Jump to:

Ness Motley Documents

Federal Government Involvement in the Smoking Controversy

Date: No date
Length: 24 pages
507118682-507118705
Jump To Images
ness 00000001

Fields

Notes

Produced by: TII

Affected Defendants: B&W, TII, RJR

Type
Outline
Alias
Glantz 2200.01
1404.03
Characteristic
marginalia, no primary author
Named Person
Burney
Bennett
Nuberger, R.
Blatnik
Moss
Kennedy
Brooke
Byrne
Hatfield
Nixon
O'Neill
Anderson, J.
Drinan
Hart
Fenwick
Califano
Richmond
Danforth
Gephardt
Jacobs
Quayle
Moakley
Carter
Koop
Schweiker
Pinney
Waxman
Horrigan
Mattox
Pertschuk
Heftel
Inouya
Wylie
Original File
TobDocs1
Case
TX-AG
Site
Texas Co-Counsel

Document Images

Text Control

Highlight Text:

OCR Text Alignment:

Image Control

Image Rotation:

Image Size:

Page 1: 00000001 Log in for more options!
1957 ex ess!ve clgare~:e smoking is a cause:lye factor in lung cancer carry label, "Warning: Prolonged use of =his produc~ ~ay resu!~ in cancer, in lung, hear: and circulatory ai!=en:s, and in other diseases." support progr~_~. 1958 scmool children on "harmful effec:s of ~obacco, alcohol and ocher July: Re~. Bia=nik (D-Minz.) im:roduce$ bŁ1l =o give FTC power 1960 ~J .anu~'r~: FTC c.l!a cigarec:e m~-nufacturers Co mcop "=at derby" . acvtFz~sing and cease rt*e ~ing Co ~prove4 heal~h effec=s of fil=e-s 013A002C PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT 10308
Page 2: 00000001 Log in for more options!
president Eisenhower to es:ab!ish co~m!ssion to s~udy ~obacoo and health questions. J.~ne: Surgeon General Terry anmounces fo.--~a=ion of Advisory o~.i=:ee on SmokinK and H~a!~h. Sen. Mo.s (D-Utah) in~roduce~ measur. =o $1ve Food azd D~a& A-'~.'.nis~ra~iou (FDA) sate power to police content, ad~r:!sln~ and laSe!in~ of ciEare:tes as :-DA has over food, dt-ugs and cosmetics. 196~ c~gare::e s=okin~ is causally related to lun~ cancer in men, is the mo~t imporz.n= cause of chro~ic bronchitis, ~ay con~rlbu~e ~o other diseases and is "a health hL~a2d of j'~ficient ~mportance in ~he U.S. Sen. Maurlne Neuber~er (D-0re.) Im~rodu=es bill ~i~.ng FTC authority ~o regulate cigarette advertising amd labe!~ng. packaK%s and in adver:isin~. J~e-Ju!v: House Commerce Co~i::~e ha~ hearinKs on ~mokin~ and 5ea[za. ~C delays its wa~ing proposal pending.Congresslonal 1965 J~mua.-~: U.$. Public Seal%h Se~-~ice (I~) bu~|e~ propo,al establishes National Clearin~hou, e for ~moki~ az~ ~ealth. Ju!v: Cigarette Labelin~ and Advertisi~ Ac~ e~anted, that "the ----Yi c may pu~ . be adequately informed ~hat =igsre~e smoking may be o. 013A002D
Page 3: 00000001 Log in for more options!
(1965 cont.) "confusing" regula:ions. Principal provisions: o Clgaret:e packs mus: bear a bea!=h Tautlon label. adver:isimg require:emma in connection wi~h smoking and health u_ncil a= least July I, 1969. ~'~C and =he Deparument of Health, Educe=ion and Welfare (HEW) are to keep Congress i~formed on =he issue through annual reports. 1 966 March: ~'2C reve s r es its 1960 position by allowinK car and u:co=ine yields Co be used in cisare=:e adver:ilin$. But i= says =here should be no implies=ions of any heal:h significance. M~.__~v: HEW releases repot= of a household survey of "hea!