NYSA TI Multipage 2
Airway Permeability to Horseradish Peroxidase in Guinea Pigs: the Repair Phase after Injury by
Abstract
Several years ago, Simani and associates (1) suggested that the increase they observed in the permeability of the respiratory epithelium after exposure to tobacco smoke was due to damaged epithelial tight junctions. More recently, Boucher and co-workers (2) demonstrated that this altered permeability was associated with structural damage to the sealing strands of the tight junctions.
Fields
- NYSA numbers
- 1200 B1793 03A
- Named Organization
- International Academy of Pathology
- Lancet
- Named Person
- Dixon, Joan
- Hare, Linda
- Hogg, James C.
- Jackson, Anne
- Kilburn, K.H., Ph.D. (Researched the impact of class on cessation rates)
- Laird, Wendy
- Liss, Alan
- Nicols, Irene
- Walker, David C.
- Hare, Linda
- Date Loaded
- 27 Jan 2005
- Box
- 0027. Library/Miscellaneous - 11-21 18205-18817
- Folder
- PA - PARU
- Division
- Library
Document Images
Airway Permeability to Horseradish Peroxidase
in Guinea Pigs: the Repair Phase after Injury
by Cigarette Smoke1-3
WILLIAM Co HULBERT, DAVID C. WALKER, ANNE JACKSON,
and JAMES C. HOGG
Introduction
Several years ago, Simani and associ-
ates (1) suggested that the increase they
observed in the permeability of the re-
spiratory epithelium after exposure to
tobacco smoke was due to damaged ep-
ithelial tight junctions. More recently,
Boucher and co-workers (2) demon-
strated that this altered permeability
was associated with structural damage
to the sealing strands of the tight junc-
tions. Their study also showed that to-
bacco smoke in relatively small doses
caused this damage to the epithelium
and that increasing the dose increased
the severity of the injury. These
changes in mucosal permeability could
be of considerable importance because
they cause the underlying structures in
the airway wall to be more exposed to
substances present in the lumen. Al-
though the permeability is increased,
for example, the irritant receptors,
which are located just beneath the tight
junctions, are more exposed. These
structures are thought to initiate rapid
shallow breathing and bronchocon-
striction (3), and they may be more
easily stimulated when the mucosa is
disrupted. In addition, the mucosal
damage allows antigens to have greater
access to the large number of mast cells
present in the submucosa (4). The al-
tered state of permeability associated
with the mucosal injury must eventual-
ly return to normal, and the time for
repair will determine the period of ab-
normal mucosal function. The present
study was therefore designed to ex-
amine the changes in epithelial permea-
bility as the epithelium returned
toward normal in the 24-h period after
exposure to tobacco smoke.
Methods
Thirty Carom Hartlcy guinea pigs of either
sex (average weight, 500 g) were used in this
320
SUMMARY Airway pemleshlllty was examined In the 24.h period immediately liter Injury by
cigarette smoke In 30 guinea p~gs studied in groups ol five at 30 rain and 1, 6, 12, and 24 h after
smoke exposure, end In 1 control group. The animals were anesthetized) trscheostomlzod, a
carotid csnnula Inserted, and purified horseradish pemxidase was instilled on the airway sudaoe
via the tracheostomy tube. Blood samples (0.8 ml) were drawn and replaced with haparlnlzed
saline before and st 10, 15, 20, 30, and 40 rain after horseradish peroxldsse instillation. The
animals ware then kilted, end samples ot trachea and lung tissue taken for weUdry wt determina-
tions and for light and electron microscopic examination. The HRP concentrations In the blood
were determined using an Ells= plate essay. We Iound the acute exposuro to 100 pulls cigarette
smoke resulted In a Irenslsnt Increase In airway aipthellal permeability to HRP with e maximum
at 30 rain and a return to control values by 12 h altar insult, Those chonges In mucosal pewneeblll-
ty occurred In relation to s well-dellnad Inflammotory reaction where Increased permeability o¢-
cuaed during the exudatlve phsso, which was monitored by measuring airway wet wUdry wl
ratios and the InfiRration of polymorphonuclssr cells. The return to the control value of
permeability was associated with the repair phase of the inflammatory reaction, which was
measured by monitoring basal cell mitoses. AM REV RESPIR DIS 1981; 123:320-326
study. Twenty-five guinea pigs were exposed
to 100 puffs cigarette smoke in the awake,
restrained state using methods that have
been previously described (2), and 5 control
animals were exposed to 100 puffs air using
the same exposure system. The smoking
machine delivered 15 m[ of whole smoke
every 20 s into a perforated manifold in
which the head of the guinea pig was se-
cured. The 25 experimental animals were
studied in groups of 5, commencing at
intervals of 30 rain and 1, 6, 12, and 24 h
after exposure. The test cigarettes were sup-
plied by the Tobacco Manufacturers Coun-
cil of Canada and were composed of high
quality flue-cured tobacco.
