Council for Tobacco Research
Hearings Before the Subcommittee on Health of the Committee on Labor and Public Welfare United States Senate Niety-Fourth Congress Second Session on S. 2902 - to Amend Title V of the Public Health Services Act to Establish A National Health Research and Development Advisory Commission, and for Other Purposes February 19, March 24, and May 27, 1976 [Hearings Regarding Most Recent Scientific Data on the Higher Rate of Death of Smokers Compared to Nonsmokers]
Abstract
MAR
Fields
- Depository Date
- 25 Sep 1995
- Master ID
- Ctrmn00014501-5129
Related Documents:- CTRMN014501-4661 Deposition of Sheldon C. Sommers [Deposition of Sommers in the Matter of Cipollone]
- CTRMN014662-4664 US District Court for the District of New Jersey Honorable H. Lee Sarokin - Docket No. 83-2864sa Civil Action - Notice to Take Oral Deposition of Sheldon C. Sommers, M.D. Antonio Cipollone, Individually and As Executor of the Estate of Rose D. Cipollone, Plaintiff, Vs. Ligget Group Inc., A Delaware Corporation; Philip Morris Incorporated, A Virginia Corporation; and Lowe's Theatres Inc., A New York Corporation, Defendants [Notice to Produce Documents Regarding Contracts with the Tobacco Institute and Dr. Oscar Auerbach]
- CTRMN014665-4666 Cipollone V. Ligget, Et Al. Our File No. 03356-113151 [Request to Present at Interview by Counsel]
- CTRMN014667-4667 Cipollone V. Liggett [Request to Take Deposition Disagreement with Tone or Content of Statements]
- CTRMN014668-4704 Thomas Hoyt Council Tobacco Resesarch 110-E-59st [Regarding Invitation to Review Experimental Material and Permit Expert to See Slides and Protocols]
- CTRMN014705-4715 Hearings Before the Consumer Subcommittee of the Committee on Commerce United States Senate Ninety-Second Congress Second Session on S. 1454 - to Amend the Federal Cigarette Labeling and Advertising Act to Require the Federal Trade Commission to Establish Acceptable Levels of Tar and Nicotine Content of Cigarettes February 1, 3, and 10, 1972 Serial No. 92-82 [Regarding Public Access to Information About Tar and Nicotine]
- CTRMN014716-4725 Hearings Before the Consumer Subcommittee of the Committee on Commerce United States Senate Ninety-Second Congress Second Session on S. 1454 - to Amend the Federal Cigarette Labeling and Advertising Act to Require the Federal Trade Commission to Establish Acceptable Levels of Tar and Nicotine Content of Cigarettes February 1, 3, and 10, 1972 Serial No. 92-82 [Money Funded by Tobacco Companies Expended for Research Grants and Contracts to Study Relevance of Proposals Received to Smoking and Health Problems]
- CTRMN014726-4762 Hearings Before the Committee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce House of Representatives Ninety-First Congress First Session on H.R. 643 - A Bill to Amend the Federal Cigarette Labeling and Advertising Act with Respect to the Labeling of Packages of Cigarettes and for Other Purposes (and Similar Bills) H.R. 1237 - A Bill to Direct the Federal Communications Commission to Establish Regulations Prohibiting Certain Broadcasting of Advertising of Cigarettes (and Similar Bills) H.R. 3055 - A Bill to Strengthen the Federal Cigarette Labeling and Advertising Act (and Similar Bills) H.R. 6543 - A Bill to Extend Public Health Protection with Respect to Cigarette Smoking and for Other Purposes (and Similar Bills) April 15, 16, 17, 18, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 28, 29, 30, and May 1 Serial No. 91-12 [Hearings Regarding A Program to Sharpen the Objectives of Supported Research of Tobacco and Health]
- CTRMN014763-4763 [Correspondence Containing Information on A Booklet Explaining Insurance and Retirement Plans for Employees of the Council for Tobacco Research]
- CTRMN014764-4778 Employment Agreement Between the Council for Tobacco Research - U.S.A., Inc. And Sheldon C. Sommers, M.D. [Mutual Covenants on Employment, Job Position, Terms, and Duties]
- CTRMN014827-4893 Deposition of Dr. Sheldon Sommers [Deposition of Sommers in the Matter of Rogers]
- CTRMN014894-4917 [St]
- CTRMN014918-4921 Statement of Dr. Sheldon C. Sommers [St]
- CTRMN014922-4922 Cigaret Blame for Cancer Is Questioned [Three Doctors Question Whether Smoking Causes Lung Cancer. Investigators Validity Challenged.]
- CTRMN014923-4926 [Insufficient Scientific Evidence to Prove Smoking Causes Diseases]
- CTRMN014927-4930 Statement of Sheldon C. Sommers, M.D. Before the Consumer Subcommittee of the U.S. Senate Interstate Commerce Committee [Regarding Research on Possibility of Tobacco Causing Cancer]
- CTRMN014931-4931 Scientific Advisory Board Members 1954-1978 [Listing of Accepted and Resigned Individuals of Scientific Advisory Board]
- CTRMN014932-4932 [New Scientific Director Assists Advice in Research Planning in the Pulmonary Disease Field]
- CTRMN014933-4934 [Successor for Scientific Director and Other Staff Positions in Short Supply]
- CTRMN014935-4935 [List of Names]
- CTRMN014936-4938 [Confidential Run-Down of What Occurred with Homburger at Federation Meeting in Atlantic City. Paper on Censorship]
- CTRMN014939-4941 [Memo Regarding the Enclosure of A Letter to Editor]
- CTRMN014942-4943 [Correspondence Regarding J.A.M.A. Not Publishing Study About Squamous Lung Carcinoma]
- CTRMN014944-4945 [Correspondence Regarding Wk's Letter. William Kleepfer Letter to the Editor.]
- CTRMN014946-4947 ["Follow-Up to Publication in Archives of the "Smoking Dog" Reports. Summary of Recommendations Arising From the Meeting."]
- CTRMN014948-4950 [Observations Concerning Articles by Drs. Hammond, Auerbach, Messrs. Kirman and Garfinkel, Published in Arch. Environ. Health]
- CTRMN014951-4952 [Article Regarding Experimental Design, Mortality, and Lung Parenchyma]
- CTRMN014953-4955 Chronic Smoke Inhalation Experiments [Long Term Experiments Involving Cigarettes and Smoke Inhalation on Larger Animals, Rather Then the More Feasible Mice, Rats, and Hamsters.]
- CTRMN014956-4957 Auerbach-Hammond Why the Present Proposal Is Not Worth Carrying Out [Procedures in Conducting Tests of Smoke on Lungs]
- CTRMN014958-4960 Why the Proposed Study Cannot Produce Meaningful Results [Tests of Smoke Intake of the Lungs and Overall Pulmonary System Are Inaccurate with the Normal Consumption of Smoke in Humans]
- CTRMN014961-4961 No. 826 - Dawber [Framingham Material Occupies A Key Position in Reference to Factors Related to Coronary Disease]
- CTRMN014962-4963 ["Memo Regarding Enclosed Article]
- CTRMN014964-4964 [Correspondence Containing Four Short Essays on the Present Status of Various Fields in Smoking and Health]
- CTRMN014965-4965 [""Highly Critical" Letters to Appear in American Druggist in Defense of Cigarette Smoking"]
- CTRMN014966-4966 [American Druggist Magazine Has Received A Number of Highly Critical Letters Regarding A Dr. Sommers Article]
- CTRMN014967-4969 in Defense of Cigarettes [Research Regarding the Smoking of Tobacco May Not Be A Serious Cause of Disease As Previously Thought]
- CTRMN014970-4979 Joint Committee on Tobacco and Health [St]
- CTRMN014980-4990 Tobacco and Health Research Some Proposed Studies [Study for Cancers, Cardiovascular Disease, Chronic Lung Disease, and Other Related Physical Ailments.]
- CTRMN014991-5129 Deposition of Sheldon C. Sommers [Deposition of Sommers in the Matter of Cipollone]
- Author
- Us Govt Printing Off
- Request
- 118
- Type
- TRANSCRIPT
- Box
- 007
- UCSF Legacy ID
- ces30a00
Document Images
r
E
®
F
THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
CONFIDfNTIAUTY AGREEMENT.
CIGARETTE SMOKING AND DISEASE, 1976
.
®
HEARINGS
I .. stiTOlE TsE
$UBCOMMITTEE ON HEALTH
OT TUE
COMMITTEE ON
LABOR AND' PUBLIC WELFARE
UNITED STATES SENATE
r'IrETI FOLTRTH CONGRESS
SECOND SESSION
ON
S. 2902
TO AMEXD TITLE V OF THE PUBLIC HEALTH SERVICES
ACT TO ESTABLISH A\ATIONAL HEALTH RESEARCH AND
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COJ1)lISSIO\, AND FOR OTHER
PURPOSES
FEBRUARY 19. )SARCH 24. AND MAY 27. 1976
Printed for the use of the Committee on Labor and Public Welfare
U.E. GOVEItNriENT TIINTtNG OTTICE
!0 Ot7 0 MAlHINGTON : 1074
C TR HN 014779

1HIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
288 CONFiDENTIAUTY AGREEMENT.
Senator Kt:xxEny. Our next panel is \!r. Horxcc Kornrg:ry. Prr'i-
dent. The Tobacco Institute. accompanied hv Dr. SlrtIdun ~ommor-
and Dr. Theodore D. Sterling. director of computing science l,rr,-
gram. Simon Fraser University of Canada.
There is a vote notv. I can probabl~ go over this this afterrroorr. I
want to give ~ou a chance and I will sta~- Kitlr ~-ou thitil tlre :i nrinutc
bell rings ana then come bnck at 2:1 5 or1:8(r. If ' vou hnve got ;r hard
hitting commcnt or statement you bettePmake it now becau.t. ~~~ith :rll
due respect to the press, the aftenroon hearings are not as Rell attended.
You can make whatever comment you want to make now ancl tht.rj
come back this afternoon. So if you would like to use the 5 or f
minutes to make whatever comment you would and we will have you
back at 2:15. " .
Mr. Koexr.rr.». I am not a scientist. \fr. Chairman, so I am goirl"
to ask Dr. Sommers if he .could go ahend with his statrrncnt tir-t.
STATEIiEFT OF SHELDOA C. SOMMERS, M.D., DIRECTOR. I.ABORA-
TORIES AT THE LEAO% HILL HOSPITAL, NEW YORK. AND PRO-
FESSOR OF PATHOLOGY, COLLEGE OF PHYSICIANS AND
t3UBdIANS, COLUISBIA IINLQJERSITY OF NEW YORH. ACCOMPA-
AIED BY HOB.ACE It. BOBAEt3eY, PRESIDENT, THE TOBACCO IN-
BTITUTE, WASHIRGTON, D.C., AND THEODORE D. STERLING.
Ph.D., DIEECTOR, CO1iPIITER SCIE!(CE PROGRAM, SIMON T'RASER
IINI?F.BSITY, CANADA
Dr. Soxist:xs. 111r. (`hairman and members of the committee. 1Jv
purlwse. in response to the imitation to present m~ personal view of
the status of knowledge of smoking and henlth-
Senator Kesxeni. You mnv summarize if yon wish and then-
Dr. Scat.-,tt:xx.0ivstatentent is a summam.
Senator KEx.eDY. OK.
Dr. Ccranrt:R~. 'Mv purJ~. in response to the invitntiorr to present
my 1>rrsonal view of the stntus of knowledge of smoking and health.
is to review the newer scientific data. This mnterinl is not included in
the quotntions from the 1)75 version of the L"SPH.q smnkina and
hen)th report cited br Senator Hnrt as justifying bill No. ~.
Cognizance of the present day knowledge by fnirnrtnded individual~
casts grave doubt on the existence of any such '°ocerwhelrning evi-
dence'as claimed by the distin~,nrislred Senator.
Fitst. in respect to the reported overall higher rate of death of
smokers than nonsmokers, the results were obtnined h* v stntistiral
eridemiologic methods now reco¢nized a5 erroneou5 nncl u<e of
is no longer regarded as justified. One to one comharisont of smokers
and nonsmokers inored many confonnding .nrrnbles. Vc Jtork:rm
predicteri the result proved to be a ctntistical artifact. This resulred
irom iRnoring thtee seriotts sourcec of error :
(1) Nonrandom comrarisnnc. menning thnt smokers nnd nnrr-
smokers are not random suhsets of the ponnlntion being tested. ~iuok-
ers chrince to smoke and others chn(Ae nnt to smoke. antl both vro,rh-
are self-selected. nnparentl' v by complex processes not hrescntlv trnder-
stood. The crucial error is the use of stnticticnl methods to tert nrn1-
random grours. designed for and applicnble only to comraring
CTR MN 014't`''80

Mr. }lorace Iiorneguy. presi-
d by lir. Sheldon C. ;otnmers
)r of computing science pro-
Ia.
go over this this aftcnroon. I
v with cou until the 5 minute
:2:3(t. If you have got a hard
make it umw becouse. with all
arings are not as.cell attended.
u want to make now and then
would like to use the 5 or 6
r would and we will have you
Mr. Chairman, so I atn going
head with his statement first.
S, N.D., DIRECTOR, LABORA-
(TAL, AEW YORg, AND PRO-
OE OF PHYSICIAlPS AND
' OF NEW YORH, ACCOMPA
tESIDEAT, THE TOBACCO IA
) THEODORE D. STERLING.
'E PROGRAM, SIMON FRbSER
~mbcrs of the committee. Nkc: '
~ present m% personal view of
~ea)tlt-
ite if~,%nu wish utd then---
ry.
~
,ze to the invitation to present
ledr,e of smokinfi and health.
ris mnterinl is not included in -P
if the l-SP}1~ smokingy ancl -
s justifying lril) \o. S. 2902
ge by fairminded indicidunlx
1 rny such "o~er~~~helminF e~i- _
nator.
?rall higher rate of death of
were obtained bc -statisticnl "
is erroneous nnd u-e of ahich
n nne compariconc of smokers
ndin- vnrrnhle-. As 14erksnn
tistical artifact. This resulted
or :
ing thnt smokers and nnn-
otcnlation being tested. Snrnk-
nt to smnke, and lxtth grnup,~
rrnce&ses not rrescntly iurcleri ntisticnl methods to te.ct nnn
rplicnble only to comparing
THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
269 CONFIDENTIAUTY AGREEMENT.
random groups. Rolliug the loadcc) dicc statistirnlly );ice. att inc,lid
ansaer.
(2) lkJxndeucc on limited statistical tests for proof. 11'Lcrr lto-c
and Bell wrote their moatogral,h on rrrdicting lnrrt,.evit., ther resrccl
factors that might be as.,~ociated with earlyrefu)1y death among a grou J~ of
Boston lt'orld 11'ar rI veterans, followed cafu)1y for 3U yeart. A one-
to-one comparison of cigarette smoker*tand nonsmokers gave sn,oking
thc ntunler one plucx as u predictor. like in nrnn} other stodie-. lloc% -
ever, when multiple factors vrem included statistically cigarette
smoking dropped to somewhere beyond thc 3uth mou si~rulr,:rrlr
predictor of early death. I)issatisfactinu with jnh l,,ecanu th~ nunrLrr
one predictor. 1
(3) Secularitt. meaniitg the change in habit l,ntterus of thc pnl.u
lation from aboitt I:+lu to 1960, xawith increatied J,roPortrnt,; of
ette smnker` in each decad(: A model population (not a tcal Ju)l,ul:i-
tion) with strch chnuges nver equal tiuic .cill show n stntt=tte:rllx
signiticant incrvase ill total denth rate as a minoritv ch:nrp= tmN:,nl
a majuritv. This secu)nrity fnctor or S1Lnngc ill Jrolrulntiou patrrrtl
has rnn health imrlication. For example. ill the original Stn-v(-u
Generul's report a tahle showed pipe smnkers to hnve n lo«er cl(-atlj
rate than notrsmokem. 11'hi)c encouraginfi H belief that IrIIH. =tt,u~c r=
nere the sturdiest humans, a be.ttcr explanation i~ou)d be thc secularity
effect. There were fewer pipe smokers ill each decade. the converse of
cigarette smokers.
These data are published and available for all to read.l\-hn- ]t:rve tLc
proposers of the bill not heard of them ? It is becnusc tlic antnt:tl
supplements to the Sur eon General's report on smoking and hcaltl~
are limited reviews anrinterJtretations of the medical and icientific
literature, from which are screened out articles that do not agree with.
call into question. or destror arguments and conclusions supporriVe
of the official Government position.
As an examJrle, in a presentation prepared for hearing, on n 1~r~~-
pos:rl h~ Senntor ~tos.c of I'tah to limit by law the amnunt!z of ni-tinr
and cnndencate, sn called tar. in cignrettes. I Jxiinted ont ill thar
approximately 1.i91 articles published since 1960 vcere not cited.
Lists of these ;vere supJrliecl.
On ncrasiou. publications not suhlrortin; the official positinti
)reeu suPJrres=ed. The epidemiolofirc proLlemse slrortcnminre nnd errur=
were aired at a panel meeting at the AAAS in 1971. so the abnve is
not secret informntion. One regrets that the prohnsers of the I-ill 1,:'A- f
not been made aware of the serions defects. obsolescence. hins nncl
incompleteness of the information on which the.% appear to b:rsc the
current proposed bill.
Xm%.. au to ]rurg cancer. there is a statistical ns-ncintimr l~of~~~ru
ci~,*uette smokinr nnd Jtnte cancer. But at present thr nnturc of tllc
assoointion or whether it is causal are not known. The test of tLc
orioinal Surgeon General's report deals with the difliculties of :rs' 4zi_n-
ing cancnlit.%. hut the summnry and cnnclu-4nns brush the-c
nnd assigrt a causnlit\ not demonstrablIV evident in the text. It i~
widcJv known that n statistical as.cncintinn i~ not hN itklf t1tnnf of
catrsntinn. A atatistical assnciatinm mn r troint to exJxvinunts thnt ~~ ill
helptodetermine Rhethertherr ixcnuce involved.
Animal esperiments to my knowled1±e have not succeedecl in thc
rrvxlnctinn nf so-called human type lnng cancers in n significnnt lret-
tentnge of an.N sPecies tested.
.
CTR M~~ 014~f='6-1-

THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
' 270 WNFIDENTIAUTY AGREEMENT,
Senator KttcN-zDy. Doctor, I am going to have to go. I only have 4
u
'
m
tutes to gret over there. "
e will recess to
rrcaxoox Basto.
~.
Senator IaNxcaY. We Rill come to order.
Dr. Sommers, would you continue ?
Dr. Soxxcas. In the interest of saving time, before the lunch break.
I did not identify myself.
I am Sheldoti C. Sommers. i11.D., director of laboratories. Lenox
Hill Hospital, New York; clinical professor of Pathology, Columbia
Ltniversitv Collef,~e of Physicians and Snriteons, New York, and l ni-
versit}- of Sonthern California, Los AnFeles; editor of the Pntholou~
Annual and Pathology Decennial Series; chairman of the Scientifi,Adt'ison $oard, Cbuncil for
Tobacco Research. t'.S.A.. Inc.; with
about 260pub1ications.
Mr curriculum vitae and publication list are available.
I irould like to briefly recnpitulnte the points made already. if vou
would like. \1r. Chairman.
Diy purJwse, in respnnsc to the invitation to present m~ personal
~-ien of the status of ktiowledge of smoking and health, is to review
the newer scientific data. This material is not included in the quota-
tions from the 1975 version of the t'SPHS smoking and health report
cited bv Senator Hart as justifying bill S. 29o-3.
First, in respect to the reported overall higher death rates of smok-
ers than nonsmokers. thc results were obtained by statistical epide-
miologic methods now recognized as errnneottc and use of which is no
longer regarded as justified.
Nonrandom comllarisons. meaning that smokers nnd nonsmokers
are not random subsets of the population being tested.
Kumber two, dependence ott limited statistical tests for proof.
When Rose nnd Bell wrote their monograph on predictinc longe.it.N.
thev tested factors that might hc associated with early death among
. ~
a9 roup 01 noslon ii ol7u ii ar J) vrlrrana. Ju1Fui.ru cri1.-iui~1 ~~.j
yen rs '11.
A one-to-onc comparison of cigarette smokers and nnnmloker-
gnve smnking the numlwr one place nc n predictor. like in mnn.- nther ~
studies. Hmcever, when multiple factor:~ were inclnded ~tnti:ticnll~, ~
ciLmrette smoking droptled to somewhere beyond the 30th most sia-
nifirnnt nredictor of early death.
Third, secularity. mennine the changm in habit patterns of thr hopn-
lntinn from abont*1Q1(1 to 1AR(l..rith increased proportions of cigarette t
A model ronnlntion. not a real pnpltlntlon. 1
smoker, in each decadc
.
~x with such clranres~ over e(lllal time will show a statlstlC11l\ stg~tltfic8nt ~
increase in totnl denth rate nc n minority changes toward a maioritN.
i
Thic cec»larity factor or change in population patterns has no health
implicntinn '.
For example. in tlle original Surgeon General's report a tllilc
nnn~m~lc~ r, ~
sllnaed pipe smokers to have a lower death rate. t1.R. than
1Chilc encouraging a lx~lief that pitle t;mnkers were tho stnr~lie~t
humnns, n better explanation ~rould hc the crcularit} effcct. t
tiow, ac tp limw canrcr. there is a statistical association hotccecil
;
cigarette smnkin_ and lnng cancer. Rnt at the present the nnture of
the aFsociatinn. or whether it is causal are not 1cnoRn. !
CTR t I t''! 0147822

tastoN
rder.
ng time, before the lunch break,
lirector of laboratories. Lenox
)feasor of Pathology, Columbia
Surgeons. New York. and l-ni-
nFeles; editor of the Pathology
ies; chairmnn of the Scientific
i Research. U.S.A.. Inc.; with
list are available.
he points made already, if you
itation to present my personal
ioking and health. is to review
al is not included in the quota-
'HS smoking and health report
I S. 2902.
all higher death r><tes of amok-
e obtained by atatistical epide-
rroneous and use of which-is no _
-
that smo)torrs and nonsmokers
m beit(R tested.
ted statistical tests for proof.
),,rahh on Dredictin¢ longe~it%. ~
)ciated with e,arly death among
?rans. followed carefully for 3()
~ctte smokers and nonFmokers
a predictor. like in many other
'; om were included statisticallv.
here beyond the 3nth most sig-
ze in habit patterns of the pr,Pti&- ,_
I creased proportions of eiftarette .
nulat ion. not aIraJ populotion.
II shoR a statistsealh- aiRnificnnt -
rity chnnges toRarcl a maiorit}.
>pulation patterns has no health
-F
raenn General's report a table
leath rate. ri.F. thnn nnn1mnkerce po smokers were the sturdiest
M the secularity eftert.
. statistical association between
tut at the present the nature of
.1 are not known.
THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
271 CUNFIDENTIALITY AGREEMENL
The te%t of the original Surgeon Ge.neral's report deals .citL tl,L
ditfiirultieb of "iFning cnusality, but the summtn. and ~-onclji-ioi:-
brush thi-x aside.and assign a causality not detuoitstrably e%idttjt itt
the text.
One wonders about the Surgeon Peneral's report. because it turns
out to be a limited review. Articles are screened out that do not =up-
1K,rt the ofticial (io%irnment position:
Senutor Iit:xx>an-. That ts a very serious charge, Doctor. as .ou
well knme.
1\'hat You are accuFing is the Surgeon (ireneral. and Dr. Cooper and
others; ~ou are accusine them of 1,ing, and fraud, and dereivtng the
public. That ie tlte way 1 read tltat language.
1>r. Suat~tr.rtc \ o. str. .
Senator Kr.XXEDY. Well...hat do you call the selective chnire±
I)r. SWN tateac. Sir?
Senator Ia:xxsm. That do not agree with.
Dr. SuxateRC. Sir. if you read the entire scientific literature-
Senator }ir.xxr.nr. I am not a scientist. I am talkiuF about .our ac-
cusntion herr. and that Ynu tnight have a different interl>retntimt of
the English 1anFuagr, but I would interpret whnt ~ou ~cere stating
here about the selective use of fact and fiQure~ that onl~ agree ~~ itl~
and support a Position. as accusing them of misleading. misrepre;ertt-
ing, and committing a fraud in terms of their responsibility.
Dt. No.sir.that 15not true.
Tlttit resl>nnsibility is to inform the public. as I nnderstnwl it. of
the danpers of cigarettes with respect to health.
MY interest is in disease, and the causes. and pathogenesis of di=ensc.
\1 P evidently read ditfirrent literature.
Senntor Kt:~xr.r~r. Well. is that not what you are saving here :
I>r. S~nr>teKS. Sir. if I ma% coutimte------
Senator Kt:xxenY. That 'is. there is no question about -har tL(snbstunce of the rerrescntntion
that they are makinF, and tLat ir ti:t
caus-e and re)ntimiship between cigarette smoking and cancer. heart
disea,;P. and other lung diseasec.
\mw. that hac 64,11 nrnde by the Surgeon (;;enernl. ltr. Ran-rher of
the National ('ancer Institute. the two outstanding \olK-l Prize win
nets,and the ChC.
.Now, if the substance and thrust of your testimony is to dot I'~.
and cross T's. talk about different aspects and sn. thnt tlurc can hP
differing internretationst that is one thing. If .ou nre trying. h% vmtr
testimnnr, to impeach the overwhelming substnnce nf 'their 'conclu-
sion, that is something else.
'.N oIN. -.vhich is it ?
Are vott challengin- their ba~ic and funclamental conclusionz. atld
that is ahOllt the cause ancl relationship between smoking nnrl cancer f
That is whnt vnn nrr nttncking.
Dr. Smtar:ac. \fV personnl belief. sir. is that the cnu:ative relatinn-
ship of cignrette smnkin~ to lung cancer is not proved.
Senator I~rxxr.m. \ot prctaf,tn what? To an all-olutc intinirr
certnintv
I mean. dnes am-thinz get proven, an~ more than this partlClllat'
fnctrn. in termr of inedical conclu5ion?
Dr. Suav%ter.s. Sir, the data available do not support the conclttrionz.
CTR f~t~`~ 0~.4'~%634

THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
272 DONFIDENTIAUTY AGREEMENL
Senator KtrvwT. Well, how are we supposed to understand all
thisT The best scientists that are available, in terms of responsibilities
to the public, all agree.
What do you know that the Nobel Aize winners do not know?
Dr. Soxxrats. Sir-
Senator KexirrmY. Or what information do vou have that the 1)e-
partment of Health does not htve, or the CDC has not got, or the
Surgeon General has not.Fot t
Dr. SoxxEtes. Sir, I cannot answer that question, because I do not
know what information these different individuals have.
All I can.F,ay to you is, sir, that I have been in cancer research for
40 vears.
kenator Kexxr.nr. I do not know Rh~- you make a statement ~~ou do
not know. The~ are all published reports.
Dr. Sox~ctats. From their pttblished rQports, sir, I conclude that the
data are insufficient to support the conclusions, that is. for examplc.
cigarette smoking is the major cause or a mnjor cause of lung cancei
Senator Iizxrr~r. Do vou think it has any relationship?
Dr. Soxxetta. I think it has an association. sir. It is in my statement.
if I mav continue.
Senitor Ktt. xmr. To what e=tent 4
Dr. SOYYLRS. If I may continue, it will be in my statement.
In respect to the 1972 hearing by Senator Aioss of t'tah. it Rac
pointed out that approzimatel~ 1,7 90 articles published since 196v Rert
not cited. Lists of these were supplied.
We will be glad to update that list to this vear.
Tow. as to lung c,ancer, there. is a statistical association between
cigarette smoking and lung cancer. But at present the nature of asso-
ciatton, or whether it is cattsal are not known.
The text of the original Surgeon General's report deals with the
difficulties of assigning causality, but the summary and conclusions
brush these aside. and migm a causality not demonstrablv evideni in
the text. It is RidelvknoRn that a statistical association is not by itself
proof of causation. A statistical association may point to experiments
that will help to determine whether there is cause involved.
Animal ezperiments, to my knowledge. have not succeeded in the
production-
Senator Kt:rxsny. Before we leave, is that all vou are going to say
about the associat ions of cigarette smoking and cancer?
Dr. Soxxsxs. \o. sir, I am Froingto it right now.
This includes inbred mice exix)sed to heavy cigarette smoke inlial;i-
tion over practically their entire lifespatt. t'erlaun false alarms like
the Auerbach beagle do and other studies of rats and mice. hi%e
stirred hope t.hat a model been achieved, but no cancers that grew.
spread. and led to death like human squamous cell lung carcinomas
have been reported in animals.
After 45 vears of inhalation research. and although expensive efforts
continue, no succeas has been achieved in proclucinF experimental lung
cancers in any reasonable, or even small numbers of experimental
animals.
Skin painting is cited in the bill proposal as part of the evidence of
carcinopenicity of tobacco smoke condensates. Suffice to snv that in the
past 5years, skin painting of animals with tobacco condensate ha~
L,, TR ! t t"t 014784

we swposed to understand all
able, in terms of responsibilities
Prize winners do not katovr?
stion do you have that the De-
r the CDC has not got, or the
that question. because I do not
t individuals'Aave.
a.e been in cancer research for
tv vou make a statement you do
s.
reporur sir, I conclude that the
nclusions, that is. for example,
r a mnjor cause of lung cancet
is any relationshipt
ation. sir. It is in my statement.
3*
.
cill be in my statement.
Senator rfoss of L'tah. it Qas
ticles published sinoe 1960 were
:his vear.
statistical antociation bet.reen
t at present the nature of asso-
toRn./
:eneral's report deals with the
the summar% and conclusions
:v not demonstrably evident in
:iical association is not bv itself
ition may point to ezperiments
I ere is cause involved.
ige, have not succeeded in the"
, -.
is that all you are going to say
;ng and cancer t
right now.
heat~ cigarette smoke inhila-
pan. t'ertatn false ilarms like
itudies of rats and mice. have
eved, but no cnncers that grew,
-quamous cell lung carcinomas
and althouFli expensive e8orts
n producing experimental lung
,)all numbers of experimental
~
osal as part of the evidence of
tsates. Suffice to say that in the
with tobacco condensate has
THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
273 CONFIDENT1ALlTY AGREEMENT.
vielded so few tumors, either benign or maliFnunt. that tlj( practwo
haspractit`ally been gi.en up. Only a feu govertuneiutal agency exl,rrn
mentsconttnue.
Why tumors were produced years ago following skin pairninF but
are now rarely produced is unknown. An English book review of a
work on tobacco and carcinogenesislit ated that if in the the
author had not reported 44 percent skili tumors when other laborat oritz~
were finding 3 to 5 percent, this field of research might have develol)cd
in a more orderly way.
On what basis is the claimm}de of 90,(K)O lung cancer cases her year?
It is based on death certificates, which are not sctentific docnmvrntsi and
in general are not corrected by finding~ if an autopsy is lrorforn1eci.
Senator ht:xxcnr. lt'ltat lxrcent do you think ?
Dr. SoiturJes. Sir, I come t.o that-I think the-
Senator Kax.rEnY. If you can answer my qnestions. becanso Rt, are
discussing this point now.
You keep saying we are coming to it. and then we are tx-.yond tlw
fact. ,
Dr. Souattxs. I believe the excess factor at least is two-fold in-
vohed-
Senator K>Exxarn. Ilb you think there are 45,0(x) lung cancer
casesl
Dr. So3ixexs. I doubt it, sir.
Senator fitNxtnr. You said twofold factor.
Dr. SouKt:xs. At least twofold.
Senator hExxtyn . R'el l, is it 30,060?
Dr. Somxcas. Sir, there is no way of determining it.
Senator KEx.rDr. Do you thinti it is more than 10,000?
Dr. Soatiitexs. I ima ine.
Senator }aft is more than ]0.ON. If it is more thnn
then why does not this approach make sense, that we are talkin,"
about here?
Dr. SouatcRt. The approach totax-
Senator Yes.:~fore than ](t.0(1(i people.
WhY does this not make sense, then ?
Dr. SOatMERS. Sir. because there is no animal, or other ex1Nrimentll
proof. that cigarette oondensate, which you call tar, is a producer of
cancer.
Senator ICtx\-iny. n'el1, I thought you just said that it was.
Dr. So7N11Enl+. No, sir. There has beeti no success in animal experi-
ments to produce lunF cancerc like those in Lnman beings.
Senator I:Exxtnl. Well, I have diflicultv following your lino of
reasoning there. You are prepared to say there is a given percentngc of
cancer because of tobacco, and you are prepared to say it is at least
taofold, and then when we give you one-ninth of that, and then y-on
move off that fil;ure.
Dr. Soxxtnr;. Well, sir, if I may explain, the 10,000. or wltateVcr
number of lung cancer cases, like manr other types of cancer. are in
my opinion, of unknown cause. You htire accepied cigarette smoking
a5 a cause.
The evidence, in m} opinion, does not support that.
Senator I1EocF.m-. Do you think it is a cause? One of the cause=?
Dr. Soxxr.ee. I'think it might be a cause, but I do not think it has
ever been proved.
C~°R ~°~N 0~.4~<~~

1'HIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
274 pUNFlDENTIAUTY AGREEMENL
Senator Kexxcnr. Do you, or do you not think that it is a cau.'e?
Dr. Soitstr.ac. I have ezpressed myself clearly, sir, that I do not be-
1ievc that it has becn proved a cause.
Senator htx. soy. Go ahead.
Dr. SoxxERs. ll'hen anilysis has been undertaken of:the accuracv
of a death certificate dialmnsis of lung cancer. when compared with
autopsy findings, slightl~'less than 50 psment were found to be
accurate.
Pneumonia and tumors spreading to the hings from other parts of
the body, so-called metastases, are most often mistaken for lung can-
cer. ReFrettably. we lack a sound data base bV which to establish the
true incidence of lung cancar. The figures appear exaggerated tRofold
at least.
Lung cancer is not an entity either pathologically or etiologically.
There are some 10 dif(erent varieties of lung cancer, each of which is
likelv a different disease with a different causation.
One type called oat-cell carcinoma recently was reported in nproup
of chemical workers, most of whom were nonsmokers, and it appeared
that smokers in the same plant were in some a-ay protected. Time.
scholatship, and money are needed to work out these dtfficttlt problems.
Chronic pulmonarv disease, also'called bronchitis-emph~sema. or
chronic obstructive pulmonary disease is a serious public liealth prob-
1em. R'hen a disease has several names, it is an indication that not verY
much is known about it.
Emphysema of the lungs is difficult to diagnose clinically. Also
' patholoiically it is difficult to establish its presence. type and extent.
''even when a panel of ezpertse:amines whole lung sections. These large
sections are only available in a few research centers. Experts examining
such sections. it was reported, could reach no agreement on whether.
how much and what type of emphysema was present. '
Senator HART. Doctor, excuse me just a second.
The first page of your statement, you talk about the Berkson stud..
Dr. Soxur.xs. Yes,sir.
Senator HART. Xow. what Ras the date of that Y
Dr. Soxst-Exs. It is given in the references on the last page.
Senator HAxr.1A55?
Dr. Soxxtas.1935.
Senator HART. It seems to me that much of orhat vou talk about.
thereafter, is based upon that study, is that correct T'
Dr. SoxartRS. No. nothing thereafter is based on that stud* v.
Senator HART. Page 2, paragraph 3, refers to data collected from
1919 to 1960.
You talk about the Berkt;on predictions. and so on.
I just wonder how valid that would be 20 years ago?
Dr. Soxmenc. Some 1er~ wise things were said about smoking and
health 20 years ago. Berkson simply predicted that when the fnct=
were out, or the science was impro~ed, the relationship would be a
ver} spurious artifact.
v I simply state that I feel he has been supported.
Senator H.+nr. Thank you very much.
Senator KE%.rrny. Have you done any research in this area }'ourself
recentlv i
Dr. Soxxms.'Yes. sir, the day before yeeterday.
C~°R HN 01 ~~~~'86

>u not+think that it is a cause?
lf clearly, sir, that I do not be-
en undertaken of the accuracv
g cancer, when compared with
50 percent were found to be
- the lungs from other parts of
t often mistaken for lung can-
base by which to establish~
~es appear exaggerated tRo
pathologically or etiologtcally.
f lung cancer, each of which is
causation.
cently was reported in a group
re nonsrookers, and it appeared
in some Rav protected. Time,
o,rk out these dtfficult problemsd lled bronchitis-emphrsema, or
is a serious public heilth prob-
it is an indication that not veaW-
t to diagnose clinically. Also
its presence, type ande:tent.
hole lung sections. These large
rch ceAters. Experts examining
ach no agreement on whether,
was present.
a second.
.
alk about the Berkson studA
ofthatf
ces on the last page.
nuch of whnt you talk about,
:hat correct P
is based on that study.
refers to data collected from
s. and so on.
20 years ago?
were said about smoking and
-redicted that when the facts
the relationship would be a
pported.
research in this area yourself
est erd a y.
THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
275 CONFIDENTIALITY AGREEMENT.
Senator KExrmr. Could you submit the reports? Could Nou file thF
reports? '
Dr. SouuEes. They Tsre also published in the medical literature.
Senator KENrEOr. When is the last one, and what medical literx-
ture?
Dr. SoxxERs. The laBt one that dealt*rith lung cancer specifically %
-
Senator KEN
xEDr. Yes, all right.
Dr. SoxxERs: The last one? '
Senator KEN-xmr. That is right.
Dr. Soxxcxs. In the nei ghborhood of 1958, I believe.
Senator KsNxEDr.19581
Dr. SokxExs. I believe. -
Senator KEXxEDr. R'hy have you not published in that area since
then?
Dr. SoxatEns. Sii, I have not had the material available.
Senator KExxEDY.What doyou mean by that ?
Dr. SoxxExs. I am a patholoRist, «orkinR with human autopsy. and
surgical specimens, and the hospital Rhere I have worked since that
time did not have enou- gli cases on which to base a good sttidv.
Senator FiE~N-Eay. What is the basis of vow testunom here todov?
Dr. Sostxrau:. 11fy continuing interest, and study in tlie field, and a
par on.rhich I am now working.
Enator KE. xfnr. On .rhat. on the lung ?
Dr. Sox a Exs. On t h e l unF, si r.
Senator KEN-xEDr. R'hen will it be published ?
Dr. SoxxEn.c. Sir, I anticipate within a year.
Senator KEx.Ear. But you have done no original research that has
been the basis of publication in 18 years f
Dr. SoxxExs. It ma~ betrue,sir.
Senator KE\\EDr. And you are the best fellow that the industry
could come up with?
Dr. Soxxcrtc. Sir. knowledge in the held involves reading as well as
research, and I am actively interested in the field.
As one gets older, sir, one leaves research somewhat to younger
people.
Senator HAxT. OrN`obel prize Rinners?
Senator KENxenr. I do not know how old they are.
Dr. So~txExs. If I could respond to that.
Thou- gentlemen were virologists. and so far as I know, they never
worked on lung cancer, and the last Nobel prize given for lung cancer
Ras to Fibi>'er for producing it in rats with worms-it is one of the
blots on the \ obel prize historv-
fienntor Kr.vxenr. Well, I*am sure thev will be intereiited in Your
medical evaluation of their scientific contribution.
Dr. Sna>tsRC. I know thev are xonderfol virologists.
Senator KENxmT.Of eourse, the Armed Forces Institute of Pathol-
og, which is probably the outstanding center of the world. qitite
frankly, completely agrees and supports the Surgeon t;eneral's posi-
tion. and does not support yourc.
So I think when Re are talkinR about biolog,. and pathology, that
that ought to be noted forthe record as well.
Senator HAx~r. Could I ask for a reference on a previous page. pAae i.
of your prepared statement, where you discussed the analysis of the
eccuracy of death certificatest
CTR Hh~ .~ 14 ~ ~'7

THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
276 CONFIDENTIALITY AGREEMENT.
Dr. Soxxnts. Yes, that is given-those are references number 1!
and 11, and they are cited more recently in other publications.
SenatorKirx.venr.ll'e hope you send us a copy of your paper.
Dr. SoxxLu. I will b46lad to sir.
Senator IizN xtDr. Why do we not continue ?
Dr. Soxmr.xs. May I coatinue?
SenatorKz.xmr.Please. ~
Dr. Soxxrsts. In the current limited state of knowledge, blaming
cigarettes as a cause is premature. Note that emphysema is largel~ :,
disease of white men. Black men exposed to the same encironment, ii.-
cluding cigarette smokinB, scarcely ever develop emphysema. Women
likewise are uncommonly affected. A claim that the cause of emphysenia
is known, if ancthing. tends to inhibit resea rch.
Coronary heart disease is considered the most common cause of deat!,
in the L;ntted StatEs, a8ecting particularly males, the overweight, the
diabetic, and individuals %cith certain inherited lipid diseases. T1.,
Framingham data originally publicized do not withstand critica?
evaluation.
Studies of twins discordant for smokinQ hace indicated that thr
strongest factor is evidently Renetic or constitutional. A certain l,er-
sonaltt} type has been discovered with a striving, time and pressurr
life style, evidently particularly predisposed to coronary diseases. To-
day actice researchers look elsewhere than cigarettes for the causes of
coronarc heart disease.
A decision to tax cigarettes in proportion to nicotine and'tar" would
be based on doubtful, specious or mistaken infortttation. The original
Surgeon General's report. for example, stated that nicotine is probablY
not a significant health hazard.
No new persuasive studies contradict this generally held opinion.
Etiologic conclusions based upon cigarette condensate (so-callyd
tar) suffer from the demonstration that fresh condensate free of arti-
facts of storage has cirtually no tumor producing quality.
In summary, I wish for better health for Americans. and halr
worked hard in the field for 35 cears. In my considered opinion. the
bill proposed is scientifically unjustified. and if passed. would Fener-
ate such huge sttms of mone} as would be likely to co-opt and to corrupt
most of our medical and scientific research efTort.
Thank vou.
Senotor Kexrenr. Corrupt and co-opt - and corrupt our medical
scientists.
Well, T think ecer} scientific researcher would be interested in that
statement, as well. Let me ask vou,what scientific stud,v, what publications in the la;t
five years. support your position?
Dr. Soxucxs. There are a large number of tliem. sir and I would
refer vou to the work of Dr. Philip Burch of England. In EnRlancl
there is a somewhat more open medical nress and sense of fair plav. and
his controrersy with Sir Richard Doll which is going on. includin.-
19TS. I think you will find very interesting.
Senator KixxcnY. Dr. Birch, and what is his - what is the thnist
ofhisworkf
Dr. CoxxExs. I will give you the references.
Professor -
CT R H U--if 0 1 4 77 6 6

-those are references number 10
.y in oj.her publications.
d us a cop~' of your paper.
ontinue ?
;ed state of knowledge, blaming
ote that emph%sema is largely a
sed to the same environment, in-
ver develop emph~sema. Women
laim that the cause of emphysema
resea rch.
I the most common cause of death
ularl. males, the oversreight, the
in itiherited lipid diseases. The
:ized do not withstand critical
-noking have indicated that the
:)r constitutional. A certain per-
th a striving, time and pressure,
isposed to coronary diseases. To=
than cigarettes for the causes of
rtion to nicotine and `'tar" would
taken information. The original
:, stated#hat nicotine is probably
ict this generally held opinione ziRar6tte condensate (so-called
at fresh condensate free of arti-
producing quality.
ealtli for Americans. and have
. In mY considered opinion, the -
ied. and if passed. R-ould gener-
be Iikely to co-opt and to corrupt
.rch effort.
-opt - and corrupt our medical
cher would be-inteted;tedan thftk_~,::
lv, a-hat-publications in tlu-bst-
tmber of them. sir and I would
Burch of England. In England
nress and sense of fair plar, and
.11 which is going on. including
ing.
xhat is his - Rhat is the thrnst
!rences.
X
THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
277 CONfIDENTIALITY AGREEMENT.
Senator liE~N-mr. Give me the name of the article.
lir.,oxxEtca. Oh, vrell,1 cau give you some references, sir.
That is aew jcientist, 1974. February 21 issue, and FeLruar%
issue. The 1975 is in various issues of Lancet and British Jlrlcal
Journal.
,enatorKE.NEar. Give me the name of the article.
Dr. SoxxEEns. The name of the arti$je-is "jmoking as a Cause of
"
Lung Cancer.
Senator IExxmr. All right.
Now, that is one.
ti1'bat are the others t .
Dr. SoxxERs. In respect to emphysema, in addition to the articlcs
I cited, there are a number of papers by Russell P. Sherwin. They af~-
peared in the Pathology Annual, about ly6e, and again -
Senator Iit\-xEaz. I am not asking you for lyGe, but the last five
yea rs.
Dr.SomMER6. Oh. in the pulmonary pathology seminat, published i>>
1975, there were articles by Dr. Thurlbecl and llr. Sherwin. reviei% in~
the subject, and with respect to coronarydisease, there are a nunil,er of
articles.
Senator hE-,-,Eny. Is this on efnphrsema and smoktng'
Dr. SOxMERS. Yes, sir.
SenatorliEx.,;Enr.The causal relationship between smoking and -
Dr. Soxmmas. No, it discusses emphysema as a disease in relation to
its development, and the possible causative factor.
Senator I:ExrEny. And it has discussed smoking in that. too ?
Dr. SommExs. Smoking is included in the discussion.
Senator Ii.ExxEOr. And what conclusion did thev reach %
Dr. SoxxExs. That since it is so hard to define the disease by pre,ent
methods, it ishard to implicate any factorscausinR it.
Senator Iitxxi:or. That is the conclusion of the Thurlbeck article ~
Dr. Som xERs. Of that particular article, yes.
Also. the article cited in the references here.
Senator IiE..Nmr. That is two. What other ones ?
Dr. SoxrERs. On emphysema. sir ?
Senator K.c.~zor. 1o; on lungs and cancer, and oancer of the lung.
Dr. SoxxERs. I have a pack of reference cards this thick in tny ba~.
Senator fiENvEar. \o; you are here as an expert. I am just askit~"
the last 5 vears.
Iwoula expect that you could be able to kickoff at least half a dozPii
prettv quickly. You are here as an expert witness. and you ought to
be abje to,since you have not done any research directl.,. but are relYin
on other peoples' aork.
Dr. Soat?fER:. Yes. article by Weir and Mitchell iu Cancer 1976. In
respect to carcinoma-
Senator KtxxEnr. A'hat is Weir and Mitchell's article on?
Dr. SoxuERS. The '"'eir and Mitchell article dealt R-ith.lung cancer.
and the difficulties in diagnosis and classification.
It drew the conclusion that with the little we know it would be pre-
mature to draw an etiologic conclusion. including cigarette smokin1g.
Senator hExxEnr. That it-excuse me t
Dr. SoxuExs. It would be premature to draw an etiologic conclusion
from cigarette smoking.

THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
278 AMOMMUn AGREEMENT.
Senator KxN'.%;ZDY. Would you say those are the Ieading three. or do
you want to add a couple more, just so we got the last couple, and we
hace your prime references?
Dr. Soxxm. R'ell,sir, there are a4arge number.
Senator liEx,%*soY..No; just the top.couple, that come to mind, within
the last 5 years; studies that you are relying on.
Dr. Soxxetts. In r+elation to the cigarette as a-
Senator Kt:xxto:. E:actly. That is right.
Dr. SoYxtxs. There has been cer~ recent interest in this. In term~
of the pathological lit.erature, and the epidemological literature, is re
viewed and summarized bv Professor Burch.
Senator ht.rrtnr. S1'ef1, that is the problem, you see. it seems that
you are referring to the old studies.
We asked You what the new studies that support your position-
you seem to have some difficulty in finding them, or naming them.
Dr. Somutrts. There are a number, sir.
Senator liExN-mr. Give me the. last two or three that you think are
the leading ones, in the leading medical journals in the country. that
support your position.
Dr. Soxut:aF. In my position, there is not enough that is known
about lung cancer. .
Senator Iaxxzny. Well, that supports your position thit it has not
been proved about the relationship between smoking and lung cancer.
Let me state that very definitirely. very preciselr. You say ~ou ha~~c
not done the research vourself in this area. You are relcinF on other
testimony, and other publications.
T o.r, name them.
Dr. Soxxtxs. Sir, the basis of my understanding is readin: in the
field for 40 tears, and investigations in the .field. and most diffi-utt
thinq to prove in science is a negative. But the fact that no article=
producing conclusire proof of a positive. causative efiect year aftrr
year. indtcates it perhaps does not even exist.
So.ou are asking me to prove the negative.
Senator Hatrr. Will the chairman yield ?
Senator KEx%aaT. Yes.
Senator Haxr. I think the chairman is asking the same qnection I am.
The first sentence in .our prepared remarks sa' vs You are goinL, to
review the newer scientific data. not analrze the Iack or absence. You
state vou.riil discum newer scientific data.
Now. I look over the references in your statement. there are 3
documents out of 13 that are dated 1975.
.%1r potition, frnnklr. and I think to a certain defirPr. the chnirman';
is based on the 197s HEW reports. Senator '.Nlorgan said there was morf
infnrmation than that.
We want to be procided.rith that newer information.
We are not talking about prorint?the negntire. We nrc talkina;thnut
thic new scientific data that you refer to, and some pro~~lc thic mnrnine
referred to in their testimonv.
R'e have three article" herethat have 1975 data on it.
N'on-, we are at a loss here.because there are no footnotes.
You make Fomp cdternrical asvrtinnc ahnut the state of the infnrma
tion nntl the e.idence. and list 1R articles. We do not knnn' whirh ar
ticleF--Rhich one refers to which statement. That would be helpful.
V,
CTR H~ ~~~~~~