~h c~aracteris:ics of smokers," asser:In~ links between cigarem~e smoklmg ~nd illness. June: Federal Commu~ica=ions Commission (FCC) ~=les =ha= sis=ions w---~.ch a~- cigare==e co=merioa!s must° under =he "fairness doo=rlne," broad=as: antl-smoking announcements. ~'~C recommends to" Congress =ha= tar ~nd micotlne yield be required cigareT=e packs and in all adver=i~In&. ~eco~enda:ion is included in commission's firs= repot= =o Congress u~.der the ~965 labeling Iz subsequent ~nnual reports. Ju!7: Sen. Moss proposes requiring !abellnK in advertising, adding s=a:emen: Of ~ar and nicoTime ~ield co packs and allowing FTC and HEW Co set maximum cigarette length. September: Sems. Kennedy (D-N.Y.) and Randolph (D-W.Va.) propose authorizing FCC co re~ula=e cig&retce broadcast adver=islmg and to ~emd ~=cernal Revenue Code Co tax ci~are=ces on basis of Tar and nico=Ine yield. November: ~'~C publishes firs= semi-~nnual ~easur~ments of =at and n~co=ine c=nTen: of U.S. clg~re~es, as requested by the SenaTe Commerce Com=i~:ee - 3 - 013A002E
Page 4: 00000001 Log in for more options!
Pebruarv: FCC proposes ban on broadcas: clgare::e adver:Ising. ~::h-ADril: Sens. Brooke (k-Mass.) a~ Wil!lams.(~-Del.) and ~47. Corm.an (D-Cal.) relncroduce 19~7 aeasure co terminate toba::o price suppor: program &md exclude shipment of ~nder P.L. ~8~, in~e.'-~a~Io~a! ~rade expansion and promotion Fmrch-June: House Co=metre Co:mit:ee hears Ces:i=on~ on ca:on- of Cl$are~:e LabellnE Ac~, repor:s "no~h!nK mew' in ~clen-. evidence si~Ce ~965 hearings. Ma._/v: FTC renews ~96~ proposal =o require health warnimg i= c~gareu:e ads, &bsen: ~-ny ex:ensic~ of ~he 1965 ac~. Ju!.__~v: Senaze Co=merce Cons'J=er |ubcommlttee hears ~es:imony on ex:emslon of ~965 ac:. Cigarette manufacturers ask a~n~i-trus: exemp=ion to pe-~i~ Inter-compan7 a~ree~en: vcl~ntari!7 to end broadcasz adver~isin~ because of its ~nlque appeal ~o young persons. Oc:ober: ~e;. B.vr~e (D-Pa.) presen:s cigarette labe!img amencmen~ requiring packs bear s:atemenc of "fire ha:ards presente~ by s~okin~." Dece:ber: Sen. Ea=fie!d (R-Ore.) proposes bill insz~ac:i=g Federal Av~a:~on Ad:izls~ra:/on (FA.A) co require air carriers co separa=e smokin~ passengers from monsmokers. ~ep. O'Neill (D-Mass.) i~troduces bill co increase clg~ret:e excise cam, m~nles to go. for research uuder the new Naziona! Cancer Progra=. 1970 ADri_____~l: Presiden~ Nixon $iEns new Public Health Ci~&rette Smoking an ex:enslon of :he 1965 legislation. The ~urpo|e is reiterated: :he public ~hould be "adequatel~ info.-me4 ~hat cigarette |mokŁm~ ray 5e hazardous co health." Principal provi|ions: o The law formalizes ~heoffer of ~he ˘IKare~te makers ~o end radio-iv Adverr!slmg, beglnninK Jan. ~, 1971. o Package "caution" label is revised tD the~present warning. o Sza:es and localities may no~ impose on cigarette adver- =islng or promotion "require=en=s or prohibition based on smokln~ and health". - & . 013A002F
Page 5: 00000001 Log in for more options!
o ~'2C may noc furGher Its wa=-~Inl-ln-adver:islng trade resula~ion proposal until a~ leas~ Duly 1971, af:er which fur:her regu!a:ion. o ~'2C and H~ will con=inue their annual reports to Consress ~ Uhe smoklug-heal:h 18sue. -~iiI ~he tobacco price suppor: program, expor: subsidies, overseas sales promotion and government inspection and grading. August: ~'ZC proposes a ~cle ~o require ~ar and nicotine yields . November: The n~w ci;aret~e package label becomes effec:ive: "Wal-ning: The Surgeon General Has Deterulned Tha~ Cigarette Smoking Is Dangerous ~o Your ~eal:h." December: ~-2C ac:ep:s, by suspending rule making, an induszry proposal vo!un:arily ~o display ~ar and nicotine yields in all clgareu~e adver~Islng. FCC ~.