At each of the predetermined time points
after challenge, the animals were intraperi-
toneally anesthetized with Nembutal® (25
mg/kg) and a tracheostomy tube (PE-10)
and carotid cannula (PE-200) were inserted.
Purified horseradish peroxidase (HRP) (1
mg in 0.2 ml tyrodes) was introduced
through the tracheostomy tube over a 4-rain
period. Blood samples (0.8 ml) were taken
before and at 10, 15, 20, 30, and 40 min af-
ter placing the HRP on the tracheal surface
with the blood volume being replaced with
heparinized saline. Because of the 40-min
blood sampling time, the morphologic anal-
ysis was conducted at 70 rain, 1 h 40 rain, 6
h 40 rain, 12 h 40 rain, and 24 h 40 mins
after exposure. The animals were then killed
with a carotid injection of saturated KCI.
and the trachea and lung tissue rapidly re-
moved for microscopic examination and
wet wt/dry wt determination.
The HRP used in this study was Sigm;
Type 11 (P8250), (Sigma Chemical Co., St.
Louis, MO), which was purified accordin
to the method of Moroz and associates (5)
Assay .for HRP in serum. An Elisa assa
was used to measure HRP in serum. Tt-
antiserum was obtained from rabbits in
munized with 100-pg aliquots of HRP in 0
ml phosphate buffered saline (PBS) in
equal volume of complete Freunds ad)
vant and boosted at 6-wk intervals.
antibody concentration in various
samples was tested by Ouehterlony analy
~th 1 mg/ml of the purified enzyme. The
with titers of i/8 or greater were pooi
(Received in origina/ form Jul.)" 29, 1980 one.
revised form November 24, 1980)
~From ti~e University of British Colur."
Pulmonary Research Laboratory, St.
Hospital, Vancouver, B.C., Canada.
= Supported by the MRC of Canada and
Tobacco Manufacturers Council of Canada
= Requests for r¢prints should be addresse
Dr. J.C. Hogg. St. Paul's Hospital, 1081 Burr
Street, Vancouver. B.C.. Canada. V6Z IY6
T!04231001

AIRWAY MOCOSAI. PERME~BILIT~
~,~1
and the serum fraetionated by precipitation
with 40% saturated ammonium sulphate.
This antiserum precipitated 2 lines of en-
zyme-active malerial in both the purified
and crude preparations on immunoelectro-
phoretic assay.
Standards were prepared by diluting pu-
rified HRP to l to 320 ng/ml in PBS, or, in
some instances, in one-fifth normal guinea
pig serum in PBS. These were prepared
fresh daily from I mg/ml stock solutions in
H 20. The stock solutions were stored with-
out preservatives and were replaced at month-
ly intervals. The antiserum fraction was
diluted from 1/500 to 1/30~ in 0.05 Mcax-
bonate buffer (pH, 9.6), and 100 ~1 aliquots
were added to the wells of microtiter plates
(Elisa-Cooke Engineering 1-223-229), the
plates were incubated overnight at 2 to 5°
C, the contents were removed, and the
plates were washed 3 times with PBS.
Quadruplicate I00-~I aIiquots of the stan-
dards were incubated on the antibody
coated plates for 3 to 4 h, and removed by
washing. Enzyme activity was measured by
the method of Saunders (6), using 0.25 M
2'-azino-di-(zet hylbenzthiazloine sulfonic
acid) or a dye and 0.1% HzOz as substrate
in 0,05 M citrate buffer (pH, 4.0). When nec-
essary, the reaction was stopped by the ad-
dition of HF:0.1 M in EDTA 0.001 M,
NaOH 0.01 M. The plates were read at 2 to
5 rain intervals in a spectrophotometer
(Multiskan Flow Laboratories), and the
average optical density for each concentra-
tion plotted on semilog graph paper. Rate
averages were:also plotted to assess the
linearity of the color development.
Guinea pig serum samples were diluted
1/5 to 1/10 in PBS, and 100-/~l aliquots
were incubated in quadruplicate in 96 well
plates, as described previously. A 6-poim
standard curve was included on each, as
well as randomly located individual stan-
dards and PBS as a blank. Color develop-
ment was assessed at 3 or more intervals
after substrate and dye addition and un-
known optical densities read at each time
from the appropriate standard curve. Cor-
rection for nonspecific serum effects was
carried out.
