Jump to:

Industry-Provided Depositions

Antonio Cipollone, Individually, and As Executor of the Estate of Rose D. Cipollone, Plaintiff, - Vs - Liggett Group, Inc., Defendants. Transcript of Proceedings. Afternoon Session. Civil Action No. 83-2864

Date: 31 May 1988
Length: 55 pages
85861680-85861734
Jump To Images
snapshot_lor 85861680-85861734

Fields

Type
DEPO, DEPOSITION/TRIAL TRANSCRIPT
Alias
85861680/85861734
Area
LEGAL DEPT FILE ROOM/TRNSCRPTS & EXHBTS
Recipient (Organization)
Usdc District Nj
Named Person
Cipollone, A.
Cipollone, R.D.
Recipient
Sarokin, H.L.
Date Loaded
12 Feb 1999
Named Organization
Budd Larner
Lig, Liggett
Loews Theatres
PM, Philip Morris
Author (Organization)
Shb, Shook,Hardy & Bacon
Stryker Tams
Webster Sheffield
Wilentz Goldman
Arnold Porter
Brown Connery
Greenbaum Rowe
Lig, Liggett
Lor, Lorillard
PM, Philip Morris
Author
Bleakley, P.K.
Cohn, D.J.
Darnell, A.M.
Decker, F.
Drozdowski, R.F.
Edell, M.Z.
Kearney, J.
Naar, A.S.
Northrip, R.E.
Parrish, S.
Silfen, T.S.
Tucker, W.S., J.R.
Walters, C.
Litigation
Stmn/Produced
Site
N14

Document Images

Text Control

Highlight Text:

OCR Text Alignment:

Image Control

Image Rotation:

Image Size:

Page 1: zlz30e00
Im "iO6 QVITSD ""tS DxSTitIGT OWST plfit '!S= t3IS'l1tIC! Of UM Jx"x'Y CYvil ASiiab lio. 81-?ifi t81!} .N: w w .. .. w. .. ! .. • .w w. .o .. .. .r • + ~ Mri at ~tor O! tha sstat~r t ~ ~. C~pOl1Mt~ es l1Aiftitgip DeftAdiOtir 1 t t Motatlt s 1/1Mrt Jetwly ia0o= I00Ws 2W.t a Onr~taljo&# ' ~ . IlaC.. a "ir *a:1t tlarpsiaat.S, s 4. w • .r w ... .. •. .r w .r • • .. .r. .r r •. a st QS8s y R R ~ ~r ix. 1l" - ~MGM`.S Ss Mm S..wwwIS MlIM STAT" mta"=f 'Im" Srr7iAltAACSSo Sm. WMINs. flR4SS, tICIWOO. ~Si1~dAqM, =KSSS= i WK. S!©S. r syi 11A~tC t. wzfiLs SSQ. i C.'Y1A 11,iMOa 8$Q. l~O~rB~lt~b1 i S~"Xl~S~. ~QB. r MILiM8' Ut ALW !1. DAMWOLS m• t ittorwwr tos tba Ylaiatilt. ANWW a rOtTIM, r~S.. a I iS'P!1! R. '~lRtalt. ~?.. no Ta01" t. 3ILlilt0 sSQ. Attetmoys tOt thr nltferiaatt. P4t1Lf Ilaesiss fta"at tv li.eetisn 7$3 TWar 39 VaitM Statss Ca4*, tre lOliaeinq tiraaadsipt is atrltlftai tE• 6t aa **"g.t. stoori as takes st""raphis"ir i.w ttrt aliew--metitlai rC*oa.il*". pul"Ii !. SiMS. fr'.SRA. Ot'lEtial Cout ts • IlrrAtai Sl~ator 0iaac~et Cour c p.d. M~a ff~~rrk. 11.m Joraw OTfei ~ cn m ~ ~ GO 0 PHTU18 'F. t.91l3r CSR' 4P$"ICIA1. CwI!'Ti Rmies t* mmmm. N,7
Page 2: zlz30e00
I 2 3 4 S i I J1 f t R A R A il Ca3 t (Cw4iAuid) ~RAM. ~01tS, 8~lITN, RAVIN, DATxS • s iNpi.. U1 AWN a. YAM M. r ~Sad- WOMMM i MRwrIv.9. TJQX.. 8!i POULD ,. CMt BOO.. .YiRta iMARM. M.t muIiCls nICK0i4 mQf "tMrs"rs fet bsiss"w!„ i.i9.tE. $INIMR i i.'M II1000 Ri04.. 1t"t Wom t* iilOLIM IQM'RRts Mo@+ e &**"t~rs e2 f~rds~~ PAill~sls. STLlIUMO TAM i VZLLf MW. r 1Tt MZLLIAIi S. TMI1' 1a JR. 0 iSQs. »slidl- ,NDOR# awT i NAGQ1iP tw.. ~Y 1 ST"n tAMSU1 m. i RQSm so i1amRx t. RsQ. . AttOcs !©r esEfndsA~ta, tl~iit~r=i.O aam tsrillaa®. PNIY.LI3 T. Lwi$. CSR,r t2tfICIAt". CAQR'!' itma'Pl6R. MEfiAU. W
Page 3: zlz30e00
I 3 3 4 5 i is 12033 tMay 3l. ].Ft8. ? 1`B8 CQQRT1 Good attscsoAm. Fiatrar be rsatad. llft. ItAn: I tkiMc yau y#t the stss&" tkat a crwple ot atta:a.rys c:af tiwatouc sW "69ttate'r tISa$s tlfiti siC btoke f#om mIl I wwlfi pt#1glE illit Mt llaZd o!!r Lf PNs.W1f. s"tI tkey yrt W** !ii Owl 1f+l1o t.w 4"y ptabissf I 11wa is that I lott m.tis matttr` at 4 i* g10ot. I lhim w"t I as i. la taka eore rf a.u.birr of the.a thlqs. I an J"t qatti" r*AgMs as tbo raaord aad At 46ytslai arqairus dls0r"i+wr. I rill Ii" thsn tho ebrwe Wken t3Nry ierlw. ona trta4t l.t ao p+rse a qawClom to aems..i tbat atosa Wken I spent Youwelay la.lcs" +rt tIM. }sry eiearq.. I VilI llrMtt lt first to pisiutiffs. Uri tinr F1,aiotitts osmtrAd t3wt pe.t-lilid swkLaq by Nes. CAg*#,1ea* is reisy&mt +rn thr issua at Frasi.ata s•aase? fqt. DA1lMa.s etlwa yonr Foaor says •prosi.atS $au.f, • is your saaer "trrq to tAe oaoaaA st,ag. of prosimato aw..r ,N~t. ~i.~.~ Y tttsM lt Rs~ s..~s. t~ ~esictsa we have talcam, io that tlrs Pew-im :lqar.ttas •» iat vs auNs t.r aaiwat • tta w r a+ist0ot f rrt. Mum 00mokssd wi t t 11 "YT.LIS T. LSWTS, WR. t,1!'rtCI1lL COURT RzP0XM, XMMta NJ
Page 4: zlz30e00
1 2 3 4 3 i 7 11034 the poot-'6i cigarstt.s, ass=* tbey aco AGaA.f*at3wt, itti1 asa a oa~staotia3 faateu. tu stiweirt rf4t4i ~- aa4 riss the pttr2 Sii o Lqmsrttaas arsated tiog 93n C(MO!!S: L!t ths toe"d uotE tMat 1tt. Cirm +tsd ft. lttrataW ar c f r.d aud i&aas jsst bern. M. KURMI 431aOk rdYe ftt #pW"IAM. Ot1C "9 b[lliht i"l1. !Ns Wish I radssotarri« MU MtML+t As t wa aWi"# tM• psMllii ai4actttg that ats. Cipaixow +M.ek", it t,t Ger ptrsitiaNr ri" 11et deptAdMt Yrm the IL" tf oi1ar,ottia lA 41ASial r Whiok raa a taotoc ln etaaalaq ber to va. ol9arstts af t.r igiiv wea tAosA ttwss poat-' id oi1acettMS ary not have bol. +i.ftetivad they stti3, plary a cois. TIR Cams a. art yes ragiaq W"t i! tAo lazy +saas to f iw that ow actx of os* oc out of the Wisdaata oa+rsf4 Mss to bsqta sftokisq p~ts-~3i, tut the only way that the jary oKl4 ati.iisr paart-'if Mo4ia4 .o t!e pcoutaats osas isasa vt her ilaasaa aad l+u" aaaamr vaarld be i3 th.y found that sm was addlats4 or tot oawr rsa+asa Gors2d aot qivM it up? M+R. Aom"Lt I rrrMtlA Ny'. YsU satlose that y#a, but to tlA .xt.nlt that aqaio ysw go b+riok to dbe sawstaftew or a.otribrbiag 1autor iasv., r*v ow baw two pataa vhiok wr Gosdfni arws the i.ajuryr a. Y*" " tht pcar»1"i ett9&slttsa DHYLLxS 3". L8G[I3o M. OFPICIJ13. COM RM- RTIit. M!6tAlRX. N.7
Page 5: zlz30e00
I 2 3 • 3 9 7 12035 wtrr of a ssb:Eaatlal coatcauRiaq favror. ftu faQtt tbat the post••it Gitaretts aignt also bavs saatcibwt.i do" aot ..au that we fail an aas burM# af ptsYia! oaasatio.. !8i EoOUl: Al i r ight. Nut ttwa th.rs a so roaaan to doal with tbe posL•-' i! s.*la9. L# YOw ar. riSht, aaW ym ssa 0"iftalp ir iqpt .n the hw. .f va"tisa is % gr ve ts,tl tlW lea tbst tbsy saa s+r"td" p"t-l"d am.ki" fas' +urr !otl~..• "w, the d.toaSastsM be,rad Gp.a arr .aclia diaaa"i.+Ns rill se"ett that pst-`!! sr"iaq ir r*l.vaut to sbot that .k+e osatioed to 4aNta d"pit* tAs rraraiala. eo tlr.ir psaiti.w if th.y iat.nd to fallorr it is visr ai.ar# asd i t4ilut it is mielraat lot that putprzr. I vaat~t to knW +eb*tbor the plaiatit€ vill aeqntead ta,t paat-'!i naatis! is t.l*+rast fat aaY Periose* M. DARMLLs aaly tb. VwcP0004 tb4t I diaosaS". 4t aWraoR Mf aro sst abasdosisl .ut ClaiM that psst•'!i sSm+e"sao of the tblrd Metias is sttil is the 4400. Tu COUR'!s Only tal.ktas +tbout krr sotaally ,omaki" alyatottN atttr 1liit m. DARNWAI Of rMtltse« joi1! 1tM" !s Ciq"riaq as to asswme that the 4*fo0i..ats will bS all.w.d to arvu to em j"T aad say rwi s,,,tyht seasi+#ft b.r aso of os vssottts afttr 1!i4 is 00sid.rstion ef y4mr detasst,aatlaa a6 to Pfl7fLirlS T. s.Silf , C8lt. tltMe^.IAL CO31t? iRMA'rVa. WWARS. NJ
Page 6: zlz30e00
I 2 3 4 s i I t ! 11 12 13 14 ~ lf Ii 12036 vtieth.r "e rsasanably aa,d +rsl.aAtas tly tssount#cad the €iak of suokioq. It i" b..n +sAr P+asltto. a)i tdraQtlwat, altbWqh we oaa't Qo.lt lisbi 1 i ty on tkrs pest-• S6 smoJtiiy !oc tMt saar raasaa,r la tw,da.axttal fairnas., .nd we at"i ad aar~stta~rr, tlM.y shoa1da 't be able to talit abvrt it, 1146 est .rt th. Qaale. !U COMe rraaitiy. N.b.ft at this patnt bas g:rnea .o aay r.qsast rt9stitiMy the s.lNrsoft .f poat-• ii sm"l". AaxOte that is tho aay iouqht to l+rave it, out Wat aoaasrn.d as vas VCaotioally r,wty bit af tba shat" t:alXtd abortt Pus-=lti oaodiot by lltrs. Cipoilsim a" by tha dryiadsata, and I an rnrardwr ial what ril i hap".a !ua tl* J*xy tom if aay8sdy sryyf*ta that tlors psst-•i8 st.olttaq ts tala,raat tot sarW PspWW. XM. GandLt.s I trilaitf Yout AaMerf we awbisitt+Kd a abass tAat said that htc crn4wrt 1" eooltial ofvarfttfs pest-•ii was rwtybt siiqAtly ditlsssat fto, what yout 8aeag is Goaascu.4 abrsrt. but we s4"ittiad a e"clos that sugy.st.d that beIC 001wuct POst"'r68 tHta AOt to bf 0"laidecsd by tL4f jaty tvr aay :.aaop. Tm&t siav3y is s" in tbm sa+0 .ad abbowldw't mlara bot fox srrswtisq aLt.at Ildi. aad ti* jatY sb"le y.t ths J."trvotioa tilliay tbee to disseqPed aay arysrr.At by attyawa that her oMtirwUq to smsice aRtss 1944 aarnbar dssoastcat.d abe wou.1d 4aww saohed .v.n i! a rarsi" aa ~ao M w cn 00 ~ 1'fjXLL13 T. LS'MISr CSR. (.WPICk`Ai. CO3A"P R8PO'lSRs NBWA.RKe A3
Page 7: zlz30e00
1 a 3 4 3 6 7 12037 WWls Mva booa .aYiior aaa thaia 1566, M CtNwkt: L*t a* auf 12 I ealeaxtend. xt It th. piaiNtit!'a p.4llct.a ebat !.lW iorY should aot taathra aity inatras2loa &b"t t,A* tala',rasoa ot piat-1665 am. DdMItSLi.l Mo. I tbiAic xL t.ba raMLr. ee iartswftxaas at ali, they WM*t 1tMVrt vbNtt to 40 with that *v1 lew00o it you sew allove the Ntoadents to acV", sd *orti.iniY It b.a brsa in tb+r aaso, I EA#ait the jtirp sboaid qot as tasts"tiow tr.i.liag tbM s2 o"t proela! raiwasa* the past-lst6 .MastiAq l.. 1And It ia aar posittod tMt tbo aa,iY r.lowaaao posa ibl. r.lwawr voo,td be ea the isaao of rrhetlrfr aa"tnq aau..d ber "Ont, aad thay s#wld bs iastrust.d that that is tbe onlp roasao that ovidaooo Ifas bsn alior" to aaRs iAt;o Qlartr ftaL' all of th* d*trxlf hav#t bfom aroYiAg in tarsW e6 h.r past -- I sapposw the yyrY aould vorraluda tt&t tbe aaAa.x was aaysad po,rt-' 66. tb.a tbty rheokd b* ie.trvAtsd that -~- M t3?ii?i!$ Nau.1d thm aoasidor it tlWA, oa proit"Wto vawaat "R. W11tMN"= daawn is! Tft3 Counrl toald thog oa00l4rrr it .a pre%tawt. PAYtL$.I13 To i.BidI$r C~`3it* OFP`ICXIIL COUR'1' 1fl'"M'1'U* T[iS[dWK. W
Page 8: zlz30e00
I 3 I 4 3 i 7 ~ ! 20 1 t 13 14 ,_ is is 17 is li 20 21 22 23 24 is 12038 AR. UARASFALr It all R.c *0akial - aatcy -- it all h1s Pt+1M ` i i amwk taq wte a atibsGas t 1 al 1`aotWr? ftytrtr Y sissad yswr *ra+.r's - V22 CO0*t1 psat. M DARYUJOi Srx.ly Me to pesty• it as l. O"Jamstion risb the pr.-'i4. M Ma'ti t t"! It tMiRt Um docomdamw atM a"Le - I a. .rs#tlsg as001pttalaa b.a.d s r"t t 1M.ard. ons ff ths t4tep the d.ftrtdaats will atow in that bed .h. •toopprd iat lfid lrst r lst at iwrq oamm wosld wr* bmm sltmtsatsd se vsrtainly sst"taottallY codsced« at. DA2Mi.Lr Tboy algaetd no +ttott .v1dsmm on that lo1Ki*. Tix COMT: Sat z b"icd so". MR. 0A2M"s Thsy bars wrqsM it Wt tbay b&ve adt sWotaattated - Nn. 21osmLff ~WN doa't bavs ts r.spod to i t. Th+r rasord is cu1l wf tb .widMS+ao: TU CWRTe Lot as aaaarMr it Is ia thm aaas. Tbra b+w do yoe raapaard to it 1as.tar as post-16i s.w.Rtnv to saovetssd? MR. DAaWLi+s 2wss It tAw laty Ueds that the, post-l"i tmokitig w" s-64Silai 980as Ln 0as vlttleq trnq +OSof t tbat doti1 not iSa* that the #iir-lfii swklaj ws ir.t a aa"taftlai laart.r. PUYI.LIS g. i.flWt3. C3A. 3PFICM GODOR'? #OVik't'illf XVUMe HJ
