Lorillard
the Smoking and Helth Controversy: Another Side
Fields
- Author
- Schafer, G.E.
- Type
- REPT, OTHER REPORT
- BIBL, BIBLIOGRAPHY
- Alias
- 85645959/85645973
- Document File
- 85645815 /85646194 /State Legislation Re: Michigan State Legislation
- Area
- LEGAL DEPT FILE ROOM
- Named Organization
- American Assn for Thoracic Surgery
- American Thoracic Society
- British Medical Journal
- Chicago City Councils Comm on Environm
- Congress
- Ctr, Council for Tobacco Research
- Havard
- Hew, Dept of Health Education and Welfare
- in Univ
- Lancet
- Natl Heart, Lung + Blood Inst
- Natl Inst of Health
- Northwestern Univ
- Ucla
- Wa Univ
- Advisory Comm
- American Thoracic Society
- Site
- N14
- Named Person
- Aronow, W.
- Burch, P.
- Burrows
- Califano, J.
- Cooper, T.
- Froeb
- Halberstram, M.J.
- Hart
- Knoebel, S.B.
- Langston, H.T.
- Lebowitz
- Lenfant, C.
- Liu, B.
- Surgeon General
- Warner, K.E.
- White
- Burch, P.
- Date Loaded
- 12 Feb 1999
- Author (Organization)
- TI, Tobacco Inst
- Master ID
- 85645816/6131
Related Documents:- 85645816-5817 Governor's Citizens' Panel on Smoking & Health
- 85645818-6131 Governor's Citizens'panel on Smoking & Health
- 85645819
- 85645820-5835 Minority Report
- 85645836-5837
- 85645869-5870 Memorandum of Understanding Between University of Michigan School of Public Health and Michigan Deptartment of Health
- 85645871-5872 Governor's Appointed Citizens' Panel on Smoking and Health
- 85645875-5878 Citizens' Panel on Smoking and Health
- 85645879-5885 Citizens' Panel on Smoking and Health
- 85645886-5890 Citizens' Panel on Smoking and Health
- 85645891-5898 Citizens' Panel on Smoking and Health
- 85645899-5902 Citizens' Panel on Smoking and Health
- 85645903-5907 Citizens' Panel on Smoking and Health
- 85645911-5957 Smoking and Health in Michigan
- 85645958
- 85645978-5986
- 85645987-5988
- 85645989
- 85645999-6000 Citizens Panel on Smoking and Health
- 85646001
- 85646002-6003 Smoking and Health - Attention Public Heating Calling the Governor's Citizens Panel
- 85646004 Citizens Panel on Smoking and Health
- 85646005-6006
- 85646007
- 85646008
- 85646009-6011
- 85646012-6013 Governor's Citizen's Panel on Smoking and Health
- 85646014
- 85646015
- 85646016-6017 Summary Research Findings on Health Effects of Cigarette Smoking
- 85646018
- 85646019 Position Paper on Smoking and Health
- 85646020-6021 Smoking
- 85646022
- 85646023 Citizens Panel on Smoking and Health
- 85646024-6025
- 85646026 Testimony to Citizens, Panel on Smoking and Health
- 85646027-6028 Testimony to the Governor's Panel on Smoking and Health
- 85646029-6031 Statement Governor's Citizens Panel on Smoking and Health Submitted to the Office of Health Education Michigan Department of Public Health in Behalf of United Connunity Services of Metropolitan Detroit 801008
- 85646032 the Governor's Citizens Panel on Smoking and Health the Metropolitan Detroit Coalition for High Blood Pressure Control Public Hearing Comment on Smoking and Health 801008
- 85646033-6034
- 85646035-6038 Statement Givenby Dr. Murray Jackson in Behalf of the American Lung Association of Southeastern Michigan to the Citizens' Panel on Smoking and Health - Wednesday, 801008
- 85646039-6045
- 85646046-6047 Open Letter and Statement to the Citizen's Panel on Smoking & Health
- 85646048-6052 Cost Effectiveness and Benefits of Smoke Stoppers Program As Compared to Two Other Popular Smoking Cessation Programs
- 85646053-6056 Statement of W. A. Wickman, General & Legislative Counsel Michigan State Chamber of Commerce to Governor's Panel on Smoking & Health 801008
- 85646058
- 85646059 Panel Report & 'illustration'
- 85646060-6061
- 85646062-6063
- 85646064-6067
- 85646068
- 85646069
- 85646070-6071
- 85646072-6073
- 85646074-6075
- 85646078 Citizens' Panel on Smoking and Health
- 85646079
- 85646080
- 85646081-6084
- 85646085
- 85646086-6087
- 85646088-6089
- 85646090
- 85646091-6092 A Proposed Michigan Clean Air Act
- 85646093-6095
- 85646096
- 85646097
- 85646098-6105
- 85646106-6107 Smoking and Insurance
- 85646108-6109
- 85646110
- 85646111 Update on the Resource People Selected to Represent Various Bureaus in the Michigan Department of Public Health
- 85646112-6113 Citizens' Panel on Smoking and Health
- 85646114-6116
- 85646117-6120
- 85646121
- 85646122
- 85646123
- 85646124
- 85646125
- 85646126-6127
- Litigation
- Stmn/Produced
- UCSF Legacy ID
- bxg40e00
Document Images
Through these research proc-ams, ccnce_-~-...ei atte*pts are beir.c 7sce to zr~..an3
our }a:owlecge of smcki.ng and nealth-related cuesticns. ':".-:e xsit.icn of the
tobacco ir)cust.v is that the answers w-i'? : e found cnl,,r t.rct:ch scL:nd, cbjec-
tive scientific inqu; .*y. To this enc, its =tiit--i---:t to researr..h is s.:,bstanti.al.
Ccr.c'_usicn
In recent years, ssroking has beccme an ea,-,, target for pecole anxicus to solve
our nation' s health prcblem. But these probler.is ~ai? 1 not be solved by icr.ori.^.g
the scientific cazple.cities si=LTdi^g smekir.g and health issues. Nor will
they be resolved by legislation that interferes with the perscr.al choices of a
large section of the populaticn, and has the cotential for unfavorabie social
and political ircpacts. onl.y an ebjec-,ive analysis of the evide-rice aryd the
contint,ed pursuit of scientific ]Qiowler:ge can help resolve t'^.cse prcble::s.
It is to be hoped that the Panel, with the assistance of its Project Director,
will present, after full consideraticn ef the issues, a balz.r.cer3 analysis.
I
I
I
I
I
I
j
I
I-
I
-124-

i
R=,E::C.:S
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
i
I
i
j
1
~
!
i
1. G~15tr=, J. , "Rising Lung- C3ncer MOi-`'~.~...~il`' NC^.3iY;}Ce_''s, " J_ ::c:::l Cancer
L^5t 62 (4) . 7s;-760, h.a'il, 1979.
2,
U.S. ?t:b~~ cc i?eatth S,,_-r_ce, _1-'nokir.(z ar.d ::ea1tZ. of the ?cvisorv
Catr,uttee to the Surce^..n Ger.eral or t.e ?:blzz Heer=n Sz...^rice, Depzr-_ie*:t
oz ~ 1, r: ;:cat~n dWelfare, PNS P.:biiat+cn No. 1103, 1964.
3. Hku)cley, J., Trans=iat, .ti'ews CG:nfere.^.ce Pe.d eased by U. S. Public F.eal th
Service, JanLar_r 11, 1964.
4. Rosenblatt, ,K. , Statement, U.S., Ccngress, House, Catmittee cn Interstate
and Foreign Corcirprce, Ci ett~e Labe.li:.Q and Advertisir.g - 1969, Hearing,
91st Ccng. , 1st Sess. , april 15-30 and MayT, 1969 (Washingtcn: G~e_Y:rne.zt
Printing Office, 1969), pp. 1255-1271.
5. U.S. Public Health Service, Smokir.a and Health. A Re=_ ort of the Stscecn
General, Depax-.,ent of Y-:ealtn, £ucaticn arri welfare, DhffW__Publ caucn No.
TTZ-37T66, 1979.
6. Ibid.
7. Sterling, T., "A Review of the Claim that Eccess Morbidity and Disability
Can be Ascribed to Smkir.g," J Am Stat Assoc 66(334): 251-257, June, 1971.
8. Berkson, J. ,"Sankinr and Lmg Cancer: Sane Cbsesvaticns on Tsao Recent
Reports," JAn Stat Assoc 53 (281) : 23-38, 1958.
9. U.S. Public Health Service, Siing and Health, 1964.
10. Lees, T., Statement, Carada, House of Ca:mons, Standing Coin.uttee on Health,
Welfare and Social Affairs, Hearing, 28th Parl=-ent, 1st Sess., May 13, 1969
(Ottawa: The Queen's Printer, 1969), pp. 1058-1078, 1087-1113.
11. Dijkstra, B., "Cn Srmxing and IArq Cancer," Suid-Afr' aa*+se Kanker'_N~eti*: 23(3):
87-109, July-Segtenber, 1979.
12. Sc.'zrauzer, G., Statemient, U.S., Coi-igress, Fzuse, Car,mittee on Agri.culture,
Suboarmittee on Tolacxo, Effect of Slmkir.Q on N.4_-T~kers, Hearing, 95th Ccng.,
2nd Sess., September 7, 197$(Wasning=: G6,-e_^ane*:t Printing Office, 1978)
pp. 139-157. 1
13. Buhler, V., State:rent, U.S., Congress, House Catmit*..ee on Interstate and
Foreign Caamesce, Cigarette Laheli~ and AiivQrt:sirq-1969, Hearing, 91st
Ccaq., 1st Sess., AgrIr30,ar May~I, 1369 ( a, . Gcvezrrrnt Print-
ing Office, 1969), pp. 769-787.
Burch, P.,"Sanking and Czsicer, " Lancet I: 1315-1316, June 9, 1973.
14. Burch, "Srmking and Car:cer. "
15. Burch, P. ,"Smaking and Iung Cancer: '2^.e P'roblem of Inferring C2arse, " J R
Stat Soc A 141 (Part 4): 437-458, 1978. --
-125-

16. lb i d .
17. Bur:»z, P. ,"Strok:.::g and Lur:g Cancer. Tests of aCsl:sa? ::yoct:.esis, °.; C,.^n
Dis 33: 221-238, 1980.
18. Burch, P. ,q and Lung Cance_*-: T".:e P=ble=n of L-iFzrri.g Cause."
19. Fei ei,A,. , Ccznp-zts on "Discussion" of presentat'_cn by P. Burch,
and Lung Ca.^.cer: The Prcblem of Inferring Cause (Wit'i Discussion," J R Stat
Scc A 141 (Part 4): 437-477, 1978.
20. Sales, S. ar~d J: House, "Job Dissatisfaction As a Possible Risk :'actcr in
Corcnar_r Heart Disease," J G`ircn Dis 23: 861-873, 1971.
21. Coopes, T., Statenent, U.S., Cangress, Senate, Ccnmit}.ee on Labor and Public
Welfare, bubc.inittee on Health, Cicarette &mkina and Disease, 1976, I:earing,
94th Cczig., 2nd Sess., Febnuary 1,Marc.'n 24, and :7ay 2~7~ (w szirg'-,^n:
Goverranent Printing Office, 1976), pp. 175-208.
22. Fr:itorial., "Very Early Recognition of Coronary 'r.'eart Disease," Br J_ Med I:
1302, May 21, 1977.
23. Reys, A., Seven Counties: A:hiltivariate Analvsis of Death and Corcra~-v Heart
Disease (Cazmridge: fiaxvand L'niversity Press0) .
24. Ibid.
25. Editorial, "'ehy the American Decline in Coro^.azy Heart Disease?," Lancet I:
183-184, Jarnsary 26, 1980.
26. National Heart, Iung and Blood Institute, National Institutes of Health, Report:
Working Group on Heart Disease Epidemiology, Depart;ient of Health, Ed-acaticn,
and Yr'e *a` ,e ,14M Publicaticn No. i - 7, 1979 .
27. Naticnal F~:eart, Limc- and Blood Institute, Naticxal Institutes of Health, "S1mm~.~ry
of the Ccnference on the Decline in Ccrcnary Heart Disease Mortality," Procee3incs
of the Ccnference on the Decline in Coronary Heart Disease Mortalitv, Decartrent
oi N.31t:j Du-cat~aiZ-W=ra-re, Nrr1 P Ticat.icn .No .=,~ pp x~ciii-=vii,
1979.
28. Stz snler, J., "Sessics: IV: Stsategies for Quantifying and StLc.'ying CED C7mge,"
Pzoces°_ir:cs of the C,onference on the Decline in Corenary Heart Disease Mortality,
DeparEe*Roi F.Ea-rt7, on rweEare~, Km P=,=ticn LNo. 79-I'oY ,-
3810399, 1979._
29. F---ie3man, G. ,"Decline in Hospit?lizaticns for Coronary Heart Disease and Stroke:
The Kaise=-Pe=nanente Dxpesiece in Northe`n Califernia, 1971-1977,: Proceedings
of the Ccnfere.-ce cn the Decline in Corcr.ary Heart Disease 1%brtality, Dep3rt:nent
oi Heal` ,c:cati39 ax 'tiveliare, NI'rI-cation No.~i5-76Sd pQ Ib9-114, 1979.
30. Shapiro, S., "Session IV: Strategies for Quantif_virg and Studying GHD Qzange,"
Proces': ncs of t':e Cbrference on the Decli^.e in Corenarv Heart Disease Mortality,
Derzr=ezt ci i?e. , i;cauoa ana'W=are :1rdPtA~auon .1o. 79-161 , pp.
381-399, 1979. (z
C!'
~
G'1
-126- ~
i
i
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
N
t
t

I
I
I
I
I
I
I
i
I
I
I
I
31. U.S. P~;blic Health Se`~rice, -`ncki^.c and Health, 1979.
32. Iar.gstcn, H., Statenent, U.S., Cor.gress, 'rioi:se, Ccmtit},.ee cn St:.,'~
Ca:mit}m on 7-tbacco, Zfrect of S;rokinc cn %1cns:xke_-s, 'r_eari^.g, 95en C:,r.g.,
2.-Y-J Sess., Segte.*rhZ 7, 1978 (6ras-y~;n: Gc-,F---: e.rt Printing Office, 1978),
-m. 158-184.
33. A`-cnew, W. , "Effect of Passive Smoking on Ar:gi.^.a ?ec~cr=s ," New E:cl JML-_,?
299(1): 21-24, 1978. - - -
34. Fisher, E., Sta*..e.me-*it, U.S. Congress, House, Cc.a;mity..ee on Ac;ricaLt.:~re, Sub-
ca;mittes on Tobacco, Effect of Smokir.G on ,:on...~~nck.ers, Hearing, 95th Cong.,
2.-ri Sess. , September 7, 1978 (ashingtCn( Gcwe,_-,e.-it Pr:rzting Office, 1978),
pp. 2-20.
35. Niden, A. ,"No: Fhvirormental Srncke Can Ir_itate Not Injise pthers," Lcs
Angeles Times, Cctober 29, 1978.
_ -
36. Knoebel, S., Statement, U.S., Congress, House, Cor,mitt..ee on Agriculture, Sutr-
carnittee on Tcbacco, Effect of STmki1^g on Nons-zek.ers, Hearing, 95th Ccng.,
2nd Sess., Sept,erbes 7, 197$ (Washing}..c.n: Govern--nent Printing Office, 1978),
pp. 49-55.
37. Piam, P., et al., "Physiological Effects of Acute Passive E~=osure to Cigarette
Smoke in Asthnatics," Fed Proc 36 (3 ): 606, 1977.
38. .47cser, K., Statement, U.S. Congress, House, Comnit+,.ee on Agriculture, SUb-
Coianittee on Tabacco, Effect of Snn~king on Nansmckers, Hearing, 95th Cong.,
2nd Sess., Septenbes 7, 19 7 8(~~:~ton: Gez,er; mernt Printi^.g Office, 1978),
pp. 35-40.
39. LzbC.wi}.z, M. and B. Burrows, "Respiratory Sym=tzm ReLated to Srm.king Habits
of Family Adults, " Cr.est 69 (1) : 48-50, January, 1976.
40. Kerrebijn, K. ,' et al., "Qzronic Nonspecific Respira}..ary Disease in Czi.ldren
A Five Year Fo11ow-up Stu~.y," Acta Paediatr Scsnd Supol 261: 1-72, 1977.
41. Sc-h? il; n g, R., et al.,"Ltu:g Function, Respiratcry Disease and gnokir:g in
Families," Am J Ebidemiol 106(4): 274-283, 1977.
42. '+vhite, J. and H. Proeb, "Small-Airdays Dysfunc+ ..i.cn in Ncnsrckers G'z.--onically
E:qosed to Tobacco Smcke," N Fhcrl JMed 302 (13) : 720-723, March 27, 1980.
43. IUi.d.
44. Halbe.rst3n, M., "SL-,jdy on Second-harri Smoke EValuated," The (LouisviLle, KY)
Ccuri.estiour+.al, Arril 27, 1980. -
45. Iznfant, C. and B. Liu, "(Passi,e) Sankers Versus (Voluntary) Snnkers, " N
Ehcl JMed 302(13) : 742-743,_ Harc'i 27, 1980. -
46. Aviado, D. ,"Sma11-ki.^days Dysfunction in Passive Sir~rs, "N IIzc1 JMes3 303 (7) :
393, August 14, 1980. - - -
-127-

I
392, auc,ust 14, 1980.
47. Huber, G. ,"Sma11-.ki-naays L`vsfiaIcticn izPassi~-e 2:,,cice_-s," N L c1 J:ed 303 (7) :
~---
48. 'rYeed:man, A., "Small-Airwavs Dvs---unc'.icn in Passive --m.kers," V H;c1 JMe3
303 (7) : 393, at:cust 14, 1980.
49. Langstcn, State:ne.zt.
50. Lenfant, C. a.zY: B. Liu, "(Passive) Snoke:s Versus (Voluntary) Sinckers."
51. Jones, W. ,"Caic: co's Sncke_rs Court Puffs Up Scme Haze, " Minr.eaoolis 'IYibc:r.e,
July 1976.
52. Salvaggio, J., Statement, U.S., Congress, Fcuse, CUtmit,..ee on Agriculture, Sub-
oannittee on Tc.bacoo, Effect of Smckiria cn Ncnsnokers, N.earing, 95th Ccng.,
2nc.' Sess., Segte:rber 7, = (was ur.gtcn: Govazzarent Printing Office, 1978) ,
pp. 46-49.
53. Cohesi, R. , Statement, U. S. , Congress, Fouse, Ccnmittee cn Ar.;ricult-.e, St:b-
caTanittee on Tcbacco, Effect of ~Smcki_~n on I3onstmkers, Hearing, 95t'~ Cong.,
2nd Sess., Septerher 7, IS'i $~waun-qtorr: Govpsrlne.~t Pr izting Of fice 1978)
FP
69-75.
I
I
I
I
I
I-
p
L
6
L
I
-128-
~
~
`