Tissue preparation. Trachea from the
control animals and from the l-h, 6-h,
12-h, and 24-h experimental animals was
fixed by immersion in ice-cold 2% glutaral-
dehyde in 0. i M Na-cacodylate buffer (pH,
7.4). However. adequate fixation of the tra-
chea for the 30-rain animals required retro-
grade perfasion of the abdominal aorta
caudal to the diaphragm. After primary fix-
ation, the tissues were washed overnight in
the same buffer and processed according to
Karnovsky (7) to demonstrate the presence
of HRP. The tissues were then postfixed in
2% O~O,, stained on block with saturated
uranyl acetate in distilled water, dehydrated
in a graded ethanol series, and embedded in
Spurr. Thin sections were cut using glass
knives on a Reichert ultramicrotome,
mounted on naked 200-mesh copper grids,
gained with uranyl acetate (saturated in
70% methanol) and lead citrate (8), and
viewed with a Phillips 400EM.
l~valuation of epithelial penetration.
Penetration of the tight junctions was de-
termined by examining for the presence of
an electron-dense reaction product indicat-
ing HRP in the intercellular space. At least
8 grid spaces (between 4 and 10 cells per
grid space) from 2 separate grids were ex-
amined for each block and at least 2 blocks
were examined for each animal. The results
were presented as a ratio of the number of
junctions penetrated/total counted. This
analysis was conducted by ! investigator
(WCH) who was unaware of the experimen-
tal condition.
Cell counts. Cell counts were conducted
by 2 investigators (WCH, DCW) who were
unaware of the experimental treatment of
the animals. For each animal, at least 3 tis-
sue blocks with 2 slides (i-~ sections stained
with Toluidine Blue O) per block were ex-
amined yielding an epithelial length in ex-
cess of 1 cm for all experimental groups.
Goblet cell~, e~slnophils, plasma cells,
polymorphonuclear leukocytes, and mast
cells were counted, and the totals were ex-
pressed as cells/mm epithelium. Mitotic fig-
ures were taken as distinct anaphase, meta-
phase, and telophase stages and are ex-
pressed as the number of mitoses per/ram
of epithelium.
Assessment of basement raembrane. The
basement membrane area was defined as
that region bounded by the elastic lamina
and basal cells. Area determinations were
made using planimetry on light micro-
graphs and the measurements are presented
as basement membrane area mml/mm epi-
thelium.
Statistical analysis. Dunnett's modifica-
tion of the t test (9), which allows multiple
comparisons to a single control, was used to
ascertain significance between the control
and the experimental groups. This test was
used to compare the rate of appearance of
HRP in the blood, the change in wet wt/dry
Wl ratio, changes in various cell types, the
mitotic index of the basal cell layer, and the
thickening of the basement membrane.
Results
The acute exposure of guinea pigs to
100 puffs whole tobacco smoke pro-
duced electron microscopic evidence of
increased airway epithelial permeabili-
ty, which was maximal in the 30-rain
and l-h groups of animals (and hence
between 70 and 100 rain), and returned
to control values by 12 h after exposure
(figure 1). The mean junctional pene-
tration ratio - SE (tight junctions pen-
etrated/total tight junctions counted)
for the 30-rain, 1- and 6-h postsmoking
groups was found to be 0.9_+ 0.03, 0.7
Hours Post Chollengewl|h
100 Pulls Whole C=garene Smoke
Fig. 1. This histogram plots the penetration ratio
(number of tight junctions penetrated/total num-
ber counted) for the 24-h examination period after
exposure to 100 puffs whole cigarette smoke.
Standard error bars are indicated, as well as the
number of junctions penetrated over the total
counted.
± 0.15, and 0.2 __- 0.17, respectively. In
contrast, no evidence of junctional
penetration was obtained by electron
microscopic examination of the control
12- and 24-h groups. In figure 2A and
B, the electron micrographs are of a
30-rain postsmoking animal. These 2
micrographs demonstrate the presence
of the electron-dense tracer HRP in the
intercellular space (arrows), and fur-
ther show an epithelial nerve in longi-
tudinal section (figure 2A) and in
cross-section (figure 2B). Note the
close positioning of these nerves to the
tight junction and airway surface. The
insets of Figure 2A and B are high
magnification enlargements of the epi-
thelial nerves and readily demonstrate
the electron-dense tracer HRP in the
intercellular space, as well as longitudi-
nal and cross-sectional views of nerve
fibers. An electron micrograph from a
control animal (figure 3) shows the
presence of HRP on the airway sur-
face, and the inset clearly shows that
there is no HRP in the intercellular
space.
