Council for Tobacco Research
Strategic Withdrawal From Cigarette Smoking [Myths and Facts About Smoking and Smokers That Quit]
Fields
- Type
- ARTICLE
- BIBLIOGRAPHY
- PREPRINTED FORM
- DRAWING
- CHART
- BIBLIOGRAPHY
- Depository Date
- 29 Mar 1996
- Named Person
- Freud, S.
- Russell
- Horn, D.
- Natl Clearinghouse For Smoking And Health
- Tomkins
- Acs
- Ochsner
- Twain, M.
- Adams
- Tamerin
- Cohen
- Sheehan, G.A.
- Emerson
- Heinzelmann
- Bagley
- Durbeck
- Usphs
- Nasa
- Russell
- Request
- 135
- Author
- Christen, A.G.
- Cooper, K.H.
- Box
- 137
- Site
- Zahn
- UCSF Legacy ID
- rgx2aa00
Document Images
Strategic lAlithdrawal from
Cigarette Smokiig
,Arden G Christen, D.D S
Kenneth H. Cooper, M.D
s
Whoever urdderstonds the human mind,
knows that hardly anything rS harder ja
a man to give up than a p/eosure he has
once experienced. Actualfj; we can never
give anything upt we onry earchange one
thing for arAother. What app4rs to be a
renunciatiort is reolly the;Jonatation of a
substitute or surrogate.
Sigmund Freud'
Cigarette smoking is an enigma. In light
of the weU-known, thoroughly publicized
health hazards of smoking; why does
this habit continue to have such wide-
spread appeai? Why is it so difficult for
many persons to quit smoking once hav-
ing become habituated? Can a person
really do anything to control this tena-
cious habit? To help understand these
questions and see the overall picture,
one should consider two imperctant gener-
alirations about the use of tobacco prod.
ucts:
o Smoking provides powerful, immediate
satisfactions for the individual-phar-
macological, psychological, emotional,
and social.
Miliions of Americans hhve success-
fuliy quit smoking. lt can be done.
Dr. Christen is Chief, Dental Invesripuion Ser
vice, United States Air Force Sehool of Aero
spaa Medicine, Brooks Air Force 8ase, Texas.
Dr. Cooper ts Er<eeotive Director;r Aerobic Cen
ter of Preventive Medtcine, ~il~t, ~aas.
Pharmacologleal SatlsfaeHons
The pddictive agent in tobacco is nicotine.
Ctol~it.Ns, a colorless, bitter liquid. Ciga-
rette smokang allows for the absorption of
S010 µg of nicotine per puff, or one to
two mg pcr cigarette.s Most smokers re-
quire the rsicotine effect characteristit of
ttmoking (i.e., "nicotitte-seeking behav-
ior°). As Russell states, 'If it were not for
the inicotiate in tobacco smoke, people
would be 'ittle more inclined to smoke
cigarettes than they are to blow bubbles
at light sparklers."'
Nicotine can simultaneously act on
various pgsts ot the brain as a stin..iant
(euphoriaotl, depressant, or ttanquilizer,
depending on the dosage. The level of nic-
otine in the brain is er cial for the heavy
and highly dependent smoker and he will
unconsciously modify his puff rate until
that intake level has been reached. Depen-
dent smokers need a brain level boost of
nicotine about every 20 to 30 minutes
thrqughout their waking hours ? `
Much of the dependenceproducing
potency of nicotine is due to its almoit in-
ttant absorp.-OK fra^t the lungc followinR
inhAlation. It is practically impossible to
smoke without inhaling: in fact, the re-
ward°' for smoking is inhaling. A slower
nicotine effect can be obtained without in- halation from pipes, cigars, or chewing
tobacco, by absorption through the oral
mueosa!
~ 5gnekiwa~ seldom a take-it-or-Itave
I i~ I' re ,n' ava, r,1RC.'WCIaI;S

it activity. It has, immediate reinforcing Why Continue to Smoke?
I
consequences and considerably delayed
adverse consequences. Only about two
percent of smokers are intermittent or oc-
casional users of Cigarettes] and the most
gtable, welladjusled person can become a
regular, dependent ttnoker.
The reasons why one staru to smoke, and
why one progresses and continues int the
habit, are not always related. After oae
has become habituated, a new set of
learned.psychological and social needs
are activated. To identify these factors,
the Smoker's Se{J Test was developed by
Psychic and Social Effects of Smoking Daniel Horn, Ph.D., Director of the Na-
tional Clearinghouse for Smoking, and
Smoking can be realistically viewed as pri- Health, Public Health Service, from Tom-
marily a psychologicai habit °7 The per- , kins'mode)!6-tTestNo.3("WhyDoYou
son who has never smoked cannot possibly Smoke?") covers factors perceived by the
understand the depth of affective satisfac- smoker relating to the psychotogical satis-
tion derived from this habit. factions. he derives from this habit
Why Start to Smoke?
There is no innate need for tobacco.
Smoking is almost entirely a learned be-
havior, primarily in response to direct and
indirect social pressures.3 The two major
influences for predicting early smoking
behavior are: (1) smoking of one or more
parents; and (2) peer pressure.s These
influences obviously operate strongly in
our culture. Recent data show that ig to
2V percent of teenagers are currently
smoking cigarettes on a regular basis.a
Many of them use smoking to counteract
[telings of inferiority and gain acceptance
by the "in" erowd ° Smoking thus.be-
comes a social requirement.
When parents smoke they teach their
children two important things: (!) "This
is the way to iive;" and (2) 'ignore med-
ical advice." Adolescents may feel more
grown-up when smoking sz:t use it tc de-
"The reasons why one slarts to
smoke, and why one progresses
and continues in the habit, are
.o! Plways !e!ated "
~~ L ~
.
t.:
fiantiy dsim adult status. Moreover, pop-
ular advertising has portrayed smokers as
being active, attractive, and sophisti-
cated. For the teenager, these effects are
highly egointegrative and socially facili-
tative.
(Table 1). For Tomkins,10 smoking is a
learned response that can be associated
with any positive, negative, or neutral
affect.
Six Psychological Reasons for
Smoking (Horn's Test)
Each person's habit is unique. Thus,,there
is no truly "typical" smoker. However,
according to the American Cancer Soci-
ety, smokers do fit roughly into one or
more of six smoking types, depending on
how their habit has developed. H'orn's
test shows how smokers use their ciga-
rettes to manage their emotions. Smoking
may be characterized by one, or a cmmbi-
nation of, these factors.tt
Stimulation (10 percent). This type of
smoker is stimulated by the cigaa'ette.
It helps him to wake up in the morn-
ing, to organize his energies, and to
keep him going. Many smokers re-
port that while smoking they experi-
ence a sharpening of inteit:itual ca-
paeity and an @a*rease in rmpulse
control.
a Handling: Sensorimotor Manipulation
(10 percent). This type enjoys manip-
ttlating the cigarette with his hands,
watching the smoke eurl as he ex-
hales, and making a production of
lighting the cigarette, holding it, and
flicking the ashes.
'The Smoker's Self Test is available from local
umu of the Ameriean Cancet Society an from
the National Office on Smoking and ealth,
Depanmmt of Health. Education and W'elfare.
I

i
i
.. . . . .~. .. .~:
o Pleasurable Rela.xation (15 percent).
This smoker geta real, honest plea-
sure from smoking, especially after a
dinner or with a kocktaii. He tends to
smoke to accentuate or enhance pleasur-
able feelings accompanying a state of
well-being.
Comment: Tlpe above stimulation-~
handling-relaxation positive-affect
smokers characteristically smoke un-
der pleasant circumstances that are
relaxing. They usually require an ade-
quate substitute fot quitting and often
find that it is not, too difficult to stop.
t Crutch: Tension Reduction (30 percent).
This negative-affect type of smoker uses
cigarettes for the sedative or tranquil-
izer effect in moments of stress, fear,
shame, disgust, discomfort, or pressure.
He uses cigarettes to help him cope with
problems. Substitutions wip generally
not help this smoker, and success is
gained from tearning how to properly
manage the situations that produce the
bad feelings in the first place.
Craving: Psychological Addiction (23
percent). This type of smoker feels to-
tally dependent upon his eigarettes, and
alternates between an inerease of posi-
tive feelings and a decrease of negative
feelings. He is constantly aware when
be is not smoking and begins the eraving
for the next cigarette when he puts out
the present one. Tapering off doesn't
seem to work; the only solution is to quit
"cold turkey." Habit p0 percenR). The habitual smok-
er gets very littie satisfaction from his
habit and J tfmas it somewhat auto-
matically. He ntav smoue a cigarette
without realirinq it ot ven wanting it.
There is very littlcrmel:onal component
to his smoking activity nnd a minimal
amount of awareness. It is important
for him to develop this awareness and to
ur.derstand tl.t pattern of his smo}ring.
Dynamics of Oulltlnp
It is not for Everyone
Not everyone should stop smoking. It is
unlikely that most individuals will be able
to give up smoking during a period of
emotional turmoil or life crisis, and it is
particularly inappropriate to ask a severe
ly depressed person to quit smoking when
he is still working through another loss"
People who are mentally ill and/or undec
active psychiatric oare probably should
not attempt to quit smoking berause they
may be relying on their psychological need
for dgarettes. The precipitous cessation
of smoking can be a profoundly disorga-
nir.ng experience and it may throw a per-
son into frank psychosis. For those who
cannot stop abruptly, we can offer advice
of safer ways to smoke. Some heavy smok-
ers, howtver, are resistant to smoking ces
sation programs. They may be excessively
fmpukive, reixiiious, or deager-seeking:
they may experitaue self-0issatisfactions,
or even have strong self.destructive ten-
dencies. Ochsner, the sioted surgeon, de-
scribed patients who, following surgery
for carcinoma of the larynx or lung, con-
tinue to smoke through a tracheostomy:a
The "Myth^ of Sutxess
Smokers am often an unforgiving lot.
They frequently feel that quitting is aa ali-
or-nothing proposition, and fail to under-
stand the significance of the dose response
relationship: the less one smokes, the less
the harard. 1he smoker who has gone
from three or four packs a day to one pack
a day should teralice that he has made great
strides. Many people appear to quit in
graduated fashion ova a prolonged peri-
od, and some have reported that a taper-
ing-off Proeess is rhe preferable way to
"People wtta sre mentally ill
and/or under active psychiatric
care probably should not attempt
to qWt smoking..:"
WL IY
quit. As Mark Twain said,'rltiia bit is habit,
and not to be flung out the window by a_n;y
man, but coaxed downstairs a step at a
time." Of the many who have succeeded
quitting, about 50 percent reported that

r
~.Ti'rsA . . . . . . . PrwF
I
I
.. ~ ~~
t+.;r:'
~rY~.~--s e_E~t~.a.r~.
Important: Answer every question. tra t~~o 1tea'1;/ C
e/eNys ouently slOnatly slldoan nerer
A. {mOke Crgarettes m or er to eep mysel
/romslowmgdown 5 4 3 2
~-1
sn rmg a cigarette 1{ part o t e enloy
ment ot itnos,n p 5 4 3 2~
$moa.ng ugerettes a oreasant and ceiaKvng 4 2
I
, 1 rgnt up a cigarette wnen 1«i angrv about -
somethmg 5 4 3 2~ 1
en t w run om o e gerettet 12nd rt
almost unbearable until I Gen get tnem 5 4 3 2 1
F. I tmoke eigaretles automat4any wrthout
t
even berng aware of .t 5 4 3 2
. 1 smoKe Ngartltes to strmulate me. to oerk
myserr up 5 4 3 2 1
Vait or theenloyment ot smo.mg a ugarette
+j,
-
comes lrom the Steos 1 take to hgM uo 5 4 3 2 1
1 ,no ooarettes p~easarabre 2 1
nen ee uncomrohep e or upset about
tomahmg, l hght up a a rette 5 4 3 2' 1
K. 1 sm very mucn swere o1 tne act wnen I am
n011m010. mgeagarene 5 4_ 3 2 1
~~p~t up a agareoe witnout reanenng 1 eau
have one burnm in the ashtray 5 4 3 2 1
S
. I smoke Crqveves to g,va me arnt . 5 4 3 2
en smokea ugarate, parl O the enroy
mem rs watchin the imo4e as I etrlare rt ~ 4 3 2 1
0. I want a crgnene most wnen I am comror table end reNastd 5 4 3 2 1
P. hen I ee e or want to take my mmd off cares and wornee, / smoke e renes 5 4 3 2 1
. I get a real gnawmg nunger 1or a uparatte
when I havent tmOked SOr a whde 5 A 3 21
. 1 ee IOunO a GgHetle in my mouth an0
didn't remember puttmg rt there. 5 4 , 3 2 1
Now to Store:
j. Fnter the numbers you have circif0 to the Test 30uettons rn the CpaMS below. putt.ng
the number you hafe dtCleo c0 Ounttion Aover line A. to Quetlron 8 over hne B. etc
4 Total the 3 trores on each lrne to Ael your totals For eeamph, the sum or your scores
over lines A, G, an0 M grw{ you your score on SlUmu/apon-hnn 8. N, and N grve tna
TeMls
~" + +
n ~ e ~ rrwaM
_'er" + ~'g'~- + Cwrar, wnneameu
~T- + Crwne ewwwiw aee.eon
r + rwn.t
SCoyeS of 11 Ot above rndiCate that this fettor it an important s0urc@ Of satltfeCtion for the
sTOker. Scores of T Ot less ate IOw an0 probably rndtcate ihet thrs (OCtor does not apply to
you Scoree in bnween are mergreel,
Kore on Nandimy, etc
NL . 117Trr
9;

a,...,~...;.cs.?~t . .- . .. . .
they stopped suddenty and 50 percent that
they stopped gradually.'r
For some, the very idea that they could
stop smoking is one that evolves very
slowly. Many persons are not quite sure
how to approach stopping. It is an awk-
ward habit to leave behind, especially
since it has been so carefully built into a
lifestyle.
For smoking die-bards who refuse to
quit, Adams's has suggested five simple
steps that can lessen the hazards: (1) smoke
fewer cigarettes each day; (2) take fewer
puffs on each-cigarette; (3) reduce the
depth of inhalation; (4) smoke less of each
cigarette; and (S) choose a brand low in tar
and nicotine. Research indicates that for
many heavy smokers, there is a"reduc-
tion floor rate" of approximately 10 ciga-
rettes per day that can be reliably met but
not surpassed." Patients must be taught
procedures for maintaining this low rate,
or they will relapse.
Each smoker who wants to quit has
two problems that must be solved: physi-
ological and psychological withdra~ai.
Horn6 suggests that there are at least four
nteessary conditions for engaging in self-
protective health behavior. These condi-
tions are: (1) an awareness of the threat;
(2) the acceptance of the impoitance, of
the threat in a personal sense; (3) the rele-
vance of the threat to the individual; and
(4) the confidenee that one can do sorne-
thing about smoking.
Physiolopical Withdrawal
pronounced -rebound" effect during
withdrawal. Moderate to severe head-
aches, irritability, muscle aches and
cramps, anxiety, visual and sleep d'utur-
bances, and a distorted sense of time per-
ception-along with an intense craving
for tobacco-have been reported com-
monly by those who are quitting smoking.
Gen,crally the peak in severity of sytnp-
toms is reached by the third or fourth day.
However, symptoms, when present, are
highly individualized, and a significant
number of those who stop state that they
have few, if any, symptoms. For example,
some persons state that they have yrob-
Iems with daytime drowsiness and lethar-
gy, while others relate thet they suffer
from insomnia and feel like "bouncing off
the walls:" Virtually all physical effects
should subside within a week. After this
period, withdrawal symptoms are con-
sidered psychological.
Psychological Withdrawal
The residual effects of a habit of xhis
magnitude are hard to imagine. As inmost
forms of habituation, the psychological
component of withdrawal is of much
greater importance and is often extremely
complex. Psychological withdrawal can
last for weeks, to years. Women have
greater problems than men in stopping
smoking because most of them use ciga
renes for a tranquilizer affect, whereas
men smoke for pleasure 6
Studies show that the fitst two td three
months after stopping is a critical period;
Physiological withdrawal is easier to deal
with than 3s psychological withdrawal,
and requires about a week. Nicotine, the
addictive substance in tobacco, is large!y
eliminated from the bloodstream hnd
body tissues via the tiidneys.s To prom,ote
this flushing effect and decrease the crav-
ing for cigarettes, high liquid intake-
especially fruit juices-is destrabte. The
first three to four days are the most diffi-
cult, since the bulY of nicotine is being
eliminated; most individuals will experi
ence the worst withdrawal symptoms dur-
ing that time.' Most of these symptoms
nre related to the effects on the automatic
nervous system, which appears to have a
"COmerelve, seare-type approaches or
those based an nuessire judgment,
mtionaiity, and ctiiticism have little
place in a quftsmoking program "
N 117g2..
it is then that people who go back to their
habit will do so.'! The rate of success has
been similar for most quitting ntethods:
about one-third of the subjects stop smok
ing immediately and about one-third of

J
<t;~ar :: :,='a~.a>r:_s~.u_ .: cYx?3t++a>Z~.lrasr=~'~,
the quitters resume smoking at a later
time. Occasionahy, some who no longer
consciously desire cigarettes have vivid
satisfying dreams of smoking.
atsliting as a Process
The cessation of smoking is best consid-
ered not as a single, isolated event but
rather as a continuing, extended process 6
It requires persistent expenditure of ef-
fort. Schematically, and perhaps some-
what simplistically, let us examine the
quit-smoking process from a psychologi
cal point of view (Fig. i).
The short-time quitter (X) can.either
return to his habit by the front door (A) by
means of a conscious decision, or he can
attempt to overcome numerous hidden
and entrenched psychological obstacles
(8). These obstacles (the list is by no means
complete) provide strong unconscious
mechanisms that can act forcefully upon
the individual so that he is "off the hook"
and free to enter the smoking habit via
the rationalized back door (Ct. Long-
term quitting (D) is a complicated, lengthy
process, and coming to grips with the ob-
stacles to quitting involves a great deal of
unconscious, constructive and painful in
ner conflict.
Obstacles to Quitting
Social Pressure
The atmosphere around the quitter may
not be conducive to his stopping.' Smok-
ing has a strong social-facilitative effect
"... the psychological component
of withdrawal is of much grealer
Importance and is often
extremely complex "
that is also tied to one's lifestyle, friend-
ships, habit patterns, etc. Smokers have
more friends who smoke than do non
smokers. If one lives with a social group
of smokers, it is rather doubtful that one
can be induced to stop by anything less
than other, equally strong social pressures
and supports. It may be necessary to
change one's circle of friends. Many quit-
ters have expressed the feeling that some
people dose to them really do not want
them to succeed.
Lack oJo Plan
Although there is no right or easy way for
everyone to quit; it is important that each
person find an appropriate private method
to fit Ir, atrnation.° For some, the best
plan is 'coid tu%key: For the individual
who is highly susceptible t:, gr:,up pres-
sures, quit-smoking groups can be help-
ful?az.iar:
Social support from those close to him
is very important, perhaps crucial, to one
who is trying to stop smoking. These
"significant others" provide origoing en-
couragetrtent, reinforcement, and non-
judgmental support. One has only to look
at Alcoholics Anonymous and various
successful weight control groups to see
how social pressures can be harnessed in
a creative direction.
Merely placing people in a group, how-
ever, will not necessarily inspre good re
suits. The'se groups should not be too large
and must not attempt to effect extensive
personality change. The more attracted an
individual member is to the group, the
more likely he is to conform out of a desire
to be accepted and to avoidrejecdon. This
can lead to a self-generating "reinforce-
ment effect," a process that can be espe-
cially effective within small social units
such as families, circles of friends, clubs,
or work groups.e.12
AlcoAol
A high positive correlation exists between
ssnoking and drinking behacior.1s This is
*Man) voluntary health otganaauons disuibe ute "hoMt4don" hterature. The American
Cancer Societ) conducts quu-smoktng chnits in
tnantcommunsties. These consist of tNtcea
week sessions for four weeks. The Ftvrt)ay
QunSmokmR Clinics conducted b% the Seventh
Day Adven sts have been h qpetgttaneAe7n
1959 p ~ At .L Y e t7 ce
-
I

especially true for alcoholics. For some
individuals, smoking and drinking are so
strongly associated that they may have to
avoid one to cont.rol the other. Certainly
during the initial,difficult quittingperiod,
aicohos consumption should be kept to a
tninimum, since willpower is the first
Enental facility to be affected by alcohol.
SsycAic Dejenses:l tlebilitea Denial
Coerciwe, scare-typx approaches or those
based on excessive judgment, rationality,
and criticism have little place in a quit-
v;moking program. "HardselP' approach-
rs, which attempt to induce guilt or shame
in smokers, should be avoided because
they may overwhelm the ego rather than
inform, assist, or strengthen it. These
approaches may leave the smoker afraid,
ashamed, or guiltridden, and he may
teach for another cigarette to soothe those
painful feelings.9 Especially for the heavy
smoker, these tactics will often merely
raise snd mobilize his psychic defenses
and affect the smoking behavior only
temporarily. Some return to their habit
within a few days, with increased inten-
sity. They may bolster their original atti-
tudeby minimizing, distorting, ordenying
the eontent of the anti-smoking message.19
;fniporiant Psychologicar Gains
DJSmoking
Smokers may ask themselves, "If this
habit offers me so much satisfaction, why
should I undergo such suffering? Is the
cure worse than the disease?"
Feared Loss ojSe(jControl
Many feel that smoking keeps thrrn on an
even emotional keel. For them, cigarette
smoking is a technique t a keep the lid over
suppressed anger and hostility. Smokers
have expressed fears of being unable to
concentrate, organize their thoughts, re
membkr, or perform various tasks which,
in the past, have been intimately associ
ated with smoking.r=
When some individuals quit - or
merely try to quit - they are unable to
control their emotions. One young house-
wife reported that when she tried to stop
she became a "shrew" and her family
practically tiegged, her to start smoking
again. She r~cognized that she was using
her bad terdper as an excuse to resume
smoking. Most ex-smokers are surprised
to fsnd that the expected loss of control
lasted in most cases only a few weeks and
was seldom as serious as was feared.
Expectation oJFailure
About 61 percent of current smokers have
tried to quit, unsuccessfully, on one or
more oocasions.' There are some who will
not even try because they feel doomed to
failure; the immensity of the task is over-
whelming. lit reality, very few people suc-
ceed on the fsrst try.
Secret Smoking
Some smokers go underground with their
habit!u Like hidden drinkers, they have
been pressured Into a pattern of deception
and secrecy. The person may smoke at
work while denying at home that he
smokes at all, or regress to the adolescent
practice of surreptitiously smoking in the
garage or bathroom. Many spouses have
been highly critical of their mates' inabil-
ity to stop smoking, and this inability fills
the smokers with feelings of guilt, shame,
and anger. Therefore, many of them have
feelings of low esteem and believe that
they are missing some qualities that others
possess, e.g., "I want to quit, but I just
don't h ekvhat it takes.
Sne.esjulSiruLrion::AcraatdF~orAteJ 4
Some will use a9y personal stress or taii-
ure as a legitimate reason to start smok;ng
again. Heavy smokers tend to be more
vulnerable to streas than light smokers.
They also appear to have more personal
problems and anxiety than nonsmokers. m
Exsmokers will even unconsciously pre-
plan for a gtressfui situation to occur to
legilimire their resumption of the habit.
They may do this, for example, by taking
on too many responsibilities at work, by
failing to get enough rest, or by spending a
great deal of time in high stress situations.

OBSTACLES
TO QUITTING
o SNf pity. "moumrog'
Switch to other forms of tobet:o
Nrtotinedependency
Weight gain, actual or anticipated
e Stresslul srtuation,actual ar
planned
Secret amOking
e E><peetation of failure
e Feared loss of seff control
Piych0lagrcal gains of smoking
e PsYchic defenses. mobihted tlen e:
Alcohol
e Laek of plan for quitting
s Social pressure
Longterm
quitting
(by using strategic w,tridrawa'
and bridge burn mg I
Fig t piagra'r+mat+c presehtation ot the owt-smoking process as seen trom ~ a pS,CnOtoQ'Ca
vantage oolnt Note the Obsta: les that must beovecome ana strong fendencres fo' 1ne mo.w0~°
to resume Srlokrng vwa uMo^SCIous meehan'sms Successful tongterm qum.!+c consksts 0'
w0.'ngthbughunto'15CrouS coI)sFuctweanOpeihfutintetna'conlactnvetanre1onpe e Pe'Wo

tA ..c+:~waa*ta~x,? ::aae^'~ ~L'".r^'aaF WeighrCain
This is often used as an excuse for the re-
sumption of smoking, especially by wom-
en. In one study, 60 percent of men and
51 percent of women gained weight after
they had quit smoking." Although with-
out dieting it is norntal to gain five to nine
pounds after quitting smoking, some per-
sons feel that a one to two pound weight
gain is entirely unacceptabie. Most per-
sons must giveseriotos consideration to the
weight problem early in the quitting pro-
cess, lest they gain a quick 20-plus pounds.
As for their relative danger, to present the
same health hazard as smoking a pack of
cigarettes a day, one must be 125 pounds
overweight!"
Nicotine Dependence
When a smoker consumes a pack of ciga-
rettes a day, over a year's time he has re-
peated a chemically rewarding cycle of
stimulus-response-reward (inhalation)
60,000 times.' It is not easy to leave such
rewarding behavior.
Switch to OrAerFoirns oJTobaeco
Some who leave eigarettes search for at
ternative tobacco sources to satisfy their
needs. Many are convinced that cigars and
pipes are safer than cigarettes and believe
that they can inhale with impunity. How-
ever, one who switches to other forms of
Mhp;co may be actually increasing his
"At one of our cllnics a woraan was
overheard to say that she saourned
more when she quit smoking than
she did when her husband died!"
health risk.l221 Most persons who discon-
tinue smoking cigarkttes and change to ci-
gars continue to inhale, and havecarboxy-
hemogiobin levels twice as high as those
who inhale cigarettes. Increased carboxy-
hemoglobin levels are associated with in-
creased incidence of atherosclerotic dis-
ease. Also, those who switch to other
forms of tobacco can expect a higher in-
ddence of oral diseases. Finally, switch-
ing is at best a temporary diversion, often
eventually leading back to cigarettes.
Se/j-Piry: "9Nourning"
The depth of psychological grief and emp
daess experienced by an individual after
quitting can be remarkable. At one of out
clinics a woman was overheard to say that
she mourned more when she quit smoking
than she did when her husband , died!
Tamerin9 reminds us that for millions of
smokers, cigarettes represent one of the
few consistent and stable objects it6 their
Gves. It is important to realize that the ha-
bituated cigarette smoker needs a reason
able period ot time to mourn the loss of
an important companion. 5tudies of nor
mal bereavement indicate that, in most
instances, a three-month period allows
adult grief to be worked through ti4 Tirk
quitter seeks todisengagehimself fromthe
cigarette-the lost love object. He must
learn to reinvest his emotional capital in
new and productive directiotts. In the
process, these patients may suffer from
anxiety or depression.
StrateBlc Withdrawal and
Bridge Burning
To successfully quit smoking, one should
attack the problem on as many fronts as
possible. A person should develop impor
tani substitute activities that cari help
fill the vacuum that is left after quitting.
A defsnite, strategic plan of action, based
on a thorough understanding of one's
own habit, should be forrnulated-~-pref
eratdy in writing.
The technique of "burning your
bridges behind you"-i.e., using various
means to cut off all means of retreating
back to the habit-is a valuable aid to
quitting. Here are some suggestions that
physicians can offer their patients who
wish to quit smoking:
'The Help Qun fiit, a program to help physr
eiens help their patants quit smoktng, is avad
able from i I units of the ~rtljnpsin~~r
Socrctr. gl~ 1 g 8N

i
Actively encourage and help others to
stop smoking.
Identify with and personally associate
with former smokers.
Leartt to avoid "triggers" of high value
stimuli that encourage smoking.
Dispose of the paraphernalia of smok-
ing.
]oin a group opposrd to smoking and
read their literature.
Make a cash bet or social pact with a
close friend or relative, specifying a cer-
tain period of abstinence. Make a pub-
lic ctlmmitment to a respected group or
person. When a person verbalizes a be-
lief or intention to others, he becomes
more inclined to accept it himself.
Develop substitute activities or habits
incompatible with smoking, e.g., aero-
bic exercise regimen.
Place signs in homeand work areas ask-
ing others to refrain from smoking.
Alternatives to Smoking
In a provocative article, Cohen states,
'Major inroads on drug abuse cannot be
made by stressing the undesirability of
drugs.. It can only be done by offering
more desirable alternative involvements-
activities, life-styles and satisfactions
which are more rewarding than drug ex-
periences and incompatible with depen-
dence on chemicak."u
He suggests that the quitting smoker
become involved in activities that are en-
joyablk and rewarding. The possibilities
are endless and diverse, but all have cer-
tain elements in common: they promote
greater self-awareness, self-confidence
and self-esteem. While all such pursuits-
artistic, athletic, intellectual, spiritual, or
social-are beneficial, we baieve activi
ties that promote physical self-awareness
are particularly important (e.g., walking,
running, dancing, gymnastics and group
sports).
Aerobic Exercises ant7
physicat Awareness
One of the greatest natural (and legal)
'highs' that one can experience is the sen-
sation of a healthy body in motion.2 Our
bodies were designed for activity, move-
ment, -graa and rhythm.u rserson rec-
ognized this fact when he said, "First, be
a good animati" Many individuals have
noted that they couldn't break the ciga-
rette smoking habit until they first started
a jogging or aerob.ic program?s Exercise
carries with it an Increase in prudent living
habits. It is difficult to find even a half-
serious runner who smokes, drinks in ex-
cess or fails to keep a-watchful eye on his
diet?' As Dr. George A. Sheehan, a noted
heart specialist and long distance runner,
states, "... for your muscles to celebrate,
and you to move about freely, you have to
pay attention to details like diet and c?i-
mate and training. How can one play and
think and Imdi truth when stu:fed with
jelly doughnuts?"u
Posirfve PsycRologicofF,jfecu oJFxercire
It is well accepted that physical activity
can change the state of the adult mind,
causing distinct and rapid changes in per-
sonality.p When a sedentary, middle-aged
man decides to enter a long-term, strenu-
ous physical conditioning program and
disciplines hiroself to stick it out, he will
often gain a sFnse of atxomplishment, in-
dependence and a sense of control of his
own life that he may never have had be-
fore. He is also likely to become more res-
olute, emotionally stable and imaginatfve,
... an exercise health program can
infiuencb how a person thinks
and feels and what he does to
promote his own health."
~ c N 11787
and this is an exhilarating experience.t'-N
Physical activity has been prescribed fre-
quently in noqt-specific ways as pan of the
therapeutic milieu of psychiatric rehabili
tation programs (for example, with drug
and alcohol abusers and juvenile delin-
quents). It is commonly employed io help
