Abstract
This document is a proposal sent from Covance Laboratory in the United Kingdom in response to an inquiry from Dr. Bruce Davies at the Philip Morris Tobacco Company, who apparently asked Covance about the possibility of performing a scientific investigation "to determine whether the addition of ammonium compounds by cigarettes enhances the avilability of nicotine to the smoker."
The lab sent Dr. Davies this proposal to do the experiment using human subjects. Mark Bentley of Covance proposed that the human subjects would smoke test cigarettes and then have blood samples drawn at various intervals prior to, and after puffing on the test cigarettes. The subjects's blood would then be analyzed to determine the concentration of nicotine in their plasma before and during smoking the cigarettes.
While we don't know if this study was ever done, this correspondence appears to reflect a continued interest by Philip Morris' in finding ways to enhance the delivery of nicotine to the smoker without actually adding more nicotine to their cigarettes.
Page 1: esn67e00
29-10-1997 17 = 03 1=P.OM QI P.OUAL I TY PNAP.MAhIALYS I S TO Lam19mA27i12991 P. la 1
w
covaM'CE-.--"~
TME DEYE6OPMENT SERVICES COfAPAMY
Datc_ 29 Uctot,c.t 1997
From: Mark 13ent[ey
FAX
Covance Laboratories Ltd.
nrlay R'narf
Harrogate
Morth Yorlechiro LIG3 tPY
United Kingdom
Tel: +44-(0)-1423-500011
Fax: +44-(0)-1423-508745
To: Dr Bruce Davies Fax Number: 00 1 804 274 2891
Philip Morris
Copy to: K Phillips, C Swinton
Dr R Carchman, Philip Morris (please copy internally)
Re: Proposed Smoking Study
Pages (including cover): 3
Dear Dr Davies
Further to your recent enquiry regarding an investigation to determine whether the addition of
ammonium compound.5 to cigarettes enharcPS the availability of nicotine to the smoker, it is
proposed that a pilot investigation should be pcrfornied in thc first iFista.ncc, rzs outliulcd
below :-
For this pilot study subjects would be recruited from employees at this site. Ethical
approval for the study will be sought from our clinical research unit based in the City
of Leeds, 15 miles from our Harrogate facility.
Volunteers will be required to give informed consent for participation and will be
screened for height, weight, age and respiratory function to ensure that they are
within normal limits.
The study will be a blind, 4-way crossover design with six subjects recruited,
smoking each test cigarette (eg control + 3 modified units, A-D) i.ti duplicate.
Subject
1 2 3 4 5 6
DAY I
DAY 2
DAY 3
DAY 4
A B C D A B
D A B C D A
C D A B C U
B C D A B C
Using this regime, each subject will smoke two cigarettes of each type under test
conditions (8 cigarettes in total).
(bafidentiality Notice: This facsimile transmi3sion m,ty contain confidontial or logally privilaged
infi rrnation which is intendod only for thc use ofthe
individual or entity nautad on this trattsmittal shccx. If you are not the intended recipient. you
are hereby notified that any disolosure, copyittg. distribution,
or reliance upon the contents of this f<tcsimilo is strictly prohibitcd. Tf you have received this
facsimitc tr.utsmission in otror, plcase notify us immediately
by tclcphone so that we can arrange for the retum of the transmitted matorialc to us at no cost to
you.
N
O
t}S
W
~
O
CW
-p
N
`~3

Page 2: esn67e00
29-10-1997 17:04 FROM AIRQUALITY PHARMANALYSIS TO 001B042742891 P.02
r
29 October 1997
Page 2
-sklbJects shoulct be alloyved to accllmatlze to smoiCing me test elgarettes, ror a perioa
of a few days to a week, prior to the test period_ However, since there will be several
ekiend'~tie
t-igarPttP °`hrnncl" nncler te-;t (control) prior to testing- all the cigarette types.
Subjects will be required to refrain from alcohol consumption for a period of 24 hours
preceding the test period and will bc; rc;striclrCd tc smoking two test cigarettes o.u thc
day of testing until the f nal blood sample has been taken.
Two test cigarettes will be smoked by each subject on each testing occasion (day) and
will be smoked at approximately 4-hour intervals.
Smoking procedure :-
- test cigarettes wili be stored in a controlled environment (22°C, 60%R1-I) for
at least 24 hours prior to use.
each test cigarette will be smoked using a puff prof le analyser capable of
determining puff volume, puff interval, flow rate and pressure change.
following each puff, a fixed volume of air will be inhaled (eg 500 mL) drawn
from an air filled bag and held for 2 seconds prior to normal exhalation
through an acidif ed Cambridgc filter.
the test cigarette will be smoked at a rate of I puff per minute for a total of 7
puffs, all post-puff exhalations passed through the same Cambridge filter.
Blood samples (5 mL by venepuncture of ante-cubital veins) will be taken at the
follow-ing times =-
I minute prior to the f:rst puff
30 and 55 seconds after the first puff
30 seconds after puff 4
1, 15, 30 and 60 minutes after puff 7
Blood samples will bc co.llcctcd into tubcs containing lithium hcparin anticoagulant
and centrifuged; the separated plasma will be transferred into polypropylene tubes
and stored frozen (nominal -20°C) prior to analysis.
Puff profiles recorded for each test cigarette 'smoking' will be used to machine
smoke identical cigarettes and hence determine `total' nicotine delivery.
Carrying out these procedures, as described above, will provide the following information
:-
the total amount of nicotine delivered by each cigarette to each subject on each
smoking occasion.
Confidentiality Notice N This facsimilc tratumission tnay contain confidential or legally pfivileged
inforntation which is intrndcd only for the u_sc of the individttal or entity tu3mad 0
uu thi.ttmJourittui .hcct. ICyou a.e riot iIie iuteadtd recirittnt, you am 1.creFy notit5cd that
any d'ucloatuc, wpyiag, diatribution. or rcaiunco upoo tho (Tti
~rn~mnc. ..f tlt;n far.ain:ile is strieety pmhibitcd. tFyou hnva rwoived thu Rtcaimil4
IrnnGmia;.ion in crror. nlcn.ec notify ua immodietol; by ielaohone Go that ~
we can arrange fbr the rtttun of thc transmitted rnaleriAls to trs at no COst to you Q`t
0
W
~
R1
oz

Page 3: esn67e00
29-10-1997 17:04 FROM AIRQUALITY PHARMANALYSIS TO 001B042742E91 P.03
.,:
r
29 October 1997
Page 3
concentration profiles Iar nicotine in plasma during and following each smoking
occasion enabling the calculation of pharmacokinetic parameters (t,,, tmnx, Cn,;,x,
AUC (0-t, t-oo, 0-0o))
total amount of nicotine exhaled immediately follow-ing puff inhalation.
Statistical evaluation of the information provided will be performed to evaluate any potential
differences in nicotine availability to the smoker between each of the test cigarettes investigated.
A provisional cost of £25,600 has been estimated for this pilot investigation, as described, to
include the following elements
Ethical approval
Subject remuneration (6 subjects)
Sampling costs (3 persons @ 4 days)
Sample analysis, plasma nicotine (384 samples)
Pharmacokinetic analysis
Statistical analysis
Management
Reporting
# Analysis of mainstream. (MS) tar and nicotine as smoked on study (48 samples)
# Analysis of exhaled nicotine (48 samples)
# Analysis of test cigarette ammonium phosphate (`salt') content
# Analysis of test cigarette MS tar and nicotine yields
# NB Covance Laboratories Ltd do not have a puff profile analyzer or a smoking machine
suitable for determining MS tar and nicotine yields. The analyses highlighted above may be
performed by another facility on our behalf (eg LABSTAT Inc). The above cost estimate does
not include the cost for these highlighted analyses.
I hope that this draft proposal meets with your approva.#l and look forward to receiving your
comments on the ideas that have been put forward. Once you have had a chance to review the
contents of the proposal, perhaps it would be appropriate to arrange another conference call, or a
meeting to further discuss your requirements in more detail. Please give Carolyn Swinton, Keith
Phillip's secretary, a call to arrange a suitable i'orum at your convenience. At Keith's request,
please can you make sure that Richard Carl:chman receives a copy of this communication.
Many thanks and kind regards
Mark Bentley BSc CChem MRSC
Study Director
Department of Air Quality Monitoring
for Covance Laboratories Ltd
Confidentiality Notice
This 1lcsimilt transmission may contain conrsdential or Iogally privilcgcd information which is
intcndcd only for the use of the indiv iduaf or entity named
on this transmittal sheet, if you are not the inrcndcd recipient, you are hereby notiGed that any
disclosure, copying, distribution, or reliance upon the
eontcnt4 ofthis facsimile is strictly ptohibiteei, if,you have received this f:tcsimile
traiLSmigsion in ctmr, please notifjy us immediately by tclephone so that
we can arrungc for the rcttun of the transmitted materials to us at no cost to you
