Tobacco Documents Online

N.M. GILLIAM, HSQ.s LEAF DEPT,t MILLSAh~. I 146D D.Go FELTON, S0UTH~ON. 19th Noven~ar, 1962 Thank you for sending me a copy of your letter to Me. ~dd concerning my note of my recent visit to S~ltze~land. ," In one important respect you appeared to have misinter- preted my meaning and as this underlies much of your argument in the subsequent paragraphs, I hasten ~ tl~ to set the mstte~ straight. The proposed Information Centre is in no way intended to disseminate to the general public information about tar and nicotine contents in the ~noke of cigarettes but to prevent exactly that. It was.envisaged primarily as a means of gathering information ~medical, epidemtologtcal, etc.) in the fleld of smoklng and health, digesting thls and then supplylng It~ through the President, to the member companies of ASKo It would thus serve as a readV source of information to the President In countering attacks on the industry which may be made from time t;o time. Once:such an organlsatlon is estab- lished, the n~ber companies of ASFC could proceed to the development of standard methods for use ~thtn the industry on a national or international scale. It was to stave off this development that I placed greatest importance on the establishment of the Information Centre. T.M.S.C. has been in existence for a number of years andt although standard methods of smoke analysis have been, and are belng~ v~rked on, no flood of analytical results has taken place, To have wtthin the industz7 standard methods of analysis is useful, especially whe~ dealing with claims made outside. Suc~ outside claims are best handled on an industry basis because In this way co-operation on an international scale becomes possible and a united defence can be put up. ~reover~ it helps to tie down the odd '~daverick" which there may be within the industry in one countz7, If a suitable candidate for the post of scientific adviser can be found, he should be able to exert a restraining influence on the more vocal members of the ASPC and should damp ~v~ Just those features you find so disquieting, He v~uld, for example, C tJ'; cx~

N.M. Gilliam, Esq. -2- 19th Noven~er, 1962 be able ~o point out that tar and ntcotlne analyses are scienUflcally of little meaning and may even be n~sleadtng in a health context. If the Swiss Federal Health Authorities are contemplating a review as indicated by Waltz, then the scientific adviser would be able to present counter reasons on behalf of the industry as a whole, ~ather than f~om the point of view of one or more individual manu£acturers. I apologise for hav~ng apparently mtsled you by ~y note.," I ~ealise now that I should perhaps have amplified the thinking behind tjne discussions, but when I wrote the account I assured that everyone ~eadtng it ~uld be aware of the parallels between T.MoS.C.~ the Gez~an Forscbungsstelle and the proposed Swiss set-up. c.c. D,S.F. Hobsonp P sq. J.G,D. lqudd, Esq, H.D. Anderson~ ~sq. O cZ~ --..a.