Lorillard
Acsh Media Update
Fields
- Area
- LIBRARY/SUBJECT BOXES
- Alias
- 81210422/81210437
- Type
- NELE, NEWSLETTER
- ENVE, ENVELOPE
- NEWS, NEWSPAPER ARTICLE
- Named Organization
- American Council on Science + Health
- American Lung Assn
- Bw, Brown & Williamson
- Desert News
- Ftc, Federal Trade Commission
- Kalamazoo Gazette
- Natl Assn of State Boards of Education
- Sun
- TI, Tobacco Inst
- Ut Board of Education
- American Council on Science and Health
- Named Person
- Whelan, E.M.
- Baker, L.
- Browder, A.
- Brown, N.
- Checketts, K.
- Leake, R.
- Luke, P.
- Steincrohn
- Varela, V.
- Recipient
- Schultz, F.J.
- Date Loaded
- 05 Jun 1998
- Request
- R1-004
- Author (Organization)
- American Council on Science + Health
- Litigation
- Stmn/Produced
- Site
- G39
- Master ID
- 81210000/1047
- 81210064-0110 Searching for A Way Out Smoking Cessation Techniques
- 81210084-0089 A Smoking Gun: How the Tobacco Industry Gets Away with Murder
- 81210111-0142 Smoking or Health: Its Your Choice
- 81210235-0236 Order Form
- 81210239-0254 Acsh News and Views
- 81210259-0286 American Council on Science and Health Sixth Annual Report Covering Period 830701 - 840630
- 81210291-0306 Acsh News and Views
- 81210311-0326 Acsh News and Views
- 81210328-0357 American Council on Science and Health Seventh Annual Report
- 81210358-0373 Acsh News & Views Volume 7, Number 1
- 81210374-0389 Acsh News & Views Volume 7 Number 2
- 81210406-0421 Acsh News & Views Volume 6 Number 4
- 81210446-0461 Acsh News & Views Volume 6 Number 3
- 81210462-0477 Acsh Media Update Winter 850000
- 81210478-0493 Acsh News & Views Volume 6 Number 2
- 81210494-0497 Inside Acsh
Related Documents:
Document Images
t
tmrnt. u.~maw
. ~....... -(nO ~,s~ Ynnr n,
aYat o w.,n wwm~ala G~f+w si..l... . unw r a,m . w ntrnt . a
trso.v....... smtw ~J.. a o..~.o.w.w,~ran n om.. rou
f
~ ~.
o .
o.wW l wwtrvLaa,, `U
~ rT,O..
' aaWWtN~ tnt'ntn
.~.7
WrY1t¢R(
Y _ r
- r+i'Yti r~~.~^^~.~/---- a ./ I-~ n Irf ran` apsw~w ~y w~„ral..a /
1mY.n w ' M nrtp.am aw
m ~ ~OnrlrllL
~ ~a _,~,\~ ~p_:!~ alrltr"~Kltlrrrnlr nYLatw.~;
, s.fa..
.. ~ '`j'.. ..utuu ewtu n.aufa~.. Irw.e7rT~
'
/ ~
=CYe,brrartErKY ~.taY4lrtIl 3M.faqlwe
. . . _ - Aw~ Iwa
mfmut u
usWra
r~w
Afl'll?flca(1
Ci0Uf1Cii
on SCiCf1Ce
8fWHe8ft1
/~ra¢YPM
l rt~ ~r.N.,. JsY ~' tLa[ Ya~
x 'msoi~n L: mmsra n le..v~.. r.n. . ~
` r.nfrwwe. ~ nnnmmru•ru
nsn¢u vlaysu .--~ _
4- 1995 BroadraYL
New York New Yttrk'.10027
al press coverage of ACSH reports and ar-
ticles Is outstanding. ACSH's work is dis-
cussed In thousands of newspaper and
magazine articles each year. MEDIA UP-
DATE Is designed to share with you the
impact that ACSH's work is having in every
state of this country, as well as the vari`ty
of health issues we cover. .
~
/ ~UPDATE
- Selected Clippiings From Sphng/Summer'63 •'-
Reeling
PUBLICATION OF THE AMERICAN'COUNCIL ON SCIENCE AND HEALTH .1993 BROADWAYa NEWYORK NY1002Y (212)
]62-7044 -- SUMMER'as
M AR' 25 1985
E
-.~Strlped-bass' fishermen may soon
become the next endangered species it
the enviyorlmentali5u lobbyy has Its
vay- Its members claim ~ that thetariped bass in the New York'.a area areeontaminatedby
polychlortnated bi-, pheny9ss, or PClia, and that this indus-
trial chetnical'poses a cancer risk-
Ttierefore, the environmenoalists in-
sstM stnped-bass' fishingg should be
banned., . .
New York's Gov. Mario Cliomo is currently onn the hookk over this issue: ,
He must decide by the start of his state's flshing season. AprN 1.
w-ileNer to limlt.or even totaAy ban
'.~tommercial and'recreational ffshing
for stnped bass. Before he makes his- decision., werecommend that Ile,:and
the many other parties to this long-
-ntnrdngdispute, read a new.report by' ---Jhe American Council on Science and
Healt , a group evot to separating
bogus health scares from real dangers
like cigarettes. _
pG:BS were produced'~ in~ the U.S
for near1y.50.years; rttaildy for use asa noacomtifutible, insulating. fluid Ie
electrical transfomners. Thesee chemi-
eals„ which haven'rt been produced in
.the U.S. sincel977;,do tend'to iiager,
fm an unusually long time In the envl-
ronrtieat before degradiltg. But stablee
attbstanees are often nontoxic, and the
American Industrial Hygiene Assacla-
tlon classifies PCBS as only
"slightly
fmdc . to practitally nontoxie.'.'
Concem abourPCBS arose.from a
19gg accident InJapan. After eating
rice oil contammatedd with PCBS,
about 1,300 Japanese tellINI, withh
symptomsincluding nausea, . fatigue,
awelling of: the extremlties, and in~
' aomecases, liver disorders; As the
victims were followed they showed
ather health problems,.includihlg 11
cancer deaths, . slightly higher than a
mrmai" rate. U.S. manufacturers
stopped producing PCBs, thougti
traces still appear in the environment
where they had' been produced or
were disposed of: Including the Hud-
con River breeding groundsof striped bass.
APR 7 19R5
~
WALL STREEf 10UBtYAL `
NEW YORK, N.T,
a na,w
Science
Slthsequent studies of the Japanese
traged7V. the A(5EI relates, showedd
that: the oils were contaminated not
only.wiUt pCEts but alsowith much
moremxicrelated: suhstances pto-
duced in certain rttanufacturtrtg pvo-
cesses.. Mostt researchers nmv agree
that the incident provides an . uncer-
tain basis fon worries about pC85
thmLVelves- Meanwhlle; toxicological stttdles on
laboratory artimalss have failed to prv
viderephcableevidence that PCBs
catlse cancer or binh'~ deteets: Moreii-
ver, several occupational-health stud-
ies of workers heavily exposed to
PCea found no evidence.of i0-0tealth
effects and no excess incidence of can-
cer, even after as much as 40 years of
expustre too the chemical3. And the
. AISH'report adds that publtlc-healtlh
studies mMichlgan and' Connecticut
show that "fish eaters have suffered !
no knowB, ill effects from PCBs.". ~
In addition~ federal statlsUts Indir .
eate.that, whatever the health danr
gets from PCBs, the number of Amer
leans with high levels of ~PCBs hasal-
ready declined sharply. That figure Isprobably below 1%, and . presumably
will dropfurtlier fwww that the com-
pound Isntn in.widespread use. The
ACSH report concludes that "tlmeit-
self Is an Important (actor In resolving
the sltuation " It's hard to seefrom the evWmce,
then,that PCHs are a major health
harard. Any kind of risk and benefd
balancing would tip, the scales In favor
of the Inng island: fisheryindustryy sports anglers and fanciers of striped
Eass, onee of the sea's most succulent
tfsh. But such ~balancJng.is not part of
the envfronmental'movetttent, .rhich
presupposes that once.there Lsanyhint that something is a"tMeat"'-
hether It's chetmcals In, fish or nu-
elear power or whatever-everyone is
etpectedto hop to comply, no matter
what the cOSt~~or how scanty' Ute evi.
dence.. Stnce. (7ov: CLomo is being
eyed as a potential Democratic pmt-
dentiall nominee, It will be interesting
to see his line, not to mention Doo J
and sinker. `
CHICAGO, iL
- CHICAGO TRIBUNE
B,7ri,asa sutt rtar,as
. .. ctT. 933.117
aYAIYM~fO~Nw,
_,.
ACSH ANNOUNCES'85 MEDIA SEMINARS 4
T
TtieAmerican Couneil on Science and.Heaith cordially invitesreaders ofMEDfA UPDATE to.attead
eitherofourtwts
upcoming media seminars. The'umbrella topic"for both will be: ENVIRONMENTAL RISKS: PRIORITIES FOR
THE FUTURE. The first evem will be held in Washington. D.C. on October 16.1995 at the Hyatt Regency
Hote4
the second, in New York CI'ty on November 13, 1985 at the Sheraton Centre. Registration forbotb
sem•naR wtU begin
at 8:30 sm., the proceedings at 9:10 a.m The eventss will md'~at',4:30'p.m. The speakers will be the
same on both -lv-
agendas. Dr. Elizabeth Whelan will open.n the morning sessions with a discussion of the filtdings in
her tattst b'ook "Toxie
- Terror". This book urgently ca8s for Americans to recognize thesevedty.of the gap between
scientific faerattd whaa's
been presented by the print media, television and radio about environmental issues. Dr. rt Whelan
asserts that it is time to
re-evaluate the term "envirottmentalistn", assess its goals, and then re-think our envisoomental
priorities for the
MAP 27 1985
. - "NNNNIPEG, MANIT., CAN-
_~ . FREE PRESS
- 172,335 a. 2st.en9
a
Buckling u :
p
iy~~
1 wear a seat brlt inn my car and ask peoplee riding with melo do the
same. A friend frequenlly reminds me a friend of his was killed
because he was strapped in a seat belt and dtowned in his wrecked car.
And he refuses too buckie up.
The American Counoil
,up$cieal,e-- znW~TU-T
m.profst consumer in-
formation group,,
reports surveys showw
many pecplee avuidwearing sa(ely be11s
Eeca ve they think it is
better to be "-tfuown ckar" of the nrin case .
of an aecident, or
because they.worry: that
.
a fastened belt ouJd keep a crash victim
from getting oul of a
bfuning or submerged'veh'ide. Soo my lrlend"s
eancern isni t unique.
Then, too. some pw
plebelieve backseat
passmgers don't need:
American
COtJn&
{~,)~g g~.V~V~~r~I ~R.~eG
r1C~71 U 1
GII~J
: Lakefront relief is on the way
OYrar, Woods & waters
..a.
Ir rr.vs M
~ .
•.Yf.Ta"19~T .
Yum.Nle, the wa0 Stteet Jar-
aal,: discusama a new repon by tbe.
d.uma tne peB isrue u a
pia ma pok*-ihat m evafence.
anywlure, aMws any harm to pco
pk f.om wa PCBs 7Te.
Pl2 w:aee tieaan whum IJW Jay.
arae her rne avi m 190 afEerconsumina nra oil oooummated
wnh PCBa FJevam.laler dwdd
mlxr. hlaher tltan the menial
nte. SnWieswlbarquenth shh.ad
Ihe adr were OOmamnlaled'with
fac nwre nnac.afbst.nrcs-lardl7e tbebasu for alarmma mdlims
abnw qurawubk p(vbkrtu wnh
PC$s. Obvlously,.eapi.nallona aR
meded from the Fand:and rhttg
Admvustratm..Ar4 taon .
1
w ... ~taadeaYSa wlasbr.'~~w~..r.r.~...... ..... v...r.:... .. -t...,... .- .. -.
P®a may . aw be as barmail' aa.
- Rah eaten as rwemmea IeaWt
, ton thmk. New Ywk state 6u
. banned all mmmeraal rntuna for
atriped baa m Ne.. York barbor
and'~aioly botb .Mtv d nMers
tmt laWd. 7Le b.n aoer mt
"Indfide easem lang Islud, where
most of the commewf fishula
takes daoa, bbr~use d atleaed
" e No: s the time sa lfed fer
In.naam'. Wolf River and sume
. apeaaadu wtaleye fithlna. Bs
rulW are oeal alay the slmea if
7ou ran't ka.e, try tle.Foa River
ia the eddrs beJOw aa7y dam.
l tna..
e AmNanltna repurta thN
N an
t~m a
utu um u \ t ++.+w
best bet
TABLEOFCONTENTS The American Council on Science and
E Health (ACSH)Js an independent scient't-
PAG
E fitorganization promoting balancedeva,l-
' ' uations of food, chemicals, the environ-
Lifestyles........... 2-4 mentandhealth.ACSHpublishesconsu-
"mer reports and newsletters on public
Food E Nutrition.... 5- 7 health and environmental issues. Nation-
srptbelts, or tAat:it'sall
right~for a child to ridee
on a¢adult's lap. Acror,
ding to the couocil„all
these beliefs are faLse.
Studies show that peo-
ple who are thrown
clear~are 25 times more
likely to die than if lhey
had stayed in thevehicle.
1¢ rare accidents
where.a car catchesf ire
or goes underwaterl
peopk who wear seat
belts are mon likely to
survnvebeca¢se theyy
have a betler chance of
remain+ng u Ynjured
and- therefore, , capa.blet
of getting out d the car.
•
BdCkSeat rlder3 need
belts . to prevent them,
frmnbeing thnown into
front-sest occupantss a crash..And. the fortesd a crash are so ba.st
that a child in an adulrs
artns is ripped loose and nung against the cadsinterior.
Manyy iYates tequire
that smau' children, be
restrained in either a
car seat or seal tielt.
A parting . stwt: . Thee
tamcfl reports that a
deiver weanng a belt
has a better chance of
being able tocontrol apr after the initial im-
pact d a crash: ~,
SPR IING 1985
T1vo Cheers
For EDB
remainder of this 20th t.enosry. -
Dr. William Haveeder,.ACSHatlvisor
aa'envvoootemaltmsuhamGomBerkeky . .
,
Califotnis, will explamn bow we can and -'
must view risks posed by tttaamadee
earcinogens in txntext with backgraunds
of aaturalcaroinogens. Dr. Haverder will ,
analyze health hazards posed by natura4
ly-occurring csmnogens. compare themwktt those.posed by syrahmc cartmogen;
and give some perspective to risks and
-.
benefits inherentm both.
Dr-Julian Simon, ACSH policYatfvisory and Professor of Business and Social
SLience, University of Maryland, will
took ahead to the year 2,000 and distvsssome importam choices we.mtcstmakee abonfen'rifUOIDental
issues now in order
too assure that the fttttne and welFbeing of
the USA (and the world) wiB bemme
better, not worse- Our luncheon speaker
will be Dr. Normaa Borlaug, ACSH
director, and Nobel Laureate, 1970. Dr. -
Borlaug will present'an overvievr of bow
chemical-phobia developed im thiss muffiry,
and'sttow how this phenomenon resulted
in unwarranted ba.utings of useful pesti-
cides. He will reviewr the impact anti-
science has had ou our standard of living
(food supply). Dr. FredSfnger, ACSH
advisor, and'dsroftssor of Environmental ~
Scient'es, Universityt>< Yirgiaia,, willi
dlscusa the billion dollar sohuioo to a
million dollar problem (the downside
risks of movielg toward regulation before ~ mntmueaonpage16
WILSON OUARTEi1L'Y
WA aHWNi6Ti(RN46-C,
-
~~
'Cr.e Th.nka tr ferddn. Too" by: FJir.
.
. abnb'~. M_ Whdan,.im A- rAr sool .
piur. 1961), a6'Dlud A.e- New Yort,
IOOQ2:
For SO ryeun, American Farmere used rhe podode ethykne dibtomide~ •(EDB) to protect ftuits.and
stored grains from msects. But after a ptds-
lic uproar sparked last year by the d'ucovery of traces of FDB in tnme
breakfast cervals and cake lmiae, the US. Favuoo.oeonl Protoction ' ,
Agency (EPA) abruptly banned t~ie diemical.
Whelan, who h'eadi.tlieAmerivan (ounc_. - oR,' pce aqd Hea116,
thinks that the EPAwas stampe~aomal` ong a mistak'e.. F.DB.':dte
contends. was only,a moderate thr<at and is naer.ely being replarxd by.
aher.chemi.cals that are "less effective in destroying pests and oHer no,
safety advantages to humans-at an eoortnous mst to the owuumer,"
Thc discovery of EDB's presence in food aet oH so Itany.LrW be-
eause the chemical is a carcinogen. Bu1 the faa that laboratory.ra'G fed
massive doara of EDB developed tumurs does n,rt mon tliat bfrnam
wlll. Indeed, the EPA estittules that the avenge Amerscan ingests be-
tween five and 10 microgramsof FJ1B daily, compued with 140,0000
miwgrants of plain old pepper. To conwme ploportiooately as mfrL
EDB as the.laboratory animals did. Amerieata would have to mcrease
their daily intake 250.000 times. The incidence ofcancenamo¢g aa
group of 156 EDB factory worken wh'u w<n eaposed todosea 5,000 to
10,000 times larger than normal "it.rsot sig¢iGrantly diHerent frvm
that eapected 5n an, unexporai populatioo."'
Another penpective: The avenge 6utnan diet contalm IO.OOO timo
mun natural careinogens ttusn ma>tmade pesticides.
Whyy tak'e even a small chance on EDB? Daause. Whelan ar{ues.,
the alternatives are probablyy worse. Not using an7 msecticide m
atoredgrain, for eumple, would guvanme.maaaive wute and'dao-gerous spoilage. And of the four
chemicab that have bi.en pressed into
service to replace EDB-ane was a known larcioogen at the time ti the
ban, one has since been founQ m ouae ancer. and twohave mever
even been tnted.
Most galling, of oil to Wbelan is the fact that EPA officials knew aID
along tliat tlieir , wn frightening estimate tttat emtinued use of EDB
tvould'cause thtee additional caset of raecQper 1,000 Americans seas
grossly intlated-14:tilrw too hi`h. Yet under prrr¢me hoto mviroo-
menrtal lobbyists and a panicked public, they withheld the revised esd-
mate untll after the ban was imposed..
........ . .. ..r.:Y.,.-.,-..er.n-..._.~.. ~...~

+ ~ nyr 1»~ '
,~r~ ~ '~`+ f ^ r
~+1r ..1! '1P1l:.
~`'!>; .e9
(
.
~ 1, 4 V
~3 .
d
0
0
J
.
>
,
X
h
®
x
0
U
y
W
J
U.

ti. ~
. I
3
~~~
~N 19
Sig lie~~~
o
~
.
.
, r.
.
:.. _ -e •. .
, m - «3 ~~1'aa~.
~ a•
~ ~~~as~e ~ 411.1
/
J
W
LL.
~~ a'~1 I
~
3
5aJ
~13~
~
$
~a .
~~
~
~
s~S
~~b
~~
b
~
r Q)
}~ 0 °..~
Cl)
i
s
S
..~~l
e
~
9
a (t~~

•

8121042s '
i
vk m
?
it
gb.
;
E
~
~~~< ~~
~ ~~~~~~ 1 ~~ ~I~~g11 g111y1~~~~
~ ~~~
~~~
~
z
~
v U~~ s.'g~~~8g~~ TC~ ~_ ~~~~gr~ ~~~~ A~=I .
. ~~ y~$'g
~~~ ~B~Cl
$B~I~°~~- ~~~. m ®°8 5 3
I I I $j°s~sl~ s~ g~ ~ig8 ~,¢~, 1`x.?~
; ~g 5£9 ~ y.
a ~~~3~~'g~~~E$5 ~fi$
9y
a~~ 8 $~Y$s y,i~gdy~;~ 9
,
~o~He ~~j~
a
~~'ii~iFi~1as~k
~
~
~
1~
~a8s~~°~g ~g~s~ I ~~-3 ~gl `~ 1~I ~ ~ ~e ~~~ ~ss~~~~~a1~~~~~~~~~~g~~~
g' a ~ a
a
a
~s
5 ~a
~$
~ ~ ~3
,~~ ~v~ ~ ~~~ E ~ . ~~sCS .
&~,~ -$o'~9 ~ i ~a C .7 E 7 e-° I
~E_C ~
!I 5Y5y }1~~ °~6 ~ g~ 5t~ ~~a ~a E ~ 1° 3~ 5
ig
Q
~ 3a 68 f 8 ~~ E~~~3y ~~ ~. :ae1s 1 ~.~ 1 : 5
0 ~
~.w~
~,~.I ~
~ ~
~ ~
~ O
0

Easter alert: Please don't eat those decorated eggs
hev may: look P~¢tly sitU^8 in th¢
[ddde of Y" k. [cheru tabie.. but
]ou'd bet[rr not eau 11~e colorrd
' Eystrr eqgs.tor breaYhal.i
Tt•o •anago.JWo tofg50childnnwho pa :inpatcd in a Fister egg humt
developed food po[ao rR alter catmt]
thezge they had collte ed lmvesnga-
- tonfuu dthattheAardb' IedkgeaR•.d
been k pt t room tempe lurr 'or
sev
enlda usmgbactma.totcuruh.
Tbs ar th amer -
Council on
ro
Scienre andHea.lhicromm¢nds you
, fnSe .anv:d..ri R. . ou mund'to
eat, And!Itt ihe d¢ro ra stay on the
tab!e
WEST PALM BEALN FL -
VENING TIMES - '-
~ E, 0.26.750
. ..
AP l< 3 1!g85
wa..ie....... n.ee ew,r.
A wad to fke .re far tkrw wko
1rID coodst Eartar. egg k.ee rLfa
O~8••pdar b4 7~' IPHf. dawaed . 71r .~e.be1dkl~d~fa d by athK.
.~':r °°.ar.,
rama dowo wtu food poh¢WOg two
pan age aHar m q8 kmt
9~mtR. wadr ¢oetamidaad:
wlm Mderfa na preetrale Ur Me0 ~
r a karatv+lr.g~ e.. a tr,bw'
r rtata
Tr k.dtk ¢Pa•li' awn'l.wea•
... Olai dMOg My.1e agg kaOfs. kYt
~ twaosm•b egv tr a rorm ta~
pvato<a lar ma rnl peW6r.
t'dtl
.. amoa..ma.
. - - NOR~FOtK. V'A
- LEOGENSTAR EAT. 4 SUN. 110.600
MAR 31 1985
Ak=ffa7
Egg-stra care
Make Pcter Rabbit'e lask a bH more jo)nY
WI. easter remr by udog a bit of cautioo
Trhen.n wlunng„ biding or muochmgoe bW-
w edled egga..
Aecording m Ne Amerlun ComK•11 m Srl
~~nr
ence.and Health.
paroapu"'t~~m.¢iie Finer ega hmn m lYa
arw.ned fmd pni~auegn from eggs diat
wrne.atand'laa long at.roem temp[illere.
e v.w
Whm~ao egg is twiled, then cooled.
am Is eleated iASide the shelli wmu un dnww
hs wner from the outeide. Twinproduang
.. bacteria un poww widun Ihe water and. iead
mR-ber that hard•burled eggs.are per..-
Idrble fdodr, evm to Iherr shNls. Allow the
• egp m sraM at raom tempentme oNy wMn
bellµ eyed, himm„Punuedor emea .
Adding mayonnaise to a food may
protect you from food poisoning
( Y
Yaoy ptopi ~an uneary alwul'
eatmg ehieken salad, potam salad
ard amdar disbes at summer pte•
dn beeause they haee beard that
foods made with maycmdse are
the mast likely to eause food poi-
emine.
Novever. aientlfu have shownn
that adding mayomaue loa food
dnes ent makr it more dangeram,
tKCOrdi!ng to lhe AmencaoCouncd
m Science andHr31nF"--
aU s conti-.rng _ mayomlatae
mey aelually be shghUy ufer than
dmWr foud..itAqTt mayvonatw
' baeause the a<id in,the ma
.&
ufle .Ibws the arowth d ttx: We
tarla tkkt e.use lood potmNhg.
Yhed.IOOd1.bke ehKkeo salid
probably ga thevbad reputattm
APR 1 1985
. TNENTmN.'NJ
TN&Tg~ENTOMIAN
~yP~rya.e „ _ , ' ' g10:0J4SWA51
~"
- I'Kee4p~ing Foods Edible in Summer
about
]dany people asr uneuyy
aal~d
eating rhieken Wed. potato
, and'simular dishes at eurnmcrpsc
nice bec.use they have heard ttut
..ddihi
foo. maa wu m,yorwee .re
Ihe moe likely m raune food poisun-
JUN 11 1985
dmplt Beeaux they.urMergo a1a
d'* handlhog during preparauoo,
and: thia no annumioate them
with.bacteria.
To prevent ba¢terial focdpd-d raning. the liasi¢ rule ie to keep Eol'
/oodr hot andeold tooda eold~. Per• .
tshable foods lwith or nthoul'
mayonuaiael'.ma~ not beld sale m
sat if they have beem he at tem.
peratuns d 60 degrees fahrenheit'a higher lor mere Nan three or
fourlwun.
One pnetteal way to keep foods
nfe tor a aummer pieeic ir to keep
Ikem m a cooler with lee or
r
aoenW remabie eotd packs mUl.
yeu.re ready laeat. If yoouse lal..
temember m pack tM tood tn tIBM
MAR "r6 198:5 : ' uurtAN'A.FL
B~ NAnw ~ sisInER
Calories & Nutrients Found in
Your Favorite Piua Toppings
• Aere'e rr list of lavurite l qtones; praein• rlboltaein,
plaa toppines - and the . niaem rmd iroa
'~ tabnes and mapr nulneota., Ooioa 11 .ImaW frledl: LIS
~ott add to a 1Y-
ttxh or 14 i alode. .
' tAth pie wtieo you Dile Nem Ytnhroontr fjlr. ro. nw);
' en, aerotWng m the Asgr-•00~ [ lK lA): 4B0 er
..
~ Man Conncil on SciesMe Ndl
HeaHh:'. bner: protem and 1h5a.
$tn cbeeae tt/e Ib.ls 3201roiru.
ealories; proteint vilamin A. Ham (ye ab.l: S23cateneL
' riDOtlavfn and cakium. Pra ein and thtamine.
' Green pepper (1 raw); 1S I Canadian bacon ('ri Ib:):
'eabnes; vnamin C.. 1t10 calones: protetn and thi.
Hed pepper (I raw): 15 anune-
tyleries: viumins A and C: I Pepperoni (SS lb.): 1.100
~ Gtound bref (69 1b.)L Ne0leatones; pmtetn.. ...
..
:•.YAR 27 1985
~ ~~',~s
CAPRAL fiME: .
