Council for Tobacco Research
Common Human Viruses As Carcinogen Factors
Abstract
MAR
Fields
- Depository Date
- 08 Dec 1995
- Master ID
- Publications024478-4479
- Author
- Cioscienski, P.J., Seton Hall College Medicine And, D.E.
- Hansen, G.F., Seton Hall College Medicine And Dentist
- Magnusson, S., Seton Hall College Medicine And Denti
- Martin, C.M., Seton Hall College Medicine And Dentist
- Hansen, G.F., Seton Hall College Medicine And Dentist
- Request
- 40
- 41
- 42
- 43
- 44
- 45
- 46
- 47
- 48
- 62
- 71
- 72
- 73
- 74
- 76
- 78
- 79
- 80
- 81
- 82
- 84
- 88
- 91
- 92
- 94
- 39
- 41
- Type
- SCIENTIFIC ARTICLE
- BIBLIOGRAPHY
- Box
- 70
- UCSF Legacy ID
- bra10a00
Document Images
Y
/R
everenees and lotcs
1. F. Duran-Reynals, Ann. N.r. Acod. Scl. 68,
4140 (1957).
2. N. P. 7tazurenko. Prohlenn o/ Oncology ~,
No. 6. 873 (1960).
3. The histological diapnoscs were eonffirmed by
Dr. Richard Sicgler, assistant patholoFrst. Chil-
dren's Hospital. Philadelphia. Pa., and vrsninl:
invcsligator. Institute of Microbiology. Rutgcrs
University. 4. This work wav suDportcd by grants from thc
Nauonal Institutes of Health anJ i.om she
American Cancer Sociny.
i Present address: Instituu of Microbiology,
Rutgers University, New Brunswick. N..t.
10 July 1961
Common Human Viruses as
Carcinogen Vectors
Abstract. Single doses of pairs of v%ruses
and organic carcinogens (in amounts too
small in themselves to induce tumors)
were administered to male Swiss mice frec
of polyoma virus. Malignant tumors devel.
oped in groups of mice injected with five
of the carcinogen-virus pairs. Prior im-
munization against the virus of a pair pre-
vented tumor formation by that pair. Car-
cinogen binding by poliovirus 2 was dem-
onstrated in vitro.
It has been a continuing paradox in
the field of experimental neoplasia that
carcinogens strongly implicated in hu-
man tumorigenesis, though present in
the human environment in only trace
amounts, will ordinarily induce neo-
plasia in animals only when admin-
istered in relatively large amounts, or
when given together with various physi-
cal or chemical "cocarcinogens" (1).
Sieculation on possible natural cocar-
cinogens led us to consider the role of
common, nontumor viruses. Viruses are
ubiquitous, often occur in family or
household patterns, are most easily
spread in urban environments, and with
relative ease penetrate suscept.blc, non-
immune cells, and commonly, cell nu-
clei. This report (2) presents evidence
of in vitro and in vivo interactions be-
tween common human viruses and
chemical carcinogens: the results suggest
a hypothesis that viruses may serve as
natural vectors for the transport of
otherwise innocuous amounts of envi-
ronmental carcinogens (mutagens) to
susceptible intranuclear chronlosomal
` loci.
Studies were performed in vivo on
male Swiss white ntice (Webster strain ),
which were obtained from a colonv
proved free of polyoma virus (3) and
which were reported to have a low in-
cidence of de nr,ro tumors (thyrlloma
and lymphoblastic leukemia) (4). The
viruses used (vaccinia, ECHO 9, Cox-
sackie B., and poliovirus 2) were har-
t
^- lW ILA
vested fluids if lul1% Inlccic.l tissue cul-
tures of mor.6c> kitincy: by the routes
given, thcv cvo}.:.: ri: aiiiblc mortality
or morbidil.. 7irc rrr:inogens injected
and thcir r-pt'cuor .toscs. judged to
be too small to inducc tumors (I),
9,10-dir ~r rh 'h: ~a:rnlllraccnc-1?
were:
(DRS°A). _. anannfluolenc
( A1= ). 1/ A. I ,2,5.6-dihcnzan
thracenc (1)l;/V ). : * 5 : "t.
Each anin,al recrivrtl a single dose,
at the same tian ;uld in the same site,
of two suh.l wn, c:,+ r. rr us suspension,
or lrozcn-l:,..t..-J .., ..S.r? kidney tissuc
culture cal: .- Ilat: lI
mediunl: . . .. ....anogen or car-
cinogen solvent (acctt.nc or propylene
glycol). Randomized groups of 6 to 12
animals. 20 tcl '", .1 .. old, were in-
jcctcd 56uhcut.,ncuu,ly, intiraperitoncally,
or intranac:llh an.l ''^trccd in mul-
tiric cnLr-: ........, n.rt survived for
12 months were killed. Cannibalism
prior to 3 months of age was hcavy,
presumably because of overcrowded
cages.
Lymphonlas. nlvclcid Icilkenlias, a re-
ticulum cell s:tr:.om:r. and a subcutanc-
ous fihrosarcoinla-malignant tumors
other than thoi,c reported to arise de
volo in this strain (4)-oc'curred in five
groups of mice that received carcinogen-
virus Oairs, and in no other groups
(Tables I and 2). The calculated prob-
abilities (5) that the tumor incidences
in these groups could have occurred by
chance arc: DMBA and vaccinia, 2.0
perccnt;. D.Nf BA and poliovirus 2, 0.7
pcrccnt: D%1BA and Coxs6ckie B., 62
pcrccnt: AF and Coxsackic B,, 16.5
percento and AF and ECHO 9, 20 per-
cent. \t1 hen the chi-square test with
Yates's correction is applied to all the
data (Table 1), the probability that
tumor incidence associated with the
following conditions is due to chance
sia^c is: sir.,s, with and without car-
cinogetl, .05 > p > .01: carcinogen, with
and without virus, .05 > p > .01; virus
plus carcinogen, p < .01. Four local-
izeJ thvmomas were found in the 161
mice aliNe after 3 months. Multiple pul-
rnonary adenonlas occurred in five mice
that received DMBA intranasally, with
or withoul virus.
Half of a group of 108 mice were
immunized against vaccinia virus and
half against frozen-thawed monkey kid-
ney cells. Each was given a single
simultaneous intraperitoneal or sub-
cutaneous injection, as described above,
of either vaccinia virus or frozen-thawed
monkey kidney cells plus either DMBA
or propylene glycol. The cages were not
Table 1. Results ohri,,.c.i hN .nl;,-ctrng mice with carcnnogcn-virus pairs. Data from two
experiments
arc included.
M,.e mrected u-ith earemnogen
DMOA AF DBA
No.
aith
mal,8.
oant
tumors
No,
ahar
ar
3 mo
ho.
\a. wilh
m. mahR-
j..rcd nanr
tumors,
No.
alive
at
3 mo.
Mice injected with
carcinogen solvent
No No.
No- uith No' No. wirh
m. mal.8- alive in- mal.g.
leercd nant 3 mo. j~ted nant
. tumnrs tumors
No.
al i.ro
at
3 mo.
No.
in
jected
11',rh rorvrmio .,.u:
5 9 16 0 11 16 0 8 t2
tt,r1, £CNO 9 .rn.
0 11 _ 7 12 0 6 10 0 12 23
H'r,n C-3arRlt S. ,.rus
If 1~ .. - 6 12 0 4 10 0 14 23
5 7 r: o* 6 12 O1 6 11
n'h ,~ceue carrorr' r,Ih
0 s r~ O 8 12 0 7 12
0 r. - , . n 6 10 0 6 lo
Prdmnnar. ac,n.n.+~ in UNIBA gr~nups: ECHO 9. 1; poho 2. 2; tissue culture cells. I: tissue
culture media. 1.
? One thyn.nm.,
l ablc 2 Rource. tumor.. and laty nt periods after injecuon of various ca rci nogen- virus pairs in
mice.
Abbrc.tal,nn ~ 1 rntr;,rcritonral; s.c., subcutancous: i.n. intranasal.
No. of mice Latent period
Carcrnogen..nu% pan Rnine Tumor with tumors (days)
DMHA and n,.m.a rp; L.-mphpma 3 132; 239; 344
uMRA and vaccmia t.p. Mvctad Ieukemia l 202
DN7BA and vacc,n,o s.c. F .broserrcoma 1 168
DMBA and t+nho: i.n. Lvmphoma 4 249; 307; 307:307
DMBA and tnhn 2 r.n. M)cloid leukemia 1 241
DMBA and eo.sacAre B. rr. lirticulum cell sarcoma 1 307
AF and Cntsa,tic B, tp,. Lymphoma 2 151.202
Ar and ECHO 9 1.p. Lymphoma 2 298; 298
1985
15 DECEMBER 1961
PUBLICATIONa
0024478

overcrowded. After S months, the only
tumors observed have been four lymph-
omas in a group of eight mice that were
not immune to vaccinia viri.ls ar-~! ,(; tr
given vacciniat and D:+1f3A Intrapcri-
tonmally. The probability th'at this inci-
dence could have occurred by chance-
in view of a group of nine in)mune mice
that were similarly injected and had no
tumors-is 2.9 percent.
Purified suspensions of poliovirus 2
(10" to 1'0" nlonke) kidney TCIDze)
and vaccinia ( 10" TCID,°) and of their
respective nucleic acids were prepared
(6), incubated at 37°C with solutions
in aeetone of DMBA-9-C" (7) conaaiil-
ing 2.7 X 10' to 5.4 X 10-' milti-
micromole of DMBA per milliliter, and
ultracentrifuged. Measurements vete
made with a gas-flow counter with a
sensitivity of 431 to 437 counts per
minute per millimicrocurie and a back-
ground of 26 to 27 counts per minute;
a precision of 0.9 to 1.5 petecent was
obtained with prolonged counting
times. Binding of DA1BA by whole
poliovirus 2 significantly in excess of
that by similarly purified suspensions of
frozen-thawed monkey kidney cells was
demonstrated. Three separate measure-
ments of uptake, in molecules pet'
TCIDs,, were: 17,000 ~:t 5000 (p <
.0l ) : 20,000 -- 12,000 (.05 > p > .01 ) ;
and 3100 -!- 900 (p < .01 ). Sigriifi-
cant binding of DMBA by vaccinia or
by virus nucleic acids was not demon=
strated.
The results obtained affirm in vivo
interactions of viruses and carcinogens
first described hv Rous and Friedewald
(8) and by F. Duran-Reynais (9) and
since described further by M. L- Duran-
Rcynals (10). The results are also con-
sistent with the report by 'Wisely er ol.
(11) of enhanced chemicsl carcino-
genesis in mice repe(ttedly exposed to
~ respiratory viruses.
Although the results suggest that
common viruses may serve as carcin'o-
n gen vectors, other interpretations of
these interactions can be made. If such
interactions occur in nature, it may
prove possible to reduce ncoplasia cur-
rently ascribcd to chemical carcinogens
by immunir:uion against a virus ( 12).
CNRISTOI'11ER M. Mn]iTIN
SIGmuNnuR N1nG'a'ssn`°
PHIt IP J. ( iosc1EN51:1'`
GEReRU F. HaNsrN:
Division of 1u/e('fi.nrs Di+rn+rs,
Depur)»renr uJ 1lrrlir-i)re.
SP)on Hnll Cr,llr'-('r of ilrthc-i»r,
Jenev Circ. Nru- Jrr srr
t9Nr.
Rderrnce+ and Nores
1. P. $hubik anat or
Compounds \\ ' ] C>rcd for
- `rrrAAc Heotr)r
Ca,--
.. . . .~-.. ,. . , . ,Ivc7).
2. TLb~rcrwrr u... *tut--
drqaipbn.rr) R.,.r r',thc American
1ted,cal Arcn: 1.-,... 2y June 1961.
3. New Animal li-n..- L...+n,, F;vmti. German-
town. N-Y. K,ndt+ uh,amujlcd by- \V. P.
ko+ e.
4. C. Friend pl n/ 1'..., Aan Aaaoc. Cancer
nP<va,..l. 9, ^- r l~r1 t~ C 1 r,end, personal
cummunraati.n
5. R. A Fn§er. .Sr_.,.-n - tr-. .. /n. Resr.rh
..Jmbwbh, Scot-
17r,.:..J r,,. Iv_.. , v~
6. J. J. Hollarrd, ei al . J- F.xprl. Med. 110, 65
(1959).
7. NuFleatChicago CnrPnrat,on. st+eeific activity
2 6c m:nnle
8 1'. i ;,nd W. t-. rrledea:,ld, !. Expll. Med.
79. SI1 (1y4J).
9. F. Duran-Rcynal, rnn \'.) Acad. Sel. 54,
977 (1952).
70. 11 L. Duran-Rcynal. personal communica.
rron
11. 1) V Wisely er 61 A.a. Assoc. Cancer
fir+irarrh 3. 278 f 1961 ~
12. Tlrce studics .vere euppnnr.t by U.S. Public
Healrh Scrvicc rcr..rr', rram, E-1695 (Cl)
:md. E-3:57 and uJ;.l h. , 4.rtnt from the
Tobacco ]nJu~er. R.h ('ommince The
as+,uncr nf ^. (,. Gra.l. and Mary Lu
Jacobs is Fratci.tr+ ,.t....... 'cdceJ
Fellina of the Sur'r, for Medical
ReseJrrh FnunJ."nr-
i Nat.onal tnsrirut<+ ut Hc.,ith scudent summer
rese.irch felloe.
19 June 1961
Estradiol Stimulittion of
Glycine Incorporation by Human
Endometrittm in Tissue Culture
Ahsrrar). The incorporation of C"-
labeled glycine intp human endometrium
grown in tissue r:utturc is a.celerated by
the addition of cslrz.iiol-173 to the cul-
ture medium und.'r" ccr7 ,in c.perimental
conditions Thi, i. :rccompanied
by an increased rol. .l Jts-.^prarance of
the glrcinc from thr medium. and its
demonstr.,lion is dc.rrndcnt t:ron the age
of the culture at.d thr frcquencV with
which the mediurn is rencwrJ
E'strogens at~t~~:'r to influence the
n7etabollsm and c)1.mical composition
of "target orban>" I+v increasing the
rates of endergoluc svnthOic reactions.
An enzOme system -.% hich is dependent
upon minute amc7unt% of estrogens has
been isolated frvrn scver.rl of these
target organs. Wh:n .rcii.,,led by estro-
Fen, it catal}'zrs th.- Irarr.ic/ of hydro-
gen frtsm rcduc:.1 Ir;t. ..rhupvriJinc
nucleou.le tr dipl,,'.ph..hvr-Jine nucico-
tidc, which n7as rc%ult in increaseJ
energy to accrler.-: th, synthetic
activities of the ccl! (I).
TimuC culture '::'1~'1 tlr c sCenled to
otler a uceful s~ ~tcn, !or further in-
t'l'stig,ttions of ctrvc~n .riion Hurl7an
cndumetrium, }lril<in-L'
tnc,rhhol,.,;rc rcsil.'n,., tt, cstn+ecn,.
PUBL ICRTIONS
can he propagated in vitro in a variety
of media (2, 3). Estradiol, when added
to slices of endometrium in vitro, in-
creases the rates of oxygen consump-
tion and conversion of g!ucose and
pyruvate to carbon dioxide. Human
endometrium from different phases of
the ovulatory cycle shows two peaks
of oxygen consumption in vitro. These
two peaks, at 6 to 10 and 22 to 24
days, correlate well with the known
peak of concentration of endogenous
estrogens in blood (4). Treatment of
castrated rats with estradiol increases
the subsequent rate of incorporation
of radioactive glycine and formate into
the protein, lipid, adenine, and gua-
nine of surviving uteri (5). The estra-
diol-sensitive enzyme system has been
identified in human endometrium (6).
This paper is a preliminary report of
the eflects of estradiol on human en-
dometriun] in tissue culture.
The methods and media used were
those devised by Peebles (7). Sterile
specimens of endometrium were ob-
tained by curettage, and sterile tech-
nique was used in all subsequent pro-
cedures. The tissue was washed once
with Hanks' salt solution, then 20 ml
of 0.1-percent trypsin solution was
added to each specimen and the mix-
ture was stirred rapidly for 15 min-
utes. The supernatant fluid was saved,
and the remaining tissue fragments
were treated twice more in a similar
manner. The combined supernatan:
ftuids were centrifuged at 600 rev/min
for 10 minutes at 12°C. The sediment
was resuspended in sufficient medium
to give a final :oncentration of about
750.000 cells per milliliter. Each tube
received I ml of this suspension and
was incubated in a horizontal position
without agitation at 35°C for the de-
sired length of time.
The medium was composed of 5.5
parts of medium 199, 1.5 parts of beef
embryo extract, 3 parts of calf serum,
plus penicillin and streptomycin. Gly-
cine-2-C"` and estradiol-17Q were
added to give final concentrations of
6-6 x 10`16f and 5 X 10'M, respec-
tivcly. At the end of the growth periorrt
the medium was poured ofC, leaving
the ccllc adherent to the tube wall. An
equal volurne of 10-percent metaphos-
phoric acid was added to each speci-
men of inedium. The resulting precipi-
tate was removed by centrifugation,
and 0.1 nil of the supernatant fluid was
pilsetted onto stainless steel planchets.
dried tinder an infrared light, and
SCIENCE. VOt. 1a4
024479