The appearance of HRP in the blood
during the 40-rain period after it was
placed on the trachea is presented in
figure 4. This shows that in animals not
exposed to tobacco smoke the rate of
appearance was slow and the value re-
vealed at 40 rain was similar (0.1 ±
0.06% injected dose) to that reported
by Boucher and co-workers (2) who
used a radioimmunoassay technique. In
contrast, in the animals examined 30
min after smoke exposure, the rate of
appearance was faster and the 40-min
blood concentration increased seven-
fold to 0.73 ± 0.3~0 injected dose. The
mean rate of appearance ± SE of HRP
in the serum during the 40 min after
Ti04231002

";22
HULBERT, WALKER, JACKSON. AHD
HOGG
F~g. 2 A. Eleclron micrograph Irom an ammal examined 30 m~n after smoke exposure. Note espemally an
ep~thehal nerve in longitudinal secbon and its close proximity to the tight junclion and atrway
surface.
and the HRP m the intercellular space (arrows). The inset shows a high magnification enlargement ot
the
nerve in tong~tudmal section; bar = 0.55 p. B. Note the cross-sectional views o! the nerve lihers
and thmr
close proximity to the mrway surface. The inset shows a h~gh magnification enlargement of the nerves
in
cross-section: bar = 0.55 ~. (C = ciha; G = golgi complex; HRP = horseradish peroxidase; M ---
mitochondna; MV .= microvilli; NF = neural filaments; N = nerve: NU = nucleus; RER = rough en-
ooplasm~c ret=culum; TJ = t~ght junct=on.)
placement of HRP on the tracheal sur-
face is shown for each of the groups in
figure 5. This shows that HRP accum-
ulated more quickly in the blood of
animals examined at 30 rain, 1, and 6 h
after smoke exposure than it did in the
control group or in those animals ex-
amined 12 and 24 h al'ter smoke expo-
sure.
The data concerning the exudation
of fluid (tracheal wet wt/dry wt ratio),
recruitment of polymorphonuclear
ce.lls, the onset of the repair phase (mi-
totic index), and basement membrane
measurements are presented in figure 6.
As shown in figure 6A, the tracheal wet
wt/dry wt ratio increased from control
values of 2.4 ± 0.16 to 3.2 ± 0.18 at
30-rain postsmoking (p < 0.05) and re-
turned to control values 12 h after the
insult. By 24 h the ratio decreased to
1.9 ± 0.06 (p < 0.05) below that of the
control group. As shown in figure 6B,
the number of polymorphonuclear
cells increased fivefold from control
values of 2.8 ± 0.7 to 14.6 ± 2.9
cells/mm epithelium 6 h after injury,
and then decreased slightly to 9.5 ± 1.6
cells/mm epithelium by 24 h postexpo-
sure. Initiation of the repair phase (fig-
ure 6C) was marked by a 12-fold in-
crease in basal cell mitoses (from 0.5 _.+
0.2 to 6.2 ± 0.4/ram epithelium) at 12 h
postchallenge, with further increases to
15 mitoses/ram epithelium by 24 h
postchallenge. In contrast to the tra-
cheal wet wt/dry wt ratios, the thick-
ness of the basement membrane (figure
6D) initially decreased from 8.9 -+ 0.4
to 6.0 ± 0.3 mm~/mm epithelium, and
then gradually increased, reestablish-
ing control values by 12 h postsmoking
and then significantly (p < 0.05) ex-
ceeded control values by 24 h.
The data concerning the numbers of
goblet cells, mast cells, eosinophils,
and plasma cells are shown in figure 7.
This figure shows that goblet cells (fig-
ure 7A) decreased from 26.8 + 10.0 to
7.3 _+ 2.1 cells/ram epithelium during
the 24-h examination period with values
of 5.1 + 1.8and2.5 _+ 1.g recorded at
30 rain and 1 h postsmoking. Epithelial
mast ceils (figure 7B) generally increased
in number to a maximum of 6.7 + 0.8
cells/ram of epithelium by 6 h postexpo-
sure. Eosinophils (figure 7C) decreased
from 19.4 +_. 3.9 to 0.7+ 0.3 at 24 h
postchallenge. Plasma cells (figure 7D)
showed an immediate threefold de-
crease from 16.7 ± 2.3 to approxi-
mately 5 cells/ram epithelium, an
amount that was maintained through.
out the remaining examination period.
