Lorillard
Transcript of Proceedings Subcommittee on Health and Scientific Research Committee on Human Resources Hearing on Deterring Childhood Smoking
Fields
- Type
- PUBL, OTHER PUBLICATION
- TRAN, TRANSCRIPT
- Area
- LEGAL DEPT FILE ROOM
- Alias
- 03745105/03745136
- Site
- N14
- Request
- R1-004
- Named Person
- Adams, M.
- Banzhaf, J.S. III
- Califano
- Chafee
- Daugherty, R.M., J.R.
- Evans, R.I.
- Ford, W.H.
- Fosge, W.H.
- Green, P.
- Griffith, C.
- Kennedy, E.M.
- Kretchmer, N.
- Leffall, L.D.
- Omalley, M.
- Pinney, J.
- Reilley, M.
- Schweiker
- Surgeon General
- Swinehart, J.W.
- Valeo, J.
- Wolf, T.
- Young, D.
- Banzhaf, J.S. III
- Date Loaded
- 05 Jun 1998
- Document File
- 03745010/03745447/Hew's Anti Smoking Campaign Vol 1 2 790100 - 790523.
- Named Organization
- American Cancer Society
- American Heart Assn
- American Lung Assn
- American Thoracic
- Ash, Action on Smoking & Health
- Bethesda Chevy Chase High School
- Center for Disease Control
- Comm on Human Resources
- Debakke Heart Center
- Gonzaga College High School
- Green Dolmatch Advertising
- Hew, Dept of Health Education and Welfare
- Immaculate High School
- Natl Inst of Child Health + Human D
- Office of Smoking + Health
- Subcomm on Health + Scientific Rese
- Subcomm on Smoking
- Univ of Houston
- American Heart Assn
- Characteristic
- MARG, MARGINALIA
- MISS, MISSING PAGES
- Litigation
- Stmn/Produced
- Master ID
- 03745010/5826
Related Documents:- 03745011-5013
- 03745014-5017
- 03745018
- 03745019-5022
- 03745023-5029
- 03745030-5033
- 03745037-5040 Califano's Request
- 03745041-5079 Disease Prevention and Health Promotion Act of 780000 Hearings Before the Subcommittee on Health and Scientific Research of the Committee on Human Resources United States Senate
- 03745080
- 03745081-5090 Preliminary Summary- 730000 San Matco County, California, Surveillance of Student Drug Use Alcoholic Beverages, Amphetamines, Barbiturates, Heroin, Lsd, Marijuana, Tobacco Trends in Levels of Use Shown in Six Annual Surveys, Junior and Senior High School Students
- 03745091 Anti-Smoking Program Has Mixed Results
- 03745092
- 03745093
- 03745094-5095
- 03745096 Smoking Ads, Passive Smoking
- 03745097 at Home
- 03745098 Manufacture Outlook
- 03745099-5103 Cigarette Labeling and Advertising-690000 Hearings Before the Committee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce House of Represetatives
- 03745104 Estimated Prevalence of Current Regular Cigarette Smoking Ages 12 - 18, United States, 680000 - 790000
- 03745137-5142 Response to Recomendations for Federal Support of Anti-Smoking Education Cessation Clinics and Behavioral Research
- 03745143-5146 Statement of Horace R Kornegay President the Tobacco Institute Inc Before the Subcommittee on Health and the Enviroment of the House Comm on Interstate and Foreign Commerce 780215
- 03745147-5161 the Federal Government Chronology of Intervention in the Smoking and Health Controversy
- 03745162-5171 Statement by Joseph A. Califano Jr Secretary of Health Education and Welfare Before the Subcommittee on Health and the Environment of the House Interstate and Foreign Commerce Committee
- 03745172-5180 Text of Remarks by Joseph A. Califano Jr at the American Cancer Society New York New York
- 03745181-5187 Remarks of Secretary Joseph A. Califano, Jr. On the Release of the Surgeon General's Report on Smoking and Health Washington, D.C. 790111
- 03745188-5213 Remarks by Secretary Joseph A. Califano Jr. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare to the Youth Conference, the National Interagency Council on Smoking and Health San Francisco, California 790426
- 03745214-5215 to Smoke or Not to Smoke: A Really Free Choice for Our Young People
- 03745216-5217 Age of Anxiety Stress Research Seeks Clues to Why Children Can Not Cope with Life
- 03745218-5228 Some Indicators of Health Related Behavior Among Adolescents in the United States
- 03745229
- 03745230-5236 Cigarette Advertising and Consumption
- 03745237-5243 Cigarette Advertising Does Not Influence Young People to Smoke
- 03745244-5254 Teens,Smoking and Cigarette Advertising
- 03745255-5272 A Study of Cigarette Smoking Among Teen-Age Girls and Young Women Volume II - Detailed Findings
- 03745273-5326 Fact or Fancy?
- 03745327-5350 Smoking and Health 640000 - 790000 the Continuing Controversy
- 03745351-5366 Smoking and Pregnancy Maternal Smoking
- 03745367-5378 Smoking and Pregnancy
- 03745379
- 03745380-5383
- 03745384
- 03745385 Secretary Califano Response
- 03745386-5393
- 03745396-5397
- 03745398
- 03745399
- 03745409
- 03745410-5428 Statement by Joseph A. Califano, Jr. Secretary of Health, Education and Welfare Before the Subcommittee on Health and the Environment of the House Interstate and Foreign Commerce Committee 780215
- 03745429-5440 Statement of Horace R. Kornegay President, the Tobacco Institute, Inc. Before the Subcommittee on Health and the Environment of the House Committee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce 780215
- 03745441-5447 Testimony of Action on Smoking and Health by Its Executive Oirector John F. Banzhaf III, Esq., Before the House Subcomm on Health and the Environment Relating to Secretary Califano's Announcements Concerning Smoking, Wednesday, 780215
- 03745448-5449
- 03745450-5826 Antismoking Initiatives of the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare Hearing Before the Subcommittee on Health and the Environment of the Committee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce House of Representatives Ninety Fifth Congress
- 03745467-5475 Chapter 1-60 Policy on Smoking in Hew Occupied Buildings and Facilities
- 03745484-5506 Excerpt From Social and Economic Issues Confronting the Tobacco Industry in the Seventies Impact of Eliminating the Tobacco Price-Support Supply-Control Program
- 03745507-5514 Excert From Proceedings/3rd World Conference Smokiing and Health, Volume II, Health Consequences, Education,Cessation Activities, Social Action Pricing Out Tobacco: Price As A Factor in Cigarette Consumption
- 03745527-5528
- 03745529-5530
- 03745531 Smoking and Health
- 03745534
- 03745535
- 03745536
- 03745537
- 03745538
- 03745539
- 03745540
- 03745541
- 03745542
- 03745544-5545 Network Responses to Anti-Smoking Announcements
- 03745546
- 03745547-5548
- 03745549-5550
- 03745551-5552
- 03745646
- 03745649-5652 'excess Deaths'--Scientific Fact or Speculation?
- 03745654-5743 760000 Report of the Council for Tobacco Research U.S.A., Inc.
- UCSF Legacy ID
- fmy51e00
Document Images
54
and why ehe is, bccauso peer group p_essn: e sseems to have
2
3
4
5
6
I
8
10
11
12
14:
15
16
17
1F3
19
20
21
22
23
24
worked in complotely contrary r®alms, and you are obviously
geared to th.3t, so that would be part of your survey, I would
Yssta~sa .
One of c:y questions is--s4sucturally, with your asw of-
fice in HEw that mr. Pinney is going to hmad up, is that cor-
rect?
Mr. Pir.r_ey. Yes, sir.
Senator Schc,reil.os. Fioc; wf.ll you integrate,
though, with
the Na_iosswS *_aetitutc of Child Bta.lt2:, because they have
very e,oparate prc _edures on p:rrr r.:views of proj3cts like
this, acd I am all fo_ tho in:cyrzt=o_--but isn't that a prob-
lem?
Ms. Pinasay. It is not a problem, Senator. The philosophy!
on which ths, offic: is bascd is oae of project managns.:.nt. In
esseaca, tha Secrstany felt tha.t thoro v+as *aot enough attFSn-
tion at his level on the prcb2a of s=king and health. Thera
was a lot going on in each of the Institutes, but the ques`cion
was: aro ke directing what resourccs we have to the best
pocsiblo reaas an3 emda? An d, for examplo, with the National
Institute of Child Esalth as.d Bums.n Dsvclop=sxt, my role would
be ons of discuss:.ng with Dr. F.ra`.c1*ner What his progr<n.
.P.-mounc=ent would say in terms of eliciting good sound ro-
eaarch in the areag that wa have ida-m-tified as top priority.
The actuc;. cont3nC: of tho resezrcb proposn.'.s and tr.c pasr

56
I
2
9
4
8
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
16
19
20
22
23
24
25
STIi'i'E.11Mh'TS O!" A PAi.EL OF $I6E SCSOOL STUDZiTS:
^aHEEBSu W0LFF AND b:OIRA REILLEY, INL+fI:CULATA
HICH SCSOOL; MARTIN O'h:ALLEY, MARX ADF.NLS, Ab1D
CI3AP.LES GRFFI'i'3, GOhZAGA COLLEGE HIGH SCSOOL;
Ah'D .TANMS YALfiO, BE':cirSDA-CHa"VY CHASE HIGH
SCHOOL
Sonator Keanscy. Wo will bave a panel of high school
stu&ont3 from GonWaga College High School, ImMaculat.a School
and th3 F,e4.kcsda-Ch_vy Chace Bigh School. Through-an over-
sig!`.t, the Sra.T,a.culata and Bn;;hcs3a-Ch,svy Chas3 High Schools
wrrc now ncatiioncd on the fcraa3l witnQSs list, but thzy have
bza:: s:^.orrcusly cooparative as thc young stud= ts havs.
We want to uolcoca you to th6 Co!:nitts3. I think ths
Cor.grCss of t2 e Uniaed StaEs3 geta its informalon from a
variecy of so-sc,es. W= bave in this legislztion that ws have
before na noa--xe a=a tryinc to ds-al with an is3u_ ar.ich I
think is of enarnous co_-cern to paremts all ovaz this country,
porhaps all aver tt:o rorld--paron°.s vhosa perhaps first in-
teTeat is tho good bralth of their childrea, paro3ts who are
f,u^raasir:gly concornrdd about t.h:, esplosion in S.c-nas of tho
co..r.:vmpticn of cigarat;:es. As so many scicntiists a,-.d research-
ers and family doctors hr-,,a poi:,t,~ci out, the ecieatific infor-
maticn is very cl~ar that rcs a.ro rcally heads3 for a typa of
hcal;,h c-?as:rophc in this nation if tha kinds of proj®c'cions
fiha: hava ta:esn placu r::iezza 2°58' ard 1974 among young peoplQ,

57
I ~
- 2
3
~-~ A
5
7
8
9
10
11
12
3 I4i
14 ~
~
~ 15
16
17
1s
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
ers
,
g
irs s~
Coatinuo
s.
teena
o
hia
g
asr.ong
I think all of you
must have baan inpressa3 by what some.of our distinguishad
researchers and doctors have poiated out to this Committee.
And wo aro trying, as we shou, d, to f i=sd ways and msans
of working with local commuaitios and working with you and
your aosociatss in the schools to try aad find out if tbere
ia some way wE can work in partcnarship to re2iava this gonera-
tioa, this younger guoration, of the burd¢n of smoking. We
realizo it's complezj xo r'®elizs it involves a vari©ty of
di'frerent guQ3tioas that affact young paopio--and we want
vQ:y much this morning to h$ar from you, whay'you think is
' the nature of the problem and thp Kays and mEans that we can
1~oest deal wit-.h it.
So we are v©rh, vcry grateful to have you join us h"e
4
t}as
morning.
IIoaa ma.ay of you hsve ever testified bGforC? UiEll, it's
nothitg to be concarmcS about, we Wa`t just to hear from you in
yoc3 oan words.
I cisatw your att:~:.ti.oa to thu cha.rLs that we have ever
here that show in t.'^_osa four di,fo-rc.:t se-3sea:c3 arezs ths
vcry eigrificantt growi:!-, in the nzmtrss of regular smokers
a2tw_3n 1960 and 1974 by various age, categorias. And we can
ses; in thn youxgest age, from 12, 13, aszd 14 year old, an
eightfold inort;asa; ccrrestoading increases, perhaps aat
p3resntagcwisc, b::t cQZ"caiz?.y from the numbers dramatically
J

al1 ~ ~a 58
continue in the 15 aand 16 and 17 to IB--and this is, as we
can see in «-ho*chart that ic just behind it, at this point
' the girls are virtually even with tho boys in tems of use
of cigarettes.
5
8
9
8ut nonmthaloss it has besp doscribed as an explosion
in torms of the uso of cigarettes, aad'Y® would like to try
and sort of gain your views about the iESuQs.
We would liks to h:as from you your own views about smo-
king. We are aot trying to makv any noral jiu!gmcnts obvious~-
ly, but 4re are trying to find out about--you can s.`.art off
with your nazaas, your ages, and whsrQ you go to achool, and
thc n we would like to ask you about trhethe r you s:ok© and
wh= did, you star-, rs.d soma other a_uestions.
I thir'c wE will gct startc maybe over hssro with Thtsrese.
16
17
18
19
20
21
23
24
TzY k into the mikcs, if you xould, aad giva us your aa=, age,
and rshe_d you go to school, ju3t initially wo will introduce
oursalv6s. I - Tod hc,.r.a3y from f:assachuse'cts, Senator
Chafao from Rtiodo Island, and Sonator Schwaikarr fron Ponnsyl-
vania, and we ar© all iFsmb`,3 of t.h0 ges?th SuL-com.vitte@ that
is conc, rnad with Vsis lcgislation.
So juct give us your ni=e, your age, your sc2rc.l, and
tFlos,. wo %-il:l come to sonz! of tha questions.
Fii sn Volff. I un T:.erf.er3 Wolff, I am 17 ycara old, and
3 plan on gcing to Wast Virgin+F z'aslayan next year.
Senator Chafss. A.^..d you just graduaWd fsVp r'-`.rrE?

0
2
3
4
5
6
C
59
lS.is s Wo 1 f f. I-culata.
Miss Railley. My rtiase is Moira Reilley, I am 17, and
I have just graduatsd from Immaculata Ligh School.
14r. O't3al10y. I am Martin O'I+.a?le_v, 15, I am a froshce,n
af Gonzaga Coll©ge High School.
Fs. Adams. I am Mark Adams, I aa 15, I am also a frash-
man at Gonzaga.
Mr. Griffi4:h. I am Charlos Griffith, I am 17, I am a
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
ju_ior at Gonzaga.
fir. Va2o.o. I am Jam=? Va?oo and I amgradue.ting fromBct;hesda-Cr.SV.y Chaso aic_rh Schoc,l.
Senator renr:edy. Cou2d you tcll us, maykr by just a show
of hands, hoVi many of yuu smo}:e?
MP.yba we could start with you, TrercEe and Hcira--whan
did you start?
Miss Wolff. A-ror.ud 14 or 15.
Senator Ecnnesy. i?hat about you, Moira?
Miss z3i11ey. 15.
Senator r~-,_nrdy. Jazoes?
Mr. 1.'alco. Yes, I was 13.
Senatior l:anacdy. . I,arlc?
Na'. ACTa=3. I was 13.
Saaetor Itenn:djP. I kaGk' t_+aL's a few yars ago, but do
you thin}: you could try and rsaybe trcll us about why you da-
c:dcd to sf:a:.'t to smo!ss or not to eaoF:c? Was it sort of a

t
3
oonsoiC s decision?
C
60
lliss Roilley. Well, basically rhen people start smokiag
csgarettes, it is because of peer prsssura: your friends start
to saokc. And then it i© a choiee of whethEr you wrant to ba
5
6
7
B
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
Ss
19
20
21,
22
23
24
sort of left out, you know, by people of your own agetif you
don't start snroking, you know, thoy aort of look down on you.
Senator Chafeo. fthat psrcaata.ge of the girls in your
class smok®, would you azy?
Miss R=illay. In my cle.sc Iwoul;d say aboLt 85 pares.nt.
So:.ator KFSmsdy. Mhaf f.bout you, Thernss, whon you
starte3 to eso3:c?
K:irs 1:olfF. I slaaxvtea s.ao'.ing mostly bscauaa I like it.
I tioald say I sta=2.:.d s:.o}:ir.g probably to fit in with tho
crowd.
So.-:atcr IC.dv. Let me Ls2: the ones wno do smoke--
cou? d I j sst seuo your hands again?
snoko? Eoih yozLr parcui.s tr:okfl?
Mr. Valea. Ono cf mins.
Sosc many of your parents
Saaator Frr.nady. On9 cf yo;n: parents. How about th3
oncs that don't smo;ce, do your pare.hts smol.e or not rmoko?
i-:ritin,, what abo4t that?
Kt:. O'Valley. Os:e of tay par= t.s sTMokGs, but bo is not
a cons3stCat Moko,.rF ha just has eo=. ec,a.ry onca in a while.
Mr. Griffith. So;:h of :aioo aaoLo.
su.^:atG_ i;ar ociy. F.:,:! ycu don't en.cke. Mark, Waa-t about

I
2
3
4
5
6
6
9
10
ti
12
13
14
15
16
17 1
is
19
20
21
22
23
25
C
you.
r
61
Mr. Adr,mg. N®itha.r of my parents smokes. My aaother used
to, but sho Qu.it.
Senator FennE dy. Do your frieads think at all about the
health iraplications of smoking, or do you sort of think about
it and think it is not going to happen.to me? What kind of
a sense do you or any of your friends have about whether it
really is go_ng to make much of a diffcranco in t~~s of your
health or not? Both your oLn vieci and whati you hea^ scmo of
your friends talk ahout.
l2r. 0'I?alley. k~ll, I vould say that kids my age aren't
really conccrnt.d wi-th the health issues, you knor; thay talk
about it maybe. But the aain e.f.aq that thay are doing it
for is, you Y.now, just to fit in crith the crowd. Smo].ing
is someth{ng that most adults do. So I Y.2',.in3: the roason why
the k..idt do it is justi so thay can get a feeling of, you know,
Piiss Re-illsy. t;aruraty.
tlr. 0'c:a.llcy. Yssa, maturity. But I don't tdiic:k they arv
really ccncernan3 tihs.t mv.ch with tho hEalth ir.enes.
SLaGror i.cnr.e3y. h'haC abaLt it, Jim?
Mr. Valso. f?tll, %:hcn I fire:t tstarted to smo;c, you know,
I usc:R to th=al; it coUdg't hzppsm. to au3, I couldn't g9t ill
from it, w was icn:uao to it or soMOishisg. But no~ 0-.at I am
o2d3r, I have bca thxn.':Sng--I cM eez how it has affected

V
1
2
4
5
7
9
10
11
12
1k
15
15
17
18
19
20
21
- 24
25
.C
C
62
my ability to run any leng`.h of distanco, you know, my wind.
Senator Kennedy. Are you an athlete?
Mr. Valeo. S?sll, I used to run track, I usxd to sprint.
When I sprinted, it didn't maka a diffo.rence, because, you
know, a hundred yards--thzt's nothing. But I am talking abon
going out to ran two or threo miies--I'don't know wDothar I
could do it anymore without huffing and pnffing at thQ and of
it.
But now, you know, I have made a vow to myself that I am
going to quit smoking, b3causo I can etc th^ effeot that it
has had on me as far es that goos.
SF=ator SchFraiker. Are you going to gui t cold turkey,
or ho;: are you going to qui_, Jim?
A:r. vzlec. t+'all, I Aaveti tried to cut down, and:it just
doa3n'r ffor}:, bacauge tb?.re are too mezy t3.mes wbsn a cigarett
tastes good--that's what it boils Coaa to. But I am just goin
to go all t_h9 way, quit cold turkny with it, wh.= I quit.
Senator Chzfee. Charles, I noS:.i.co that you don't spoke
and both your parr-nts smakQ. No4, arfi yoL involved in athle-
tics or what particula:z r¢ason do you not sraota?
F1r. Grifritb. I didr't saol:O--a lot of ay frieads starta
to eno'.o br.cl; in 7tFt and 8;. gra&_s, and my parents =o1:od,
ar.3 I just vaate3 to be diffCZc_-,t. I a.ike to ba irz3apendaat.
S; uatcr F'.e:x.cdy. Let m3 as:r you ab3ul.: the attiLuie of
thr, schools t.boutt tIh3 ssaking. Do your schoals p.y.-n<_t it, do

.
63
C
2
3
4
5
6
7
9
10
11
- 12
l
I
17
18
19
20
21
23
thay'discourage it? Does that ra1:e any differanco? What
about it, Moira?
Miss Reilloy. Woet Catholic high schools, I would say,
allow it for saniors. Our high school didn't allow smokieg
at all. Geaeraliy, most pubiic high schools,'there's so msc2
s=a1:ln3 tharois nothing you can do about it.- But I oroulu
gencrally say that most schools allow it; there's not much
you can do, so mauuy g-aoplo saok6.
Ssnat.or rev=1y. What about thio hcalth issue, 'lha.resa?
Do you trir.k that many of the youn3sr people that get started
givQ that very a_+.ch atti=, tion or much thought, or do you.
fiad cut when they got a little oldsr that t:-qy bcg3.n to give
~~ it aore and then ar6 they hooked on it, or uha4?
i
:S
Misfs Wolff. When you fir,:t start smoking, it doesn't--
at least wit.h me, it didn't tako effect unti],.like m couple
of yezxs afC:mr, lihe.now I can s¢3 that I csm't ren as sauch
or par':ic_pato as much in activi::.as. I don't thi_Zk they
roay ly lcol: into 1t., thra health conditicas of it.
I
~ St A
eneoroar.e42y. Iht d thini?
Mar:, Yao you.. D you thik
on
ticv ti.ink muah a.bout ths health factors in ths s:.-~oking? .
~ Mc. P.rie.ms. Y.hzr, I first sta_4:ed, yes, Z. thouabt about
tlat, b'At I f:.v_-uTCc3, yoe know, that I seoul3.Z 't be smUking my
whol4 litot I figured lf.}ui c:he:a I turnad 18 I would stop or
something like that.
Bst now, as timm goea by, you know.
25
~

s
C
C
64
&anstor PCsnrredy. You axe thiaung more about it, about
3
9
10
it
12
13
14
15
16
17
iB
to
20
21
- 22
23
24
25
w5cthez to stop?
What do aay of you think would be-have some of you
thought about stopping s:aoking? Lxt ma sea a show of bande.
How saany of you thcugbt about stopping smohiag? Jia, you
thought about it.
Sanator 6chwoiker. Be's going to do it. '
Scaaltor Kenae-1y. Iio'B going to do it. What do you thin:
are roally the factors that vsould make a diffsr2nc® in whethe:
you can s3top or not? It it agai.n what is happeaing with your
fri.end ,, your colleag': es? Or do you think tho fact that you
r.r.ow aorc tbout thu health itcplicatioa3? Dccs that help you
or a..~cc-a-rage you to stop emokiag?
Ph:at do you th_a", _ are the things that ca^n help the rsost
in texcas of getting tc-Un4gars to stop?
Hiss pzillcy. Most t;G;.nagcrs aroa't re_lly well iSai`orm¢fl
about the health problemc. You Eee co=_rcials and ads that
tscy, you know, in tv:enty ysaxa you might develop luuq cancer
or somctF iag liko that. Sut when you are young aad you start
smoL-iag, you don't th`nh ot the long-tcs:cm effectss you are
juct th...infiing about acw and you arc thinking about--I will
jus;- try sroking for a while ind thea quit.
But you woLld bavo to e;;art at tho schools probably, bo-
catise r-hat is wh;,re r.osL p2oplCt start. And if you can stop
pFop13 from sTMo3:icg ct Echocl, th.-c thzy are just not going to
=
M~h ~=-