=nounces cha~ af:er cigare~:e commercials are off :he air ~he "fairness do=urine" ~ill no lon~er a~ply, ~ha: broadcas:ers may assume ~here is no more controversy abou: a!le~ed ill effects. Anti-smokin8 announcemen:s may be broadcas: as public ~ervlce anuouncemen~. Col'~=nis: ~ack Anderson repor:s ~ha: yet-=o-be-released Joinu PAA-PHS study concludes tobacco smoke does non represen~ a hea!:h ha:ard to nonsmoking co===erciai airline passensers. 1971 January: Claiming a health hazard co nonsmokers, SurSton General . "Ste~nf~!d proposes a government ban on smoki~ in public places. .Januarv-Amril: Ne~ Congressional bills propose ~o limit or ban cigare:~e smoking aboard alroraf:, trains, buses ~nd ~assenger vessels; to ban ~ailing of u.usoliclted cigarette sampAss; =o prohibi~ business ~ax deduction for amy cigarette adver~Isln~. FTC Łor'aa!l7 ac'Cepts tobacco Industry's proposal for volunmary. display of uar and nicotine convene in brand adver~isemencs. April: Tobacco lnstitute announces ins member companies will enh-~-~-~for~h voluntarily display ~he package wa.--ning label in all - 5 - 013A0030
Page 6: 00000001 Log in for more options!
(1971 con:.) print advertising. Ju!v: FTC vote, to vacaue i~s Congressionally e~bargoed proposal uo~equlre a health warning in cigarette ads. ~nste~:l, ~he co=:ission says, lu will ne$otiate wlth.each m~nufact~rer.to require a more "clear" and "consplcu~us package waz-n~ng ~n ci~areu:e ads. National C!earinEhou, e for SmoklnE and ~ea!~h remains a Ne~ York a~ver:islnE aSeucy for $~56,000 ~o prepare anmi-smokln~ ads for November: U.S. Disuricu Cour: reJecu~ plea ~f ~ix broadcas~ers.~o de~Ision i~ sa~s: "Con~ress has ~he power ~o prohlbi~ uhe adver~Isln~ of ci~are~ss in any media." Sen. Harks (D-~nd.) In:roduces a bill ruquirin~ cigarec:e ads deplc: porzlons.of pack bearin~ Surgeon General's heal~h warninB. 1972 ˘~spia~ of the packa~ war~In~ i~ adverzise=ents. Februa---~: Chain-man Moss of Senate Consumer ~ubc=mmiz:ee has hearings on h~s ~97~ proposal to regu!A:e ~ar amd nico=ine con~ent of ciga- rettes. The FAA-PES re?or~ o= smokin~ in aircraft is released af:er Sen. Cook (K-Ky.) =hi~es PES witnesses Zor ~ot making public i:s conclusion. The 8S-page report says tobacco s~oke is "~u/ged no~ to represen~ a health ha:ard to ~h.e non~oki~ passengers. ~r~h: Supreme Cour~ upholds appellate court's finding of ˘ons:Itutlonali~y of the 1970 law ~hat ~rohlbi~s broadcas~ cigarette • advertising. September: Civil Aeronau:Ics Board (~.B) proposes airlines vo~un~ar~!? segregate smokers and nonsmokers. 1973 'J~nua.-v: EEW's annual report to Congress On ~okin| and health, ~rsu ~o o~lU legislative recc",enda~ious, sul~ests special hamards for women smokers And ~helr unborn children. March: Sen. Moss in=roduces hi!is to prohlblu broadcast advertisln~ o:-~.utle cigars, impose a mar uax and di~allow business expense tax deductlons, for clgaretue a~verulssmenus. - 6 - O ~4 013A0031
Page 7: 00000001 Log in for more options!
