Abstract
This both worrisome and amusing R.J. Reynolds document may make you laugh and cry for smokers all at once. It is a compilation of consumer responses to questions about what smokers like and dislike about smoking, and what features they would like to see in cigarettes in the future. The questions were asked as part of market research to help develop new products consumers wanted.
Among the more worrisome items are the comments that reveal the extreme fire hazards cigarettes pose in everyday practice. When asked to identify problems with cigarettes, respondents' comments included:
"If sparks drop off, they should go out immediately rather than burn holes in your clothes,"
and
"Want cigarettes that will go out when sitting in an ashtray."
When asked about their frustrations with cigarettes, comments included:
"I have to hold the cigarette away from myself so the fire doesn't fall on my clothes," and "Holes burned in pants."
When participants were asked to list "situations when you most enjoy cigarettes," one response was:
"Lying in bed."
One person said, "I want a cigarette that puts itself out. It wouldn't be a fire hazard in bed."
Such comments point to a serious fire hazard from cigarettes.
Ironically, to the question "When do you least enjoy cigarettes?" a respondent replied "When I have money problems." But to the question of "When do you smoke the most?" came the response "[When I have] money problems."
When asked how they could make a cigarette that doesn't bother non-smokers, participants' ideas included "Make passive smoke enjoyable and beneficial for everyone to breathe--like a medicated vaporizer," "Provide smokers with gas masks," and "Give non-smokers names to the mob."
To the question, "How to make a cigarette that 'hibernates' when you put it down"? a respondent stated, "Hire a guy with a squirt gun to follow you around." Another more practical smoker suggested leaving out the additives that keep a cigarette burning.
Participants repeatedly requested information on what is in cigarettes and how they are made "so I'll worry less." Other frequent requests were for cigarettes that go out on their own, cigarettes that don't stain teeth, don't stink in an ashtray, don't annoy others, etc.
With regard to future products, smokers were very imaginative, but their ideas reveal a conceptual disconnect between how much they enjoy taking nicotine, and yet how much they dislike smoking cigarettes:
"Something like an insulin pump that is computer controlled to give you the feeling of smoking on a programmed schedule."
"Like the movie 'Total Recall'--a way to make you think you just smoked a cigarette, but you didn't. All you have is the memory of enjoying a cigarette."
"...little chambers is mass-transit vehicles where you can go inside and breathe smoke without even lighting a cigarette,"
and
"Suck smoke from special tubes at the bar and do without individual cigarettes."
Fields
- Quotes
Product Ideas and Problem Identification
DETAILED FINDINGS
Note: The following ideas, thoughts and problems are listed as they [described] by participants in the groups. Particular care was taken during the group discussion not to "lead" or "focus" participants. Good judgement should be used to guide interpretation and application of the ideas and findings.
Product Ideas and Problem Identification
Window on pack so you can tell when only one or two cigarettes remain in the pack.
Make "boxes" quieter so the last few cigarettes aren't so noisy when they rattle around.
Tighter packed tobaccos.
A filter that disappears when the cigarette is put out.
An instant cigarette -- just add water and they puff up -- saves space.
Air freshener in cigarettes so your car doesn't stink.
Take the additives out of cigarettes -- organic tobacco is richer and sweeter.
A way to close a soft pack so the cigarettes don't fall out - resealable soft pack.
Would like to see more endorsemem of motor sports.
A way to relieve the irritation of non-smokers so I can smoke at my desk.
A cigarette that "hibernates" when you put it down. Let it go out without smelling bad -- I'll relight it.
Especially in dry climates, the cello outer wrap gets static electricity and sticks to your hands. The new Winston "wrap" still does it.
If sparks drop off, they should go out immediately rather than burn holes in your clothes.
Recyclable butts.
Want a more full-bodied flavor -- more aromatic, active smoke, no residual.
More tobacco flavor -- less additives to enhance flavor.
Ashtrays that either disintegrate or destroy butts.
Cigarettes that are smokeless for the environment, but the smoker still gets to enjoy smoke.
Advanced filter design.
Cigarettes that are more acceptable for society without violating anyone's rights.
Cigarettes that keep the smoking sensation - the draw, the inhaling, the feel -- but diminish or eliminate smoke and chemical substances.
To make my cigarettes better, take out the additives.
Vending machines with individual code numbers that dispense single cigarettes.
Smokers will be able to smoke anywhere again.
Want more cigarettes per pack: Reduce the smell of stale, lingering, clinging smoke.
I wish cigarettes didn't smell so bad when smoldering in an ashtray.
Hate the smell of stale ashtrays.
Don't like the residual smell of cigarettes in car, on clothes or in my hair.
Why can't they sell all cigarettes at generic prices?
I wish we could get someone to go to battle for smokers on where we can smoke.
Hate the aftertaste and feeling of "shoe-leather" tongue in the morning from smoking.
Cigarettes stain teeth.
Situations when you most enjoy cigarettes:
After dinner.
When watching TV.
After a meal.
Lying in bed.
To cap off total satisfaction.
After sex.
In the morning with coffee.
Relaxing outdoors.
Mellow moments.
Drinking beer.
When working on a project at my desk.
Situations when you least enjoy cigarettes:
In traffic.
When stressed by other people, particularly several people at once.
When there are no-smoking signs staring me in the face.
When I have money problems.
When I smoke too much.
When an ash burns a hole in my clothes.
When I'm sad or angry.
When the smoke burns my eyes and particularly when I am wearing contact lenses.
When non-smokers are watching or glaring or complaining.
Times when you smoke the most:
Smoke when angry or frustrated.
In traffic.
Money problems.
Frustrations with cigarettes:
Smoke in the eyes hurts.
Nagging non-smoking spouse.
When you smoke your last cigarette and don't have any more. Harassment from the non-smoking rabble.
Holes burned in pants.
Filled-up ashtrays.
Emptying the ashtray in my car,
Smelly ashtrays.
"No Smoking" signs.
Odor of smoke
Stains on your fingers.
Expense of cigarettes.
Smell on clothes and in the car.
I have to hold the cigarette away from myself so the fire doesn't fall on my clothes.
Women who smoke are always deanlng their purses and holding them upside down to clean out the spilled tobacco. Embarrassed about smoking because people who don't smoke say kissing them is like kissing the bottom of an ashtray.
- Company
- R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company
- Author
- Dube, M.F.
- RJR
- Delta Research
- Fay, J.E.
- Recipient
- R.J. Reynolds
- Region
- United States
- Type
- REPORT
- Named Person
- Dube, M.F.
- RJR
- Einstein, A.
- Lloyd, R.A.
- Fay, J.E.
- Santa, F.E. Natural Tobacco
- Mcdonalds
- Federal Express
- Starvin Marvin
- Surgeon General
- Dominos Pizza
- Cruise, T.
- Philip Morris
- 7 Eleven
- Fitzen, T.
- Laughman, D.
- Wong, W.
- Peller, C.
- Nascar
- Faino, C.
- Arzonico, B.
- Dufour, W.
- Dept. of Health
- Time Saver
- Mobil
- Circle K.
- Grateful Dead
- B&W
- Subject
- marketing
- marketing research
Document Images
Page 1: vab43d00
~ . : .F ,. .,
eiil
Page 2: vab43d00
I
I
9
I
1
I
i
j
.0
I
I
Who said this?
srrdmk a4a ua,E
-11-~,,Q, ~
~~, " s am "i 7
c.
h
~ T
e ans.ver is...
ALBERT EINSTEIN ~
N
~
R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co.
Research & Development
Creativity Workshop
September 9,10, 1992 .
Hilton Head, SC
~
~
Page 3: vab43d00
Sanaple Letter.Sent To Creatives To Recruit Them
July 1, 1992
0
9
Michael.F. Dube
Et::J:~' Iteyrioid"s Tobacco Co
BGTG~', Bldg. 611-13/301;,
Winston,Salern, NC 27105
: , .. .
~,7.
r.
t;33;
V
'f
;
.
. , , . ;
3oweve,r, througti "a diasto"li c'conflux of genetic and cosmic aberration; a; unique moment -
~_,,
~oluhon ©f the univeXSe~. has3oGc,~urred It has been"determined tHat sr rtt .fiable$
;''
1
+
'
~
L
%F;
r
a
3i'
M
{
It is rumored " that a` creative
genius comes alorig only cince every hundred years or so
.~. ....
e
Fa
.r
'~
i''cW Ctv.~.
i~^ Y a
fi e~nclo~ed)F~ereatrv~ g s~xist at this very moment.' Statisti~ e~'rcherat;a
rG . h 6. .,..;4G~a~ r..,; *c '
~~'as~ er~i ;thml ,~~t~ii ~t ~~ ~v~f n~rmed that the'odds of having s~5 geniu(alive~
k, i, jaGd"' 4FSF ~"
s ve~y,~s~ine time are.only one in a googol (and that it may not happe~ ag tt until the year
L Reynolds Tobacco Company has the distinct pleasure of inviting all six of the
unfiverse's certified creative geniuses toconverge for the purpose of creating a new product
<<.; }
brea,kttiar~ugh ;~or ~the; c~garette busmess. ~ ~ ~ ~~' ~~~
i
4
rr1'} 1 f~
Some° detal ls 'bn the_ event
rr~:r.~
0?ta{K~kil~Z's
t.
1
."1'he site, js,the.Westin Resort at Port Royal Plantation on Hilton
Head Island in,,
,
South Carolina (accommodations' are ieserved in your name). Don't forget to
pack clothes appropriate for getting wet in.
. Please plan to arrive on Tuesday, September 8 (there are no activities planned on
I
"We Work For Smokers"
Tuesday so you can arrive as early or late as you like). The "convergence of
creative genius" will start Wednesday morning with breakfast at 8:00 a.m. and
continue until late Thursday evening, September 10. You may arrange to fly
home Friday morning, or stay and enjoy Hilton Head; however, you're on your
own expense account if you decide to stay after Thursday night.
Ln
W
N
N
r.&

Page 4: vab43d00
-4
r
a
0
;. Make your own air travel arrangements. U. S. Air flies a puddle jumper into
Hilton Head. Or you can fly to Savannah, Georgia, rent a'car, and drive about an
hour, to , Hilton Head. Please be kind and reseie only "coach" airplane seats since
that's_ RJR company pohcy. Your, travel expenses will be reimbursed by RJR
. You,will sbe paid.nan honorarium,of $5,000 for..your participation, and your ,
., , , . . , :
signatur~on a confidentiality agreementwill ~e requ~red.-
other creative genius once'said that, "Invention is 99% perspiration' and 1%
~i'k We have,already done; ~nuch ~bU~ w ot all) of the perspuat~~~;'G° ou will receive in '
~ t' Q~~ne rspir~,~?t. t e b.. o'M~d'atey, ,'} Y ur,~/ h: <, y1 a, e, ore
©
Qcs °a nu num:~6ii-~rauna~iad
tr~
e hning of my stomach is. made ,o
n:.
Che best ;creativit
l
n;`in`iag!tl~;,`~s ,.
tbe' 'F
~
elp' in an~w~~ig "tlie `~otl~"~lhg questio
yssue`;~paper~~~
lummum foil x~f Holes~ `used to
v
exeC cas,e designed to develop.ane
~
0
n
;r
oduct id~,As I have
i3
v
t
J
I enjoy, or think I would enjoy
most enjoy) ...
Golf
Reading a trashy novel
Sweat
Parasailing
Building sand castles
Being pampered
rank order the following with "1" being what you
"We Work For Smokers"
Kayaking
A quiet walk on the beach
Fierce competition
Dinner on a yacht
Tennis

Page 5: vab43d00
I
I
both c.opaes, keep one for your files and return,one autographed copy to me pronto.
. The foods I live for are, (check all that apply) '
Tabasco
Metamucil
Big Mac and fries
Ben & Jerrv's.'
Coffee .- 100 octane,
~
Other
~~~
~~`o~"~~Klf "tlie an, f~ahes'~~
.FtV4-h r t~~. r a
.~S,aadw~~~F
'" M
,
,
. ,
orkshol~,' ~'lease uncierstand that,t
P ear on;' the"r~ aes of USA TodaY~.y, p g ~;
Enclosed with this letter, please find a contract which not only spells out the terms of
payment; but also obtains your consent to maintain all information. confidential, and gives RJR
: exclusive` rights to any and all GREAT ideas resulting from the workshop. ' You need to sign
Call me at (919) 741-4980 with any questions. Have a great day, and I'll be waiting to
see your responses.
Sincerely,
Mike Dube
"We Work For Smokers"
Ln
~
N
N
M
Page 6: vab43d00
I
1
+I
0
I
I
j
I
i
I
J
I
Sample Letter Sent to Creatives After They Agreed to Help
August 18, 1992
1-
Dear 2-,
sections, feedback, obtained from retailers of 7-Eleven
~Indianapolis, Boise and Providence; in the next three (3)
four (4) sections, reactions from consumers in Sante Fe,
I'm glad you found this book!! As promised, here's a
written record of the 'perspiration' completed by us prior to our
upcoming workshop. Within the book, you'll find in the first
convenience stores and independent store owners in Boston; and in
the last section, the results of days spent working the trade
with sales representatives of RJR in three of the six sales
regions in the country.
We expect that you'll read through this book. As you read
please make notes on anything you think is important or creative.
Your objective is to help us reduce this book of information to a
concise summation of the data. We want you to assimilate the
data and find the key learning contained therein. Extract key
elements and major themes; identify new great ideas;
springboard from these ideas to new ideas of your own. We hope
to leave the workshop with a two or three page document which
gets to the heart of all the data on these pages. Remember that
our ultimate goal is to direct long-range product research plans
for RJR which will bear fruit in the years 1995 and beyond.
On the first morning of the workshop each of our six
creative experts, you being one of them, will be asked to present
your summation of this information. We are scheduling 30 minutes
for each of you to do this. Shorter presentations are OK but
longer ones are not acceptable. You may do this anyway you
choose. Handouts and overheads may be used but we prefer that
you use your own creativity to create a presentation which is a
dazzling, brilliant, and insightful analysis which captures and
propels the imaginations of your audience. Please let me know in
advance if you have special A/V requirements or you'll be up the
proverbial creek. By the way, it is mandatory that we have at
least one hardcopy of the content.
J

Page 7: vab43d00
I
I
1
I
I
I
I
I
7
;
I
I
I
j
There are some critical elements we'd like to see
incorporated into your summation. We want to know what you think
and we understand that you're not an expert in cigarettes or
tobacco. In fact, that's why we chose you! What do we want to
know?? Following are seven (7) questions we want you to answer:
1. What are the six (6) most important issues for the
cigarette business?
. Identify at least three (3) trends you envision for
.the future.
What do y'QU 1see as the six (6) `1best product
~improvement icieas y .
4. What are six (6) great non-product ideas that
should be pursued?
5. From all the ideas, which one do you think is the
single biggest idea? Add some of your creative
talent and develop the idea to a stage ready for a
project team to begin work.
6. List six (6) smoker related problems associated
with the use of cigarettes and solve one of them in
a way applicable to current product.
7. Pick one idea on which you'd like to run an
ideation session, and come prepared to run it.
Assume you'll have thirty (30) minutes to doit.
These queetions are to be used as an outline to help focus
your:interpretation of the data and to assist you in pulling
together a presentation. Use creative license anywhere you
please. If you have any questions about what's expected, callll
Have fun!!!
Sincerely,
Mike Dube
I

Page 8: vab43d00
1
BACKGROUND
1
1
i
U
~
I
I
I
7
I
I
J
I
I
The background for this project is best summarized in an excerpt of a 1/24/92 letter from
Mike Dube in RJRT R&D to R.A. Lloyd:
"Current management theory tells us that successful companies are those that
constantly interact with their consumers and know them intimately. At RJR we
continually conduct focus groups and consumer tests to obtain feedback on product,
advertising, promotion and all other elements of our business for the purpose of
guiding business decisions."
"One are where we have failed to involve the consumer is in the arena of new product
Idea generation. We routinely conduct ideation sessions, however, these sessions are
generally done among ourselves or with outside consultants/experts. In reviewing our
documentation, the only studies I've found that asked consumers for information are
large marketing research studies which used questionnaires to solicit input."
"The proposal being forwarded here is to conduct idea generation among consumers
to build a consumer driven idea base which can be used to focus research efforts for
products 3 to 5 years down the road."
"An example may serve to illustrate the approach. In the early 1950's, all cigarettes
sold were non-filtered. A common complaint among consumers at that time was that
tobacco got in the mouth. This was an inconvenience and made the act of smoking
a dirty and sometimes disgusting habit. Such a complaint, on the surface, would
appear to be trivial. Yet, it spawned the filtered cigarette and the current market
situation, dominated by filtered cigarettes is the result. The development of filtered
cigarettes, at that time in the '50s, was probably looked at as a change that would not
revolutionize the industry, but rather as one which could differentiate the market and
generate a solid small share of business. The ideas needed to drive future product
development are probably out there in the minds of our consumers and what is
needed is to tap into that source of ideas and develop executions which truly solve the
problems. Adding a filter to a cigarette must have been a monumental change,
considering that there were no suppliers of filter material and no machines which
could mass produce them or hook them onto cigarettes. Packaging had to undergo
radical changes and so did the thinking of management of the tobacco companies.
The next ideas need to be the filters of the 1990's.
A first set of consumer ideation sessions was held in Santa Fe, NM on March 11-12, 1992.
A second set of consumer groups was held in Indianapolis on March 30-31, 1992. Two
more groups were held with 7-Eleven convenience store managers and clerks in Dallas,
Texas on April 15-16, 1992. A third set of consumer ideation sessions was held in Boise,
Idaho on May 11-12, 1992. A fourth set of consumer ideation sessions was held in
Providence, Rhode Island on May 20-21, 1992. Convenience store owner/operators in
3
Alik'L DELTA RESEARCH

Page 9: vab43d00
I
t
1
I
i
0
0
I
1
]
i
J
~
TI
I
I
j
the Boston area participated in Groups on June 9-10. A second meeting with selected 7-
Eleven convenience store managers and clerks from the Dallas area was held on July 9.
This report details results of four days of sales calls with RJR sales representatives during
the week of July 13.
4 A -
~.- DELTA RESEARCH
Page 10: vab43d00
D E L T A R E S E A R C H
~.---
Marketing Research/Marketing/Product Development
U
I
i
I
i
:.:
f
I
I
I
I
I
J
R.J. REYNOLDS TOBACCO CO.
Constuner Ideation for Produot Development
Stants Fe, New Meadco - March 11-19, 1992
March 1992
Research By:
DELTA RESEARCH
James E. Fay
1049 Kalfahs Street - Neenah, Wisconsin 54956
414n29-9266 FAX 414/729-9254