Lorillard
760000 Report of the Council for Tobacco Research U.S.A., Inc.
Fields
- Type
- PSCI, SCIENTIFIC PUBLICATION
- ABST, ABSTRACT
- BIBL, BIBLIOGRAPHY
- ABST, ABSTRACT
- Alias
- 03745654/03745743
- Document File
- 03745448/03745915/Hew's Anti Smoking Campaign Vol 2 790524.
- Master ID
- 03745010/5826
Related Documents:- 03745011-5013
- 03745014-5017
- 03745018
- 03745019-5022
- 03745023-5029
- 03745030-5033
- 03745037-5040 Califano's Request
- 03745041-5079 Disease Prevention and Health Promotion Act of 780000 Hearings Before the Subcommittee on Health and Scientific Research of the Committee on Human Resources United States Senate
- 03745080
- 03745081-5090 Preliminary Summary- 730000 San Matco County, California, Surveillance of Student Drug Use Alcoholic Beverages, Amphetamines, Barbiturates, Heroin, Lsd, Marijuana, Tobacco Trends in Levels of Use Shown in Six Annual Surveys, Junior and Senior High School Students
- 03745091 Anti-Smoking Program Has Mixed Results
- 03745092
- 03745093
- 03745094-5095
- 03745096 Smoking Ads, Passive Smoking
- 03745097 at Home
- 03745098 Manufacture Outlook
- 03745099-5103 Cigarette Labeling and Advertising-690000 Hearings Before the Committee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce House of Represetatives
- 03745104 Estimated Prevalence of Current Regular Cigarette Smoking Ages 12 - 18, United States, 680000 - 790000
- 03745105-5136 Transcript of Proceedings Subcommittee on Health and Scientific Research Committee on Human Resources Hearing on Deterring Childhood Smoking
- 03745137-5142 Response to Recomendations for Federal Support of Anti-Smoking Education Cessation Clinics and Behavioral Research
- 03745143-5146 Statement of Horace R Kornegay President the Tobacco Institute Inc Before the Subcommittee on Health and the Enviroment of the House Comm on Interstate and Foreign Commerce 780215
- 03745147-5161 the Federal Government Chronology of Intervention in the Smoking and Health Controversy
- 03745162-5171 Statement by Joseph A. Califano Jr Secretary of Health Education and Welfare Before the Subcommittee on Health and the Environment of the House Interstate and Foreign Commerce Committee
- 03745172-5180 Text of Remarks by Joseph A. Califano Jr at the American Cancer Society New York New York
- 03745181-5187 Remarks of Secretary Joseph A. Califano, Jr. On the Release of the Surgeon General's Report on Smoking and Health Washington, D.C. 790111
- 03745188-5213 Remarks by Secretary Joseph A. Califano Jr. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare to the Youth Conference, the National Interagency Council on Smoking and Health San Francisco, California 790426
- 03745214-5215 to Smoke or Not to Smoke: A Really Free Choice for Our Young People
- 03745216-5217 Age of Anxiety Stress Research Seeks Clues to Why Children Can Not Cope with Life
- 03745218-5228 Some Indicators of Health Related Behavior Among Adolescents in the United States
- 03745229
- 03745230-5236 Cigarette Advertising and Consumption
- 03745237-5243 Cigarette Advertising Does Not Influence Young People to Smoke
- 03745244-5254 Teens,Smoking and Cigarette Advertising
- 03745255-5272 A Study of Cigarette Smoking Among Teen-Age Girls and Young Women Volume II - Detailed Findings
- 03745273-5326 Fact or Fancy?