The observations concerning celt
counts made by 2 independent obser-
vers (WCH, DCW) unaware of the e×.
perimental treatment are compared i~
table 1. The table shows that the corre
lations are all greater than 0.986 an.
that the slopes of the regression are a"
close to 1.
Discussion
Previous studies (1,2) have shown th,
tobacco smoke injures the respirato;
epithelium by damaging the struetur.
components of the tight junctio:
which in turn increases mucosal pernf.
ability. Our work extended these obse:
vations and showed lhat this incre-a ;
TIO4231003

• IRWAY MUCO~I,,L PERMF.ABILri'Y 323
Fig. 3. Electron micrograph Irom a control animal demonstrating the presence ot HRP on the airway
sur-
face and no intercellular penetration (arrow~). The inset is a high magnification enlargement of the
boxed
area and clearly shows no penetratton of HRP Into the intercellular space, (C = cilia; GC = goblet
cell;
HRP = horseradish peroxidase; M = mitochondria; MV = microvilli: NU = nucleus;TJ = tight junction;
bar = 2,0 ~.) ":"
in mucosal permeability is transient in
nature, with maximal permeability oc-
curring between 30 rain a~d 6 h after
exposure and a return to control values
by 12 h after injury. In contrast, Marin
and associates (10) fourtd that perme-
ability returned to normal as early as 6
h after mechanical injury of the trache-
al mucosa. They showed that while only
point contacts were present between
epithelial cells 6 h after injury, the col-
Iodial intercellular tracer lanthanum
hydroxide was excluded from the inter-
cellular space (11). Total reformation
of the epithelial tight junctions was
found to occur by 12 h after mechani-
cal injury. The 6-h difference in the
time required to restore the barrier
after permeability between mechanical
and smoking injury is of interest. It
may be that the initial injury after
smoke exposure in our study was much
greater than the mechanical injury
studied by Gordon and Lane (11). It
could also be that the initial injuries
were the same, but complete restora-
tion of the junction was required to
prevent penetration of the HRP in our
study. A careful investigation using the
freeze cleave technique will be required
to settle this point.
Increased alveolar permeability in
symptomless chronic smokers was re-
cently demonstrated by Jones and col-
leagues (12). They measured the rate of
transfer of [99mTc]diethylenetraimine
penta-acetate from the lung into the
blood and found a significantly higher
transfer rate in the symptomless cigar-
ette smokers when compared with non-
smokers. That chronic smoking in-
creases airway permeability is of interest
with respect to our findings that corre-
late increased airway permeability with
inflammation. Thus, the increase in
permeability that Jones and colleagues
(12) observed may be related to airway
inflammation occurring before the onset
of the classic symptoms of bronchitis.
It is of interest that mueosal perme-
ability was increased at the same points
in time (30 min, 1, and 6 h), that the
tracheal wet wt/dry wt ratios were ele-
vated. This suggested that mucosal per-
6 t'o ~o ;o 20 ~'o
Hmules
Fig. 4. This figure shows the accumulation of
HRP (as % inlected dose) in the blood during the
40-rain sampling time and demonstrates the marked
increase in HRP accumulation in the animals ex.
amined 30 rain after smoke exposure. Time 0 is the
time at which the HRP was placed on the tracheal
surface. Standard error bars are indlcalad,
meability is increased during the exuda-
tive phase of the it~flammatory response
induced by ~he tobacco smoke and re-
turns to normal as the exudation sub-
sides. A change in mucosal permeabil-
ity associated with acute inflammation
could have important implications with
respect to airway function. A number
of studies have shown that a wide vari-
ety of insults, including viral infections
(13), NO~ (14), and ozone (15), cause
increased bronchial hyperactivity, and
Empey and colleagues (16) have sug-
~. ooo=
In0 Pulls Whole C,garelle Smoke,
Fig. 5. This histogram shows Ihe mean slope or
rate of HRP penetration (as % injected dose) at
each of the time periods studied alter exposure to
100 puffs whole cigarette smoke. Each bar ~epre-
serifs the data lrom 5 animals. Standard error bars
are indicated, and experimental values signifi-
cantly different at the 95% confidence level are
aslerisked.
