Anne Landman's Collection
Business Planning & Analysis 850300
Abstract
Buried in this 1985 Philip Morris (or PM, now Altria) Business Planning and Analysis report are subjects of interest to public health authorities and the general public. Among these are PM's plans to increase cigarette marketing to ethnic groups and minorities: [From page 27, Bates Page 2043599745]:
"...The use of black models will be expanded in POS [point-of-sale] displays for B&H [Benson & Hedges] and Virginia Slims to gain exposure in black markets...
...To more effectively reach ethnic smokers, advertising will be modified and targeted locally while sponsorship of ethnic promotional events will increase..."
The report also discusses the maintenance of tobacco farmers as a "valuable resource and political base for PM-USA and the industry...the U.S. tobacco growier is the most sympathetic voice of the tobacco industry."
Starting on page 33 {Bates Page 2043599751] however, is a startling section entitled "SOCIOPOLITICAL STRATEGY" in which Philip Morris (PM) reveals remarkably aggressive plans to "maximize industry volume by blunting attacks from anti-cigarette advocates and improving public perceptions of smoking." PM's plans include maintaining a tobacco leaf purchase program to help the company continue to manipulate U.S. Congressional representatives into supporting their company's objectives. PM also outlines its intent to circumvent campaign finance reform laws to help meet its ends:
"State political action conmittees will be created to make contributions to key political decision-makers in states where direct corporate contributions are not permitted."
PM also planned a comprehensive program to influence the public on smoking issues:
[From Page 34, Bates No. 2043599752]:
"Lobbying alone cannot stop the anti-smoking movement or influence an indifferent public and media that tolerate fanatical anti-smoking activities...Direct and aggressive action is required to combat the anti-smoking movement by enlisting public support. PM-USA is developing a comprehensive program of identification, education, recruitment, communication and mobilization to reach out to the smoking and non-smoking public."
Perhaps PM's most ambitious plans, however, involved manipulating the mass media in its favor. PM planned a massive program to monitor news coverage of tobacco issues nationwide and act on reporting it considered negative:
"The mass media, like political decision-makers, require a special program. The goal of PM-USA's program is to achieve a more balanced presentation of positions in the media. The target audience is the print and broadcast editors, who influence the general public. For the print media, PM-USA will develop a computerized "objectivity index" to monitor articles and editorials on smoking in daily newspapers throughout the U.S. This index will allow PM-USA to detect media that is imbalanced and respond accordingly."
Responses included "rebuttal pieces, letters to the editor from allies, meetings with editorial boards, special press briefings and cultivation of editors and journalists through special events."
User-Contributed Notes
- p. 1 ethnic targeting
Fields
- Quotes
[From page 27, Bates Page 2043599745]: ...POS [point of sale] materials are effective in targeting ethnic smokers without changing major media advertising... The use of black models will be expanded in POS displays for B&H [Benson & Hedges] and Virginia Slims to gain exposure in black markets...
...To more effectively reach ethnic smokers, advertising will be modified and targeted locally while sponsorship of ethnic promotional events will increase...
• Black and Hispanic models, as well as Spanish translations, will be used in ethnic magazines and newspapers...
[From Page 33, Bates No. 2043599751]:
SOCIOPOLITICAL STRATEGY
During the last ten years, the incidence of cigarette smoking in the U.S. has declined from 39 percent of the adult population in 1974 to 33 percent in 1984. Contributing to this decrease were a number of external factors -- adverse publicity on the health effects of smoking, unfair taxation and laws that restrict smoking in public places. Attacks on the industry have become more visible and threatening in recent years, with a further impact on cigarette consumption. As publicly stated by Surgeon General Koop, the ultimate objective of these attacks is a smoke-free society by the end of the century.
PM-USA's strategic objective is to maximize industry volume by blunting attacks from anti-cigarette advocates and improving public perceptions of smoking. The severity of the threats facing the industry dictates that PM-USA's tactics become increasingly aggressive in the future. Four major challenges are expected during the plan period:
• Social ostracism of smokers as a result of unfavorable perceptions of the smoking and health controversy, effective lobbying by anti-smoking groups and restrictive smoking laws.
• Restrictions on the type of cigarettes sold and how they are sold, including advertising/sampling bans, self-extinguishing cigarette bills and tax-based constraints on pack size.
• Pressure for higher excise taxes by federal, state and local governments.
• Unbalanced media reporting.
To address these issues and counter the anti-smoking movement, PM-USA is developing programs that target political decision-makers, smokers and benign non-smokers and them mass media.
Political Decision-Makers
The key group of political decision-makers represent the tobacco states. No political program, regardless of its effectiveness, can equal the impact of the tobacco growing representatives in Congress and the southern states. A leaf purchase program which is responsive to tobacco farmers is the best strategy to retain support of these allies. Alienating this constituency would have profound negative effects on the industry's ability to defend its interests, especially at the federal level.
PM-USA is taking actions to improve its ability to participate directly in the political process. To influence federal, state and local politicians, a regional public affairs network is being established to monitor and combat legislation (in conjunction with the Tobacco Institute) unfavorable to PM-USA interests. State political action committees will be created to make contributions to key political decision makers in states where direct corporate contributions are not permitted.
Smokers and Non-Smokers
While direct lobbying can obstruct or slow the imposition of legal restrictions on smoking, it is not effective in every instance. Lobbying alone cannot stop the anti-smoking movement or influence an indifferent public and media that tolerate fanatical anti-smoking activities.
Direct and aggressive action is required to combat the anti-smoking movement by enlisting public support. PM-USA is developing a comprehensive program of identification, education, recruitment, communication and mobilization to reach out to the smoking and non-smoking public. This program has three goals:
• Secure the freedom to smoke without fear of ridicule or social ostracism.
• Make the public aware that PM-USA and the industry have a valid and reasonable case on the smoking issue.
• Put anti-smoking groups on the defensive.
As potential allies are identified, they will participate in a comprehensive communication program on smoking issues designed to appeal to the concerns of each group. Individuals will be entered into a political mobilization system to identify voting districts and elected representatives. When political threats arise, advanced mobilization techniques will be utilized to encourage these groups to communicate with political decision-makers.
Mass Media
The mass media, like political decision-makers, require a special program. The goal of PM-USA's program is to achieve a more balanced presentation of positions in the media. The target audience is the print and broadcast editors, who influence the general public. For the print media, PM-USA will develop a computerized "objectivity index" to monitor articles and editorials on smoking in daily newspapers throughout the U.S. This index will allow PM-USA to detect media that is imbalanced and respond accordingly. Responses will include:
• Rebuttal pieces.
• Letters to the editor from allies.
• Meetings with editorial boards.
• Special press briefings.
• Cultivation of editors and journalists through special events.
In addition to redressing media imbalances, the comprehensive communication program will generate media articles and academic pieces on the negative effects of excise taxation, the suppression of research questioning the adverse health effects of cigarette use, the social engineering fanaticism of anti-smoking groups and the rights of smokers. Advocacy advertising will also be explored as a way to communicate PM-USA's side of the issues.
- Region
- United States
- Named Organization
- BAT, British American Tobacco
- BAT US
- BW, Brown & Williamson
- Congress
- Grandmet
- Liggett
- Loews
- Lorillard
- Mckinsey
- Readers Digest
- RJR, R.J.Reynolds
- TI, Tobacco Inst
- American Tobacco
- Named Person
- Gori, Gio Batta, Ph.D. (Tobacco Consultant, formerly w/ NCI, Industry Expert)1993 Started career at NCI and then went to work for the industry. Believed a safer cigarette could be made, and that there were safe threshold levels for exposure to the chemicals in cigarette smoke.
- Koop, C. Everett, M.D. (Surgeon General ('81-'89))former US Surgeon General (1981-1989)
- Litigation
- Stmn/Produced
- Type
- REPT, REPORT, OTHER
- CHAR, CHART, GRAPH, TABLE, MAPS
- NOTE, NOTE
- Subject
- target market
- Target/ethnic (targeting ethnic markets)
- Political Action Committee
- political interference
- Political participation
- Corporate philanthropy (Company giving behavior)The giving of money to causes by a company, usually in a manner that makes the company appear altruistic to the public. Corporate philanthropy is usually done to achieve public relations or political gains.
- Corporate strategy
- Social Acceptability (Social acceptability of smoking)The industry fought the decline in social acceptability of smoking through public relations campaigns, legislation, etc.
- social influence
- social policy
- Fire Safe Cigarettes (Products)
Document Images









