Lorillard
Statement by Edward N. Brandt, Jr., M.D. Assistant Secretary for Health Public Health Service Department of Health and Human Services Before the Senate Labor and Human Resources Committee 820316
Fields
- Author
- Brandt, E.N., J.R.
- Area
- LEGAL DEPT FILE ROOM
- Type
- SPCH, SPEECH/PRESENTATION
- TRAN, TRANSCRIPT
- Site
- N14
- Named Person
- Koop, C.E.
- Luoto, J.
- Surgeon General
- Luoto, J.
- Request
- R1-037
- Recipient (Organization)
- Labor + Human Resources Comm
- Date Loaded
- 19 Dec 2001
- Named Organization
- American Dental Assn
- American Pharmaceutical Assn
- Hhs, Dept of Health and Human Services
- Natl Inst on Drug Abuse
- NCI, Natl Cancer Inst
- Office of Cancer Communications
- Office on Smoking + Health
- Surgeon Generals Advisory Comm
- American Pharmaceutical Assn
- Litigation
- Feda/Produced
- Author (Organization)
- Hhs, Dept of Health and Human Services
- Public Health Service
- Master ID
- 03613129/3672
Related Documents:- 03613131 Untitled Document 03613131
- 03613132-3134 S.2869 A Bill to Provide for the Inclusion in Printed Media Advertising and Upon Billboards of A Conspicuous Statement of A Cigarette Health Warning
- 03613138-3142 S. To Provide for the Inclusion in Printed Media Advertising of A Clear and Conspicuous Statement of A Cigarette Health Warning, and for Other Purposes.
- 03613143-3144 Untitled Document 03613143/3144
- 03613155-3157 S. A Bill to Provide for the Depiction in Printed Media Advertising of Cigarette Packages Legibly Showing A Health Warning Notice, and for Other Purposes.
- 03613163-3289 Transcript of Proceedings United States Senate Committee on Labor and Human Resources Hearing on S. 1929 Comprehensive Smoking Prevention Education Act
- 03613290-3295 Testimony of Charles A. Lemaistre, M.D. On Behalf of the Coalition on Smoking or Health Before the Committee on Labor and Human Resources United States Senate 820316
- 03613303-3311 Testimony on Behalf of the American Cancer Society Before the Subcommittee on Health and the Environment Committee on Energy and Commerce U.S. House of Representatives William G. Cahan, M.D.
- 03613312-3318 Testimony of John A. Oates, M.D. Chairman Subcommittee on Smoking American Heart Association Before the Subcommittee on Health and Environment Committee on Energy and Commerce U.S. House of Representatives 820305
- 03613319-3323 Testimony of Robert M. Daugherty, Jr., M.D., Ph.D. Chairman National Interagency Council on Smoking and Health Before the Subcommittee on Health and Environment Committee on Energy and Commerce U.S. House of Representatives 820305
- 03613324-3326 Statement of the American Lung Association to the House Subcommittee on Health and the Environment on H.R. 5653, the Comprehensive Smoking Prevention Education Act Presented by Steven Ayres, M.D.
- 03613327-3333 The Importance of the Federal Government in the Prevention of Smoking-Related Diseases Testimony in Support of H.R. 5653, A Revised Version of H.R. 4957 the Comprehensive Smoking Prevention Education Act by the American Lung Association
- 03613334-3335 Questions and Answers Concerning S. 1929, "The Comprehensive Smoking Prevention Education Act" by Senator Orrin G. Hatch
- 03613336-3337 Press Advisory From the Senate Committee on Labor and Human Resoures Hearing on S. 1929, the Comprehensive Smoking Education Act
- 03613338-3339 Statement of Sen, Orrin Hatch Before the Senate Committee on Labor and Human Resources Hearing on the Comprehensive Smoking Education Act, S. 1929
- 03613340-3344 Testimony Before the United States Senate Labor and Human Resources Committee on: Tobacco Additives by John H. Holbrook, M. D. 820316
- 03613345-3351 William Pollin, M.D. Director National Institute on Drug Abuse Alcohol, Drug Abuse, and Mental Health Administration Public Health Service Department of Health and Human Services Before the Committee on Labor and Human Resources United States Senate on 820316
- 03613359-3366 Statement on S. 1929 "Comprehensive Smoking Prevention Education Act of 810000"
- 03613367-3368 File Number 792-3204
- 03613369-3376 Testimony on Behalf of the American Cancer Society
- 03613377-3381 Statement by Rep. L. H. Fountain
- 03613382-3388 Statement of Senator Walter D. Huddleston of Kentucky
- 03613391 Federal Trade Commission
- 03613392-3394
- 03613395 Ftc Staff Report on Cigarette Advertising Waxman - Hatch/Packwood Legislation
- 03613396-3398
- 03613399 Please Circulate
- 03613400-3401
- 03613402
- 03613403
- 03613404
- 03613405 Memorandum to the File
- 03613406 Preparation for Packwood Hearing
- 03613407 'worn-Out' Warnings on Cigarettes
- 03613408-3409 S. 1929
- 03613413 S. 1929 - Hatch/Packwood Bill
- 03613414-3417 Tan Action Request - S. 1929
- 03613418 S. 1929
- 03613419 S. 1929
- 03613420-3422 Tma Issues Moniter
- 03613423 Important Message for James Cherry, Esquire, Arthur J. Stevens,
- 03613423A-3424 S. 1929 - Hatch/Packwood Bill
- 03613424A-3425 Tan Action Request - S. 1929
- 03613426-3427
- 03613428A S. 1929 - Hatch/Packwood Bill
- 03613429
- 03613430 Labor Opposition to H.R. 5653 & S.1929
- 03613431 Untitled Document 03613431
- 03613432 Untitled Document 03613432
- 03613433-3440 Statement of the Bakery, Confectionery, & Tobacco Workers International Union
- 03613441
- 03613442-3444 Hearing - S. 1929 and H.R. 4957
- 03613445 Memorandum
- 03613446 Press Release 'bc&T Submits Testimony in Opposition to Cigarette Package Labeling Bill'
- 03613447-3449 Bc&T Submits Testimony in Opposition to Cigarette Package Labeling Bill
- 03613450
- 03613451-3453 Tan Action Request - S. 1929
- 03613454
- 03613455
- 03613456-3458 Statement by William J. Holayter Legislative Director International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers on Hr-5653 Before the Health and Environment Subcommittee of the House Committee on Energy and Commerce
- 03613460
- 03613463-3464 Mearings - Packwood Bill, S. 290000
- 03613465-3466
- 03613467 Packwood Hearing
- 03613468 Memorandum to the File
- 03613473-3478 TI Newsletter
- 03613479-3480 Hearings - Packwood Bill, S. 290000
- 03613495
- 03613496 Statements Submitted by the Tobacco Institute on Behalf of the Following Individuals in Regard to S. 1929 'comprehensive Smoking Prevention Education Act' 820315
- 03613497 Statements Submitted by the Tobacco Institute on Behalf of the Following Individuals in Regard to H.R. 495 'comphrehensive Smoking Prevention Education Act' 820312
- 03613498
- 03613499-3508 Statement of Robert Casad Hockett
- 03613509-3510 Curriculum Vitae of Dr Robert C. Hockett
- 03613511-3519 Statement of H. Russell Fisher, M.D.
- 03613515-3517 Curriculum Vitae for H. Russell Fisher, M.D.
- 03613520-3523 Concerning the 'comprehensive Smoking Prevention Act of 820000'
- 03613524 Gerhard N. Schrauzer
- 03613525-3533 Curriculum Vitae Barbara J. Van Den Berg
- 03613534-3538 Curriculum Vitae
- 03613539-3544 Curriculum Vitae for H. Russell Fisher, M.D.
- 03613545-3548 Curuculum Vitae
- 03613549
- 03613550
- 03613551
- 03613552
- 03613553
- 03613554 Memorandum to the File
- 03613555 S. 1929 - Hatch-Packwood
- 03613556 Untitled Document 03613556
- 03613557
- 03613558
- 03613559
- 03613560
- 03613562 Waxman / Hatch
- 03613563
- 03613564-3565
- 03613566-3567 H.R. 4957, S.1929
- 03613572
- 03613573-3574
- 03613575 the Waxman / Hatch Bills and Hearings
- 03613576
- 03613577-3578
- 03613579
- 03613580-3581
- 03613583-3584 Untitled Document 03613583/3584
- 03613585-3586 Untitled Document 03613585/3586
- 03613587-3588 Untitled Document 03613587/3588
- 03613589-3590 Untitled Document 03613589/3590
- 03613591-3592 Untitled Document 03613591/3592
- 03613613 Bill # C-1929
- 03613614 Bill # S-1929
- 03613615 Bill #1929
- 03613616 Bill # S-1929
- 03613617-3618
- 03613619-3620
- 03613621-3622
- 03613625
- 03613629
- 03613630 Federal Activities Department Information Update
- 03613631-3632
- 03613633
- 03613634-3635 Sen. Ford Says Ftc Should Propose Trr to Deal with Cigarette Ad Warnings
- 03613636
- 03613639
- 03613640-3641
- 03613642 Cigarette Labelling Hearings
- 03613643 Urgent Message for Your Executive Named Below
- 03613643A Cigarette Labelling Hearings
- 03613644 Federal Legislation Self-Extinguishing Cigarettes Comprhensive Smoking Acts
- 03613648 Federal Cigarette Legislation H.R. 4957 Waxman S. 1929 - Hatch / Packwood 'comprehensive Smoking Prevention Education Act of 810000'
- 03613651-3654 the Senate Version of the 'comprehensive Smoking Prevention Education Act of 810000.'
- 03613656 Untitled Document 03613656
- 03613657
- 03613658 Federal Activities Department Information Update
- 03613659-3661 S. 1929
- 03613662 H.R. 1854
- 03613663-3672 S. 1929 to Amend the Public Health Service Act and the Federal Cigarette Labeling and Advertising Act to Increase the Availability to the American Public of Infornation on the Health Consequences of Smoking and Thereby Improve Informed Choice, and for Other Purposes.
- UCSF Legacy ID
- yir88c00
Document Images
DIEPARTMENT OF }9EALTH:l' HU.r't'AN SER~'fCESI Public Health Service
Office: of the Assistant Secretaryfor Health: -
W.asningtonOC'. 20201
FORRELEASE' ONLY UPON DELIVERY
STATEMENT BY
EDWARD N: BRANDT, JR., Mi.D.
A55ISTANT SECRETARY FOR HEALTH'.
PUBLIC HEALTH, SERVICE'
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES
BEFORE THE
SEN'ATE LABOR AND HUNtAN RESOURCES COMiV1ITTEE
iNARCH' 16,, 1982

Cigarette smoking, acts synergistically with oral contraceptives to enhance the
probability of coronary and some cerebrovascular disease;, with. alcohol to increase
the risk of cancer of the larynx, oral cavity,and esophagus; with asbestos and
some other occupationally encountered substances to increase the likelihood
of cancer of the lung; and' with other risk factors to enhance cardiovascular risk.
Involuntary or passive inhalation of cigarette smoke can precipitate or exacerbate
symptoms of existing disease states, such as asthma and cardiovascular and resp'cratory
diseases and may be, carcinogenic for nonsmokers. Smoking, is also the, major
identifiable cause of deaths and injuries from residentiallfires.
Mr. Chairman, cancer was the first disease to be associated with cigarette smoking.
As Dr. Koop pointed out in introducing, our 1982 report on smoking and healthh
a few weeks ago; reports linking smoking and lung cancer began appearing in
the scientific literature as long as 5& years ago. In 1964, when the Surgeon. General's
Advisory Com.mittee's report wasissued, l'ung cancer in men, and chronic bronchitis
in both men~ and women, were the two diseases which, the Committee identified
as being caused' by cigarette smoking.
The evidence which links cigarette smoking with.l'ung, and other cancers was reviewed
in the most careful detail in the 1982 report just issued. Today, 18 years after
the 1964 report, additional' human, experience and, enormous amounts of new research,
make it possible for science to conclude that cigarette smoking is a major cause
of cancers of the lung, larynx,, oral caMity, and esophagus, and that it is a contribut-
ory factor in the development of cancers of the bladder, pancreas;, and kidney.
Lung cancer accounts for one out. of every four cancer deaths, and 85' percent
of these are due to smoking, Overalll, approximately 30 percent of all cancer
deaths are attributable to tobacco use.
O
W.
OS
2'. - M+r
~
~!1
~i1

Mr. Chairman and Members of the Committee:
I am pleased to submit to you. today this statement of the Departmen:: of Health
and Human; Services. on. the health effectss of cigarette smoking. Thes- health
effects and their significance to the American peopde must necessarL;: provide
the rationale, and justification for whatever action your Committee nray take
in regard to the bill before you.
With. me today are Dr. C. Everett Kooo, Surgeon General, and, Dr. Joanne Luoto,.
Acting Director, Office on Sm,oking and H'ealth..
I'will begin by presenting a capsule description of the health effects ef cigarette
smoking and', then a more detailed description of smoking and cancer and cardiopulmonary
diseases. I will also address research efforts by the National Institute on Drug
Abuse on the addictive characteristics of'cigarette smoking.
In summary, cigarette smoking,is clearly the single most important preventable
cause. of premature illness and' death in the United States. Estimates of the. numt _r
of deaths related to smoking exceed 300,000' annually. One may compare this.
figure with the I05;000 deaths that occur each year as a result of all injuries,
20,000 deaths fcomm homicides, or the 40,000 infant deaths:,
Cigarette smoking is one of the three major independent riskk factors for coronary
heart disease and arteriosclerotic peripheral vascular dfsease; a major cause
of cancer of' the lung, larynx, oral cavity and esaphagur; and a major cause of
chronic bronchitis and emphysema..
Cigarette smoking is a contributory factor in cancer ofthe urinary bladder, kidney,.
and pancreas. It is also associated' with peptic ulcer disease. Maternall cigarette
srnoking, is associated with retarded fetall growth,. an increasedrisk for spontaneous
abortion andi prenatal death, and slight impairment of growth andi development
during early childhoodL

The Watiunal. Cancer Insti;tute is interested in pursuing some new leads. There
is a growing body of evidence that people who smoke low tar and, nicotine cigarettes
adjust their smoking behavior-inhaling more deeply or covering the ventilation
holes in the cigarette filters. This is thought to be an attempt to compensate
for the decreased nicotine yield., We plan to take a look at this question. If these
preliminary studses are confirrned; it would imply that smokers of tod'ays''cigarettes
are not decreasing, their exposure to nicotine and in fact may actually be increasina
their exposure to harmful combustion products such, as hydocarbons and carbon
monoxide.
Smoking and Cardio-pulmonary Disease
Chronic, obstructive pulmonary diseases (COPD)' today represents the fastest
growing,of the major causes of death, now ranking fifth. in. 1980, 55,000 Americans
died of pulmonary diseases. Almost three million Americans now suffer from
emphysema, a terribly debilitating disease. More than seven million have chronic
bronchitis. Chronic respiratory diseases account for approximately ten percent
of disability benefits for lost work. hours. And, the evidence is. substantial and
unequivocaD that cigarette smoking is the chief culprit in the onset or exacerbation
of these diseases.
Research, has for some time provided us with data demonstrating that smokers
have higher mortality rates from. chronic bronchitis and emphysema and that
smokers. have far less pulmonary function than nonsmokers. During, the past ten.
years, we have also obtained a far better understanding,of the mechanisms of
lung,damage, including the destruction of elastin, a major structural protein of
the lung which is adversel'y affected by cigarette smoking.. And, within recent
years, evidence hasbeen reported~ which suggests that the small airways function
of the lung may be adversely affected in healthy nonsmokers if'they are exposed,
to cigarette smoke from others.

Research~ continues in this area to give us a better basis of knowledge in order
to prevent or arrest the progress of pulmonary diseases. Stud'tesfiave demonstra2ed
the benefits of smoking,cessation, including improvements in lung performance
on stand'ard' spirometric (breathing) tests soon after one quits. However,. pulmonary
diseases represent a progressive condition and once a certain point is reachedl
we can only hope to retard its progression. Investigators are working towards
deveYoping a simplified means of d'etecting the disease condition at an early enough
stage too intervene and reverse the process. At the same time,, research continues
to:try to develop and evaluate programs designed to help individuals give up smoking,
since. smoking prevention or cessation represents the only effective intervention:
measure we now have.
Despite a dramatic decline in: mortality during the past decade, coronary heart
disease remains the number' one killer in this country, cPairning, three-quarters
of a millicn lives in the Uni2ed~ States each year. For every: minute of the day,
there are aboutthree Americans who suffer a heart attack. While the progress
in reducing coronary heart disease and'other cardiovascular deaths during recent
years is heartening, the scope of the probiemm remains enormous.
Cigarette smokingg is one of the three major risk factors for coronary heart disease;
the other two being high blood pressure and high, serum cholesterol. Epidemiological
evidence clearly places the smoker at a higher risk of heart disease than, the.
nonsmoker. The more one smokes, the greater the risk.. There is also evidence
that smoking cessation can decrease the risk. After only one year free ofi'cigarettes,
a former smoker may be able to reduce the risk of heart disease to close within
that of the nonsmoker:,
The exact mechaniisms of how cigarette smoking affects coronary heart disease
are still unknown and are the subject of considerable research, now underway.
Nevertheless, the evidence based on epidemiologic and autopsy studies clearly
linking the amount of smoking with higher incidence of heart disease, is indeed
impressive.
6,

o It is now clear from a large number of epidemlologie studies--both retro-
spectiue and prospective--that smoking is causally related to,at least
30 percent of all cancer deaths.. This means that approximately 129,000
people a,vear die of cancers related to smoking.
o The causal relationships are strong.If we. just look at lung cancer, the
major cause of cancer death among, U.S, males, a. cigarette smoker is
60, times more likely to die of this disease than a nonsmoker'.. And this
risk increases witlh the number of cigarett'.es'smoked--a direct dose-
response relationship.
o>ror the first time,, two preliminary epidemiologic studies are suggesting
an increased risk of lung cancer in nonsmoking wives of smoking husbands,
implicating sidestream smoke as a cancer ri=_k factor,
o We are encouraged by the figures om people who have been able to quit
smoking, most of them through their own efforts. Im 1965, 42' percent
of adults inthe United' Statessmoked. In 1980, the proportion dropped'
to 33 percent.
I would like to mention one program of the Office of Cancer Communications
because we are proud of itssuccess. Based on the well L-docum en ted evidence
that counseling, by a physician can motivate smokers. to quit, the office developed
a"Nelping Smokers. Quit Kit" for physicians to use with, patients. More than
135,000 of thesee kits-wMich include posters for the waiting room,. take-home
materials for smokers, and information on counseling the smoking, patient--were
distributed. In fact, the kit was so well recelved that a similar one was created
for dentists. This project was endorsed by the American Dental Association,
which,is cooperating with us to distribute the kit. Staff are now working with
the American Pharmaceutical Association to develop a similar program for pharmacists.
4

A subject which was hardly touched upon in the 1964 report is the effect of smoking
on. women, and in the case of maternal smoking, its effect on the fetus and infant.
In 1980, this was the topic of the Department''s report to Congress.. Its, concl'usions
were that women are not immune to the damaging effects of smoking,, and that
the lesser occurrence of smoking-related diseases among women smokers is a
result of' women having, lagged one-quartier century behind men in. their widespread
use of cigarettes.
The 1980. report established that cigarette smoking is a major threat to the outcome
of pregnancy and the well-being of the baby. The risk of spontaneous abortion,
fetal death, and'. neonatal death increases directly with. increasing levels of maternal,
smoking during pregnancy. Smoking causes a markedly increased risk of heart
attack, and subarachnoid hemorrhage:,
Another public health question, now enormously important, relates~ m the use
of the. new, low-yield cigarettes. This was the subject of. the Department's.19'$1
report. The Report's conclusions were that although~ there is no safe cigarette,
smoking cigarettes with.lower yields of tar and nicotine poses a lower risk off
lung cancer than smoking higher-yield cigarettes, provided' there is no. compensatory
change in smoking patterns.. Increasingly, smokers have turned to these lower-
yield products; there is evidence to suggest that in doing,so, at least some have
increased' their smoking or changed the way they smoke. This may have negated
any potentiai,benefit in,their having switched to these products.
Smoking and Cancer
The 1982 Report of the 5urgeon General on the Health Consequences of Smoking,
focussed upon, cancer. The report noted that the more than 100 diseases we call
cancer are the second leading, cause off death. in the Unitedl Sates. The report
also made these importantpoints:
