Ness Motley Documents
Federal Government Involvement in the Smoking Controversy
Fields
- Notes
Produced by: TII
Affected Defendants: B&W, TII, RJR
- Type
- Outline
- Alias
- Glantz 2200.01
- 1404.03
- Characteristic
- marginalia, no primary author
- Named Person
- Burney
- Bennett
- Nuberger, R.
- Blatnik
- Moss
- Kennedy
- Brooke
- Byrne
- Hatfield
- Nixon
- O'Neill
- Anderson, J.
- Drinan
- Hart
- Fenwick
- Califano
- Richmond
- Danforth
- Gephardt
- Jacobs
- Quayle
- Moakley
- Carter
- Koop
- Schweiker
- Pinney
- Waxman
- Horrigan
- Mattox
- Pertschuk
- Heftel
- Inouya
- Wylie
- Bennett
- Original File
- TobDocs1
- Case
- TX-AG
- Site
- Texas Co-Counsel
Document Images
1957
ex ess!ve clgare~:e smoking is a cause:lye factor in lung cancer
carry label, "Warning: Prolonged use of =his produc~ ~ay resu!~ in
cancer, in lung, hear: and circulatory ai!=en:s, and in other
diseases."
support progr~_~.
1958
scmool children on "harmful effec:s of ~obacco, alcohol and ocher
July: Re~. Bia=nik (D-Minz.) im:roduce$ bŁ1l =o give FTC power
1960
~J .anu~'r~: FTC c.l!a cigarec:e m~-nufacturers Co mcop "=at derby"
. acvtFz~sing and cease rt*e ~ing Co ~prove4 heal~h effec=s of fil=e-s
013A002C
PLAINTIFF'S
EXHIBIT
10308

president Eisenhower to es:ab!ish co~m!ssion to s~udy ~obacoo and
health questions.
J.~ne: Surgeon General Terry anmounces fo.--~a=ion of Advisory
o~.i=:ee on SmokinK and H~a!~h.
Sen. Mo.s (D-Utah) in~roduce~ measur. =o $1ve Food azd D~a&
A-'~.'.nis~ra~iou (FDA) sate power to police content, ad~r:!sln~ and
laSe!in~ of ciEare:tes as :-DA has over food, dt-ugs and cosmetics.
196~
c~gare::e s=okin~ is causally related to lun~ cancer in men, is the
mo~t imporz.n= cause of chro~ic bronchitis, ~ay con~rlbu~e ~o other
diseases and is "a health hL~a2d of j'~ficient ~mportance in ~he U.S.
Sen. Maurlne Neuber~er (D-0re.) Im~rodu=es bill ~i~.ng FTC
authority ~o regulate cigarette advertising amd labe!~ng.
packaK%s and in adver:isin~.
J~e-Ju!v: House Commerce Co~i::~e ha~ hearinKs on ~mokin~ and
5ea[za. ~C delays its wa~ing proposal pending.Congresslonal
1965
J~mua.-~: U.$. Public Seal%h Se~-~ice (I~) bu~|e~ propo,al
establishes National Clearin~hou, e for ~moki~ az~ ~ealth.
Ju!v: Cigarette Labelin~ and Advertisi~ Ac~ e~anted, that "the
----Yi c may
pu~ . be adequately informed ~hat =igsre~e smoking may be
o.
013A002D

(1965 cont.)
"confusing" regula:ions. Principal provisions:
o Clgaret:e packs mus: bear a bea!=h Tautlon label.
adver:isimg require:emma in connection wi~h smoking and
health u_ncil a= least July I, 1969.
~'~C and =he Deparument of Health, Educe=ion and Welfare
(HEW) are to keep Congress i~formed on =he issue through
annual reports.
1 966
March: ~'2C reve s
r es its 1960 position by allowinK car and
u:co=ine yields Co be used in cisare=:e adver:ilin$. But i= says
=here should be no implies=ions of any heal:h significance.
M~.__~v: HEW releases repot= of a household survey of "hea!~h
c~aracteris:ics of smokers," asser:In~ links between cigarem~e
smoklmg ~nd illness.
June: Federal Commu~ica=ions Commission (FCC) ~=les =ha= sis=ions
w---~.ch a~- cigare==e co=merioa!s must° under =he "fairness doo=rlne,"
broad=as: antl-smoking announcements.
~'~C recommends to" Congress =ha= tar ~nd micotlne yield be required
cigareT=e packs and in all adver=i~In&. ~eco~enda:ion is included in
commission's firs= repot= =o Congress u~.der the ~965 labeling
Iz subsequent ~nnual reports.
Ju!7: Sen. Moss proposes requiring !abellnK in advertising, adding
s=a:emen: Of ~ar and nicoTime ~ield co packs and allowing FTC and HEW
Co set maximum cigarette length.
September: Sems. Kennedy (D-N.Y.) and Randolph (D-W.Va.) propose
authorizing FCC co re~ula=e cig&retce broadcast adver=islmg and to
~emd ~=cernal Revenue Code Co tax ci~are=ces on basis of Tar and
nico=Ine yield.
November: ~'~C publishes firs= semi-~nnual ~easur~ments of =at and
n~co=ine c=nTen: of U.S. clg~re~es, as requested by the SenaTe
Commerce Com=i~:ee
- 3 -
013A002E

Pebruarv: FCC proposes ban on broadcas: clgare::e adver:Ising.
~::h-ADril: Sens. Brooke (k-Mass.) a~ Wil!lams.(~-Del.) and
~47. Corm.an (D-Cal.) relncroduce 19~7 aeasure co terminate
toba::o price suppor: program &md exclude shipment of
~nder P.L. ~8~, in~e.'-~a~Io~a! ~rade expansion and promotion
Fmrch-June: House Co=metre Co:mit:ee hears Ces:i=on~ on ca:on-
of Cl$are~:e LabellnE Ac~, repor:s "no~h!nK mew' in ~clen-.
evidence si~Ce ~965 hearings.
Ma._/v: FTC renews ~96~ proposal =o require health warnimg i=
c~gareu:e ads, &bsen: ~-ny ex:ensic~ of ~he 1965 ac~.
Ju!.__~v: Senaze Co=merce Cons'J=er |ubcommlttee hears ~es:imony on
ex:emslon of ~965 ac:. Cigarette manufacturers ask a~n~i-trus:
exemp=ion to pe-~i~ Inter-compan7 a~ree~en: vcl~ntari!7 to end
broadcasz adver~isin~ because of its ~nlque appeal ~o young persons.
Oc:ober: ~e;. B.vr~e (D-Pa.) presen:s cigarette labe!img
amencmen~ requiring packs bear s:atemenc of "fire ha:ards presente~ by
s~okin~."
Dece:ber: Sen. Ea=fie!d (R-Ore.) proposes bill insz~ac:i=g Federal
Av~a:~on Ad:izls~ra:/on (FA.A) co require air carriers co separa=e
smokin~ passengers from monsmokers.
~ep. O'Neill (D-Mass.) i~troduces bill co increase clg~ret:e excise
cam, m~nles to go. for research uuder the new Naziona! Cancer Progra=.
1970
ADri_____~l: Presiden~ Nixon $iEns new Public Health Ci~&rette Smoking
an ex:enslon of :he 1965 legislation. The ~urpo|e is reiterated: :he
public ~hould be "adequatel~ info.-me4 ~hat cigarette |mokŁm~ ray 5e
hazardous co health." Principal provi|ions:
o The law formalizes ~heoffer of ~he ˘IKare~te makers ~o
end radio-iv Adverr!slmg, beglnninK Jan. ~, 1971.
o Package "caution" label is revised tD the~present warning.
o Sza:es and localities may no~ impose on cigarette adver-
=islng or promotion "require=en=s or prohibition based on
smokln~ and health".
- & .
013A002F

o ~'2C may noc furGher Its wa=-~Inl-ln-adver:islng trade
resula~ion proposal until a~ leas~ Duly 1971, af:er which
fur:her regu!a:ion.
o ~'2C and H~ will con=inue their annual reports to Consress
~ Uhe smoklug-heal:h 18sue.
-~iiI ~he tobacco price suppor: program, expor: subsidies,
overseas sales promotion and government inspection and grading.
August: ~'ZC proposes a ~cle ~o require ~ar and nicotine yields
.
November: The n~w ci;aret~e package label becomes effec:ive:
"Wal-ning: The Surgeon General Has Deterulned Tha~ Cigarette Smoking
Is Dangerous ~o Your ~eal:h."
December: ~-2C ac:ep:s, by suspending rule making, an induszry
proposal vo!un:arily ~o display ~ar and nicotine yields in all
clgareu~e adver~Islng.
FCC ~.=nounces cha~ af:er cigare~:e commercials are off :he air ~he
"fairness do=urine" ~ill no lon~er a~ply, ~ha: broadcas:ers may assume
~here is no more controversy abou: a!le~ed ill effects. Anti-smokin8
announcemen:s may be broadcas: as public ~ervlce anuouncemen~.
Col'~=nis: ~ack Anderson repor:s ~ha: yet-=o-be-released Joinu PAA-PHS
study concludes tobacco smoke does non represen~ a hea!:h ha:ard to
nonsmoking co===erciai airline passensers.
1971
January: Claiming a health hazard co nonsmokers, SurSton General .
"Ste~nf~!d proposes a government ban on smoki~ in public places.
.Januarv-Amril: Ne~ Congressional bills propose ~o limit or ban
cigare:~e smoking aboard alroraf:, trains, buses ~nd ~assenger
vessels; to ban ~ailing of u.usoliclted cigarette sampAss; =o prohibi~
business ~ax deduction for amy cigarette adver~Isln~.
FTC Łor'aa!l7 ac'Cepts tobacco Industry's proposal for volunmary.
display of uar and nicotine convene in brand adver~isemencs.
April: Tobacco lnstitute announces ins member companies will
enh-~-~-~for~h voluntarily display ~he package wa.--ning label in all
- 5 -
013A0030

(1971 con:.)
print advertising.
Ju!v: FTC vote, to vacaue i~s Congressionally e~bargoed proposal
uo~equlre a health warning in cigarette ads. ~nste~:l, ~he
co=:ission says, lu will ne$otiate wlth.each m~nufact~rer.to
require a more "clear" and "consplcu~us package waz-n~ng ~n
ci~areu:e ads.
National C!earinEhou, e for SmoklnE and ~ea!~h remains a Ne~ York
a~ver:islnE aSeucy for $~56,000 ~o prepare anmi-smokln~ ads for
November: U.S. Disuricu Cour: reJecu~ plea ~f ~ix broadcas~ers.~o
de~Ision i~ sa~s: "Con~ress has ~he power ~o prohlbi~ uhe adver~Isln~
of ci~are~ss in any media."
Sen. Harks (D-~nd.) In:roduces a bill ruquirin~ cigarec:e ads deplc:
porzlons.of pack bearin~ Surgeon General's heal~h warninB.
1972
˘~spia~ of the packa~ war~In~ i~ adverzise=ents.
Februa---~: Chain-man Moss of Senate Consumer ~ubc=mmiz:ee has hearings
on h~s ~97~ proposal to regu!A:e ~ar amd nico=ine con~ent of ciga-
rettes. The FAA-PES re?or~ o= smokin~ in aircraft is released af:er
Sen. Cook (K-Ky.) =hi~es PES witnesses Zor ~ot making public i:s
conclusion. The 8S-page report says tobacco s~oke is "~u/ged no~ to
represen~ a health ha:ard to ~h.e non~oki~ passengers.
~r~h: Supreme Cour~ upholds appellate court's finding of
˘ons:Itutlonali~y of the 1970 law ~hat ~rohlbi~s broadcas~ cigarette
• advertising.
September: Civil Aeronau:Ics Board (~.B) proposes airlines
vo~un~ar~!? segregate smokers and nonsmokers.
1973
'J~nua.-v: EEW's annual report to Congress On ~okin| and health,
~rsu ~o o~lU legislative recc",enda~ious, sul~ests special hamards
for women smokers And ~helr unborn children.
March: Sen. Moss in=roduces hi!is to prohlblu broadcast advertisln~
o:-~.utle cigars, impose a mar uax and di~allow business expense tax
deductlons, for clgaretue a~verulssmenus.
- 6 -
O
~4
013A0031

(I 973 con:.)
~'~smokgrs because vol'~n~ar7 arramsement$ aren'~ worklnS. "The
~: Cons~e: Product Safe:~ Co~ilai~ (CPSC) chai~a~ tells New
N~erous Congressmen and ~e Tobacco Ims=i~e poln~ ou~ than Consist
Produc= Safe~y Ac:, se~:In~ up =he co=missiom, ~pecifically
tobacco from CPSC ~isdlc:ion.
Se~uember: CPSC makes public a "cmnsu.~er product hazard index" and
puts ~obacco in an area cf "~ues:ionable Jurisdiction."
Presideu: Nixon signs bill prohibiting broadcast advertising of
lit:is cigars.
o
November: General Se:-~Ices Administration (GSA) 0 ~Ich operates all
~e~era! buildings, issues vol~n~a:-y guidelines res~rictlng smokin~ in
federal conference rooms, audi:oriu-~s, cafeterias, elevators and so~e
shut:!e vehicles.
December: CAB urges its employees :o be "observers." reporting
V~oiat~ons of smokizg regulations and actions taken by airplane cre~s
to e-~or~e._ - the ~a!es.
1 97.___~&
Pebruarv:. Sen. Moss ~nd American Public Health Associ&:ion pe~i=Ion
CPSC ~o prohibi~ sales of cigarettes ~ieldlng
no:im~ that limit "will remove the nos~ dangerous varieties of
cigarettes from the ~arke~."
ADrift ]~nce--s~:aCe Commerce Co˘=is,lon (ICC) imRlemen=s rule
~a:ing 20 percen~ of sea~s on Inters~x~e buses for smoklm~
U.S. Comp~rollsr General rules ~hat CPSC "does noc have the authority
~o ac~'[ on the Moss pe=ition ~o ban sale of hish ~ar and nlco~Ine
ci~are=tes.
FT.C begins investigation of sizt of warnings on cigars:re adver-
tisements, requesting of ~00 ~e~,papers and ma~amlnes.coples of all
cigarette ads r~n in precedin~ six months.
May: CP~C decides i= backs authority to se~ mandatory cigare::e tar
-eT~vels as urged in ~he Moss pecicion.
- 7 -
013A0032

FCC votes to limit application of "fai.-~ess doctrine" to broadcast
vi~-~oimts, rever,ing ~he 1967 application ~o a whole category of
produc= advertising, clg&re=tes.
August: In Washington. Sen. Moss, the American Public ~ea!th
Association and the local lung association petition U.S. Distrlc=
Court ~o ~ale CPSC has authority =o regulate cigarettes.
September: CPSC reJec:s'fu.-~Iture manufacturers' petition to regulate
c~garecze burnln8 clme before regu!azlm~ upholstery f!a=mability,
c!alming'lack .of Jurisdiction over cigzret:es.
October: Presidenz Ford asks Nations! Cancer Advisor? Board (NCAB) to
assess scientific evidence suppor:i~K responsible re~!atlon of
clgaret~e tar and nicotine bevels.
November: NCAB makes persia! response to President Ford, whose
rea~z~cn the New York Times records as "coo!."
U.S. Diszric~ Court denies cigarette manufac'u, re-s'. .pe:i'~ion to
dismiss :he Moss sui: requiriz~ CPSC regulate :at and nicozlue levels.
December: Fu.-T.IZure manufacturers seek tour= Judgment the= CPSC does
have 2urisdiczion over clgare:ze ~u--nlng rates.
U.S. afoOt-hey and cigare=te companies again requesz court dismissal of
Moss suit, claiming CPSC lacks Jurisdic:ion over cigarette tar
IS75
M~ro_____~h: ~T.C's 197& report to Congress a~ain criticizes clgare:te
acver:islng bu: make~ no reference .to the advertising investiKation
beg~n =he previous April.
Sen. MOes, with no reference to hi, court suit, Im~roduces bill =o
Kive'CPSC Jurisdiction =o regulate ~&r and mico:ine.
e
Ma.__Zv: U.S. Dis~ric: Cour: rules in Mose euit tha: CPSC does have
authority to regulate tar and nicotine. House and Senate consider
bills ~o exempt tobacco ~rom CPSC Jurlsdic:Ion.
Ju!_____~v: S~n. Moss reintroduces bill requiring PTC to s~ limits on
~nc nicozine allowable i~ cigare:zes.
- 8 -
013A0035

(197~ cont.)
~: He)otis that ~'T~C pla~s to cha:$e cigarette companies for
October: ~C racalv~s $50.000 frou P~'~ National Cancer
~ov~be:: Rep. D:im~ (D-Mass.> introd~es bill to stiffen cigarette
smoklnE in federal buildinss and lu~ars~a~e u:anspor=a:ion and
increase the fede:~! cigarette tax to fund heam=/lunE reset=oh.
1976
Feb:-u~rv_: Sens. Kennedy (D-~.ass.) and ~a== (D-Colo.) introduce bill
co ~x cigarettez on car and nicotine concen~, wi=h es=i~a=ed
billion added ~nua! :evenue fo= ~ove~men= health research.
D..nan Introduce measuzes
Sen. Ha=field and ~e?.
~m~: ~C's annual report to Congress says i: 'is Investigating
cigarette adve::isi~ ":o dete~Ime ~e:he: ~he:e may be decepcio~ and
~mfai~ess.
Preslde~= Ford sign~ feEls!scion ex~p~i~E tobacco f=om CPSC
Is=ion, m~king =oo= =he Moss lawsuit ~d =he ~i=ure m~nufac=urers'
effort =o O~=Ain regu!a:ion of cigarette ~u~in& rime.
~CC bans smokir.~ In raii=~d dinin~ c~ s but
orders sepa=~e coach c~:s foT smokin~ ~nd nousmoking passengers.
Ju!~: Gemera! Acco~=i~g Office (G~) urges.Com~ress =o =i~h~en
smo~in8 re~ulazlous.
AuK~:: Senate defeats, 60-~5, effort to add ~ar:-Kenn~y tar and
uico~ine ~ax ~ a pendin8 tax bill.
October: ICC ~ends i~s ~97~ regulation, increasing from 20
percen~ the allo~en= of bus seats for ~oker~. Bus opera=ora had
requested 50 percent.
Claimin~ tobacco smoke a~d radioactivity are ~ealthy combine=ion,
Na~ional Park Semite bans smoking In federally o~ed caves.
GSA requests "Affi~a~ive ac:ion" by a~ency hea~ In each federal
building i: o~e~a~es ~o Impiemen~ ~mokln; re~ric:ion Euldelines
Issued In ~9~], a~king "full coopera~ion...Im en~uriu
equitable balance is main=ained between ~he rights of nonsmokers and
~hose of
- 9 -
01 3A0034

1977
Janua-'L~: ~ep. Drlnan In=roduces bills =o provlda ~nn~xl HEW re~org
ADri!: .Sen. Ear: and ~ep. Drimam Iz=roduc~ ~eal~h.~ro~ec=~on Tax Ac~
labeling.
~izis=razi~n's healzh plan will be decreasimg =he n~ber of
~okers.
~ ~rohibics smokiug In mobile passenger lo~s a~ ~ashin~zon's
Dul!es Inze~a~ional Airpor=.
July: Eouse defe~s what has become an annual effort :o e!imina:e
~oca:co price support
~C's 1976 reporz ~o Congress urge~ limning ~n packs ~d in
adver:Isin~ ~he ~leld of "any additional dangerous co=pone~=s of
cigare~e smoke, ~he measuramen, of ~.ich c~ be eszablished by
"furzher scientific or medical
AuZusz: Rep. Penwick (~-N.J.) in=roduc~s measur~ requirin~ asbestos
~n~ cigarez:e =anufac:ur~rs ~o compensa:~ workers disabled by
~plo~en~-relazed diseases "~ause~ by ~he ~nha!a:ion or
of asbestos, and/or ghe [nhalac~on of asbescol coupled wlzh
inha!ac.ion of cigare=:e gobac:o smoke."
October: H~ Secre~a~ Califano orde{s r~va! of a~h~rays from
~c'nfere=ce rooms ~nd posting of no-smokim~ si~s in EE~ e!eva:ors.
~edical devices, asser:In~ a~s izply heal~h claims.
naziona! no-s=okin~ day; ~ncrea~ed federal ci~ar~=~ max; a g~ on
˘Iga.re~:e s~!es in HEW buildings; paid time off for federal ~rkers
attending stop-s~oking clinics; s~reng:hened package wa~ing;
phase-ou= of federal ~obacco supper: programs,' with ~ocia! welfare
help for s~al! ~obacco fa~ers.
November: Following ˘riglcism of Richmond's proposal ~o end tobacco
price suppor~ programs, Califano tells press he will noz "=if: a~
~indm i ii."
- I0 -
013A0035