Page 9: zlz30e00
A 2 3 t S t. 7 12039 Yc* pr+ty bavf tbsM t3oth aoozistiaq aped both caariiaed to iaaw the iajtrry, aNd zWaK tbo trsarA obarOs that we gave yoair 3v+or » tba ooaavx r.at abargr fres ir lday' w ooaltCrass - I tapr tA.t vorrii be the trs tic.+o yoi" ery Yb! btil, Wttioo at sace. I tltiajc It that to tb. PiMW Warr4 we art at in tats O..*, b.bir Waa sautalt. 4n Q0osTr tl I aaR rOa to liRiOk this aoat.waf in !s VOCda os looa. 1964 .rr*i*, aiarltl" ..ltor IM by sos.r Ci0olto®o !s rst6raat tot ths lallaMt61 rosoas, vbat wouid yoar aamrr be? MR. 3MLOWt.L& Only rahnraat as to wbotber tb* Pro*1li0 rm"taq raa a sub.taatlal faotox in vs»aiag Dweg iajorX# It Is rtloyaat orly - rr1*v"t oaly is th. "a0* that the do!'oa+irata aCOs tbat it to an tateYvenf,ag s%persodlraq oauns La whierb they havie to slrow it is aot Caaooaamy fas.rs+taabl;. .VA vod.id tot bawr ooaunr.d bat far tbo p.st-'tt as"irg. Ya0 t'OA?s itlrs is tht belps,r, Nr. S#1ttsT PlX. SiLMI I luvo ao ltlta obara yaw aco (Jolaq 044 2 ta very uavrmtbctaala. Ts cfws I will toll you *hat 1ro2Aora ao. 1.p.wt all day Yrastos/lay on tr.M1 4Marqe. a~ad ro Mar* oft Oivas the jury aar lsstiroNtiaR as to Wboab.r ot aot they aaa voarLdox po+st-' Oi srroAiwq by l1rs.. CtpoliaerS aad for OD Ln T m ~ ~ CZ) ,P2YIfLIS 3`, T.IWYSr V$Rr 0lFICIAt. G`OW ]M?OMM, WD1lMr #J
Page 10: zlz30e00
1 2 3 4 S i T 12040 rhet purpvrrs, and it Aay be teat ewrybody ksss't r"ah" the aggAimeat, they dorilt tl!i!!t 1s 8iX iAyt$Il1Se but I d4+R't koor wsthss t.Moat ss t.bw fait tr tie jacy betawrm ot tA. pastaT• .9 this a..S. l1it. SxLiPiNI iow Wmi sarrsatly LdWtiti.d an 4tWAMM& Whiek w zAtaad ta awk* sai t takf it that that is Nt i P6l1mM AO'r.ritb4tAAmq Xt. DavAl11oa SelgawIfi. TU CSg"i Met a pcairLsru OR. i1"Stl We as't t.q.its sawt4ias *Ut+c tbws tkat. tk! t.<rt wo art "l" to -- ?rs COURTS 0at yaG dan' t 6*0d 64 Z11stt?Adtioa is Yhat yyom at* Mp 44'r ji[, ?80PASs N4 did tpwst owa that fa.siiolly s.id tt siar wa3d pave atsmp.k s.oNciaq ia 1964 aar wmlda't kare q+0lt*a *&mor, +4Ad tpat tAiy MYlt blMt sodft the pCaxisate ca4ss t..t ard we strrad o4 that taqsast«. TtS C0~'!S ?Mt tqaases tbs .dd#ettwa qustion, dosa it not? It, tAa jury aooiptsd tk. plaistilt's rstsfoa that tbir aar ia" a! +rs.a ot srors et tbG datsftftata Ptr 'i i ris a pac"iaatt oawe ef bec dida • t sr"iws,, aAd t"t .wiciwq smma bstF to be aidiot.d, tkwm tlar P.rt-'ii srMkleq vver it t! 41" owttsl,.bqtsS tr b*r iajactrs vaald tk.A be rvwttiexq lsir Jrsr vasld psvpatly 44A+otdirt. Aqtad? MLLIS ?. E.SItIS. CSA, 4FtICiAL tOpIT RSVMU* NEWARR, NJ
Page 11: zlz30e00
1 2 2 4 2 6 7 2S 12041 KR. RILrsns Their addiotion srqoa.nt Ms al+eo lewea a rrspsustr to oac .ajar abslQO - M Come Ljust rNrnt tr EfM out tcvr all -1 t i s%Asr* asy#rvdy rrho Mtatcw that Uwt. .lrwid be a spesi! to fastrsatioft to th* Jssy ss to thi stswrstawms Meits .1t1®b Ip"t•1i66 ss"i" as4 be Serr""ad by tAo jury? M1t, "RMi.e Mt thiii w aM +rlll be Mtlm to try ts atatt ss110tlti" MM Mrtrrt it te YOGs NOW t,as.:r.w« !!IS OOt=I tar not letap to to tfat. s.t• is what I reaAA itfm yos tm ds and this rii 1 be tlw 9 hsl ot+6•r ot todsy . 11'en we 9 Utsb t.oiay „ boomaa I wuNE t" swcgt lias sh.A aed ftliwrsi tMewror s+araie4, awrybtav s1Mr ia dwsr and I wwt wttybodY to hare it 9sslr t..asw. aam you eaa laot at tt ta.ot rar .ocnial Rttece yw badiu awwA.tiaw. I would appcoeiatf betoie you 14t1v+1e twudbt, try to got tofethac atd )nst tiv• me two *r tMrw wotasoa-1 tol,ling t1Mr jrrr reaat r.iarsaae. tt .ny# tb+aro is to psst-il66 •w"iaqp and it .4obt be jost the t.+Mrs ooutattiatrc of the p.rti", tbe d.f.aaaat "?inti it fs colow"t to sWuw that sfita9 .IN. ws Sraro", $M owtLMa.d to 0src.. .od ts. JUsy aro a.motlude tr+ts that o: iw#ir tram that, it a" lrad i.a»r w.uo.d ssai.r. slre a.martAoi." w.2A Ma s4Mi~w..de md the plaiotiff's sospowas to tmt* tMtt the plaintitt costlWlds Mn dLs othet bood that #wt-'66 8wliti" is 05 VI oD ~. N m tD a pdYLLZS 'x'. LWIBo C8R,f t'?MCIAL t'OURT RMXTISR. Mi`WAJRt. NJ
Page 12: zlz30e00
I 2 3 4 f i 7 3s 12042 telaaaat, ioc~su$e it w,rs cass.d by the doffb"mts prror to I iio tbat it vu af orasteoaiio eoa,awq~mmo that sso bs a"tetisl, aad tbersior• lt is t.lowat. I as a,at swi"st#ay that ir is appropriatos bat I kbiaft the jury will Cro told it tmy saa aoasiMc grat-•64 aaoltia4 aW !or rlrat patyra. U You aaa slr.., I waula awoolato it. All sirtbt. MVe rhat I rwld 1l;ki lue do fitst* aad /tll I iat.ad to do, lhaoo q.w t.bro•s0 al1 ot the .xbibitsr asd Ybat I rili Jost do !ot tko parromes eI tio tovec+i to toll you or 1CSllli4a. I h&V* a tiMVl• of looNrtloArr 444 somebody x bsp" vilt sa.ks aotes. Jourt tor the rscotd? I an stactup with - MR. DMrltia. & SoY ocoyeac aon" jts to tbo Onri.o,406, w:ovi.aod tbo dost#o4s ovtr the WQok*adt a*A I daa't taav !i yoor Fjasatr rasets to doal with it. TaE O?iqrl: fte tator ro"Eses ioa? lqt. ttAMMLr xs. Tax C4puTs I a+s dotaq t,haro a.il ovor. xorr vi x 1 have tbou twr"car. 41„ DAMAn.L,l tti2l ut amit aa ofpv~rtumis y to doal with thoa boloce -- M C0JI'i': Wo oortaiwly vili Aa+ro armo Cias with the latocYOyet+oti.s tb&a with the ohakroo. but I would l:Lkr ~ m ~ ~ ~ to ~A M#.L1li T. fvaWIe:. CSS, OlrlICM COURT A$""Us NM"g, '-'f+3'
Page 13: zlz30e00
I 2 3 i 5 6 7 ~ f 10 11 12 13 14 ~ 16 16 17 12043 you to kav* tbo ch.rg* xmotrawr boKtaoe. Shavs att®Wted to xoislvo a~ o# tDe dtejtato6 aad tbo 4isouss3os wr had tieu otMot daY. aa0 I waat you to ba9s at Ya"t law" A"ur to .nll rbM. .v.r. 4hs ffxst matvh that I an le.kiaq at is oatifil*d, ad6iti.rral trial oabiieit. no 1a.Pr i& .rriti.wn as a r.w3t .K u. Cwwse • r"Abq. x aiitMt that abat is aOsetMtisaf aW t cou tthoi do" this ialZ W. di 1 Lan? I erill tato tbaw »p iA the ortl*t that tbey aro pcesatt.d aft tL. sUaat. MR« diLMS I tbtax i,t is sa. yont voaar. SU tWR'?t WoYl, it "xs ap ia tbo iott-4weid ooanote ilfbatlt a" Stefflerld* fw. BILpcu: T&tirs, too. TU C'0OM A1l c3 qbt. I wiLl *LtboE LwAidatt objaCtioft sastalee.d or oportaled. 1MR. Ct?8n: zsvase af„ roar moser -- ttit. 8IL1rawa 7%wse ac+r obj.atiaas, so tlee snstaCnerd ro.aa objoetioa sostaiaat? Vti iSOu"s Rsaot.ty. iiR. Canii« lu.taiaid li aat? ''" Qome "ataiw+irQ ls "t. tivostetled is la. 111t. CClsnt '1'4aeelt Y1w.. i43YLL I5 T. GiMAd o C3s, M0ICIAL COU.KT 6t8FaR"PgR.. MWMM, WT i
Page 14: zlz30e00
1 Z 1 4 S i 12044 XR. SILyBk= tft wotic4d that eut. !'RD Come lbet i.a rby Ihavv "" vrssy. n» ixLMi tlaJer luordlr. tLsvqbt.*r. ) 1'8i COt3RT t The f i ta t oats# ss rw itarrs tJio ssst .bsit s is F-i00J. Dtws ev.ryfiodY have tbat? r400r1 sustaiaod,r K, O. r, Q. R, as* altl srtslllel. s-+14! 04,11tatAOd. 444, Y bad a qufstio*# betass I aooutiin't f ivust ertt rbat it wos. KR. tfiARWs 444 io a &wiwirrat Wst ras latr.duced aVala os the Wladiuu tsvuwb tfi d.alt with tb+M Lusw of tbs dissles»rs, the praratisa, t1t ,i.arkstliad ot s satt Giwssht*. saW it a.rsa +ritbi• yOUx dasar's raliaq, ir which yoos Wws rslfd that the piilidim deam.ata ats eat **lt tOx, aaMiyr tRss pfo0rtive, wtYe* fa +wtvotqbsd by .ny prsjudl,aial valui tlat *xiat.* preJudiatal effect that eststa whia6 ot.us larqsly 2taw eaa.ttustw that would ttM"t ia the Juey !f psttiaw of tX+t paYadius doomaate w.es put ts, aad Yss the alale Wa. aak.W ottt. wsWa aW. And tl.Q t4s ptiJudWs that Mrsiarid +"t'tt" te, the dats,rALaRts uNCi it the QaM that a purtiMn of f.bs ps11ldlsw rRYLf:IR ?s LWIl, CSH, OtTIC;At. CWRT RMIT"s AMAM. N7
Page 15: zlz30e00
2 2 a : i 12013 dsaaweots wrre ds 4nd yrett t" palladius 6444 wss uot paattte4 to t* dealt Wttb os s3M Wsniw ea.e. !u CvMj fte aaly aessas I Wi sas* tr.ubie with tsat. Ar. X.arsey, is that it yeu loot st the f lrst page of Wa tCassariVt, it bas se.W tsskrlal 1s!'s<alstila0 sWWt tbO as~.rura. 1 pts.rtt4ti4s ,rE Dr. tsssl,.r ari rwying wbsr. It t,a"Ir1t MW plai"tf f. siy4t be eft.r 1" it fos tAst pvepis" srwt that is W"t ths.w ss .9t. M. CUMR$ !1!t rN/i tW p!'N4stallM at tAe 9u.ft" AEES o+mff:.aas sOs a bi0 isiww~ 92 tlar pal.di1M i.rm. It aaan aarrs for What i,s is faat as a.lt.raatlr* o3far.tt., tvo, ghs ssy yosr 1100" vi+wed It Is wb.wrsc or "t it sb"ld btrre boas msrketad astt vby it wasn*t, tkrst, a tssq.alG.tal isssr, rrss it dfse1eaed psopttly. ihat the snsnas A16f. Qas.tirOns. Waa awe st ths discl"ures, it vas vux pfoitivs it had lrsea 41salos" ao rb+f satlonl.it le +saruftsity„ disalos.d to the «ewscAmesrt an+9 pab"G'. It wur the plaLetift's pwrs-ltiaa It wsa*# disoiaswtd` art Mtck as you 11tr* it to boo xss wipe the waols tM11n0 Ost. As • rei"t, w4lt a" s"srss it witlt Dr. jovMSltt s iluda• t 1wt lny Us* Ssyawtt. Nr bsd tlM atIMMSt bMtes+t, ar+! I "a• t maAsrstrard rby it 4ars sr« It waa xosarraii. It eaeats aart just with 4". Iwt it alsa ls Ute tP81'L:.IS 4. LYti[l3, ::M 01MC11i& CDMM ReJOMRr NZtltRX, gL7
Page 16: zlz30e00
I 2 i 4 g 6 7 11446 sssat saaae with SQ4, Sa3, SQ7. 3a apalladiux 4"wwot. Pial,Ui Et' a omnswtl wiat to pat ia tbrro doouwatr wbiczh yoss pea.rt tsaic oat waftt 403 asd prt i,n jvst a posttem of tdNt aOd f IiltbNY "t OW1=1iMArA 4d Ui JOty ii1d the pcajadlas of the d.tasdwAta by dainy st at1tat yous donar sitoody raiod and altfa tlre !at stitaarm an the tY11", did1! 't Ilddltls4 tberle 1SWisr 11f. MALVMt T6is drsaaertt La ae1Mac atattsent ot bt« iatista Wirs wtk.eE tar Arihur V* i.lttle, 4se the validity vf aaass s%ia pal,atift •ted.tos sW thr:t ta the .aia petposs At*S val liabli to 9ii. '1`ltiy at! 1oif R4 MiiN akf Ap11 fJlt 1ag as a ba'itti !ot satea#aowatui.. 'lltS QXATs ; will .nstaia t!m, oijaatie,n, Wmiusa that la - U. ISAMY: TMt arVmMt r&a pt.aisely a"s aFi4 yanr *mar xrlad what owa stay is ia the pwtart. "s. W11b'1!$Rbii Sit down. tGadghE.r? Tes fWJRTI T ralad *a it aissft. M DARVU#Lt zoop =s1 ic iaq, Nr wi ll. o"ad* h1$ In tK"sr So the oO3aetim ts 444 Y. .n,r"ia". $03 >wst.lrNd. 404, al l I "a s+tX io that 1!1 e/taaift 544s Igiad that pi8ti ot lt ats adalislble aAd patts ate LawW1"lbl.f. P"4LaS T. LWI3. C3ft, JP'rIcIAL CoaxT amm'Pur mmARx, m3
Page 17: zlz30e00
a 3 4 3 i 12047 ftora to a qtoit d+Ral of biatonoai Isforaatios in h+tre that I wrold p.rai;t to be cooeive#. Wt at fost sar thfs$ '!lwrt Y+rtli avasrala tRo .Itjootion and porrit it to w cowtv.d it it is pt.perYy cafMQ1~~. api "yM es"sal oaa wotk oat rhst rhwld ba ta aA vM0 aMoald be out,. " x+ra torta0iV.tY prrrtttia0 it to ..rr ts* a Ot.at deal ofrw24 a*. Mr&a Os..t 60,t Owd 4aft laf " t wi11 l.a" it to Owasel aAd a" tt they oau "rsJt it wt. I ttattsd to 60 tw t.iastlo+t siralt bwt the doQ~MrMSt to 34 pi+jes .1u1 'P'- Ra. f d/1AMS Got srlt rir aMatwar tSbiaLot 1es31 y colat+M to errtaiuly ommlativ+w 09 rbatavoar to la tlNr t~+t. il0"aLaAalty, this io akwia+rslr a saa.arY of tbs pall+dlrr. votlco it bu absttacts at the pMrt/s!ed pallididu eaawwat. t3w first Wag we t.lY.d adsato, !fo titst p.qt# a" a euMr ot t1e" so»asllod rsports d.: !io" oasia to the yaar oa.p vtieb va. 1034 mad tQe a--as."t af the praqras at &tthns D. Little. There io t+aair at onridoaot iO the cNrned aUoat Lt. 't#[s E2mT1 ar. Keasmw 31/t rf toil yw rbat casgut rr oy*. il you isoat e i,qM - tAw` aei so aMrbtts eat tbo Wo"rMi ""' llitt t t baAR * AC fA 293!! Y Mal" the laiR !4 yMt s tboca aas bfoa a steady aurmaliwq at tpid+wialo0t® stmlios, UDut CD N ~ co PVMYS T, WrOlS. CZR. {)L'!'tCI1ki. COfRT 1tBV<W$A, W7$OARlCe *J
Page 18: zlz30e00
I a 3 4 s 6 7 • ! If 11 12 12 14 ,_ 13 ls 17 is is 20 21 22 ?3 24 as 12048 UihiCb baVe been tt=tOrpt*t*4 tp!y son iaVi#tiqalOca Ss bavfAQ a o.ct.latiaa betwfa rs"aa4 wattsS "d buisa oaaatrst the 1933 ttya0irr-4cabar aad CroftinqEr MrsrastraRsd oitarstto somE "MdorwMtES dwalap ttrwt. Oak tlori akias sd +- 1fA. KXARAXX 1 I bara so - vu COM'1t: - tAis sspssis.at 1k" Msa Eafif f sued by • wam"s Ot 1R111suqstisso ft+Ra .owairraMr bm so.w soiewset a~t +r4rlssi3xtilRy. 00 tblrs atE tbi:a4s iA iK* %IMre i thish it. At ts prapsri.y sadaatad, tt aaa !w air4saiilrlt. 1tE. RBAAW s I ksvt ruo p`asflso MEtb it. This is Nrt type stn!! I as Nayisq ia ornwZatlas. This lirtl• jntcad8ctioo tbate ruoiaas t.he bi.torY, PL+jst)tt 1c8Ors they savE that ta t.bu re~d ail .vlg tb* plum. '!"bey art att.rpting to grt tb: 4oawaMsat ia rItb tbs ps3i4dtvR. !1[E CiQE.'PS "a pal1adidarr in ant Mtd ot,h.r psrts aco in. I will a" plaisti#E' to r."at it vrd qiw you a Olpy to Nir it yoe oaflwsL iGrN. Maa ZZARMS rifw. Tilt COM: Objoatiaa to $47 susEais.d. 302 "stala104. )2' araasul.d. 433 wortsi.d. tw sa#s,rin.ef« =bs tsli+owiag ats s,raccelrrel. 215. 3ti, lwft sarry ® PHYLLXS T. LEXY3* CSiR. OfrI€Xa1L COM A8lQlr'lBR. MOOMK. NJ
Page 19: zlz30e00
I 2 3 4 s 12i#4t 2315. x316. 3312. 2319s 23Z0. x321r 4S7-D and 445 asM s:ll ovirrsLfl. J11s0 sostsaled st• )4-A. li1`. asd Ct!#s ar• tvo, tblags aboot sbatts# wAiab t do s•rt a#rll, so I could Rat rals, s0 thwasf at l*rst ast Y*t. 0bj*.at iaer wftr ral.d opt t78". $i4-A, 471M. Osj-C* dbjootles to 54-1 rwrsjrr"+ra, a" 4i0`A0 aatrtsl.d. "!!w most 4rMw io onttt3rd 'a--r~w~ts altsady ia .wtd.ns. .61.et iaw. First qrowp 1321. 13390 t110-4. 13ZS, aad 2327. s1tj.ctisss swrcsi.d. Iifst group 200S-A, 34190 2i11rA. $013. 7120, YsB9, sh1sotios ovotrul.d. $10 *oorrs2od. 701 aad 700 sustakald. $23 v*stxslad. t2f sustaLa.d. 10ti. 1807, and ASb o0+rstioa srwttaiasd. 027, 1d14, $140 oblaati.a s4atAiwsd.. !3g obj"tion evacrulial. 0)7. Cbj*ctioa sustALaod. 1043, ssstaiasd Is patt Mdk smsslei ts pact. I will psraLt ks sar#do"a lr+lm the 6ottawe 09 page s thcwo Urs bala.aw to paan iS, wt sustala the ei.joattsa to .vtrr7taiaq Umt s.r" b.rtere tAau A". as T t.morAot the sslelbtt. L thialt It was IKMLx9 T. LxwYsx Cs'ao orFiCtAL GOURT RttQA?M. #;SVAR1f, M;
Page 20: zlz30e00
I 2 3 4 3 4 ~ 17 li 12050 6*9i:nnlaq with it.eu fivi -» tCwn't rar.#e+t exaatly ahat it war, bet t.bat is tao pirtx wouid par"t. Aat ~wtwt. "riQ asd M1 1 80 .79o# ov.:ral.d. 1703, naa 17t3,r .aj.oti.& s"taimd., 1204-#r obj0st19a swrt.l~M. 2014 +watraiol. My OrrtttrlM. !M "st 4ttep 8"y'17t i710. 141f, 1q11s 1416•i: 131~-~f 111l~ lqa1-0r .b#satiMn ts ovwgul+rd. t117. .rbjwot tam .nt"iaM. M t3MttI "at 1a ua wwrbw agsiu? Von COW: 4E1'1. Co"t U2t3btt 5e th* arjsstt+rx is aVOxsnY.4. Xt ts aet qtrias to the juay. " it is ar tlie tor Whrt~ it i's ott.c+.d. XIt. tAMSXI ia that tm DC. ttilla• attidavit? '!`u CWMt Yls. l1R. rtMt4: Ut that will uot bt t+rW to tne jYCy? T'AS CE1ti'its"1 11WO1vWY aft. .=ast f*8 tMu! pnrpowrr 0! Cimtt lp aUth"Itisitg e1 1lii4" U)latjA". 3TS ltwtt+.fn.a. sl01 a00tainod, oD f13-tlt, enstat,n.d, C.1 ~ ~ co !PUL2.IS. Y. WMI#3. Ctit, -W!'ICM CWlt'! tSlO#tM. %=AM, NT
Page 21: zlz30e00
I 2 3 4 3 I I 12051 1fillw2 sust.iA&d. $30 ahr,r ral.d. 0#1! "atatu.d. 7123 ov.: csl.+4. itde errsrrttUd. fu .rercex.a. !s: .a.taSad. 912 ."Cntl.d* iMw, tlitttt io a 1l.tiss 01 MWSONAs oEt.r.d with u. "Jstls. a.d tlwre t• air r.aaw !on mt to put tWa in the c+arard. t ws4w0 Cbsy Mill all go is. a11 ilqU. So tUt i, t"t. M 4* sli.EUs t hasa a ommmet aw asir vt Mans on 3tti* ta tJwe 1yc 1947 rfpOrt. Md iba.* a t.allsg tmt pocbspa rwar B~r didn 't got var statemmt au thatr Doa+rsat it .asait attasb" by the piai;»tttt. "t did year memorc reviav t#. c.&attoM aQd sa"i®d. -•- I1t 4OIk9lO I did wt ranriw the :odoottons. I r.rl.+red wbat was Iatt alts the rO&sottNur, wharO tri* rtdaQtiaa ws* bla4s04 +eat. 1iR4 iiLtm 3ast nme=, the ltc.t ltse is tM. iadfA to t" ttt.ot of aiquEcat. 1.Ir.li". a~asd POVS i. .ltsstivemoaa o# a#qaratta tab.linq. Jart tallinq raa r1bat Uw doommeat ts. Go Ul m Cti N ~ 0 0 "MIS 1. 4titZ8'. CBR, Or1"2GIAL CORT RBPOWBU. IAZWAR1K, x?.3
Page 22: zlz30e00
I 2 3 4 S M 7 I i20Sa On tAO fwurth paso thW act tooa" aff*ativo OR Uaaaty lat. no viaiatio« ai the aat has Woa broaght by the 2wttlwr Dtpactmeat. raqo 4. "tivations tsr 4010kise pbYsi.l"iaal)yt p.po6ei"iaailY aro aooplos and a aNt-ro rsLndst ot tasards ow tbo p.o""t araaot 60"Ot* aft tm Eore" that proawt. 617i840t16o IM004tJ. 7wr sosor. ~ s, baMSao the "altb ""oro ar• e.t -O- =s 7U RMR?i1t: ploaaa ropMat tbst. bt. Sllftae an. ia!'axt A,'iI r i#bt. rorqot it. You straek it, asd they triod to put it in, aad hbW strNtsic tJW rr.ry a.nteasa. --- lfi.ffi COM& I amo! auI I rroat thros9b tAat 4oawMWt. a" tb.r• wCO iauy tbia90 that I Q01aldo,C roimrant and odmtrsibl• fa tbsrs.o aot iRSt.aaaey tbey Aaw bi.toriaal tatoraatiorr aboaE rri4it wx sps+rt on a"or tisiaq aed pr ior - MR. SILlUs I hawt ao asJussat Witb tt. 8wt I QaaAot btlisvo wo vi21 a.llow into tbo aa.eR a.*atonc* that "Ya Liat the aottva:tioas tas anokl" sro 0000" snd elm Nt* jM/la"r of the tilas&t'di eI a 1N1cutal on aiqesitt* baMrr4! "" "It COUTt The prablNN I oa" aith taw dosure»ts ls that I ftnd larq* srotioaW of tlanr to bo adwissibi* &04 a4 V m 0 IPA ~. 0 IPA PH=Ia T. LLaris. CSR, WFzczA-to WUxT RswOaTEa, NXaaax' UJ
Page 23: zlz30e00
1 2 a 4 5 4 7 • LeleVaAt. 1~l11 r . ?bd sbSsattaa You WAlto is that it sheuid W taatract, oaaAwt bar it 1n tiiat baaia. I tsaA bar posttaAs itbst ym aor slwaid be cedaatad. swd 1 a,s psrttetd3y Miltia9 tEa do tt, bet thers is an a*atall .bjsatiau to admisoibtlit'. I""6t awrttaia it aor.lr boewaf it h.a rsorrr tum" u tlnus tlr" Obseld mot 60 tbft• ar riy ast lara saiavaNte I INnra adivAtuad It bas.nme a wa.Mms .r9 tAia" sre saawaRt. =. a1LMs I will svb.it a aaR.ta~s.aaQti+cs. 7a Comi may I sR"st tr.asau va ar* mr dern to the Vics* that vhst sboR2d be dNa boro i4 an so[tort to rsaoir sa.e afrssmat with yaur aa..+raary,. 9a%irw tban asreat aa ta ga rrAcGU9b - ftosr iaRq As that ripoart? Ml. STLF"a That waar the pCwtst I t1waot roRld tak! plaQa yRstlrdaj+ and di"' !. No. MLt.TBiti': ws did appar*rtlr yat an objaatlaa l*ts last Riobtr rot iR rize to aarta it aw4 g4r* it to Your ve"s, aAd tbep statad ttwrrt wrs aN seataav+R im bw$• yau bad alEaa4y rRiad out dcartag tb* tgiaie if tbat is the easa, we rttil be ql.d ts bliadt i.hat sratssea "t. tNt* Suorsug t.a tarit1nq at -- ln 4mTi Y..t Rs not do it tuw* I voRld sriqglst i! Qteta at. 4tht6 Q1eliaw, try to raim awNMMt It iYl /C4YltaMl. Zt A4t R ZAd LeLts t! Men C.ho ~ C.11 ~ ~ N ~ O N PQlXL4IS T. '"RWl_Sr C-SR. C11PFICIll,L COM R11POWMr HE'i1l1Rl[. Uj
Page 24: zlz30e00
3 2 3 4 5 i 7 0 11054 daoUWAMt wtaat sxaa YOt thiPA ssghC to cswvr ost 4A# I vili afxtaisly losk at it. Just davs to t40oi1* tba" ttkiaga aaci 7NIyt as . Ibtt I QiW1t 114t "st"la siif blN1Rlt lbSM"1ims, ibi4L0N I tbiAk t"lfi nllt`f ii" tbla" lA, t11lgf !"t voxi tolowartt sA smefasiblo. so vill +wrtOsft tarll ss uw last, assbst7 Mt. PbMi1tt i1.i. I ilellwo. U! Coun1 l111ask ylNla r" asst 2r*Qp. I tak* ift,e •ta ssYllbit+f olEeged by tb• arlsadiati to wbtaA the pxsistifts taYS sds oif.etEeaa. sAd I did sst s«.e Ir,o have a list !rt iti s• I vilt )sst go tiucee" the twld.rs sad iRtdioats by iirAt4ft air.os• tlre Cantt's tellaga. 8o tb•se ars asbibits otgssed by tW ftfosdaL•a, rrhisb tw piaiat3if bava rade objeatioas to. Is it asv+rsaarY that I qi,vo the lattsss oc vili cba AYiblrs suggi@+f ? Mt. Sxs.F18i Nambeta. "laa ,C'OURTS 1Rt. Kiies1y? 1qR. RaAAM'!: ia awrM ta#tow"s idwst ate tw sats, 14 .A at at1wr W!. 'las Coons I%" I bsttss ra"a it si.ras. WT-4li3dr M11"tlaa ov*s1Ylsd. Af'! 2Q35, inrixtulsd. PVLLTS T. Y.BWIS. C:a3t, JFYiCIAL 4"OM aMN!'!'81t. NtM'AiK* W
Page 25: zlz30e00
I z 3 4 i 7 120,55 OiT 4A37. a0juat,laa ortrx4led, iat s413. +objlaiaon "staiA". L/I A 41or sbjlttt irM1 sm/iti111od. LM 4d10, vbjoattl+tx ssstataodo . LN 3 obj.otioa aYatattMd. U't dA#9 tbos, ac! Amvats to Istet+rowt"i0a0 and iON lot.$ to sv.rguls ta .Ojestioo to the toidfrp .E mulftot 1O# so! wstala tt to 24,0 rwkoss sosMdT awa ttlY af v" 24 amot to bf tosa. It is ." tn Ut osso a4yW"r** liR. MulTI I ssd. the saa #*tst on tbo, iucy #astt4ttiosr that Moat to s.astsaatiaq das)gn det.ot* we ax* 9elaq to v3s.t" Ws f"y Csrt they aan tin3 loiiwco to wags s sa.etkinq to tbat stlost, ss thot they ssa !ied afaisit the plaiatilf Lff"tt, svo's tlroztob oar piidYQt 1Nts 6019004 jKlpi=ly. !eliltsOtdrNd ~» si1 gotthr r~G fot rb. 1lMat irttorre"sscy wilx be soad tbat ycays pasiatlti dorsA•t vest.hi that +aoc pCei"t was Saffifaotasod Lawo"Cly or haA asavyaetscinq ctiassa. I bell+trs that is a+n aaawol. l3iso,rt -+ dir+tst sssolastaa to the Jiuy to that typa of a @hs9S!. 3flos0s0 tUt is AOtt iS 9110 oiisS - !!at Cams i will Sm"MAs the sbjostloaO rtay" w. .a4bt to *a sm.thiw io to! $MC4o aAorrt .#t, MeAt aoruYniy tles.r is so dLspwto that is r+tt & ilaL! is this 68ss« ss 1+rill ovorsalO t!N obj"ttow to 14 sd aistaiu NH?4L28 T. EAMM L'OR. OPlICt" CO1R"! RMRS"M WWAU. SJ
Page 26: zlz30e00
I 2 i 4 s i 1206 it ts nwmvc 24. ~ 4069, orarruLd. A~ i0M x137, 18191 1is4 4, li 1 sn toarNing that sigSt, it is b7 aosssst, ao oblotias. NS. yAUTM i rft rsqmst tt: laty Mw qiv.r t#M PCOVOC i"t,rwtl.n .s to trose d"W..rNts. M Cf,m* AU t ijbt. W# Ml,r +I" ~- wet*ugb S a"eM1.4. La 0417, A. .bfsRtias. Llt 04l1r Ao oir10otto/t. OJ'1' 4074# wo rbjNtis*. LIt 0413* oalsatiom ssstaisW. LK 0414. 4baear tos svsW#e0. W 0413, objfctios ssstoleps+l. W! 4034. Objeattoft mqstaimm. OJ'! W0r oblsatisu o1rutslaQ. iiJ? 94041, orrwtsisd. W9t 4044 arsxtu2*d, 4043 wsrrulrrd. 4440 e+rsrtuiscds 40" orrsssulsdt 4471 ave,tsvl.dr 4072 owsstvlsd. aiest 9iaug i;s deswoots to be iateodmtaW by d*t*sissts, WT 3003, ss.tatsat. ' =lt0i *nrttselsi. N01 sustaifted. 0141/1i )tii4t4e 10s. 11l. 111. Uls I31t l0ir A" 1t4 s"t+aie.4o Pftlt.~.I4 T. Lw1sf LSA. Ogt*XCZA4 cDm AMRTOl'it. LISWA., w
Page 27: zlz30e00
I a 3 4 S 4 T i ! 10 11 12 13 14 ~ iS 2,8 17 18 i! 20 21 22 23 24 2m 12057 1)T2 232ti, ousteinod. JtAet in #diruess, I har+ smstalnOd tlm +al+rctl+s to f.#a4 aaa •1se OJT 4032. oM is tl0 .ae90"0 r"ort e4 tt* ptsldeat, sad tqa stA+f is the diaplosti0 aad sfiatistintal uwwa of wrs4al dislyd*rs, 6awws. I framkZ t diA apt taw for s"e pwtposes it ws mi" Ot90r+d, Wt it fir a lirtl. xsf.+ t. be gi.iap us Joex beAc., "" Mawnr aaYOt 4 t"as.nd rbl"• U, s!Wd1lI 7fers ies"s with r..p1st to the r.port +f t#W PacOside.t, the sectisa Wss rrai trieao ftae is little awt+i.n0m that -- aad Ws waa ram ou araa~~ts~taO~kts+ to nr. C+4sA asW toad oo dir"t +9 Pt+tfss.t Nartiso aw ti tW ebjs+tta" is tbat Ur. Vr+l+ bo" is yoAeg ia: nb+s oalf apacapaypi vovaes„ I wwAd say We b$ttOt rsWVS2aat+ ta+ JarY bsodacs bs0.us0 tb" 490 isy 1: ot d.etsssnlts that cusa ia, M COUt?S s'rrs 1100 I ss Oot saying 1L is isaftso~tiits to do it. ~ I an arrjiaf MMu I roftivsd the er4fes. I b" ld4a +r~at its uattvsms0 wita Witho+t tbessbia4 t6cOrt" the lweu to Etad It& aad Iha.I so idra v" it ms Vsiaq ia* AA. Siiftsus I an mfisure vft `t vaNIA bf •ir` oblaotlsw sratis tus is rrl+nr"t to ow lwatlomrAYp +f cllacaRts a4vatisiaq an4 eaESSa- as* +siN -~ aa~ ~ e+f+rO~ts, lus 00Mr Sot I did +at aee cocn. ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ lBTLLIS T. L9t+tIB,r C39. Oi''MM COURT RCPOMlt. MWARIt, l4J
Page 28: zlz30e00
1 2 ) 4 S i I 22058 do yors sgre*7 Thocw is rra Vay I raould tura ta th+e 4o0ce a. StLlawt As lu . a1wdt1tY is scgllag, Iwtll gtrrs It to Yw saea tn C40AYs I• It aoetsssty ihst tIw whsl* bwo1t go LAZ s XRr Slum& I t U Iin R~als we C10~~t If WS laglraMt1om is QttMjY bif0ce la. sLSAWMi Just so l"# " tbasi is se qo"t.loa abwt fts abil ity to shwr that la"w10 ts the 1691 1.A a1M,IIO &r9fipwftt. 2%8 CAm$ i! Ivu r.prsssst tir .e th+tt It is •Xriift La lYLalNm. W. sT.tAKtM= Tba d0a.sst io at is ev L"A". I vsad It - the lalorsrtiorti vas saA La oc~s~asswia~atlon of aas vitssss and the Airst tsaataatios e! .aofi.bet wtts:ss, !ut tm d+ros"at fttsttlf is - euQatpt its,l! 1s sft in t'r 1drrlWtl. It thtra is ew q,+oostisa arbewt my abilittr to ss. tC La oZa*lat, it mamm so dilftrss" ++betDss to rswive it ia MI/Ldoft" St' "t. !!i smw thing is tnk* vltb rNRRprtt to 442i2, the aaY postloft at abtsb ve ars tst.rsst.+1 is the ..6tiaa - a littlf PsrspapiR that rslatss to ri4wttw vit#Atiral that was sssi ia the ar*&ars"iAStisr et Ot. Jslt.o Go u~ m ~ ~ 0 a paYLLIs X'. L1lNI$! MRf 41FFiCXAL Coo $~` RBM3!!'lSA. HWARK, W
Page 29: zlz30e00
1 2 ) 4 5 f I 13014 It tAers is ao '4Uastias aboat oar abili.tp to rot.t to that laaguaq9 in D" 1 SI-R !s al*slnq, abies• io ao saod !sr it to 6s in .vLataaa. ZU tMTS L.t as say as t psMt.&l Ym.t** tut il a stats"st 99010 a tsst erc tnoaUs.a is aW1448M lty C.asoO ol !rw taat that a otRess hss iskswl~ itp to War QMtxt;s stsi tt io in .WN4.oss .stme the do.m.is la l. ea Mt. IN. WipAMWli TWNt 1Ne hilo gs }eftaMor us cm"s iE t4S wi.tilsss is oNlrsat" asA says. lNird sc it at 60 sst iskAdU'ledts iR. I "l1Ylst ti.sswt 441 tho" nht"s, but it g" tf13. s that it is in Md 0o004d6d to 60 in by 4400 Isqitiats 86404, s! WMasej xM1 Ns illK t* lQ. M=M 9LB pCwbi.i tltat :t•s taseiv.d,. Ray I satwr a etaosrioa xitk r*spat to 4.4@4Ml to whLoh yOQc 80wr so.toia.ri tbs abjostLsftq ?mt COOtT: Ali t lqkt. teu bettor ttll so whers I 0" gia4 It, Ir tAat le Chs last gtenpt NR. SLBARLrVs Tim laart qss* that ysu just disaussat sad ra swstota.d tJw Ndeetios. 11R. L'CO1tS dast "l.e* tISMT M Como teS. =. WAIMLtY S I an s~t avc* I saiststard the bss is log cs1ssttap this dac3vuwat. tbts ts a d000wpt %Uat we do PUYLLIS ?. LZWxSt COSR. SPfIi:IAL CDUR? a$PC)RT3ltr 31lWUSr FcJ
Page 30: zlz30e00
I 2 3 • S 4 7 i 3200~3 »at ofttr Eor the trutn of tfm atatoattst aAUa in thek AM olirotial, bue for tn* as4a mpww that, as to ahica sarra 200 t.rastia+ea w.c* raoariv.a ia a+rAOsaf uas ut abjeatioa, b.aaw" tb.y wrs ril i.d u by or. Naraia fes tlr* pac.pariitiu that the datasdants «rert on raftioe a1 tbo Mkit'ial tbelfi1la iiN u~r .ltstA" tUs 9os +th. saw pupu.t so are oltirtst tita !o s!M tx ifSi. tW l+baasf 2rdestay a" ia partltsiar: at. Gtt2lreaa wlrr wo qwwtLsmw aiwt %btst rAttacr vas pasoaally of os riw that tlr.t=a wra still rlspoasiblt sedloal amtlwr1tios, tsiting the position It had noi 0ofn pratiea. xe do Mot ott.r the Artricu 4hidtsaa Asa.oiat3os. 04i.tosia! 1or tiw purp*" af sayiaq sssitiaq dwosa't ausi oaaots, bat r#thtr that Eb* vebaavr xodnstrr had a q.od taith basis. It war usti prov.a in 1059 - 'lHR COMi'z I rlli toll Y*e WLat .y 0IAt.ing 1rasr aaW ivaderitau0 bacasu that was pupui if tb* prstffe. I did aot tbiMt that iur sditoaciai esarM into that ast"Orp. in ethor warr4s,. this raa ast an.diul @s ssiaAtiWo *Owiooyt i't tba AAA IWuaal GPM Oki" any of the "t.ase reasonably Ga1d hav* c.l iM. It woM a two prraOsapft o4irac tat sa4 iJuic f tasUy M sst Pat it ia tbo aar. oat.lar p. MiE. sLah"iY s Yost $060ta th! dutor vt iti" ha ltfYLJ.IB T. :.aKIg, C.S&, orrxcIAi. CM]!? 28POXTBw0 x8'iiau, NJ
Page 31: zlz30e00
I 2 3 4 S i 7 a 12061 the Josreai rith the larqast S.dfcal *tqaoisatiorr ia tiber world, ssPcwsinq the opiaion that It Y,aaalt b.ea Prov", Aat am Y" say tt ia Mt ta the aar. sat"oty? ft"Gtally +r#rs lt's o!'tetad toc the 1tsltoA patposs tiwt aa of Y!3l,, t1Mt tob"" imita.try haA a rossowrhle joad t4f th 11asis !or h"lel'1" that cespoaaimo sodiO&A "tbYt ttioa sttll tio"ht tllot l4 hsdm't MNe pt0w64 awd the imirlMO 1M"0al Aoro*olattat a4re4 to p*ilah the editertal 1a Its )ausaal rstl.ot4" s" i"iwtlws oo tb.ir part that tt wa a ctspon+sibi. positiao #or s.meb"Y to talte? Aui We *go+t ti, at loaat it sto" to .o, be p.rsitt.d to poiat to ttis artiele as vsw of the hasos opoa Whish thn iadwtcY aaotiawA t* h+ilmrs lt h"*`t hror Prov.e. I thiolc I oaqbt to be ahlo to asJUo it to tho laty. TU IoA'yt JUl tij1rt, wt " ta4W a looh at it. Thff is 4!t aA iitVitatioA to tlitVW a1l th+ai. !!R. W.E"EaY3 I will Sat bother ,yMt with a si»q3e let eom.* I Viil V.1o" at it. Ka. pARRiM: 3a4"p it x4a"d aat aqw&t i0% mf yous 66"+r abowt the rau" os t e rats law. *ah.aits" lhNro wss• aiwt i iw or ats ot kim* ni11 ad =sid var the tLt'st em. UX *Oltlft As I 90011 it, yait waro adtttiaq tbose to establtsh the datort i aosa ym sai# that uhat had s.aes PtTLLIt T. LS1rs, COt, OsFICxJ4t. CCM RVOWMA: MWIORX. NJ
Page 32: zlz30e00
I 2 3 ~ S i T t ! 11 13 14 ~ 1s ld 17 12062 c.ttcoawr to t.Yw timr that ar+r. Cipollono s.tdu hsc nsveaaa. J1a i lbiaKluq abwt tbo r ight qcorpv MR. r J1NRIMB t Aigi1t. !!i. plaistifE had sltocN orrtai• redlda1 rstvcds aad tjasa wsxe jwt - w ats ddf" the s.crer thisg plsistif E ws# me qw"tlsa abo+at tb. 4"bostisitY. tt was aqueetitw as to vbm ws 11sa. Elpollmo's ~ia4, ri.isg troati.d by a ds"sc toc that,O we plalatilta, !oc okriowr ratsas. .+cf 1uCpi" to Ps.lr that dato b*sk as tsc as pr64ilal.* lbero va. Jsst e~ds rik lab "ltoato r3eo ras vsughisy at as ssl3oa tisw taau the plaiatllfa p41C &A that fbem4 arir CIV@1ZsAi rtii M"ZIiAQ in 1!i!. 158 GOORT4 CIAS ot the thlVs: aai I vbvieWs'Yp did not bawt tM tUW taday to pafi oa UNt sOMsd sy Aroasos tsr every oaa af ebess rullais:, but to a au.bor of i.nsts*os*+ aad r.vtsvla4 thss deaummts, they alqht vstY welx - .nd Ws is a p.ct*ct axa pi. - siobt be rals"nt and afti.oW*s bet tbore baa to be a pelat WhOCi vO bs.M ta Mccy •nauO is o~wrng~, aPd it a,a+d reek a linited probative wal", a.d I ym daweraad tMt the Srry aosat w+fawt snro3,ved la atlNrn rrilaai c.eosds that cosl2r bat so solw+ra•o to aw .t CAo ataitslylaq MR. r11WlMt '!io p+ceb&IrrM. Xats 8irMUts to Oit it Mt. WWil will be silow.d t. arvt ia *loats, that iles. PIMLIS ?. LEWI9. ~SR. OIPFICtAi. tOM RasumR, mri1ARRf w
Page 33: zlz30e00
1 2 1 4 3 4 7 1206) 'Cipollons +xould nQCt have b*ara &ayi4a% Ravoiwo dat12l at laast If6t it •y0r bNOad" 10.k at the aod1Yal c."i+do, tllore Is nathlag taat pAor. a!S was oentqhtng astil 1969 wbeft th". r."rd4 sW+r It ws -- lagerrttd ta th*sa 0041661 ta0o=ds sta wS rapertiag to a pbysiaiad $b. *aa o"49hiaf W"b .axil.t. aad that f i ta i.poc tant peiNt. XS. WALrTMr I1 tbert wti anything amoat aGOiaqO maybe It oaLLB go tRa iat Id"'t •sr "rthtaq. I1 y" NiMt to point it +1it - it hiM to be St i0A1 ptabatlv4 volwo. Us COUTi 'Tjiel, wjw so w1Aii$b iA tboC• that Wed Sothiwel to da with tMra Qaaf, I)+t.t Aafirisd that wbatirac liaitM pCobatiwa raluo it ol191et laova, aad x s*00"1z0 the C+aNA it +Iai beiAq Psaiilri1d, it was too @YO4'whMIaia4 for the jacy to "ro all tAo aa4LvaI tsf®zmattsa thaE did not Ytlatf to the tasx* ip the caiso. XR. PARRIM Is that tk.r aaaae rnYtaq wikn tat laxt btts srW pt.ara wi piaLotltC•. O"1Oa1 rtaarrdaY 1oe wwt'USs I ofttrMi +tlght oc aloe rasotd4 the pil4iatilt ft" ao o*4astti.*n to, and tbotra ara records trrawt doctrwsAt wbaw sho beg" t$ avaqb. 9f'!ii Come it tlw tw oE Tou am ftSi4* on what to . s a.111 C.lsraati on that I will give yow a ahawa to t.ll ab"t it ant do it by slsaomeeste bwt I s"ta1a4d the abjastion !ac tbs toaaear I•spliiwaw tow Yev. P4-MLIS 'I'. L!T/M ~ ~~. :-VTICIAL COUNT MOt9CIS, H8l/AU, N,i
Page 34: zlz30e00
2. 3 I 4 s 6 I • they did obj.at. Yau sriowl& krva aew pcvwidsd wtth as obiiattow, asd Y.w w*r.alt. sd." t".:as go .n awA au. "Rot a" the iMot4 OmA1il11* i11 aRy am bf tb* cNet'"t If tbW QpqlItlt tt ilitt, iAW W* MNl ayllNl 04 8*d"11C it. ;2l963 Sy tho W.y, ttoakimtorit 4ith vrhat so afts Mr. A1iaaxlov diaqnaA*d, ia it otherwlde ia ~ ctaa+~7 M3;. P113AIM ftA't bilieri ~4. TaE CdiiR'1't 0l"I't tbink bo. *1., RtJ1AciRYs I "w*x aaii t did "t Objeft to tbt ott+rr t"t Yoe wrd" o! 2.dt0a2 rmwrala t"t .bowed o"hinve t wwolA uewr a4t" to it withwt iii" tb. ar."s* sr ra..t Ua* tbt boiy r! »~.+lioa twotds Ord saw +raat taresdr tiaa w#* that roice,rt.d to IUS. Cip.tloG960 ~iaq. a.rl L+ r tbaa tbr o"s Uo* ftl tasr &46 ftwr plab2.rr bara l,a Icbat wratw.r gappr,aiss they b.tb k.ve to be tr"ttd a=our tl* aaiwe ar tae jvxY vilx gwt a rrsrp mutasr pietar* ee#' v4sx the ®ewoing atart*d. W* would ipe dal t'sntad aot to bav* aay rsdtsa2 ra"*+1* la, bet it tho 1platariff is going to off+rs rh4m "d "y b+era I hav a r.oar4 la l.ldt* thfa, wa ara "inq to pot a" In La '8% ar that abre r"rtr aawyuiaq, so iot ra& S*t aa a'rao"Cit. W* wi 1l 4* tua sa" thtaq, KS. wALTUtc i oftsrad c.oo,rda. TDav dida't *bJaat to the soosra a" thay are ioaiu,da4 in the tooac da tiiat we wlll intsod*" in .vi4amta. 'lbsy didalt abjeat. It +YHY#.1y1B T. C.0#13, C.$!!ts rJPlrZC2A1. COU" R$PORTBR. tiEW11lR7Et SJ
Page 35: zlz30e00
I 2 3 4 s 6 T • 9 zo 12-16'5 rat co€iRTe it yeu "a 49reo on wtat is c*3:ev4At, aad it Cnat is tso putpEt", xs* waleoca tases the Ptrsttian it xtl.rte[ t1o slWsht,at, li will to ta. I dtidu't ltt It ge, blos*so it had tar rqtoh modiaat intol,aritfoa that lrW a4tbtng ~scra[vsi~ tL~e to dv •+ri.tt this caas*, aad X+ra* f.actal of I+tty. MR. lAWtlf8 Ws will uaR Mr.nt tlwt latsr* in t*=t t..t ao rN wiwtt else ia .o +fpf &100"• tqsta, a~d lt t• .aly bssraww sf Uo rreaswru al tiawr Y aili tell towi h" I/m 'gal" to tale m the vasietts aroti4oa, bst Qinriaws2y tAars rwold bs wa say# p+rccieaiatly sloc+c I stota .e as" tiaw woskLriy am tirs jury ehsrjt# that I ttsoiA YoYO aa optaioA t'rady an tbt4* tsssESs Wfc LNtaasa0 vo ac* b"taalT4 eYsaisV atqw#AWts ~ttort I tMW*bt yo12 Vore ewtltlld C• im0v how I dtQid*4 tb*so Mtterst re"svl" the cigtt to fiie an opiniaa an aaoh at tbrs. I taee 44mtdfd t itat, to tcant tbe a.ties of tbt d.ffn"ftts e0 this iad.p.aitat 0141,4 o! poMt-x466 itippC "fAear 1 will d,eAy t;i3e iOtt4;ls, tOr dileatlii V*cdtCt that bdiy`o b"ft i44@ lltrher liiy tbo plliAti1f 48 Ivy tbo 4otlwsaAts. I will gcantr ai.tbonlb it dia not sawr ap as I re4nlt. - yls# it did* I talt+c It baste tarttoc lal hw tt araw apt I xil lVsant the r*tiaa of Wrillat4 and Philip Noi,cic is iw the isso# ot to oO V1 Oo ~+. ~ oDb PMY'LL2S T. LawLs. C3i1, OMPI'CiJL COURT AVOR'PARP MWi", MJ
Page 36: zlz30e00
32066 I i 3 4 S i 7 bet yfil deny It as to tAe P.laiqtlf$'s Slaie ef alimpXesintatiitn. So la sthec Woeds. +rMt rrill to to o. Jocy to the alaia a1riaat alY thtao da.a"ata c+q"Irdifts niarcrps*sarAtetiaA, but t.*o eor0MalOwnt alain will de to the jrtY " oqai,Rrt Liggetti waljr. I rili Itaat the d~tMrwlswts' *tfa^ ar Ura aan.w.c SRaild statesl1. T" Cwt 9Uw1s Illiit t1Ntt Is IU't a Npiist* &wO. 4t ssioO aW Wlll sos bO wbsittad to th* JUsy ~rs arek* ri"ltY* as I 1arve altsa$y "Wiaated. I*poet 411 d..y yesussar rsiri[iny on tAe abac"s zt to a" bei" tyQed. E rawid lils W+rre the day ir *ver to raeatvo ts+arr riw what I )sat isdtmat+d. Amwlr. Arspeta3lAf ajetat tmatr"tiou a. to what r.levsaae tcAeeo to to ,cey of 1lt.. CIpelloui'S p4Mt-1'A64 0i"Lng. Ota.+c r.hsa th4t: ih.ve afflwidarc" all at the dtseasshurt IrMt W+c WW cbe st%*1 dayr .4 Wir+c #0ra - In +c!loot sade cal inqs as ri l l be c.rfiested bY 1he omRys. it, s"old am ready !or yert rraclr tsmeszew morslag, so rou am efahtr sead soft*body to Plot !.t ap as at least aall a" tind oes vr"w it ri.il Irs C*"Y. t&.r. ba.atw sporc a aaeos .d 00" ceit"a: ,e.quistQ to vmp. a"ia .crasi tbe i8*aeapeos3.#se .A those xill he r.ady later teoucw seteing #aeesa40 I ar still in s. IPA -.1 YMLIS T. LiRWIS. '"` R, OffIClA4 4.'~3t7" ASMIM H1MARiC. W.T
Page 37: zlz30e00
I 1 3 L s i 7 ths procaaa oi worki€ry wltb tuaw. So tkat ia yb. e re staow. mA. DARNMLi CAa x N&kr i ~1tQ~A«OAs AIAO* ~11Y~i ~lltl~[flqatOr~N~ I0A0c is A"ACiAtIr still MARki114 AA tho sd r.i ssre the d1.iN»daat a woaOt©o3.at? I tkink yaat sanot saswsod tm qraitiaas aN tskrt -fs0 litMt tMpiMMlOt'j dMSvli. YitMt 20t se"tMtlli wt ,r"tai apMlslt Mi ftdioa2 sNo*s+wts a.A .tieoe tAi+aqs0 it is aat SiGr.taMiay t"t the +rodfl civil cbarlMr aM I will 1* qlad to Qils yVA a*rrpy, it doaa aat allov, bnt satlN: a iaw* r" •- M CMRTs COmpomaatoty daai9sr I an iwt+~ tbar dltlAeiats baV! !RY objliiklAp tt t$at* m. OUlfULi rivstti4, they vliiitld11' I6. i'ut CoUA?e 8o juat ao.Penaatory da"q+ nY MR. 0J4ARKo4• Ca9K"t. 788 CflUlt'y& 0dlD that 1Rf1Jud1 tbo atrdiaax ao +rai i 7 [IR. DumL s I btl iolr• i t doos, y*dt s+asim. lta. V"lMt JV49o, rith r*g4nj to y-aur calx.aq6 *A tu Q*Aawra fraud "t,r is your culinI it io t"7.lY Sayitoatiwr ol tbw oEa+sr aass.a et striv~caai sa* Coo t'tr Xti is mot an ireft.ara.n.t saas. *S a4ti4A. Pra"Ix. I40 not tbink 16 ts arts coxavant 484 x will a+rt inaLstl. it &a tb. shar1s aac! aot iaolwttn4 it •6 a PHYL;.1'S T. MWlt[, CSs, ;)rT4CIAL =R°! 1tNlORT11t MMAHK, %-4;
Page 38: zlz30e00
I 2 1 1 5 6 7 • 0 to 11 I 245;~ 40PiXat'e CAiiSr.. k$. WAMJt$t ' realia* that. Bt1L if 1a thM OVOUt ++o wwre to r.oor.r lt It W.r a dapiiaativ. 4atioa, it r.qaLca the Conc t to lrve*. oUirr iaarse# that are aat r.levaat to tb* jucy cans iderat tc+rz ••y TVi CL1UM wo iasa 4lral with It latac. Pec the Eiae brrl"* it is art 4rris4 as rt at#"ato oaaao arot *ill tr.1er •be aw iwat rrrat to'A. aad 1 t it lrar erew+rPoaset, yvw w" *rgsa` lattx* n. DAMML; x t "o qoeattos 170 I1ft or"08o tuat the 94.8txoo staply o.as wxtA Wkst aM.o9.. 414 lu.. Civollo" an.t.sA, io.s .wough to Aasorp"ato the aVo.co. 40 tbat I. sai we asar on th.r. M oOMM aks.. Do tb. 2aMM th.tog tar xr. Ctpo+tlaaiw. M. DAMLLs x. s. 1nstW`44 ot "! t i GA00; l oaa ot GOV04aLoMALg, 1rrt" it 0lt. Aa p.q* 20 taux Soaos Ats t4e tota:3 •ttrfbataa1s to aaaro ot tAe partioa, and it Is th. +r.so thluq oa 4"stteft 20 - emaoea su - qatatioa 1s aad 20,, ro+tld arl10"te the a.rewst attrimwtanlo ta *a" of tiNr P&rtirs. ib.11a•re ag.tn tlro wAr3 4bar qo r 1qtt t r rts tm ptEttrlt"o et Iclw tetsIs ao i t your iqAMC V"l4 alroai out ftift"St• and put operQlAtale.IP tn COMM Do tbs ifasaiaR1:. aqrwwtT XR. TBOiA6i iden't Wak tb.s* to any reqaorc PLY4GIS V. L$wt$r G32. 0MCIAL Coos? At$PO1tTERr ~4iWd1RN. N.7
Page 39: zlz30e00
a 3 4 ! i ? 3106P far An si'iac:atxo». Tsn'L it just )sint and seveV41 1 t aWi 1 t Y t v1hy uou1ds' t yau bri a+i efwg+c aaur awwor? ltit. D1191tD"S 1 t hJaAK w+ie b" t bit Csq"st in ss r ptapass4 sharr". !9! CoalM Lst ,.i asic the riasa"rts, thm plalntit! *ts aot rsPir• ra a3lssitiaA. lit. URliU.bt I Wiix """ tLat " me- awi4swsri ts." - !lt! E'Oiftt3= T"t is snax bstaatm tarm ple4at14t awd btqltt, that will stay lb. 1lat do the - aay sf tha 4tttaaaSta want an allat~atloa of ctasspOa? as tt'a~ KR4 DMX9LLs Tr+rr ne"c, s laos uwifrstsod. L.t ua assiwe it 1*" 06 amal, sNrt the a*araist is svstal4e4 as to .ww dolhndaat aad aot tr to ths+ +rowra. They rill wavs to uadlrtstiwd vhotrrt ls isie t'n after .Mal rill haws to bt liablt !ar t#o rh*1# Wmg. 129 COE#R'Ps Joint aW ssVOrsl, tbat rsa J»st talkud abOut . Mlt. Tam": w! M+1E71lt to talt Ib"it liG. Tqg (;OU$'x`i t wo1iLd Xik! to lilS011 COdiY. tCQ1tAatl 00At10g. ) h11. C=Xs ihLib 4ilsstip/tY MR* Dll!lMLS flaestion id aad t9. Mik. WAMd.: Mt*t's1tt its61t 1`Ot I=s iiVAit1rlt daara9ss. PRY :LIJ' T. f...W19, CSR* OrPICIAL COtlRT RXMltgtR,, W
Page 40: zlz30e00
I 2 3 4 5 12-4'?1 nt COURT; Yss. KR. CtiM A.3a rtqhr. Oaf. Tst Cams 4'ra.. 1i1o ol3vsarioa. That is by A9KOm11t to s4ko it siapltt. Xk. aAMML1 do tiir reomxd i,o Cl..c, I doa;& waac to baVrt a pcebl+ae +ra.a they .aI it .h"xd brrv* b.r". = Wusls lb.p sr• "Ifafi" twre sbooid a.t bs oA "211"tliA ft SompeeiatASy* ftMitlTf dM"s* vwisllslx' it the Jory giads Pwit3wr iAftal"s, th.p harQ aaoR ,ska sfparats .aracda. u+x. tI11RMLL4 Ia additYono rro bass aa.w lsaqaaqs* maYbe too lst.. Ort oo Uair rrMA19Y1 death 1MR'I4 Lis terss at rkst *l.raarnt. +hwld be awsptiato t®s tho 1sty to oonsidst got trrs. Civoilo".'a loas. I believe +r1Mea yoar moaor cni..3 tb.t ",eru Woid be aa tiaaooi;al kost, it W+tsa't wsry mcsh 1e!'t. TtiB CiJItT1 I titds't tal+ It. It vas rttAdxara. An. DARS$L:.t so didMf t meia to withdraw tbo ~'iitiq rrorstss 9itsar, t.f I aan hand Lt to you. Tillt COMi 4iV* it to U. W*i»rr. SA. MOWt ih aLsb "i* probablY sqltbiiv that. *." witlr ito that io o r+iqsNtt tmt, t/aY be rsqwrstad that a~asatoty 4ora"s atar MK aabje4t !O ie4.m tas. vbisb L Cbiak is past of tho mYdil 1i0". TU EOWL'YS no you travs it harro7 PUTt+isx9 T. LXMfISi Cg9t. OIFYCia1L COUWT JM3tdlt'Ptik. HUMARKr W
Page 41: zlz30e00
1 a 3 4 3 4 7 gi ?20li RrL. T901W7 4IN Q4ii jjoC 1ts RR• QARMW %'--) 1009 il the 1449U&Jls ti La aie"araaxaa wltil the *WWl, w have a4 plvizlor. TOM C40R?r l1aYbody "rr+e it? !'bis is !t. NR. R.IMR t A 4uast itra - NA. CARWMW I also lravt. +rnd id+on't ktt+w tt rvar 00"c W"ta iR# but L vatlua as it .A I a# +rtEas"I it# oa the 94AINfi to lfalif NM 1aa~0 a tM+lte frM hlintAf we tlsitic is alpropc iana t. ow* the jrry ta ass*la of vbat ta swat Nh.a we a+iy it d"Sa't Uays to rwr a"aolsaiv+r arridfftcs. It is An iCt "l illld it Oi TolIaiA aqd 4te baVe the P1LQ4 iMlA toe jarr +rbato.. Rit. BLSMtYi t thought tbac vo.s tiat+sairdt. Ma. D"Nl2.L: Llt saurs ar " s result ot the 41.444*100 rr &d.y. Tt[i COUR'!t Vfii, it tmaa is Aa abje4tlets. I son` t 1064 at it . X1. W.RAM$Yi There is an objeCtlislt- WR CGCilt Al2 right. XX. SIi.EBUs Just a claxltiarEisn. The wMwsl.eatr rawr colinlr on svLdoa+aa irsat by quaiclys Dat I " .at. I itaaw Uuet a~ at the .^rUiss.. Ebrc vent woi.r the ta9 iEa+t# thtea,»patty ramatotrn vont ia. stv iMwesstaaA that it' i+Q+rs1ng in tas .." s*A.r purvoaso p+st.•'ss. tLk4 tp. Ba+Mwr"r iaai+iaat aad Am ant ~~jl~.Ia '!. ~.~iXS} 'GSRr flAplCIA#~ ~R1' RRi~?RTR. 1Kaa ~t1~tAR2~# ;~~
Page 42: zlz30e00
2 2 S ! S 4 12072 Tu7G COOR'CO iCoentt teXx yas'r tir, stxfta. I kaow C"a ii Yom toiT as ohy it la aGawiaq ta or a.akiag 20 titoE r it ot aw. I va*l4 barro dllt iou1Cy sayia4 I4+ a. axLMx *oll, Uo plalutitts ottored stvoral t.aaons* seL the Naairvrlor iaaridaatt, t" Spsian bwttts Md t.a. Yirysos bat.M alt/Wi lrssa La. I ss*psot it pot-'ti t"r41-jsttY saplsc"sleft is sot of t1O oaaros Lt will 1ro prottj aMaCooiw a, itar. it. t d"tt o"t eo start aW"1. jMW PCsWo00 tt#. W11LTMs i 4o0 't aAieA raay +rf Uo doswwacs we pro!lorad wro friarid sa Eh.Ltd-rpstltir smWtaaioa. M COMM Dldn' t tRisk re* ag. itALTIM savt t4 bi aftissfo!m of aa1otRaqso.ais, mossa POAAUwqa, that sort 09 thirw. Ug Cam$ I rdat say, b*t*se I bsq" the r+ra i w .t %k* .s!kibits I bad dsvl.dt+L tcyrirA-pacty siVr"aioa vaa sut, so I xa. Lairl7 aaarp.ttaLs iL I ltt tt stay ia, At was a~ ~1~1R~ t~a4Efli. 11t. J4BMLXT1 sbo{ijdalt be aclliolit iWi to th! )say abowt tbo rftarGs to suvpCsas poot-'i6? US CO=rs E>t 06mrso aot. It is ost at tbs 6400. MR. L1{AW=1 Mi WNp aad I ituW l."t yas weAtk shtOso - 2'1t! CtlM4s Lsfc so as4 a qwstctoa. Met is tbe saAsdllla Mr MR4 is #*fM+a tiest7 pmLI8 T. m(1s, Ca1t, OPPICIAt. CMAT kX"arfial DfWAM, *7
Page 43: zlz30e00
12073 3 I Z 3. 4 S i ? KA. MANS21 Tha dalenctaRt*. (Lawqhesc.l l1R. X2AItMr Sdr ry. i tha'Ot Mc «MO1 i aata *.kia'. ?ka C.~t to a.ki". W* rt21 say )tic. Cokn. TRZ COFJRre What to tm raqv4ua*, " I ti#sw. l1& WAAKWs 11e at'O 11!! WilO Y41Ls rllt Ai[. CobA wtll ie sustfog tieasrtor: !ax i.WMt Us .uir aawastlom "mrrsr.w viil be Mt. faM. '!vo oa ftwtsaaayT Me. 4Laii1i1/ 1*tr asd tWO Plar14tlflf PrA411Y. ?ti[s COal'!$ Plsisttff fir.t tbisy rriday mcsihq? rilt, COM Ye** fttll CORTI Dv tos all apse. s vtn it the pr2alatiff f isiahss by a" 0•4l.0A that ws sR"id sA chargo tuo )sry till gooday wcrsi,a9? *A. COM I s1=.e. TRA GOOtTt AsybodY tbialc w"4t to otsat4s rAa Jvey rriday aad start dolib.ratian elorWayt ft. MitMMLs 'tht osly ass+rptisa .roald b+e it the jarY said we wauld iika to wrsk rwar uw vfat.ad. Hse tILl"Li]ti what2 lM. DARWW#W Us sslr txceptiot rs$,id be it the JoxY l.old your Ma+at w waet to jet staR,rtaa distasday. I d4s `t ksvw %hat they wil l wsat to dw it. PSY4s.13 T. .'.fiv1'qe CS8. OYFIClu CtX3R2 Xr?4K3ftu* P1mm"#"-Mmy?
Page 44: zlz30e00
I 2 3 4 S 6 12074 The other thing I think it is perhaps tiAe to deal with it, or before alosinq, is the qutstion of seqeestratioa. 4UB CCBiATs We dealt with it. l1A. DABN8L3.= I uisaed i.t. I was probably back in al oftioe writing sse of my [4rv briera. XR,, iiXWd'i e Ia yorr lisner ctoas Lde r iny 4sk ing the jury it they want to sit wfa the wrssfmttd? TBlQ CC/QAT& No. I will aharge thew on Monday. NR. HLWL3lt I would do it Monday. Yoo asked what the ordec will be. It will probably be Mr. Cmlun, Nr. Northrip and ". U. x BMIMY i t F I say, I ve r ta i nly don' t baq r udge you the work you had to do over the •athibit*. It aaused me • headache over the we.kend and with the speed you did it, it was a very difficult tAUk. I an now rearguieg LW003. It is the note$ af a researeh aont.renae 4t Liggott'a in January of x953. It asy have bson lost., your Honor, because it was tbree stAer Liqq.tt or ADL reseasoh type dovumeAts that w.nt to a dllftreAt issue that your 4anor mry have conceived to be aoliateral. This document - its authentsaity ba« been PHYLLIS T. LSW!S, CSR. JFFICYAL c.'WRT REI+OR3"SR, NWARY, A;5
Page 45: zlz30e00
I 2 3 4 5 I 7 12075 stipulated and the only iasue and objection wus its It vas uved during the croas-exasination of Dr. Harsi.. The last thrae pages of the eYhibite, you may not Aaw q"teA that far - the Last faur pages it reports that oa af the r0searoh soientista, Dr. L.isersoa, wint and to a pre..atatioa by pr. iMphtr aesoornla4 ine4 cancec &ced aiq+arftte srwkiag and .thor enviroamental etEtcts. It is a report iA essence of a literature survey or search. It rwpoeds to one other thing. & number of these oonfere+nae ,ceports or notes of monfersnces have been in the ra"rd* lls. tdell sslect.rd these he wanted in his charges against Liggett on their researaA and what lae didn't wanti, he didn't select. I don't begrude it, ckbviousi,y, it is an ancient docuesnt, so there is no prcrblen with respect to hearsay. We have been cbarg+ad with reaurinin9 in the Daric Ages prior to ' 54, doing no research pr 'sar to 054. We have btea charged with oanduct against Ltggett that goes to Liggett's motivation, state of mind what they do. Nr have been "arqed with fraud. This docwrent relates to all of the e5argee. it says pcioic to Wjr»der. we wre out there doing soaothing and what we learned and what we learned ia here. It goes to our . PFiY?.LIS T. LEW13, CBR, 4FFICIAL COURT RKPORTBR, NT4ARK. NJ
Page 46: zlz30e00
1 2 3 4 $ 6 7 121 137f, knawl.dge of what was in the 5cientitic community regarding ss*ing and baaltb, like sa ,nany other docvnsents like titis put i.n that tir. Harris didn't like. I ask the Court to reooAsider. Overrule the 4bjectioR. TU CW1t'f sWhat is the nu.bar? MR. lSARbiUs Li4-0003t researctb eauferenee report, and re wst to df r"t tbe Jurlr's attention to the pact being o!lered Qosw.enaiag on the last four pages and I can't give you a auMer. M! CWKgt I must say th4re -•- and I cannot ceaseaber the reasoning I went trr©uqh, and I recall that document in fsrtioular. I tbink there is a big ditferenas between the plaintiff offering an internal docusent ayainst tho defendant suggesting that it contains somw admissions, and the defendant bisselt offering a docusent without any w itnsas, witbout any explanation. I tbint that ia -- in other wttirds, to that axtent, it is self-eerving, and although I conceive that the poature of the case has recoqsi'sed the autmeatia+ity of the doauoRents, IJust have sQ.e besitascy in dsopping a deouMent an the Jury without any eapianati.aa as to what it is and no rritnsa frow the defendant esPlainiAq it in any way or being subjected to cross-.xa+xination. PHYLLI3 T. LMIS, C3R, OFFICIAL COURT Rti£~ORTF.R, Ng-dAARR, `:~7
Page 47: zlz30e00
12077 I 2 3 4 5 6 7 ~ ! io I2 12 13 14 , 15 16 11 ld 19 20 21 22 23 24 23 MR. tFsARMY: Tnere is a diff'erence, I agcae, analytically and lugically, but it doesn't apply in tAYra Ca". AnalyticalZy, it doesn't apply in this case, because Mr. adsll can introduce all doaur-ents that are ada#srions of a party because that is not haarsay under ladoral Rtlos. Not a hearsay prabxaa. 111 this QaN bma1tYe we are dealing with dtlcupents over twenty ysars of aqes tlato is no hearsay boQause they ats aamepted by the ancient doesser-t e=ctptios, which is a romarkabl• fxcaptioa and is the law. !-nalytioal ly. they are dif fsrant# but it deosn' t have a meaningful difference. 4cpically in fairness, vbich Is, I can see why it's sowwhat dif£arrstt in the otdinary caso, that is, that the plaintiff ought to have the abilLty to put theaa in, I wouid think, and the dafendaat at:ould have, to eYp1aiA it. tlartvor, here* when you are dealing with 30 ysa,r-old docwatnta, who can explain these documents? They are ber• and there are tons of them, 30,000 more that were produced here. Be I think in gaicntss, sinae I1r. Raxris and ar. Sdoll oould go through all of them without a ritnass, wittsout anybody to put tbar into coatext, without anybody to explain thaar we should be able to do the smat* PHYLLIS T. I,MS, C.SR, OPPYCIAL COURT REP4RTER, NI,,WARK, °l;T
Page 48: zlz30e00
I 2 3 4 5 6 7 t 9 120 7 ~ fiHR COURT: I v+ill take another looic at ttem. MR. dLF%CLgYi I wanted to make sure we know what the schedule is.. 3hould we have soseDody here to pick up the charge, and if sd, what tisup T80 CO t1RTs I would say ttn o' alock is probably saf a. 1tR. aLBARdTt lhursdax, what tiaoY Tu0 Ct7tilt?': I thisk we ought to start early. l4R. OLZ M BYt I a9rse. ToH Cf?MMs wbat is your suggestion? MR. sLgmlS'i: 9 400 or 9 230. TH8 COURTs Bither ef tnose is fine. Let us t ind out fron the jury if they hav• a problerr getting here at 9:00, but 91300 ttte latest. NR. 1?RDtDCri+1S1I swith regard to the plaintitfla lawful death charge, I have a problem in the ssns* that we prepared vn+t and unfortunately it is being typed at the present ti}ae. It haa a few paragraphs that vock in the aatuarial, the tiat, and I don't think it is nwch different, but I hopefully ask tkea Court to get it ia at 9 o'clock irl the MOtniR1g. woxald that be a probl.o? Tt3B COURTs Yes. Kft. DRt3tDNASKIs How about in an hour we will bring ~ OD ~ N ~ N ~ PgYLLIS T. L4WIS. w3R, OFFEC1Ar. COURT WQRZ`BR. NEWARI, :+~j
Page 49: zlz30e00
1 2 3 4 5 6 12079 1t livet ? Ma TDOMS1 Hili-i'lYui s, TBR C4URT: I need it today just in fairneas to my seoretary. I want everything here and reselved. dgsin, it would be very helpful if you sit down wf th Mr. 1laarnell and a9ree on the language. 1M. D~Dpi~1~SI =Ny preblem is x t' a dictated and -- 782 tOUATa I,Reaa when it arives, look at it. I would .rtoh ratber have somebody Eaa.* in and say you reviewed it aad rather than worrying about it being acceptable. There vertainl'y should be no proble,a about the appropriate instruction for wrongfu.t death. MR. ©AWKJ.# While we are asoadinq, I hate to got up, I qet two things FAX'.d to w this afternoon from Webster z Sneff ield, one on reliance and one on the commeat I issue re discussed. On the comment I, your Honor has seen enough paper. I trust your Hoaor got the rest of the br ia€ Saturday afternoon. T88 COtJR?: Yes, thank you. MR. pRRAiBLLt But on the reliance issue we will not brief it eaoept to point out what was aiready contained in our trial brief page* 52 through 53 we taink meets the arguments rsised. we have estra copies if your uonor would like tb.Nt. TRE COURTs It will all be resolved. it will be my P43YLLI3' T. LEWI9t CSRi OFFIGIAf. COUS'1' RE'Pt7UAT8R. NEWARK. X
Page 50: zlz30e00
1 2 3 4 5 6 I ! Y2Q!30 jury irostruc:tiori, and I will hear fxo;a a11 of you I' am sura in tlse formn of objecstions once you receive it. 911. DARN&LLs Tret sM ask you about it. When you say •objectiona,' I think it would be are we going to proceed with closing before we kn©w what the dafisite f inal ruling is on tbo aharga? ?ItR C4D1tTs do. You vill have my aHarge tmorton, se b.gosa y+ara wr ups you will lsa.a it. Nt. 04="s so any objections axe toc the r.rsord, I taRa tt, what is !n, is doae? Titft COURTs I have dealt with the probless. I ruled np+sn tt and the last tbinq I waAt, asileua you look at the cbarq" and say that I am eo clearly wrong on the lar, but it is what we already discussed, and I have dealt with it aW rrtestli d with it, and this is my ruling aad that is the way it will go to the Jury. There tias to come a time when I say enough. l4R. PAARISH: One tbing. I spoke to g++. Walt®rs before we started today, aAd apparently we do not agre4 ©n his - on eur approach with r.rpect to the deawnstrative •sthitsits. !ly suggestion was asW is that we take t4e approach that the dermoesatratire exbibits should not had gone into .vi,denoe. I don't have a problem witb the Jurors looking at the d8nenstea.tiva •sbiDits iP they vastt, with the exception PHYLLIS T. LEW'IS, C3Rr OFFICIAL COURT RBPU:i'PRR, NV11RK, ~4j,
Page 51: zlz30e00
2 3 4 3 6 12')'31 I don't rbink the jury should be taki.rig into tae jarcy room with then deaoaatrative exafbits t4at were created with eounsel wbi i• the witness was on the stand, by wr iting thxAgs a& the witness was testifyiaq. --• I think that is improper and I think TB8 CCURTs L.t aa do this beaaust we ace now under somw time presuuc.o. Do you all aqsee that anything that was utilissd as a desoart.satiw esbibit duriaa tbf oourse af trial can be utilisard fo+c demosstYative purposes in sumstion? 1t8. PAARI98= Yos. Kit. COHNi Yes. SUB COURTs Then what I think we avot to do is do it atter I h+rve instructed the jury on Aonciay, we can then deQide what, if anytbiaq, we should do with the exhibits. Thete is no reason for us to spend the time doing that now. tiR. C©gN: Your Honor, did you g.t our ietter about the teliance point? 'PBS C4SIM Yes. !!R. CaM When Prichard caae. I am a littie bit familiar with it, and that is why I waAted to sake sure your dorsoc g4t tAe latter. TKS COURTs I have gotten all your letters and beiefs. MR. CaSNi That ia smstbing L know about it and PUYLLIS T. .LEWIS, C3R, QFIPZCIAL COURT RtPORTSR. NSWRRK. :4xT
Page 52: zlz30e00
1 2 3. 4 3 6 7 24 2s rtliance was Qharged to the jury. 143, WALTERSt Judge NR, CEflWs I have the aharqe, if you want to ses it. TglC COLiR?s No, I taka your word for it. Ifd. 1p1t.TM There wert & aonple of eahlbits that 1k« Keara.y had ia 4is jary binder aAd I hid in my jury bladtr that wrr• alal,lar, Iwt we bad highlighted different a.ations. We both ros* qoinq to offer it in redaoted iarr, aAal we have wt +ror k.d i t out. I asame that that is a dea"est rs will have to work out aaid rubnit later. Tbose are the indaxes. Are you still planning to oitex them? The health qafscionn&ires that itts. Cipollone filled out? We had to work out redactions and didn't qst the redacti0ns, your version og what you wanted to use. MR. ICaAANZY i Al l r iqn t. T11B COURTs Anything else? I have two matters waiting Eor a+e. MS. WALTEltSs We have to read iato the record one of the exhi'bits that we have no objections tar both aides. TBB C00ltT s Why don' t you do it tomorrow aorni nq? blS. KAt.TbltSi 4kay. MR. DAitML: We can do it at any tiae as long as PBYLLLS T. LEVIS, C3R. OFFICIAL COURT REPCIRTBR, HEWARK fNJ
Page 53: zlz30e00
12033~ a 2 3 S 4 7 the parties stfpulatQ. we can do it whi;l'e the jury is out as long as the f ury is :n -- ?UB Ct?Uit?c Might be good to do it before suatsations, though. MR. SIXJ3AI I was wrong. You sustained the abj.atiaa to BoNbwrqs and I apoloqiso. My last words are an apoie4Y, uS CiOM= Al l r i qht. Oood. tLwg6ttr. ? TBR CaQit'!r May I ask counsel a questioA oA these eshiAiti7 11s usual f do I have copies? For instanoa, these ,folders that I rsc.ived from the detendaAes, are these or iginaYs or copies? MR. BSMKBX& You tzavo copies ro presented. You have copies. We bave the doaomsnts with the orilinal Sesking. *e will hav.r to tate the list you have given us ansd ccwpile the actual doauxenta and give it to the clark. 'i'RS COtJBtT: I want to icnow wbat I do with all the.. t1lt. BSMWEYs Why doA't you give thest back to us, or teep th.e. THN COURTs I do aot want to keep them. mR. lCSAMsY s?hat is why I sa id give then back. I brought my so-aaaled originals to submit to Bria agter your P'KYLLIS T. L$WIS, t::iR, OFi' ICIAt+ COURT REFORTF.R, 14-451ARfL, _'kJ
Page 54: zlz30e00
1 2 3 4 3 6 7 ruling$, but I nee3 90me time to 9vt st tvqether, TfiE COURTs Leti ae qive you thia back. I will take tbe otber mattere &f ter counsel clear out. (8ahibits were sarked Cour tExbibit* 128 through 132 ia evidene..y {Court adjourned.) PRYLLXS T. LFWISr CSR, JFFICIA,L COURT REPORTCR, tiDWARK, 4J
Page 55: zlz30e00
1 © 2 3 4 5 6 7 9 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 ~ e N 16 b 0 0 e O u 17 0 ~ 18 a a • 20 a O s W a a M 21 C ~ 22 C O u 23 24 25 I N n r, ': E X Ii 7 I3 t T' S Pln . Tn I;VTnL'NC'T' ('ourt Exhih'its: 123 thru 132 1?034

Text Control

Highlight Text:

OCR Text Alignment:

Image Control

Image Rotation:

Image Size: