Lorillard
Report on Recent Ets and Iaq Developments
Fields
- Alias
- 87805387/87805423
- Master ID
- 87805364/5929
Related Documents:- 87805364 Shb Reports on Recent Ets and Iaq Developments 930100 - 930600
- 87805365 Reports on Recent Ets and Iaq Developments 930100 - 930600
- 87805366
- 87805367
- 87805368
- 87805369
- 87805370
- 87805371
- 87805372
- 87805373
- 87805374-5385 Reports on Recent Ets and Iaq Developments Index of Articles Index of Appendices
- 87805406-5407 Statement by Secretary of Labor Lynn Martin
- 87805408 Environmental Tobacco Smoke in the Workplace
- 87805409-5411 Facts About Secondhand Smoke
- 87805412-5413 Secondhand Smoke in Your Home
- 87805414-5415 Secondhand Smoke in the Workplace
- 87805416-5417 Secondhand Smoke in the Restaurants
- 87805418-5419 Secondhand Smoke in the Restaurants
- 87805420 Tips for Effective Letters
- 87805421-5422 Organizations with More Information
- 87805423 Ets / Iaq Report Fax Communication Sheet
- 87805425-5484 Report on Recent Ets and Iaq Developments
- 87805450-5458 Remarks by Lautenberg (D - Nj) on S. 261 and S. 262 Preventing Our Kids From Inhaling Deadly Smoke (Pro Kids) Act of 930000 (Cr Page S-916, 114 Lines)
- 87805459-5461 U.S. Ties Secondhand Smoke to Cancer
- 87805462 A Dying Smoker's Tale
- 87805463-5465 Epa Designates Passive Smoking A 'class A' or Known Human Carcinogen
- 87805466-5471 S. 262 Preventing Our Federal Building Workers and Visitors From Exposure to Deadly Smoke (Pro-Feds) Act of 930000
- 87805472 Resolution Before the Boma Board of Governors
- 87805473-5480 Passive Smoking Questions and Answers
- 87805481-5483 Press Notice Passive Smoking Opens at the Science Museum
- 87805484 Ets / Iaq Report Fax Communication Sheet
- 87805486-5543 Report on Recent Ets and Iaq Developments
- 87805515 Request for Information Regarding Environmental Tobacco Smoke
- 87805516-5521 Ets Bibliography Smoking and Sudden Death Syndrome
- 87805522 Environmental Tobacco Smoke References: Otitis Media
- 87805523-5528 Ets and Perinatal Effects Bibliography
- 87805529-5537 Ets Bibliography Cancers
- 87805538-5542 A Bill to Amend the Health and Safety at Work Etc. Act 740000 So As to Provide for the Control of Smoking in Places of Work, and for Connected Purposes
- 87805543 Ets / Iaq Report Fax Communication Sheet
- 87805545-5581 Report on Recent Ets and Iaq Developments
- 87805573-5574 Attachment II Exhibit 3
- 87805575-5580 Environmental Protection Integrated Risk Information System (Iris): Announcement of Availability of Background Paper
- 87805581 Ets / Iaq Report Fax Communication Sheet
- 87805583-5619 Report on Recent Ets and Iaq Developments
- 87805606-5611
- 87805612-5618
- 87805619 Ets / Iaq Report Fax Communication Sheet
- 87805621-5662 Report on Recent Ets and Iaq Developments
- 87805657-5659
- 87805660-5661 What Editorials Say About the Epa Report
- 87805662 Ets / Iaq Report Fax Communication Sheet
- 87805664-5704 Report on Recent Ets and Iaq Developments
- 87805691 Junk Science
- 87805692-5703 Tobacco Institute of Australia Limited Plaintiff Stephen Woodward Defendant Statement of Claim No. 2146 of 930000
- 87805704 Ets / Iaq Report Fax Communication Sheet
- 87805706-5742 Report on Recent Ets and Iaq Developments
- 87805732-5735 Joanne Bahura, Plaintiffs, Vs. S.E.W. Investors, Defendants Civil Action No. 90-Ca-10594 Judge Rufus King, III Plaintiff's Second Amended Designation of Expert Witnesses
- 87805736-5741 Involuntary Smoking the Factual Basis for Action
- 87805742 Ets / Iaq Report Fax Communication Sheet
- 87805744-5777 Report on Recent Ets and Iaq Developments
- 87805777 Ets / Iaq Report Fax Communication Sheet
- 87805779-5805 Report on Recent Ets and Iaq Developments
- 87805805 Ets / Iaq Report Fax Communication Sheet
- 87805807-5849 Report on Recent Ets and Iaq Developments
- 87805838 Occupational Safety + Health Administration National Advisory Committee on Occupational Safety and Health, Request for Nominations
- 87805839-5848 Testimony of Lynn Rhinehart Occupational Safety and Health Specialist Department of Occupational Safety and Health American Federation of Labor and Congress of Industrial Organizations Before the Senate Subcommittee on Clean Air and Nuclear Regulation Committee on Environment and Public Works on S. 656, the Indoor Air Quality Act of 930000
- 87805849 Ets / Iaq Report Fax Communication Sheet
- 87805851-5928 Report on Recent Ets and Iaq Developments
- 87805878-5926 Flue-Cured Tobacco Cooperative Stabilization Corporation Plaintiffs, Vs. United States Environmental Protection Agency, Defendants. Civil Action No. 619301370 Complaint for Declaratory and Injunctive Relief
- 87805927 Tobacco Firms Sue Epa on Cancer Ruling Secondhand - Smoke Studies Based on Fudged Data, Industry Alleges
- 87805928 Ets / Iaq Report Fax Communication Sheet
- Type
- REPT, OTHER REPORT
- PSCI, SCIENTIFIC PUBLICATION
- Site
- G65
- Author (Organization)
- Shb, Shook,Hardy & Bacon
- Litigation
- Stmn/Produced
- Area
- SPEARS,ALEXANDER/OFFICE
- Characteristic
- PARE, PARENT
- Date Loaded
- 12 Feb 1999
- UCSF Legacy ID
- ixb40e00
Document Images
SHOOK, HAR,nY& BACON P c.
REPORT ON RECENT ETS
AND IAQ DEVELOPMENTS
January 22, 1993
SHB

REPORT ON RECENT ETS AND IAQ DEVELOPMENTS
- IN THIS ISSUE -
IN THE UNITED STATES
REGUTATORY AND LEGISLATIVE MATTERS
OSHA directed to commence rulemaking
on workplace smoking, p. 1.
ASH files new court petition to force OSHA
action on workplace smoking, p. 1.
Centers for Disease Control campaign:
"Stop Being a Passive Victim," p. 2.
ETS-RELATED LITIGATION AGAINST
CIGARETTE MANUFACTURERS
In Blanchard plaintiffs file first amended
petition, p. 4.
In Broin, plainti8s file brief in class action
appeal, p. 4.
ISSUE 39
IN EUROPE & AROUND THE WORLD
REGULATORY AND LEGISLATIVE MATTERS
In Canada, smokers gather signatures to
repeal Ottawa's workplace smoking ban,
p.8.
In Hong Kong, antismoking lobbyists base
call for smoking bans on U! S. EPA Risk
Assessment on ETS, p. 8.
LEGAL ISSUES AND DEVELOPSIEN-rS
International airline traveler threatens suit
against United Airlines after allegedly
contracting viral pneumonia, p. 9.
SCIENTIFIC/TECHti1CAL ITEMS
"Factors Associated with Bronchial
Hyperresponsivencss in Australian Adults
and Children," p. 9.
"Atopy and Environmental Factors in Upper
Respiratory Infections: An Epidemiological
Survey on 2304 School Children " p. 9.
"Passive Smoking and Hearing Loss in
Infants," p. 10.
ETS/IAQLITIGATION NOT INVOLVING
CIGARETTE MANUFACTURERS
A Pennsylvania woman allegedly sues a
restaurant for assault and battery because of
alleged exposure to ETS, p. 5.
SCIE'.?IFIC/TECHNiCAL ITEMS
"Passive Smoking Increases Experimental
Atherosclerosis in Cholesterol-fed Rabbits,"
P.5.
OTHER DEVELOPMENTS
Nursing home accreditation to include
smoking issues, p. 6.
OTHER DwELOPMwTS
In Canada, a business advises smokers not to
apply for employment, p. 10.
MEDIA COVERAGE
"Children's Frequent Illnesses Part of
Growing Up," p. 6.

- TABLE OF CONTENTS -
Issue 39 January 22, 1993
IN' THE UNITED STATES
REGULATORY AND LEGISIATIVE MATTERS
U.S. OCCUPATIONAL SAfETY & HEALTH ADMINISTRATION (OSHA)
[ 1] OSHA Directed to Commence Rulemaking on Workplace Smoking
......................................1
(2] ASH Files New Petition to Force-0SHA Action on Workplace ETS
.......................................1
(3l' U:S. Chamber of Commerce to Propose Draft of OSHA Rcf'orm
............................................ 2
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES (HHS)
(4]
New Health Secretary Expresses Smoking Views
.....................................................................2
(5l Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Launch Nonsmoker Campaign
...........................2
STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
[6),
(7) Privacy Legislation
....................................................................................................
............... 3
Other State and Local'Legislative Activities Relatcd to ETS
..................................................... 3
ETS-RBLATED LITIGATION AGAINST CIGARETTE MANUFACTURERS
[8] Blarrchard Plaintiffs File First Amended Petiuon
.....................................................................4
(9) Brnin: Plaintiffs File Brief in Class Action Appeal
....................................................................4
ETS/IAQ LITIGATION NOT INVOLVING CIGARETTE MANUFACTURERS
ASSAULT AND BATTERY
(10] Pennsylvania Woman Sues Restaurant
.....................................................................................5
LABOR REIATIONS
1111 Dnig Plarrics e Gtau Carrrpany, Inc. (National Labor Relations Board)
(decided December 16, 1992)
.................................................................................................. 5
SCIENTIFIC/TECHNICAL ITEMS
CARDIOVASCULAR ISSUES
(12) "Passive Smoking Increases Experimental Atherosclerosis in Cholecterol-fed Rabbits,"
B: Q. Zhu, Y.-P. Sun, ILE. Sievers, W.M. Isenberg, S.A. Glantz, and W.W. Parmky,
Journal af the Amerrrarr College of Cardiolagy 21(1): 225-232, 1993
.......................................... 5
OTHER HEALTH IssuEs
[13] "Maternal Cigarette Smoking DuringPregnanry: A Risk Factor forChitdhood Strabismus,°
R.B. Hakim and J.M. Tielsch, Arrhiurr ojOpbrhalmology 110: 1459-1462, 1992
[See Appendix
A]..................................................................................................
.................... ...................................................... 5
INDOOR AIR QUALITY
[14l "Engineering Controls for Clean Air in the Office Environment," M.J. Ellenbecker,
Cli+oirr in Chert Medicir'x 13(2): 193-199, 1992 [See Appendix A)
........................................... 5
OTHER DEVELOPMENTS
[15l Nursing Home Accreditation to Include Smoking Issues
.........................................................6
(16] Environmental Consulting Firm to Write IAQTattbook
...................................................
..... 6
(17] Michigan Lung Association Conducts Workplace Smoking Seminar
.......................................6
MEDIA COVERAGE
[19] "Children's Frequent Illnesses Part of Growing Up," B.A. Epstein,
Sa AerertLurg Tima. January 11, 1993
.....................................................................................6
[19]'USA Weekend Focuses on Indoor Air Pollution and Health
...................................................7
1201 "No Smoking Rules Forcing Employees to Cut Baek," S. Ross,
The Rertrer Bserirreir Rtport January 5, 1993
............................................................................. 7

Contents Continued, Issue 39
IN EUROPE & AROUND THE WORLD
REGULATORY AND LEGISLATIVE MATTERS
AuSTwu.u
CANADA
[211 Municipalities Near Toronto Consider Toughening Smoking Restrictions
..............................7
[22] Smokers Gather Signatures to Repeal Ottawa's Workplace Smoking Ban
................................ 8
CZECHOSLOVAKIA
HONG KONG
[23] Antismoking Lobbyists Call For Smoking Bans
....................................................................... 8
ToaxEY
[24] Official Calls for Smoking Bans
...............................................................................................8
UNITED KINGDOM
[25] Health Minister Warns Antismoking Legislation May be Introduced
......................................8
LEGAL ISSUES AND DEVELOPMENTS
[26] International Airline Traveler Threatens Suit AgainsrUnited Airlines
.....................................9
SCIENTIFIC/TECHNICAL ITEMS
CARDIOVASCUlAR ISSUES
(27] "Serum Lipids & Lipoprotcin Profiles of Cigarette Smokers & Passive Smokers,"
J. Whig. C.B. Singh, G.L. Soni, and AK. Bansal, Indian Jor.rna! ofMrdical
Rexarch 96(B): 262-287, 1992 [See Appendix A]
.................................................................... 9
RFSPIRATORY DISEASES AND CONDITIONS - CHILDREN
[281'"Factors Associated with Bronchial Hyperresponsiveness in Australian Adults
and Children," J.K. Peat. C.M. Salomc, AJ. Wookock, European Rrspirasory
Joarna! 5:; 921-929, 1992 [See Appendix A]
............................................................................ 9
[29] "Atopy and Environnxntal Factors in Upper Respiratory Infections: An Epidemiological
Survey on 2304 School Children," E. Porro, P. Calarnita, I. Rana, L Montini, and
S. Criscione, huernarionalJorrrnalofPedia:ric Ororhinolaryngology24: 111-120, 1992
[See Appendix A]
....................................................................................................
.................9
(30) "Circadian Rhythm of Peak Expiratory Flow in Children Passively Exposed and
Not Exposed to Cigarette Smoke." R. Casale, G. Natali, D. Colantonio.
P. Pasqualetti. Thorax 47: 801-803, 1992 [See Appendix A]
.................................................... 9
OTHER HEALTH ISSUES
[31] "Passive Smoking and Hearing Loss in Infants,° R.A. Lyons,
IrisbMedicalJor.rnal85(3): 111-112, 1992 [SecAppendixA]
............................................... 10
OTHER DEVELOPMENTS
AUSTRALIA
[32) Solomon Airlines Imposes Smoking Ban .........................
...................................................... 10
CANADA
[33] ETS Objectives Revcaled as Part of National Non-Smoking Week
........................................ 10
[34] i Business Advises Smokers Not to Apply for Employment
...................................................... 10
[35] Nonsmokers Publish Dining Guide
.......................................................................................10
[36] Woodstove Users Warned of Health Risks
.............................................................................10
APPENDIX A
....................................................................................................
................................Anicle Summaries
APPENDIX B
................................................................................................Secr
etary Martin Memo and Press Release
APPENDIX C
....................................................................................................
........... HHS ETS Campaign Materials

JANUARY 22, 1993
1
REPORT ON RECENT ETS
AND IAQ DEVELOPMENTS
IN THE UNITED STATES
REGULATORY AND LEGISLATIVE
MATTERS
U.S. OCCL'PATIONAL SAFETY & HFALTH
ADMINISTRATION (OSHA)
[1]' OSHA Directed to Commence Rulemaking on
Workplace Smoking
On January 13, 1993, six days after the EPA released
its Risk Assessment on ETS and one week before
leaving office, then-Labor Secretary Lynn Martin
directed OSHA "to commence rulemaking to address
the hazards of occupational exposure to secondhand
smoke." She instructed!the agency to prepare a report
for current Labor Secretary Robert Reich (who was
confirmed by the Senate on January 21) that would
provide rulemaking alternatives and analyze "the
evidence in terms of the threshold OSHA must meet in
order to regulate."
Martin urged OSHA to consider all information
about the alleged health effects of ETS, including the
EPA risk assessment. As to the latter, she noted that
EPA focused upon the "home environment" and that
OSHA would need to "examine these concerns and
determine how they apply to the workplace."
Currently, there are no federal rules regulating smoking
in privately-owned, non-industrial workplaces. Published
press reports indicated that after the ETS tisk assessment
was released, former Secretary of Health and Human
Services Louis Sullivan and others tried to persuade
President Bush to sign, before he left office, a proposed
executive order banning smoking from federal agency
offices, but the order was not signed.
Martin said the review of workplace smoking issues
would include information received in response to the
Request for Information on indoor air quality, issued in
September 1991, but that continued action with
respect to ETS issues would be "apart from the indoor
air quality rulemaking." She was quoted as saying, "'If
we look at a rulemaking without separating [ETS issues]
we'll be at about [the year] four billion and ten before we
get a rule.'" See Daily Labor Report, January 15, 1993.
With respect to the RFI, she said OSHA's Office of
Health Standards is currently completing its analysis of
the 1,200-plus responses in the public docket.
Before delivering the above directive to OSHA,
Martin requested several policy options with respect to
ETS issues. According to one media report, Martin
"expressed interest in more dramatic action - such as
proposing regulations or an emergency temporary
standard limiting ETS exposure - but OSHA officials
had responded that such measures could not be
supported by available evidence on the work-related''
hazards of breathing secondhand smoke." See Daily
Labor Report, January 15, 1993.
Like President Bush and most appointees of his
administration, Martin relinquished her government
post on January 20 with the inauguration of President
Bill Clinton.
Copies of Martin's press release and memorandum to
former Acting OSHA Director Dorothy Strunk are
attached as Appendix B.
[2] ASH Files New Petition to Force OSHA Action
on Workplace ETS
On December 22, 1992, Action on Smoking and
Health (ASH) filed a petition for review in the District
of Columbia Circuit Court of Appeals seeking, among
other matters, to overturn OSHA's recent denial of
ASH's request that the agency initiate separate
rulemaking proceedings for ETS in the workplace.
ASH's written request was made on July 31, 1992.
OSHA's denial came in an October 30, 1992, letter to
ASH from then-Acting OSHA Director Dorothy L
Strunk, in which Strunk stated that nothing would be
gained by separating the issue of ETS from other
indoor air quality issues. Sce issue 34 of this Report,
November 6, 1992.

2
The ASH petition: also seeks the regulation of ETS as
a potential carcinogen pursuant to the alleged mandate
of the OSHA Cancer Policy and claims that OSHA
has unreasonably delayed making a determination
about initiating rulemaking proceedings on workplace
ETS exposure following its September 1991 issuance
of a Request for Information on indoor air quality
(RFI). ASH requests that the court remand the matter
to OSHA for further consideration of ASH's petition
for the regulation of ETS in the workplace and that a
timetable be set for OSHA compliance.
Submitted to the court with its petition for review is
a request by ASH that the case be heard by the same
panel of judges which considered ASH's previous
petitions against OSHA. ASH notes that, in a January
1992 order, the panel "clearly contemplated that there
might be the need for further review and adjudication.
That order was issued 'without prejudice to renewal of
petitioner's request in the event that OSHA unreason-
ably delays resolution of this matter following receipt
of comments'" to the RFL Sce BNA Daily Labor
Report, January 7, 1993.
ASH v. Department of Labor, No. 92-1 G61 (U.S.
Court ofAppeals, D.C. Circuit) (filed December 22,
1992).
[3] U.S. Chamber of Commerce to Propose Draft
of OSHA Reform
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce is reportedly
drafting its own version of job safety reform legislation.
According to Steve Bokat, the Chamber's vice presi-
dent and general counsel, the Chamber will probably
not release its draft until after it sees the legislation
being considered by Democrats in Congress and the
approach of the new Labor Secretary Robert Reich.
According to the head of the coalition, the coalition
is still interested in discussing OSHA reforms with
labor and Congressional leaders, but emphasized that
the bill introduced in the last Congress should not be
the starting point for discussion. As noted in issue 32
of this Report, October 9, 1992, the Comprehensive
Occupational Safety and Health Reform Act of 1992
died in the last Congress without moving beyond the
committee level.
Bokat has reportedly stated during testimony before
the House Education and Labor Committee that the
ETS/1AQ REPORT, ISSUE 39
Chamber opposed the mandatory safety programs and
joint committees and expansion of criminal penalties
that were a part of last year's reform legislation. The
Chamber did support, however, provisions requiring
more timely reporting of fatal and serious accidents,,
stronger worker protections in imminent danger
situations and pay for employees accompanying OSHA
inspectors during safety inspections. See BNA Current
Davclopments, December 21, 1992.
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
AND HUmw SERVICES (HHS)
[4] New Health Secretary Expresses Smoking Views
During her confirmation hearings before the Senate
Labor Committee, HHS Secretary Donna Shalala
reportedly pledged that she would be an avid cam-
paigner against smoking. Shalala daimed that when she
was chancellor at the University of Wisconsin, she was
most noted for "firing the football coach and ending
smoking in all publirbuildings." Although Shalala
evidently did not address the EPA's Risk Assessment
on~ETS during her confirmation hearings, she did say
that she would work to find "powerful incentives" to
help turn people away from smoking. Srs AP, January
15, 1993. Shalala was confirmed by the Senate on
January 21, 1993.
[5] Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
Launch Nonsmoker Campaign
As announced by then-HHS Secretary Louis Sullivan
during the January 7 press conference for the release of
the EPA Risk Assessment on ETS, the Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention have launched a
multimedia information campaign entitled "Stop
Being a Passive Victim." The campaign includes a
guide book that offers suggestions to nonsmokers.
Among the suggestions are recommendations that
employees ask their employers to look into health
insurance that rewards the company for being smoke
free, that nonsmokers write letters to restaurants with
smoking sections and request that they ban smoking
altogether, and that nonsmokers tell guests in their
homes that they may not smoke there. A toll-free
telephone number is provided for individuals to order
free copies of the booklet, which also discusses the
alleged hazards of ETS exposure. See Gannett News

JANUARY 22, 1993
Service, January 7, 1993. Other materials from the
campaign are attached as Appendix C.
STATE AND LOCAL GOVERN9v[ENTS
[6] Privacy Legislation
The term "privacy legislation" refers to state statutes
which protect workers who smoke off the job or, more
generally, use legal products or engage in legal ~ activities
outside the workplace.
District of Columbia
On January 5, 1993, Mayor Sharon Pratt Kelly reportedly
signed a measure which prohibits employers from dis-
criminating against smokers. Washington, D.C., joins the
twenty-eight states that currently have privacy laws; a 29th
state provides protection to workers by executive order. Ste
The Washington Tima, January 7, 1993.
Massachusetts
A bill that would prohibit employers from discriminat-
ing against applicants or employees for the use of
tobacco products outside the course of employment
reportedly passed the House on December 22, 1992,
and was sent to the Senate. See H.B. 3857, 177th
General Court - Regular Sess. (1992).
[7] Other State and Local Legislative Activities
Related to ETS
California
A bill that would prohibit employers from permitting
smoking in enclosed places in the workplace was sent to
the Assembly Committee on Labor and Employment on
January 14, 1993. SeeA.B. 13, Regular Sess. (1993).
Mississippi
On January 6, 1993, two bills that would prohibit
smoking in certain public indoor areas were reportedly
introduced and sent to the House Committee on
Public Health and Welfare. See H.B. 184 and H.B.
185, 162d Legislature - Regular Sess. (1993). On the
same date, a bill that would prohibit smoking in state
office buildings was reportedly introduced and sent to
the House Committee on Public Buildings, Grounds
and Lands. See H.B. 181, 162d Legislature - Regular
Sess. (1993).
Montana
The Senate State Administration Committee is report-
edly considering a measure that would end a require-
3
ment that all state buildings have a designated smoking
area. See USA Today,January 1'4,1993.
New Hampshire
Already among those states with tough antismoking
legislation, New Hampshire will apparently broaden
current smoking restrictions on July 1, 1993, applying
them to private-sector businesses, hotels, motels, resorts,
convention centers, inns and restaurants seating more
than 50 patrons. Smoking was already prohibited in
public schools, day care centers, grocery stores, malls,
beauty salons, hospitals, elevators, and public transporta-
tion. Smoking restrictions requiring designated smoking
areas or bans were in effect for theaters, banks, sports
facilities, stores, office buildings and all public or govern-
mental buildings. See The Union Leader, January 7, 1993.
A bill that would require each county superior court-
house to have a separate nonpublic smoking area for
crime victims and their families was reportedly intro-
duced on January 6, 1993, and sent to the House
Committee on the Judiciary. Set H.B. 160, 153d
Legislative Sess. (1993-1994).
New York
During his "Message to the Legislature" on January 7,
1993, Governor Mario Cuomo (D) announced that he
would seek legislation this year to prohibit smoking on all
school grounds and to expand smoking prohibitions in
places where children typically meet. The chairman of the
Assembly's Health Committee has reportedly endorsed
the governor's proposals. See UPl, January 7, 1993.
Obio
Governor George Voinovich (R) has issued an execu-
tive order banning smoking in all state buildings and
vehicles, whether owned or leased by the state. Accord-
ing to published press reports, residential areas of state
universities and other institutions, such as prisons, will
be exempt from the ban. No implementation date has
apparently been set, but it is expected that the ban will
take effect after the Department of Administrative Services
meets with state employees. Apparently, the union
representing the 37,000 state workers will not oppose the
move, but will request that the state assist workers who
wish to quit smoking. See UPI, January 10, 1993.
Oklahoma
A bill that would prohibit smoking in licensed nursing
homes and day care centers was reportedly prefiled on
December 21, 1992. SeeH.B. 1015, 44th Legislature
- 1st Regular Sess. (1993).

4
Wisconsin
According to the director of the Wisconsin Initiative on
Smoking and Healthi the organization is working with
state legislators to enact laws that would restrict smoking
in public places. In a recent study released by the group, it
was reported that nearly 25 percent of Milwaukee area
restaurants are violating state laws by failing to set aside
areas for nonsmokers. Some of the restaurant owners
surveyed by the study apparently said they were unaware
that state law requires that restaurants seating 50 or
more patrons must have a nonsmoking section. State
Senator Fred A. Risser (D-Madison) daimed to be
disappointed in Milwaukee's lack of compliance and
said that patrons should complain to their district
attorneys if they want a nonsmoking section in a
restaurant. See UPI, January 8, 1993.
Local Governments in California
Ventura County Public Health Services officials are
reportedly trying to convince cities in the county to
enact anti-smoking legislation in light of the release of
the EPA Risk Assessment on ETS. Apparently, Santa
Paula and Fillmore are the only cities in the county
which do not prohibit smoking in public buildings or
reserve at least 50% of restaurant tables for nonsmok-
ers. According to a senior health educator with the
county's Tobacco Education and Control Center, the
Center is working with residents of Thousand Oaks, who
are lobbying to strengthen the city's current smoking
restrictions. SeeLorAngelrs Tima,January8, 1993.
Local Governments in Washington
The Snohomish County Health District Board report-
edly learned on January 12, 1993, that it cannot
mandate smoking bans in restaurants as it lacks the
authority to supersede state law on the issue. Evidently,
one of the county's health officers had considered
proposing that the district require all restaurants to be
smoke free in order to obtain a business license. See
The Srattlr Times, January 14, 1993.
ETS-RELATED LITIGATION'AGAINST
CIGARETTE MANUFACTURERS
[8] Blanchard Plaintiffs File First Amended Petition
On January 11, 1993, plaintiffs filed a First Amended
Petition purporting to add the daims of nine new
ETS/IAQ REPORT, ISSUE 39
plaintiffs. The total number ofplaintiffs now stands at 14,
three of whom are making daims individually and as the
representative of a decedent.
All of the new plaintiffs' claims appear to relate to active
smoking, with one exception. Plaintiff Pamela Kastrin
Stephens claims unspecified "lung and respiratory
diseases" allegedly caused by exposure to the ETS from the
cigarettes smoked by her deceased father, George Kastrin
(whose widow has made a daim individually and as his
representative).
The original plaintiffs in this case, Raye Blanchard and
Tamara Reed, are mother and daughter. They allege
primary-smoking injuries to Raye Blanchard's late
husband, Thomas, who allegedlysmoked for more than
50 years, and Raye Blanchard hetself, who daims she
smoked "for about ten years." In additionj Raye
Blanchard and Tamara Reed'both claim damages for
unspecified "illness and disease" allegedly resulting from
exposure to the ETS from cigarettes smoked by Thomas
and Raye Blanchard. Prior to the amended petition filed
on January 11, plaintifls filed a First Supplemental
Petition purporting to add three additional plaintifffs, each
ofwhom daim injury from active smoking. The named
defendants are purported to be the six major U.S. cigarette
manufacturers, The Tobacco Institute, the Council for
Tobacco Research, and a number ofwholesalers and
retailers. Blanchar~ a a1 v. R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Com-
pany, etaL (District Court; Galveston County, Texas)
(filed July 31,1992).
[9] Broin: Plaintiffs File$rief in Class Action Appeal
On January 11, 1993, plaintifis filed their opening briefon
their appeal of the dismissal of their dass action allegations.
Defendants' brief in response is due February 10.
With respect to defendants' petition for certiorari
relating to plaintif35' attempts to depose top company
executives, plaintiffs sought an extension - until Febru-
ary 9- to file their response to the petition.
Both the appeal of the dismissal of the dass action
allegations and the petition for certiorari are pending in
the Third District Court of Appeal.
In the trial court, plaintiffs filed a second amended
complaint containing amended fraud and conspiracy
counts against the Council for Tobacco Research and the
Tobacco Merchants Association on January 7, 1993.
Both CTR and TMA had been dismissed by the court
on November 2.

JAN UARY 22, 1993
As to defendants' written discovery requests, unsigned
responses to interrogatories have now been submitted
for 26 of the 30 plaintifffs. Ten of those responses were
submitted after the December 21 deadline established
by the trial court. Plaintiffs made no effort to extend
the deadline.
At issue in this case are the claims of 30 flight atten-
danu allegedly injured by occupational exposure to ETS.
The injuries alleged by the putative dass representatives
induded lung cancer, breast cancer and unspecified
respiratoryy ailments. Thedefendants are purported to be
the six major U.S. cigarette manufaaurets (plus related
entities), Unite& States Tobacco Co., Dosal Tobacco.
Corp., the Council for Tobacco Research, The Tobacco
Institute, and three other trade associations. Bmin, cr aL v.
Phikp Morr'u, et aL (Circuit Court, Dade County, Florida)
(filed Oaober 31,1991):
ETS/IAQ LITIGATION NOT INVOLVING
CI GARETTE IvIAN UFACTURERS
ASSAULT AND BATTERY
[10] Pennsylvania Woman Sues Restaurant
According to published press reports, a Pennsylvania
woman is suing a restaurant in Allegheny County, Pa.,
for assault and battery because of alleged exposure to
ETS. The woman, Diana Andromalos-Dale, reportedly
claims that she suffered a severe asthmatic attack after
the restaurant seated her near smokers, despite her
request to dine in a nonsmoking area. See The Wall
StnerJournai, January 7, 1993.
LABOR RELATIONS
[ 11] Drug Plastics 6 Glau Company, Inc. (National
Labor Relations Board) (decided December 16,
1992)
The Board has reportedly affirmed the decision of an
administrative law judge that the employer lawfully
discharged an employee for violating its policy against
smoking on the production floor while production was
in progress. Although the Board rejected the
employee's claim that he was discharged because of his
union organizing activities, it did affirm a finding that
5
the employer committed unfair labor practices in the
context of the union's organizing campaign. See BNA
Daily Labor Report, January 14, 1993.
SCIENTIFIC/TECHNICAL ITEMS
CARDIOVASCUlAR IssUEs
[12] "Passive Smoking Increases Experimental Athero-
sderosis in Cholesterol-fed Rabbits," B.-Q. Zhu,
Y: P. Sun, R.E Sievers, W.M. Isenberg, S.A.
Glantz, and W.W. Parmley, Journal ofrlxAnuri-
can Collegr of Cardiology 21(1): 225-232, 1993
A paper based on this study, which was presented at
the American H'eart Association Meeting in November
1992, has now been published! It is essentially un-
changed from the manuscript previously excerpted. See
Issue 36 ofthis Report, December 4, 1992.
OTHER HEALTH ISSL`ES
[13] "Maternal Cigarette Smoking During Preg-
nancy: A Risk Factor for Childhood Strabis-
mus," R.B. Hakim and J.M. Tielsch, Archives of
Ophthalmology 110: 1459-1462, 1992 [See
Appendix A]
The authors report on a case-control study investigat-
ing a daimed association between childhood strabis-
mus(i.e., "'cross-eye") and prenatal risk factors. The
authors report that maternal smoking during preg-
nancy was associated with an elevated risk of strabis-
mus. Moreover, they claim that maternal smoking
during pregnancyand'exposure to paternal smoking
was associated with an even higher risk.
INDOOR AIR QUALITY
[14] "Engineering Controls for Clean Air in the
Office Environment," M.J. F1lenbecker, Clfnics
in ChtstMediciru 13(2): 193-199, 1992 [See
Appendix A]
The author of this study reviews basic characteristics
of "building engineering control systems" and how
they might contribute to occupant health and comfort.