T!04.231004

:~24 -
HULBERT, WALKER. JACKSON. &ND HOGG
~ E
Hours Posl Cholfe~ge wdh 100 Pulls Whole Clgorelle ~moke
Fig. 6 A. ~ulnea pi9 trachea wet wt/dry wt ratio for 1he 24-~ examination period after exposure to
100
puffs whole cigarette smoke, Experimental values significantly different (p < 0.05) from 1hose ol
the con-
trol group a~e asterisked, B. The number of PMNImm of tracheal epithelium Ihroughoul the 24-h
I~on perio~ alter exposure to 1~ Duffs whole mgarette smoke. Standard error bars are indicate~, and
perzmental values slgmbcantly different (p < 0.05) from those of the control group are asterisked.
G. The
mitoU¢ m~ex or number of mitoseslmm of guinea pig t[ac~eal epithelium for the 24-h examinalio~
perio~
after exposure to 100 pu~fs whole cigarette smoke. ~la~t~ error bars are indicateU, and experimental
values szgnihcantly ~ifferenl (p < 0.05) from those of the ¢ontroI group ar~ asl~isked. D. Basement
brahe are~ mm~/mm guinea pig tracheal epilhelium for the 24-h examination period alte~ exposure to
100
pulls whole mg~relte smoke. ~tandard error bars are indicated, and ~xperimenlal values significantly
~ifle~enl (p < 0.05} from those of the control 9~oup are asterisked. (PMN = polymorphonuclear leuko-
cyzes).
gested that the increased nonspecific
reactivity is related to "mucosal dam-
age." Although the nature of this mu-
cosal damage has not been well de-
fined, Boucher"and co-workers (2)
have presented data suggesting that the
hyperreactivity and increased mucosa[
permeability may be linked. The pres-
ent study was relevant to this question
because it showed that increased muco-
saI permeability is a feature of the exu-
dative phase of the acute inflammatory
reaction. This raised the possibility
that the common denominator between
viral infections, ozone, NO~, cigarette
smoke, etc., may well be linked to the
increased mucosal permeability that is
associated with mucosal inflammation.
~ s ,
°il[i'l r I
Hours Post Cholle~e w~th 100 Pulls Whole C go:elle ~moke
F~g. 7 A. Goblet cellslmm guine~ pig tracheal epilhelium for the 24.h examination period afler
exposure
to 1~ p~lfs whole mgarette smoke. B. Mast cell~mm of guinea pig Vacheal eoithelium for the 24-h ex-
ammahon period after exposure to 1~ puffs whole mgarette smoke. C. Eosinophilslmm ot guinea pig
Jrac~eal epithehum fo~ the 24.h examination per~ afte~ exposure to 1~ puffs w~ole cigarette smoke.
D. Plasma cell~mm guinea pig ffacheal epithelium 1or the 24-h examination peri~ alt~ exposure to 1~
puffs whole cigarelte smoke. Standard error bars are indicate, and experimenlsI ~lues significantly
diif~ent (p < 0.05] fr~ Jhose of the contr~ group a~e asterisked.
The precise reason for the increased re-
activity could not be pinpointed in these
experiments, but increased exposure of
nerve endings (figure 2A and B), that
occurred as a result of the epithelial
damage is one possibility.
As shown in figure 6C the epithelial
repair begins about 12 h after the in-
jury when the number of basal cell mi-
toses increase. Previous investigators
(17) have demonstrated that exposure
to tobacco smoke results in a dose-re-
lated increase in mitotic activity that
peaks 24 to 36 h after exposure, with
delays as long as 72 h in previously in-
jured epithelia (18). Our data provided
additional information that showed
that permeability remains high after
the injury until the repair phase begins.
This means that toxic chemicals, in-
cluding carcinogens present in cigarette
smoke, could have prolonged access to
the dividing basal cell layer. Our work
was consistent with others (!!) who
have demonstrated that the new epithe-
lium is composed of squamous noncil-
iated cells that previously comprised
the basal cell layer.
It is of interest that the tracheal wet
wt/dry wt ratios follow a pattern al-
most directly opposite to that observed
for basement membrane thickness.
