Abstract
This strategic plan by Philip Morris (PM) Corporate Affairs Department in Europe describes PM's strategies for fighting the progression of smoke-free laws in Europe between 1994 and 1996.
PM labeled as "threats" both voluntary and legislated smoking restrictions in workplaces, public places and on public transport, as well as conferences held to discuss smoking and health. PM's "overall objectives" were to protect smoking as a permitted activity, prevent legislation the company believed was adverse to its interests, "promote private sector policies that accommodate smokers" and "mitigate [the] impact of [International Agency for Research on Cancer] ETS study," which PM anticipated would mirror conclusions already reached in the U.S. that exposure to secondhand smoke was harmful.
PM's attack plan included delaying smoking restrictions within the European Community (EC), "locking in" the company's own model legislation in multiple countries, promoting policies that preserve smoking in workplaces, "pre-empting sub-national bans with suitable national legislation," creating an information bureau in Brussels, Belgium to "counteract pressure of antis" by "disseminating favourable views" about tobacco, creating additional smokers' rights groups in Italy, Spain, France, the Netherlands and Greece, and increasing assistance to existing groups already set up in Denmark and the United Kingdom. Other activities included portraying U.S. efforts to control where people can smoke to the European media as "extremist, indicative of intolerance and health fascism," defeating an EC directive to eliminate smoking from public transport, and much, much more.
This document reveals not only the extent of PM's corporate strategies to fight public health efforts in Europe, but also demonstrates the depth of this American company's intent to interfere in European affairs.
Fields
- Quotes
I. THE EUROPEAN CONTEXT
RESULTS OF PM BENCHMARK 1992 SHOW :
- SMOKERS UNDER.HIGH AND INCREASING DEGREE OF SOCIAL PRESSURE: 57% OF SMOKERS FEEL UNCOMFORTABLE WHEN SMOKING AROUND NON-SMOKERS
- NON-SMOKERS PERCEIVE HEALTH RISK:
86% OF POPULATION BELIEVES ETS TO BE HARMFUL
- GROWING SUPPORT FOR RESTRICTIONS ON PUBLIC SMOKING : 79% SUPPORT SMOKING BANS IN INDOOR PUBLIC PLACES AND 60% THINK THAT SMOKING SHOULD BE RESTRICTED BY LAW
II. THREATS AND TRENDS
1. EUROPEAN COMMUNITY '89 COUNCIL RESOLUTION TO BAN SMOKING IN PUBLIC PLACES (HORECA EXCLUDED)
--'89 DIRECTIVE ON HEALTH AND SAFETY IN THE WORKPLACE "IN REST ROOMS AND REST AREAS APPROPRIATE MEASURES MUST BE INTRODUCED FOR THE PROTECTION OF NON-SMOKERS AGAINST DISCOMFORT CAUSED BY TOBACCO SMOKE"
- '93 PROPOSED DIRECTIVE TO BAN SMOKING ON PUBLIC TRANSPORT (TO PROTECT WORKERS)
- '95 STRICTER RESOLUTION ON PUBLIC PLACE SMOKING BANS LIKELY
- '95 POTENTIAL DIRECTIVE ON SMOKING IN THE WORKPLACE
2. MEMBER STATES - TREND TOWARDS LEGISLATIVE SMOKING RESTRICTIONS WILL CONTINUE, BUT CAN BE MANAGED...
III. OVERALL OBJECTIVES
• PROTECT CONSUMERS ABILITY TO USE OUR PRODUCTS
• PREVENT ADVERSE LEGISLATION
• PROMOTE PRIVATE SECTOR POLICIES THAT ACCOMMODATE SMOKERS
• MITIGATE IMPACT OF IARC ETS STUDY
- Company
- Philip Morris
- Author
- Philip Morris Corporate Affairs Europe
- Recipient
- Presumed recipient, Philip Morris
RegionEurope
LitigationStmn/Produced
Named Organization93 Focus Group
Alitalia
ARISE, Assoc. for Research in Science of Enjoyment (Industry scientific front group promoting "pleasure")Association for Research in the Science of Enjoyment (1994)-Industry-funded scientific group out of the United Kingdom which proclaimed that a little pleasure is essential to good health. Created to combat tobacco control initatives. Previously knows as Associates for Research in Substance Enjoyment. Grouped tobacco use with pleasureable activities such as drinking tea, shopping, and eating chocolate.
Basp
Brussels Tobacco Information Office
*EPA ( use United States Environmental Protection Agency)
European Chefs Assn
European Community
European Community Commission
European Community Council
European Community Joint Research Centre
European Confederation Natl Hotel Restau
European Parliament
Horeca (Hotels, Restaurants and Catering/Cafes)European acronym for an association of hotels, restaurants and cafes or caterers in the European Economic Community. Also seen spelled as "Ho.Re.Ca" or referred to as the Horecasector. Businesses or individuals pay membership dues to belong to Horeca.
International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) (WHO cancer research arm)International Agency for Research on Cancer - The cancer research arm of the WHO. Conducted a multi-center epidemiology study on ETS, initiated in 1988, data collection completed in 1994 and results were published in 1998
ICAO (Int'l Civic Aviation Organization)Int'l Civic Aviation Organization
Intl Horeca
Ix World Conference on Smoking or Health
National Manufacturers Association (Defense groups for cigarette companies worldwide)In places around the world where these associations did not exist, the tobacco industry created them to help defeat public health efforts around tobacco.
Philip Morris Crisis Communications Team
SRG - Smokers Rights Group
Smokers Rights Groups (Groups set up by tobacco companies)Smokers Rights Groups (SRGs) were created clandestinely by the major tobacco companies of Philip Morris and R.J. Reynolds (usually through public relations firms) to produce the appearance of "grass roots" opposition to laws restricting smoking in public places. The U.S. SRG, set up by Philip Morris, was the National Smokers Alliance. European groups had names like HEN-RY, Smokepeace and FOREST.
TypeSPCH, SPEECH, PRESENTATION
Subjectindustry activity
industry influence
industry response
industry strategy
Political Influence (How the industry develops and applies political influence)
political interference
Document Images
Page 1: hmd34e00
PHILIP MORRIS CORPORATE AFFAIRS EUROPE
SMOKING RESTRICTIONS 3 YEAR PLAN 1994-1996
I. THE EUROPEAN CONTEXT
II. THREATS AND TRENDS
Ill. OVERALL OBJECTIVES
IV. IARC STUDY
OBJECTIVES
ACTIONS
V. THE WORKPLACE
OBJECTIVES
ACTIONS
VI. PUBLIC PLACES
OBJECTIVES
ACTIONS
4Tc4Gtszoz
Page 2: hmd34e00
I. THE EUROPEAN CONTEXT
RESULTS OF PM BENCHMARK 1992 SHOW :
- SMOKERS UNDER HIGH AND INCREASING DEGREE OF SOCIAL PRESSURE :
57% OF SMOKERS FEEL UNCOMFORTABLE WHEN SMOKING AROUND NON-
SMOKERS
SMOKERS
- NON-SMOKERS PERCEIVE HEALTH RISK :
86% OF POPULATION BELIEVES ETS TO BE HARMFUL
- GROWING SUPPORT FOR RESTRICTIONS ON PUBLIC SMOKING :
79% SUPPORT SMOKING BANS IN INDOOR PUBLIC PLACES AND
60% THINK THAT SMOKING SHOULD BE RESTRICTED BY LAW
-
8'IE'LGtSZOZ
Page 3: hmd34e00
II. THREATS AND TRENDS
1. EUROPEAN COMMUNITY
-`89 COUNCIL RESOLUTION TO BAN SMOKING IN PUBLIC PLACES
(HORECA EXCLUDED)
-`89 DIRECTIVE ON HEALTH AND SAFETY IN THE WORKPLACE
"IN REST, ROOMS AND REST AREAS APPROPRIATE MEASURES MUST BE
-
INTRODUCED FOR THE PROTECTION OF NON-SMOKERS AGAINST
DISCOMFORT CAUSED BY TOBACCO SMOKE"
-`93 PROPOSED DIRECTIVE TO BAN SMOKING ON PUBLIC TRANSPORT (TO
PROTECT WORKERS)
-`95 STRICTER RESOLUTION ON PUBLIC PLACE SMOKING BANS LIKELY
-`95 POTENTIAL DIRECTIVE ON SMOKING IN THE WORKPLACE
6Tc46ti!;ZOZ
Page 4: hmd34e00
THREATS AND TRENDS
2. MEMBER STATES
- TREND TOWARDS, LEGISLATIVE SMOKING RESTRICTIONS WILL CONTINUE,
BUT CAN BE MANAGED
»`87 BELGIUM : ROYAL DECREE AFFECTING RESTAURANTS
»`92 UK : IMPLEMENTATION OF EC DIRECTIVE ON HEALTH AND SAFETY
IN THE WORKPLACE
»`92 FRANCE : ADOPTION OF LOI EVIN
»`93 BELGIUM : ROYAL DECREE AFFECTING WORKPLACE
»`90-93 ITALY : SIX PROPOSED LEGISLATIVE BILLS ON PUBLIC SMOKING
» SPAIN : VARIOUS REGIONAL RESTRICTIONS (GALICIA, CATALONIA,
BASQUE)
oZcLGjvszaz
Page 5: hmd34e00
THREATS AND TRENDS
2. MEMBER STATES (Cont)
- INCREASING PRIVATE WORKPLACE INITIATIVES TO RESTRICT SMOKING IN
RESPONSE TO :
» STATUTORY REQUIREMENTS
>> INSURANCE COSTS/WORKER COMPENSATION CLAIMS
>> EMPLOYEE COMPLAINTS
TzE'Z,GtSZOz
Page 6: hmd34e00
THREATS AND TRENDS
3. INTERNATIONAL
- IARC : 11 COUNTRY ETS STUDY CENTERED IN EUROPE; PRELIMINARY
RESULTS EXPECTED MID-'94. LIKELY TO REFLECT EPA FINDINGS AND
PRECIPITATE MORE STRINGENT RESTRICTIONS/BANS
- ICAO : IN 1992 ADOPTED RESOLUTION URGING COUNTRIES TO BAN SMOKING
ON NATIONAL CARRIERS AND CONSIDERING BINDING STANDARD TO BAN
SMOKING GLOBALLY ON ALL COMMERCIAL AIRCRAFT
- THE IXth WORLD CONFERENCE ON SMOKING OR HEALTH, PARIS, OCTOBER
1994, WILL LIKELY ESCALATE PRESSURE FOR FURTHER RESTRICTIONS.
zzc4Gtszoz
Page 7: hmd34e00
III. OVERALL OBJECTIVES
PROTECT CONSUMERS ABILITY TO USE OUR PRODUCTS
PREVENT ADVERSE LEGISLATION
PROMOTE PRIVATE SECTOR POLICIES THAT ACCOMMODATE SMOKERS
MITIGATE IMPACT OF IARC ETS STUDY
czcLGvszOz
Page 8: hmd34e00
IV. IARC ETS STUDY
OBJECTIVES
SEEK MOST ACCURATE AND OBJECTIVE WORDING OF STUDY CONCLUSIONS
AND OFFICIAL STATEMENT OF RESULTS
MITIGATE POTENTIAL NEGATIVE IMPACT OF THE STUDY ON :
- REGULATORY AND LEGISLATIVE ACTION
- MEDIA
- PRIVATE SECTOR WORKPLACE POLICIES
- GENERAL PUBLIC
tzcLGtszoz
Page 9: hmd34e00
IARC ETS STUDY
ACTIONS
GET ORGANISED
- PM TEAM TO MANAGE IMPACT OF THE STUDY HAS BEEN ESTABLISHED
- CREATE WORKING GROUPS AT PM REGIONAL LEVEL TO ENSURE PLANS ARE
CONSISTENT AND IMPLEMENTED GLOBALLY
- INITIATE AND LEAD INDUSTRY-WIDE COORDINATED EFFORTS TO ENSURE
CONSISTENCY OF STRATEGY AND EFFICIENT USE OF RESOURCES
Page 10: hmd34e00
IARC ETS STUDY
ACTIONS
SEEK MOST ACCURATE AND OBJECTIVE WORDING OF STUDY CONCLUSIONS AND
OFFICIAL STATEMENT OF RESULTS
- ESTABLISH LINKS,WITH IARC
- MOBILIZE SCIENTIFIC RESOURCES IN THE 11 COUNTRIES PARTICIPATING IN
THE STUDY TO :
>> ESTABLISH CONTACT WITH STUDY RESEARCHERS
» DETERMINE MEANS OF EXPLAINING SHORTCOMINGS OF STUDY
METHODOLOGY
» TRACK PROJECT STATUS AND PREPARE TIMETABLE FOR STUDY
COMPLETION
9zc4Gtszoz