Ness Motley Documents
Bio-Research Institute Third Report
Fields
- Notes
Produced by: PMI
Affected Defendants: PMI, CTR
- Type
- Report
- Characteristic
- Incomplete date
- Named Organization
- U.S. Public Health Service
- AMA
- British Medical Journal
- General Foods Comapny Laboratories
- FDA
- American Cancer Society
- American Heart Association
- Muscular Dystrophy of America
- National Science Foundation
- Council for Tobacco Research
- Sciences and Arts Foundation
- Bernard Reis & Company
- Motley & Holt
- American Association for the Advancement of Science
- American Association for Cancer Research
- American Chemical Society
- American Federation for Clinical Research
- American Geriatrics society
- American Medical Association
- American Society of Biological Chemists
- American Society for Experimental Pathology
- Society of Toxicololty
- The Endocrine Society
- the Gerontological Society
- Israeli Chemical Society
- Swiss Medical Association
- Society for Experimental Biology and Medicine
- New York Academy of Sciences
- Massachusetts MEdical Society
- New England Rheumatism and Arthritis Society and the Royal Microscopic Society of London
- American Society of Animal Science
- Royal Society of Health (London)
- and the Histochemical Society
- Named Person
- Page, Irvine
- Filtonburger
- Harpel, Dr. Peter
- Sandburg, Carl
- Berfeld, Peter
- Ph.D.
- Homburger, Regina T.
- Reis, Bernard
- Nollman, Bernice H.
- Bogdonoff, Philip D.
- Ph.D.
- Nixon, C. William
- Ph.D.
- Beiber, Robert F.
- M.S.
- Boger, Eliahu
- Ph.D.
- Baker, John R.
- S, F.R.M.
- Treger, Abraham
- Ph.D.
- Caulfield, James
- M.D.
- Murphy, Edwin B.
- M.D.
- Wilgram, George
- M.D.
- Ph.D.
- Noether, Gottfried
- Ph.D.
- Wadsworth, George
- Ph.D.
- Whitney, Rae
- Ph.D.
- Clifford
- Goodband
- D.V.M.
- Cormier, Helene
- Gaston
- Snown
- Panel, Anicmal Care
- Original File
- TobDocs1
- Author
- Langone, John
- Case
- Butler
- Site
- Box 11 (PM+)
Document Images
PRODUCED IN
BUTLER V. PHILIP MORRIS, ET AL.
DISSEMINATION IS PROHIBITED BY
PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED BY THE
COURT.

---

Bio-Research Institute
Incorporated
9 Commercial Avenue
John Langone, former
Medical Science Writer
The Boron Herald
Cambridge, Massachusetts 02141
Telephone: (617) 864-8735
Third Report
1966
Drawings and Photographs
Thomas Am$1er
This brochure woa made [m.ible by funds from the Sciences and ,4rts Foundation.
Dedham, Ma.~. and Irom B,o-Research Consultants, Inc.

The Front cover symbolizes the tree of life.
Aerial photograph shows Institute location.
Gifts and Bequests to Bio-Research Institute, Inc.
are Tax Deductible
to the extent prescribed by law
Under present U. S. Public Health Service cost-sharing policy, funds
from private sources are indispensable to obtain government health research
support. Each dime obtained from private sources can attract dollars of
government support. ~Nithout private money no Public Heal|h Service
support can be obtained.
L

Contents
Foreword
.............................................................................................. 6
Scientific Achievements ........................................................................ 7
Muscle Studies
...................................................................................... 8
The Heart Muscle in Muscular Dystrophy ......................................... 9
Studies on Diseases of the Vascular System " 10
Cancer Research ..................................................................................
11
Genetic Studies ....................................................................................
14
Histochemistry
...................................................................................... 14
Enz)a'nology Studies ..............................................................................
14
Endocrine Research .............................................................................. 15
Background
.......................................................................................... 17
The Seeds of Enterprise ...................................................................... 19
Facilities
................................................................................................ 19
Educational Programs .......................................................................... 20
Extramural Staff Activities .................................................................. 20
Statement of Financial Research Support .......................................... 22
Director~ and Ol~..cers ..........................................................................
23
Research Associates ..............................................................................
23
Advisor~
................................................................................................ 23
Current Bibliography ............................................................................ 24

i
Foreword
The continuous publication of our research findings in scientific journals and
through papers read at meeting~ of national scientific societies keep our colleagues
informed on our work. Periodic comprehensive reports such as the present one are
intended to provide information to the public who supports this Institute through
private donations and through grants of private and government foundations and
agencies. In addition, these reports endeavor to give an overall picture to the public
and scientists of the purpose, organization, method of work and achievements of this
Institute, the type of information which is not contained in scientific publicatiom..
Since publication in scientific journals establishes credit for the individuals who have
carried out the published work the present report denotes the Institute's studies
collectively without acknowledging individuals. A professional medical science writer
ha~ interviewed our staff and reports things as he sees them. From an experienced
*cience journalist we thus learn how others ~ee us and obtain a better view of the
whole than we may have ourselves.
On reviewing what John Langone has written whi!e he still was Medical writer
of the Boston Herald, we read about an impressive institution which has accomplished
much in a "..hort period of tirt,e. Muck, remains to be done to realize o**r fondest dream~.
This Institute ha., already made significant contributions a,:d is showing the way to a
new and fruitful approach to the solution of Bio-Medical problems.
On the occasion of the opening of the AMA Institute for Biomedical Research
Irvine Page noted that "After a decade or two a body of knowledge with some in-
ternal structure should begin to emerge." Here at Bio-Research Institute this has
already happened during our first eight ),ears and it will be the task of the coming
years to consolidate and to expand this structure of new knowledge, hoping that by
doing so some of the problems which we have discovered and defined will be solved
for the benefit of mankind.
F. Homburger, M.D.
President and Director
o
o

Scientific Achievements
Bio-Research Institute, Inc is an aggregation of scientists with a wide raoge of
interests. Their motivation ~s the inquiring mind of the scientist and the necessity of
increasing mankind's knowledge of the healthy and diseased bodies of all living crea-
tures. The basic research they perform falls within the spheres of experimental
pathology, endocrinology, genetics, biochemistry, immunochemistry, nutrition, histo-
chemistry and organic chemistry. These studies have some bearing on consti-
tutional diseases of man such as chronic heart failure, aging in general, muscular
dystrophy and related neuromuscular disorders, environmental hazards such as
carcinogens, the relationship of certain antigens to cancer, the relationship of serum
llpoproteins and lipids to arterial and cardiac disease, certain physiologic factors
affecting reproduction, and endocrine studies bearing on health and disease.
Some solid successes after eight year~ of operation are listed below, achievements
of which Bio-Research Institute may justifiably be proud. Some of this work already has
brought forth results which are clearly applicable to the problems of human health, and
the Institute's achievements have been widely recognized :
• Bio-Research Institute has discovered, for the first time, a spontaneously and
predictably occurring heart disease, congestive heart failure, occurring in a laboratory
animal, the golden hamster. In essence, the discovery means that scientists can now
"take apart" the syndrome of heart failure.
• The discovery, of a dystrophy-like myopathy (muscle disease) in Syrian golden
hamsters will go a long way toward advancing the understanding of httman mus-
cular diseases.
• Findings made by Bio-Research Institute relative to the liver carcinogenlc~ty
of Safrole and to the mode of action of tobacco smoke condensates when al~lied to
the skin are clearly relevant to the serious problems of man's relationship to his
environment.
• Following the catastrophic Thalidomide episode which left in its wake thou-
sands of malformed children, Bio-Researrh Institute under a contract with the Food and
Drug Administration studied the possible usefulness of inbred hamsters for the study
of drugs for teratogenicity, the causation of fetal malformation. This work continues
under a grant from the National Institutes of Health.
• Bio-Research Institute studies have resulted in the development of a method
for the formation of water-insoluble, biologically active antigens. The water-insoluble
antigen is a new tool in immunology. It makes it possible for the first time to obtain
specific antisera against minute amounts of antigens free from contaminating antibodies
against other antigens occurring in large excess.
• The development of an analogous t~hnique perroitting the transformation
of any enzyme into a water-insoluble yet biologically active form. This new principle
not only allows easy removal of enzymes from reaction mixtures with multiple appli-
cations in industrial and basic research, but also permits the study of certain phases
of the mechanisms of enzyme-catalyzed reactions.
o

• By use of insoluble antigens, minute amounts of a strange antigen were
detected at Bio-Research Institute in the blood of virgin ,nice susceptible to certain
tumors, whereas this antigen was not found in non-susceptible virgin mice.
• Systematic research on the chemical composition of mouse uterine secretions
has resulted in the isolation of a mucin-llke glycoprotein with a ve,y high content in
carbohydrate and which contains a novel carbohydrate component.
• A new approach to the study of human serumlipoproteins has made it
possible at Bio-Research Institute to draw conclusions on the complex molecular
structure of low-density lipoprotein, a substance which occurs in human serum and
which is responsible for the transport of most of the fat in blood, and which may be
implicated in the deposition of fatty materials in patients with vascular diseases.
• Fundamental studies in en~'mology at Bio-Research Institute ha~'e given
further insight into the behavior of enzymes at high dilutions and into the mechanism.
of their inhibition by macromolecular polyanionic substances.
• Bio-Research Institute studies have demonstrated that the incidence of lung
adenomas (tumors consisting of glandular material) in certain strains of mice was
reduced in groups of animals having received one or more intravenous injections of
from 2 to 4.5 mg of a denicotinized cigarette tar condensate. The findings, therefore,
suggest the existence of a tumor-growth-inhibiting substance in cigarette smoke
condensate.
• Bio-Research Institute studies of anticoagulant and clot-dissolving materials
in secretions of the mouse uterus may apply to problems currently encountered with
certain widely used hormonal drugs.
Some of the Institute's other research projects have yielded new and valuable
knov,ledge, the practical significance of which may not yet be apparent.
Muscle Studies
During the early year~ of the Institute a study was begun on the inheritance of
coat color in hamsters, as well as on the anatomical features of the various inbred
lines with different coat color~ which had been developed. It was soon noted that
one line, identified as BIO 1.50, had a shorter life span than all the others, and ~hat
animals in this line showed evidence of premature aging, becoming weak and dying
at about 200 days of age. Subsequent microscopic studies revealed cardiac lesions,
and shortly thereafter typical lesions in skeletal muscle were observed and recognized
as resembling muscular dystrophy.
This discover7 of a dystrophy-like myopathy in Syrian golden hamster~ ~ an
achievement which has made Bio-Research Institute a leader in the field of muscle
research -- is significant became the heart muscle also is involved and a unique
opportunity is provided for the study of spontaneous heart muscle necrosis.
The ~nly dy.~trophy-like mu.~cle dls.-.a~e which was noticed ~-x't urring in animals
up to the time of this discovery was spontaneous dystrophy in mice and chickens.
Myopathies induced by vitamin E. deficiency have also been described in rabbits,
hamster~ and desert rats. The newly-observed myopathy evoked considerable interest
in the scientific world. (including two editorials in the British Medical Journal
"Lancet") because it appeared to have a simple genetic mode of transmission
(three separate genetic studies indicate transmission of the disease or the suscep-
tibility to the disease by an autosomal |-ccessive gene).
"['he animals are not severely int'apacitated until late stages of the disease, which
means they are able to breed and are available for study over extended periods of time.
o
1"-4

Work carried out in the Bio-Research Institute since this discovery has dealt
with the detailed descr;ption of the disease, its genetics, histopathology., histochemist~',
and its enz.vmology. Attempts have been made to clarify its pathogenesis, and to evalo
uate the position of hamster myopathy among the many experimental myopathies
and its relationship to progressive muscular dystrophy in man.
These studies have demonstrated that in the inbred lines carr)'ing the dystrophic
gene, all animals develop myopathy. When animals beyond weaning stage are sub-
jected to the severe exercise test of swimming, all individuals of the dystrophic lines
show weakness of the adductor muscles of their hind legs. This occurs after as little
as one hour of swimming. By four hours it is evident in all animals of the dystrophic
lines, whereas this type of weakness of the hind leg~ is not seen in equally stressed
individuals of non-dystrophic lines. Animals allo,ved to live a normal life and to be.
bred have relatively few litters, the females usually dying after the second or third
delivery.. The average life-span of breeding females is 144 days,, that of males 130
days, and that for the combined sexes of the dystrophic 14.6 line is 146 days. Death
usually occurs from cardiac failure with decompensation.
These studies have shown that until the animals die they suffer from progressive
muscle weakness, not growing as well as animals of other lines. Their "normal" or
abnormally high body weight at later ages is the result of fluid retention, while their
organs and muscle mass are actually normal or reduced in size, with the exception
of liver and heart which are often markedly enlarged.
Since dystrophy-like myopathy and cardiac necrosis of hamstem are transmitted by
an autosomal recessive gene or genes, it is possible that the genetic constitution causes a
primary enz2,'matic defect similar in its general nature to other inborn errors of metabo-
lism. In that case, the problem is to discover the primary molecular disturbance as
distinct from the secondary changes which result from muscle breakdown.
It is also possible that only the susceptibility to the disease is inherited and that
unspecific and perhaps ubiquitous environmental factors could be responsible for
triggering the disease in susceptible animals. This situation would be analogous to
the combination of inheritance and milk agent which in mice cause cancer of the
breast. In that event, it would remain to discover in addition to the primary molecular
disturbance, the environmental agent or agents.
Attempts have so far failed to transmit the myopathy to animals of non-suscep-
tible strains by direct injections of crude muscle and Organ extracts, supernatants
and cell-free filtrates from muscle and kidney tissue cultures as well as by injection of
the cell cultures themselves into newborn and weanling animals.
The Heart Muscle
in Muscular Dystrophy
The acquisition of knowledge concerning heart involvement in progressive mus-
cular dystrophy and in other forms of primary myopathies is important from several
viewpoints. Ignorance of this subject may lead not only to i**correct clinical classifica-
tion of the cardiac symptoms, but also to inaccurate etiological diagnosis and treat-
ment. From a pathophysiologic viewpoint, cardiac involvement is of great interest
in respect to both its hemodynamic effects per se and the underlying mechanisms of
heart failure. Furthermore, studies of this type of cardiac condition provide an oppor-
tunity to gain information concerning the difference between the disease susceptibility

l
10
of the cardiac and skeletal muscles, since virtually nothing is known of the factors
that determine which of these two structures will undergo degeneration in any given
set of pathogenic circumstances. From a biochemical viewpoint, an analysis of the
altered myocardial metabolism may elucidate the primary biochemical derangement
responsible for the disease of striated muscles. In addition, animals which invariably
develop progressive fatal heart failure constitute a uniquely valuable model for the
study of drugs that may benefit the failing heart and circulation.
Studies on Diseases of
the Vascular System
Over the years, great emphasis has been placed on the blcod serum l'evel of
cholesterol in relation to heart and blood vessel disease. Cholesterol v~as singled out
among all the blood lipid components simply because an easy clinical method for
measuring it has been available for some 40 years. It is accepted that cholesterol
occurs in the serum only as an integral part of the lipoproteins. Therefore, the relation
of these serum proteins to heart disease should be at least as close as that of cholesterol.
In fact, certain researchers feel that lipoproteins may be even more important than
cholesterol.
Bio-Research Institute has been engaged in studies of beta-lipoprotein and its
relation to disease. With experience gained investigating the interactions between
certain large, charged molecules and beta-lipoproteins, the first practical, simple and
accurate method for the clinical determination of beta-lipoprotein in serum was
developed. Statistical evaluations on large populations without costly and intricate
instrumentation, thus, became practical for the first time. Subsequent work has led
to new ways of purifying serum beta-lipoprotein with charged macromolecular poly-
anions as precipitants.
At the present time, human serum lipoprotein is being reacted with proteolytic
enzymes, i.e., protein-splitting enzymes, including trypsin. Lipoprotein which contains
75 per cent fats and 25 per cent peptides has been found to be only very slowly
degraded by trypsin, and this degradation stops at about a point when only a quarter
of the peptides is removed. The lipid does not separate from the lipoprotein during
this procedure. -
Amino acid analysis showed that the amino acids or peptides which are re-
moved have exactly the same composition as those which remain on the lipoprotein.
From this, it is concluded that the trS'psin does not take off a small part of the protein
from the surface of the lipoprotein, but that certain particles of lipoprotein are com-
pletely broken down, while others are not degraded at all.
This led to a closer look at certain structures making up the giant particles of beta-
lipoprotein. It is believed that instexd of having a single large spherical particle contain-
ing all of the lipids and a thin coating of peptides at the surface, there are small
spherical particlm of lipids coveted with peptides, and that many of the small ,~pheri.
cal particles clump together to form a large spherical particle. Thh is the structure
which, at the moment, explains best the experimental findings. Modified lipoprotein
can be prepared by proteolytic digestion, with the resulting products being useful
for study/ng the steric organization of the water-soluble lipoproteins.
Degradation of certain lipoproteins and of chylomicrons by the enzyme lipo-
protein lipase is an important step in the lipid metabolism of the human body and
lipoprotein lipase has been known to be generated in serum upon administration of
the mucopolysaccharide, heparin, a substance which prevents clotting of the blood,