Comparison of Figure 6A with 6D
shows that the basement membrane
thickness decreased when the wet wt/
dry wt ratio increased in the first 6 h
after the injury. By 24 h, however, the
wet wt/dry wt ratio has decreased below
control values (p < 0.05), whereas the
basement membrane thickness was sig-
nificantly increased (p < 0.05) above
that of the control. Because of this in-
verse relationship, we felt that the in-
crease in basement membrane thickness
at 24 h after smoking represented the
synthesis of new material and could not
be attributed to swelling of the base-
ment membrane by an inflammatory
exudate. This suggested that increased
production of collagen and glycopro-
rein moities comprising the basement
membrane occurs in concerl with the
increase in basal cell mitoses, all within
a 24-h period. This observation was es-
pecially interesting in light of the recen-"
work by Vracko 119) and Vracko ant'
Benditt (20) relating basal membran~
thickness in diabetics to endothelia
turnover. They found that each genera
tion of endolhelium produces a laye
of basement membrane, and, mor.:-
over, that diabetics have a higher tha:
normal rate of endothelial turnove~
T!04231005

TABLE 1
INTEROBSERVER REPRODUCIBILITY
Polymorpho-
nuclear Mast Plasma
Milalic Goblet
Leukocyles Cells Cells
Figures Cells
Number of observations 368 83 113 83
145
Correlation 0.998 0.996 0.988 0.987 0.987
Slope of regression 0.907 0.990 0.900 0.985
0.810
Intercept of regression 1.27 1.65 0.73 - 0.88
0.67
Thus, Vracko argued that the excessive
accumulation of basal membrane found
in diabetics resulted directly from in-
creased turnover of the vascular en-
dothelium. Our data suggested that a
similar relationship may exist for the
airway epithelial turnover and its base-
ment membrane and raised the possi-
bility that the thickened basement
membrane seen in chronic inflamma-
tory states such as asthma may well be
related to an increased epithelial cell
turnover.
The cellular component of the in-
flammatory reaction was indicated by
a peak number of PMNs at 6 h after the
exposure (figure 60). Kilburn and co-
workers (21) have reported that in the
hamster, peak recruitment of PMNs in
response to tobacco smoke exposure
occurred at 24 h after insult, whereas
cotton dust and .tobacco extract caused
a peak recruitment between 6 and 12 h
after exposure. The difference between
our results and those of Kilburn and
co-workers (21) could represent either
exposure or species differences.
The data on eosinophils, mast cells,
and plasma cells (figure 7) reported
here were included for descriptive pur-
poses. It is possible that the reduction
in eosinophils could be related to their
emigration to the epithelial surface be-
cause we found the mucous layer rich
in eosinophils in favorable sections
where it was well fixed. However, this
observation cannot be quantified since
not all the tissues demonstrated an in-
tact mucous layer. The increase in epi-
thelial mast cells is interesting and sug-
gests that tobacco smoke might cause
the release of positive chemotactic fac-
tors that attract mast cells to the in-
jured region. The possibility that in-
creased numbers of mast cells might
contribute to airway hyperreactivity
deserves further investigation.
The sharp reduction in the number
of goblet cells observed in this study
(figure 7A) at 30 rain after exposure is
coincident with the increase in epitheli-
al permeability. This is interesting with
respect to previous studies (22) of guin-
ea pig tracheal epithelia using freeze
cleave techniques where a high degree
of disarray was found in the junctional
complexes between ciliated and dis-
charged goblet cells. A similar observa-
tion of junctional disarray was also re-
ported by Wade and Karnovsky (23) in
osmotically stressed epithelia. These
data suggested that there may be an in-
terrelation between goblet cell dis-
charge and increased mucosal perme-
ability. Although previous studies have
reported an increase in goblet cells
after exposure to tobacco smoke, they
have not concentrated on the changes
that occur immediately after injury.
An exception to this is a study by Reid
(24) in rats showing a decreased num-
ber of goblet cells 2 wk after injury and
then an increase to values that ex-
ceeded those of control values 4 wk af-
ter exposure.
In summary, the acute exposure of
guinea pigs to 100 puffs of whole to-
bacco smoke caused an inflammatory
reaction with a well-defined exudative
and proliferative phase. Increased mu-
cosal permeability was associated with
the exudative phase of the inflamma-
tory reaction and appeared to begin
with goblet cell discharge. The mucosal
permeability returned to control values
12 h after the exposure when the epi-
thelial repair phase began.
Acknowledgment
The writers express their gratitude to Joan
Dixon and Linda Hare in preparing the
manuscript, to Irene Nicols for help with
the graphics, and to Wendy Laird for re-
sourceful technical assistance.
References
1. Simani IAS, Inoue S, Hogg JC. Penetration
of the respiratory epithelium of guinea pigs fol-
lowing exposure to cigarette smoke. Lab Invest
1974; 3 ! :75-87.
2. Boucher RC, Johnston J, inoue S, Hulbert
W, Hogg JC. The effect of cigarette smoke on
the permeability of guinea pig airways. Lab In-
vest 1980; 43:94-100.
3. Widdlcome JG. Reflex control of trachea-
bronchial smooth muscle in experimental and
human asthma. In: Lichtcnstein LM, Austcn
cds, Asthma--Physiology, immunopharmacol-
ogy and treatmenh New York: Academic Pres.g
1977:225-31.
4. Guerzon GM, Pare PD. Michood MC, Hogg
JC. The number and distribution of mast cells in
monkey lungs. Am Rev Rcspir Dis 1979; 119:
59-66.
5. Moroz LA, Joubert JR, Hogg JC. A potent
non-peridoxasc glycoprotein tmmunogen in com-
mercial horseradish peroxidase. J Immunol 1974;
i 12:1094-9.
6. Saunders GL. Art of solid phase im-
munoassay including selected protocols. In:
Nakamura RM, ed, immunoassay in the clinical
lab. New York: Alan Liss Co., 1979:173-89.
7. Karnovsky MJ The uhrastructural basis of
capillary permeability studied with peroxidase as
a tracer. J Cell Biol 1967; 35:215-30.
8. Reynolds ES The use of lea~l citrate at high
pH as an electron opaque slain in electron micro-
scopy. J Biophys Riochem Cytol 1963; 10:308-12.
9. Dunnett CW. A multiple comparison proce-
dure for comparing several treatments with a
control. J Am Statist Assoc 1955; 50:1090-121.
10. Marin ML, Gordon RE, LaneBP. Develop-
ment of tight junctions in rat tracheal epithelium
during the early hours after mechanical injury.
Am Rev Respir Dis 1979; i 19:101-6.
i 1. Gordon RE, Lane BP. Regeneration of rat
tracheal epithelium after mechanical injury. II.
Restoration of surface integrity during the early
hours after injury. Am Rev Respir Dis 1976;
113:799-807.
12. Jones JG, Lawler P, Crawley JCW, Minty
BD, Hulands G, Veall N. Increased alveolar epi-
thelial permeability in cigarette smoke. Lancet
1980; 1(8159):66-8.
13. Laitmen LA, Ekin RB, Empey DW. et aL
Changes in bronchial reactivity after administra-
tion of llve attenuated virus. Am Rev Respir Dis
1976; 113:194-201.
14. Orehek J, Massari JP0 Gagrard P, Grinoud
G, Charpin J. Effect of short term, low level ni-
trogen dioxide exposure on bronchial sensitivity
in asthmatic patients. J Clin Invest 1976; 57:
301-7.
15. Golden JA, Nadel J, Boushey HA. Bron-
chial hyperirritability in healthy" subjects after ex-
posure to ozone. An1 Rev Respir Dis 1978; 118:
29:287-94.
16. Empey DW, Laitmen LA. Jacobs J, Gold
WM, Nadel J. Mechanisms of bronchial hyper-
reactivity in normal subjects after upper re-
spiratory infection. Am Rev Respir Dis 1976; 113:
131-9.
17. Wells AB, Lamerton LF. Regenerative re-
sponse of the rat tracheal epithelium after acute
exposure to tobacco smoke: a quantitative study.
J Nail Cancer lnst 1975; 55:887-94.
I$. Wilhelm D. Regeneration of tracheal epi-
thelium. J Pathol 1953; 65:543-57.
19. Vracko RV. Basal lamina layering in diabe-
tes mellitus. Evidence for accelerated rate of cell
death and cell regeneration. Diabetes 1974: 23:
94-104.
20. Vracko RV. Benditt EP. Manifestations of
diabetes mellitus: their possible relationships to
an underlying cell defect. Am J Pathol 1974;
75:204-21.
21. Kilburn KH, McKenzie WN, Thurston RJ.
Cellular effects of cigarette smoke on hamster
Ti04231006

airways. C'~t 1975: 67:545-9.
22. lnoue S, Hogg JC. Freeze-etch study of Ih¢
lracheal epithelium of normal guinea pigs with
particular relrerenc¢ to intercellular junctions. J
Uhraslruc! R~ 1977: 61:89-97.
7.3. Wade J'B, Karnovsky M.,]. Fracture faces of
osmotically' disrupted zonulae occludentes..I Cell
Biol 1974; 62:344-53.
HULBERT, WALKER. JACKSOH, Arid HOGG
24. Rcid L Bronchial mucus production in
health and disease, in: Liebow AA, Smith DE,
ecb,. "[he lung. International Academy of Path-
ology monograph no. 8. Ne'~-" York: The Williams
and Wilkins Co., 1978: 8:87-108.
T104231007