- 03745327-5350 Smoking and Health 640000 - 790000 the Continuing Controversy
- 03745351-5366 Smoking and Pregnancy Maternal Smoking
- 03745367-5378 Smoking and Pregnancy
- 03745379
- 03745380-5383
- 03745384
- 03745385 Secretary Califano Response
- 03745386-5393
- 03745396-5397
- 03745398
- 03745399
- 03745409
- 03745410-5428 Statement by Joseph A. Califano, Jr. Secretary of Health, Education and Welfare Before the Subcommittee on Health and the Environment of the House Interstate and Foreign Commerce Committee 780215
- 03745429-5440 Statement of Horace R. Kornegay President, the Tobacco Institute, Inc. Before the Subcommittee on Health and the Environment of the House Committee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce 780215
- 03745441-5447 Testimony of Action on Smoking and Health by Its Executive Oirector John F. Banzhaf III, Esq., Before the House Subcomm on Health and the Environment Relating to Secretary Califano's Announcements Concerning Smoking, Wednesday, 780215
- 03745448-5449
- 03745450-5826 Antismoking Initiatives of the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare Hearing Before the Subcommittee on Health and the Environment of the Committee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce House of Representatives Ninety Fifth Congress
- 03745467-5475 Chapter 1-60 Policy on Smoking in Hew Occupied Buildings and Facilities
- 03745484-5506 Excerpt From Social and Economic Issues Confronting the Tobacco Industry in the Seventies Impact of Eliminating the Tobacco Price-Support Supply-Control Program
- 03745507-5514 Excert From Proceedings/3rd World Conference Smokiing and Health, Volume II, Health Consequences, Education,Cessation Activities, Social Action Pricing Out Tobacco: Price As A Factor in Cigarette Consumption
- 03745527-5528
- 03745529-5530
- 03745531 Smoking and Health
- 03745534
- 03745535
- 03745536
- 03745537
- 03745538
- 03745539
- 03745540
- 03745541
- 03745542
- 03745544-5545 Network Responses to Anti-Smoking Announcements
- 03745546
- 03745547-5548
- 03745549-5550
- 03745551-5552
- 03745646
- 03745649-5652 'excess Deaths'--Scientific Fact or Speculation?
- Characteristic
- EXTR, EXTRA
- MINI, MINIMUM CODING
- Litigation
- Stmn/Produced
- Author (Organization)
- Ctr, Council for Tobacco Research
- Date Loaded
- 12 Feb 1999
- Site
- N14
- Area
- LEGAL DEPT FILE ROOM
- UCSF Legacy ID
- hlr40e00
Document Images
200
1976 REPORT'
of
THE COUNCIL FOR TOBACCO RESEARCH-U.S.A., In
THE COUNCIL FOR TOBACCO RESEARCH-U.S.A., Inc.
110 East 59th Street, New York, N.Y. 10022

Organization and Policy
The Council for Tobacco Research-U.S.A., Inc. is the sponsoring agency
of a program of research into questions of tobacco use and health. It is the out-
growth of an organization formed early in 1954 by tobacco manufacturers,
growers and warehousemen. Research support has been mainly through a pro.
gram of grants-in-aid supplemented by contracts for research with institutions
and~ laboratories. The Council does not operate any research faeility:
The Scientific Advisory Board to The Council meets regularly to evaluate
applications for grants-in-aid and for contracts, judging them solely on the basis
of scientific merit and relevance.
The Council awards research grants to independent scientists who are as-
sured complete scientific freedom in conducting their studies. Grantees alone
are responsible for reporting or publishing their findings in the accepted scien-
tific manner - through medical and scientific journals and societies.
Through December 1976;, The Council approved research projects for 358'
investigators in~ 239 medical schools, hospitals and research institutions. These
awards totaled more than $40,000,000.
This Report includes a brief summary of The Council's present program in
the cardiovascular area as well as lists of current and previous research projects
supported' by The Council'. Also ineluded are abstracts of 80 researcK papers,
acknowledging Council support, that were published in scientific journals dur-
ing 1976. Project recipients have so far published 1,420 such papers.
ADDISON YEAMAN
Chairman and President

®
202
SCIENTIFIC ADVISORY BOARD
to The Council for Tobacco Research-U.S.A., Inc.
as of~ December 31, 1976
SHELDON C. SOMMERS, M.D., Chairman
Director o f Laboratories, Lenox Hill Hospital
Clinical'Professor of Pathology
College of Physicians & Surgeons of Columbia University
New York, New York
.' 3.
RICHARD M. BING, M.D.
Director of Cardiology and Intramural Medicine
Huntington Memorial Hospital~ Pasadena, California ~~.
Professor of Medicine
University of Southern California School of Medicine
Los Angeles, California -
JOSEPH D. FELDMAN', M.D.
