Lorillard
Report on Recent Ets and Iaq Developments
Fields
- Type
- REPT, OTHER REPORT
- Area
- LEGAL DEPT LIBRARY
- Named Person
- Alho, O.P.
- Allamneni, K.P.
- Aviado, D.M.
- Balmes, J.
- Barnhart, S.
- Barrettconnor, E.
- Begom, R.
- Belanger, C.
- Bernstein, M.
- Bostick, R.M.
- Brown, M.J.
- Burge, H.
- Buring, J.E.
- Cheeseman, K.
- Chen, Chc
- Chen, L.C.
- Choukroun, R.
- Clausen, J.L.
- Clipp, E.C.
- Coggon, D.
- Cook, N.R.
- Cresson, E.
- Cullen, M.R.
- Dockery, D.W.
- Feng, W.
- Finkel, A.M.
- Fogarty, J.
- Folsom, A.R.
- Frarey, L.C.
- French, P.
- Frette, C.
- Friebele, E.
- Gairola, C.G.
- Gaziano, J.M.
- Gergen, P.
- Glass, A.
- Gong, Y.L.
- Goodman, G.E.
- Gredler, M.
- Greenberg, E.R.
- Haapanen, N.
- Hammar, S.
- Harris, J.R.
- Hennekens, C.H.
- Heritier, S.
- Holt, J.
- Howard, D.J.
- Kajosaari, M.
- Keller, K.
- Kelly, F.
- Keogh, J.P.
- Khatchatrian, N.
- Kochersberger, G.
- Koivu, M.
- Koplan, J.P.
- Koutrakis, P.
- Kushi, L.H.
- Lamotte, F.
- Landau, L.I.
- Landsberger, S.
- Link, B.G.
- Lynch, J.W.
- Maluf, P.
- Manson, J.E.
- Meyskens, F.L.
- Miilunpalo, S.
- Mink, P.J.
- Mitchinson, M.J.
- Moloney, A.C.
- Morabia, A.
- Munzer, A.
- Myers, S.R.
- Nadas, A.
- Neas, L.M.
- Neuf, M.
- Newell, J.B.
- Oja, H.
- Oja, P.
- Omenn, G.S.
- Pamuk, E.R.
- Parsons, A.
- Pasanen, M.
- Penn, A.
- Perera, F.P.
- Peto, R.
- Phelan, J.C.
- Pinkerton, K.E.
- Pinorinigodly, M.T.
- Plopper, C.G.
- Prineas, R.J.
- Pritsos, C.A.
- Ridker, P.M.
- Rosner, B.
- Rotcajg, L.
- Saarinen, U.M.
- Schofield, P.M.
- Singh, R.B.
- Snyder, C.A.
- Sorri, M.
- Speizer, F.E.
- Sporn, M.B.
- Stampfer, M.
- Steinheider, B.
- Stephens, N.G.
- Subramaniam, S.
- Thornquist, M.D.
- Valanis, B.
- Valverde, J.L.
- Vuori, I.
- Weinman, G.
- Wells
- Willett, W.
- Williams, J.H.
- Winneke, G.
- Wu, D.
- Wu, Y.
- Zheng, P.
- Allamneni, K.P.
- Document File
- 93139702/93140355/Reports on Recent Ets and Iaq Developments 960100 - 960600 Nicholas Simeonidis
- Alias
- 93140321/93140354
- Litigation
- Ppla/Produced
- Master ID
- 93140295/0354
Related Documents: - Named Organization
- Actualidad Tabaquera
- Agence France Presse
- Air France
- Ala
- Archives of Otolaryngology + Head Neck S
- Asahi Chemical Industry
- Brazil Justice Tribunal
- Breathe Easy
- Business Wire
- Caret
- Cdc
- Center for Immunology + Cancer Research
- Civil Liberties Council
- Corrections Ministry
- Council of the Vale of Glamorgan
- Courier Mail
- Daily Yomiuri
- Deutsche Presse Agentur
- Discover
- Echo Yorkshire Evening Post
- Environment Intl
- Epidemiology of Infections
- Europeans Leaders Against Tobacco
- European Commission
- European Parliament
- Europe Against Cancer
- Forest
- Guardian Council
- Herald Tribune
- Houston Chronicle
- Indian Express
- Institution of Chemical Engineers
- Irish Health Board
- Irish Independent
- Japan Times
- Joint Research Center
- Journal of the European Communities
- Matsushita Electric Industrial
- Monaldi Archives of Chest Diseases
- Morning Bulletin
- Natl Heart Lung + Blood Inst
- Natl Inst of Allergy + Infectious Diseas
- Nikkei Weekly
- Oshawa West Lyons Club
- Ottawa Citizen
- Polish Press Agency
- Prisoners Legal Service
- Proserpine Guardian
- Publican
- Punjab House
- Queensland Corrective Services
- Sao Paulo Hotels Restaurants Bars + Food
- Science of the Total Environment
- Sexta Feira
- Sharp
- Shiseido
- South Wales Echo
- State Public Services Federation
- St Vincent Hospital
- Times
- Tornex
- Toronto Star
- Tvq10 News
- US Today
- Wa Adventist Hospital
- Xinhua News Agency
- Agence France Presse
- Characteristic
- OVER, OVER SIZE DOCUMENT
- Site
- N63
- Date Loaded
- 07 Jan 1999
- Brand
- 1r4f
- UCSF Legacy ID
- vnq99d00
Document Images
A-6
should better assess past and current exposure to
tobacco smoke in the home and elsewhere."
RESPIRATORY DISEASES AND CONDITIONS --
CHILDREN
[551 "The Attack of Asthma," E. Friebele, Environ-
mental Health Perspectives 104: 22-25, 1996
"The number of people with asthma increased by
42% in the last decade, according to a recent report by
the Centers for Disease Control. Not only is asthma
becoming more prevalent, but it is also more severe.
According to the National Heart, Lung, and Blood
Institute, the number of people who die of asthma
jumped 58% between 1979 and 1992. Emergency
room visits and hospital admissions for asthma are
increasing. Children, ethnic minorities, and the urban
poor are at the greatest risk. Researchers suspect that a
variety of factors such as air contaminants and height-
ened exposure to aeroallergens in airtight homes trigger
bouts of asthma or cause chronic airway inflammation
that may lead to permanent lung dysfunction."
"What could be making a respiratory disease, trig-
gered by an allergic response and aggravated by a
multitude of factors, more common, more acute, and
potentially more fatal?"
"The rising number of asthmatics might be attributed
to increased awareness among physicians, said Gale
Weinman of the National Heart, Lung, and Blood
Institute (NHLBI). 'Physicians may now be recogniz-
ing ailments previously diagnosed as a cold or
bronchitis as the long-term, chronic illness of asthma.
However, increased diagnosis of asthma cannot
[totally] explain the rise in its prevalence,' she said."
"For the 70-75% of asthmatics who have allergic
asthma, their respiratory systems have developed a very
specific response to a specific allergens [sic]. Nonallergic
asthmatics, on the other hand, may wheeze after
exercising or taking aspirin, and show little sensitivity
to allergens. Asthma and allergies appear to be inher-
ited separately, but they are mysteriously associated."
"The increase in asthma is not unique to the United
States.... In Great Britain, deaths and hospital
ETS/IAQ REPORT, ISSUE 123
admissions due to asthma doubled between 1979 and
1985. In Finland, the proportion of military recruits
with asthma increased 20-fold between 1961 and 1989."
"Asthma is the number one cause of absenteeism for
schoolchildren and a common reason for adult absen-
teeism from work."
"Though death from asthma is relatively rare, it is
becoming more frequent. Asthma mortality in the
United_States declined by nearly 8% per year during
the 1970s, but by 1977, the trend reversed, and the
number of deaths due to asthma began to climb
steadily, increasing about 6% per year."
"Most asthma deaths occur in urban areas."
"Although some evidence suggests that asthma's death
tcll could be leveling off, the rising rate of hospital
admissions and emergency room and doctor's office
visits for asthma suggests that the disease is becoming
»
more severe.
"Blacks, Hispanics, and people living in urban environ-
ments seem to be at the greatest risk for asthma."
"These findings raise important questions about why
the economically disadvantaged are at greatest risk of
dving from asthma. 'Poverty is assol-;-red with all sorts
of diseases,' said Gergen [Peter] [of the National
:nstitute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases]. `Pour
people in the United States die more than the rich of
all causes, and the gap is widening. General health is
poorer, as well as access to medical care. Exposure,
environmental quality of life, stress, and social factors
all play a role,' said Gergen."
"Spurred by the alarming statistics, researchers are
focusing on direct exposures to allergens indoors where
people are spending more of their time. Allergen levels
are thought to be higher in less well-ventilated homes,
where moisture accumulates, allowing mildew and
molds to grow."
"'We're also concerned about second-hand tobacco
smoke,' said Alfred ATunzer, pulmonary specialist at
Washington Adventist Hospital and former president
of the ALA. 'There is increasing evidence that child-
hood exposure to environmental smoke can be a
predisposing factor to developing asthma."'
-"Infants of women who smoke have higher levels of
the antibody immunoglobin E (IgE) in umbilical cord
SHB
93140331

MAY 10, 1996
blood compared to infants of nonsmokers, indicating
an immune reaction. Whether children born to
smoking mothers develop asthma pre- or postnatally is
an unanswered question."
"Increasing asthma incidence cannot totally be
explained by smoking in the United States, however.
Between 1965 and 1990, cigarette smoking in the
United States declined by 40%. Though the greatest
number of smokers are 25-44 years of age, poorly
educated, and live below the poverty level, according to
statistics from the CDC's Office on Smoking and
Health, the proportion of smokers in this group is also
following a downward trend."
"Other studies are exploring the influence of a child's
surroundings during the vulnerable first weeks and
months of life. It is precisely during this period,
scientists believe, that the environment of a child with
a genetic disposition can tip the scales toward develop-
ing a full-fledged allergy."
"`The consensus seems to be that the environment is
playing a tremendous role in the increasing prevalence
of asthma,' said Munzer. In addition to the provoca-
tion of asthma by allergens, he says, `air pollution is a
big factor."'
"The nation's air has improved dramatically in the
past 25 years. Emissions of soot and smog-forming
volatile organic compounds have decreased signifi-
cantly in the United States since 1970 despite crowded
highways where more vehicles are driven twice as many
miles. Release of sulfur oxide has decreased by 30%
since 1970. Between 1988 and 1993, overall industrial
emissions of toxic compounds decreased by 39%."
"The distribution of asthma in other countries also
fails to implicate pollution as an aggravating factor.
Some of the highest asthma mortality rates occur in
Australia and New Zealand, which have excellent air
quality. Asthma is more prevalent in rural areas of the
Scottish highlands, which have some of the lowest
ozone concentrations in the world, than in more urban
and polluted parts of the United Kingdom, according
to a recent report."
