Filter Ventilation and Design
CIGARETTE SMOKE AND FILTER DILUTION ANALYSIS USING TUNABLE DIODE LASER INFRARED SPECTROSCOPY: I. DESIGN OF A COMPUTER-CONTROLLED PUFF X PUFF SYSTEM
Abstract
Reports on research in which a tunable diode laser (TDL) was used to determine the change in filter dilution as a cigarette is smoked, monitoring carbon monoxide as the representative smoke component. Finds that the average dilution of all lit puffs is greater than the dilution for the unlit puff, with the exception of the last puff, in which the dilution value decreased b 0.5% dilution units. Includes data.
Fields
- Type
- Report
- Chart/Graph/Table
- Company
- Philip Morris
- Site
- R577
- Author
- Harward, C.N.
- Hill, A.T.
- Kuhn, W.F.
- Parrish, M.E.
- Vilcins, G.
- Recipient
- Davis, R.E.
- Dwyer, R.W.
- Fagan, R.
- Farone, W.A.
- Gauvin, P.N.
- Geiszler, W.A.
- Harvey, W.R.
- Hausermann, M.
- Houck, W.G.
- Ikeda, R.M.
- Jeltema, B.D.
- Jenkins, R.W.
- Kassman, A.J.
- Lephardt, J.O.
- Lilly, A.C.
- Martin, P.
- Meyer, L.F.
- Osdene, T.S.
- Parrish, M.E.
- Seligman, R.B.
- Watson, D.C.
- Waugh, R.M.
- Whidby, J.F.
- Wiley, R.M.
- Belanger, W.T.
- Bokelman, G.H.
- Carpenter, R.D.
- Charles, J.L.
- Claflin, W.E.
- Cox, R.H.
- Named Person
- Belanger, W.T.
- Bivins, J.
- Donathan, A.
- Jeltema, B.D.
- Trainer, D.
- Wiley, R.M.
- Named Organization
- Alltech Associates
- American Time Products
- CTI
- Digital Electronics
- Filtration Physics Group
- HPS
- Laser Analytics
- Matheson Gas Products
- MKS Instruments
- Potter Brumfield
- Princeton Applied Research
- Tektronics
- VA Carolina Controls
- Valco Industries
- Wavetek
- Alcatel Vacuum Products
- Thesaurus Term
- Industry Sponsored Research
- Puff-By-Puff Analysis
- Carbon Monoxide
- Filter Ventilation
- Keyword
- Tunable Diode Laser (TDL)
- Indexer Comment
- Document set 1
Document Images
oaC
Accession No. 52-153'
Copy No. 1'
Issued To -P(,Zq,'Z,{;3
aZ-
PHILIP
M O R R I S U. S, A,
R E S E A R C H C E N T E R
CHARGE NO. & TITLE: 1752 CIGARETTE SMOKE STUDIES
TYPE REPORT: 0 ANNUAL Q SEMiANNUAL 0 COMPLETION ® SPECIAL
BATE' May 12, 1982
REPORT TITLE:
PERIOD COVERED:
Oct. 1980 - April 1982
CIGARETTESMOKE AND FILTER DILUTION ANALYSIS USING TUNABLE
DIODE LASER INFRARED SPECTROSCOPY:
I. DESIGN'OF A COMPUTER-CONTROLLED PUFF X PUFF SYSTEM
BY
MiLton E. Parrish, Charles N. Harward, and'Arthur T. Hill
SUPERVISED BY
G rs Vilcins ~
APPROVED BY
DISTRIBUTION:
Dr. R. B. Seligman
Dr. M. Hausermann
Dr. W A. Farone
Mr. L. F. Meyer
Dr. T. S. Osdene
Dr. R. Fagan
Dr. R. M. Ikeda
Mr. W. E. Claflin
Mr. A. C. Lilly
Dr. A. J. Kassman
Dr. J. F. Whidby
Dr. W. A. Geiszler
William F. Kuhn
Mr. R. M. Waugh
Dr. J. L. Charles
Dr. R. W. Jenkins
Mr. P. N. Gauvin
Mr. W. G. Houck
Dr. R. W. Dwyer
Mr. R. D. Carpenter
Dr. P. Martin
Mr. R. M. Wiley
Mr. W. T. Belanger
Mr. B. D. Jeltema
KEYWORDS:
Tunable Diode Laser
Cigarette Dilution
CO Puff X Puff
MINC 11/23
Dr. G. H. Bokelman
Dr. R. H. Cox
Mr. R. E. Davis
Mr. W. R. Harvey
Dr. J. 0. Lephardt
Mr. D. C. Watson
Central File (2)
Day File (4)
l

Table of Contents
Page No.
ABSTRACT
I. OBJECTIVE 1
II. INTRO DUCTION 1
III. OPTIC AL LAYOUT 4
IV. COMPU TERIZED GAS TRANSFER SYSTEM 6
V. ELECTRICAL CONFIGURATION 10
VI. EXPER IMENTAL 14
A. Calibration and Standardization of CO and N20 14
B. Cigarette Information 16
C. Procedure 16
VII'. RESU LTS AND DISCUSSION 23
VIII. CONC LUSION 41
IX. ACKNOWLEGMENTS 43
X. REFERENCES 43
APPENDIX 1 44
APPENDIX II 47
v

ABSTRACT
A computer-controlled gas transfer system which is linked to
a tunable diode laser(TDL) system is used'to determine the change
in filter dilution as a cigarette is smoked. This information
can be utilized in the development of new products.
The approach we have selected is to place a cigarette with
the ventilation holes of the filter in a chamber filled with a
gas not found in cigarette smoke, such as nitrous oxide (N20),
and to mix this gas with the smoke under actual smoking condi-
tions. By judiciously selecting a TDL with the appropriate
tuning range, molecular absorption lines for both the N20 and a
representative smoke component, such as carbon monoxide (CO), can
be located and monitored simultaneously. The N20 provides
information concerning the dilution level and the CO provides
information about mainstream smoke. Thi~s is the first study of
which we are aware that the concentration of CO inevcigarette
smoke is obtained along with information about the filter dilu-
tion for each puff under dynamic smoking conditions.
Experiments were conducted using cigarettes having different
filter dilutions. Each cigarette was measured for static dilu-
tion prior to smoking using a standard~pressure drop method. The
values for 100% N20 absorbance and the N20 absorbance obtained by
taking a puff from an unlit ci~garette were determined and used to
calculate the percent dilution of the filter. Analysis of the
data show that the average dilution for all lit puffs is greater
than the di~lution determined for the unlit puff except for the
i

very last puff where some of the cigarettes showed a decreased
dilution value of 0.5% dilution units. All of the levels
measured by the TDL method are higher than the dilution level
determined by the static dilution method. The average dilution
level for the lit puffs stays relatively constant though there is
a slight tendency for the later puffs to drop to the dilution
level of the unlit cigarette.
ii %W, !

:
1
I. OBJECTIVES
This study was initiated to characterize more fully the
relationship of filter design and ventilation to the dilution
level as the cigarette is smoked. Results from this study will
provide information which can be compared to models developed by
the Filtration Physics Group. Some of the models developed by
that group are designed to predict the relationship between
filter ventilation and the level of dilution under actual smoking
conditions. In order to meet the above objectives, the initial
phase was to design and implement.an experiment incorporating the
TDL system and the Digital Electronics Corporation(DEC) MINC
Microcomputer to provide accurate data for this investigation.
II. INTRODUCTION
The quantitation of combustion gases in cigarette smoke can
proiride an abundance of information useful in achieving controlled
modification of cigarette deliveries. The objective of the work
is to determine more clearly the relationship of filter design
and ventilation to the dilution level achieved as a cigarette is
smoked. This information can be utilized in the development of
new products.
The investigation was performed with a lead salt tunable
diode laser (TDL) emitting in the 4 to 5 micrometer spectral
region. The technique used was particularly well suited for the
measurement of gases from~ the cigarette because of the high
speed, sensitivity, and resolution of the TDL.

2
The technique for measuring the cigarette dilution involved
placing the ventilation holes of a cigarette inside a chamber
filled with a gas not found in cigarette smoke. When a puff was
taken on the cigarette, the gas, in this case, nitrous oxide
(N20) was pulled through the ventilation holes and was mixed with
the cigarette smoke. The amount of N20 that was present in the
mixture is proportional to the dilution of the cigarette. If the
operating wavelength of the TDL were judiciously chosen, then a
representative smoke component, such as carbon monoxide (CO), can
be monitored simultaneously with the N20 pulled through the
ventilation holes, with the N20 providing information about the
dilution level and the CO providing information about the main-
stream smoke. Although cigarette dilution during smoking has
been investigated(1), this is the first study of which we are
aware that the concentration of CO in the cigarette smoke is
obtained along with information about the dilution level: for each
puff. This investigation will provide the basis for obtaining a
clearer understanding of the complex interaction that filter
dilution has on the CO delivery. In order for this investigation
to provide accurate and meanful results, special attention had to
be focused~on several areas of concern in the experimental design
of the TDL and the gas transfer system. The major areas are as
follows:
1.) To obtain puff-by-puff results, time constraints
required very fast evacuation of the 13 L volume cell.
2.) To mini'~mize contamination from one puff to the next,
adequate sequential flushing of the gas handling lines had
to be performed.
0

3
C,
3.) To minimize atmospheric contamination and back diffusion
of smoke from the cigarette ventilation holes, the system
required the design of a dilution chamber with sensitive
automatic pressure sensing and control as well as constant
flushing.
4.) To control precisely the amount of smoke to be analyzed
and. improve reproducibility, a low-dead volume sampling
valve had to be incorporated into the gas transfer system.
5.) To perform all of the tasks within the time restraints,
the automation of the entiresystem was required.
6.) To provide the accuracy and precision needed in this
experiment, a microcomputer was chosen to control all aspects
of the experiment, thus necessitating the design of a custom
interface between the computer and gas transfer system.
7.) Since no software existed to control the experiment, to
collect, and analyze the data, computer programs had to be
written, debugged, and implemented.
8.) The storage of the data collected from this experiment
required a microprocessor with capabilities beyond those of'
the MINC 11/03. Thus a larger, faster microcomputer had to
be specified, ordered, and delivered to fulfi~ll the exper-
imental requirements.
9.) Because the TDL wavelength is a function of its time-
history (wavelength hysteresis), special electronic circuitry
had to be designed, and specifi'~ed.
This report discusses in detail the design chosen for this
investigation and examples of the type of data generated.

4
III. OPTICAL LAYOUT
A diagram of the optical system based on the Laser Analytics
LS-3 spectrometer is shown in Figure 1. The diode laser (#0168-28,
Model SP5610-2170, Laser Analytics, Bedford, MA, 01730) which is
mounted in a cryogenic closed cycle refrigrator (Model 21,CTI,
Waltham, MA, 02154) is collected and collimated by an f/1 KRS-5
lense. This collimated radiation, which ranges in frequency from
2160 to 2190 cm 1, passes through a compartment that houses a
reference gas cell and a 75 mm solid Ge etalon. The reference
gas cell contains CO and is used to identify the absolute frequency
of the TDL radiation from the known positions of the molecular
absorption lines of the reference gas. The solid Ge etalon is
used to find the frequency of the TDL between the known reference
absorption lines. This is necessary since the tuning of the TDL
can be highly non-linear. The TDL radiation, after passing
through the sample compartment, is focused onto the entrance of a
4.17 m base pathlength Laser Analytics White cell(2). The radia-
tion after passing through the cell is focused on the exit aperture
of the cell. Transfer optics recollimate the radiation and then
focuses the radiation onto the entrance slits of the LS-3 mono-
chromator section. The radiation is also mechanically chopped at
the entrance slits by a tuning fork chopper (Model L2, American
Time Products, Woodside, NY, 11377). This is done because the
A.C. detection system requires modulated light. The monochromator
is used to isolate a single TDL mode from the multi-mode (multiple N
frequency) TDL radiation. The separated mode passes through the ~
Ca
exit slits of the monochromator where transfer optics focuses the P_
radiation onto a liquid nitrogen cooled InSb detector. The wo
4~b
lob
C4

Figure 1
Schematic of Optical
Path
- TChopper
- ~ ~ }Ref. Cel~ t
. --,_ ~----- !~
- ------ - _ _----- -_-- - ~ _ t i ~T~ 1
I ~ Etalon ]
t
-- .~
White Cell
-f=-
i
Grating
Detector I V Monochromator
i
,
Interface
Optics
9
~
y
i
Q
L f/1 Lense
Three Position
Sample
Compartment
9i~ES~~zaz
~

6
signal from the InSb detector, which is proportional to the
amount of radiation passing through the White cell, is demodulated
by a lock-in amplifier (Model 128A, Princeton Applied Research(PAR),
Princeton, NJ, 08540) referenced to the tuning fork chopper
frequency. The output of the lock-in, which has a one volt
maximum value, is offset by one-half volt. Then the output is DC
amplified'by a Model 113 preamplifier (PAR) to bring it up to the
± five volt level required by the analog to digital convertor
(ADC) on either the MINC 11/03 or DECLAB 11/23 (DEC) microcomputer
used to take the data and control,the experiment. The offset and
amplification are needed to take advantage of the full dynamic
range of the 12 bit ADC.
IV. COMPUTERIZED GAS TRANSFER SYSTEM
Figure 2 shows the gas transfer system used to sample the
cigarette smoke. The dilution chamber in which the cigarette
filter is inserted is made of glass and has rubber dental dams
which seal the pure N20 obtained from a pure (>99%) N20 tank
(Matheson Gas Products, East Rutherford, NJ, 07073). The filter
end of the cigarette is inserted through a dental dam so that the
ventilation holes are exposed to the N20 in the chamber. The
very tip end~ of the filter is inserted into a second dental dam
fastened to a glass tube which is supported by a #4 rubber stopper
placed in the other end~ of the dilution chamber. The glass tube
passes through the stopper and is connected to the input solenoid
(A) of a one-port, syringe type smoking machine. This solenoid,,
as well as the others, in Figure 2 are indicated by square boxes