6
He advocates increased ventilation and maintenance of
HVAC systems to alleviate complaints of poor indoor
air quality in the workplace.
OTHER DEVELOPMENTS
[15], Nursing Home Accreditation to Include Smoking
Issues
According to a newswire report, the nation's principal
health-care accrediting body reportedly voted at its
January 1993 Board of Commissioners' meeting to ,
impose smoking restrictions upon the more than 1,000
nursing homes it accredits. The action reportedly was
taken to reduce bed fires and prevent interference with
the care of respiratory patients. Although nursing home
residents are exempt from the ban, the Joint Commis-
sion on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations will
require that accredited facilities prohibit staff and
visitors from smoking. The ban is scheduled to become
effective on January 1, 1994.
The Commission is a private, non-profit group that
surveys health facilities to determine if they meet
industry standards. Lack of accreditation does not
affect a nursing home's ability to obtain~reimbursement
for Medicare and Medicaid, but it can reportedlyy
impact a facility's ability to obtain loans and low
insurance rates. The policy will only affect a small'
percentage of the nation's 20,000 nursing homes.
The Commission had previously imposed smoking
restrictions on some 5,000 hospitals and mental care
facilities. This policy was reportedly modified follow-
ing criticism from psychiatrists who said some mentally
ill patients smoke to relieve stress. Mentally ill indi-
viduals, long term care residents, prison psychiatric
patients, and post-acute head trauma patients will now
be permitted to smoke without practitioner authoriza-
tion under the commission's restrictions. Sce AP,
January 16, 1993.
[16] Environmental Consulting Firm to Write IAQ
Textbook
Gobbell Hays Partners Inc., a Nashville-based
architectural, engineering and environmental consult-
ETS/IAQ REPORT, ISSUE 39
ing firm, has reportedly signed a contract with
McGraw-Hillito publish what the firm believes will be
the first comprehensive textbook on IAQ for students
and professionals. According to Gobbell presidenr,
Ronald V. Gobbell, students and professionals arc
currently not getting training on IAQ issues. Gobbell
previously consulted on an asbestos manual for build-
ing operators that was prepared by the EPA and the
U.S. General Services Administration. See Nashvilk
Busiruss Jousna4 December 7, 1992.
[17] Michigan Lung Association Conducts Work-
place Smoking Seminar
The American Lung Association of Michigan report-
edly held a seminar on workplace smoking on January
20, 1993, in Southfield. Entitled "Smoking in the
Workplace in the 1990s," the seminar was expected to
deliver the message that Michigan businesses must take
action to reduce the alleged threat of ETS in the
workplace. According to published press reports,
faculty participants were to include representatives of
the state department of public health, a health consult-
ing firm, a law firm and a hospital! S« PR Nrwswire,
January 8, 1993.
MEDIA COVERAGE
[18] "Children's Frequent Illnesses Part of Growing
Up," B.A. Epstein, Sti Perershurg Times, Janu-
ary 11, 1993
Dr. Bruce A. Epstein, a St. Petersburg pediatrician,
claims in this opinion piece that "children who live
with tobacco smokers suffer a type of child abuse."
Epstein makes this assertion within the context of
explaining that nearly all children suffer six to eight
colds per year during the first five years of life. He
attributes their susceptibility to illness to the following:
immature immune systems; allergies; direct exposure to
other sick children in day care, preschool'and nurseries;
and indirect exposure from older siblings who are in
school. Epstein believes, however, that ETS exposure is
the "most notorious" of additional risk factors predis-
posing children to illness and insists that parents,
grandparents and babysitters not smoke in a confined
area in the presence of children.

JANUARY 22, 1993
[19] USA Weekend Focuses on Indoor Air Pollution
and Health
USA Weekend recently published a series of anicles
answering reader questions about sick building syn-
drome, ETS, radon, and other alleged sources of poor
indoor air quality. Readers had been asked in Septem-
ber 1992 to submit written questions on these and
other related subjects. See issue 30 of this Report,
September 14, 1992.
Bob Axelrad, director of EPA's indoor air division,
was consulted for this special issue and was quoted as
saying, ""The EPA does not have a mandate to regulate
indoor environments. Whether Congress will give us a
mandate to do more, we don't know. Regulation
would be tough: There's a gap between what people
report and what science is able to document.'"
USA Weekendwriters generally recommended
increasing ventilation and keeping home and office as
clean and dry as possible to limit exposure to indoor air
pollutants. On the issue of ETS exposure, USA Wrek
end claimed significant adverse health consequences to
children of parents who smoke and said the American
Lung Association advises parents who smoke to limit
smoking to rooms away from children. The artides also
gave specific recommendations regarding dry cleaning
fluids, office equipment fumes, furniture off-gassing,
household cltaners, asbestos, radon, and carpet fumes.
An additional article outlined the ways in which
newborns and young children allegedly can be affected
by the indoor environment and proposed ways in
which parents could reduce exposures, induding airing
out new clothes and bedding, purchasing used furnish-
ings, and not smoking. The incidence of SIDS (sudden
infant death syndrome) was related to synthetic
chemicals and decreased levels of ventilation during
winter months. Electromagnetic fields and food safery
were also discussed in this issue. See USA Wnkrnd,
January 3, 1993.
[20] "No Smoking Rules Forcing Employees to Cut
Back," S. Ross, The Rtuter Busiruss Rtport,
January 5, 1993
Employees interviewed for this article reported that
they have significantly cut back on their use of tobacco
products in response to workplace smoking restrictions
that have been imposed either by government regula-
7
tions or private-sector policy. In addition, some
smokers have cut back due to heightened peer pressure
at work. According to surveys conducted by various
antismoking organizations, some 500 municipalities
across the United States have smoking restrictions in
public places and one out of every three U.S. compa-
nies now limits or bans workplace smoking. Stiff fines
in some locations have apparently motivated smokers
to obey workplace smoking restrictions.
According to the antismoking group, Smokenders of
Phoenix, Arizona, complaints from nonsmokers are the
main reason for the increase in smoke-free working
environments, although the companies adopting such
policies are also reportedly concerned with health,
safety, cost and liability issues.
IN EUROPE &
AROUND THE WORLD
REGULATORY AND LEGISLATIVE
MATTERS
AUSTRALIA
In Queensland, the Woorabinda Aboriginal Council has
reportedly introduced a smokefree zone policy which bans
smoking from all offices and endosed areas in town. Su
Rockhampson Morning Bulletin, January 4, 1993:
CANADA
[21] Municipalities Near Toronto Consider Tough-
ening Smoking Restrictions
According to published press reports, municipalities
in the Toronto metro area are considering emulating
Toronto's tough new stance against smoking as
reflected in the antismoking measure that went into
effect in that city on January 1, 1993. See issue 38 of
this Report, January 7, 1993. Although smoking is
restricted or banned in some metro locations, local
health officials and antismoking activists arc reportedly
considering seeking the amendment of local ordinances
to either meet or exceed Toronto's restrictions. See The
Toronto Star, January 5, 1993.

8
[22] Smokers Gather Signatures to Repeal Ottawa's
Workplace Smoking Ban
Unhappy with the Ottawa workplace smoking bylaw
that went into effect on July 1, 1992, the Smokers'
Freedom Society has reportedly collected more than 7,000
signatures on a petition for repeal of the measure. The
bylaw requires that designated smoking areas be separately
v,entilated, and smokers' rights activists say that this means
smoking has been effectively banned in workplaces. The
city's licensing and enforcement branch has apparently
received some 70 requests for investigations of offices and
public places since the bylaw went into effect. See The
Ottawa CrtiZen, January 8, 1993.
In a related story, managers of bingo, billiard and
bowling establishments in Nepean are eoncerned'that a
similar bylaw which went into effect on January 1, 1993,
will hurt their business if it is enforced. Like Ottawa's
bylaw, Nepean's antismoking measure restricts smoking to
50 percent of the area in restaurants and shopping mall
food courts. Smoking is outlawed completely in the
common area of any mall, barber shop, laundromat,
restroom, elevator, escalator and stairway. Unlike
Ottawa's law, however, the city of Nepean applies the
50 percent restriction to bingo parlors, bowling alleys
and billiard halls. According to one bingo hali man-
ager, the 10 percent area that has been set aside for
nonsmokers has never been filled. See The Ottawa
Citizen, January 8, 1993.
CZECHOSLOVAKIA
According to published press reports, a proposal to
ban smoking in the Czech assembly building failed by
a narrow margin at the close of the 20th and final
session of the 200-seat Czech National Council in spite
of its support by Deputy Czech Premier Jan Kalvoda,
who reportedly referred to the bill as a real gem. See
BBCSummary of World Broadcasts, January 1, 1993.
HONG KONG
[23] Antismoking Lobbyists Call For Smoking Bans
Citing the U.S. EPA Risk Assessment on ETS, the
executive director of the Council on Smoking and Health
(COSH) has reportedly urged the government to institute
a smoking ban in banks, Kai Tak airport, MTR stations
and shopping centers. Apparently, a smoking ban already
ETS/IAQ REPORT, ISSUE 39
applies to public transport and certain public places, but
COSH would like it to be extended to commercial
building foyers and govemmenr departments frequently
visited by the public. COSH has also reiterated' iu call for
a ban on smoking in restaurants and urged the govern-
ment to list "passive smoking" on death certificates as a
cause of death.
According to published press reports, the Hongkong
Bank extended a five-branch pilot program and began
providing smoke-free queues in 30 of its branches on
January 11. 1993. Customer response will be studied
to see if the policy will be expanded to include all 241
of the bank's branches in the territory. See South China
Morning Post, January 8, 1993.
TuR1cEX
[24]' Official Calls for Smoking Bans
The president of the Turkish Green Crescent has
reportedly called for a law banning smoking in public
places. President Selahattin Kaptanagasi believes that
the number of smokers in Turkey, approximately 20
million, would double if nonsmokers exposed to ETS
were counted in their number. Apparently, Turkey
ranks fourth in the world in tobacco consumption, and
news reports associate 160,000 deaths per year to
smoking-related illnesses. See Xinhua General News
Service, January 7, 1993.
UNITED KINGDOM
[25] Health Minister Warns Antismoking Legislation
May be Introduced
Speaking at the opening of an ETS exhibition at the
London Science Museum on January 14, 1993, Health
Minister Dr. Brian Mawhinncy reportedly daimed that
legislation to control smoking in the workplace and public
transport would be introduced if voluntary targets on
nonsmoking in public places are not met. In its White
Paper, The Health of the Nation, the government
apparently stated that at least 80 percent of public places
should be covered by nonsmoking policies by 1994, and
the majoriry ofworkplaces by 1995. According to
Mawhinney, the Department of Health is studying the
EPA Risk Assessment on ETS and it "'may well affect the
way we take forward our future plans.'" See The Indrpcn-
dtni; January 15,1993.

JANUARY 22 1993
LEGAL ISSUES AND DEVELOPMENTS
[26]' International Airline Traveler Threatens Suit
Against United Airlines
Businessman Jonathan Bloch is reportedly consider-
ing bringing a class actionlawsuit against United
Airlines for illness allegedly caused by inadequate air
circulation. Apparently, Bloch contracted viral pneu-
monia two weeks after he returned to his home in
north London from a trip to Hawaii aboard United
Airlines. He claims he was hospitalized after being
bedridden for 10 days and that hospital doctors
suggested that the plane was the source of his infeaion,
According to a letter written by one of Bloch's
doctors, "It is likely that you picked up your infection
on the aircrafn . . . This is based on the frequent
observation that many patients who travel by air tend
to go down with respiratory tract infections within a few
days afterwards." The doctor added, however, that "it
would be virtually impossible to prove conclusively that
your particular mycoplasma was caught during the flight."
Bloch evidently daims that airlines are attempting to
save fuel by cutting back on the number of times they
recirculate air within the cabins. He is gathering evidence
that such practices cause illness. Experts on the subject
such as Farrol Kahn, who recently wrote the book Why
FlyingEndangrrs YourHr.akh, apparently believe that
cabin environment can increase the risk ofcontagious
diseases. See Sunday Tilegraph, January 10, 1993.
SCIENTIFIC/TECHNICAL ITEMS
CARDIOVASCUI:nR ISSUF.S
[27] "Serum Lipids & Lipoprotein Profiles of
Cigarette Smokers & Passive Smokers," J. Whig,
C.B. Singh, G.L Soni, and A.K Bansal, Indian
Journal ofMedical Researcb 96(B): 282-287,
1992 [See Appendix A)
This study, conducted in an Indian population, reports
nonsignificant elevations in cholesterol and triglycerides in
men reporting ETS exposure. The authors daim that the
high density lipoprotein cholesterol/low density lipopro-
tein ratio was lowered in "passive smokers," and further
9
daim that this suggests an increased risk ofcoronary heart
disease in exposed persons.
IZESPIRATORY DISEASES AND CONDITIONS
- CHILDREN
[28] "Factors Associated with Bronchial
Hyperresponsiveness in Australian Adults and
Children," J.K. Peat, C.M. Salome, A.J.
Woolcock, European RespiraroryJournal5: 921-
929, 1992 [See Appendix A]
In this Australian study, 4,366 children and 878
adults were studied for bronchial hyperresponsiveness,
a measure of airway abnormality associated with the
clinical diagnosis of asthma. While the authors report
that parental asthma, history of respiratory illness, and
being born in Australia were significantly associated
with bronchial hyperresponsiveness, parental smoking
was reportedly not associated.
[29] "Atopy and Environmental Factors in Upper
Respiratory Infectionx An Epidemiological Survey
on 2304 School Children," E Porro, P. Caiamita,
I. Rana, L Montini, and S. Criscione, lntmui
tionalJournal ofPediatric Otorhinoluryngology 24:
111-120, 1992 [SeeAppendix A]
This epidemiologic study is based on questionnaire
responses from the parents of Italian school children
concerning factors possibly related to upper respiratory
infections. The authors report that family history of
asthma or chronic bronchitis appear to be important
predisposing factors. They also claim that "passive
smoking" is related to ear troubles, such as otitis.
[30] "Circadian Rhythm of Peak Expiratory Flow in
Children Passively Exposed and Not Exposed to
Cigarette Smoke," R. Casale, G. Natali, D.
Colantonio, P. Pasqualetti, Thorax 47: 801-803,
1992 [See Appendix A]
This study measured circadian rhythm, i.e., an approxi-
matdy 24-hour rycle, in pulmonary function measure-
ments in Italian school children. The authors claim that
children exposed to cigarette smoke reportedly exhibited
changes in the circadian rhythm, which they interpret as
an early indication of airway obstruction.

10
OTHER HEALTH I'SSUES
[31] "Passive Smoking and Hearing Loss in Infants,"
R.A. Lyons, Irish Mcdical Journa185 (3): 111-
112, 1992 [See Appendix A]
This study reports on data collected on hearing loss
and the condition of the eardrum from infants sched-
uled to attend a developmental examination. Report-
edly, infants exposed to cigarette smoke were approxi-
mately five times more likely to have a hearing deficit.
The author condudes that his reported findings
support the position that ETS exposure causes middle
ear problems.
OTHER DEVELOPMENTS
AUSTRAI,IA
[32]' Solomon Airlines Imposes Smoking Ban
Solomon Airlines has reportedly announced that it will
ban smoking on all of its flights beginning February 1,
1993. SetS)rlnryMorningHeralW January 1,1993.
CANADA
[33] ETS Objectives Revealed as Part of National
Non-Smoking Week
As part of Canada's National Non-Smoking Week
held during the week of]anuary 18, 1993, the govern-
ment of Ontario reponedlyannounced that it has three
objectives related to tobacco, among which is the
protection of nonsmokers from ETS exposure. See
Canada NewsWire, January 8, 1993.
[34] Business Advises Smokers Not to Apply for
Employment
Safeway Electric Co. in Winnipeg, Manitoba, has
reportedly advised smokers that it will not hire them
even if they otherwise qualify for the job. According to
owner Michael Andruchuk, many of the company's
contracts involve nonsmoking locations and smokers
hired in the past have broken promises not to smoke
on the job. Civil rights groups have apparently criti-
cized the restriction, but there is no legislation prohib-
ETS/IIAQ REPORT, ISSUE 39
iting discrimination against smokers. Ser Xinhua
Gcneral News Service, January'4, 1993.
[35] Nonsmokers Publish Dining Guide
The AIRSPACE Non-smokers' Rights Society, a non-
profit, nonsmokers' advocacy group based in British
Columbia, is reportedly preparing a new edition of its
Breathers'Dining Guide for publication. The current
edition lists 235 eating establishments in British
Columbia that are smoke free. More names will be
added to the list, and, when published, the guide will
be available to the public free of charge. See The
Vancouver Sun, January 11, 1993.
[36] Woodstove Users Warned of Health Risks
Public health officials have reportedly become
concerned'about known and suspeaed'carcinogens in
wood smoke. Because smoke spillage into homes from
wood-burning units has been blamed for serious
indoor air pollution and related health problems,
different levels of government arc apparently looking
for ways to reduce wood smoke pollution levels
through legislation. See The (Montrtal)~Gazurtt,
January 3, 1993.

JAN UARY 22, 1993
APPENDIX A
The numbers assigned to the following article
summaries correspond with the numbers assigned to
the synopses of the articles in the text of this Report.
IN THE UNITED STATES
OTHER HEALTH ISSUES
[13] "Maternal Cigarette Smoking During Preg-
nancy: A Risk Factor for Childhood Stnbis-
mus," R.B. Hakim and J.M. Tielsch, Archives of
Ophtbalmology 110: 1459-1462, 1992
"Strabismus is a common disorder in children that
requires intensive therapy and costly surgery. Strabis-
mus is thought to be a defect in central nervous system
control."
"The etiology of nonrestrictive strabismus is not well
understood but is presumably related to factors affect-
ing the normal development of the oculomotor control
mechanism....[L]ittlc work has been done to exam-
ine epidemiologic risk factors for adverse pregnancy
outcomes and their association with risk of strabismus.
... Because of smoking's wide range of effeas, we
hypothesized that it could play a role in the develop-
ment of this abnormality. Herein, we present results
form a population-based study of maternal smoking
and risk of strabismus among their offspring."
"A population based case-control study was con-
ducted to investigate the association between child-
hood strabismus and prenatal risk factors including
maternal smoking. Ai1 incident cases of strabismus
diagnosed during a 21-month period, ... in nine
metropolitan area pediatric ophthalmology centers
were selected for study (n=377). Controls were chil-
dren born on the same day and in the same hospital as
the cases (n=377). Data collection included in inter-
view with the biologic mother and abstraction of
obstetric and neonatal birth records."
"Exposure to secondary smoke was associated with
esotropia ["crass-eye"] when the mother smoked during
pregnancy. Conversely, when the mother did not smoke
during pregnancy, there was no increased risk of esotropia
when she was exposed to her spouse smoking or to
significant amounts of smoke from other sources."
A-1
"Results from this studyd'emonstrate an association
between maternal smoking during pregnancy and
esotropia among offspring. While birth weight seemed
to modifythe effect of maternal smoking on risk of
esotropia, there was little evidence of an association
between exotropia ["wall.eye," where the eye looks
outward] and maternal smoking after stratification byy
birth weight."
"The finding that exposure to secondary smoke
elevates the already elevated risk associated with
maternal smoking suggests a synergistic effect between
maternal and secondary smoke exposure during
pregnancy. However, the lack of an elevated risk due to
secondary smoke when the mother is a nonsmoker
suggests a maternal barrier that may be protecting the
fetus. Also, this lack of an association between
esotropia and secondary smoke exposure among
nonsmoking mothers may indicate that postnatal
exposure to tobacco smoke is not a risk factor for
esotropia. These results agree in part with a previous
study that found the lowest birth weight among infants
whose parents both smoked."
"While a direct causal role for maternal smoking in
the etiology of strabismus cannot be proved based
solely on observational data, the consistency of the
findings, the strong biologic plausibility, and the
relation of smoking to other adverse pregnancy out-
comes and developmental impairments strengthen the
argument that this is a direct etiologic effect."
INDOOR AIR QUALITY
[14] "Engineering Controls for Clean Air in the
Office Environment," M.J. Ellenbecker, Clinics
in Cbest Medidne 13(2): 193-199, 1992
"Because the quality of the office environment is
strongly affected by the quality of the air in that
environment, the use of engineering controls to
provide clean air to buildings plays an important role
in determining people's health and comfort. The major
topics described in this article include the basic charac-
teristics of building engineering control systems in the
office environment and how these characteristics
contribute to occupant health and comfort."
"The primary engineering control for ensuring good
air quality is the building heating, ventilation, and air-

A-2
conditioning (HVAC) system. These systems are
designed primarily to provide an environment with
adequate comfort for building occupants. This involves
controlling the temperature and humidity within an
acceptable range and providing sufficient fresh outside
air to limit odors. Until recently, health concerns have
been less imponantn The energy crisis of the early
1970s, however, forced building managers to look
closely at the energy used by HVAC systems.$ecause
the primary expenditure is the energy required to condi-
tion the fresh outside air drawn in by such systems,
building managers decreased fresh air flows as much as
possible and complaints of poor air quality increased
dramatically. Many such complaints fall into the discom-
fort category, but a large number concern ill health such as
headaches, sore throats, or nasal congestion. The modern-
day HVAC system designer and the occupational health
specialist thus must concern themselves with developing
an environment that is both comfortable and healthy and
must provide such an environment at a reasonable cost."
"The usual first reaction of a building manager when
receiving a complaint of poor office air quality is to try
to find the culprit. He or she then spends what is
invariably a large amount of money trying to measure
something in the air that might cause the problem. It
has been the author's experience that money spent in
this way is usually wasted, because little or nothing is
learned from the measurements. It is usually better to
skip the identification phase and move directly to
assessing and improving the building ventilation
systems. The most effective step in improving office air
quality is almost always to increase the amount of fresh
air being supplied to work areas; consequently, this is
the first thing that building managers should try."
"The disadvantage of increasing fresh air supply, of
course, is cost. Each cubic foot of fresh air that is
brought into a building must be heated in the winter
and cooled in the summer. The indoor air quality
specialist is frequently put in the position of lobbying
for increased air flow, where the well-defined cost of
such an increase is balanced against the uncertain
likelihood that air qualiry complaints will decrease.
Frequently, such an adversarial situation can be
avoided by redistributing the fresh air already being
supplied to the building. The ventilation survey may
indicate that some parts of the building are receiving
too little fresh air, but other areas are receiving too
much. In these cases, air flow can be redistributed, with
ETS/IAQ REPORT, ISSUE 39
no increase in energy costs but with an overall im-
provement in air quality."
Besides increasing fresh air supply, the second fruitful
tactic for improving office air quality is to improve the
maintenance of the ventilation systems. As discussed
previously, poor maintenance frequently is the source
of air quality complaints, and in such cases improve-
ment in maintenance will bring an immediate decrease
in complaints of poor air quality."
IN EUROPE &
AROUND THE WORLD
CARDIOVASCUlAR ISSUES
[27] "Serum Lipids & Lipoprotein Profiles of
Cigarette Smokers & Passive Smokers," J. Whig,
C.B. Singh, G.L Soni, and A.K. Bansal, Indian
fournal of Medical Raearch 96(B): 282-287,
1992
"Very little attention has been paid to the effect of
passive smoking on serum lipids and lipoproteins. In
view of the fact that [a] large population in India is
exposed to passive smoking, the present study has been
undertaken to know the effea of passive smoking on
serum lipids and lipoproteins compared to that in
chronic smokers and control subjects."
"Serum lipids and lipoproteins of 50 active and
passive smokers were compared with levels in 25
control subjects. Active smoking resulted in an increase
in total cholesterol (T) and triglycerides (Ts) as
compared to control group. The passive smokers also
showed relatively higher levels but the effect was not
significant. Active smoking raised the low density
lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL) and very low density
lipoprotein cholesterol (VLDL) levels whereas high
density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL ) content was
lowered, thus resulting in decreased ratios of HDL' /T~
and HDL./LDL~ The passive smokers also showed
slightly higher levels of LDL and VLDL but lower
levels of HDL< and a lower HDL</LDL< ratio."
"Since the ratio of HLDJLDL! is also significantly
lower amongst passive smokers, it indicates that not

JANUARY 22, 1993
only active smokers but also subjects who are in
contact with active smokers are at a relatively higher
risk of developing atherosclerosis. The lower degree of
risk amongst passive smokers compared to that
amongst active smokers could be due to the filteration
[sic] ; of smoke in the lungs of the smokers. Some of the
components like nicotine and tar are deposited in the
lungs of active smokers and therefore the passive
smokers are exposed to a lower density of harmful
components....[TJhe levels of serum lipids and
lipoproteins were altered in passive smokers in such a
manner that it may have a deleterious effect on [the]
cardiovascular system."
"The passive smokers also show relatively less altered
lipid and lipoproteins, in a trend'similar to that of
smokers. The alteration in the individual value of lipids
and lipoproteins is not significant in [theJ case of
passive smokers but the results are significant only in
case of ratios of HDL~/Tc and HDLC/LDL.. As decrease
in this ratio is responsible for the development of
atherosclerosis, the results indicate that even the passive
smokers are at a relatively higher risk of developing
coronary heart disease "
RESPIRATORY DISFASES MND CONDITIONS
- CHILDREN
[28] "Factors Associated with Bronchial
Hyperresponsiveness in Australian Adults
and Children," J.K. Peat, C.M. Salome,
A.J. Woolcock, European Respiratory Journal
5: 921-929, 1992
"In the last decade, population studies of asthma have
focused on the measurement of bronchial
hyperresponsiveness (BHR), because it is the single,
objective measure of airway abnormality that is strongly
associated with a clinical diagnosis of asthma. Although
the measurement lacks sensitivity and, to a lesser extent,
specificity as a marker of asthma, it has proved to be a
useful indicator of the severity of current disease that is
independent of diagnostic patterns and symptom aware-
ness. Because there are both regional and racial differ-
ences in the prevalence of BHR, which relate to
differences in the prevalence of respiratory symptoms,
the study of BHR in populations is likely to provide
objective evidence for the aetiology of asthma and, as
such, has an important role."
A-3
"We have measured the distribution of BHR in four
population samples of children living in different
regions of Australia, and in one population sample of
adults.... In this paper, we report the relationship of
BHR to atopy, age and sex. In addition, we examine
the influence of early respiratory illness, race, country
of birth, dietary fish, parental smoking and a parental
history of asthma on the prevalence of BHR in chil-
dren, and the influence of smoking history on the
prevalence of BHR in adults."
"Atopy to common allergens and age are the most
important independent predictors of BHR. In adults,
smoking history and gender (being female) were also
important. In children, a parental history of asthma
and respiratory infection in the first 2 yrs of life had a
significant influence on BHR and, after taking these
factors into account, being born outside Australia and
regular fish meals both had a protective effect against
BHR. We did not find a significant effect of parental
smoking, race (Caucasian/Asian); gender or region
(coastal/inland)."
"It is thought that differences in the prevalence of
BHR between countries and races result from a
combination of genetic and environmental influences.
Our finding that children born in Australia had a
higher prevalence of BHR, adjusted for other factors
including race, than children born in other countries
raises some interesting questions.... Because race was
not a risk factor for BHR in these populations, there is
reduced possibility that genetic factors are predominant
and an increased possibility that BHR has a largely
environmental aetiology. Children born in Australia
may be exposed to an additional allergen load that is
most effeccive in causing BHR early in life, but this
hypothesis remains to be tested."
"The presence of BHR is obviously influenced by a
variety of genetic, physiological and environmental risk
factors of which atopy remains the most important
known factor in both adults and children. This, taken
with the evidence of a higher prevalence of BHR in
children born in Australia and a lower prevalence in
children on a 'protective' dict, suggests that environ-
mental influences are very important. It is vital that
future epidemiological studies collect information on
both BHR and asthma from populations living in~
regions with markedly different environments, for

A-4
which the risk factors can be measured accurately.
Such investigations are likely to provide invaluable
insights into the aetiology and prevention of asthma."
[29] "Atopy and Environmental Factors in Upper
Respiratory Infections: An Epidemiological
Survey on 2304 School Children," E. Porro, P.
Calamita, 1. Rana, L. Montini, and S. Criscione,
International Journal of Pediatric
Otorhinolaryngology 24: 111-120, 1992
"Upper respiratory infections (URI) during the first
years of life are mostly viral in origin. However, a
number of observations suggest the influence of both
predisposing and triggering factors. Atopy in particular
seems to play an important role as do environmental
factors. Many children with early symptoms such as
blocked or runny nose are likely to become skin-
positive later in life to antigens.... A standardized
questionnaire was administered to 2304 schoolchildren
in order to ascertain the URI frequency and to corre-
late it with family and environmental factors and with
results of prick tests for main allergens in our climate.
Results showed a wide overlapping of URI and lower
respiratory illnesses (in particular, asthma), which are
widely distributed in the families of patients. Passive
smoking and the quality of housing are the main
triggering environmental factors.°
"Amongst the predisposing faaors in URI, family
history of asthma and chronic bronchitis appear to be
relevant: the definition of these ... parameters in our
study (occurrence of one or more affected relatives)
does not permit the evaluation of the relative role of
'genetic' and 'environmental' factors (the latter refer-
ring to common negative family environment)."
"Passive smoking is often cited as a contributory
factor in respiratory troubles but according to the
present investigation it does not appear to exert a
major influence in nose troubles, emerging only in the
case of ear troubles. In our opinion the role of passive
smoking should not be underestimated as a triggering
factor of URI. A correlation between nasal and'ear
infection is well known and both are affected by the
same factors. It is therefore probable that only the
most severe and relapsing cases of nasal infection lead
to recurrent otitis, while passive smoking may be a
prominent factor in the severity of these cases."
ETS/IAQREPORT, ISSUE 39
[30] "Circadian Rhythm of Peak Expiratory Flow in
Children Passively Exposed and Not Exposed to
Cigarene Smoke," R. Casa]e, G. Natali, D.
Colantonio, P. Pasqualetti, Thorax47: 801-803,
1992
"This study aimed to investigate whether children
exposed to passive smoking, assessed by questionnaire
and urinary cotinine values, show greater variation in
the circadian rhythm of the peak expiratory flow (PEF)
than children not exposed to cigarette smoke."
"Questionnaires completed' by 60 primary schoolchil-
dren aged 10-11 years were analyzed and 20 children
(12 boys and 8 girls) exposed to passive smoking were
identified. These children were matched for sex and age
with 20 respondents who had not been exposed to
cigarette smoke."
"The mean value of urinary cotinine concentration was
1.85 umolll in unexposed children and 3.44 (0:52)
umol/l in exposed subjects."
"Both groups showed diurnal fluctuations in PEF
values with a peak in the afternoon. PEF showed a
significant circadian rhythm for both the unexposed and
the exposed children."
"The circadian rhythm of PEF in the exposed children
differed from that of unexposed children ... Since any
change in the normal circadian ~ pattern of any variable
can seen [sic] as abnormal and as a step towards clini-
cally symptomatic disease, the increased PEF rhythm
amplitude may be a measure of early airway obstruction
in response to passive smoking."
OTHER HEALTH IssuEs
[31] "Passive Smoking and Hearing Loss in Infants,"
R.A. Lyons, Irirh Medical Journa185(3): 111-112,
1992
"The aim of this study was to determine whether passive
exposure to smoke is also associated with hearing deficits in
infants, the majority of which are due to obstruction of the
eustachian tube with consequent middle earlydysfunaion."
"A cohort of infants due to attend their first scheduled
developmental examination in a socially deprived area
where [sic] chosen as the study group. As part of the
examination hearing was assessed ... and the tympanic
membranes inspected,"

)ANUA,RY22,1993
"73% of mothers were current smokers and smoked
on average 17.8 cigarettes per day. Overall 77% of
infants were exposed to cigarette smoke."
"Infants who were exposed to cigarette smoke were
nearly five times more likely to have a hearing deficit
and were three times as likely to have visible abnor-
malities of the tympana.°
"This is the first study to report an association
between passive exposure to cigarette smoke and
hearing loss in infants."
"The prevalence of hearing deficit in the non exposed
group was 10% compared to 49% in the exposedd
group. If the association reported here is causal then
75°l0 of hearing deficits in this cohort could be attrib-
uted to exposure to cigarette smoke. The results of this
study support the hypothesis that passive exposure to
cigarette smoke is a cause of middle ear effusion and
hearing loss in children."

.
VSDL: 93-16
CONTACT: Carol Kccain FOR REL?.ASE: IlQiEDIATE
OFFICE s 202/219-5a23 THLJRSDAY, JANUARY 14 , 1993
CONTACT: Douglas Fuller
OFFICE : 202/219-6027
Department
Of Labor
United States
Office of Information Washington, D.C. 20210
STATEMENT DY sECi1LTARY OF LksOjt LYNN ]RARTIN
As part of our commitment to improve vorkplaee health and
safety, today I am directing OSHk as soon as possible consistent
with applicable statutory requirements and executive orders, to
commence rulemaking that addresses the hazards of occupational
exposure to secondhand smoke.
This is an issue that requires our immsdiate attention.
There is a growing body of evidence that exposure to secondhand
tobacco smoke is hazardous to the health of nonsmokers. The
EPA's report on the effects of passive smoke in the home
environment is a major contribution to this evidence.
OSHA's Office of Health Standards is currently completing
its analysis of.the responses to our recent request for
information about issues related to indoor air quality. A qreat
deal of the information received in response to that request
relates specifically to the hazards of exposure to environmental
tobacco smoks in the workplace. OSHA will continue to evaluate
this information and the EPA report, and incorporate the material
into its consideration of this issue.
Tb. action we are taking today is apart from the indoor air
quality rulemakinq. The EPA report focuses an the home
environment. It raises troubling concerns about the effects of
passive smoke. OSAA must examine these concerns and determine
how thsy apply to the workplace.
So I have asked OSHA to proceed expeditiously and
comprehensively. J1s a first step to implement my directive, OSHA
will prepare a report for the incoming secretary. This report
will discuss the extent of the hazard, describe the rulemakinq
alternatives available to the Departm:nt and provide a basis for
determining the most effective rulemakinq eourse.
-more-
ISSUE 39
APPENDIX B

specifically, the report will include an analysis of the
evidence in terms of the threshold OSHA must mset in order to
regulate. It will also discuss any special pertinent issues,
such as means of applying evidence obtained from studies of
exposure to tobacco smoke in the home to workplace settings.
Our actions should be dictated by scientific evidence, and
not by emotions or special interests. This approach allows OSHA
to best understand how to move ahead.with a proposed rule.
II
Th n ormation wi be mavai a e to sensory ~mpa r3 e~-
individuals upon request. Voice Phone: 202-219-6060, TDD Message
Rsfsrral Phone: 1-800-326-2577.
The text of th s re ease is ava a e at no cost to cal er from
the Department of Labor electronic bulletin board, LABOR NEWS, at
1-800-597-1221 or locally at 202-219-4784. 300, 1200 or 2400
HATJD; Parity: None; Data Bits - 8; Stop Bit - 1. Voice phone:
202-219-7343.

I
U.S. DEPARTMEN7 OF LABOR
iiGRt'iARY OF LA/QR
WAiHMQtnN. D.G.
JAN 13 193
NEMOwwMM FOR DoAOTM STRONx
lROM: LYHN MARTINZ,--0`
SUB.TECT: Enviromental tobacco smoke in the workplace
I appreciate our recent discussions on the growing body of
evidence that exposure to secondhand tobacco saoke is hazardous
to the health of nonsmokers. I understand that OSHA's Office of
Health standards is currently completing its analysis of the
responses to our recent Request for Information about issues
related to indoor air quality, and that a great deal of the
information received in response to that request relates
specifically to ths hazards of exposure to environmental tobacco
smoks in the workplace. As you know, the Environs.ntal
Protsction Agency has sent the Departm.nt_its recent rs.port.
dno
othi= pis4rders. I would like OSHA to study that report and
incorporate the msterial in it into its consideration of this
issue.
By this mamorandum, I am also directing OSHA, as soon as possible
consistent vith applicable statutory requirements and executive
orders, to commence rulemaking to address the hazards of
occupational exposure to secondhand ssoke. As a first step to
implement this directive, OSHA should prepare a report for the
incoming Secretary. This report should discuss the extent of the
hazard, describe the rulemakinq alternatives available to the
Department, and provide a basis !or determining the most
effective rulemaking course. Specifically, it should include an
analysis of the evidence in terms of the threshold OSI;A must meet
in order to regulate, and discuss any special issues that are
pertinent, such as means of applying evidence obtained from
studies of exposure to tobacco smoke in the home to vorkplace
settings.
I believe that resolution of this issue is one of the most
significant matters facing OSHA, and I ask you to direct your
staff to treat this project as one of the Department's highest
priorities.
-A...

Facts About Secondhand Smoke
Some of the key facts about secondhand tobacco smoke and its dangers are
summarized below. Use them to Inform yout family and friends and to work for
smoke free policies in your community. '
General .
,
Secondhand smoke is a cause of disease, Including lung canoeir, in healthy nonsmokers.
Each year secondhand smoke kills an estimated 3,000 adult nonsmokers from lung '
cancer.
Secondhand smoke causes,30 times as many lung cancer deaths as all regulated air
pollutants oombined.
Secondhand smoke causes other respiratory problems In nonsmokers: coughing,
phlegm, chest discomfort, and reduced lung function.
For many people, secondhand smoke causes reddening, itching, and watering of the
eyes. About eight out of 10 nonsmokers report they are annoyed by others' cigarette
smoke.
More than 4,000 chemical compoeutds have been identified in tobacco smoke. Of these,
at least 43 are lanown to cause caneer in humans or animals.
At high exposure levels, nicotine is a potent and potentially lethal poison. Secondhand
smoke is the only source of nicotine in the air.
Nonsmokers exposed to cigarette smoke have in their body fluids significant amounts
of nicotine, carbon monoxide, and other evidence of secondhand smoke.
Three out of four nonsmokers have lived with smokers, and nearly half (45 percent) are ,
worried that secondhand smoke might cause them serious health problems.
More than 90 percent of Americans favor restricting or banning smoking in public
places. '
ISSUE 39
APPENDIX C
US. DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH & HUMAN SERVICES (DC
Pubtic H.akh S.wic.

Forty-six states and the District of Columbia in some manner restrict smoking in public
places. These laws range from limited prohibitions, such as no smoking on school
buses, to comprehensive clean indoor air laws that limit or ban smoking in virtually all
public places.
0
Laws restricting smoking in public places have been implemented with few problems
and at little cost to stwre and local government.
Smoking policies may have multiple benefits. Besides reducing exposure to
secondhand smoke, such policies may alter smoking behavior and public attitudes
about tobacco use. Over time, these changes may contribute to a significant reduction
in U.S. smoking rates.
Children
Each year, exposure to secondhand smoke causes 150,000 to 300,000 lower respiratory
tract infections (such as pneumonia and bronchitis) in U.S. infants and children
younger than 18 months of age. These infections result in 7,500 to 15,000
hospitalizations yearly.
Chronic cough, wheezing, and phlegm are more frequent in children whose parents
smoke.
Children exposed to secondhand smoke at home are more likely to have middle-ear
disease and reduced lung function.
Secondhand smoke increases the number of asthma attacks and the severity of asthma
in about 20% of this country's 2 million to 5'million asthmatic children.
Each year, U.S. mothers who smoke at least 10 cigarettes a day can actually cause
between 8,000 and 26,000 new cases of asthma among their children. . -
A recent study found that infants are three times more likely to die from Sudden Infant
Death Syndrome (SIDS) if their mothers smoke during and after pregnancy. Infants are
twice as likely to die from SIDS if their mothers stop during pregnancy and then
resume following birth.

Workplace
Workers exposed to secondhand smoke on the job are 34% more likely to get lung
cancer.
The simple separation of smokers from nonsmokers within the same airspace may
reduce, but cannot eliminate, the exposure of nonsmokers to secondhand smoke.
There is no safe level of exposure to a cancer-causing substance.
Survey responses indicate that at least 4.5 million American workers experience great
discomfort from exposure to secondhand smoke.
The best method for controlling worker exposure. to secondhand smoke is to eliminate
tobacco use from the workplace and implement a smoking oesaation program to
support smokers who decide to quit.
About 85% of businesses had adopted some form of smoking policies in 199I, up from
36% in 1986.
US. DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH & HUMAN SERVICES CIK
Pubtic H.a1th Selvia ".o" :OM

Secondhand Smoke in Your Home
We spend n1oQ+e time 3n our homes than anywhere else. So the thought of cancer-
causing chemicals circulating throughout our houses and apartments can be quite
unse.ttling. Yet, aooqrding to the Environmental Protection Agency, that is exactly what
happens when someone lights a cigarette in your home. '
Those most affected by secondhand smoke are children. Because their bodies are
still developing, exposure to the poisons In secondhand smoke puts children in danger
of severe respiratory diseases and can hinder the growth of their lungs. On top of that,
the effects can last a lifetime.
Ventilation systems In homes cannot filter and circvlate air well enough to eliminate
secondhand smoke. Blowing smoke away from children, going into another room to
smoke, or opening a window may help reduce dlildren's exposure but will not protect
them ffrom the dangers of secondhand smoke.
Benefits of a Smoke Free Home
The greatest benefit, of course, is that you will remove all the health risks associated
with secondhand tobacco smoke. Plus:
* When your home Is smoke-free it will smell much better. ,
* Your food will taste better.
* You'll spend less time, energy, and money cleaning your curtains, walls,
windows, and mirrors.
* Your insurance rates may be lower - check with your insuranee company.
Even your pets will behappier. For example, secondhand smoke increases
the risk of lung canoer in dogs.
,
vs. DEPARTMENT OF HMJH & HUMAN sERVICEs
Public H.akn s«wo.
CDC
.~..~.~.~.~
. smfftlvx~

How to Make (and Keep) Your Home Smoke-Free
It may feel awkward at first to tell people not to smoke in your home - no one wants
to make their guests uncomfortable - but if you simply explain the facts about
secondhand smoke, they should understand completely. Tell them that for the sake of
your family's health, you simply cannot allow smoking in your home. Have gum or
mints available as an alternative to lighting up. If visitors absolutely must smoke, tell
them they can do so outside.
If someone In your household smokes, be sympathetic and understanding =but
encourage them to quit. Let them know that cigarette smoke affects everyone, not just
them. Let them know you care and you want to help. Again, if they absolutely must
smoke, tell them they can do so outside. .
Don't Forget Schools and Day Care
Make sure your child's school and day care programs are smoke-free. And insist
that babysitters not smoke around your children.
. flc
~
. m
~
- ,~
N
~ ca

Secondhand Smoke in the Workplace
The Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970'promises job safety and health
protection for workers by providing safe and healthful working conditions. The
Environmental Protection Agency now states that exposure to secondhand smoke
greatly increases the chances of developing lung cancer and other serious respiratory
problems.
In general, ventilation or filtration of air in the workplace to remove secondhand
smoke is futile.It's like trying to filter a lake to control water pollution. The only
viable approach to protect nonsmokers Is source control: making the entire building
smoke free or restricting smoking to a separately ventilated area that nonsmokers never
have to enter. Your health should never be placed in jeopardy for the convenience of
smoking employees. The right to breathe safely is more important than the right to
smoke.
Benefits of a Smoke-Free Workplace
The greatest benefit is, of course, the removal of all the health risks associated with
secondhand tobacco smoke. You'll also experience the immediate benefit of a better-
smelling workplace.
The business Itself will realize several benefits from a smoke-free policy:
* The company protects itself from possible lawsuits from nonsmoking
employees affected by secondhand smoke.
* Every smoker costs his or her company at least $1,000 a year because of
decreased productivity and increased health care costs. Much of this money
may be saved If a smoke-free policy is instated. And management will no
longer have to waste its time and energy on the smoking issue.
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH & HUMAN SERVICES
Public H.aKh S.nia
CDC
.oportsuram

* The company's life, health, and fire insurance premiums may be lower if
smoking is not allowed on the premises.
* The company will realize other cost savings because computer equipment,
furniture, carpets, and other furnishings last longer and need less
maintenance in a smoke-free environment. .
* Most companies document an improvement in employee morale after
establishing a nonsmoking policy. A recent survey found that only 5% of
Americans oppose any smoking resti3ctions in the workplace.
* A well planned smoking policy sends the message that the coalpany Is
concerned about the health and well being of its employees.
* Most smokers want to quit, and workplace restrictions can provide another
reason to stop.
How to Get Your Workplace to Be Smoke-Free .
Speak with, or write a memo to the person in charge of making company policies.
Be sure to indude the facts about the health hazards of secondhand smoke. Position
yourself as someone who is not bringing a complaint or a problem, but a solution.
Then help provide the right solution for your work environment.
If you have co-workers who smoke, be sympathetic and understanding and support
their efforts to quit Let them know that tobacco smoke affects everyone, not just them.
Work with them to design a smoke-free plan that everyone can live with.
Also be sure your company's benefits administrator looks into insurance plans that
offer premium breaks for smoke-free workplaces.
Many national and local health organizations provide expert help in establishing
smoke-free workplace policies. Consult the resource list in this guide or call the Office
on Smoking and kiealtty CDC, for a copy (1-800-CDG1311).

Secondhand Smoke in Restaurants
When eating out, you want to be comfortable and enjoy your food. You certainly
don't want your dining spoiled by toxic chemicals floating around in the air. Yet,
according to the Environmental Protection Agency, that's exactly what happens when
someone lights a cigarette.
Restaurants that allow smoking can have six times the pollution of a busy highway.
Secondhand smoke has many of the same poisons as the air around tomc waste dumps.
Don't be fooled. Restaurants that have separate smoking and nonsmoking sections
cann,ot eliminate your exposure to the tmdns from secondhand smoke. Ventilation
systems are designed to efficiently circulate air within an enclosed environment, not to
filter and clean it. Trying to have a smoke-free section of a restaurant is like trying to
have a chlorine-free section of a swimming pool.
Benefits of a Smoke-Free Restaurant
The greatest benefit, of course, is the removal of all the health risks associated with.
secondhand tobacco smoke. Plus:
* Clean air makes the food smell and taste better.
* Your clothes and hair won't smell like stale smoke after you've left the
restaurant. '
* You71 be more likely to return to that restaurant because it is smoke free.
Surveys show that 80 to 90% of nonsmokers ask to be seated in the
nonsmoking section of restaurants when one is available.
How to Approach Restaurants to Become Smoke-Free
Talk to or write a letter to the owners or managers of your favorite restaurants.
Explain the facts about secondhand smoke. Tell them that it doesn't make much sense
for a restaurant to go to great lengths to protect its food from contamination, yet still
allow smoking. For example, why would a manager prohibit cooks from smoking in
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH & HUMAN SERVICES ~L`r .Pubfic H.aQh S.rvios °" ~ . 'p1"°

the cooking area, yet allow people to smoke in the dining room? Encourage your
friends to take this action with their favorite restaurants. The more that people are
aware of the dangers of secondhand smoke, the more successful we'll all be at
eliminating our exposure to it.
If any restaurants in your community have not even established separate
nonsmoking sections, ask them to do so - as a good first step. In restaurants that have
such divisions, always ask to be seated as far as possible from where people are
smoking. That is especially important if there are children with you.
Be Aware of Tobacco Industry Arguments
Tobacco companies, often acting behind restaurant association "front" groups, try to
convince restaurants that they will lose business if they prohibit smoking. There is no
evidence from any city that has passed a 100% smoke-free restaurant ordinance that
such measures hurt business. Some restaurants even report an improvement in
business, thanks to attracting more nonsmoking customers who want to avoid smoky
restaurants. It helps to remember that three fourths of adult Americans do not smoke.

Secondhand Smoke and the Local Media
The Environmental Protection Agency's dassi5cation of secondhand smoke as a
"Group A" carcinogen (known to cause cancer in humans) is newsworthy enough to
bring to the attention of the media. There are several ways of voicing your conoerns
and being heard. Call in to radio talk shows. Write letters to the editors of your local
newspapers. You may even want to contact your local TV stations.
Benefits of Getting the Media Involved
The more that people pre aware of the dangers of secondhand smoke, the better
chance we all have of reducing our exposure to it. And the more we reduce that
exposure, the healthier well be.
The facts about secondhand smoke speak for themselves. If you get the media on
your side to publicize these facts, we'll all be better off.
How to Involve the Media '
Radio Talk Shows. Call and ask to speak with the station's producer. He or she
will first want to hear an overview of the subject matter. If you cart, fax the information
so the station can have it on hand. If the station can tie in a local "angle" (related
happenings, 'events, or human interest accounts in the community), the chances of
getting air time are much better. Suggest a local expert who would be available to
discuss issues relating to secondhand smoke, such as a local pediatrician, family doctor,
cancer specialist, or respiratory therapist If you know what program you or the expert
would like to be on, suggest it to the producer. If you don't know, the producer should
be able to identify which program would be most appropriate.
Contact your local hospital, cancer society, lung associatim or other health groups.
They can help you line up experts and give you other help you need in working with '
the station.
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH & HUMAN SERVICES
PubGc H"M Swvioa
CDC

Letters to the Editor. The key here is to write an original letter expressing your
concerns. Personalizing your letter is more effective than sending in someone else's
form letter from a mass letter-writing campaign - newspapers are more interested in
your own thoughts. Highlighting facts and experiences from your community will
increase the chances of your letter being printed.
Newspaper Articles. Also talk with the editors of your local newspaper and try to
persuade them to write editorials In support of nonsmoking polides. Team up with a
local health organization to interest the newspaper's health br community affairs
reporter In writing a news orfeature article about secondhand smoke and what your
community is doing about it.
Television. Television is a little more difficult to work with, since broadcast time is
starm and expensive. The.best way to get started is by writing the community affairs
director. State the facts about secondhand smoke and explain why it's important for
the station to address this Issue. Most stations cover public issues on Saturday or
Sunday mornings, so a local angle increases your chances of getting a response.
Also consider working with a local health organization to explore developing a talk
show for the community access station of your local cable TV system.

Tips for Effective Letters
A brief, to-the-point letter is a good way to raise the issue of secondhand smoke
with an employer, restaurant owner, day care director, and others. An effective letter
",should follow an outline like the one below:
1. State your purpose: Your goal is to have a nonsmoking policy instituted. State
recent facts from the Environmental Protection Agency and other Information found in
this guide. Secondhand smoke is now officially a"Group A" carcinogen (known to
cause cancer in humans).
2. Explain why secondhand smoke Is an Important problem: State reasons why
you and everyone in your community should be guarded against the effects of
secondhand smoke. Mention the special vulnerabilities of children and the permanent
effect It can have on their lung development. ,
3. Support your opinion with facts: Tailor your facts to the particular area in
which you want to see a smoking policy instituted. Remember that the facts are on
your side - they are your ammunition.
4. Be clear about what action you are looking for. Be sure to state clearly what
action you would like to see, such as a total ban or the designation of a restricted
smoking area. ,
5. Explain how you intend to help the cause: You need to be willing to back up
your opinion with specific,actions that will help initiate this policy. Ask what else you
can do to help change things. :
Some additional tips: '
4 Be firm and get your point aanss - but at the same time note that you
understand and sympathize with smokers, who must fight a powerful
addiction. Emphasize the Importance of a smoking policy for the health of
nonsmokers as well as smokers who are lpolcing for a reason to quit.
Follow up your letter with a phone call.
U.8. DEPARTNAENT OF HEALTH & HUMAN SERVICES ' CI)C
Pub4c H.afth S.rvb. '01O` . '°"°

Organizations With More Information
Lsted below are selected organizstions that provide Information about the effects of secondhand
smoke, assistana in establishing smakefree polides, and advice on dcpping smoking.
Office on Smoking and Health ,
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
msilstop K 50
4770 Buford Highway, N.E. ~
Atlanta, GA 30341-3724
1-B004=-1311 (copies of actian guide on secondhand smoke)
(404) 488-5705 (other informatim)
bormation a6out smokingand HaaItli induding pamphds, pasterr, and wkW#c r+epivrts.
Action on Smoking and Health
2013 H Sheet, N.W.
Washingtoq, DC 20006
(2A2) 659-4310
In/ormatiori aboat avaridy of smoking and hmlth issues, with afocus on noassmoking Iams and paTiaes.
American Cancer Sodety 1599 Clifton Road, N.B.
Atlanta, GA 30329
1-800-ACS-2345
-Information and aduaativn programs on toGoxo and secnndhand amokc iaidiaiduaI and graup
atop-smoting
yrograrns
.
American Heart Association
National Center
TtTS Greenville Avenue
Da11as, TX 75231
(Z14) 373-6300
Or contact your local Heart Association in the white pages of the phone book.
-Smoking information and eduaationp^W=for sdwoLs, uiorkplam and haalth care faalities.
Aaxrlcan Lung Association
1740 Br+aadway
New York, NY 10019-4274
(212) 315-5700
Or contact your 1oed1 Iung Association In the white pages of the phone booh. ,
h*rnwtion and pnogmma an smoking pnarntivn, assatian, and tlie piotectioa of aaismoJren'tiglrts.
AatierZcaac for Nonsawkeas' Bigbts
Snite J .
2530 San Pablo Avenue
Berkekq, CA 9l702
(510) 841-3m
Jnfornadioa to help argrosimtions and iadiaiduals pm eTm iadoor air ordinm&oe4 impiemart roorlcpiaae
reguTat+ons, and deaelap aunrkPiaae snioking policies.
US. DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH & HUMAN SERVICES CE)C
PubGc Fi.aRh Servio. :OO.WW"M

Ettv~rona~eatil Protection Apncy .
Indoor Air Quality Information Caeuinghouse
P.O. Baa 37133
washingtot,, DC 20013-7133
1-800438-4318 '
-!fWrrustion abnut saaottdhmid smake and irrdoa ait' pollutiat.
Group Agaiod Smokas Pollution (GASP) ,
P.O. Box 632 .
I
Colkse Park MD 20740
(301) 4.59-'l791
Information and programs aboat sewndhand smoke mrd ehc estableshmait and aifcroanrnt of riaumoking
faws
andpoli6es.
March of Dimes Bi:th Defects POundatlon
1275 Mamaroneck Avenue
White Plains, NY 10605
(914) 428-7100
bftrnrrtiori a6ad PnoTdng md fiaalth autuding the effects of awkmg durmg pe8nwtq
National Cancer Institute
Bnilding 31, Room 10A24
9000 RodcvIlk Pilae
Bethesda,l4ID ?A892
1-8004-CANCER
-hormatkn aboad snwhng and hoatft sfap-ar~g tdephone coroisekag. ~
National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute
Information Center
PO Box 30105
Bethesda, MD Z0824-0105
(301) 951-M60
bftmation abard smohn& haart draw m,d lumg disew
NatOnal Institutc for Oocupationat Safety and Health
4676 Columbia Parkway
Cindnnati, OH 4S22&1998 ~
1-800-3*-NIOSH
Infartaation ort tecandhand smwb and offia waqdmnal aaft and /u+alth praWcncs. '
.
State and Local Health Departmeart.
Check the government section ot the phone book for current munbesa and addtesxs.
Infan,ation on :,nokri,g and Imattli m,d eziating onabing regulations.

ETS/IAQ REPORT
FAx COMMUNICATION SHEET
NOTE- If you would like additional information on one of the stories contained in this issue, or if
you have
information or ideas that we could incorporate into future issues, please complete and FAX this
form.
To: Mark W. Cowing, Esq. From.
Shook, Hardy & Bacon P.C. Company/Title
FAX 816-421-5547 Telephone:
Date:
I would like additional information that may be available on the anides in Issue numbered as follows
[indicate the bracketed number next to the artide headline]:
~ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ]
Name FAX #
Address Overnight Delivery
Regular Mail
(rfpr~Ierrwcr er,wr haliam44 rwfornmkoR w: