Lorillard
the Health Consequences of Smoking - Part 2 of 3
Fields
- Type
- PSCI, SCIENTIFIC PUBLICATION
- BIBL, BIBLIOGRAPHY
- CHAR, CHART/GRAPH
- BIBL, BIBLIOGRAPHY
- Document File
- 03763512/03766002/S H Re 1979 Surgeon General S Report.
- Area
- LEGAL DEPT FILE ROOM
- Alias
- 03764350/03764451
- Characteristic
- OVER, OVER SIZE DOCUMENT
- Master ID
- 03764103/6002
Related Documents:- 03764105
- 03764106
- 03764107-4109 Bibliography on Smoking and Health
- 03764110-4112 the Health Consequences of Smoking
- 03764129-4257 the Health Consequences of Smoking 750000 - Part 1 of 2
- 03764200-4257 the Health Consequences of Smoking 750000 - Part 2 of 2
- 03764260-4261 Statement by Horace R. Kornegay, President of Tobacco Institute, on the 740000 Health Consequences of Smoking, Hew Report to Congress Released 740628
- 03764266-4273
- 03764274-4551 the Health Conseguences of Smoking - Part 1 of 3
- 03764452-4551 the Health Conseguences of Smoking - Part 3 of 3
- 03764552-4727 the Health Consequences of Smoking A Report of the Surgeon General: 720000 - Part 1 of 3
- 03764555
- 03764567-4666 the Health Consequences of Smoking A Report of the Surgeon General: 720000 - Part 2 of 3
- 03764667-4727 the Health Consequences of Smoking A Report of the Surgeon General: 720000 - Part 3 of 3
- 03764729
- 03764730-4735
- 03764736-4737
- 03764739-4740
- 03764747-4748
- 03764749-4961 The Health Consequences of Smoking A Public Health Service Review] 670000
- 03764962-5073 the Health Consequences of Smoking 690000 Supplement to the 670000 Public Health Service Review
- 03765074-5541 the Health Consequences of Smoking Part 1 of 4
- 03765309-5541 The Health Consequences of Smoking Part 3 of 4
- 03765543
- 03765545-5546
- 03765548
- 03765549 Informational Memo
- 03765550-5553 for Simultaneous Use with 710000 Surgeon General's Report on Smoking and Health
- 03765554-5556 Smoking Is Very Debonair
- 03765557
- 03765558-5965 Smoking and Health Report of the Advisory Committee to the Surgeon General of the Public Health Service - Part 1 of 3
- 03765573-5726 Smoking and Health Report of the Advisory Committee to the Surgeon General of the Public Health Service - Part 2 of 3
- 03765727-5965 Smoking and Health Report of the Advisory Committee to the Surgeon General of the Public Health Service - Part 3 of 3
- 03765966
- 03765967-6000 Report to Surgeon General's Advisory Committee on Smoking and Health - Materials on Cigarette Filtration
- 03766001-6002
- Named Organization
- Boston City Hospital
- Nas, Natl Academy of Sciences
- Natl Center of Health Statistics
- Natl Inst of Neurological Diseases
- Ontario Dept of Health
- Nas, Natl Academy of Sciences
- Named Person
- Alberman, E.D.
- Alexandrov
- Alp
- Andrews
- Astrup
- Auerbach
- Baribaud
- Benedict
- Berg
- Berry
- Bisdom
- Blake
- Bock
- Boots
- Boucot
- Buncher
- Butler, N.R.
- Bynum
- Carlassare
- Cole
- Comstock
- Cooper
- Cragg
- Crosby
- Davies
- Delarue
- Delint
- Diamond
- Dietz
- Dipaolo
- Doll, R.
- Domagala
- Dorn
- Duncan
- Emanuel
- Feron
- Ferrara
- Fingerland
- Fischer
- Flaxman
- Ford
- Frank
- Frazier
- Fredrick
- Freeman
- Gielen
- Goldstein
- Gordon
- Greiner
- Hajdu
- Harris
- Hatcher
- Haworth
- Healey
- Henderson
- Herriott
- Herrold
- Hirayama, T.
- Hoffmann
- Homburger
- Hoover
- Inui
- Jacobsen
- Johnson
- Kaalen
- Kallen
- Kass
- Kennedy
- Kirschbaum
- Kizer
- Konturek
- Krain
- Kreyberg
- Kullander
- Lazer
- Lee
- Leone
- Levin
- Longo
- Lowe
- Lundin
- Macmahon
- Maenza
- Martinez
- Mcgarry
- Merker
- Meyer
- Miller
- Mills
- Mohr
- Moore
- Morales
- Mukherjee
- Mulcahy
- Murphy
- Nagata
- Nelson
- Niswander
- Oneil
- Ounsted
- Perlman
- Pike, M.C.
- Pindborg
- Pollack
- Rantakallio
- Ravenholt
- Reddy
- Reinke
- Rhoades
- Rickard
- Robbins
- Robert
- Roe
- Rondia
- Rumeauroquette
- Rush
- Ryser
- Saffiotti
- Sampson
- Sawyer
- Schlede
- Schmahl
- Schmidt
- Sellakumar
- Shabad
- Shaikh
- Ship
- Shubik
- Simpson
- Sivak
- Solomon
- Stell
- Sterling
- Suzuki
- Swartz
- Syndor
- Takayama
- Thompson
- Tjalve
- Tolins
- Tyldesley
- Underwood
- Vanduuren
- Vendrely
- Venulet
- Welch
- Werfmessing
- Whitehead
- Whitlock
- Wilson
- Wynder
- Xipell
- Yanysheva
- Yerushalmy
- Younoszai
- Zabriskie
- Alexandrov
- Litigation
- Ppla/Produced
- Date Loaded
- 07 Jan 1999
- Site
- N14
- UCSF Legacy ID
- kau99d00
Document Images
i
~
Iducation,
~( Health~
~ fIea:lth,
Advisorg
p: Wash-
Public
Public
Ilking. A
~ti, Ed'u-
11'ioati'on
~
bg: 1.968
kirttnent
,5hrvioe
~g. 1989
~rtnient
5ervi~ce~
Iing. A
4, Eflu-
[ ) Zi-
~ng: A
Edn.
) 72'-
j men
ioine
1teki
:.
(2)
i
l4ue:
rimo-
>olic
458,.
I

03764351

Co~mtemts
Page
Introductiom-------------------------------------------- 67
ILiing Cancer-------------------------------------------- 68.
Egidemiologieal St2idies-__-____________________-____-_ 68'
E'x-Smokers----------------------------------------- 71
Lirdnium, Mining and Exposure to RadioactivztV _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ 72'
Air Pollution---------------------------------------- 72
A'sbestos-------------------------------------------- 73
au,topsyand Cytol'ogical SGudies-__--_-_____-__-___-____ 73
nral Cancer -------------------------------------------- 74
Cancer of't.he Esophagus_________________________________ 76
Cancer of t'he Larynx ------------------------------------ 76
Cancer of'the Pancreas___________________________________ 77
C aneer of the Kidney andl Urinary Bladder_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 77
E_.perimentall Carcinogenesis-__________________________-__ 78'
R'espzratory Tract Carcinogenesis'_ _-- _ _- _ _ _ _ _ _- _ _ _ _ _ _ _- _ 78'
Experiments in Mice_________________________________ 80
Aryl Hydrocarbon Hydroarylase (AHH), _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _- _ _ _- _ _ _ _ 82
Cell an.d Tissue Culture Studies_____-__________________ 84!
B~inding of ~Polycy,cli;aH'ydrocarb'onst~~o~~DNA~ dnd~RNA_ __- 86
AT-lVittosdmines in Toba.cco Smoke_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 87
Summary of Recent Cancer Findings_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _. 88
Referenees--------------------------------------------- 88
List of Figures
Figure 1.-Standardized lung cancer mortality ratios of'
Japanese by number of' cigarettes smoked (1966-70) ------- 69.
Figure 2'.-Lung cancer mortality ratios of Ja.panese by age,
at initiation of' cigarette smoking (1966-70) _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 69
Figure 3.-The survivall of'~ ex-srnokers and continuing smokers
who were treated for a primary cancer of the oral cavity,
pharynx,orlarynx------------------------------------ 75.
65

List of Tables
Page
Table 1.-Age-standardized lung cancer death rates of' British
physicians and the population of' England and `?Pales at
various time geriods----------------------------------- 70
Table 2.-N-dimethylnitrosamine (DMNA) content of'~ con-
densates obtained from several tobaccos grownn in both!
.
"high"' and "low" ni~~trogen soils------------------------- 87
'
66

Introduction
Tiiis introduction is a brief summary of' the major relationships
brt weensmoking, and cancer which have been established in, previous
nvl)orts on the healahi consequences of smoking', (;9~L,92,93,,94, 95, 961)~.
('i'(;arette smoking has been clearly identified as the major cause of
14u1- cancer in the TJ.nited S'tates:This conclusion is based on detailed
vhi'kllniiological, clinical,autopsy and experimental data, which have
:uccutnulated over a period of more than 20 years, For both men, and
woxmeii,, the~ risk ofdevelopinglung; cancer is directly related to total
klxpostue to cigarette smoke as measured by the number of cigarettes
smoked per day,, the total lifetime number of cigarettes smokedl, the
duration of' smoking in, years; the age at initiation of smokingy the
depth of inhalation of tobacco smoke; and the "tar" and nscotine levels
in the cigarettes smoked. Lung cancer death rates, however,,are lower
for Nc,omen than they are for men, ai finding due, in part;, tloa differencein exposure. `Vomen,
smokers use fewer cigarettes a day, choose filtered
cigarettes with lower"tar'''' and nicatine~ val!ues,, and also tend to inhale
less. E-Iowever; even when women experience comparable levels of' ex-
posure to cigarette smoke as men, their mortality rates for lung cancer
stiill remain somewhat lower.
Those who stop smoking experience a decline in the risk of'develop-
ing lung cancer relative to continuing, smokers. The air, pollution!
commonly found inan urban setting, appearsto result in elevatedllung
cancerdleathi rates; however, thiseffect is relatively small comparedl to
the overriding effect of cigarette smoking:.
Certain occupational exposures have been found tio be associated
with ani increased risk of dying from, lung cancer. Cigarette smoking
interacts with many of theseexposures!.toproduce much higher death
rates from lung cancer than would result from one e.xposure alone.
Inte racting exposure factors may be : experiencedl simul'taneously or at~
different times. The uranium mining and asbestosind'ustries,are exam-
ples of occupations in which this interaction occurs.
The bronchial epithelium of smokers often shows premalignant
changesincludingsquanlous,m!etahlasiay atypical squamous metaplasia,,
and carcinoma in situ.
Pipe and/or cigar sinokers experience a risk of developing lung
cancer that is higher than t'herisk of nonsrn~o~kers;howe,ver, it,remains
495-028 Q'--73
M
,.
, d

significantly lbwer than the risk of'cigarette smokers. A more complete
discussion of the risks from pipe and cigar smoking, is found in
another chapter of this report.
Epidemaolbgical, experimental, and autopsy data have demonstrated
that cigarette smoking is, a, significant factor in the development of
cancer of the larynx, oral cavity, esophagus, and urinary bladder.
B-naphthylamine, a carcinogen known to cause cancer of the urinary
bladder in humans, has beenidentiified in cigarettesmoke. Thereisalsoe an association between
cigarette smoking, and cancer of the pancreas.
Experimental studies with animals in which cigarette smoke or one of
it's const!ituent' compounds is administered in & variety of assays have
confirmed the presence of'complete careinogens cocarcinogens such as
tumor initiators and tumor promoters, and tumor accelerators in
cigarette smoke.
Reeent'1y, additional epademiological, autopsy,, and experirnental'
studies have added to our understanding of these rel'ationships.,
Lung, Cancer
Epidem,ialogical Sta.t,dies
An ongoing prospective epidemiological study condtzcted in Japan
provides a unique opportunity to examine the relationship of cigarette
smoking ta death~ rates in a population: withgenetic, dietary, and
other cultural' differences from previously examined Western popula-
tions., Hirayama (37) has now reporte6 5-year foll'otivup data on
265,118 men and women aged40 y ears and older.. This represented 91' to
99 percent of the total' populatiotr in the area of' the 29 health districts
where the study was conducted. A totali of' 11,858 deaths occurred dur-
ing, the 5-year periodl which incUaded a total of 1,269,382 person-years
of observation: Both men and' women wh.o sm.oked cigarettes experi-
enced higher death rates from lung cancer than nonsmokers. Among
smokers,the lung, cancer mort<alityratio«-as3'.85 ~ fbr men and 2:44 for
women as,compared to nonsm~okers~ . (P < 0.001). Dose-response, relation-
ships were demonstrated for the number of' eigarettes smoked per dayy
andl the age at initiation of smoking (figs. 1 and 2). These mortality
ratios,areconside-rablylower than those reported, forthehnited States,
Canada,, and Great Bri~taQn, and may reflect ai lowerar-eragenumber of
cigarettes smoked a da,y;an olcder.age at imitiation of smoking, or re-
duced inhalntion ofe cigarettle smoke among the Japanese. In spite of
these differences, thee overall results,of'thisstudy, includingthe dbse-
responserelationships, are similar.toAhe resnlt&ofal'l the other major.,
68

r'"`w
I I
l~lete.
~
rated~
it of
Ider.
h.ary
i alsoo
reas:
ke of.
Rave.
~11 as
~ in.
I
t~tal
el,iiioiui,ological investigations. Thus,the rel'iabilityand accuracyof'the
iictliods of' population selection and analysis used in previous studies
h;r~e<i on population sa,rnples,and the conclnsion that cigarette srnok:-
w,L, is the major cause of'lung cancer are again confirmed.
Figure 1.-Standardized lung, cancer mort~aiity ratios of'Japanese by number of
cigarettes smoked (1966'-1970),.
9'.0
S!.0
7.0'
6.0'
5:0
4.0
3~.0
2'.0
1.0'.
0
1.0
3.6
4.4
7.8'
4.3
Mlorn 1-14 15-24 >24 Ex,
smoker cigarettes per day smoker
SOURCE: HfFayamaj T. (37).
Figure 2.-Lung, cancer mortality ratios of Japanese by age at initiation of
cigarette smoking (1966-1970).
5,0
A~ 4.0~
r.
0
2 3',0!
2.0
11.0
'
0
Non- >25' <24 <19
smoker Age at initiation of smoking
SOURCE: Hirayama, T.,(37):
69
0
0
79

TABLE 1I.-Age-stand'ardized lungcan.cerdeath rates of Briti:'sh, physicians
and the population of England and Wales at vdrinus time periods
Lung cancer standardiied!deiath rate per 1,6C10 men per year in-
Dootors. England and Wales
Years------.--,-------------------------------------- 1953;-57 185741 196i-65 19M-57 19,58-611
1962-65
Death rate per 1,000~----------------- 1. 10 0. 85 0. 83 1l 49 1. 71 1. 88'
Source: Doll, R., Fllee;D3.,C. (tt).
Kennedy (~.45); studied primary lung cancer in 29 men and 11 `eomeni
diagnosed before the age of 40 land found a strong association betweeni
cigarette smoking and'the development of this disease.
Boucot, et al. (11) further characterized the 121 cases of lung
eancerdetected in the population of tiliePhiladelpllia pul'monaryneoplasm research project. Ti he
risk of developing lung cancer in-
creased with age, was higher ini nonn-hites than in whites, and increasedd
sharply with, increased cigarette consumption.
The relationship~ between cigarette smoking and lung cancer was
investigated in a retrospective study by: Ferr.ara (25) in La Plata,
Argentina. The: smoking,habits of 144' lung cancer patients were con-
trasted with those of 386' controls. A dose-response relat'ionship, was
found between cigarette usage measured by the number of cigaret.tess
smoked per day and the durat'i'on of smoking,and the risk of'develbping
lung cancer.
A high incidence of' lung, cancer is reported from the island of
Jersey in the Channel Isles compared to England and wales.. The
island has no heavy industry and only minimal levels of air pollution.
Cragg (16) ~ studied 144 patients who developed lung cancer on Jersey
during a 4-year study period. Only three nonsmokers were found
among the 113'patients for whom histories were available:
Fingerland; et al. (26) determsned' the prev.alence of! 1'ung cancer
and certain other diseases in an~ autopsy series of 1,338 adults in
Czechoslovakia. Some 198 cases of primary lung cancer were identifiedl.
In the autopsyy population, 1.4 percent of the nonsmokers, 14'.1 percent
of'thosesmoking Tesst11~an200,,O0b'lifetime eigarettes,, and 33.3' percent
of those smoking more than 500,000 lifetime cigarettes had lung,
cancer.
Rickard and Sampson~ (71)~ studied 94 Negro patients with lung,
cancer in Washington, D.C.,, and found, that 57 (92 percent) of 63
patient's whose smoking history was available were: regular smokers.
Epidemiological studie& conducted in Italy (10)i,, Swe,deni (48),
Poland (46), Russia, (42), Cuba (73), 11Tiexico (13), and the Nether-
lands (98) demonstrate an association between cigarette smoking and,
lung eancer.
70
I
#
i

omen
fween
lung
mary
LC In-
~ased
was
lAta,,
iCon-
I was
Oes
?ing
~ of
T'he.
:ion,
hsey
und
icer
li in
led.
ent
;ent
tng
[ng
63
irs.
id
Berg, et al. (5) examined the incidence of recurrent primary cancers
following initiall prirnary~ cancers~ of~ the~ respiratory and upper di-
'restiti-e systems in New York. During 23,802 man-years of observation
in .1,11i5 patients with an initial squamous cell cancer,, 518 second
cancers developed at other sites. Patients whose first primary cancer
;nas in the lung had an observedl to~ expected relative risk rat'io~ of' 5'.:7~
( P< 0.05 ) forr subsequent cancers of' the respiratory or upper GI
~,V:;tem~. Patlient'is, with the~~ first cancer in the~ oral cavity or~ laryna
frea(luently developed a second cancer in the lung.. AIiedical records
_ ontirnaed long sTnoking, histories among almost all of' these patients
Nti IioAeveloped second cancers.
C'uncer~~of the~ lung~, oral cavity, larynx, and esophagus were~~ reported
!~v Schmidt and De~ Lint, (79)~ to be~comrnon~ causes, ~of~death~ amongg
f,WN ' men and women who hadl received treatment~ for~ alcoholism~ in~
Toronto. The authors attributed this finding to the strong, associa-
t irn.t that exists between alcohol and tobacco~ u~se~andnot bo~~ the~effect of
zi Lcoholl alone.
Carcinoma of the trachea is~ a relativeiy~ rare~ condition with, only
ahout-1D0 cases~ha:ving~bee~n reported in the literature~.,lii a study~ of~41'
l)atients~ w~ith, carcinomai of~ the trachea, I}Iaj'du,: et~al. (.31) found an,
~-,Pparent association between cigarette smoking and the development
=4 'epidermoid cancers,of this st'ructure:~
An association between ci:garette~ smok~ing, and the development of~
broncliu:olo-alveolar~ carcinoma in~ 74 patients-~was, described~ by ~ Delarue;~
et al. (18).
.
Ex-sm;okers
Those who stop smoking experience a decline in the ri'sk of dev.elop-
ing lung, cancer relative to continuing smokers: Doll and Pike (2N)
<<onducted a~~ st~udy~of~ the~ smoking habits and causes~~of death of 40,000~
Briti,sli physicians. Smoking ha.bi~tis, were~ surveyed in~~ 19~511, 1957',~ and
.
l:)6G., Durii,2;, the~ study ~ perio<l,, more~ than 3,500 physiicians~ becan:ze~ ex-~
.~niokers~., The age-standardized percentage of ex-sni,okers~~ among 1?hy~-~
sicians 65 to 64 years of age rose from 1I8',1 percent in 1951 to 26,5 per-
cent in 195 1 and ~?~J~:5 hercent, in~ 1966. Concurrently, t~h,e~percentage~of
hhy:sicians~ s~nioking, ci~,rnrettes~~ fell fi-om, 44.1 percent to 22.0 percent,
while over ~ the~ same period estimates of' the~~ per capita ci'garet;te~ con-
sttmption for the adiilt male population in the~ Linited! Kingdom su~g-
(*este<1 ,t slir.ht increase in ciga~ret-te~~ consumption. Over this 15-year~
heriotl, the~ niorttility from hu2g,cancer arnor:7g,physicirans~~dlrophed con-
sidera1hly: While~~ lung cancer death rates among,the nnale population in
1!ar,aand and Wales increased to~ some~ extent (tla~ble~ 1)~.: :llthougll cer~-
71

tain limitations apply to the interpretat,ions derived from secular data,
analysis~ of the~ study ~ design and the~ magnitude of the results~ ihdi-~
cate that~this study constitutes important evidence~of~some~of'the~bene~-~
fits~~ tliat'~ result fionii the cessation of~ cigarette snsoking.
Uranium Mining and Fxposure to Padioaetivity
Epidemiological evidence supported by autopsy studies has estab-
lished that'~airborne~radiationy~ particularly~ in synergi~stie~comb~imation
«itlrcigarette smoking,,is the major cause of the excess of respiratoryy
cancers among uranium miners.
Lundin;, et al. ('53), considered quantitative~ and~~ temporal aspects!
of radon.idaughter~exposure and respi'ratory~cancer ini a report'~~fromthe:
Epi~d!emiologica1 Study ~ of~ United States~ Uranium Miners. They~ ob-~
served a stati~stiicalZy~ significant excess~~ of~ respilratory~ cancer among
«hi~te~u~raniom mii7ers~~at each cu~mulative~~ radiation exposure category
dow~n to~~ and' including~ 120-3W WL'M (w~ork~~ing~~ llevel montlLs)~_ The
authors~ noted that although cigarette~ smokiirg~ alane~ entailed a risk of
the~ dl;~veloprnent, of' eancer~ of~ the respiratory.~ tract in, miners just as
it~ does in nonm~iners; cigarette~~ smoking, in combination wi'th; radion~
daughter exposure appeared to result in an even greater risk.~
Several authorsi (30, 44,~638/~~, 104) continuelo~ report the presence~~
of' polbni~um-~210 or~one~of the~th:oriurn isotopes in tobacco l~eaf;~ tlobacco~o
smoke, or the l ungs of smokers.
Air Pollution
Data standard'ized, for~cigarette sm:oki~ng~~ind'icate~the existence:of an~
u~~rban factor~in the~develapm~ent of~lung carlc;er; it is~likelythat ai'r~po1-
lution,,frequent,ly~ part~ofi the city.~ environment, is~ai component of~ the~
urban factor.
Th~e~ National Academy of~ S'ci~ences,published a review (6r')~ of the~
biolbgicall effects of atmospheric polluti~on~ by~ particulate pol!ycyclic~c
organic matter.~ Detailed epidemiological,,experimental, physicaI,,and
chemical data were revie«-edi., It was concluded that air pollution as
commonly ~ found in urban settings, was found to~be associated with: in-
creased creased lung cancer~ mortality in cities, An examination of the data
presented,~however, indicates that eigarette~ srnok~ing is,,i¢l, most~ cases,
the~ overridia'ig factor~ in tihe~ development of lurrg, cancer. IPolycyclic
hv~d~rocarbons~an~d relatedlcompourrds which~aire~known~to~cause,cancer
of the~lhng and other organs in experimental animals were~ found t'~o~
72
I
