Council for Tobacco Research
the Tar in Cigarette Smoke and Its Possible Effects; Amer J of Cancer 16,6 [St]
Abstract
ILL;MAR
Fields
- Type
- SCIENTIFIC ARTICLE
- CHART
- DRAWING
- BIBLIOGRAPHY
- CHART
- Depository Date
- 29 Feb 1996
- Named Person
- Rush Medical College
- Lane
- Raleigh
- Hilger
- Royal Baking Powder
- Auchincloss, R.
- Univ, P.A.
- Crosen, R.G.
- Garner
- Van Leeuwen
- Bailey
- Pietet
- Rotschy
- Lehmann
- Kissling
- Thurston
- Asherman
- W Interstein
- Aronson
- Dixon
- Gawrilow
- Koperina
- Zebrowski
- Mertens
- Ratner
- Vas
- Heubel
- V Ohl
- Johnson
- Webb
- Philippson
- Noorden
- Guillan
- Gy
- Adler
- Stoeber
- Wacker
- Hamilton
- Lee
- Brunton
- Large
- Mcnally
- Thompson
- Fleig
- Baumberger
- Perry
- Martin
- Henderson
- Haggard
- Us Bureau, O.F. Mines
- Drechsel
- Loebisch
- Warburg
- Trillat
- Gundermann
- Cooper
- Brosch
- Schmincke
- Hoffman
- Schreus
- Zurhelle
- Helwig
- Schaer, H.
- Bossi
- Jouse
- Hosel
- Papadia
- Fuerbringer
- Woglom
- Amer, J. Of Cancer
- Tobacco World
- Bergerhoff
- Lane
- Request
- 131
- Author
- Mcnally, W.D., Rush Medical College
- Box
- 129
- Site
- Hockett
- UCSF Legacy ID
- lqk2aa00
Document Images
NK02216538
1506 \P\f. U. TfCNALLY
and ncusea are induced (Ilendcrson and Iln-gard). Thc 11. S.
Bureau of nlincs examined the air in a confinrd spnce after inten-
sive smoking, and found that the carbon monoxide conccnti;ation
of the air of the room did not increace bcyond 0.01 hcr cent; the
maximinn blood conrcntration did not risc ahove 5 per cent,
quantitics that arr, considered negliril,lv. Carb'om monoxidc :is
inhaled in ihc smokc of cigarettes cannot, therefore, be cousidcred
as an irritant.
Since this investigation has to do with 1 he smoke of tobacco in
the form of cigareites, it. oill include the water-sohuble components
as well as the tar-like substances. In in effort to obtain pruduct5
of smoke as much like those taken into the system during the
process of smoking <iR possible, the smoke from six cigarettes in a
holder was passed through a serics of Drechsel mash bottles (Fig. 1).
Both intermittent and continuous suction were used. 'Nu atterolit
was mnde to collect such gnses as carbon monoxide and carbon
dioxidc.
The Amount, of tar separating incrcased rapidly in the ]nstt
three quarters of an inch of the cigarette. Thc process of smoking
is like a volatile distillation, the moisture, as stcani, carrying along
the volatile product,;, some of which accumulate in tLe cooler
portion of t.he cigarettc, which happcns to be the last half inch in
the holder. The water extracts contained (in addition to the tars
and tar oil;) cyinides, carbonates, n]trltes, arsenic, alnnlonln,
hydrogen suiphide, methyl alcohol, fatty acids, furmaldehyda,
acrylic aldchyde, nicotine, pyridin, picoline, hrtidin, collidinc,
and phenolic bodies. Loebisch mentions the presence of creosote.
Amn:onia, which is in irritant, is present in mere traces, 0.1 mg.
per cigarette. :.t is never recognizcd in the smoke by its odor
(1,20 vol. of 111, per 1,000 parts of air imparts a strong odor).
Warburg believes that nicotine is not wholly respunsililc for the
syiyptoms resulting from execssive smoking, that. sonic other
substance plays a rolo. This substance, I believe, is the tarry
material scparating from the smoke. Uethyl alcohoi disco.ered in
tobacco smoke by Neuberg, formaldehyde by Trillat, and hydro-
cynnic acid by Vogel, mny intensify the irritant action of the tar
and tar oils on the delicate mucous membranes of the respiratory-
tract. Lehmann and Cundermanii elaim that the hydrocyanic acid
in tile smokc of a cigar amounts to 0.002 to 0.5 nng. and is of no
significance. Where there is tn inflnmmation of the mucous
niembrane, continually irritated by thc products of smoking, the

C
,
1512 W.M. D. xicx.ar,i,Y
cancer of the lcnigs. In r:nO:cncl dcning the per.ec] 1901-1910 the
deal L rate nas I per 100,000, incrc;;sing to 2.3 per 1t10,11(Itl in 1927.
, The ntore frequent occurrciice of ulccr and c:crcinocua in
sniokcas ccui be attrihutccl to the irrit;iut aciion cd th'c cbeuiic:cl
substanecs mentionecl. In Ilolland, where 1ob;wco is usecl iuore
extensive1y than anywhcrc else in I:wnpc, thc de:cth r;ctc for
canccr of thc stom:cch i~ 553. ln England it is 333. (':mccr of
the stomach is much more prcvaleut in the male than in the
felmlc.
Bossi quotes the expcriments of .ldlea, Jouse, Hosel aud Papadia
with tobacco smoke and reports the results of having :iAiim~cls in-
hate the sinoke of cigarettes. after the incthod of Bufa]ini. Fcmnc of
his rabbits developed a glycosuri:c, which in my opinion ralm from
the carbon monoxide absorLed. Roffo, from his experiments,
believes that the wsctcr-solublc constittients of smoke have more
carcinogenic properti" than the alkaloicl nicotine.
Fiirbringer claims that the inhaler absorbs as much as cigbt
times the amownt of nicotine absorbed by mouth suiolccrs. The
mord "inhaler" is gcnerally used to desienatc a pcr5on who cx]::lles
smoke through the nostrils, and not in the sense that the suction
action of thee lung during smoking makc,, every one an iohalcr, aa a
popular brand of cigarette advertizes. 1'ioglom, in discussiug
experimental t:u (from coal) canecr, say's: "There are a]most as
man} explanations of the way in which tar produce, a malignant
grou-th as there are investigators."
The rcater-solubie products from the snnoke of 100 cig;trettea
werc made up to 100 c.c., and 0.1 c.c. was given daih as n spray per
mouth to 6 half-grown rats. To another 6 rats the tar collccted
was applied at the back of the left ear; 6 other rats had thc tar
applied to a spot shaved ou the back, about I inoh in di:;mcter, 6
others had tar applied to the tongue and buccal surfaces. Two
rats were kept as controls. The tar was soluble ir chloroforin,
pctroleum ether, and benzol, but was insoluble in ethylic ether.
Since 3 of the rats ha.ino the tar applied to the back died on the
eighth day ftom nicotine poisoning, the amount of tar was reduced.
On the fifty-second day one control rat died. Ou thc seventy-
second day a rat died having two areas of inflammatlon on the
tongue about the size of a grain of tirheat, caused by enc,ysted
?'ricleiucll<i spirnlis. On the ninet}-seventh day a rat died which
h:id received tar per mouth. On the hundred and tenth day
three rats having tar on t lie back became ill ; nd lost nrioht, and it
HK02216544

HaU2216545
TBr TAtI 1, C1G.SRI:7Tb S.1tu1Cr'. AND 17:; 1iF11.C 1S ].31~
was nc.cc;,5z:-'r3 to tt-ilhclr:rn the tsr. 7'hc llair grew ilag:1in nftcr
the unhlicntion of the t:u ce:ls<d. Thc rros~z ez:uniilntion of the
organ5. of the rats dying during the eXl)crinicl,l <ii<l not show nny-
thin of n'otc. .1I1 of the l:rt5 grci. :r co: rScr h:'ir th:m the coutruls.
Tbe experimental aniin,tls did )rut grow :o; ral,i<11y n, the conttol
aniluals.
raXCLl'Slo\ S
1. The tar of cifimctte slnnkc eont;rin~z nicotinc, phenolic bodic.,
pyriclinc bases, and ammonia, irrifnnt< which could nccouut for
"cit;nrettc cough," thc chronic lrronchiti., of the cir:rrette snioker,
1he ]cukopl:tkia in hcavy smaker;, and thc recorded incrc:r~:c of
cancer of thc lung.
2. The tentper.rturc is not an important factor unless ihccigar=-
ette is burned don11 to the last ccntil))eter, whcn the hot snlolcc^
becomes more irritatll)g.
3. With a tarr.% residue of 4.S4 to 1;i?9 per cent, a<lcfillitc risk
attaches to the smoking of a cig:<rette., especially sincc 6.56 to l l.3S
per cent mny be absorbed or ret:<ined in the body.
4. Cigarettes should not be smoked too short, as the last two
centimeters retnin ma:t of the tar and other pro<lucts of incomplcte
combustion.
]3I13L10C nA PN Y
Anrrt:n.,o% : Chem. \cu'~ 120: 130, 1919.
$Aa.t:Y: C'onn. :1gric. 1:xpcr. Station, Iiu11. =9.i, 1927;:i07, 19?S.
13er~)sta<cla<, .l. P., Penun., E*. 1:., AND .lLtnTiN, E. G.: J. Inde>lriol
Hygiene 3: 1, 1921.
]3snGr:nnol'r: C'itecl by ]tolfn)nun, Schrrur, nrld 'Lul'llellC: I>etlt~ch< med.
Wchnschr. 49 : G3:3, 192:3.
Bocr:-,, 1:.: J. A. \l. .1. 93: 1112, 1929.
Bo,sr::1u. d..accarl. med. fis. fiorcnt 80, 19J0.
Reo-scn, .1.: Circho<s's Arch. f. parh. .annt. 102: 32, 1900.
Brst-m'o-, +sn Ttxxtct)1re: J. PhN.iol. 17: 272, 1S9a-9i.
C'ourr a, F.. A., L.AIArn, F. W. AI., SAxurus, E., AND tlni"r, 1:. L.: J.
liygiene 32: 293, 1932.
Dixox, W. ];.: \I. Standard 51: 9, 192S.
Flsu:: Compl. rend. ac:rd, d. se. 146: 776, I90S.
Funnalxosk: Deutsche Ined. Wehnschr. 02: 2020, 1926.
Ganxtin: I'. S. Dept. .agriculturc, 13urcau of Plant Industry, 131111. 102,
1905.
GAIVarLaW AND I:orsn<N.a, A. 1C.: liiochem. 7.tschr. 231: 25, 1931.
GrrLL.t. AND Gi: Gaz. h8t,. 81: 1616, 1905.
HAASE, G.: bcutschr \lmi:rlschr. f. Zahnh. 15/: 9`_'9, 19:3t.
IIAMnLTON: Industrinl Poisons in the L'. S., Maomillan C'o., Xcn York,
192:i, P. 510. '

,
T11F. TAII I\ clc.axr,rrr, Miohr. AND rr, l:rrLCr7 1511
i1I which prolifcrations of nn cstcnsirc na1±uc, and of a close
histolo;ic resemLlaucc to squamous-cell epithclion,a, were pro-
duced irith ioLacco tar. The1 deternlinctl that onl. lipoid soluble
subst.ances prodneed epitllelial lnolifer:dions. In 1923 11ofl'nl;ln,
Schreus and '/,urhelle succeeded in produciltfi only a hypcrker:Itoc:is
on thc skin of mice. The hair fell out and gre« in ngaiu when the
application of tar ccnsed. Hehcit; uscd the residttc found in bowls
of briar pipes, but as most of his mice dicd frrnn too strong solution
he tried an etherenl extract and repmtcrtl the development of
suggestive lesions in about two weeks.
TenLI: V
Rcsnlfs of Eapnrnlrrd., vi01 Co>din+utr, Ru.fi.m
Brnnd bfoisturc Vol:It1lC Tarn' ne~iduc
33 12.71 f0 17.73~~
15 14.15
i
13 87 10.f.1
32 1s.S~ 1C 33 7.5a
13 &&S 17.73 5 ~n
Tn
Lartg altd J/ovfll Absorption of ms VI
Tnr for 1'ar
i. as Iha
nd. of Cigmrrb>
E nranil
15 VolalilP
32.75rt R .ridue
2.97cc .Al..orl Md or I1at2llif.: In 14.nI)'
7.o-l~c to 11.5,,;c'
i 13 11.a:t''< 4 ^G';i G.Sfr;
1S 15.56;, 1.07 I~ 5.10!~
14 5.20 ; 1 3.aG~i 10.3fi!'~
29 5S.5firi
33 15.G1~a 2.35'; o 7.17~i
H. Schaer, in the exnmination of 237, esophnguses, chicfly from
men, found leukoplakia in 67 per cent of all of the cases. This
occurred more often in men than in t.omen. Leukoplakia, accord-
ing to TTanse, is n diseasc of males, women hcing affccted in only 1.99
per cent of t.he enses, According to 1ioffnl:In, cancer of the cso-
phngus inercascd from 1.0 per 100,000 in 1915 to 1.7 in 1922, fell
to 1.'t in 1924, rose to 1.9 i11 102fi, but declined to 1.7 in 1927.
kor canccr of the hings, he gives thc death rate as 0. 7 per 100,000 in
1915, 1.1 in 1920, 1.6 in 1924, and 1.0, the 1nnximunl figure, in 1927.
Comparing the enormous eonsunlption of cigarettes in 19°.5-1931
with the increase in pulnlonauy cancer, one i- certainly led to believe
that cigarette smoking is an important factor in the increase of
3KC2216543