Sensitive to sulfiting agents?
CheFk~ingredients carefully
_. a?. [ATaL6EN A. YBhTEIt "- ~ reRamw mduery.lhe Naneod
..tleacaaraes Aaodanod heltevea.
E.IW irn have kecome rnNra- that mat of tta memlxrr bave dm-Yadat IoHowmO heavlly'. po0tltitiod
cantmued the me of sumWg (gn sc
nhthlrd
reposU to wc peope eapernce .. geVRs adverae.naflmor to redao-
raat adado tcntuodng adittlog
ageaK Theae ageals.may be addcd
m nw vegenlNes and rrvils it res
tamaata to keep them Ioodng besh
Tbey.an alao used as.pressrvdher
r seme pa<laged foods, al¢okbne
keraagea atd rrttmaatknn
. Tbe podem wltb aulfiUdg agema
r red, hin n mly arfecu a oru11!seg-
ed of the pp(Wdra Yod peqye
- •mean toonone these.eebblanate.ratt-
.•: 4. bm aume Indladoala appear to
baee a apetiat.senoUrdy to Ihem.
. Yod of the known eases of advene
racWns IosalHtes have occurtM te
mtkmaUO, but there hive dsR IXre
a few reports a rr.rtrom m peopk
•ttbm known hleloryY of asibma
The evR seglrent'of the populatiat
alMlepnEle to ilm.- proNem has not
yettema identifkd'and researcb w
ao1RWg agents it coalmumg
The leameg 1rWe amotlanan m
'Sdentmb have ahown; hoererer..
doeat mt makeai~nmoK daner fr..
P~~ual~y ne dighutym0elrper tnN ..~,-'
centainen or pmsne bags so Ihat II
doern t get wet when the in starta
to ma1L
If you're earrying hamburgera
or other raw meat for a cookout,
tbey should go Into the rookr, but
keey:Ihem, seW nte Ovm tke otbar
toodi Uncooked me~ss rneuln re
lanvely IareFnumOen d Eaeta-
rm, rane a.kicb could be karm-
tu1. Tke rnmmm~ food poiwoln8
..type. .n srwn.~ to beat, aoeookm[ wiH! kW thdn, makfng the
me.t rafe to eat These baeterla
ean caure probleate.. howererr SI
tAey eoouminate uttxr.taodr qda. s.WL wwcb ao0't rec< MrrFe
ther, eooking belgra fkey pre
.atea t, r
tre the Arsoelatrtl has recam.d mended ta.ils membea).However.
dmcee some rdtamwle are sUHuttn`silRtq aahmauca m otberf
whe ronpect that they may be aeaw-
flve.m theae agents ahouW, ask be•
foro ordemg, In a resamant
.kether aoy'a the foods. on the
menu kave Deeo tnated ~witk them.
P.a'arls are trrng made to provide
wnHm warnmgR m rmamnnlas
where stttttting ageats an med
(thtougb ppeled sgtu or menu oo-
tkes)..twt sfnee thu must be donr o0
a ttate by, etate bttas, nltxr tham
tbough atedera1 regulatory actioqsxh eoucea may rot yet be posted m.s
mme anua Indi!MuaL+ wm are.
ferwlm to1WFtes should ioqulree
ahoutthem.ntherthandependingoa
wtittenwarmngrs f7bu artide was Nsf yulJisbid toNe.A6N News A Vleen a PuDGea-fAx of Iqe ,-Maencan
Catmcil an 6o-
I 'aOdStaleh)i
lar foodl wiohouf mayun»sise be•
cauue arid totlie mayosloweo the
8rowW d'the becteru that uus.
foed pouonong.
Ar.eording lo lend he Americae
en~ce eR-aTth-.T-o
~ nt n'eP.oi nib8.
the buie rule u m keep hot fooda
hot and eald foods cotd.: Prri.linble
foods Iwich orwithaut eyonnaier)
y na be rek to eet7f they' h'ove.
Aeen held at t<mpentune d 60'.
drg~ees PahrenheiM1 h[ghe for
Uun three or four houn.
Une practiral way to keep foods
safe for a summer p~cnie i. to~ keep.,
them ~in a cmler with itt or com-
mal nusahle mld yeclu untd it
ie time to eat'.them.
n
:' JUN 28 195 ; ~ EcA
., A009 ~'A10~
.:.. at7t •.-•.
~
He~~ thier barbecue: Don't letYat drip on coals
. A_
, .; ]lo~r t6a~patid barbecun are becomiot re0d'm tatdow.ntuab•tligfafetT _.,'.
.,
tl~ ffom tke Atoerinn Coaodl ee S{l~~d HeaiY mkn ae added aipY6- . eaxe: To avad traaes
dtaoter,ramiotsiYarceg m tfimeml-Rtlkd..
. mrats, qmtiao the tvab ao that fat from coekret meat eaonot dr'ry.m them. -
.. '.: one aulutide Plate.a barrier nck n alotmeim IW berwem the mat and, the
' eak Tbe mbdancn in qagetiou are hut prodsN be the hookigt protrst pe .. ae; thry are formed whm
tal tramtbe meat etipe mlokot co.8 agd r
tLereb~ 8mrrraling mote that
. renvattd, ooaiiga Ikem. ., a
. : r v ( ••:. .. ~R .
.,-
~ TeE csses arv s[e
MaH 27 1985)A
_ 1MSAS Gtt, ro.:. ~.tet 2 7gtLyl
~ 1
T
Table tidbits
11at1reS Ch1ic
nrynolgwtoDet?5fart..
dd Gr eating yoqwt,ba Tne
WrWMS4d tLey po01C N
. b~eryx~.rof-simea~ns9onjrW
anntretlsssm, socm{prq esan
Oe~l wEmetle Id Rioe! wln ean7
_ Okikn.RAnd.e'sPeckedwimamw
rutriOO.W tlvraaqesaewra:.
For aawg taed+. pmlea and mua-
dee. mdli can'1,be. betl. 01e htr.a
Rer naros a. wupe, o.Ybq
mL. ra[esa atamefA upsd. bbeF
Inp, niltulence and durrlMa. T1N.
pmblanrmx an aewgrhx aa teqc
d an.uryn. omu7ls.m.. neea
"edbOqastmwanr4Eva~0eopM
'dtldtlnd
wltennkmrtil'wnenF
~! voioP a Lcme 0dkaercy oawya dder-
. I ~/bve/seeanrpuoMS~heaMl
~ um patMn an0 Yiumir A aM D
_ ~i. gW.milk pmedesiTiw arsww s
.. yoqur[. fLrearch hae lawd'Itql
peuqewnunTbMkmdconlau-
' I w a>,erae,o;,k.uaeta..a nnra
- 'tbuWShrlwnwMWmtpmaGe caxw, becana dut Pmdxe due
o.n lecfase arrsyma. TM Lcta+e
. oaw.M1a lacra.. (aw tr•saaieak'i wqn Orrrs Mn1 tr6p.Y) irb AR.
pr lUpin. fYCC/1 Y gkl[ON. meI
uy eesuy elpeaea. .
The Yogurt
,
Advantage rt
yl' A~
:,t.-~.~-iaodpai.oaiugra.poadbil-
me
,.-.ar ~ ~ keg perr ~ oda~ ti k~
- -` Tke Anterican Cormcil 0~
~
'Sde:e a ea rcpotta -
~ aaso Clatr
-drese who pardeipated in an
H k d
_ader eggael cuoeowe
fum
o pooeft.
f ~
.': A.. ke.edtgrtme e tbe. ow-
~_ break shuwed that water coa
~ aBdY
_ pmetratM the e:gp
evte wrm they were camt
`-- plelel) lataet At room teID-
pe+ <ae, tke enaneil ea7s,.
.. bacteeia a an egg tan pow.
`'.a.g prodYCe the terins tbat'.
' asse food potsoaiag.
The best advice u to tlmk
d egp aa perikh.kle foo~
~et tbem d+nd'at room tam~
peraturt oo1rat the fLne. ~
tke~7e beieg dyad ttW
: deh.. ,.
or eata
Yoyut r nnn palCatla gVn
n.MbrnwRp~op1e, rrrysParrf
HdnrAd,. ph.D.. a nutrikpwl oirll
gl. ~ Ir.Sf ..J' M C.~. 1;
and rwsn.. ar am pGeea om oa
saw aus and ee~lr7e[e,gesaF
Y.~q..as rfYW a nUt.
Ewn.gd9wMgmi[.mpa? i
twntrFu..ars..ecdwrrw.ws I
kr nnke yrqt/1 tarrt a rw med .
plrn fa an riq. ra e~od or .
Yoao prr neoar. tr
aad.e. Yopa tra .n r.aoltc
dra gr qr ap.em a siety a
rodww lacterr< N 4so .orka
orwrinew
tpalrEtabrkwoporawq R
Yopn amsrew aosrsted tgKtr
8W dtleaoLL an.rpnreM naF
/egrr"salodkxlr.wW arr
mia G.:y rr Mrtrnmeon pra.
cam br..reC[ yogurl s n.0., gr
oawveatet a kkc s~ a k.
aaoa ao mum aa tarMOal.
Sar6Y auqpaR gWppR h-
ONMa me latr «/OL dtllsrnOl
in tlr bkod Tirt rtl+e rnneed
9rodikir!Gteatemi Pat Ilrnra[Y r
W re.s•Lta
F'eeer. trow t r b. In rarl~
Itrl tOQ1r1 n1rYa il aimg~. fOF
trlararl.nal.r 1v o. ae..
ana nr.y oe.n.oouoto[p.

6tBBILE• AL
APR )1 19A5:' THEMOgftE
/RESS g'EGISTER
6AT• i SUlL gLatt
; Cancer. diets spark debate -:; -_-.,:;
" B7 DQN ~~KIRRMAN Raseareh Couneil committee that rald there i.
flatppe-Harard News 6ervlw "~tttvvr "m eonehufve evidence that fiber /ooda protect
b ~% - `~-ateaneer. . . . .
' v,
1lotrgs a 6reat ded has been wrltteo 8511.1 mee.y... we may be able to prevent ..
. many as 35 pereent of a8 cases of cancer by'
.•lbe ability of foods m prevent oreaux caneer ~.
. .deeYruah'm ch'artgeyour diet, the American modflytna our die4, but that someday ia not
`-4`wncilonScienceandHealtbadvisea- now,"aaidACSH Rceeutive Director
'T6s-ieisou: There iatremeedeus dia-' RNe` U Wheten.
~:-qreemeet am~g eaperta an what laoda m•;:_,,
d hlrb should be avolded -
-'-aotf<anceroua an ww
-.
.
-'Alat'a particularly true for fiber, which
allcgedty prevenu cancer o[ Ne colon Pd
q
IgcNm. J~ I
L you want to eat a high'diber cereal for
ffieakfast, that'a fine But:you should realise
.. .,
1gatYiberhasnt been proven m h'elp prevent'
, t-- y
- elutcer,•'eays Dr. Michael Parita of tlie .,. li / -
... T(nlversityy of Wisconaia'a Food Research
Irutitute. +
' Pariraa said . the recent National Cancer
Ipatitute statement'thatHber reduces cancer
'fePresents no more tltaa the opmion: of a/ew
apecrailsts, and a.lot of other esperts dfsagree.
- v-Rh t6is advtce." -
' .ihaae other experts Incfude a National
MAY 121995
~
Diet and
tanar raa ~ ~
Foo~ fo'~r
//h 2~,er...~jy+tyn
.. By WENDY GREENFIELD
' amer. ar.rr wmw
No matter what'you tell pea-
going to do
pk, theyYe likely.l
what lkey want anyway, , eape-
elally wbea it comes to eating.
Most people won't stop eating
tce cream even ahough, . it's high
In fat, nor will they stop bar-
beeuingalthoogh studies have
shown that cooking foods in that
wa) may cause cancer.
What foodss cansee cancer,
which'h ones help prevent.it.and
tt,ancer
:: -.. 01romPaget,.' •.-~.
l
y t~e bs oot eaouge scientine•ev- ldene ta give that N.ice.
Recently, two Brltish epide•
mlologists estimated that 35 per-
nntol all cancers mayhe
reLttd tothe.fooQs we eat, but
qme atlentists believe that Dg-
ln la tao ldgh- •• . Tbe debate rages 001 mainly
iecause.the datais inconclusive
aog eoqfBcHve, but also because
MfOpb are not quick mchange
~tr peraonat habils-.
~bile population atadies~Ilmtrdngeehat foods people eat
~II their Ineidence of cancer
!•gm;o-lnducate a link, smaller
6/e stud'inandlabontory ea•
~imentss in ani~mata fail to
atwup with the wmecouclu,
aeu.
ThH9 whal'i bSpeWng," says JDody G_ Herm3mn, registered
~stlUan at Memorla4 Sloan-Ket-
tering Caeeer Center.In Manhat•
tatt- "The populatlon dataseetrta
al~gestlve, hut when one looks
at:a smalller group there isnorelatiomhip Then we get kind of
stuck."
Michael W. Parira,.a 12year-
- old PhD., pr~olessor and chair•
' manr-of -the UMversesyY of
Wticonafu's Department ulFood
g6lcrobklogy and Tnricolegy, .
odnted oul these dtxrepancieslo a report he authored ory, Diet
and Cancer"' for AmFricaMn
n ea
q.nae-prn I Prganura ton.
Q sclentlsts,: considered to have
t~. conserrative tieat..
For Iratamee,Ae pointed outt
t algkoaghepideriniologtcal'
odles.tompanng, Japan to the
Ijnited States suggest a link be-
='ati
t,*tntnc tt.tano Aoirann aIARYlllAND.~
N.Y.- . p f.•JI: 9nl Maa . _
cancer:
:
ou4hh
bow strong of a link esists be-
tween diet and cancer are cur-
rentlyquestiona otheated
debate amoog the publi'c. Dhysi-
eiana,, scientists and dtetitians.
Some docmrs, scientists and
the ArAerican Carteer~ Society
recommend that p,eoplefoUow a
luw-fat„high-fiber diet and:eat
lots of cnmchy-lype vegetables
mreduce theiv, chances ol get-
ting cancer, while othen believe
(See CANCER. Page A 6,
~
Nutrition and cancer seminar
scheduled Tuesday at CSI
The Staten Lelaod Unit of
the American Cancer Society.
w111 hold a rnnderence on
. "Nutrilion, - Common Sense.
andCancer" Tuesday at the
College of Staten ialand's Sun,
nyaidecampus: .
The seminar, which, will
run from 7:30 pmto 10 p.m-,
will be held in the Williamoon
Theater- It is free and open to
'' the public. and Is co-sppnsored
hy the coltege. Advance
health reporter Wendy Greea
field will i moderatethe con•
ference, which dncludes sevenn
guest'apeakere..
Mindy Hermann; areglp-
tered dietitian, at Memorial
Sloam-Kettering Cancer Cen-
ter, will speak', on "Foods
Which May HelpPrevenrt
Cancer." Margaret M..
Gundacker, associate food
service manager for Brooklyn
and Statentsland public
. schools, will speak on "Nutrl-
n tlon forr the Adolest•eot":
Dr. Jerry Beeher, ekief gar
troenterologist at' St. Vin-
cent's Medleal Center, will
present, a talk on "Environ-.
mental Factors Influencing .
NutriUon and Camer."' Dr.
Andrew Conli: assiatant pr~y-
fessor of tnedicine at, N6w
York Medical College and as-
sociate director of inediclnee
at'.St. Vincent's Medical ICen-
ter, will talk on "Nutrltion
and the Therapeutic Modai-
Itiesft ot'Cancer.'•'
-Dr, Walter H. Rothman, at-
tending gastroenterologut at
SL' Vincent's Medical Center
and Mt.. SinaiHosputal in
Maahattan„ will speak on
"Diet andCancer." '
Mary' Kelly, chairperson of
tAe pubiiceducation cummit-
tee of the Staten dsland Unit
ofdhe American Cancer Soci-
ely, will give the weldoming
remacks.
APR' 30 1985 uNANOUSUA; N r-
,..~e~~rw,e,. ~- . MESSEMGEB -`:
Diet, cancer link is studied
•. Do opeell?< nwL e.use ar prevent pnoiie tNl'd eamg mne nov will ~
ancer'The idea fhat thy.do hav reduceaurchaneesotgettfngcolonor
tdemonthe aura of a nahonal pohty: ratal cancer, yet thies representa nn
yet' bMind tM acotra there w more tlun the opnnon of a ree
dingreernent'atmay the eaperts.on, specialioLe," Dr. Parw uid. -'A ltt.
ItWeiaae.accordlhgtothe"DleliM. of other esperta disagree wnhthu Caecer,',' publiahed Ey'the
American ~dvice• A Nabdnal Research Camtil
i
Cburcll on Scfenee .M HeaTn. INRCI.comnuttee that was forrned:
"1Le tvrtent akirmish'over G'ehrY spectftcapY to odvise the public and
fiber ls an excellent example of th'e goavnment agencies om diet and'very tentanve'rlale of the art'
In this . cancer aaid that tnere wn no
rnr~
field," aaid Dr. Mkhael W, . Pariza, elueive evidence that fiber u nncer- Prohasor and CTeirman of
the protecnve -
Department of Food Mierobfology Tooblain~ a- copy of 'Diel aM'
and Toricology; Food Raearch(]rcer;' send setf-addrerM
tute,,.
titute, University.ofWiacvnsin,.atarhped llv<entpostagei,biuiness
W ti
andaullforaftlleACStlreport: alre (No. 10)'.errvelope to fhet end'.
••7Le Natlaoal Cancer IrutihAe hncer lteport, A(SR, 47 M.pk St., ,
(NCI)',reanBy toW'the American Stmmut.N.J:0501 . . ....
ASSOCIATION TRENOS
WASH~N~op. D•C-
JUM -7 . 1985
~~ po~Rm~mTweA~ireEgr~nfnurc~ltenY pearb.
.. MYhn. re,lalingarut bMuN Ih uer~ea n~ere
t,emennc„s e.eement amme ine:aoem.
. . lpacapr.seMaSenanEreaalEAestaml%d:
Ws,eas-sve en.ebpe to D. i G-•.
: raeno.t. AeSN. ,.7 wple St:, avmnM ru1
. .. o7sm . ... ~ ~ . .. .
bmmends.that people cut theirr
lotal faC~anhke in.n hail ((rom 10.
, perceocof tat calories to 20 per-
ceat) to reduce therisk:olcolon
'i and breast cancer, as welll as
, heart disease. IThis is more
' drastic than the American,Can-
, ter Society's recommendation to
' reduce the fat calories to 30 per-
ceetb
', He also advises increased use
of cereal fibers (fromwhole
'i grains" rather than vegetables
j and fruitls),i lower use of'salted
. and pickledloods toreduce the
risk of gastrointeriinal cancer, and hypertension, and "a bit
, moreesercise only alter a
', strees test is done.and il~yoo're
noUhypertensive."'
He alsoo rectommendsa health
test fur cholesterol, which he
said should be under 200.for
adu7ts.
But here s the real question.
What do these' menn eat? -Dr, Weisburger. who is 64 andd
conclode that.there.is a lot.of-evidence that diet and4festyle
play a role in, whether you are
going to get caMer. The prob-
1em comea in when you talk
aboulspecific dietaryfactors-
"For example, try toseparateo high,•/at dleu.and problems.as-
soNated with obesity There. u~a
very real question whether a
high~ (at dierbyilself is all that
bigi
tyreeo meal and a tiigh inndeott of ahMor in lernu ol can.
Oseaat,calon•rectum andcer. People who want to reduce
le cancm - Amencam fat should do it_ But certainly the
~ ve a high..inctdence of tnex studies to date.haven't proved
dncera,.whllee the Jappnese, thatthatu.goingtoreduceyour
camcer:'
who eatt much less meal than risk of
Americam, have a low rate - a For instance, be pointslo
case atadv among Seventh D.y studoes ronttrning the Mormons
Advenluts in Calt/ornia lailed to in Utak.
. turnn up the same results-. The. ,
stutlyy revealed that meat-eating "Beef ronvumption is associ•
taid vegeurian. Sevt4uh-Day Ad• ated, with cancer, and yet'go to
tientists lwth showed a lower itr Utah. It has the highest per cap.
eidence of these cancers Ita meat consumptton and yet a
tsanparedtomastAmencamd low risk for breast and colon
"The Lsaue ta stD1 unresolved,' ~cancer.I think other factors are
PaHra uid In a telephone inter• involved," be said. refernng to
v1ew, referring mhow much'h of atudies that have shown that aa
an infl'uertte diet has on canter: lackof eaercase is closely linked
"I Wnk that one can certamly wtth rnlau cancer-
({
I
Weisburgen a bio-
1k. Jokn H.
chemist with an hononryM.D-
degree. director of the Na4lor
Dana Institute far Disease Pre•
ventlon ~ in, Valhalla,. N'.Y: dis-
agt-eea with Parita, advocating a
low-/at, high fiber dieL"
Weisburger, pointed ou4 that
studies have shown, that the Jap•
anese have a lower incldence of
hean attacks, cancen of the co-
Ioq breast' and endometrium
thando Americans. When study-
ing what theyeat, il; was found
thatmwt of their lat intake
comes from unsaturated oils
from flsh and vegetables.,whtle
In America, wnere there is
heivy, consumption of beef'and
dairy producu,most of our fat
Inhke comes from saturated
oils, Weisburgeresplained.
"ItY the latin dtet;'aaid Dr.
WlCsburger, a naure of Stutt-
gart. Germany: referringg to
many palienuwho come lor
treatment at his insGlute,
Dr. Weisbucger i Instltute rec-
~ J .
describes himselb as a smadl
man, said. "For bre fasti I have
nice howl uf A I Bratn. or
Nabisco's 100percent Bran. Thatt
gives m my, daily recnm,
mended allowance.'•
Does be eat meat?'
"Rarelyr once a week. Wee eat .
a lot.o/ soups, vegetable soups,
bean and pasta soups- We miisdifferent focds."
And wh'at does Pariza, who
ca4lsBot.dogs, bacon andsam•
sage "whodesome loods,'• advise
his wife and three daughters.tos eaC
' We try to eat ab'alanccd diet..
The basic four Joud group app
proach:. We don't. aroid any-
thing,"
MAY 15 1985
`- NDEIYSCH ONfIGLEA
- gtt71as0a22t1/
Diet and cancer , :.
Studies show, link but exact~+
nature still uncertain '
-% Do.specifie:foods canse or aecording m the ACSH
eer? The idea report. The major
em caOn
tttey.do has taken on the dLsagreemenkamong
aura of a national'policy. 7N scientists ls over whether :
.. behind the scenes there is eooa6h is knowanow m
g. tremendous di.ugreement )asti[y reeammeadmg
among'theexperts on this - dietary, ehaego,: ACSR aaya..
..
ble
ktsue, according ma new •"Someday, we may be a repoR tiUed "Diet and' -- to prevent'umamy aa IS
Cancer," published by the pereen0 of all cases af eancer
Dut
American Councd on Science by motiiEyLtg ohr diets,
and Health (ACSH), an ., that someda7is aot now,':"
independent scientific . '' said ACSH ezeentiVee
organiration. director Dr. Eliiabeth M-
'Tlie current skirmish over Whelan.. "The75 percent ~
dietary fiper iss an excellent rigttre, which was proppaa"
example of the very tentatlve by two eminent Bntuh_-.
'atate of the an' in thb eptd!mw1og uts, iti very
6eld;" said'lh. Michael W, temta:ive. Tbe seientists who
came professor ard me up with d warned that
chairman of the department it'u highly speculative aad
of food microbiologyand ' chiefly refen to dietary
msitrology; Food Research factors which are not yN
Instltute at the University, otreliably.identified,' ' he'
Wiscomin. and author of the wid.
ACSH repom.. . "At ACSH, we believe that
"The National Cancer apee Uic retroDtmendations -
Institute (NCI) recentlytold should be givettmlhe publie ,
the American public that only when there is aoffieteat -.
eating more fiber will reduce basis to expect that they will
our chances of gettmg eolon . in fact aceomplish what Is -
-,
nr recral eancer, Yet lh~iv promised; "she said. "In the
rtpresenta no more thaa tbe ease ot diet aod'caocer, I
opwon of a few specialists," dto't think we have that
Dr. Pariza said. ••A lot ol basis yet. Certalnl*. some
other espettYs disagree with lltdividtuls may wanlm
this advice. A National ~ t~ange tAeir dietv on Ne
Research Counli] !(NRC) ~ be.w of lhe correnl evWence, .
committeetlutwasformed .batanationalpoliayof__
specificaU7 to advise the dietary change ie not
public and government warranted-"^•.{ z~.
agencies on diet and canca: The American Coarae8 oa
- `
said [Aat Ihere was na Scienceand Health is an. conelusve evidence that hydependep6, oon.profit'.
fiber is cancer-protective. coruturier edncgUon
And siiB'other scientists . argantsatran promoting .
d •
contend that some types of scieotifically bal.nce. rrber work and others donY. rgluatiom d fopd.
"H you wanl to eat a Oigl>• chemicals, the enviroamerrt
fiber cereal for breaklast, apd hqlth,..
that's fine- But you should
realize that it'hasn:'t been To obtales a compllmentary,
proven tohetp yreventeopy.ot ttie repoR "Diet and
cancer," be satd. -Gnttr" xod a seH-
Evidence trom.a variety of addresud,'~ stamped (29r
sourees indicates that diet postage), budnesis-aiae and cancer.are linked, but envelope m1);et and
Cancer
the eaacl nature of the Report, AfSH. 17 Maple SL,
relationshi~pis uncertaia,. " S®mit, NJ 07901i
"
Cancer deaths
Does he eat.red nxal?'
a
Sure;, a couple nf umesa
week. And I've never even givee
a thought to it On the other
hand,: there are vegeubleson
the table_
And, he adds, "W'ereall in.ao
eacrctse program .
What's his recommendation
for the.publlC
"Dr+erstty Fating /otda IfEm
a wide vartietyy ol sources ia the
best way to miimmuuthe bad
things and rnaa+muae the good."
~~~ HEALTH
vamoose

' JUN 1985 MICN1611NFOomNEwS
. . . ~ _. 1AN51N&M}CIL
-
~ YDN(ILLr
. - ' 31;ti~i M
iet and cancer_
Don't jump to concluslons, study says
•
,
Thequnlio o(whnkeifoad'axampldo/tae.verv'tenqtrvc Scxnce.ndHaleb,weEClxe srs~' '
ean. he)p, prevenl'.'„or. evenTtateofdxan',mthisfuld:'t.ys that specific rcaommeodaGona I r N~;
ry"AlEh
eaux- wnceeapparenl m-MichlmlW:Puus.tawtwrv soua be given to tM pubhe
mains.qunndryinthesciemifi<ihe:repon 'andcAairmanofthe onlywhmlhertiasuRrnlboa
.
~'
_eommw,.,:,- ..[Iepansoentaf Food Microbio- to eapeci lhat tlrx,qiU in f
uy, act
'- The mostrasol reporton•the-logy'tndToaicology of the ~'.ccwoDiisb. what ri- prommed,
ssue i d b A h'd Rhj d'Ihf dfd ~
s vpt nsy themv.ooeseare Institute at the
sle u~,n te cae nel an
_ f eaa Counci4 eo Science a d„ Uuvenuy of Wixonun +:wrce fdonYthlnkwehwetpat
'. Heah'h, an. mdepcndenl,:aon "The Nwonal Canc<r Imy--. -basla y<t..Cenainly„kome indt €~~,f,..
-profiluiem
, f o gsnitatw ~ Nk reosnty IoW the Amencaovulwlsm.Ywaml[oehangethcu ylt~i '•.
.,..,v
;` and that mpon ad' ioa therc la a• public lhaue.ung m«elecr wdl ~ dlelr on the bnia
o6lhe:currtnt ~ra~" ' E~_ ~•
,: tremenEous d agreememl teduca our ehances of aalutg..; aWCncybulanationdpulicyof ~+i. At r
t~ amoeg the experh oe whrthe ysobs or ncW r+nrer yef thu dutarycAangeitmolwarnmed '1f;F~~'•.tis
,,~ y,y~ ,ra
.. spar6x fo p
uxods ux orI
prc4eo4 nprcxnts ne more than lhe Two Mirih'iaam Stue Univer fkl
v ., ' tanar~'~~•k •••opuionofafnrapceiahsts aayaauy xientut4 Hekn Hucaea s~'1a-a;~ ~rtTtA~ t
, ..e.r +r.f •t B t m
tkr mt reamt report Periaa. "--• „•} profcasoro(nuur.lsciena,attd
r doa ducradu maoy of the fd 'A lqt mf etberexpena' CIC Wjlitehurh
epro[euor of
.,.-'
dsels rhichnponedly'ue de-- aires rnA lhia WvKe.~A Nt palhologyand vNerinary mcd~
1•41ti1passibkintheaeatoJiesla4e'ta.e~tg aat fal~l
.,~,,.rs
ighed to prerentpqcer I4 ,'liuaal Rtiearch Councd eom• aine tervedorvthecommitttttoftnon aihei b
famon whd '•
nreneventat
~
y ,e :"rteadiu xienoisu aeem w wp- miitee that wn forpsedd'apccili ' review the mox rccent-rcpon
ti~artlki r Dtatly = y..C
easa~
..•ee smqn the public and ?~' grtat mayontF 4
question Ihat d t rTht tht
-? ponche basictheoryof eommom p1(y, to advixfhercy nope rrpor nolesa many y
tootrol n.esttgatrom iadut'ate
.-lmseaadmoddrauon.-. ',-a+?yonerhmema;eociesondinand -u pl.yiog uwrc o( i.rok
wls(utliu'anbased'onoerteHHOd that there ia aodlspntliam a
_ Evidea« Iram a varicay af:aancarsaid'lhatthwas no di.utore tAea eren vt inve.tigations bul 1h'
,ere.euc-ew,~.
ne studw, . marynalasaociatjnnbetweeo(s[, ;'purtzs ind:ieatn thas dkt aed ooncluriie endenrz that
fibcr u lhnc dars,'sap WAioehair. trays die report,.don\ hold p A-'consumptiom and ranocn of the ~
-
'.'nncer arelinkede but the exacl . datacer•protecti..e:AndtliDothar'~••'T(Lere.hn been cvidence.
foi -aveeomrolled':investigu ons. A:,,bre.at.. aolw.cuum and prm auure of IhereLlionthip is
uo-scknun a conteod tlut somee ex.mpk that Ihen and"Jkr-;;When apeufc dkta.' 'uk(h f
, ...iry Com:..aqaa ruc ss age.atrst ~.
tswnaacon a pnof fba tvorf, aodothen enmbctweenpeopkoftli/ferwl -posenu such as fN,
meal or ~.prcgnancy and the hiatory'ef
~ ~t ~an~ The mi r duag~ g Thenue hiRlier evi- :'fruiu and regetabks na invest- „bnut oamxr.®
blood nlltive.
('=; sciehoisu is ncetoerr enough 's ,•_'Someday we may be able todemed o( wnxrs but'an awful "ted
uipdepcndcn4 variables sams tobt much mafe fmp
,,., ;,ar
" l
~ enown nor tu~ jiulilyy reepm-: peesent as many aa 35 percent of lot of mislnfortnauon ba gone '
the astxiations bnween~ their "tant than the a nt of fat i a;`
.
therc- .1Ncase.ofc.naerbymad':'-
.oerM.ingdia[vychanges,tfying oul.,~ -~•.,, ,,tonsumptioo and theuncen wromaatd'ee
. ponnya... eardicu,butthusomedayuool- For.example, tharc r
u u a, `{hcy'an supposed to ioflucnce ` ~ T''}'*~~'Wg'
•'iU.isaue, notestberepott,li -~ar•.,'aafd Council Eaeeutive atudy of.the axmbels of the
aregenerallymtachneakcr,and tehalr aed tke ethet.
`-.
the magnitude of the Possibk Director Dr.,Elieabeth M.Se4<nthDayAdveatinChush,.'heocc the riak seems
much, scivntuuontheoommitarsagne. V
promota vegeterianism tmaUer: a.ys the sludy it ii very diffieult ta do ~~
keoefiu-a danare in a.aesr--. Vfhekn •73e 35 perr:eot figun' which
.
~ tbat might be derivod itom die• ":whieh was proposed byy two There were repons that the :wib'u
disturbina diaaepanry V~ ~k~~~
re rw p~ ioa for :» tary ehanges Sorve belie.e that , tmisem Bmkh epidemtologiau, '-Seventh Day
Adventssu bad a between oorrdativoal endcasr
: the bcrrefit may be large but . ts.veryrsanutive. The xkntiau much lower inodenrsof raorert
iwmrolepidemrologicdata uone m°x40 yeua _ y..~ • F~,,,,r•h 2y^?~
other spcdaliau think it man'rhorame uprith il ramed llut and they deeided this wu proo( o/ We
myornasoru whymany The oeigidaf aldfcicf c ~
.usoamotr . Ukcly lhat the benefit at Eest it `is highly .peculative and that meat wn a factor, -'
'-iiciemlisu qoestioo the wiuom.of began wim rats 40 . years .{o ~
' would bemargimal and that ~ chiefly relers to dinary fan.ois- "Well,.then they looked at the
pvittg the pnblk speeiGu: dietary rhem a tientins found'th.t nu ~..ta•'
-~
. ulher risks might be genenled_ which are ooi yet mh bly esemo- Mormons, andthey cat as much -
ad.vits basedd on wrrmt know` •on.a high fau dict tended to form ,2`'
'The eurrcnt lkirmiah orer fied. r Nr:'y t.~r.meatumyone<I buttheysttU ledge.' .~:mo tumon than thox
oi
du:ury,faber tt an-eseellens AftheAmsencanCouncdon haveksaer<enrxr s; ~ciLereponnotes forexa pk,
bwerw4oiedict,
>K+'~"..'.!ss'd.=.--...
4t tt,- K~~rA'7f.4:.' aE "!FL . z kk ,.i e!~•~'S, t Ff1' "^CI' Swyr•. d
~IAY 15 1985 ~CULUMBIA TN ; T.^~ fbr~ a
'~
~ tI7 HERAL
~ _ p,d
~ 012771 .. kL 4a~M-,,...} R.~ ,a.
iet and Cancer May Be Linked, But ~#~ ~
. ~'~;... E
Don't ChangTe YourEating Habits Yet -Y ]'i
_-- ..r..w.--.w..,-,.,~..,,i.
.= NEW YORK - Do specific ~sourees IAdilcatcs~that diet and . which are not yet re11ab1y itleti- ~~^
`--'eaaut eancerarelikedti[t tlfiedl'•-'
r.acprorer3,caoeern,u1heezace. •-.• Idea UtsT lIfey d0 Nagtaken~`daMC`yr-the'telatanshq-r- we
pel1cve that -.
_At+ACSH. oplAeauraofanatlomalpolfcy - -mecrtaln• .a[cording.to, thee specitic recommend llo s'
Yet Dehlnd Utesoenesthere ta ~5\CSH The major
'shoWd he glve te thbtl -
report.
.ne puc on
' tremendous dlsagreement ., disagreement among scientists - ly when th'erels suffictent basis'
,,
's.'y;amonB the experts on Nls issue-'-b over whetheeenough iskhown i to expul ttiat lheyI wtll m
fact
.,aceordmg to the rteww"
~Yt+. txport, , now to }ustilq. recommendlog . ucomplish: what lspromised. .,
d amd'-0anceq'• published 'dietaaychdnges.ACSHsays. - _shesaid.•'Inthecaseo/dtetand
-D f2 A (4 ~ ~
•ytnmrnr nn,n I nn • . - - ' ~- ..' ' Cancer,.! don'L think we have -.
"' Scie '•Sodae De 5ble to h
nmey; w mav . that
asis yet Cenainly; soma
~ epen en lclentt tc orgaaYza- -prevena ae many as.35 percent of Iddividuald may want to change •
~ tbm. '- ' a•+g `; L-J,. aBl cases of carto:r by modifying their diets on the . basls of the
'-•The cdrrenl gk/rmtsh ovei~ "our diets, but that somedayy is curttn0 evidence, but aa natlortal i
dlt fib
earyyer is an esccellent ex-" not now," nld ACSH Executlve policy of dietaryy ehange .Is.ttot.
. ampe
l of Ulevery , tentative Dlrector Dr.. Elizabeth M.. warranted." •
'state of the art' In, this fleld,`•' Whelan. •'The 35 percent figure,- . The American
Council un `' - qid Dr. Michael W. Parlu,.pro-whkh was proposed by two emi- Sclence and! Health', is
an In- ' teslor and edalrulan of the nent British epidemiologists• Is dependent,: tqn,proflt
consumer '
-D e p a rt m e n t o f, F o o d: very tentative. The eciemllsls educatlon, organiration V
o-
'l6iaroblologyy amdToxieology,.,,trhocatneupwlth'~Itwarnedthat moting scientllicallyy ba0anced
IFood tt•Ig mgbly npltill
Research Institute,ecuave and evaualpnsof'food, cl:rmlca6,
:. Universl0y of Wlsconsiq and ehleRyreferstodletary, (uton theenvi4vomentaadttealth .
...,
.. {
. auNor of theACSH repprt r. ;:; . i;:, • . - . . . .. ., , „
<"1'he: Nationali Cancer In-
glftute (NCU rtxenUytold the
_
~ ~ publt'c tht~t
- Americana~ ning
' Ubllld . . < ~ . . ;
moreer tv reuce our -ehances of gettJng col6n or.rec-
-' tad cancerl yet this represenis no
' more than the op,lnlonn of a few
speclallsls:" Dr. Parl:a safd.. "A
; lot of other experts disagree
;with mis sdVl[e. A Na01ona1.
Research CouneBINRCj com-
mlttee thatt was formed
, specifically toadvise thee public
and . governmen0 agenciess on
•dlet and.cancer sald that there
' was mcencluslveevldence that
fiber is cancer-pr'otective. And
~ still other aclgnt(stl contend that
aome typea of (Iber work and
othendon't:, - ' ~•-
"•f R yodwan[ fo eat a hVgli• .
flber cereal for hreakfast; that's
- flne. But you should'realize that
- N Aasn't been proven to help pre-
.",
venlcancer,"hesaid.
. Evldence from a varktyofy
'ABEROEEN.,WASH a--
WORLD
0.1a7e5i1a6g1
,,. ~_ -
N utritional foods in--moderation
still best for, anti-cancer diet
. ......IVi.'Y.. - . ._ .. ~ , . . , .. . ~ - _
PUL.UMAN- Claims that a Inaking dietaryy retommMdattons ' The ACSH t' dY.pol c out that
d1<r of certain foods wnl help arem dlsappolnted Inn mee lack ol lumping to, ronHusl n can he
preventcancer aremore often available knowledge atrout.the re-dan8erous. For enmpll,.J4 notea
wl.hfull think9ng tham x1enU01'c Iitlorbh111 of dlet and cancer. mal aa socielies devdop.~ comum•,
fact, aceoming to a wasningtonEvidenre.ltnking dfet.and ea . demands Innrrase for wen
StaOeUnlversllynutrilionlal. eer eomes lromi two klndsof er lhingss a clgaret+es and; toilet
t. rrenl,repon,.Hle Amrrl•atudles. One.ases taAor.tory,lests paper. tiung cancerlncreasear ta
Couoq'I~ Scle ee.and.Irealtn an rata and I„and me other looHOwever, It.would be wrong
endorses dielaryy recummenda- make, ob+ervattons or groups.o/ lollek.cancer to the Increased use
lYona onlyo to lhe.extenl ms0 thex people:wiMh dllferMl rating hatiits of toilet paper, even lhough
there
guldellnea mlght.help consumers
edect nulrlDOus:foods for overaltl
healm-
ACSH„ consumer educatlon
aboclallon.i emphaticaWy' states
lAat there la insuHlclent evidence
lo eslabllah, n,atlonal dletaryy
guldeHnes and modificatlons tor
all Amerleana lo follow to reduce
the rlsk of cancer. .
Dr Dean Fletcher. a WStI n
trltlan Daoresnr wiw ras.one.at
tM nvkwen ofthe study, saye
that utrltloua diet helps de eY.
nD: general goodd he lth and m rt-
fam better disease resla0ance, hut
cerlaln foods do notdlrectly com,
ba[cancer.
Fktcher adds mat'even . thosee
aclentUta rMare In favorr ol
at dllferenl'rlsk levels f eYncer.
Teats on laborato ynimals
over the last 40 yean:have: sAownn
that just aboutevery component
m a diet can, affect cancer,.pps4
tl'.velyy or negatlvely, under the
right tes4 eondltwnf. according to.
the ACSH. In other w.ords. Fletch-
says, there <M be a link
between dlef and Caneer In a
controlled ar3Hng. - Ob.eree Cbna made or peoplee
altm tho rrelatlonsbut many.
other uaoontrollable lactora 1MU-
ence. me resultt.. For esample-
observmg a canrerous pet•wn's
diet cannottake.lnwacwuntt mee
diet trom the yean preceding the
tesl;:when the cancer waa.actual• ly.devehYpyng.
(~•+.,5 u_ i:y drP z q:
.44
K Z
~ ~ ~4&
~H EALTH ~
.Z. i=s- L.
~
t -.BbF~a.icYaSA~`.t
J
•.ii'C•i1s:s
r1 ~
' a.-t 1f}~~+z:
,+-
......r a ,'$
' -•, g,U,41L1Z00 GAZEfIE
. ~a *,gALpMA30D, MILH. .
lt::a gpmf sWL 68.324
~ ~ARR 18 -1985
y } •
'. `BURRE[1E'S t'~{-. • `_
[ Diet and rancer..t
Ttiem.Aas been considerable attentton lately des'ot-
? ed to ihc relationshi~p between diet and cancer. par~, ,
tkulany theprolectlce banefits that aue supposed l0 Y hederised Erom certaln vegetables such as
bnoccoli- ~-
- r--But, says.thC Amrriran o mcllon Scrence and •
Nralth IACSHI: Itchwd the:seeminge strong support •.for a pfoper die t there remains
considerabiescientific
-debatc. . .... -.~-: . ., . ;~-.'-.
''Evidencefromaranety.ofsourceslndicalesihat ~
''dkl and cancer are linked, but lhe esacl natun ol the ~" relationship is umcertam, says theACSH,.
The nujur :
_ dingrttment amongscienlists ia whether enougfi is '
. kntm'nnow.ta.justify,recommendingdietarty-thanges. ~
_.:'3omeday we may be able wpr~ent as many as A'percent o0 al l cases of cancer by modityjng our
dleu," •
aald ACSH Executive fhrrcl,T Dr Eluabetn Whelan.
.. '
' •'tul thatsomeda•v fsn
laem eltw.
T t. reHa ch conllnues tode-
t i' Ihe.slrengthof IM corn-
latlons het.veen.diet and'cancer
Studies eompare c r with the
/atly lood.. Iresh meaC mncheon
meat, frults, .rgetablea. Ilber,
rllamw and mineral nupplements,
eof/ee,. tea and olhercaffelner tourcea; foodd addltlvea and'~me1h'd a0s of crooktng:.
Cbnelatwns have been found to -
ealtt- but FlelchM tays xldntlsta
art hesttant.toannouneet cause
andeffecl relatlonahlps whenn so
many variables are mvolved.
Until hard evldence /s IwM,
the best:recommendetton a tlnl
to, eal'nutrlllouy flwds m medera•
Udn.
r
pREENYILLE. g-L.
pIEDNPXL~~
e=
~kPR 12/-1985 ~
w ~ ~'~
Nutri~ianist
'says there uo s . ;
+;
-~e...
die ~$ncer l. '~ ~~je.
a\
•-fiu:reu stlB ndipetihe dreCTd :"p '
comhat nnoer and the best bel
ls nulrt[_tlus tvod eaoat in~ andec{
atsvu, a nutritlm es~ert a31L ti*t
CeNip: (tmt(k do ttot dtree/fy
eombat.caacer." Dr. Dean.;: :k-etl"t_
Fletcher, aa vashmgtom Staft : _,.~
Unneruty nu[ntton ptwftxaor a''-
nld Thursday 'Bw a nut7ltiwu
dlet hNp: develop gdrerat good '
heJHh altd• IlterE orc, betlar d~
t4setuWaltee
~Flelchel (evte`Wed ateces
Ameripn Camlcil, an Scietce als1:
fn ~
tecanurlrsdatkni--
'±rLei had ev/deooe 4 tmud, ~rv
s
he gaId, "the best eecommmd.-s °-
titq N flW to eataslQ~tiwa loodd
Y moderatitn.^ :_- C:Xyyr i
Evesadeulsra vln (.varttsak '. ~
ng. diexaryrecotnmadatfltru are
dtsappotmed a theJsck 90C avaiF ~-
abledata ayout the relatlanship
of dlet and dnoer. he aald.
,-_+•The proWem k reati a. bsboo
.'
ratory an~imals over the laat 10
yeyn have skewn mat yvtrt alsua4' ,-
erery' lwtrlputeatt a a diet nn af -~
(ectcanaer.poslHrNyorseg.. ^
ttvety, wder tnerfght tex capdi• <_';
tioms••' nid ~Flalelxr, a
Nlfonal he.
lnh report. ira
The ACFLS statdy pamu eut tlrs i•
jumping te eonemslens an ba.''
daugimwa• It note that:whllean '~
increase./a consumer demanda `
ram such: things as ctgarettes nd. .
to1lK pperon occur alpng with
='
an stcsease as lung cances, they .
aren'rneCenanlylm4el.
- "Nowerer, st would ne ~rnsrg -_'
to Itnk ancerio the moreaxd .
use of totkt pper, eren though
there is a oprsetatkn•" ihe antly
, rartu-
Studtes compare uncer Ith ~'
the fatty foa1, freslt meart luttch-
eon meat;.frutts, vegeeablea f~-
ftber. viumial and mioerallup- ~g
plemenu, eoffee, tea and other
nlfesne snttrces, fswd addatrvea
and IlNthok IN tzoktrtg, .. ,a~
"Correfatwtu have been ftaand
10lxilt,lxrtlCkrttuulnhelN e?
tam toannmmoe cause and effect
.
relattonshq s rfien so many rart-
ables are 4rYolye¢:.xfleteher
saro . -_.
~
Report examurtes iniormf~q2~ n on ~diet and'cmndar
Does ea[ing too mucA:fa[ ause'tanretr! Gn a e.et neAl in (ruiu .-%
vegeubles.andf'berpzeventRhedlsease?. ,- -, , .
Whule.many people belteve.the answer do both qiestions Is
smemists haven't proven it yet• aeeonding toa reporn tined'•DPet and.
Cancer;"published by the American Councilon Scicnce and Hntth. -
The report esammes th<T'va,TPoTinSommat+ona7 otet an cancer
and aoncludes that there ts'msuffrlemt evideuae " t: a Ank between '
lne.lw.o.. - -_ „ -
"Someday: we may be able io prevent as manv a-. 3~ percent of all
cases of uncer:by'modiUy'ina our dirta, bul that sont :ay is not non;^' says ACSH eeeculi0e director
frr FIS,.4•e v._r;,tji6_ "•„{r ,
ACSH we heLeve.that specifiRe [dteuryl recomrtr.enr m:ons shouJd beb
given lo the pcMic only.when Ihere is sufficunt baefs tu exprct tluruey will ia fact xccomphsh what
Is nromiscd.
"In the ca+.^ of diet and canaer, t don:'t thick w- have.thal basu yet. Cerlainly saate individuals
may wanl la change heil diets On t]e
ba s of the crrenl evWence. but a national pohq or dieurv.chanage
isnotwvrantrl:"-
The ACSH is .n independent. non-profrt consue sr.educaticn . r.
ganiratlon cotaposed of sclendist 1 Y\er ne.. a:rolS.the naPNa. .
The grpup sa95lt promoter^scenrf sl-ybalanaef evatwtiyns of
h A dh
IOnd. C emifl i.[ eenMnnmMl neellA.. .+
For a freetopy'ofthe report"Diet and Canar,- xnd a setl•addressed, busintss:envelope stamped with:
39.ccnt, postaZe wlbet'.
andCancer Repofl• ACSH, <7 Maple St.. Sumnit, N_, 07901. •"
~ . . _ . • ~ . . .
~4
.
: ~ '.:H EAITH ~ ~
-5
. .. ..... : y .. ~ . . ,..df ?r`-
~

t
, j..
-~ c '
IN9 a85
ND
Y
. S
I
l Nf
I
tMES
I
A
Ame a15"
Editorially Speaking
EDITOp
The drowning season
is upon us
'lberewas aa staryy from Gary.
Tnd, about five children wbodied
.: when they could not climb the slimy
walls of an yet ttnopetted:municipal
awimming poob. Thestorye iss a
horrifying reminder that the
drowning season is upon tn:
- If reasonable precautions aretaken, though, dranming season can
be ntade atatisnomer,
Advise on the matter is readily
available, and VayWert'is fortunate
. to have' the AmbncenRed (koss.,
They' aree a good source foS/water
safety tips and the American
Ctlupcil onSci'eoeeaftd Health (1995
'BroadwaY, New' Yottt, N.Y., 10D2:4>
SU'RvIvIrsuG SUMMER
has ilrst LSs[fed a Irseltll flyeZ 6n 1De
subjecC
Among other things the Cafndl .,
makes these basic points: -learn to
stwa so that you can survive...in an
emergency; don't swim in ln-
supervised areas; d8rt't swim alone; .
know you limitations; don't swim in
ttagupervised areas; don't swim if
y.u ve been drinking alcoholic
beverages; stay out of ttiun-
tierstorrns- don't dive in shallaw.ar
unfafniliarwaters.
Nothing •uotic there, just good '
aetlse. Which if used may be Yhe
difference between life or death. ." _.
=Accidents preventable, experts aqree, "'if you exercise caution
Satnmertime. aad lhe hut: u sut eomeruw safety meaurn eaa •neep out'of the water duelo( ' pnaee
namoen nif pool rules. Wnu: ..
eory. 7*e fitLa.re turnPri: aed the be uken ad'deNees parcbasM to, arvaderstwne.. pon tauo ~ . g
pusnia8. ~.ve th'e water rheeked aad
tvaon u hfult. Yosr daddYa rrirh and red.ce sammertahe rislu auhennttat'. e Flotahon devtees can lad
ta. approved by the local health dep.n-" aean maY Pond /aakra'.' Soq oRrrnofidence. Doe't ru
korsePlaY, 81sa m sharp obleru asar
telituu an the POOL me r
Aar!'. attie tnba: dwt ..yo. sr9. lbaorlag N a compilMtoa of lolor- ' au eattren or ldeeetuee far
n~ter . L'alesthe telephone M cordlms.. re noan dlvlee
the •BewIteardl,
autbe f[om e min8 abthtfdoe't use it wtldeyoeare m
By ROBIM' LICHTENSTEIN ' rfudiot the erican Cuuneil on • Doot swim, nmr tlBWng twvds arf wata. H
tae phooe e droppeA, Itra puia ad securel Lanchotedt are weu
fert sntv 'mee phttorma otee a xrwus elenrreal shocL y -
Iloa 1'~. afety.Coaad to Ctlleago,. pan't hYPe.enlHae before •Pest emergeeeY tmencnoaa-
TTeotae dermatalo8tat Gabrtel F. awlmmmgder water. HYpm'eah' 'A aew "pool al7rm" desig,ad to phoae
oumber, aod'LeKkrul!>:
Sum~~U . -8uardd agaiM dro+ma8s a a llahle Safely al the
h.Ik1W6q'c~ak a iao the hrp llID< vl m a INe dtw le>fly im SeYllb adLwrencenik aNMgtW yrioe ea
maoul'awfuspo frmmaemwgtomPrudtMaofCOmeet-: .S.imm in areu superrlsed by
eb Yetroaiowaa
Ap
ad tveoalactouLL
.. . ..,
B
. teut. 7ne.e de.ke. whiah rwu ahout
tl11 yaar flogenfp rarWel
Bu4ahmmenimeaboY Wetlmelo SafrlY fsr traol eweers:8La operales. o w mmtion M
.
.
'
-
- • peemft ayoae to awim . ie edloaahle sa ce
h
aprd alarmrests
~
SWAMllrtO SBtetV ~•er
aaerrY. nutaom alwrsa arr+e,. ae -
raele mCat aCeldeaY tafe oteu! ~ ' )onr. P^n a.n,c.,auu ne.er ,o.~ . te thr watM wltam lary'teaee at
aurine the rMtimer aroalm ate.lae- •leaa re awtm wea eaoueh to rLfld ueatumded'tn or amr. the
poal', ponNide_ wTea a cedd tuls um the
~Mpk wrvr.e m oe ..rer au ma aa
000 people dtbwo amually amerBaeY.
About 7
.
lo the United States, andd neany twe • Don't awim abne. .aa namwlne
„wha
tkhUa of the.kuw eever lateoded aeen e u~+Per•ixd areas
to go lue the tvaer. the Aaaisted' rou ir verttred weea yoo're
hraa reported receeUyPeopfe fau °Y~rDr
mte the waer from dacaa, hridga Wnae Ine a f6N.dotset aule
andshorea They'ate.m rar er boatrW une Akobol a tbe undenyln(
arddeet Drownlne Is thee third' unse ot maYdto.oiogs and aher
teade( ef aeeMenw deat! m a•Tbenu beeauae it Impws. /ude-
W a(e oapa: mem aod'coordlluttoa
JiTN 13 1985 I+L .W.. ~,lt: IH
_ ..__.~. . ".'!
