Lorillard
Testimony Special Committee on Aging U.S. Senate by Robert N. Butler, M.D. Brookdale Professor and Chairman Department of Geriatrics and Adult Development Mount Sinai School of Medicine
Fields
- Author
- Butler, R.N.
- Area
- SPEARS,ALEXANDER/OFFICE
- Alias
- 87679902/87679917
- Type
- DEPO, DEPOSITION/TRIAL TRANSCRIPT
- Site
- G65
- Recipient (Organization)
- Special Comm on Aging
- US Senate
- Named Person
- Belanger, A.
- Burns, G.
- Butler, R.N.
- Carter, J.E.
- Clinton, W.J.
- Rogers, A.
- Rogers, R.
- Shalala, D.
- Surgeon General
- Burns, G.
- Date Loaded
- 12 Feb 1999
- Document File
- 87679789/87680362/Missing
- Named Organization
- Alliance for Aging Research
- Carter Administration
- Centers for Disease Control + Prevention
- Health Care Financing Administration
- Milbank Quarterly
- Mount Sinai School of Medicine
- Nas, Natl Academy of Sciences
- Natl Inst of Aging
- Natl Inst of Heart Lung + Blood Diseases
- Natl Inst on Alcohol Abuse + Alcoholism
- Natl Inst on Drug Abuse
- NIH, Natl Inst of Health
- Nutrition Screening Initiative
- Special Comm on Aging
- US Public Health Service
- US Senate
- Alcoholics Anonymous
- Carter Administration
- Litigation
- Stmn/Produced
- Author (Organization)
- Mount Sinai School of Medicine
- Master ID
- 87679895/0021
Related Documents:- 87679895-9896
- 87679897 Witness List for A Hearing on Preventive Health: An Ounce of Prevention Saves A Pound of Cure Before the U.S. Senate Special Committee on Aging the Honorable David Pryor, Chairman
- 87679898-9899 Preventive Health: An Ounce of Prevention Saves A Pound of Cure Senate Special Committee on Aging Opening Statement of Senator David Pryor, Chairman 930506
- 87679900-9901 Opening Statement Senator William S. Cohen 'an Ounce of Prevention Saves A Pound of Cure' 930506
- 87679918-9921 for Testimony Before the Special Committee on Aging: the United States Senate 920513 Preventive and Older People
- 87679922-9932 Statement of the American Association of Retired Persons on Preventive Health Care
- 87679933-9941 Testimony of Dileep G. Bal, M.D. On Behalf of the Coalition on Smoking or Health to the Special Committee on Aging U.S. Senate on Preventive Health Care 930506
- 87679942-9951 Testimony Michael F. Jacobson, Ph.D. Executive Director, Center for Science in the Public Interest Washington, D.C. 930506 Senate Special Committee on Aging Hearing on Preventive Health
- 87679952-9953 Prevention's the Issue Your Money or Your Life Style
- 87679954-9957
- 87679958 Leading Contributors to Premature Death
- 87679959 Leading Causes of Death
- 87679960 Costs: Leading Causes of Death
- 87679961 Proposal for An Annual Surgeon General's Report on Diet and Health
- 87679962-9963 the Coalition for Nutrition Services in Health Care Reform - Position Statement
- 87679964 Stop Coddling the Booze Industry Tax Reform: Clinton Should Raise Rates and Cut Subsidies to Wineries and Distillers
- 87679965 Estimated Number of Deaths Attributable to Alcohol Consumption: United States 860000, 870000, 880000
- 87679966-9967 Alcohol Advertising Facts
- 87679968-9969 National Alcohol Tax Coalition Organizations Endorsing Increases in Alcohol Excise Taxes
- 87679970 Healthy Indulgences Breakfast
- 87679971-9972 Federal Alcohol Tax Facts
- 87679973-0013 Statement of Roger Herdman, M.D. Acting Director Office of Technology Assessment and Maria Hewitt, Dr.P.H. Senior Analyst, Health Program Office of Technology Assessment and Mary Laschober, M.S. Analyst, Health Program Office of Technology Assessment on Smoking - Related Deaths and Financial Costs: Office of Technology Assessment Estimates for 900000 Before the Senate Special Committee on Aging Hearing on Preventive Health: An Ounce of Prevention Saves A Pound of Cure
- 87680014-0016 Statement to the Special Committee on Aging United States Senate Re: Health Effects of Tobacco and Alcohol Upon Senior Citizens
- 87680017-0019 Statement to the Special Committee on Aging United States Senate Re: Health Effects of Tobacco and Alcohol Upon Senior Citizens
- 87680020 Statement by the Coalition on Smoking or Health, on New Estimates by the Office of Technology Assessment on the Costs of Tobacco Use
- 87680021
- UCSF Legacy ID
- cbd40e00
Document Images
persons over 65 report doing any regular exercise including
walking. Older people need to maintain flexibility, strength,
coordination, balance and aerobic conditioning or else they do
develop what George Burns calls "the old person's act".
6) Adult day care centers and senior centers should be mobilized
to build health promotion and disease prevention activities.
These can provide opportunities for socialization; hot meals
with assured nutrition; information about health habits and
relief of family burdens which means principally respite for
women who care for older family members.
7) Medicare reforms. There should be important legislative steps
to build upon Medicare's preventive package to create a
stronger preventive geriatrics. This should certainly include
increased payment or reimbursement for primary care under the
resource-based relative value schedule, to cover time for
specific counseling about prevention. So far Medicare covers
pneumonia and flu vaccines, the PAP test for cervical cancer,
and mammograms. There should be Medicare support for
screening for cancer as well as hearing and vision. The
latter two account for many injuries and both are excluded
from Medicare coverage.
But it is particularly important to find a Medicare code
for geriatrics assessment which aims to gauge function and its
maintenance and restoration. The essential goal of geriatrics
is to maintain functional status.
Revised 5/4/93 -11 -

8) There should be a national campaign to avoid unintentional
injuries (or accidents) among the top ten causes of death of
older persons. It is possible to evaluate living arrangements
to protect against falls which account for some 200,000 hip
fractures, in excess of $2 billion in costs, per year.
9) Professional education is as essential as public education in
prevention. Specifically physicians must be reached through
continuing medical education.
10) Older persons and persons of all ages should maintain health
diaries (a method that has been used with some success in
Japan) to help raise health consciousness.
11) Legislative Efforts:
It has been established that taxation of tobacco does
change behavior. For every increase in taxation there is
reduction in purchase, especially among the young. It has
been estimated that a 10% increase in tobacco tax would
account for 4% reduction in purchase. When cigarette taxes
began to rise in Canada, tobacco consumption fell by 20%. It
should be noted that cigarette consumption in the U.S. and
Canada were about equal in the early 1980s but not today.
Taken together taxation on alcohol and tobacco is also a
source of funds to finance health promotion and health care
reforms. Obviously as tobacco and alcohol use declines it
leads to a fall in revenues, a happy result. If tobacco and
liquor companies were to cut prices there could be a
comparable tax increase to keep prices stable.
Revised 5/4/93 -12 -

12) Regulation of smoking is also restricted in restaurants,
airplanes and other public places.
* . * * *
Conclusion
I have oriented my remarks specifically to the later years
drawing some attention to the Baby Boom generation which is in
transition to old age. In truth, health promotion and disease
prevention is a life-long activity and its promotion would do much
to insure a higher quality late life. Similarly, environmental and
occupational safety and health would enhance late life and save
billions of dollars in worker's compensation.
There has been a gathering and extraordinary
movement toward
national goals of health promotion and disease prevention over the
last 15 years. In 1979, the U.S. Public Health Service under the
Carter Administration began to specify such goals. These goals and
the supporting data-bases are most recently summarized under Health
Objectives for the Year 2000, a U.S. Public Health Service
initiative. The private sector through the Institute of Medicine
of the National Academy of Sciences has produced the important
volume The Second Fifty Years.
There is no question that self-responsibility is of great
importance. We should enhance self-consciousness regarding one's
responsibility for one's health. But certain caveats are in order.
Those less advantaged, the poor in general and members of minority
groups, may have enough to do to get through the day. They do not
have the time or education to pursue health habits. The
older age
Revised 5/4/93 -13-

group of today grew up in a different era when there was less
knowledge of health promotion and disease prevention. Moreover,
their physicians had less knowledge as well. This is why it will
take some time for self-responsibility to evolve.
As part of the eagerly awaited national health reforms,
we
must build a national campaign to promote healthy lifestyles. It
will not be easy and it will take time. Moreover, we must support
research to better understand health as well as disease. We have
a National Institutes of Health, not a National Institutes of
Disease. In the meantime, we must apply what we know. Our rewards
will be a higher quality of life in old age and a marked reduction
in health costs.
Revised 5/4/93 -14 -

TABLE 1
HEALTH PROMOTION AND DISEASE PREVENTION
GERIATRICS PERSPECTIVE
First line of defense --
Immunization Program
Prevention of injuries
Informed Nutrition
Oral Health
No Smoking
Moderate Alcohol Use
Second line of defense -
Detection and treatment
- prompt detection of reversible confusional states.
- early detection of depression and suicide prevention.
- control of hypertension
- screening for cancer
- hearing check
- vision check
- elder abuse check
- osteoporosis prevention
- smoking cessation
- Medicare codes for geriatrics assessment and care
= coordination.
Third line of defense -
Geriatric Rehabilitation
stroke rehabilitation
amputation rehabilitation
cardiac rehabilitation
rehabilation to end ventilator dependence (chronic
obstructive pulmonary disease).
Revised 5/4/93

TABLE 2
QUALITY TIME
If you're healthy at age 86, you can expect to remain independent
for most of your remaining years. But even if you're dependent at
this age, you have a good chance for another year of active living.
(Remaining life expectancy for individuals aged 70 to 92 and
percent of remaining life expected to be lived independently, by
age and dependency status at beginning of age interval, 1984.)
Independent
Independent Total Years Percent
remaining Independent at age
70 ............................ 13.4 75%
72 ............................ 12.2 73
74 ............................ 11.1 71
76 ............................ 10.0 68
78 ............................ 9.0 66
80 ............................ 8.1 63
82 ............................ 7.3 61
84 ............................ 6.6 59
86 ............................ 6.0 57
88 ............................ 5.5 56
90 ............................ 5.2 56
92 ............................ 4.9 53
Independent
at age Dependent
Total Years
remaining
Percent
Independent
70 ..................... ....... 12.5 51%
72 ..................... ....... 11.3 48
74 ..................... ....... 10.1 41
76 ..................... ....... 8.9 32
78 ..................... ....... 8.0 29
80 ..................... ....... 7.2 28
82 ..................... ....... 6.5 25
84 ..................... ....... 5.9 24
86 ..................... ....... 5.3 21
88 ..................... ....... 4.8 18
90 ..................... ....... 4.5 19
92 ..................... ....... 4.3 19
Source: Richard Rogers, Andrei Rogers and Alain Belanger, "Active
Life Among the Elderly in the United States: Multistate Life-Table
Estimates and Population Projections," The Milbank Quarterly, Vol.
67, No. 3-4, 1989.