Head, Department of Immunopathology
Scripps Clinic and Research Foundation
La Jolla, California ~
WILLIAM U. GARDNER, PH.D:.
Scientific Director, The Council for Tobacco Research-U.S.A, Inc
E. K. Hunt'Professor of Anatomy (emeritus)' ~
l
i
h
ool of~ Medicine
Ya
e Un
versity Sc
New Haven, Connecticut
ROBERT J. HUEBNER, M.D. ~
Chief, Laboratory of RNA Tumor Viruses
National Cancer Institute Y
Bethesda, Maryland
LEON O. JACOBSON, M.D.
Director, The Franklin McLean Memorial Research Institute ~
Regenstein Professor of Biological Sciences ~
University of Chicago "`
Chicago, Illinois ~
AVERILL A. LIEBOWM.D. A
Professor of Pathology (emeritus) ~:
University of' California School of Medicine
San Diego, California 4'
HENRY T. LYNCH, M.D. °~
Professor and Chairman
Department of Preventive Medicine and Public Health ,i
Creighton University School of! Medicine
Omaha, Nebraska =4

nc
203
FANS MEIER, D.V.M., Dr. Med. Vec, M.R.S;H.
Senior Stafl Scientist
The Jackson Laboratory
Bar Harbor,,Maine
LEE W. WATTENBERG, M:D.
Professor of'Pathology
Department of', Laboratory Medicine and Pathology
University ofMinnesot'a Medical SchoolMinneapolis; Minnesota
JOHN P. WYATT, M.D.
Director
Tobacco and Health Research Institute
University of Kentucky
Lexington, Kentucky
Scientific Staff of The Council
WILLIAM U. GARDNER, PH.D.
Scientific Director
ROBERT C. HOCKETT, Px.D.
Research Director
JOHN H. KREISHER, PH.D. VINCENT F. LISANTI, D.M.D.
Associate Research Director Associate Research Director
DAVID STONE,Px.D.
Associate Research Director
I
H
I

204
. CONTENTS
Studies Related to Cardiovascular Diseases and Function
Abstracts of Reports ,
Cancer-Related Studies
The Respiratory System
Heart and Circulation
Neuropharmacology and Physiology
Immunology and Adaptive Mechanisms
Epidemiology
Active Frojects
Completed Projects
Index of Principal Investigators
Index of Senior Authors
P,'
Counci
monar,
relevar.
Ir
of card
Cardi
A:
from p
the Un
stroke;,
6721 failure.
to preci
7$f I Ati
Epide)
0c Nu
posstble
eases, TII
The "ris
relations
it might
Am
elevated
personali i
predispo!'.
factor, bi
the other
scientfists
to what
operativestrong, a
personal
but has t(
observatic
coherents
prove vali
30-498 O V
I
I
C

Studies Related to
Cardiovascular Diseases
and Function
Previous annual reports have presented the general plan and rationale of
Council-sponsored' studies of carcinogenesis and the etiology of chronic pul-
monary disorders. Their purpose was to provide a framework in whichi the
relevance of individual contributions wouldi be more easily apparent.
In the present issue, we describe similarly some of our approaches to study
of cardiovascular diseases and function.
Cardiovascular Diseases
Among the many disorders of the cardiovascular system, those deriving
from progressive atherosclerosis rank first as causes of disability and death in~
the UnitediStates. These include heart' attacks (myocardial infarction), angina,,
stroke, arterial blockages irn the limbs, and some cases of congestive heart
failure. Hypertension is believed not only to accelerate atherosclerosis, but also
to precipitate acute events in damaged circulatory systems..
Atherosclerosis is, therefore, a principal focus of the present discussion.
Epidemiology o f Atherosclerosis-Related Diseases
Numerous epidemiological studies during the last 20 years have sought'
possible "causes" (primary or contributory) of the atheroscleresis-related dis-
eases. These studies often summarized their findings im terms of "risk factors."
The "risk factor" is essentially a stati'sticali concept based upon mathematical
relationships without necessarily any known or established mechanism, by which
it might contribute to etiology.
Among the many such "risk factors" frequently reported are hypertension,
elevated serum cholesterol, diabetes or a prediabetic diathesis, cigarette smoking,
personality type, inadeqpate physical' activity, and emotional stress. Genetic
predisposition (e.g., hyperlipoproteinemia, homocysteinemia) is another such
factor, both in its own right and as a contributor to most or possibly all of
the others: Biochemists, physiologists, pharmacologists, psychologists, and other
scientists have thus been challenged to fill the gaps and learni whether, how,
to what extent and' in what kinds of persons each factor might actually be
operative. The stimulus to conjecture, speculationi and hypothesis has been
strong, and many scientists have apparently seized the occasion to test their
personal hunches in the hope of a lucky strike. This was entirely legitimate
but has tended to produce a welter of' fragmentary, confusing and inconclusivee
observations subjected to speculative projections. Clarification may come as
coherent, integrative theories emerge that can accommodate all the findings that
prove valid.
5
30+498 0 ~- 78 - 14

Cigarette Smoking as a "Risk Factor" ~
The identification of a"risk factor" can be no more reliable than the
statistics on which it is based. Smokers select themselves from among the .~;
general population on a basis or bases that are little understood. Is it legitimate ~
to compare them with nonsmoker controls as animal experimenters eompare' ~
their test animals with genetically identical litter-mates?
Tobacco use has many variations, both qualitative and' quantitative. To ~
what extent does voluntary adoption of any particular behavioral pattern
select out a sub-population with innate characteristics or life-styles that' are'`
linked to cardiovascular disease susceptibility?
There are many evidences from studies of man that genetic predisposition'.~
plays an important part in determining which individ'uals are potentiali victims
of atherosclerosis-related diseases. ln several types of rather extreme suscepti-,;
bility, the patterns of inheritance have been well established.
Review of the "risk factors" listed above indicates that most of them, are ;
already known to be influencedi if not determined, by heredity.
Studies of' spontaneous alcoholi consumption by inbred mice have shown '
substantiall strain differences in appetite, in behavioral responses and in, meta-`
bolism. Analogous mouse studies of spontaneous nicotine and tobacco smoke '
intake have now been inaugurated by a Council grant to learn whether similarc genetic variations
occur.
a
Twin Studies
tary influences (even among twins reared apart), in determining initiation and ;:
Identical twins provide the human~ counterpart of animals of inbred straini
~
Studies of all like-sexed twins in Sweden and! Finlan& are being assiste& by ~
The CounciP in an effort to determine broadly the relative influences of heredity ~
versus environment upon the incidence of atherosclerosis-based cardiovascular ~
diseases. A key strategy is to compare the incidence of such~ disDrders in smoking
and nonsmoking identical twins, including symptomatology during life and, ~
eventually, age at death, the primary cause of decease and post-mortem evalua-
tion of vascular pathology. Non-identical, like-sexed twin siblings serve as "
controls. :. ;~
While the incidence of discordance in smoking practices is low among '
identical twins, an observation that in itself evidences a strong role of heredi- z~.
maintenance of smoking; the numbers of discordants are great enough to accrue
to increasingly significant levels in substantial twin populations followed over
a sufficient period of time. These studies have now been extended beyond
identical twins to other relatives of various defined degrees of consanguinity,
such as half-sibs and the offspring of twins.
These time-consuming, 'investigations will' require a considerable induction
perio& before comprehensive new reports emerge. They may eventually provide
more direct evidence whether cigarette smoking per se is a truly significant
"risk factor" in these and perhaps some other diseases. They cannot, however,
be expectedi to add greatly to elucidation of pathogenic processes or to ~ provide
6
V1
M
M
0
e

207
strain.
ed by
nedity
pscular
Inoking
e and,
valua-
rve as
,,.
among
heredi-
n and
accrue
pd over
beyond
uinity,
duction
brovide
pificant
~wever,
`rovide
I ~.
methods usefuli in reducing risks due to biochemical aberrations imparted by the
genes from ancestors. For this, other types of research are required.
Cholesterol Metabolism
Another prevalent "risk factor" in epidemiological studies has been "ele-
vated serum cholesterol."' Contradictory findings over the years suggest that
this concept; was an oversimplification, especially since many victims of heart
attacks had no history of high cholesterol levels. That cholesterol is implicated
in atherosclerosis has been assumed because mature arterial plaques contain
the steroid both free and in combinations. Nevertheless, long-ter~m adminis-
tration of drugs that lower serum cholesterol has not been as generally effective
in arresting or reversing the process in man as had been hoped.
Accumulating information about the states of combination of cholesteroli
in blood is directing attention to the several cholesterol-containing combina-
tions, classified as chylomicrons, very low density lipoproteins (VLDL), low
density lipoproteins (LDL) and high density lipoproteins (HDL). The LDLs
are the major carriers of' blood cholesterol and there are a number of experi-
mental as well as epidemiological findings that an elevate& serum level of
VLDL is correlated with progression of atherosclerosis, whereas elevated HDL
is a favorable indication.
Thus certain "lipoprotein profiles" are now considered by many to be
better indicators of susceptibility to atherosclerosis than elevated totali ch&
esterol. Certain~ of these profiles, associated; with very high susceptibility to
disease, have been shown to be genetically determined.
Barring some unforeseeable empirical discovery (which does occur im
medical research and is a perennial hope), the rational route toward effective
control is through systematic study of the pathogenesis of atherosclerosis, at
biochemical' and physiological levels. This obviously must include a better
understanding of the regulat'ion of synthesis, transport, function, and elimin
ation of cholesterol and of the aberrations in disease in the hope of altering
these by targeted'treatment.
The Council is presently reviewing the most promising concepts and leads
that now exist in this complex field with the intent of increasing its support
of basic study of athererosclerosis. The intent is not only to assist these im-
portant developments, but also to seek more directly relevant assay systems
for assessing the possible effects of cigarette smoke inhalation.
The task is additionally difficult because the atherosclerotic disorders
appear to be peculiarly human ones with few counterparts among animals
under natural conditions. Highly contrived manipulations to produce animal
"counterparts" tend to diminish probability of relevance to human experience.
Human studies have been impeded by the lack of non-intervention tech-
niques for assessing initiation and progression of the atherogenesis processes
in the vasculature of man. New experimental techniques for visualizing the
condition of the arterial walls, including scintillation photography, appear to
show promise for the future.
7
1

208
In Vitro Studies of Arteries and Veins
Meanwhile, in vitro techniques provide one method of studying synthests :~
and uptake of lipids an& cholesterol by human arteries an& veins, both _-`
"
"
and atherosclerotie inct comparison with those of animals
, dire. -,
normal
Though in vitro conditions cannot be made to duplicate the in vivo situation ~
perfectly, they may provide useful guides to in vivo research.
Such studies have already been made with CTR support as.deseribed in
the Council's Annual Reports for 1972-1975. It has been reported (and is
reiterated in a current review) that human atherosclerotic and normal coronary
arteries as welli as saphenous veins, perfuse& under pulsatile arterial pressures
with human plasma containing labeled cholesterol an& acetate, do not synthe=
size cholesterol from acetate and produce only small amounts of' cholesterol
esters. Cholesterol is taken up in identical amounts by normal and diseased
vessels and this uptake is increase& at higher pulse pressures, which seems
consistant with the reputed effects of hypertension. Labeled acetate is incor-
porate& into various lipids. Both normal and diseased coronary arteries and
saphenous veins synthesize free fatty acids, triglycerides and phospholipids.'
Addition of nicotine to the perfusion fluid did not influence cholesterol
uptake. Analogous experiments with dog arteries appeared to shown an in-
fluence of nicotine upon cholesterol uptake. If this is confirmed, it suggests
caution in extrapolations from this species to man (1972' report).
Carbon monoxide in the perfused plasma was reported' to enhance chol;
esterol uptake by all arteries in this in virro system.
Several' new studies report a dramatic inhibition of cholesterol uptake by `.'
both~ human and animal arteries, under these in vitro conditions, by 7-keto-q~
cholesterol. :
Living rabbits also showed am inhibition of cholesterol uptake, but to a
much smaller extent. The low solubility of the 7-keto compound; imposed t
technical problems. Improved techniques may increase the efficiency of the;
'
effect. Meanwhile, the disparity, between the in vitro an& whole animal re-T
sponses is another reminder that extrapolations must be cautious. ~A
°
Other current studies deal with elucidation of possible mechanisms bf_`
the inhibition and with the metabolic fate of the injected 7-keto compound iA;
rabbits.
Role o f Smooth Muscle Cells in Atherosclerotic Plaques
The heretofore prevalent theory of atherosclerotic plaque formation posti-l-lated that the
infiltration of fatty substances from the bloodstream into tbd `
arterial wall gives rise to cholesterol deposits that act as an irritant, causinr
inflammation and proliferation of cells by processes akin to ordinary healiny
This "insudation"' concept was consistent with the associations of atherosclet F,
osis with elevated blood cholesterol, high blood pressure and high fat diets..
Animals fed large amounts of saturated fats and cholesteroli sometimes s*
plemented with~ hormonal or other treatments, developed lesions superficiMresembling those observed
in man at autopsy: These lesions often regressod
in animals when the diets were altered, an observation, that stimulated hum22
dietary studies involving restriction of! cholesteroli and saturatedl fat consump'.
6
cc
VE
m
ia
ht
is
Ce
sn
to
vc
m
m
01
tl
rf
0
si
st
b,
ai
li1
ce
th
w
cc
in
e%
m
E
th
hZ
c
r
0
s

ibed
and'
ron
ressurt
synthe~
leste
ise
see
in
ies
xolipids:
:)lesterd
an ta~
ugge
n postu-
into the
causing
healing. TF,
eroscler- '*
~t diets.~
es sup- _
~~erficiallyregressed `
4 human "`
~-
~onsump- _`
209
tion. Complicated by difficulties of control, the results in man have been
equivocal.
Recent electron microscopic studies of human arterial' plaques have re-
vealed that the major component' of authentic plaques is proliferating smooth
muscle cells like those normally composing the center (medial) layer of arter-
ial walls rather than fibroblast cells such as proliferate to heal a wound. Early
human arterial lesions (streaks) contain little lipid, suggesting that insudation
is not the prime factor in typical atherosclerosis. Cholesterot deposits and
cellular debris appear later. Present debate centers on what incites normali
smooth muscle cells to migrate from the mediali layer and what causes them
to proliferate. Presumably, damage to the inner surface cell' layer of the
vessels is implicated and a number of theories as to how this endothelial layer
may become damaged have been advancedi
Many of the plaques generated in animal arteries by non-physiological
manipulations are reported to be radically different in composition from those
of genuine human atherosclerosis and their relevance to the human diseases is
therefore questionable. Recognition of the difference has, however, led to
reports that certain animals can develop human-type atherosclerosis under
other more appropriate conditions.
Smooth muscle cells from primate arteries are now being maintained
successfully in culture media. Low-density lipoproteins added to the media
stimulate them to multiply. Further, it has been reported that the ever-present
blood platelets, normally involved in the clotting process in response to injury
an& im other, functions, also secrete a substance that strongly stimulates pro-
liferation of these smooth muscle cells. Damage to endothellal and' intimal
cell layers of an artery, which ordinarily separate the blood from contact with
the smooth muscle cells of the medial layer, can bring these cells into contact
with~ platelets and presumably incite multiplication in the artery wall.
Another concept holds that the smooth muscle cells multiply as the
consequence of a mutatiom akin to that which transforms other normal cells
into malignant ones. This "monoclonaV' theory which is supporte& by striking
evidence but is nevertheless in some dispute, would suggest quite different
mechanisms of action by external agents than those described heretofore.
Endothelial Cells and Blood Platelets
A single layer of endothelial cells composes the thin membrane lining
the inner surfaces of arteries, performing, an important function in retaining
the red corpuscles while allowing water and some other substances to pass
through. As mentioned, damage to the endothelium is believed to contribute
to all three of the mechanisms of atherosclerosis described. Many possible
causes of endothelial damage have been suggested andl are being studied.
It is possible that severali may be involved. The damaged endothelium can
repair itself, rather slowly, but if damage is sustained or repeated too often,
repair may not be achieved.
Clots (thrombi) forming in an artery are thought to injure the endo-
thelium by pressure and by impeding the access of oxygen. The blood platelets
have long been known to play a role in the complex events that produce