--DITp/1AL
~; ~v ~Water traqe~
The:ttagiodeath of five youngsten.who became trapped:
in the. murky water of aGary mun.icipal swimming pool I
Sunday nuggests the need f r vigilance anyplace where children might comein, contact with bodies of
water.
The victims werejuut being children. Surely it wasn't the
5nt time children in the FisAenPark area had anuckk through
a holein the:fence [otry to catch frogs in the stagnant water.
Somehow, the children all fetll into the 6 feet of :rainwater in
the deep end: of the: pooi,: and weren't ablee to climb the
slippery'wells to get out of danger.. Neighb'ors.told reportenthey'd complained about that pool
for yeers.. The city should bave drained!the pool during the
off seeson or closed it altogether and rtlled it in, theysaid.
Michigan City doesri t have any outdoor municipal pools:
bttt tAere.are any number oEprivale pools.in this area. The
tragedyv in Garyy ought' to prompO anyone whoo n s a
backyard pool to consider howw secureiris.. Is there a
childp,onnf fence all the way atoundT.la.th'e gate locked when
adultsa aren't nearb'y?'
All swimmers, and all iparents of children who wilE be near
the water, should know and paw .m rhr.se tipsfnn safe
awimming suggested.by the American Council bn Science and
Hea6th::
1. Learn to swim welt enough so.tAatyou can survive in
the water in anrmergency.. ' -
2: Don't atvim ,in unsupervised areas- 3! Dori t swimm alone, or.when the.unly.other people inn the
water ere mmrs-swimmen
4. Knoww your limitations. Remember, youu won't be able to
nwim as well when y-ou ere tired or overheated.
5: Dori t swimm if you've been dnnkling alcoh'olic.beveragee.
6.: Stay out of the water duringg thunderstorms.
7. Dori t dive in ehallowor unfamiliar waten..
8.: Don't place too much confidence on flotation devices
(i.e., an inner tube). These crutches are no substitute for
ew•imming abilitv.. -9. Stay a safe distance away from diving b'oards, platforms
And floats.
10. Don't hypenantil'ete before sw-imming underwater.
None of the children who drow.ned in, theGary.p;oo1 knew
howtosw.im.Thebestdefenseparentsrenuu.is.togivetheir .
children competent switmmingg instructionet an early'ege.
HEALTH
AUT1er1Caf1 •
CMoucn^ctl
N I .lt..e
~
' f •ed. and thattae (ate has bct.
aClearly' mar.k deep ad shalb,a
'parta n[ teePOOL
U you Plaarwlar Pnol
aorer..remove it completely before
uiog the pooL Unroverieg )he pool
partiall).basled La several accideMs
m whiee people surfared uoddr the
eover .nd~Mdrnweea
• Pnt aen<v inelructbns, tele'
;. JU~Na 13 1985
~ ...'~
pool, the waves from Nb imWet set
aff the alarm Fon moreltlldrma[ia,
call 21261n,4010..
Safely al the.ao.d and Yvimmidg
Nle .
Yark off.safe hmmm( areaa
wHa Ipulayybdlines
Rerowe underwater debrb sueh
aa balles ad cans Irom uwlmmlag
a Dont srim.m iareu near needs'
[5afe summer
A few swimming tips
can help avoid tragedy
ayKIMMNYDLEBROOKS
avwnr aeaw.wr
For.many Easit Tentsseate; sumuner vat'atidns wmddntt
be the same.wilnout'~sw.msmmgaM ot:her.wat . spons.
Tho'e m meeume activities,% hov+ever, can kad to 1sa-
gedY if satety,preeautnns are nat followed
' Tennessee Valley Authonty.figurts show there have hten
two accdental dinwnmgs at. Fort Loudnum lake thayear
and three m~ 19a1. ..
~Rtere e no ~reason. whyeverytxlesheuwni he aale tdo
learn how'to swlm and fdlow prqzr vfety' prerautior6,'
yid Vim, StlYUa sifely, drtectar for the beal Amencan aed
Cros rhaplee. Free sw.imming.g prograrta are offered byy theitea er~, shr saa
Silvts recommerded a8ahst tliving'. m stnnge plat'es andtited the:xridenW death ar Ll-yfar-old
Christopher Ertsley:
wnodrowned Sunday alter hebetame entangled in branches
atan unram,har spR on Norrtis Iake
The Am,vtcan Counril &Scirnrc. and Healch offen these
aealth'ia '1J ety t,ps. or your wmvner vxalwa
' . , Swlmmieg Peat Owaen ..
t. Never perma anyone to svnm io your pool 1ame, and .erlraw... .luhl unattenddd in the pool area
~vz Make s„rethat the poa: at adeqwley retred ann that.
the gate has a lak when rat'in trse.
1Pva e,merp,enry: irstrwct,ors, e,ne,er.y trlephane
nambers.and poa rules.
L: Mark the deep., and khaltnwvctqns c4arly. `
3. Don, allbw.rummna, pusaina or horsepia~. ,
i. Make sure that tMwater1nltlratunn syst and eMmt-
al treaumenl of pool water an aderam
7: Oont allow-peaMe re•letryt twtlllra gtMasrs eraarPr uhlects mt- p-.-
a. tf you have.one of tne. new uan yarenl soWr pool cov-
ers, rernove d campletey hefore usingal6e pool.
9. Dont rc~he tekphone if you zrein the pool. If you
drbp the pho , the w.ater, yo,u caJd get a senas ele<trical i
aiwck
la aead ard follow the to ups ror.vfe awimming
Pands asd swllnmieg hMes .
1: Mark Nf safe sw,mmmg, areas wM1h buoyed hnrsL Remuve.underwater debra, such az bottlas and rars,
n'dnswmm+ng areas
1. Don't uu a'reas. nean rteeply sbqed banks- 4. Poea w rn ng s,grtt in dangernus areas where people
YwuW nat swmu
S..Have. the wate- ch:cked:and approved by lheadcal
health depanmenc
6 Make sure that lbats, di.mg boards.piers and sanilir
rervctures are.wet-built and setvtely arrhbreLL
7. , Pest'emergency instrvcuons, emergeMy' teiephwar
namaers and mks toe the swtmmit~g area:
i Read'and fdlbw the Idups far aafe swvpntin8:
LSwim, inaneasauperv.W bY'lifeguarsta.
2 Dont kavt cluldren unitrende4
1 If you grl'rmyht in a currenC swen wilh it 1xs diagorul-
q arrna n uatif you ramget free or <all1f4r hrlp.
4. If you want ta try a Img-distarre ss,eri, swon paraON
ard elare tu the skore.
y, Lbn1 use breakable o6iects on the beacA
l Dont' mterterr vnth' periormance.or the Idrguartta
7. Pead ad nM- Uw le, npa far ofe rw~mrwra.
1t
LILeBUaNs.
. Dun;t Inve:eMldree umaneadei erfmp. aeemEm( m the A49L
a u a weaward ia oo dan. ~
tu.e.e.. UyouYt aola8 to eaen' '
.U you eet uaear la.a curreel. ..
swim with A or dugonaHY.arrrmt n eYe rery - temely. or d~ yonrc ie
unW you caa eet free w s'W far help. Iroor Ph9skal tvnddioq rou maY Dnn't attempt sm swtm a8alnst m
eaPerir°ee aome daomturt °1a --
•DurinB beedismace swtmmia8.. Nu .am uotd your mnln dt(ealel
- awim paralktaad dae aoueh~to the Soa eapame shouWnan smad ,.
alme so y~~ nn reaeh n e~sdy. aad lutreasr (radttWy. Suaaereem • Dout hteakabk oD/ects w aharlldbe
apptrdd atnut 45 miovlb.
tae Ircuh: before goia( ou aud perrodioHy.
• Dunt dratt and drl.e a boat wEilr mtlie wu '
lfmM„M at leart 70 peRlnr af W e aaaYpF aunarrela at14 rMae .
Oroung accidentr aad fattlGtia eesun econtiyued! on DD4, ookrnn t(": .
from drmking hi/e rkiPPrrmN.,ac
: RNIOXYILI.E la
JOONNAL
e an xro
10 tips for safe swimming
1.1 Learn to swRn well bnouqh so that you cen aurvive
In~ the waler in an emergency, .. .
2. Don't swim,in unsuperdsed areas..
3: Don'1 awim alone. and don'tswirn wlten tlne only
other people in thewaler are.nonsvnmmers-TfkMr
presencae mtght'seem reassusinq. but ttNYf arould be of
IiAlle help itt an enler9enCy..
4: Know your limulatlons. Don'A overestithate your aEi,
li6y. And don't forget that your abllity to swmtt may no4
be up 10 par underaorne cvcumstances, sucei as wnen
you are tired or overtieated.
5. Don't swim if you've been drvtkinq akohdicc tlevar-
ages.
6. Stay out of the water during.ttNrrWaratartma. .
7: Don't dive In shallow or un/anNiar waters..
6: Flotatiwtdevices can kadlo overconfidrawa. Don'1
sUbslinutaan air mattress. inner tube, or.otfler noatir[q
obiect7obswlmnninq ability.
9. Stay a safe dlstance away Iran dndnp boartu, plat-
lorms and floats..
ld. DonY nyperventilae.eefmre sanmmerq lrttdertuater.
Hyperventeatlon can cause nsenW eonNalon rlnd werr
blackouta.
v'AN wfe~T. 0hlo ~.
11YES'60uLEnN
aaoas
aaMmB m acrieeet'pre.eellee ape,
liau at the National Safety
Caaa[iL -
• DoaR nrihe.ptaaver»tHm wna
tae ~eeua ao tertere wrW thar -
~ a perf y: way.
• We tluestm afeee ask'ed b how '
lan( to ran hetore sammut( attar
you mi U ryati re ia good health and
,mt!! am planom8 a rt8wars swt0. .
yau ahmdd UeaNe le.swtm tmmedt
atety after, enoa athuut'flertmg .

~t~, PA
0. 72,76e
APR 1.6 1'1R`
Sa/monella
Poisoning
could be
te`rrori,~ J
ti~ATE CO1LEOE~ ri'fAPi-Ter-
tMm, andno[ lu ralat! slaodard. m
.. qe dalry indusvy, apnbably tobiame
ter tbe salnwoega outbreas.mal tu.
pNauoedWd lamta aorpoholas 'people inme Hy-va
OaM,s amm toe
gmat Wumte of Food Tecanologlsb.
-we mve a real llfe detecuve rtary
.. a ac b.nda"t.ia efamted gmger,
Paataylrama State Valverauy pts
Aeor ol tdad acience. "t eadd malae
tme Nel tlun b aae persoolevolved.
vho aehbenltly msumioated a 4steh
atWlL.llhamaunedoseormlertlm
- st a. WrtenaL tultun - samrdy the
aeinaoeuarullora."
gmyu.,aso a tctemn6e aerleer.te
a oo bem idralved:iolhe
Im or IM came o/ ~tae baetenal out-
brtal mat haf kh ~aeaHy5:00a People
laflhmq Mlnhlgaa, lltaiaua.. Wirr~
W and loea 1N etm oa,aea, lever ud
~ auae •'Ne aaky Indmtryhaa ..
tee ol the best mfity recotda" of llt
ta0mrta. Ktoga said.. "r almple act
- af raodatiam^ h the maa plautlble of
ior.:4F.-
B< mncMM Ihal ••a IecnaoloprJatoalem" rnuld hare.c.med the tea-
ia-mluwtltome0ewot IaelroalltlH erter wu
mtamhuted and dnbbled mm the
mils'° tmcugh a led. baclMla caufa
baeeenteted,firogersaid
That. be lltwted,'. "b bl" ®IWe-
b:`bUeeTlr.. .
Tbe .auer trosld ban been eos
tammated eim aeme kind af mitl
-.easle hkcaaae ulmmetu umt:a
eater-groemH>>Kllria. Et sald.
Aay leak large enough..ala com-
panbk amonnts of inetammasu, to
uuae sura'aa aatbreat probably .mla .
bm t Wenarater
are been appme.s a•c of
mamlt,aragertala la a0altme, a L a kat aoald have
- been diacm'ered by now, he seld.
Tbe mdY matauers alaoeaWa ha.e
bem toslammatad: . but that tm ytoW- •
Itryrooidharetkesoorn.ered nheady.
aomplag a~alspect Yenvae Pa[raairy,.
~meean~gaton ate dlamahtahH +aa
twtlag ecnmay at the Rlllhtm
Dairytl~
mH Dm t~eu OWIhh raW aea..
arymu
.- gaeH m ~taelr amnaesrlW seurh lar
: IYr>•petlae WaaerJreb.eurta-
ree oml.mfealbah.a m e..a m-
~
hefee t afiaf lae9nllmH ~d the eoo-
1alnee~ tGtoger taid„ because the bcat
beatmiata eodd haoa tilloa the ulto-
~Mrla.
APR 29'1985
~
Chelation therapy not -
proven effective nor safe,
f~ tloo. thorapy h'as nut
been ehoeeto be bene5rial ia the .
teeaement of. angina or other
manlfsetatioa of
athaoedswia and tbe pra
eaduee em have asriaus or avtm
faeal sida d/srt., ..na Dr.
Daods Hatt/ald, rasesrch
. ...oa.a. .tch tb.~Am~.a
Seience ~e th
-npmtuus
dAG4XNe..aod 9iews.
. C'haation thvapy. which in-
.aMes.tha .dminiatr.HCa wL a
mbaaou hich binds~ th
metaL in the bldod aod fs them
anated by' the Iddaays, I. aP
. prtmd by th. Food od fJrttg
Adntinistration IFDAI) tur the
trsetm.nt of lead poi.oning..
Hawaver• it also fs beittg pro'
moted for y onapproved
oaes,. particulaly the traatmmt
of .eh.oseleow. Some ptos motere rl.lm it Is a viaM.
a1t.<native to wroaary Eypwo.
sargary. About'1.000 dinic. m
practiti- M. admiaiatsiog
tdtslatiou tltwspy in t- E.t~S',
and'ebaut350,000
have.umdsgooechdaioather
apy. ACSH nportw
•No perwacve widm hmm
ptop.rly controll.d studi.s . bae
eatablish!ed that't cheletion
Nerapy' nlievsa .ymptams ot
WONa." Dr. Hatfield
said• 'On the other h.nd, thae u
alirming Mdew atiout the
praudtue'a ndta FaF matance,
- 13 tisaNas m vrred over . t.o-
. yaar period from eb.lation
tbsspyy sdmioi.ter.f et a rLoic
In lauirau. Deaths aleo haw
ba- r.partea alaanh.R and
maey I.wault. ha.e beea
broaght agaiostt chalation
therapy pra tttionca by p~
tienW who ooNered .eriou~.ide
effeeu:"
9avm hypaglywmi., nnal
/siluo.,=
cvngastive hevt failure,
afrdte and: di.beeie mmplirr
tfoes m .mmg tha sertuua
adverw~ atfects ~ that bave bem
stfribut.d to chelatioa threpy.
ACSH ray.
"A nwch tome toddioua, butno. Ieas reeL' bazaed of chdstiw
therspy' ia ttiat some_ patkom'
camplats belief in ita h.Wag
power. pr.vsnts them, . from
aeek'ing ventinnal tkenpiea
hich codd'tie of mdv.lua,"
vaid ACSH Esatvtivn.Directcr
De. Elirabeth M.. Whd.n. "Some
promoten ot ehalatioo therapy' .
rlaitn ttcaacure a widee ariety of
' 7ente,. c just
athesosdvaais• inn some of tb.ee
ease.,. tEis tvuld lead patienta en
aub.tituta m ineffectivs therapy
far m effeetirvs aoa, trlth 1aa-
MARI23 1995 ., LEWOSrott,kwftr
- ~ -~ . . _s . .. f JOURNAL AsPirin-Reye snydromE Bit tk_ studied
fEdlfor'a Note: 7he'Annerfcan Councif on r-"'
Scietttt and'Heatt6'erocently publishid a rc-
port :vttiffed "Reye Syndrome - Questiom
aod Amwers." 7riis, the Iasthalfof the
tevpert seriea, explorea tAe.eausd d(feye
{ydrvme• - 1 ; . •
. By CATHY B. POPESCSJ, MS :
. Amerf an fo •n il on,e,.3•Y
, ~rlenee A filallh . 1l
- Wl.at causes Reye syndromel,
b k R
It nott yetnown what catueseye
'syndrome, altliough there are manyl~y-
. ~ polltesea. Reye syndrome almoa Invariably fol-
~
- lows a minor viral nfecuon, suggesting
that virtutes are somehow involved in
`: fhitiating thee patbological changes of
' Reye syndrome. [nflueru.a typr.B infee-
`'dbn and chickenpoxarethe illnesses
- uuost likely to precede Reye syndrome..
InDuettzaa type. A. Infection andd gas-
treenteritia are alio associated with
Reye. syndrome, although lese fre-
qwently..Other virall infections have, on
.- occastwt, beea linked to lteye s.yn-
- dranre. There.aree some reportas which
hii
. auggest tat live.vrus vaccnea may be
. aasociated, elthough rarely;,with Reye
. syndrome.
' The overwhedming majority of chi1-
.dren who acqWireauch viral infections
do not develop Reyee ayndrome; how+
. ever, indicating that another factor tor
factorsl'l must also be
present for Ihe_ Wness to occur. It.appears that'manydlfferenCco-factona.may tie invoUved in.
-Heye syndrome andAhat the illness isthe rlsult ot a number of different ptroc-
esses whieh cattse a common metabolic
derangement.
. ,
What have eontrolaed studles indicated
boul the relatfUn of aspirin atd Reye.
. ayndromei
The first controlled investiga'ti,on of the
relation between saltcy1ales and Reye.
syntlrome.was reported in 1980.
Seven Arizonaschoolchildden who de-
veloped Reye syndrome following in
' Duenza A' infection 1the. c seslwere
' compared with siaeen classmates who.
alsa had symptoma ofinflue.nza but did
not develop.Reye syndrome Ithe tron-
trolsl- Parentss of casess and controlss
were qwestioned regarding symptomsand the types and quantities of:medica-
f tion t8ken by their children. -
Reye syndrome patients took the
-. eame number of n sali¢ylate con,
' taining medications during their antece•
= dent illness as did eontrols- AII . e
Reyesy dromecases, howeve . had'
. . taken medtcahon containing salicylates
durin~g their antecedent illness. com-
paqedtoonly iHhtof'teencontrols-
' a stattsti lly svgnifi a t d'ff rence.
Since more Reye synd2omepatients
the viral illness, medicationa taken.dur, -received higher dases at aapirin than did
Ing the viral illness, dietary history and eontrol'l children wtio took aspprim, at-
other factorss of interest was obtained though the amounts takm generally tftd
from parents of cases and eontrols.. ttot exceed the recommended dosa.g
Children who developed Reye syn- Do these studies provethat aspiri.
dronte we emorelikely to have re- es ReyesyndromeT ' -
ceived medication containing salicy- No. When an association be•tween a ftee--
Iwt-squring their viral illness than weree tor and an Illness iA de.motsstratede ia
controls.. This was true even when cases ortlyy a faev, atudies, this does not eottsti-
and controls were matched according to tute proof that tha.faetbr catue ehe ill-
tever. ness. While the associabnna onsefved f0
Children who developed Reye syn-Ihese studiea ptnovide a strong Wsis far
drome werelesslikely to have takenn au5pecting that.aspirin producta may
cetaminophen, although a significanlt contribute to the developtttent of Reye
differencee was not detectable when syndrome, more researchis Iteeded to
cases and controls were matched for t•uufYrmor.refute this hypothesis. ,
fever. CYitics have noted naws in eae4 of the
Duringthewinteroflfato-ls8l,another ease:control studies which tn:ght have
studywasy undhrtaken in Michigan tnbiased', their findings- Such triases, or
examine mesedifferences more elosely systemauc errors, could result in a spu-Tw.elve school age
children with Reyee riow or artifically inflated assocv'ationn
syndrome . and their matched controls betweensalicylat!-use and Reye syo-
rc sludiied:All 12 childre with Reye drome- -.
syndrome had received' medications Among ttieDaws cited are:',
cog tafiting asp- in while less than half Sejecttoo biAs. Sin.ce Reye syndrome
of the eontrols. lall matctied4or fever/as defined on the basis of clinical find-
did. Again, children with Reye syn- ings in all four casecuntrol sttrdies. pa-
- drome were s g ficantly'Iess likely to tienis v-ith mild,. less reeognir bie
have received scetaminophen than torrns of the disease may have unAer-
'• 'had feveand since.parents might beereeontrols.. - ,rapresemed.. --
mores lik ty to g Ive aspt ntn to chi Idren -~•ITee most recently reported case~on-~ ~- Errors
c~oild reeuntrorn atudying ~
- wlth a fever the i vestigators com- trG1'studyy included9TReye syndrome the more serious formx of
Reye syn-
.
..
- pared the salicydale eurtsumption of just
those cases and controlss who had fever...
-" All five Reyee syndrome cases who had
' fever took salicy1ates; whilenane orthe
`' controllchildren with fever did-again,
-a significanrdifferencet
inIB82, three additional case<ontrol
=shtdies weree reported. One study i' cluded 25 cases of Reye syndrome which
..-occurred among school age children in
Michigan during the winter oUlws-tseo.
. Controls were selected from a llsc of
_ ehildren from the patient's school.grade
. who were absent at approx tmately.the.
same time as thee patientaexperience
... Iheirantecedent vical illness.. Controls w e matched according to
;year of birthTrace, school'grade and
nature of'the presumed'viral tillness. Ih-
fnrmation concerning characteristics of
manmt dtlnabt'L'by or ev® deatE .-
O a rmu1L"
ACSH ootas cE.latioo tberapy - an be very atpewivs. "A omvas
of ehelation th< spy may' begin
trlth a battery'y of tests coeting
mon than H1,000.'• Dr. HatGdd
aaid' 'Ttie trrttnect itself typ-
Wlly eanalats ot 30 to 40
.es-
aions costing ehout $75 each.
-Ths overW coet may aseeed-'
14.000. : ChkLUon ehenpy ob-
vlouely, is not a ch'eap alterwtivea
to mthodbx medidne. a. m.ey.ot Its wppmrtere eLim.•,
TW Am.riem Couocilongdeon aodHealth:. la an ie-
dep.ndmt,
ooaprofit rao.umar
education gsaitation pro-
moting ecieotificalyy bala;n.ad
ersluetiooa of food: rhemie.4r,.
the envusommt aad 4selth
Copiw of ACSf7 A'e.e aed
t•inee can bs obtai>lad trom
ACSH. 47, M.ple St. 9ttmmi4
NJ.07HO1•
12
cases reported in Ohio from.Decemtier drome, if,, for example, salicylate
tmsthrough March' 1980' and their acted to.tnerease.the severity of symp-
match'ed controla:. Medicalions con- toms. Thua, Reye syndootnc would be
taining aspirin wereused morefre- more likely too bedelected among t3W-
.
quentlyy by cases t9r pereentl: than by ttren who had taken aspirin. In addition.
controls t7t percentry during the viral physicians may have.been more likely
illness. to diagnose Reye syndrom m patients The only other medication for which who had taken
aspinn„due tn pttblioty
there was adi'fferencein usage by cases about a possihle association between thee
and controlss w.s acetaminophen- Sig- two. Ineittier rase, salicylate expostua
nificantly, fewer cases (t6; pereent) tmk would heover-represented in Reye syo-
medications containing ace
.taminophen _ drome cases. -_
than did controlst3d'percentl: Conversely; selection•af-eases based
. A statistical model.used tocontrot for on symptomatology, alone may have re-
the presencee of feveri headache and sultedin the misidentircation of other
sone, lhroat indicated that',childzen wtioo diseases as Reye syndeame. This would
received aspirih had! an eleven-fold have weakened... rather thanetrength-
greater risk of developing Reyee syn- ened, the ob'served as_wciadatt of aspi-
-
drome than did children who did not re- rfn ~with. Reye ayntinome
ceiveaspirin.Reyesyndromecases.alao Ctaliauedoo, Pasel7
JVJAY~ la1985 ... ~ ~ BOSTON. MA~ _ -. .~.
HERALO~ .
.. . . . ~.: ..- ~..
- -.C]/7,561 SVN„280,774
_ - -.. -,
~~ uc;st nac
~. .
r50-UP I Surgeon General recomlmendt drug be avoided
Aspirin use for young kids is suspect
. By Nan Car/eton ~
I
DEAR NAN:1 got the acare ot my The Amenean ;,;; ~„itioa ta.yra,aet Q-
ure lut.monu rnen f g ve m6. Couneit~ on a.d twa..resia to the aaur
Hraodd.arkter t sta, b.ll. a .• oslama8otceverleaaweo/>a.w
.anplftn.tlwas0shyshn l,etaa•e Science and .. . N+raerylettr.casbea srt..'
Ov parente eork,.andsbebad a tAe su'rpper- Sae uilt sae rae
Iwat w,th the na / Aea.vralne b Health has .- q.r.tlae.or~.a.e~arltet.,~ae
mlaauahle p11nInlhLteltaa.- fefAewor/peup7cPriletoNeesna. 1.. mr noN0.1 area u rar a -~. mro
°f fak ButeaNrretd, Or
PrePared
.. ye.re a In .d. 1 ot my aaet.r -. RerotL Hqaaras
aTOataa. rYa.
, _:
wnromyw hlld nhedRrlppr brochure on aF1K
.. Plra.e teR M tand e.an,. the .,
n..
i~.aatherweSllearrandm..lthe, sub'eet of Reye'S
qteet an Bry~e'e ayedrnme aaaJ ..
asplHi- BabyslltluR Grandma
DEARGRANDMA: The rela-
116tuhlpp,between Reye Syndrome
ge. mause nt a,plnn ev'raang auamPea w'Rh 30 centa porta`a
lldrenwltn<h3ckenpoxarRUisSendtoREYESYNDROMERE-
ellll nm cunrlualv, they tell ur- PORT. ACSH,I 47 Maple St-SUm-
But breauu It Is suepeet<d.,and mn, NJ Otaol.. ' '-
--
because of the rerlou+neu ot IneHytWronme, the Surgeon General
reeommenda that aapirln be
volaed Euller tLls year the Se-
eretary ot Health and Human S<r
vl'tta requestea m.nufscwrer. ot
uplrln and other salleylatw lc
Mmo.e from thelrISbeia any aug-
geatlon that eMse be used to treat
ehlldren w.lln flwlikk Illnesses or
rtlh: chleken poa.The n
Hcl ncered
hlcci H
arers frequently a.ked quleeclotu
- and' au oarlt.ea what medical
sclence no+ knows abwt tl. Tka
repnet m tree whh a selt.ad-
area.ed'bwlntu-alm anvelope
Syndrome.!