"In spite of overall improvements in air quality, many
Americans are not breathing risk-free air, according to
EPA Administrator Carol Browner. Almost 100
million people live in areas where the air does not meet
A-7
national air quality standards. Eighty percent of
Hispanics and 65% of blacks live in 'nonattainment
areas' for air standards."
"The question remains whether small particles in the
atmosphere provoke asthma episodes."
"While many factors that provoke asthma, such as air
pollution and cigarette smoking are decreasing, the
disease is becoming more prevalent. Its increasing
severity is concentrated in urban pockets where
children live under poor conditions, are frequently
exposed to allergens and air pollution episodes, and
have sporadic medical care. Research suggests that
education, controlling exposure to antigens in the
indoor environment, and improving urban air quality
could improve the quality of life for these children."
[56] "Fungus Spores, Air Pollutants, and Other
Determinants of Peak Expiratory Flow Rate in
Children," L.M. Neas, D.W. Dockery, H.
Burge, P. Koutrakis, and F.E. Speizer, American
Journal of Epidemiology 143: 797-807, 1996
"The present investigation has replicated the previous
Uniontown summer study [of haze episodes and daily
variations in symptoms and peak expiratory flow rates]
in a cohort of children in State College, Pennsylvania,
and has included daily measurements of specific pollen
and fungus spore concentrations."
"Airborne spore concentrations of Cladosporium,
Epicoccum, and Coprinus were associated with
deficits in the mean deviation of morning PEFR for
the entire cohort." _
"Precipitation afE°cted both the mean deviation in
PEFR and the concentrations of airborne contaminants."
"In this study, a 12-hour daytime time-weighted
exposure to an additional 125-nmol/m3 particle-strong
acidity was associated with a mean 1.2-liters/minute
decrease in evening PEFR.... Cough episodes were
associated with 12-hour daytime exposures to
particle-strong acidity and total sulfate particles."
"The principal determinants of the day-to-day
variation in PEFR among children include time of
observation, growth, temperature, precipitation, air
pollutants, and airborne aeroallergens. The effects of
time of observation, growth, and temperature are very
consistent across two studies, with similar measure-
SHB

A-8
ments for comparable children's cohorts. In this study,
airborne spore concentrations of Cladosporium,
Epicoccum, and Coprinus were associated with deficits
in the mean deviation of morning PEFR for the entire
cohort; and five children showed significant
child-specific declines in morning PEFR v.th increased
Ganoderma spore concentrations. The effect of
particle-strong acidity on the mean deviation in
evening PEFR was somewhat less in this study. These
data are not incompatible with the previous finding of
an association of PEFR with aerosol acidity among the
Uniontown children. These results are also compatible
with a respirable particle hypothesis. Daytime expo-
sures to ozone and particulate air pollutants were
associated with the increased incidence of summertime
cough and cold symptoms that evening or on the
subsequent morning. Precipitation days and fungal
spore concentrations did not confound the association
of PEFR with the levels of particulate air pollutants.
Fungus spore concentrations affected the mean devia-
tion in morning PEFR, and air contaminants affected
the mean deviation in evening PEFR. We conclude
that summer episodes of excessive aerosol acidity and
particulate pollution are acutely associated with
declines in peak expiratory flow rates and increased
incidence of cough and cold episodes in children.
Similar, if not stronger, effects were associated with
variation in fungus spore counts, which suggests that
additional exploration of the influence of aerobiologic
contaminants in conjunction with summertime haze
episodes is warranted."
[57] "The Impact of Lung Development on
Respiratory Disease Later in Life," L.I.
Landau, Monaldi Archives of Chest Diseases 3:
167-169, 1995
"The airways are fully mature in their structure and
branching pattern at birth, and no major changes occur
after birth. However, considerable alveolar develop-
ment occurs in early postnatal life and probably
continues through to adult life, although the peak
development is completed within the first 3-4 yrs.
After 8 yrs of age, there is most probably a greater
increase in size than in number of alveoli. The growth
of blood vessels supplying the conducting airways
parallels the development of the airways."
"The effect of various insults on lung growth and
function will depend on the timing of that insult. It is
ETS/IAQ REPORT, ISSUE 123
becoming increasingly clear that insults from concep-
tion until early school years may have profound effects
on lung development, which persist into later life."
-"Genetic disorders are present from conception but
their effect on the lungs will depend on the disease
process that results from the genetic abnormality."
"Those at risk of subsequent atopy and asthma may
have abnormalities detected at birth, such as increased
airway responsiveness, and raised cord blood immuno-
globulin E (IgE) levels. Although these may evolve in
relation to in utero exposure to allergens or mediators
from the mother, the genetic predisposition is a vital
component of this response."
"Gender is a very important factor influencing lung
development and the increased predisposition of boys
for lower respiiatory tract symptoms and asthma
during early childhood. Boys have lower flow rates for
lung size than girls from birth until puberty."
"There is increasing evidence that in utero events have
an effect on lung development manifest at birth, which
may predispose to respiratory symptoms in infancy,
asthma during early childhood and young adult life,
and chronic lung disease in later adult life. Those with
the familial predisposition demonstrate a maternal
pattern of inheritance to atopy and asthma. This may
be genetic with paternal imprinting, so that the gene
acquired from the father is not expressed. It could
equally be related to allergen exposure transplacentally
or to the movement of m..eiiators from the mother to
the foetus. The presence of abnormalities at birth does
suggest that aims at prevention of asthma will need to
take into account events during pregnancy."
"Maternal smoking has now been well documented as
an important cause of lower respiratory tract symptoms
during the first 2 yrs of life. Babies of mothers who _
smoke have reduced flow rates and increased airway
responsiveness present soon after birth and before
symptoms have developed. The timing of the effect of
smoking on the foetus has not yet been definitely
identified, and it may be gender specific. However, in
line with other effects of tobacco smoke, the major
influence probably occurs after the first 3 months of
gestation. The effect appears more marked in girls and
may, in fact, represent a masculinization of the female
during intra-uterine lung development."
SHB
g3140333

MAY 10, 1996
"Young, et al. reported a cohort in whom up to 10%
of apparently normal infants were found to have
considerably reduced flow rates soon after birth. These
infants had a very high rate of subsequent lower
respiratory tract symptoms and asthma. Although
many can be shown to have had a high risk oi'ast .:na
on the basis of family history and exposure to environ-
mental tobacco smoke, there are almost certainly many
more risk factors and insults predisposing to abnormal
airway development during foetal life that have not yet
been identified."
"Bacterial infections in early life cause considerable
lung damage but, in the developed world, are rarely
associated with long-term functional disability."
"The effect of viral infections during the first year of
life on subsequent lung development and function is
particularly interesting. Although uncommon, some
can certainly cause significant, permanent damage."
"On the other hand, there is some evidence that a
reduction of viral infections during early life may be
associated with sensitization to common allergens
rather than tolerance."
"Bronchial responsiveness appears to decrease with
age. However, tests of airway responsiveness in differ-
ent sized children are difficult to interpret, as one can
never been sure whether the challenge dose is equiva-
lent. Whether airway responsiveness does decrease with
age or not, it appears likely that those with increased
airway responsiveness will maintain this status, with
allergen exposure through early life leading to subse-
quent atopy and asthma."
"Chronic obstructive airways disease in adults has
frequently been shown to be associated with childho-id
respiratory trouble. It is becoming increasingly clear
that these childhood respiratory symptoms are not the
cause of subsequent lung disease but a reflection of
abnormalities of luing development through
intra-uterine life and early postnatal life. Prospective
longitudinal studies are giving us important insights
into these events, and should lead to interventions
which will prevent respiratory illness both in childhood
and later adult life."
A-9
[58] "Breastfeeding as Prophylaxis Against Atopic
Disease: Prospective Follow-Up Study Until 17
Years Old," U.M. Saarinen and M. Kajosaari,
Lancet 346: 1065-1069, 1995
"Environmental exposure during early infancy may be
particularly important for sensitization and later devel-
opment of atopy, probably because of the physiological
immaturity of the immune system. The possibility of a
primary defect in intestinal absorption of macromol-
ecules in atopic individuals has also been suggested."
"The role of breastfeeding and/or avoidance of cows'
milk-based formulas in early infancy has been the focus
of much controversy.... The purpose of the present
study was to evaluate the very-long-term effects of
breastfeeding by assessing the occurrence of atopic
manifestations in the same prospective series through-
out childhood and adolescence in a follow-up study
until the age of 17 years."
"The results of this prospective, very-long-term
follow-up study from infancy until early adulthood
indicate that breastfeeding can protect against develop-
ment of atopic disease. In the group with short or no
breastfeeding there was a consistently higher prevalence
of atopy, which increased to a demonstrable difference
at 17 years of age. When the gr.,,.p with short or no
breastfeeding was compared with the prolonged
breastfeeding group, atopy was observed in 65% and
42% of subjects, respectively, and substantial atopy in
54% and 8%. The difference in substantial atopy was
significant irrespective of positive or negative atopic
heredity. Unexpectedly, the differences between the
infant feeding groups were pronounced at the age of
17 years."
"According to our follow-up data, breastfeeding for 6
months or longer is required for prophylaxis of atopic
eczema for the first 3 years of life. On the other hand,
exclusive breastfeeding for longer than 1 month already
seems beneficial in preventing food allergy with its
prevalence peak at 3 years, and respiratory allergy with
the prevalence peak at 17 years. With regard to sub-
stantial atopy at the age of 17 years, greatest benefit
was achieved by prolonged breastfeeding."
"Heredity has hitherto been considered to be the
strongest predictive risk factor for atopic disease. In our
series, the differences in atopy among children grouped
according to early milk feeding were of the same order
SHB

A-10
of magnitude as were the differences caused by positive
or negative atopic heredity; at the age of 17 years, the
differences due to infant feeding were even more
pronounced, suggesting an influence of early milk
feeding that may exceed the heredity burden."
OTHER CANCER
[59] "Relation of Breast Cancer with Passive and
Active Exposure to Tobacco Smoke," A.
Morabia, M. Bernstein, S. Heritier, and N.
Khatchatrian, American journal ofEpidemiology
143: 918-928, 1996
"It is ... paradoxic that the work on passive smoking
has consistently shown a tendency toward an increased
risk of breast cancer while studies on active smoking
have failed to demonstrate an association. This appar-
ent contradiction may stem from not separating passive
smokers from the unexposed when assessing the effect
of active smoking.... If passive smokers are at greater
risk of breast cancer than are the unexposed, grouping
passive smokers with the unexposed in the referent
category may reduce thc excess risk for active smokers
to nonsignificant levels. This was the a priori hypoth-
esis that motivated the design of the present study."
"There were 126 cases (52 percent) and 620 controls
(60 percent) who were never active smokers. Among
them, 28 cases (22 percent) and 241 controls (39
percent) were neither active nor passive smokers and
were used as the referent 'unexposed' group."
"[T]he adjusted odds ratios of breast cancer for ever
active smokers, compared with women unexposed to
either passive or active smoke, were 2.2 (95 percent CI
1.0-4.4) for an average lifetime consumption of 1-9
cigarettes per day, 2.7 (95 percent CI 1.4-54) for 10-19
cigarettes per day, and 4.6 (95 percent CI 2.2-9.7) for
20 or more cigarettes per day."
"To examine the effect of cleaning up the referent
category from the passive smokers, we computed the
odds ratios using never active smokers as the referent
category, that is, pooling passive smokers with the
unexposed. Among ever active smokers, the two-step
odds ratios were 1.2 (95 percent CI 0.8-2.0) for 1-9
ETS/IAQ REPORT, ISSUE 123
cigarettes per day, 1.7 (95 percent CI 1.1-2.5) for
10-19 cigarettes per day, and 1.9 (95 percent CI
1.2-2.9) for [greater than or equal to] 20 cigarettes per
day (not shown in a table)."
"[A] mong nonactive smokers, the multivariate odds
ratio for ever being exposed to passive smoking at
home, at work, or during leisure time for at least 1
hour per day for at least 12 consecutive months of
smoking was 2.3 (95 percent CI 1.5-3.7). The odds
ratio became 3.2 (95 percent CI 1.7-5.9) after addi-
tional adjustment for saturated fat and alcohol intakes.
There was no statistically significant trend according to
the number of hours per day-years; the two-step odds
ratios were 3.1 (95 percent CI 1.5-6.2) for 1-50 hours
per day-years and 3.2 (95 percent CI 1.6-6.3) for more
than 50 hours per day-years."
"The present results suggest that both passive and
active smoking increase breast cancer risk. They seem
biologically plausible, since it is reasonable to postulate
that constituents of tobacco smoke have a direct and/or
an indirect influence on the carcinogenic process
leading to breast cancer."
"[T] he observed associations for active smoking are
surprisingly strong in contrast to those of most previ-
ous studies."
"[A] detailed assessment of lifetime exposure may be
necessary to show the relation of active smoking with
breast cancer."
"The present results are not directly comparable with
previous literature reports on active smoking and breast
cancer since, to our knowledge, none of them separated
passive smokers from subjects unexposed to active and
passive smoke. Removing passive smokers from the
referent category increased the odds ratio by a factor of
1.5-2.5 according to the active smoking category. It is
therefore possible that the strength of the breast
cancer-smoking association has been underestimated in
the available body of literature."
"Lifetime exposure to passive smoking is clearly
difficult to assess. In the present study, to be classified
as a passive smoker, a woman had to have been exposed
at least 1 hour per day for 1 consecutive year or more.
This definition was relatively strict in order to identify
women with at least one period of substantial exposure
in their lifetime. It was more difficult to assess accu-
SHB
93140335

MAY 10, 1996
rarely the number of hours per day of passive smoking,
especially during leisure time. Misclassification orthe_
intensity of exposure may therefore have diluted a__
possible dose-related effect." -
"For comparison purposes with the_litera_ture, we
computed the odds ratio of passive smoking among
women ever married to an active smoker compared
with women never married to an active smoker. The
t<vo-step odds ratio was 2.0 (95 percent CI 1.1-3.7)
(not shown in a table). The lower bound of the
confidence interval was consistent with the odds ratio
of 1.4 computed by Wells. However, this proxy
measure for passive smoking probably underestimates
the association, since women married to nonactive
smokers may have been exposed at home by someone
other than their spouse. They also may have been
exposed somewhere other than at home."
"Being exposed to passive smoking 2 hours per day
for 25 years was equivalent to having actively smoked
an average of 20 cigarettes per day for 20 years. This
was disturbing, since the effect of passive smoking was
not a priori expected to be as strong as that of active
smoking. A similar problem is encountered when
studying cardiovascular diseases.... A better under-
standing of the biologic effect of tobacco smoke on the
mammary gland is needed to decide whether this
phenomenon reflects a different etiologic mechankm
from that for lung cancer. Direct exposure to tar
deposition should not be an issue for breast cancer or
atherosclerosis."
"The risk factors of breast cancer were incorporated as
potential confounders in logistic regression models.
Alcohol and saturated fat intakes were not strong
confounders."
"The present study had limited statistical power to
perform subgroup analyses.... None of them indi-
cated that the effects of passive and active smoking
could be limited to a subgroup of women."
"A strength of the present study design was to
incorporate variables allowing us to quantify potential
selection, detection, and recall biases."
"[S]eparating passive smokers from unexposed
women resulted in a group of 28 cases in the referent
category. The odds of being unexposed drive the
findings related to passive smoking. We were not able
to identify a methodological flaw that could have
A-ri
generated the relatively small proportion of cases
unexposed to active and passive smoke. The most serious
consequence of an_ unsuspected bias for the present
results would have been that some truly unexposed
women had been classified as passive smokers."
"The present study findings do not allow us to
conclude that there is a causal association between
smoking and breast cancer. There is no dose-response
relation between the intensity of passive smoking and
the odds ratio of breast cancer. The strengths of the
associations for passive and active smoking are of
similar magnitude, while one would expect the risk of
one's own smoke to be much larger."
"However, recent reports offer evidence that can
reconcile these apparent incongruities with a plausible
biologic mechanism. ...`3Ue can speculate that
women who develop breast cancer as a consequence
of passive smoking are likely to be slow acetylators,
rapid acetylators being able to metabolize low doses of
the toxin."
"The absence of a dose-response relation for passive
smoking, if true, may be due to a low threshold of
exposure among slow acetylators. Above that threshold,
the risk associated with passive smoking would increase
rapidly and then plateau. The latter hypothesis would
also explain the relatively small magnitude of difference
between the odds ratios for passive and active smoking."
"In conclusion, the present findings may be surpris-
ing, but they suggest uiat it is important to consider
the effect of passive smoking when examining the
association between active smoking and breast cancer.
Previous studies may have failed to find an effect of
active smoking, because they did not exclude passive
smokers from the unexposed category. The association
is not entirely explainable by analogy with the biologic
mechanisms involved in established tobacco-related
diseases. Additional studies of comparable design are
needed to decide whether these intriguing findings are
causal or not."
[60] "Molecular Epidemiology: Insights into Cancer
Susceptibility, Risk Assessment, and Preven-
tion," F.P. Perera, Journal of the National
Cancer Institute 88: 4_9 _6-509, 1996
"For more than a decade, there has been wide agree-
ment that most cancer results from man-made and
SHB

A-12
natural environmental exposures (such as tobacco
smoke; chemical pollutants in air, water, food, drugs;
radiation; dietary constituents; radon; and infectious
agents) acting in concert with both genetic and ac-
quired characteristics. It has been estimated that
without these environmental factors, cancer incidence
would be dramatically reduced, by as much as
80%-90%. Cancer risk from these environmental
carcinogens is strongly influenced by many factors,
including genetics, age, ethnicity, sex, immune
function, pre-existing disease, and level of nutrition.
Genetic predisposition acting in isolation probably
explains no more than 5% of all cancers in the
United States."
"The counterpoint between the environment and
host susceptibility has been elaborated in recent years
through molecular epidemiologic studies of biologic
markers present in human cells, tissues, and body
fluids. Examples of 'biomarkers' are chemical-specific
genetic damage in the form of carcinogen-DNA
adducts or changes in key oncogenes or tumor suppres-
sor genes that either trigger or block cancer
development. Others document genetic and acquired
susceptibility traits affecting processes such as carcino-
gen metabolism, DNA damage, and repair. Analysis of
biomarkers is ir...__asingly being incorporated into
cross-sectional, retrospective, prospective, or nested
case-control studies to gain improved resolution of the
risk factors and mechanisms responsible for cancer."
"Molecular epidemiology has the advantage of being
directly relevant to human risk, unlike animal or other
experimental models that require extrapolation to
humans. In contrast to traditional epidemiology that
relies on cancer incidence or mortality as the end point,
molecular epidemiology has the potential to give early
warning by flagging the preclinical effects of exposure
and increased susceptibility, thus signaling opportuni-
ties to avert cancer through timely intervention.
Moreover, biomarker data on the distribution of
procarcinogenic changes and susceptibility factors in
the population can improve estimation of cancer risk
from a given exposure."
"However, molecular epidemiology is also subject to
many of the limitations of epidemiology, such as the
vulnerability to confounding factors that can give
misleading results.... At the present time, many
biomarkers can be useful in assessing exposure, dose,
ETS/IAQ REPORT, ISSUE 123
and potential risk for a group or population; most are
not, however, sufficiently characterized in terms of
their ability to predict disease for use in screening,
diagnosis, or quantitative estimation of individual risk.
... Although routine screening for cancer susceptibility
is not justified, the substantial body of molecular
epidemiologic and other data on susceptibility now in
existence can be helpful in shaping cancer risk assess-
ment, public health, and environmental policy."
"Unfortunately, prevention is not well served by
current methods to assess environmental risks. Al-
though sometimes characterized as overly conservative,
risk assessment methods currently used by government
agencies, such as the Environmental Protection
Agency, may underestimate the risk of certain environ-
mental carcinogens because of the inherent assumption
tiiat all individuals in a population have the same
biologic response to a specified dose of a cancer-causing
agent. The result can be regulatory and health policies
aimed at protecting the 'average American,' ignoring
the sizable, more vulnerable, fraction of the popula-
tion. While the assumption of population homogeneity
has long been in question, considerable quantitative
information on the range of susceptibility within
populations now shows that it is invalid."
"This review discusses representative examples of
molecular epidemiologic research during the last 10
years into the nature of susceptibility to common
environmental carcinogens. These are viewed within
the context of related experimental and epidemiologic
data on carcinogenesis. A brief summary of recent
evidence on molecular mechanisms in carcinogenesis
provides a framework for an in-depth discussion of
molecular and epidemiologic evidence of the role of
the environment in cancer. The sources of variation
in individual susceptibility to environmental carcino-
gens are then described in detail, with illustrative
examples from the recent literature. The final section
discusses some of the implications of individual
variability for current policies concerning risk assess-
ment and cancer prevention."
SHB

MAY 10, 1996
REPRODUCTIVE AND DEVELOPMENTAL_ISSUES
[61] "Neuroendocrine Cell Expression in Fetal Lungs
After Maternal Exposure to Aged and Diluted
Sidestream Cigarette Smoke (ADSS)," K.P.
Allamneni, C.G. Plopper, and K.E. Pinkerton,
The Toxicologist 30(1, Part 2): 235, 1996
"Pulmonary neuroendocrine cells (PNEC) are
specialized airway epithelial cells that may be involved
in chemoreception and cellular differentiation. These
cells are most abundant during the fetal and neonatal
stages of development. The purpose of this study was
to examine the effects of maternal exposure to ADSS
on the expression of PNEC. Timed-pregnant
Sprague-Dawley rats were exposed to ADSS for 6
hours/day, 7 days/week, from gestational day (DGA) 5
to the day prior to sacrifice, while control mothers were
exposed to filtered air only....(CGRP), a neuroendo-
crine marker was used to visualize PNEC
immunohistochemically in lung tissues at 14, 18 and
21 DGA. The frequency of positive cells in the airways
was measured per mm of basal lamina. At 14 DGA,
CGRP positive cells were not detected in the airway
epithelium of either group. At 18 DGA, CGRP
positive cells were found to be in greater abundance in
central airways compared with peripheral airways.
Maternal exposure to ADSS resulted in a significant
increase in CGRP positive cells at 18 DGA within
central and peripheral airways. These differences were
also found at 21 DGA in central and peripheral
airways. We conclude that PNEC differentiation in the
fetal lung is site-specific and that maternal exposure to
ADSS at environmentally relevant concentrations
significantly increases the number of neuroendocrine
cells within airways during cellular differentiation of
the fetal lung."
OTHER HEALTH ISSUES
A- 13
[621 "Risk Factors for Chronic Otitis Media With
Effusion in Infancy: Each Acute Otitis Media
Episode Induces a High but Transient Risk,"
O.P. Alho, H. Oja, M. Koivu, and M. Sorri,
Archives of Otolaryngology and Head-Neck
Surgery 121: 839-843, 1995
"Our current research was conducted to measure the
biologic effects of different risk factors on chronic otitis
media with effusion."
"Our results indicate that previous acute otitis media
episodes pose the greatest risk for chronic otitis media
with effusion. Each episode induces an increased risk,
which is highest immediately after the episode (>
10-fold) and gradually vanishes after 3 months. The
number of earlier episodes or an early first episode do
not affect the risk directly, ie, the risk associated with
acute otitis media episodes is not cumulative, as earlier
reports have indicated. It is true retrospectively that the
risk for chronic otitis media with effusion is higher if a
child has had numerous acute episodes, because tran-
sient risk is involved in each of them, but at any fixed
point of time, if the child has avoided chronic otitis
media with effusion so far, only information about the _
current month and the past 3 months is relevant."
"Accumulations of acute episodes proved to be
especially risky. This high risk attached to successive
episodes decreased rapidly. More aggressive treatment
of acute episodes, such as performing a
tympanocentesis and prescribing a beta-lactam antibi-
otic, did not affect the risk."
"The risk introduced by extrinsic factors is markedly
lower than that in previous acute episodes. On the
other hand, more powerful extrinsic risk variables exist
for chronic otitis media than were found for acute
otitis media earlier in this series." _
"Attendance at a group day nursery posed a twofold
risk, confirming earlier results. Previous screenings
have shown a clear seasonal variation in the occurrence
of abnormal rympanograms; the risk is markedly
higher during spring, autumn, and winter. Children
typically have acute otitis media episodes and attend
day care outside the home during these months, which
affects the figures. The dynamic model showed that the
risk estimates for autumn were especially high, but
SHB

A-14
those for the spring and winter were similar to the
summer figures. The maximum occurrence of chronic
otitis media with effusion was at the beginning of the
second year, even after adjustment for the other
time-dependent risk factors. Male sex also increased the_
risk twofold. Atopy, bottle-feeding, number of siblings,
and parental smoking [OR = 1.44, 95% CI 0.86 -
2.41] had an effect only through acute otitis media
episodes, and their effect was more modest than
reported earlier, probably because of better stand.rdiza-
tion of the effect of previous episodes."
"The risk of chronic otitis media with ::cfusion is
highest for a boy who has just had his first birthday, is
attending a day nursery outside the home during the
autumn, and has just experienced successive episodes of
acute otitis media. Previous acute otitis media episodes
were the greatest risk factor, and this investigation adds
to our earlier understanding of how this risk is medi-
ated; each acute episode induces an increased risk for
chronic otitis media with effusion that is highest
immediately after the episode and gradually vanishes
after 3 months. Successive acute episodes are especially
risky, but this high risk similarly decreases rapidly. The
number of previous acute episodes or an early first
episode do not affect the risk directly, ie, the risk
associated with acute otitis media episodes is not
cumulative as reported earlier."
[63] "Epidemiology in the Assessment of Small
Risks," D. Coggon, Transactions of the Institu-
tion of Chemical Engineers 73 (Part B, Suppl.):
S36-S38, 1995
"Bias occurs when deficiencies in the design or
execution of studies cause risks to be systematically
underestimated or overestimated.... Some bias is
unavoidable, even in the best designed epiderniological
studies, and the effects cannot be quantified precisely."
"Statistical uncertainty arises because we are limited
in the numbers of people we can study ... Uncertainty
of this sort can be quantified rather better than that
resulting from bias, for example, by calculation of
confidence intervals around risk estimates, but again it
cannot be eliminated."
"Confounding occurs when the people under investi-
gation differ not only in their exposure to the hazard_of
interest but also in other ways which independently
ETS/IAQ REPORT, ISSUE 123
influence their risk of disease....[R]eliable adjustment
for confounders depends on the accuracy of their
measurement. Furthermore, one can never exclude the
possibility of unrecognised confounders."
"The uncertainties in the interpretation of epidemio-
logical data are most troublesome when relative risks
(le the ratios of risk in people with and without
exposure to hazards) are small -- less than a 20%
elevation say. At this level, it becomes very difficult to
distinguish the effects of a hazard from those of bias,
chance and confounding."
"While the ability of epidemiology to detect effects
depends on the relative increase in disease incidence
associated with an exposure, risk management is based
on the absolute increase in risk and the number of
people affected. Uncertain risk estimates may be
tolerable when the disease caused is rare and few people
are exposed to the hazard."
"Difficulties arise when the diseases affected are more
common. For example, a 20% excess of lung cancer
represents an absolute increase of approximately one
case per 100 people over a lifetime. This would be
important if it applied to large numbers of people.
Some regulatory authorities seek to prevent lifetime
risks as low as one per million from environmental
carcinogens. Such small increases in the occurrence of
common diseases cannot be measured directly."
"An alternative, therefore, is to extrapolate from the
risks associated with higher exposures. This requires
first that exposure-response relationships can be
assessed reliably....[E]rrors in the assessment of
exposure can seriously distort exposure-response
relationships."
"A second requirement for the extrapolation of risks
to low exposures is that the shape of the
exposure-response curve can be predicted reliably
outside the range of empirical assessment. Calculations
often assume a linear relation between exposure and
risk, but this may not always be justified."
"Another consideration in the extrapolation of
exposure-response relationships is the comparability of
the populations from which data are derived and those _
to which the results are then applied. Often
exposure-response is assessed in occupational popula-
tions from which potentially vulnerable groups such as
children and the elderly are excluded."
SHB
9314,0339

MAY 10, 1996
"Can anything be done to counter these method-
ological problems? One approach which could reduce
the uncertainties in extrapc'.ation of exposure-response
relations is to examine intermediate endpoints in
epidemiological studies as well as looking at clinically
manifest disease." -
"While developments such as the measurement of
DNA adducts may eventually lead to improved
assessment of the risks posed by low exposures, many
of the problems will persist for the foreseeable future.
Thus decisions in risk management will continue to
rely on data that are often incomplete and uncertain."
[64] "The Epidemiology of Haemophilus influenzae
Type b Disease in the Republic of Ireland," J.
Fogarty, A.C. Moloney, and J.B. Newell,
Epidemiology oflnfectioru 114: 451-463, 1995
"The importance of Haemophilus influenzae type b
(Hib) as a cause of serious disease in infants and
children is well recognized. Meningitis is the principal
clinical disease but other conditions such as epiglottitis,
pneumonia, cellulitis, bone and joint infections and
septicaemia also occur. The major disease burden
occurs in children under 5 years."
"The purpc..,., of this study was to document baseline
incidence data on Hib disease for the Republic of
Ireland (ROI) against which Hib vaccine efficacy could
be evaluated after its introduction. A case-control
methodology was used to investigate the hypothesis
that certain risk factors not previously investigated in
the ROI or the United Kingdom (UK), were more
common in children with Hib disease than in controls."
"The annual incidence of Hib disease in Ireland was
similar to that experienced in England and Wales,
Scotland and France, lower than that in northern
Europe, Australia and New Zealand and American
populations of European origin, and substantially
lower than rates experienced in native American,
aboriginal and African children."
"Two significant risk factors for primary Hib disease
were identified: attendance at creche or day-care and
the presence of chronic illness. A strong relationship
between age and risk of Hib disease for creche or
day-care attendance was observed with the highest risk
experienced by children in the second year of life....
When stratified analysis was carried out for meningitis
A-15
and non-meningitic disease, creche attendance emerged
as a risk factor for non-meningitic Hib disease but not
for meningitis alone."
"The presence of chronic illness was another risk
factor for Hib disease in Irish children."
"No association with risk of Hib disease was observed
with such family characteristics as household cigarette
smoking, household crowding, presence of school-age
siblings or breast-feeding, although many of these
factors have been shown to be risk factors (or a protec-
tive factor in the case of breast feeding) in other
studies. The homogeneity of the Irish population may
account for the similarity in distribution of many of
these characteristics that have been shown to be risk
factors elsewhere. Of the two risk factors identified,
creche or day-care attendance may operate as an
environmental factor by increasing the likelihood of
children's exposure to Hib bacteria and chronic illness
would appear to act as a host factor increasing the
susceptibility to development of invasive Hib disease."
"Until there is evidence that Hib immunization
coverage rates reach 95% for eligible children in the
ROI, it is essential that children with chronic illness
and those who are creche or day-care attendees receive
Hib conjugate vaccine as a priority."
[65] "Inequality in Income and Mortality in the
United States: Analysis of Mortality and Poten-
tial Pathways," G.A. Kaplan, E.R. Pamuk, J.W.
Lynch, R.D. Cohen, and J.L. Balfour, British
Medical Journal312: 999-1003, 1996
"For the most part, socioeconomic level, whether it is
measured by income, education, occupation, social
class, or other measures, has been conceptualized as a
property of the individual. This is not surprising as
one's economic resources can determine, to a great
extent, the availability and quality of food, housing,
medical care, and other necessities. Recent findings,
however, suggest that it may also be important to
consider the overall distribution of wealth as a charac-
teristic of a society or group."
"We studied the relation between variations in
income distribution between states of the United States
and a variety of health outcomes, including variations
in mortalities adjusted for age. In addition, we exam-
ined some of the potential pathways, possibly reflecting
SHB