(I 973 con:.) ~'~smokgrs because vol'~n~ar7 arramsement$ aren'~ worklnS. "The ~: Cons~e: Product Safe:~ Co~ilai~ (CPSC) chai~a~ tells New N~erous Congressmen and ~e Tobacco Ims=i~e poln~ ou~ than Consist Produc= Safe~y Ac:, se~:In~ up =he co=missiom, ~pecifically tobacco from CPSC ~isdlc:ion. Se~uember: CPSC makes public a "cmnsu.~er product hazard index" and puts ~obacco in an area cf "~ues:ionable Jurisdiction." Presideu: Nixon signs bill prohibiting broadcast advertising of lit:is cigars. o November: General Se:-~Ices Administration (GSA) 0 ~Ich operates all ~e~era! buildings, issues vol~n~a:-y guidelines res~rictlng smokin~ in federal conference rooms, audi:oriu-~s, cafeterias, elevators and so~e shut:!e vehicles. December: CAB urges its employees :o be "observers." reporting V~oiat~ons of smokizg regulations and actions taken by airplane cre~s to e-~or~e._ - the ~a!es. 1 97.___~& Pebruarv:. Sen. Moss ~nd American Public Health Associ&:ion pe~i=Ion CPSC ~o prohibi~ sales of cigarettes ~ieldlng no:im~ that limit "will remove the nos~ dangerous varieties of cigarettes from the ~arke~." ADrift ]~nce--s~:aCe Commerce Co˘=is,lon (ICC) imRlemen=s rule ~a:ing 20 percen~ of sea~s on Inters~x~e buses for smoklm~ U.S. Comp~rollsr General rules ~hat CPSC "does noc have the authority ~o ac~'[ on the Moss pe=ition ~o ban sale of hish ~ar and nlco~Ine ci~are=tes. FT.C begins investigation of sizt of warnings on cigars:re adver- tisements, requesting of ~00 ~e~,papers and ma~amlnes.coples of all cigarette ads r~n in precedin~ six months. May: CP~C decides i= backs authority to se~ mandatory cigare::e tar -eT~vels as urged in ~he Moss pecicion. - 7 - 013A0032
Page 8: 00000001 Log in for more options!
FCC votes to limit application of "fai.-~ess doctrine" to broadcast vi~-~oimts, rever,ing ~he 1967 application ~o a whole category of produc= advertising, clg&re=tes. August: In Washington. Sen. Moss, the American Public ~ea!th Association and the local lung association petition U.S. Distrlc= Court ~o ~ale CPSC has authority =o regulate cigarettes. September: CPSC reJec:s'fu.-~Iture manufacturers' petition to regulate c~garecze burnln8 clme before regu!azlm~ upholstery f!a=mability, c!alming'lack .of Jurisdiction over cigzret:es. October: Presidenz Ford asks Nations! Cancer Advisor? Board (NCAB) to assess scientific evidence suppor:i~K responsible re~!atlon of clgaret~e tar and nicotine bevels. November: NCAB makes persia! response to President Ford, whose rea~z~cn the New York Times records as "coo!." U.S. Diszric~ Court denies cigarette manufac'u, re-s'. .pe:i'~ion to dismiss :he Moss sui: requiriz~ CPSC regulate :at and nicozlue levels. December: Fu.-T.IZure manufacturers seek tour= Judgment the= CPSC does have 2urisdiczion over clgare:ze ~u--nlng rates. U.S. afoOt-hey and cigare=te companies again requesz court dismissal of Moss suit, claiming CPSC lacks Jurisdic:ion over cigarette tar IS75 M~ro_____~h: ~T.C's 197& report to Congress a~ain criticizes clgare:te acver:islng bu: make~ no reference .to the advertising investiKation beg~n =he previous April. Sen. MOes, with no reference to hi, court suit, Im~roduces bill =o Kive'CPSC Jurisdiction =o regulate ~&r and mico:ine. e Ma.__Zv: U.S. Dis~ric: Cour: rules in Mose euit tha: CPSC does have authority to regulate tar and nicotine. House and Senate consider bills ~o exempt tobacco ~rom CPSC Jurlsdic:Ion. Ju!_____~v: S~n. Moss reintroduces bill requiring PTC to s~ limits on ~nc nicozine allowable i~ cigare:zes. - 8 - 013A0035
Page 9: 00000001 Log in for more options!
(197~ cont.) ~: He)otis that ~'T~C pla~s to cha:$e cigarette companies for October: ~C racalv~s $50.000 frou P~'~ National Cancer ~ov~be:: Rep. D:im~ (D-Mass.> introd~es bill to stiffen cigarette smoklnE in federal buildinss and lu~ars~a~e u:anspor=a:ion and increase the fede:~! cigarette tax to fund heam=/lunE reset=oh. 1976 Feb:-u~rv_: Sens. Kennedy (D-~.ass.) and ~a== (D-Colo.) introduce bill co ~x cigarettez on car and nicotine concen~, wi=h es=i~a=ed billion added ~nua! :evenue fo= ~ove~men= health research. D..nan Introduce measuzes Sen. Ha=field and ~e?. ~m~: ~C's annual report to Congress says i: 'is Investigating cigarette adve::isi~ ":o dete~Ime ~e:he: ~he:e may be decepcio~ and ~mfai~ess. Preslde~= Ford sign~ feEls!scion ex~p~i~E tobacco f=om CPSC Is=ion, m~king =oo= =he Moss lawsuit ~d =he ~i=ure m~nufac=urers' effort =o O~=Ain regu!a:ion of cigarette ~u~in& rime. ~CC bans smokir.~ In raii=~d dinin~ c~ s but orders sepa=~e coach c~:s foT smokin~ ~nd nousmoking passengers. Ju!~: Gemera! Acco~=i~g Office (G~) urges.Com~ress =o =i~h~en smo~in8 re~ulazlous. AuK~:: Senate defeats, 60-~5, effort to add ~ar:-Kenn~y tar and uico~ine ~ax ~ a pendin8 tax bill. October: ICC ~ends i~s ~97~ regulation, increasing from 20 percen~ the allo~en= of bus seats for ~oker~. Bus opera=ora had requested 50 percent. Claimin~ tobacco smoke a~d radioactivity are ~ealthy combine=ion, Na~ional Park Semite bans smoking In federally o~ed caves. GSA requests "Affi~a~ive ac:ion" by a~ency hea~ In each federal building i: o~e~a~es ~o Impiemen~ ~mokln; re~ric:ion Euldelines Issued In ~9~], a~king "full coopera~ion...Im en~uriu equitable balance is main=ained between ~he rights of nonsmokers and ~hose of - 9 - 01 3A0034
Page 10: 00000001 Log in for more options!
1977 Janua-'L~: ~ep. Drlnan In=roduces bills =o provlda ~nn~xl HEW re~org ADri!: .Sen. Ear: and ~ep. Drimam Iz=roduc~ ~eal~h.~ro~ec=~on Tax Ac~ labeling. ~izis=razi~n's healzh plan will be decreasimg =he n~ber of ~okers. ~ ~rohibics smokiug In mobile passenger lo~s a~ ~ashin~zon's Dul!es Inze~a~ional Airpor=. July: Eouse defe~s what has become an annual effort :o e!imina:e ~oca:co price support ~C's 1976 reporz ~o Congress urge~ limning ~n packs ~d in adver:Isin~ ~he ~leld of "any additional dangerous co=pone~=s of cigare~e smoke, ~he measuramen, of ~.ich c~ be eszablished by "furzher scientific or medical AuZusz: Rep. Penwick (~-N.J.) in=roduc~s measur~ requirin~ asbestos ~n~ cigarez:e =anufac:ur~rs ~o compensa:~ workers disabled by ~plo~en~-relazed diseases "~ause~ by ~he ~nha!a:ion or of asbestos, and/or ghe [nhalac~on of asbescol coupled wlzh inha!ac.ion of cigare=:e gobac:o smoke." October: H~ Secre~a~ Califano orde{s r~va! of a~h~rays from ~c'nfere=ce rooms ~nd posting of no-smokim~ si~s in EE~ e!eva:ors. ~edical devices, asser:In~ a~s izply heal~h claims. naziona! no-s=okin~ day; ~ncrea~ed federal ci~ar~=~ max; a g~ on ˘Iga.re~:e s~!es in HEW buildings; paid time off for federal ~rkers attending stop-s~oking clinics; s~reng:hened package wa~ing; phase-ou= of federal ~obacco supper: programs,' with ~ocia! welfare help for s~al! ~obacco fa~ers. November: Following ˘riglcism of Richmond's proposal ~o end tobacco price suppor~ programs, Califano tells press he will noz "=if: a~ ~indm i ii." - I0 - 013A0035

Text Control

Highlight Text:

OCR Text Alignment:

Image Control

Image Rotation:

Image Size: