Council for Tobacco Research
Human Papilloma Viruses Textbook of Human Virology,20psg Publishing [General Discussion of Pathogenesis of the Virus]
Abstract
MIS
Fields
- Depository Date
- 08 Dec 1995
- Named Person
- Bunney
- Licht
- Ciuffo
- Serra
- Wile
- Kingrey
- Strauss
- Melnick
- Bunting
- Almeida
- Rowson
- Ma, H.Y.
- Crawford
- Hirt
- Zurhausen
- Buschke
- Lowenstein
- Vonkrogh
- Pfister
- Licht
- Request
- 39
- 40
- 41
- 42
- 43
- 44
- 45
- 46
- 47
- 48
- 62
- 71
- 72
- 73
- 74
- 76
- 78
- 79
- 80
- 81
- 82
- 84
- 88
- 91
- 92
- 94
- 40
- Type
- BOOK
- CHART
- BIBLIOGRAPHY
- CHART
- Box
- 62
- Author
- Jenson, A.B.
- Kurman, R.J.
- Lancaster, W.D.
- Kurman, R.J.
- UCSF Legacy ID
- zou30a00
Document Images
957
they are indistinguishable from multiple papil-
lomas. " In females, condylomata may regress
spontaneously, persist for years, or undergo a ra-
pid increase in size during pregnancy. Genital
warts of long duration appear to have a low risk
for undergoing malignant transformation.' Most
show evidence of mild dysplasia but greater de-
grees of dysplasia are extremely rare. Approxi-
mately 5074 of squamous carcinomas of the vulva
have been reported to develop in association with
condylomata.' ' Perhaps the best clinical evi-
dence of maGgnant potential of genital warts
occurred in two rare cases in which carcinoma of
the vulva in young teenage girls was preceded by
condylomata (reviewed by zur Hausen'). In
males, 15074 of squamous carcinomas of the penis
have been reported to develop in association with
preexisting condylomata.' " Many penile carci-
nomas are of the verrucous type with features of
giant condylomata acuminatum of Buschke and
Lowenstein" Of interest is the observation that
circumcision reduces the incidence of penile carci-
nomas but not the appearance of penile condylo-
mata.' Perineal and perianal condylomata may
also undergo malignant transition to squamous
cell carcinomas, particularly in homosexual
maies."O Of particular importance is the recent
observation that papillomas/condylomas of the
distal male urethra may be flat or exophytic with
some showing atypia.^ ' these lesions are most
likely transmitted by sexual contact to the cervix
where a productive infection gives rise to cervical
dysplasia.
Cervical dysplasia (cervical intraepithelial neo-
plasia, CIN) has been associated with HPV-6,1
-11!' and -16 (personal communication, zur Hau-
sen), and other unknown types, and is the precur-
sor of squamous carcinoma." The development
of cervical cancer is thought to proceed through a
continuum of progressive cellular changes from
mild (CIN 1) to moderate (CIN 11) (Figure 34-2) to
severe dysplasia and/or carcinoma in situ (CIN
III)"" This sequence of events has been docu-
mented by a number of studies with transit times
from mild dysplasia to carcinoma in situ ranging
from 84 to 96 months." Approximately 40074 to
70074 of the dysplasias undergo spontaneous re-
gression. Although the etiology of cervical cancer
is still unknown, epidemiolojW-studies suggest
that both precursor lesions and carcinoma are
linked to venereally transmitted agents." For
many years, herpesvirus type II was thought to be
the most likely etiologic agent based on seroepi-
demiologic evidence.1O01Ot However, since 1980,
morphologic, immunologic, and molecular viro-
logic studies support the view that HPV plays an
important role in the development of cervical neo-
piasia."" i42"O' HPV is one of the most com-
monly sexually transmitted agents, having been
identified by the presence of koilocytotic cells in
cervical smears of 1076 to 2°70 of all women and
S% to 10% of young women screened.'o1.uo-1u
E'ig.ee 34-2 Moderate cervical dysplasia showing zone of papillomavirua-auodated
hyperplasia occupying the lower half of the thickness of the epitheliutn. The upper half of the
epithelium shows cells with vacuoiated cytoplasm and mild nuclear uypia. Papillomavicus an-
tigens and DNA were present in this case (hematoxylin and eosin, x I0o).
k
G

958
CLINICAL SYNDROMES
(UNCOMMON)
Epidermodysplasia verruciformis (HPV-3, -S,
-8, -9, -10, -12, -13, and -I4) or verrucosis gener-
alisata"3 is a rare, autosomal recessive, disease
characterized by varying degrees of decreased cell-
mediated immunity and increased susceptibility
to HPV infection manifested clinically by poly-
morphogic skin lesions resembling either flat
warts or macules indistinguishable from pityriasis
rosea." f2 114-11' In approximately 25070 of Cauca-
sian patients malignant transformation occurs
within the pityriasis rosea-like lesions in sun-
exposed areas such as the face and hands. Only
lesions containing HPV-S appear to progress to
premalignant lesions, histopathologically similar
to cervical dysplasia before developing into carci-
noma in situ (Bowen's disease) and, eventually
invasive squamous carcinoma. HPV-5 can be
identified in primary or metastatic malignant le-
sions as a replicating, nonintegrated plasmid!'
Immunosuppressed patients, particularly those
undergoing renal transplantation, also develop
pityriasis rosea-like lesions associated with
HPV-S, which may undergo malignant transfor-
mation." Although warts that are present at the
beginning of therapy become aggressive,3 newly
acquired warts are usually seen only after the first
year of immunosuppression." Squamous cell
carcinomas usually do not develop in patients
with immunosuppression of short duration, sug-
gesting that HP V-S is acquired from some reser-
voir which is as yet unknown. Flat warts asso-
ciated with HPV-3 have also been reported in
renal transplant patients."'
IMMUyOLOGIC RESPONSES
Available evidence suggests that spontaneous
regression or persistence of warts is related to the
immunologic responsiveness of the individual (re-
viewed by von Krogh"). Studies of HPV infec-
tion suggest that stimulation of cellular immunity
is associated with regression of lesions and such
immunity is HPV type specific. Humoral antibody
responses to HPV are almost always type specific
and can apparently be used to determine evidence
of previous infection." The antibody response
can also be used as a prognostic indicator of spon-
taneous regression and/or successful therapy.
Many of the previous studies of immune re-
sponses to HPV infection are, however, difficult
to assess in view of our current recognition of the
plurality of immunologically distinct HPV.
Cell-Mediated Immunity
Patients with clinical evidence of altered cell-
mediated immunity have an increased incidence of
warts that are usually flat." This has been seen in
immunosuppressed patients,"3-7" patients with
cellular immunodeficiency,' and patients with
weak cutaneous hypersensitivity responses.i° aIl
Specific immunologic defects may be involved,
however, since not all patients with persistent
warts have evidence of nonspecific abnormalities
in cell-mediated immunity. There is pathologic
evidence of cell-mediated regression of warts,
particularly flat warts." A perivascular infiltration
of mononuclear leukocytes is usually seen in the
upper dermis with epidermal invasion localized to
the flat wart. Patients with regressing flat warts
will maintain plantar or common warts, suggest-
ing that HPV type-specific structural or non-
structural proteins are recognized at the level of
the cellular immune response.'0 Noteworthy is the
observation that spontaneous regression or cure
following treatment is frequently associated with
enhanced specific cellular immunity as tested by
cutaneous hypersensitivity to wart virus-asso-
ciated antigens 1::.1u The role of substances
associated with cell-mediated responses such as
lymphokines is unknown.
Humoral Immunity
Serologic evidence of wart virus antibodies ha~e
been detected by a variety of techniques in various
population studies (reviewed by von #Crogh").
The significance of these sudies is unknown
because the tests have been performed on dif-
ferent preparations of wan virus material. Pa-
tients without wart virus antibodies or with 1gM
alone are less likely to undergo spontaneous
regression or be cured than those with IgM and
(gG virus-specific antibodies''i" Furthermore,
after spontaneous or therapeutic cure, IgG anti-
bodies will remain elevated for up to six months
and as long as nine years." IgG antibodies are
known to be circulating in half of patients who
give no history of having warts."'-"' Patients
with chronic andlor multiple warts are much less
likely to have IgG against HPV." Of particular
interest is that patients with warts that do not con-
tain viriotts are less likely to have antibodies."'
Regardless, the role of serologic tests in evaluating
HPV infections must be performed using HPV
type-specific polypeptides as antigens. In such a
study PSster and zur Hausen,:' using purified
HPV-I polypeptides, demonstrated by radioim-
munoassay that 40% of an unselected group of
individuals had circulating antibody to HPV-I.

959
LABORATORY DIAGtiOSIS OF
iNFECTION
The multiplicity of HPV types and the relative
lack of cross-reactivity of type-specific reagents
has impeded an assessment of the role of HPV
types in lesions suspected of a HPV etiology. In
the past, evidence for the presence of HPV in a
particular lesion was mainty inferential, based
on the morphologic similarity of the putative
HPV-induced lesion to warts or condylorna acu-
minata, lesions known to be caused by HPV.
'. Identification of PV particles by electron mi-
croscopy" " 103 ` I=s us offered a direct method
(Figure 34-3). However, because of the possibility
of sampling error, particularly with the mucosal
lesions, and the fact that it is a time-consuming, ex-
pensive technique, its value is diminished as a prac-
tical screening technique.' u Recently, application
of immunological and molecular hybridization
methods to assay tissues for the presence of PV
genus- and HPV type-specific structural antigens
and DNA sequences have become possible and are
routinely used for diagnostic purposes.'. 54 #9
Genus-Specific Tests
Human and animal papillomaviruses contain
regions of conserved polynucleotide sequence
homology that can be detected only under non-
stringent hybridization conditions such that
heteroduplexes with 25076 to 350/o base mismatches
remain thermally stable." In addition, papil-
lomaviruses from diverse species have cross-reac-
tive internal capsid antigens that can be detected
using antisera prepared from disrupted papillo-
mavirus."" Using these genus-specific reagents,
it is now possible to test for the presence of HPV
structural antigens and DNA sequences regardless
of the HPV type associated with a particular
lesion.
Productive HPV infections, identified by the
presence of genus-specific structural proteins using
hyperimmune sera prepared against common anti-
gens derived from either HPV or bovine papilloma-
virus, can be demonstrated in acetone-fixed frozen
sections by immunofluorescence (Figure 34-4) or
fotinalin-fixed paraffin-embedded sections rou-
tinely processed for pathology using imrnunocyto-
chemical techniques (Figure Since
1980, a variety of cutaneous and mucosal lesions
have been screened for the presence of the PV com-
mon antigen. The frequency of HPV antigenic ex-
pression using these techniques was 5007s to 7001o in
plantar and common warts" 40e/o to 60% in ver-
rucae (Figure 34-6), multiple papillomas, and con-
Finrs 34-3 F.lectron miaoaaph of Fanular layer-keratin junction in same piantar wart as Figures 34-4
and 34-5.
PapilLonuvirus particles (50 to $5 nm) in crystalline array fill nucleus of cell immediately prior
to undergoing
keratiniution. Reprinted by permission from Jenson et al'= ( x 27,000)
©
®

1%
960
Flfure 3i-i Acetone-fixed frozen section of plantar wart containing HPV.1. Type-
specific structural antigens (arrows) are seen in many nuclei of cells in upper prickle
and granular layer of epithelium. Reprinted by permission from Jenson et al.`s
(Fluorescent antibody stain, x 400.)
E'is.es 344 Formaiin-(lmd paraalnembedded section of same piancar .raet ai in
Figure 34-3. Papillomaviru: senus-specific (comaion) struaucal antigens (acrows) stia
seen in nudd of koilocytotic Qanular cells. Reprinteri by permission from Jeasoa a
al. `s (Peroxidise-aaaperoaidase stain and hernatoxytin, x a00.)
I ~~ ~ ~~~~ PP
7a~'~ 5'~

dylomata of the oral cavity;'-" 30474 to 45'1% of
single papiAomas;' u approximately 5047s in laryn-
geal papillomas;-"° approximately S0e/i of vulvar
condyiomas;10f,10' 4S%a to 6S41a of male urethral
papillomas/condylomas^"' and 4047% to 30% of
mild dysplasias of the cervix (Figure 34-7).'-1" leis
currently unknown why viral antigens are detected
in only 40014 to 70479 of these lesions. Although lack
of antigen detection may be due to sampling error,
limited sensitivity of the test, or denaturing of viral
antigens during tissue processing, it probably is
related to a cyclic or periodic expression of struc-
tural viral antigens by the viral genome, perhaps
modulated by the immune response. In a study of
102 laryngeal papillomas, 48% were positivt for
viral antigens.' However, when four or more con-
secutive recurrences of the same lesion were ex-
amined, at least one was always stained positively.
Thus, although a positive immunologic reaction for
HPV means that the lesion is associated with the
virus, a negative reaction does not necessarily ex-
dude an HPV etiology.
961
Figure 3a-6 Verruca from hard palate of
oral cavity. Papiilomavirus genus-specific
structural antigens are identified by posi-
tive PAP reaction (arrows), mainly in
koilocytotic cells of granular layer of a
single papillary frond. Reprinted by per-
mission from Jenson et al.' (Peroxidase-
antiperoxidase stain and hematoxylin,
x 197.)
Nonstringent hybridization techniques have
been used to demonstrate HPV sequences in two
of four laryngeal papillomas"' and 10 of 16 cer-
vical dysplasias (Figures 348A and B)."-10' When
correlated with immunocytochemical staining for
genus-specific antigens, it was concluded that at
least 75% of laryngeal papillomas and 93+ti of
cervical dysplasias, respectively, were associated
with HPV infections.
Type-Specific Tests
HPV-1, -2. -3, and -5 type-specific viral anti-
gens have been identified by immunofluorescence
in frozen sections of cutaneous warts""'"
Although no cross-reactivity was observed among
these HPVs using heterologous antisera, the im-
munofluorescence technique is of little practical
use for diagnostic purposes since tissues for most
retrospective studies are preserved in formalin.
Recently, HPV-1 type-specific antigens have been
identified in formalin-fixed tissue using hyperim-
mune rabbit serum and the PAP technique"
MASTEER ~ :avp
Z. #
C'

1
962
Figure 34-7 Mild cervical dysplasia with prominent epithelial spikes containing numerous
cells with intranuclear genus-specific papiilomavirus antigens (arrows). Papillomavirus DNA
was also recovered from this case. (Peroxidase-antiperoxidase stain without counterstain,
x 197.) Reprinted by permission from Lancaster et al.s'
HPV-1 antigens were found in S407o of plantar
warts and 11 07e of common warts. Moreover, the
presence of HPV-1 viral antigens corresponded to
the presence of HPV-I specific nucleotide se-
quences determined by molecular hybridization
studies.
Preliminary classifications of HPV DNA in
biopsy specimens are made on the basis of the
hybridization spectrum of viral DNA fragments
generated by appropriate restriction endonu-
cleases and by assessing the relatedness of viral se-
quences as judged by hybridization efficiency
under relaxed and stringent conditions.'" When
warts and/or mucosal papillomas undergo malig-
nant transformation, late gene expression (struc-
tural viral proteins) is no longer detected, but the
PV genome continues to replicate as a plasmid, al-
though at a lower copy number. Detection of
HPV DNA associated with the transformed state
is best accomplished under stringent conditions
that are at least ten times more sensitive then non-
stringent conditions, a difference which appears to
be particularly critical in PV systems.
At least 16 different HPV types have been char-
acterized by molecular hybridization studies
(Table 34-1). Besides being preferentially asso-
ciated with specific clinical lesions, subsets of
HPV appear to be primarily cutaneotropic or mu-
cosotropic (HPV-6, -1 l, and -16) and noncarcino-
genic or potentially carcinogenic (HPV-S, -6, -11.
-16). Therefore, most studies on squamous cell
carcinoma of ttie skin have been probed with
HPV-S DNAs, whereas most studies of squatnous
cell carcinoma of the laryngeal and anogenical
areas have been probed with HPV-6,"'6 -11,'
and, more recently, HPV-16 (zur Hausen, per-
sonal communication).
HPV-S has been detected in both primary and
metastatic squamous carcinomas of patients with
EV= and in the primary carcinomas of patients
undergoing immunosuppressive therapy." Dem-
onstration of HPV in metastatic lesions is of par-
ticular importance since HPV DNA sequences
found in the primary lesions could possibly be a
contaminant from an adjacent benign skin lesion.
HPV-Il has been found in half of laryngeal
papillomas, approximately one fourth of genital
warts, cervical dysplasias, and four of 24 cervical
cancers (two in situ; two invasive)!' HPV-6 se-
quences have been found in the majority of
typical condylomata acuminata (venereal warts)
and condylomata acamittata of Lowenstein and
Bushke," an ag=ressive infiltrating squsmous
lesion that usually does not metastasize." Other
evidence that HPVs are associated with malignant
tumors has been the finding of an untyped DNA
isolated from a puient with EV in four squamous
cell carcinomas of the vulva and cervix." Re-
cently, HPV-16 has been found in 609e of squa-
mous cell carcinomas of the cervix from German

A --IWE #LttMBER
- ..v
-C=- 13
Kr 19 23 30
Figures 344A&B Aucoradiograms representing hybrid-
ization of in vitro 'lP-labeled bovine paptllomavirus
type 1(BPV-1) DNA to human papillomavirus type I
(HPV-1) DNA and DNAs isolated from five cervical
biopsies. HPV-1 DNA (10 ng) (lane C) and tissue DNAs
were digested with either BamHl (panel A) or Hindlil
(panel B) and electrophoresed in 0.8m+ agarose gels. The
separated DNA fragments were transferred to nitrocel-
lulose membranes and subsequently hybridized to
3jP-BPV-1 DNA. Bands I and 2 represent the migration
of circular and linearized HPV.I DNA. respectively. In
both panels A and B. four of the five cases tested con-
tained DNA sequences to which the BPV-i probe hy-
bridized. These sequences comigrated with either open
circular and: or linear forms of HPV-1 DNA. Arrows
indicate migration of low molecular weight DNA. pre-
sent in case 19 (seen in Figure 34-7), that specifically
hybridized to the BPV- I DNA probe. (Performed under
relaxed or nonstringent conditions to detect PV genus-
specific polynucleotide sequences). Reprinted by permis-
sion from Lancaster et al."
patients but in only 10*l0 of cervical dysplasias
(zur Hausen, personal communication).
TREATMENT
Bunney,' in her assessment of a 10-year pro-
gram evaluating wart cures in approximately
14,000 patients, concluded that 709s to 8044 of
paiients could have been cured of warts by simple
methods applied either at home or in the clinic.
Whether warts are treated or left alone is usually a
prerogative of the individual patient. Although
most warts are usually treated for cosrttetic tYSsons,
others are treated because they cause discomfort or
are truly disabling. Since warts frequently undergo
spontaneous regtession, veatmett should not result
in permanent damage such as excessive scarring or
disfigurement.
8
C
963
CASE NUMBER ~r
13
15 19 23 30
In general, warts that respond most favorably
to treatment are usually single, of short duration,
and found in children.' Home treatment of warts
includes topical application of salicylic acid and
formalin or glutaraldehyde; podophyllin or strong
acids or bases should be used under supervision.
Cryotherapy is the most universally popular treat-
ment for warts, although surgical intervention
may be indicated in some cases. Perhaps the best
biological reason for not routinely recommending
surgical intervention is that surgical extirpation of
the wart is not associated with enhancement of the
immunologic response such as is seen following
multiple topical or freeze-thawing treatments that
appear to facilitate recognition of HPV-asso-
ciated antigens by the immunologic system.'='-"_
Quick removal of the bulk of wart virus antigens
without concomitant exposure to the immune sys-
tem is probably the main reason for the high re-
currence rates of warts following surgery. Other
treatments, such as interferon and retinoic acid,
appear promising but are experimental at this
time.
The duration of treatment and criteria for cure
of warts are important factors for clinical man-
agement of these lesions. Bunney' suggests that 12
weeks after beginning treatment is an adequate
length of time to expect warts to disappear. Since
failure to completely eradicate the initial lesion is
the main reason for recurrence, a valid criterion
for cure is the appearance of a normal skin after
disappearance of the wart(s). Similar criteria have
not been developed for treatment and cure of HPV-
associated iesions arising in mucosal epithelium.
HITRS T E Ik
ip

964
VACCINATION
Vaccination offers potential prevention and/or
cure for cutaneous warts and HPV-associated pa-
pillomas of the tnucosal surfaces. It is apparent
that effective vaccination will utilize either type-
specific structural or nonstructural antigens and
that the lesions to be targeted will be those of the
anogenital area that are sexually transmitted and
are at risk of malignant transformation.' Future
vaccines will depend on the progress made in the
molecular virology of HPV and the development
of bacterial expression vectors capable of synthe-
sizing highly purified, immunogenic structural
and nonstructural HPV proteins. Otherwise, the
use of an autogenous vaccine derived from tlte pa-
tient's own lesion is the only other alternative for
vaccination because of the possibility of poten-
tially harmful biological contaminants associated
with heterologous vaccines.
Most cutaneous warts either spontaneously
regress or can be cured by simple treatment.' Ap-
proximately 20074 to 3Q07o of these lesions will be
recalcitrant to therapy. Aithough presumably
associated with general or specific immunologic
defects, half of these recalcitrant warts may dis-
appear after vaccination of patients with formalitt-
inactivated HPV' all patients cured developed a
positive IgG response and delayed hypersensitivity
reaction to the HPV preparation.
Vaccination of persons at high risk for develop-
ing or transmitting anogenital HPV-associated
lesions appears to be indicated for several reasons.
First, many of these are sexually transmitted and
reinfection by consorts must occur frequently.
Second. S°1o to 154% of squamous carcinomas of
the vulva and penis appear to arise in preexisting
condylomata, usually of long duration. Third,
successful autogenous vaccination appears to be
higher for venereal warts (up to 80410) than cutan-
eous wans.+" Fourth, recombinant DNA tech-
nology should be able to provide the necessary
biological materials in the near future for vaccina-
tion. Evaluation of the efficacy of vaccination for
lesions of the aaogenital area, however, will de-
pend on well-controlled epidemioiogic studies and
clinical ttiaLt.rith evaluation of humoral (possibly
secretory ISA) and cell-mediated responses to
type-specific antigens. Regardless, preventive
measures to avoid transmission of these viruses is
much preferable to the best cure.
SiJMIri.+1RY
HPVs are a beterotenous group of oncogenic
viruses that replicate as true plasmids in selected
benign (wares/papillomas). dysplastic (cervical
dysplasias/?bowenoid papulosis), and malignant
(anogenital carcinomas) lesions of squamous epi-
thelium. Spontaneous regression or successful
topicallcryosurgical treatment of the benign
lesions are largely dependent on either naturally
acquired or iatrogenically-related stimulation of
HPV type-specific cellular immunity. Malignant
transformation of warts and papillomas appears
to relate to a variety of factors: 1) infection by
certain HPV types (HPV-S, -6, -11, and -16),
2) decreased cellular immunity to HPV-associated
antigens, and 3) interaction with physical carcin-
ogens such as sunlight or x-rays.
Research on HPV has benefited more from re-
combinant DNA technology than any other area
in virology, mainly because HPV cannot be grown
in culture or transmitted to other animal species.
Future use of recombinant DNA technology in
HPV research should: 1) allow many more HPVs
to be identified and characterized; 2) permit the
products of early and late gene regions to be syn-
thesized in bacterial expression vectors and used
as immunogens for diagnostic and vaccination
purposes, and 3) provide a substantial amount of
information about mechanisms involved in
carcinogenesis.
REFERENCES
i. Rowson ICEK, Mahy BWJ: Human papova ( wart)
virus. Bacterrol Rev 1967;31:114-131.
2. Bunney MH: Viral Wans: Their Biology and
Treatmettt. New York, Oxford University Press.
1982.
3. Praetorius-Clausen F: Rare oral viral disorders
(moUuscum contaposurn, localized keratoacan-
thotna, verrucae, condyioma actuninatum and
focal epithelial hyperplasia). Ora/ Surs Oral Med
O.al Pathol 1972;34:60~b1n.
4. Jenson AB, Lancaster WD, Hartman DP. Shaffer
EL Jr: Frequency and distribution of papillomavi-
rus structural antigens in verrucae, multiple
papillomas, and condylomsta of the oral cavity.
,4 m I Pathol 1962a:147:212-2I a.
S. Cook TA, Cohn AM, &unschrvit JP, et at:
Laryngeal papilloma: Etiolopc and therapeutic
considerations. Am I Otol 1973;32:649-653.
6. Lack EE, Jenson AB, Smith HG, a al: Itttmuno-
peroxida>ee loaliation of human pzpillomavirus
in laryngeal papillomas. tnnrvirolotr 196Q:11:
148-154.
7. zur Hausen H: Human pspillomaviruses and their
possible role in squamous cell carcinomas. Cttrs
Top MteroDicl hnmuttol 2977t78:I-30. .
i. Kurtnaa RJ. Jenson AB, Lmeasta WD: Papillo-
mavirus infection of the cavitt.lI. Rdadonship to
irttraepitlsdial neoplasia based on the preseace of
speci6c viral structural proteia:. Am JSrrj Aathol
1963a:7:39-52.
9. Kutman RJ, Jmsac A8. Sinelair C, et al: Detec-
tion of human pepillomaviruses by immuno-
cytochemisay, in Detsiis RA (.d): Advasica in

AL
,
Immunocyrochemi.rtry. New York, Masson,
1983b.
10. Orth G, Breitburd F, Favre M, et ai: papillomavi-
ruses: Possible role in human cancer. Cold Sprtnt
Harbor Conf Cell Prollf 1977a;4:1043-1068.
11. Orth G. Jablonska S, Breitburd F, et a1: The
human papiliomavtruses. Bull Cancer 1978a;6S:
151-164.
12. Butel J: Studies with human papillomavirus
modeled after known papovavirus systems. J Natl
Cancer Inst 1972:48:285-299.
13. Koller LD, Olson C: Attempted transmission of
warts from man, cattle and horses and of deer
fibroma to selected hosts. J invest Derrrtatol
1972:58:366-368.
14. Melnick JL, Allison AC, Butel JS, et ai: Papova-
viridae Intervirol 1974;3:106-120.
15. Jenson AB, Rosenthal JD, Olson C. et al: Irttmu-
nologic relatedness of papillomaviruses from
different species. I Nat/ Canrer Inst 1980;64:
495-500.
16. Law M-F, Lancaster WD, Howley PM: Conserved
nucleotide sequences among the;enomes of papiI-
lomavirttses. I Viro! 1979;32:199-207.
17. Crawford LV: Nucleic acids of tumor viruses. Adv
Virus Res 1969;14:89-132.
18. Lancaster WD, Meinke W: Persistence of viral
DNA in human cell cultures infected with human
papilloma virus. Nature (London) 1975;256:
434-436.
19. La Pona RF, Taichman LB: Human papilloma
viral DNA replicates as a stable episome in
cultured epidermal keratinocytes. Proc Nat! Acad
Sci USA 1982;79:3393-3397.
20. Lancaster WD, Olson C: Papovavirus infections
of vertebrate animals. Comp Dwtn Viral Dis
1981;II1:69-98.
21. Bett WR: Wart I bid thee begone. Practitioner
1951;166:77-8p.
22. Clarke GHV: The charming of warts. J Invest
Dermato! 1965;14:15-21.
23. Rolleston JD: Dermatology and folklore. Br J
Dermatol 1940;43:43.
24. Licht C de F: Om Vonters Smitsomhed. Uteskr
Laej S Raekke 1894; I:368-369.
25. Ciuffo G: Imnesto posidvo con 5luato di verruca
colgare. G Itol Mat Vener 1907;45:12-17.
26. Serra A: Ricerche istologiche e spetimeatali sui
condiloma capo e la verruca voi8sre. Coatributo
all'etiologia, patotanesi, Ntrabilita. G Itd Mol
Vener 1908:49:11-42.
27. Wile UJ, Kingrey LB: Tbe etiology of common
warts: Prdiminary report of an atperitnental
study. JAMA 1919;73:974-973.
28. Strauss MJ, Bunting H, Melnick JL: Virus-like
particles and inclusion bodies in skin papillomas. I
Invest Denrtatol 1949;15:433-444.
29. Meinick JL, Bunting H, Banfield WO, et al: Elec-
tron microscopy of viruses of human papilloma,
moiluacuta contaposum. and vaocinia, including
obsavations on the formation of virus within the
cell. Ann NY Acad Sef 19S2:S4:1214-1225.
30. Bunting H: Close-packe+d array of virus-like par-
ticles within cells of a human skin papilloma. Proc
Soc Esp Bio! Med 19S3:a4:327-332.
31. Ahneida JD, Howatson AF, Wiiliams MG: Elec-
tron microscope study of human warts: Sites of
965
virus production and nature of the inclusion
bodies. I Invest Dermatol 1962:38:337-345.
32. Melnick JL: Papova virus group. Science 1962;
135:1128-1130.
33. Favre M, Orth G, Croissant O, et al: Human
papillomavirus DNA: Physical map. Proc Nar!
Acad Sci USA 1973b;72:4810-4814.
34. Gissmann L, zur Hausen H: Human papillomavi-
ruses: Physical mapping and 8enetic heterogeneity.
Proc Nat! Acad Sci USA 1976;73:1310-l313.
35. Gisstnantt L. Pfister H, zur Hausen H: Human pap-
iDomavirtues (HPV): Characterization of four
different isolates. Virology 1977a:76:J69-380.
36. Orth G, Favre M, Croissant 0: Characterization
of a new type of human papiliomavirus that causes
skin warts. I Virol 1977b;24:106-120.
37. Orth G, Jablonska S, Favre M, et al: Character-
ization of two types of human papillomaviruses in
lesions of epidermodysplatia verruciformis. Proc
Natt.lcad Sci 1978b;7S:l337-1541.
38. Kluj A, Finch JT: Structure of viruses of the
papilloma-polyoma type. I. Human wart virus. J
Mo! Bio! 1963;11:403-423.
39. Viac J, Thivolet J, Chardonnet Y: Specific im-
munity in patients suffirrina from recurring warts
before and after repetitive intradermal tests with
human papillornavirus. Br J Desmatol 1977b;
97:365-370.
40. Crawford LV, Crawford EM: A comparative
study of polyoma and papilloma viruses. Virology
1963;21:238-263.
41. Crawford LV: A study of human papil)oma
viruses DNA. J Mo! Bio! 1965;13:362-372.
42. Gissmann L, zur Hausen H: Physical characteriza-
tion of the deoxyribonucleic acids of different
human papilloma viruses (HPV). Med Microbiol
Immunol 1978;166:3-11.
43. Howley PM. Law M-P, Heilman C, et al:
Molecular characterization of papillomavirus
genomes. Cold Spring Harbor ConJ Cell Prol
1980;7:233-247.
44. Howley PM: The human papillornaviruses. Arch
Pathol Lab Med 1982; 106:429-432.
45. Lancaster WD, Olson C: Animal Papillomavi-
ruses. Microbiol Rev 1982;46:I9I-207.
46. Morrison JM, Keir HM, Suback-Sharp H, et al:
Nearest neighbour base sequence analysis of the
deoxyribonucleic acid of a further three matn-
maliatt viruses; simian vinn 40, human papillottta
virus and adenovirus type 2. J Gen Virol
1967;1:I01-106.
47. Gisstnann L, zur Hausen H: Inverted repetitive se-
quences in human papiUoma virus I (HPV-1)
DNA. Virology 1977b;83:271-276.
48. Favre M. Breitburd F, Croissant O, et al: Struc-
tural polypeptides of rabbit, bovine, and human
papitloma viruses. J Vlrol 197Sa;1S:1239-1247.
49. Orth G, Breitburd F. Favre M: Evidence for aati-
genic determinants shared by the structurai poiy-
peptides of (Shope) rabbit pepillomavirus aud
human type I. Virology 1979;91:243-235.
S0. PSstet H, Gissmann L, zur Hausen H: Pntial
characterization of the proteins of human pspillo-
maviruses (HPV.I) 1-3. Vbotosy 1977;83:131-137.
51. Pass F. Maizel JV: Wart-aasociated antijets. 11.
Human immunity to viral structural proteins. Jltt-
vest Dermarol 1973:60:307-3! 1.

966
52. Spira G. Estes MK, Dreesman GR, et al: Papova-
virus structrual polypeptides; Comparison of
human and rabbit papilloma viruses with Simian
virus 40. IRtervirolojy 1974;3:220-231.
53. Favre M. Breitburd F. Croissant O. et ai:
Chromatin-llke structures obtained after alkaline
disruption of bovine and human papillomavtruses.
J Virol 1977;21:1205-1209.
54. Coggin JR, zur Hausen H: Workshop on papillo-
maviruses and cancer. Cancer Res 1979:39:
545-546.
55. Gissmann L, de Villiers E-M. zur Hausen H:
Analysis of human warts (condylom.ata acu-
minata) and other genital tumors for human
papillomavirus type 6 DNA. Int J Cancer
1982a;29:143-146.
56. Gissmann L. Diehl V. Schultz-Coulton H-J, et al:
Molecular cloning and characterization of human
papillomavirus DNA derived from laryngeal
papilloma. ! Virol 1982b:44:393-400.
57. Heilman CA. Law M-F, Israel MA. et al: Cloning
of human papillomavirus 8enomic DNAs and
analysis of homologous polynucleotide sequences.
J Virol 1980:36:393-407.
58. Jenson AB, Sommer S. Paylin8-WriBht C. et al:
Human papillomavirus: Frequency and distribu-
tion in plantar and common warts. Lab Invest
1982c;47:491-497.
59. de Villiers E-M, Gissmann L. ztu Hausen H:
Molecular cloning of viral DNA from human
genital warts. I Viro! 1981;40:932-935.
60. Green M. Brackmann KH, Sanders PR, et al:
Isolation of a human papillomavirus from a pa-
tient with epidermodysplasia verruaformis: Pres-
ence of related viral DNA genomes in human
uroQenital tumors. Proc Nati Acad Sci USA 1982;
79:4437-4441.
61. Lancaster WD, Kurman RJ, Sanz L. et al: Human
papilloma virus: Detection of viral DNA sequences
and evidence for molecular heterogeneity in meta-
plasias and dyspiasias of the uterine cervix. Inter-
virology 1983:20:202-212.
62. Ostrow RS, Bender M. Niimura M. et al: Human
papillomavirus DNA in cutaneous primary and
metastasized squamous cell carcinomas from pa-
tients with epidetmodysplasia verruciformis. Proc
Nat! Acad Sci USA 1962;79:1634-1638.
63. Hirt B: Selective exuaction of potyonta DNA
from infected mouse cell cultures. I Mo( Biol
1967;26:365-369.
64. Chad AL, Giumann L, Me:er B, a al: Molecular
donin= and partial nudeotide sequence of human
p.piiloma virus type Ia. Vlro/oLy 1952;118:
2Si-739.
65. Soutbatn EM: Detection of speci5c sequences
amon~ DNA fragments separated by gel electro-
pbocsut. ! Mo! Biof 1975;93:303-317.
66. Howley PM, israel MA, La.v M-P, a al: A rapid
method for detecting tlfe mapping homology be-
tween lteeteroiorous DNAs. I Biot Chent 1979;
254:48764a33.
67. Getb LD, Kohne DE, Martin MA: Quantituion of
simian virus 40 sequences in African aeat
rttonkey, mouse and virtts-transfotmed cell
genoma. I Mol Qiot 1971:57:129-243.
6i. Massiag AM. Epstein WL: Natural history of
warts. A two-yeu study. Arch Dermatol 1963;
87:306-310.
69. Quick CA. Foucar E. Dehner LP: Frequency and
significance of epthelial atypia in laryngeal papd-
lomatosis. Laryngoscope 1979;89:530-560.
70. FriedberQ SA. Stagman R, Hass GM: Papillary le-
sions of the larynx in adults: a patholo8tc study.
Ann Otol Rhinol Larynjo! 1971:80:683-692.
71. Pfister H. zur Hausen H: Seroepidemtolo8ic
studies of human papilloma virus HPV-1 infec-
tions. 1978;21:161-163.
72. Summers L, Booth DR: Intraoral condylotna acu-
minatum. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Parho!
197438:273-278.
73. Morison WL: Viral warts, herpes simplex and
herpes zoster in patients with secondary immune
deficiencies and neoplasms. Br J Dermarol )975c:
92:625-630.
74. Reid TMS, Fraser NG, Kernohan IR: Generalized
warts and immune deficiency. Br J Dermaro! 1976;
95:559-564.
75. Spencer ES, Andersen HK: Clinically evident,
non-temnal infections with herpes virus and the
wart virus in immunosuppressed renal allograft
recipients. Br Mcd J 1970:3:2S1-2i4.
76. von Krogh G: Warts: Immunolo8ic factors of
prognostic significance. Int I Dermarol 1979; 18:
195-204.
77. Orid JD: Natural history of genital warts. Br J
Vener Dis 1971a:46:37-42.
78. Jenson AB, Openshaw H, Hooks JL, et al: Herpes
and other virally-induced oral diseases, in Slavkin
HC, Cohen DW (eds): Current Advances in Oral
Biology. Bristol, Distributions System. 1979.
79. Grussendorf El, zur Hausen H: Localization of
viral DNA replication in sections of human warts
by nucleic acid hybridization with complementary
RNA of human papillomavirus type 1. Arch Der-
rnato! Res 1979;264:55-63.
80. Berman A, Berman JE: Efflorescence of new
warts: A si8tt of involution: Histopathological
findings. Arch Derntatoi 1977;113:1219-1221.
81. Berman A, Winkelmann RK: Flat warts undergo-
ing involution: Histopathological findings. Arch
Dermotol 1977; 113:1219-1221.
82. Tagami H, Ogino A. Ra.kipwa M, a al: ReRes-
sion of plane warts followinj spontaneous in!!am-
mation. A histopatholopcal study. Br I Dermatol
1974;90:147-154.
83. Ricciuti L, Lancaster WD, Scofield H, a al: Iden-
tification of papillomavinu structural antt;ens in
single papillomuous lesions of the oral cavity.
Submitted for publication.
$4. Gissm^^ L, Woinik L, Ikenbas H, a al: Human
papillomavirtn types 6 and 11 DNA sequences in
nnital and larytskai papillomas and in some csr-
virai ¢anoars. Prot 1Votl Aced Sd USA 19e3;W.
560-363.
83. Galloway TC, Soper GR, Elxa J: Carcinoma of
the latynx afia itradiation for papiilomaa. Arch
OtolCrynfaJ i960:72:289-294.
d6. Putney FJ: Borderline maliptant lesions of the
larynx. Aidr Orolaytrtot 1933;61:3i 1-333.
S7. waislt TE, Bamer PR: Epidetmoid carcinoma of
the iarYnx occurrint in 2 chiidrm with papilloma
of the larynx. LaryRta*cbpe 196Q;60:1110-1124.
4.
