ itt t1 t r ttt' 1 n : 1 r r I! )r
. ..lc- rr 3'p 1 r t )rrt 1 rt'. !1 I.Y 1' !l
rr1P. o: t 1+1 + t: 1.:I ! t' . : . I 14 : 1- I Y.t:ny \.l:x
_ ~ )lol y...l. t. t +1 tl tt : \-+1 t 1 rn trr ccrm 4 Y 1 ;Yi~ It t" 1<( 1;-.
v t
i t
: !, ~ 1
t-n,^ c
rt d 1 J ~ H
r
T1
T
r
ru t 111 Icar r 1 I c x IL , rv
;u mou., h,^, I I n ct . '
1]
1
J
T1
1.
I TTG:1. - 1
or t.r.::.vu:r, t)nlYd!nr tu } ur Icrnir . f!' Ir cc nu:cnt LhercJll
7 ntrt ocYl JI d't C I,-/tY,lh,rh ' yis r 1^
c
c
l
c
lH
t
h
t
t
1
d
I
p
.
cs . --. _
. o.
). r
s_Y
n
:.rrnn,
t
r
.
ttl n.Ght
Jli'37)G71(1V5£(1PNF.PRt.S'L'):T/.111'1-S toror::lltnpt.rt:tncyucstlnn; I'orcen+nlrl-r
a;ers!vtyrr:e[nl.ofthrux,;ln^' t.:-.II+
)lirctl7:CSG6J, i,IdrC7D 1°, )?70 ~ . 7+ ]:cpi'rir,lUrihl'~. resu!tac:~rrcdl Ya:
reihlY-Lho~rotqs.e:.criGCc^d. ia,rd.ou loj C!+a::]nho.~
Lf
1Sr. Cl:1tTTS :. ?3r: .;;]::"1cr, 1Losc of
tls \r11o nttcnJCd lrst'YCar s len,alty 1icl+r-
Snl;s on 11]is bill v:e:o n!nszV:d to fYn d,
from t1iescores-ot Ecicntfficc cxpcrlsr;tlo
np)Irarc9''bcSorc us. t5at rir,u°II?: no sic-
)]lfic;int rrro^,rc;;s hns h^erl mad : Ill rc-
LC8Tt11 tq ICSolA"J11YC. COlltl'o-
\'C1sy" S(11CC L11C. 1lisL. (IlC1Cd o:7
o_
I+' thi5 rnattcr 5)c ra ^-
~
~- ~ 7,°sU nxrHll, )t_..t rs (L`c confcrccs rr( rc
~.,PbouL to mcct on tl;:s L:It- iac i}lncnc:d}
/
v l '
Cnnccr ~i'ciei3 ]tc3d a 7 -s cWtvrrr~.ncc
' to't:fyllouncC rC511h5o1 cr^:^1i1' :P1C .ill';
ia.cvli .nr. rca r:fa.l l. nuJc:v t.c r.'t cTl,c.rl.ncc L
cLs1-o.tslcJrl. c.,ucc,
no.l :tli:r bhc tr u.:. rl:n ^r ta t1ICW Ill n:ly hvmIa\Cltll tllls ht ntludi,lloa cnn cuy'onc
cir,lm1*^PulzLlnct' -
tlYrtdFIscNqzrnncntcpnrozvn.li tlYC.natu- 7.:;frnila*tr, rll.n+nm.zIng :tw-cntg-f:t-c pct.. .
rul Imclhnd. of s:nol:lni Ill ):v+nsn~7 'J'hr. t'ent o(tticf non-srno:dr/r,. do ;; srac Ycportcd
r.:otliod ulcdlrc. hr..AUCrbcch l:r'ohcs td:ce to,LnY~cr drecto..rtt ivuloa \Ch:d1nIr.P:t
t',cdirco:Q
drllrcry a1 clgarcttc :..no1 c to1010),;Lrc IYetn If the dcr: had t-xn
7a:vrr lrrvlicn; t]:c F:onc1;1 nt.d : hcllmr ;, t.r'.nscccl: loath~c ot:t.ihclr r:IIItR.llc s+
thoccliy Uicoral c:n~.t5::thc.p!:nr- quc:.tSo:,s.[aro lult.cd by Ihls.r[:ro:.rl: Gl.ctisr,
plts: t!ic. Ir.ryvl+ nnd,thc v)ti,.r por:loa or LP:c: 1.!ltlh rcn;,.c: to tLC. tuso: ItctJur.t c.f
d.o-s.
1rroh-. / t imcor.Yp is n 1 xo lcnc. /lc: but o, the 'c lisa c: In V:I 1 )-,. le-.
v:Yp for r Iru-.,rl.lo tinc.:h_ 1.1dcc-i~1f,1,t`." c~1r:c.it l:,ral rczl r...rclof
latrc.luc:.,thc o-s,l.fll.y o.' 1rtccct.n, toJl Ccnr..c,.t.nl: (nslrolr+nr77Lil L:ndI c.1YCr
Iic-ti trJsl y d\J :!. I ct o Ir,lclic- Lo:o 1np-`'cd7
n o-vc, b t r- sn, b;. Ic rc . L f- Jt~t!clt ol }.fccllcI "b c' l.tli ovl+'s°, Csu 7l nn-'
t)YC. ha`1G 1 tCx:' d': to ):-[; ll'ClrnC11M:- nDl;l C f1:1 I I1C 'I..r IYC:.diln
' O Ilu1
.
,C]:pCrilr:C:1lSiI]tolt-iti lr'l'>i0 lrl cnjI cllou,d L,:irl..tP:.,,,,.+._h o,tich- ovL to bc:
ri5 !,,o u...rcllls vncrl
\P171C)1 sOt71C Irl^1]ifei:ti.:0115 eY.f 1111:~~ P -nl ,t:e v.o Ltd cro:ute -'trrr e
s.:c;,ul[!:nl.s to cirrJVl eeientY'ee ce1~+ltl :. }:or c~.Y1,IC; e- c2ncCr \t':CrC &a1c1
tol':a\'o. bzcnob5crrc~!. }:ot only- v:c:cr:11 of llic !::o~..ttc: r:,cch,_ )loccnlbcr 19G7 nrtlc:.c
hyr)td C1I1!` YIL 1es bCio.rC our co:'n1r:1 J' 11 (t 1'~-<=1SOf.t-IC U). C' It . ~ .c7 l: at 1 L'tI-
rc;l'Xtrd ttiC ):.^.%::1r.1o:n 4 li n: LunYD:} Ins.....,. :: 1] rVu 1*e a, rlr ci+:1rc.c vI
h,^.:Ld'b:r
m, ~C:cC : Y n+r 1.J I 1 hlr, rc ~t, (..'.Goer. tiy~. .,y- r~ r r9 Lu I -1,
7»OSL ( 15t `_Ln .ECt. p], r- -'r 1°CS d I'.' Ihtl co^t' t 2 cou d n~ 1 n' c t ~vn~e1 ) I trid )
~d s ilhu cU to c cclt ~~
d
}
:Y
r
..., - _ fCril Cr L~~ LbC C ' C O a 10 - e lie t ~ c. ce cv ri ner :. Lncr~ r~ tl uc m1 li n Ye of t
r lai '
` r SG2L 1'it]t 10 f C P~`e ii1 hf ( Sa-~ t nl .y^tcc; ir ` Le: accr~_t c1 C 1Ytle s~ t 1tt e o
the tr i_cco.iltv~trj 'J Ir'L.L
v.
t rlOfu rc ~~ rCi 1 ~I 1 1~ n Ci;l +'l ]ti} o~ no E L 't I:I b, : r Go chDuL~ ) Ir o t)c y~ Ic ld
'1 t . . nr ?~Y-
rI ' Stut:.CS T\.rtl c to D- L tbli r~t S s. xd~ 1 3 -nil 1 .r c r Ivoi : c). ..I
.
I -. 7] to (Yt ~1 a ILC1'~t:,i 1 .sL.rr 7J l 11 i luzvc:l cd r C_.r+!s~v c t d 1; u,+l:,.h,. Ila.o
)ish d c:clc: t.,c~ nu.::r rtttl!n Ci t[ ~
1IJ
7cllly~ ti1)ios fa]C S~vP-r,x.t ph. ,4 fc.c^ hu:; cc::::o b_~ c,vc cd
r' o: t~,I>: ia 1 Lo . t i ? G tu I 1ta t.o Ic ~l }~. uY n t ' 1 u n rr I o~.
Gf1i (1 CL13G.~c`.'i "t IC?17 '~~' c'~r.~ ,c.I.l-bt~ tr:t,lc. c^ cr~czc,lo~~,icft c it~-.li or
~- - fICRI y C C~ Oh r 5 F r C I llJ ly~ co t:cr ~ co., d r 1 :c i: un~: 1 r. r,tc I.. o'+~.t
o~.1 t c 1Y r'~'
( 1"OI`9r Cd t:: 1 F~: ~]i -C 1 h'C r d -c o c crc ,c c . c t s lo t ic }~cn l~ 1: c: ti~ c h 0~ c
11 ~.
(71GrB 1. S t`Y'Ctl rl- ..1.}"SG Ci,i- r c ,:.c t. c~.r,.... J'So~.s.l.:., Lp .
C21 rclta?:17~ b o :r . i:- .. ' I Y -tr 1. t t'~ t'3~ (. :1 rc G .~ICri c H~r~ c ~ ~
r' Di. IJL'll:::. 5 ~~ .-s~s f0 1<. :, G. t. C r I.1 fi It c. c. . 1 -I rl . r t ~m
tl 111 r~ .C . wt IY C 7
l Antl, T.'it:it:lll OJICc,i0.71~ Z. F'U r.~ ):':C lo c~. c clr: t e I~(.cn il:c aL:c Y ~..c. 1!
J
!. ._ _v._.._ _._.:.a_ _..._ ,....-:...,._....-. ..- r-.L. ,fi..C 1.,..nC.l E.:_C:...Cr..G.-S !:f
t.,~~:
... ..
.
.
.. -
. ... ...... -- __ ._..
~
-~
L
I
t Y~.t
.
T_o:IC:roKi:: Il-c
' . I:b
J J:-r c,.c.
rsc cJ
,
.
. ., t.:c, :.w to
1
be ~ ~ too n-1. T~ If L e
-
c' IJ c.rtfor acsrr-
D`
~ ~~..... ccr r t, c.. c.o :o H^ Y...u:,In
eent .~le.e.r. 1a c`cn e:.I 1ae,:ioct o' t'rlr 1._Lcd:r.::.:.o.:,ie::~l da*esc:ICCS.f:DSt
on nuW::a tr.olc3n's_a:.eu capa:a:,c~: rv:c- mcu.
- naune.:d bc. llr5, iucruae.'n Lnd' 17:rn= ~nd~. 1in}- vuc.ihc:oo:
,ly cltad eonlrol do;
i
_
,
e.(, . 0.'L:IICr t!Ia reo~ai.. au o r. to ~"i-; 1 7 -u'^: -o Y e- r lr 1'
'
+
e
t r Laa c bo
. Iu eon::c :.c c
. _ [ctc r[ n r\-r x'hc c< Yt r u r,.. rd
ou: (~n. o~ cntJ ^ to
y- o u: i ui t,ll . 1..- <,o,!ur L~c. trc .Vd
s:rs~):.:r^ G^:oe~,r'~ ft- -a:~h e )~ot- in set' nt rS~l'c.otn ~o.:c cD. 7'yt~dc s
rnoud t e:,ea!
:c _=.), l e: . :, lt:n: 1YOc t`rt r .c, uly.. cm:'ca:dcd Iah
1n r.o:coliih.!r,aon c:;c:).^.-:cr.:' `t`+c:c. h_s. ditceled P,:c~:riY :hrn tr.:cLro_:o:::a
Lccn Ln ti~lc rc: ~i.Yeto:}- vresr.vUyt!_uS;ct fur'" c.lir...c^d. v::!cc- aY!s..
. rqs!A-m of t)ioco'tilr.l1- rc P;xceu:cs trsd'one.7a:a1::c:ir:ccf loc;;:c::::D:r v:i:cthc.r'.
ItcAc' I v-c:'.i. os to s.y t:~ cs::,ccr t?
. ,[to.c1.C.! .cfo;s [viCtl t_ G:~.emvd :cc'cqu::tce
l:crtp:o3ucca 1',ctt:a.nc, ;.rl:ncn:al r,:otl'.c.~.. c~:rtrna,.
SL
"I t tc to .[IC ~ i Yc c c v:] 1r r
:ov7U )
f, 4
~
11
i
~l~
t)]
/
L
1
~
.
.
.-.~ -.
c
n
r t
.
,
v-1
~c
c
c
1
_~ 1}D' ir u 1~ Lz11 I [ht I- tc ] :d lu. ' c. Itc ~. iry lt tz. d t v~L fi r
. ~ rntc
rrull t~ [ h L , s r 1 r t Ydi i c:rth
iTYC r]c. 1 t~vtt 1 ~D Lc I^:c t s lu C nC s.' 1 ~ 4 1..' I: t ~l [_3 1. ~ 1 c1u:;p
Ltlcli rrl~~ c}),^~rlmn:Yi lJ I~ 1C+ (:n 1111.1.. n:..ti.l [.1t::i^JLal0
~'.. fccet cc.. )'.r. tvvc.} do,^,s (t-::-7!.^s) vi,o "tcar1LU,:na-fi~-rfli' c~ I.. ~',.:Y c.
.'ct.
:._ "Llnc d ~lttut -tf ~ ~h r suf llcr~Ur /rc ` rrt. s:l - no.`I ~~q
` n~tu r c} 1.cl o Y n tc t[c t/ v ffic
r ) ur r c + -JL' . L ) c<
1rnc1 ~ ~h H~t . 7.Lc ) ~. d-r c t c t t I r 1 c c r
( I~~.~~i r r fc F.1 r 7 tlu ~~l- al s.o.i 1c ~.. 1 :- Y ~t.I
I t lhl+ 1~ c ll-:If l: r Y~l t "l. n 1 t.ic r t~ c ir c, t-.11 ,t f:.,. ih_ t.
. L Yrp~ I.t v.hlch r. bu..a:al ri.3Yg t cs~ t. tcrt ,) [0 1 t
'' C1;~.~iLll^- . 7. :~.t t~ l. t."1 C' C:1 5 tr:.+:~r t
f.s you L:.~in}.. 1 :::,s: 11Y~ I t.l.i
.
.
...
.
. _ . C _
E,. U
ti S~ V
ua. c:c ..:
~ Ln_ p: sr Y;
rrrr_ ~
~ Sr JDS_rr Iia°
~
-
lQ
...k~ol r~ c ~ :~I ~c~ lr o_
!' j
Xalcs,;}~Crtg, A1o. tcortccry 71; 157J. ~:1 ~ 1G5. 1t nn.. t.r[-t~ - l. ~ d' r F~ ~.,s _,_ce~
ll 1) t r ~ o o~ ,I-' Lz fr9u ic: L~~Y :I ~
I r) cr ln
Eoa.iY- ) ~(,. -rs
C~-cre s 11' Il~ 1 -il
c c c c e
t
f
"
bls crAra+;uc; 1n<F str!c:::rl: I:;on,)c,!cr. ut. r~ Lehl' t.lr'4rmreh,(Y:p.e.'1':it".
;:t!i- I~_. I.: ihC I~~ , c.-:. `ICar I.:fi.1 I nL 1-1
.~.
c ):c,..ltl+
t!fli... J'u.u:,l:.'Jl:r ;cs: ft;, r.,c. I~.tc kc.rr+ 1tcL: ~ l.tc .: 1 t!~:r. t .Stvno::
b:,air7lo::~)..I:,_..r.~l t'1'
',.c:-..i 1)i. I.+:r:
).1y'f..ak-..o!!c:-:fr:,1'.)etc:cL. l.:.,,!.,....+ tt!~+I^
ftnln r, 3:o'+IL 1`1:S r:I:1dc.1rY t.:ar.1.Y:+:: Ixla, [. (cil o.~(u-.r:,,+ c:+, L:r 1:,
ctrdmt.:; ti+al Uit:
o-r t.- c.s
r.n,fn [z r
YC
bp 1\ ', tC e rmIt h 1 c,1 C.[c
lo c 1ntJ:u.c t--o.:nr 1: tvl -
~
Ls"cd rrp.n..Gi,U...,.cy...?:
c:ft:l,c,l...[:.-a.IL tc';ri..t..7 .;acr;r7y'!:enr
.L'.l:.t ]:Is.IC:i.^::I1:;' [.f -an
b:.o:r`ra cvc-:. ....11.a:: t.-D tn; scrl:l
no:L` ]ic.'[ti 1ur G~: rc::iJtc rl 1,
t:rc ) D 1r.s to >,i trr o:r no: c.-.t.c
t r.oi );r'_5 L iltrs tl1. Cnl:st
o.' :.Irl Mnct1 1:1 .:.lY. 1,5. itr;lcl1u11 ~
\'s.nall.3:vl:r.rs,`.
I'af i: 070 ,ia.
i
S10rl.'O1C1 1 LyJC 1`C2.r2 1t'L
~
JutlN. 31iuu ~Ji (iC +l_uI lP
~.. a1):rl'!l-o'):
}X'.T3IE.1:C]J`:C Q?'r:l.)It1:5L\I'.!Tlt'::°.7l'1 ~cc+, V[rch ~.G J:.501:(1 cL'1 i r. ~ I tri
llt ncl-
liol ) n clcd.c t! t! 1 , :Ih d:-c-
talc l.,a lc.u:'
I'r.crto LY:c..crl[+ )IC«ca ini (E = lat:rllc
] t~.
11LCC in thc
:,iblcI
i: Ll~c }:antl: ya^Mi:rlir: I'+ncc
(i7;:: nUL 1CCU1+i, L11,; p.('o ' : :llvl.hl:::'.
1:clnb,~i'.t t.illronll r. I<1 C: L" ''r
CO.tlltI I n11 1`L :!
J77:' :)f:irr,s Ilrc:ntl thr ct.n!t'rt. rl, l..l;r.
G
0