e leading three, or do
e last couple, and NTe
come to mind, within
rest in this. In terms
.gical literature, is re-
you see, it seems that
,port your position-
or naming them.
ee that you think are
: in the country, that
nough that is known
asition that it has not
KinR and lung cancer.
el}-. You sar vou have
, are relyi.ng on other
jing is reading in the
Id. and most difficult---
! fact that no articles
itive effect year after
he same qnestion I am.
sars ~ou are ~,+oinr to
e lack or absence. You
t
tatement. there are 3
degree. the chairman's
`
-an said there was more-
ormation.
~. We nre talkinr about
-ne people thir morning
a on it. .
)o footnotes.
ne state of tlie informa-
dn not knnR which ar-
I'hat would he helpful.
THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
279 CONFIDENTIAUTY AGREEMENT.
if you would provide them. Three are dated 195;,. and then you go to
the 1960's.
1 am talking about the HE1t' report. 'Health Con:rqitense~ of
Smoking." %chere on page 15 it sav~---
Coronarj heart disease is the major cause of death in-tbe L'nited StatrS. alad
la the most Important single cause of e:ceai morulltp among cigarette en,oler-
I am referring to paRe 65, which saV--
Ctprette amoking ia the most Important cause of chronic obstructice pulmonary
dlsrase, emphfaema, and broncIIlUs.
I think it is, in a sense, with regard to this report, that we %cant
the newer scientific data whieh you have promised.
Dr. SoxxExs. In addition t,o.vhat.ras already cited there are three
papers b* v the Leuchtenbergers, orho work in tiwitzerland. they point
out that if vou use condensates, so-called tar, in their model system. it
has no relationship to the'development of abnormal changes. whicln
they regard as possibly cancerous, and if there is any part of the ciga,-
rette that might be held responsible. it is not the condensate.
Those are the three papers in 1974.
Senator H..Rr. But those are neRer than the HE11' report ?
Dr. SouxERs. Yes.
Senator HARr. June 1975 !
Dr. SoYUEx.c. Yes. If `ou will look at the reference in the HEAV
report, in certain se.ctions. about a third of them were within % Venrs
of the report, in others, about half of them within 2vcars of the report.
So the references used in that report also go back quite n nttnlber of
yea rs.
Senator HaRT. But the Assistant Secretary for Health sipied tlti~
in Tune 1975. and I presume he agreed with the conclusions then.
He would have had the benefit of the Leuchtenbergers. or N% hoever.
Dr. SowitERc. No. sir. you do not realize there is a little ln involved
between publication and receiPt of a journal in the United States. that
in abstracting, and the use of it b~ the Government.
Senator IiExxEny. In fairness. just-your point just does not hold
up.
The~ have list after list of pages of recent studies, and I.~ill just
read tl,e year. Starting-I mean just at random, on page G1. this is r,ue
of them. December 19i3. September 1972-going down. December
again. 1972.
American Nfedical Arsociation,\o.emberof lA;?.1Iost of these ref-
erence-~--\farch of 1973. Jfarch of 1973. INfai v of 1A73..Tust taking, otie
nace. And this is 1974 report. There is not one that is before 1Q7 1.
Dr. SOxaERc.1 es. sir, but I referred to the 1975 report.
Cenator I:ExxT.nr. "'ho does Dr. Burch work for ?
Dr. Snu.rr:Rs. He is at the t'niversity of Leeclr.
Senator fiExxEny. Is he a consultant over there f(ir nm organiza-
tion4
Dr. SoatvERE. He statea in one of hif- articles. to answer ohwinu~
questions, he is, \o. 1. not a smoker: and No. 3. not in the pov nf the
tobacco industn-.
Senator KEN-xmT. Ofi.
f The prepared statement of Dr. Sommers and supplemental letter
follow:)
CTR HN 014"791

THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
DONFIDENTIAUTY AGREEMENT.
1(y purpose, in response to the inv4ation to pre'sent ap perscn a: vie,
of the status of knowledge of smoking and health, is to revirw ::._
nwer scientific data. This material is not included in the q~ctat:::.=
frow thr 1973 vers16n of the USPHS Saroking and Hea;th rercr: c:te:
Senator Hart as justifying Bill flo. S 2902. CoPni:ar.ce of the rre:e--
day knowledge by fairminded individuals casts grave douC; or. :'.e
existence of any such 'overwhelming evidence' as -:ained by tne
I am Sheldon C. Soeters, k.D., Direetor of Labora:ories, Lencx r:::
Hospital, New York; Clinical Professor of Pathology, Coluabia U:.iv.
College of Physicians & Surgeonq, New York, aad Univ. of Sou:ne -.
California, Los Arigeles; editor of the Pathology Arvwa: and Pa:.".o:ag.
Decennial series; Chairman of the Scientific Advisory Bcard, Co zr.c'_:
for Tobacco Research, U.S.A., Inc; with about 260 pub a=atior.s.
curriculum vitae and publication list are available.
First, in respect to the reported overall higher dea:- rates c''
smokers than no:rsaokers, the results were obtained by statist:=a:
epidemiologic methods now recognized as erroneous ar.j use of is
no longer regarded as Justified. One to one comparisor.s of s:.:te:s
and non-amokers ignored mary confounding variables. As berxs:-. :_
dicted the result ;roved to be a statistical artefact. :...r res:::e_
f: x+ igr.oring three serious sources of error:
(1) Nonrandoa comparisons, sx aning that smokers and non-scokers a,e
CTR (~~~ 0 14~t='~~

.
.tion to present rky personal view
; and health, is to review the
is not included in the quotations
ioki n: and Healt` re'.ort cited by
i290,- Cognizar.ce of the present
,:s casts grave doubt on the
:vidence' as ::aimed by the dis-
:or of i.abora:ories, Lenox Hil:
Dr of Pa:hology, Columbia Univ.
e York, aad Univ. of souther.^n
he Patholopr Annual and Pathology.
ientific Advisory Boarty Council
ith afu: 260 publications.'
: are available.
era a higher deatt rates of
: were obtained by statistica:
~. as erroneous and use of which is
le to one comparisor.s of smokers
iding variables. AsBerRson pre- .
I:istical artefact..;.'t;ir resuited
of error:
:hat smokers and non-saOkers are
-2-
;~: .°?f ' ` .
281
THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
CONfIDENTIALITY AGREEMENT.
not randcro subsetS of the population being testFd. Smokers ch=se
to smoke and others choose not to fmoke, and both groups are se:f-
selected, apparent:y by complex processes not presently unders:oo:.
The crucial error is the use of statistical methods to test nc-.-
random groups, desigried for and applicable only to comparinb
groups. Ro11inQ the loaded dice statistically gives arn ir.va-:'
answer.
(2) Dependence on limited statistical ttsts for proof. INher. Rose a.d
Bell wrote their monograph on predicting longevity, they tes:e:
factors that might be associated with early death among a gro,:; cr
Boston MW II veterans, followed careiLlly, for 30 years. A one-to-
one comparison of cigarette smokers and non-smokers gave smok:ri
the nuAber one place as a predictor, like in mary other studies.
However, when multiple factors were included statistically, cigare-:e
smoking dropped to somewhere beyond the 30th most significar.: Yre-
dictor of early death. Dissatisfaction with job becaWe the nu.:`-er
one predictor.
(3) Secularity, meaning the change in habit patterns of the poplla:::-.
from about 1910 to 1960, with increased proportions of cigare::e
smokers in each decade. A model population (not a real popula:`_on;
with such changes over equal time will show a statistically signif-
icant increase in total death rate as a minority changes torart
a majority. This secularity factor or change in population pa::e:-.s
has no health implication. For example, in the original Surge=-
General's Report a table sho.ed pipe smokers to have a lower death
rate (0.8) than non-smokers. While encouraging a belief that pipe
10.011 0 - 76 is
Y:.+.--.A-Xm0s
CTR HN 014,179-.~

282
THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
-3- CONFIDENTIALITY AGREEMENT.
smokers were the 'sturdiest humans, better e:planation would be
the secularity affect. There were fe.er pipe smokers in ea:h
decade, the converse of ciprette smokers.
These data are published and available for all to read. Why have the
proposers of the,bill not heard of them? It is because the annual
supplements to the Surgeon General's Report on Smokir4; and Health are
linited reviews and interpretations of the medical and scientific
literature, from which are screened out articles that do not agree with,
call into question, or destroy arguments and conclusions supportive
of the official government position.
Aa an aYample, in a presentation prepared for hearings on a proposal
by Sen. lfoss (Utah) " liait by law the smounts o!' nicotine and con-
densate (so-called tar) in cigarettes, I pointed out in 1972 that ap-
proximately 1790 articles published since 1960 were not cited. Lists
of these ere supplied.
On occasion, publications not supportinQ the official position have
been suppressed. The epidemioloQic problems, shortcomings and errors
fere aired at a panel sectinY of the AAAS in 1971, so the above is not
secret information. One regrets that the proposers of the bill have
not been sude aware of the serious defects, obsolescence, bias and
incompleteness of the information on which they appear to base the
current proposed bill.
liow as to lung cancer, there is a statistical association between cij-
arette asoking and lung cancer. But at present the nature of the
CTR HN 01417c.-14

a better explanation would be
feser pipe smokers In each
smokers.
for all to read. Why have the
s' It is because the annual
eport on Smoking and Health are
the medical and scientific
t articles that do not agree with,
ts ard conclusions supportive
red for bearings on a proposal
e amounts of nicotine and oW
I pointed out In 7972 that ap-
nce 1960 .ert tat cited. Lists
.nQ the official position have
oblems, shortcomings and errors
1 tAA.S in 1971, so the above is not
the proposers of the bill have
'eets, obsolescence, bias and"-
rhich they appear to.base the
tistical association between cig-
at present the nature of the
283
-<-
THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
CONFIDENTIALITY AGREEMENT.
association or whether it is causal are not kno.n. The text of ae
original Surgeon GeneYal's report deal# with the difficulties cf
assigning causality, but the utmrry and conclusions brush these aside,
and assign a causality not demonstrably evident in the text. It is
widely known that a stitistical association is not by Itself proof
of causation. A statistical association may point to ezperixr,:s
that will help to determine whether there is cause involved.
Animal experiments to apr knowledge have not succeeded In the production
of so.called human type lung cancers (pathologically termed
sq_s-a~s
cell earcinoaxs) in a sianificant percentage of any species tested.
This includes inbred &lce erposed to heavy cigarette saoke fnhalaa cr.
over practically their entire lifespan. Certain false alarms like
the Auerbach beagle dogs, and other studies of rats and itiice, have
stirred hope that a model had been achieved, but no cancers that grew,
spread and led to death like human squamous cell lung carcinocas have
been reported. After 45 years of inhalation research, and a::hocg=
expensive efforts continue, no success has been achieved ir, ;rod ci^g
experimental lung ca.ncers in any reasonable or even small n.unbers of
experimental anima:s.
Skin painting is cited in the bill proposal as part of the evidence c'
carcinogenicity of tobacco smoke condensates. Suffice to say that in
the past 5 years, skin painting of anisnls with tobacco condensate has
yielded so fe+ tumors, either benign or an lignant, that the practice
has practically been given up. Only a few governmental agency erperixe-.:s
continue. Why tumors were produced ye:rs ago following skin pai^tir.g
CTR ~~~~ ~~~r~~~
~

TNIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO ~
QONFIDENTIALJTI( AGREEMENT.
.
~
but are now rarely produced is unkno.m. M English book reviev of a
work on tobacco and carcinoWesis stated that if in the 19511's the
author had not reported «S skin tumors .hen other laboratories were
I
finding 3 to 5S, this field of research might have developed in a I
I
more orderly .ay. ~
~
On what basis is the claim made of 90,000 lung cancer cases per year?
It is based on death certificates, which are not scientific doc.inen:s,
and in general are not corrected by findings if an autopsy is performe!.
'rhen analysis has been undertaken of the accuracy of a death certificate
diagnosis of lung cancer, when compared with autopsy findings, slight?y
less than 50 percent were found to be accurate. Pneumonia and tuaors
spreading to the lungs from other parts of the body, so-called metastases.
are most often mistaken for lung cancer. Regrettably we lack a scur.d
data base by which to establish the true incidence of lurg cancer. :he
figures appear exaggerated two-fold at least.
Lung cancer is not an entity either pathologically or etiologically.
There are some 10 different varieties of lung cancer, each of .hich is
likely a different disease with a different causation. One type called
oat-cell carcinoma recently was reported in a group of chemical workers
s»st of whom were non-ss»kers, and it appeared that smokers in the sa.:.e
plant were in some .ay protected. Time, scholarship, and money are
needed to work out these difficult problesss.
Chronic pulmonary disease, also called bronchitis-eophysema or chronic
obstructive pulmonary distase, is a serious public health problem. Whe-.
CTR HN 0 147`96
I

. An English book revie of a
ted that if in the 1930's the
s .her, other laboratories were
h a:ght have developed in a
D,,)J lung cancer cases per year?
ch are not sci" fic documents,
ndings if an autopsy is performed.
he accuracy of a death certificate
j with autopsy findings, slight'_9
accurate. Pneumenia and tumois
s of the body, so-called srotastases,
.. Regrettably we lack a sound
je incidence of lung cancer. The
least.
thoiogically or etiologically.
',Df lung cancer, each of which is
erent causation. One type called
`
ed in a group of chemical workers
appeared that smokers in the same
e, scholarship, and money are
blems.
bror.chitis-emphysana or chronic
rious public health problem. r'hen
285
THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
-6- CONFIDENTIAUTY AGREEMENT.
a disease has several names, it is an+[ndicatlon that not very much :s
knom about it. Dnphysema of the lungn is difficult to diagnose
clinically. Also pathologically it is difficult to establish its
presence, type and exteat, even when a panel of experts examines w.'.c_e
lurtY sections. These large sections are only available in a few re-
search centers. Experts examining such sections, it was repor:ed,
could reach no agreement on whether, how much and what type of e.:,`,v-
sema was present.
In the current limited state of lmowledge, blaming cigarettes as a
cause is premature. Note that emphysems is largely a disease of .:`_:e
aen. Blcak men exposed to the same environment including cigarette
smoking, scarcely ever develop esrphysesv. Women likewise are uncocr=-.:;
affected. 3luch investigation, including animel models, Is needed. A
claim that the cause of amphysema is 3mo.n, if anything, tends :_ _-.-
hibit research.
Coronary heart disease is considered the most coamon cause of dea:. :-.
the U.S., affecting particularly msles, the over.eight, the diabea :.
and individuals with certain inherited lipid diseases. The Framingna
data originally publicized do not withstand critical evaluation. S:ui'_e_
of twins discordant for smoking have indicated that the strongest
factor is evidently genetic or constitutionol. A certain persoraii:;
type haa been discovered with a striving, time and pressure life s:y:e,
evidently particularly predisposed to coronary disease. Today ac:ive
researchers look elsewhere than cigarettes for the causes of coronary
heart disease.

286 THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
. GdFlDENTIAUTY AGREEMENT.
_7_
.
A decision to tax cigarettes in proportion to nicotine and 'tar' .ou:d
De based on douDtful, specious or mistaken inform.tion. The orig:r.a:
Surgeon General's report,.for e:aiaple stated that nicotine is proba::y
not a significant health hazard. No new persuasive studies con;rad:c:
this generally heldopinion. Ftiologic conclusions based uporn ciga-
V rette condensate (so-called 'tar') suffer from the demonstratiorn t`.a:
fresh condensate free of artefacts of storage has virtually no t=cr
producing quality.
In suaraary, I aish for Detter health for Americans, and have*.orie:
Aardin the field for 35 years. In sd considered opinion the Di:i pro-
posed is scientifically unjustified, and if passed would generate suc':
Duge sums of money as would be likely to coopt and to corrupt eos: cf
our medical and scientific research effort.
, ~
JtvE .J
CTR HN 0147"96

287 THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
ODNfIDENTIAUTY AGREEMENT.
, I ReCerenc^s
on to nicotine and 'tar' would
1.
Berkson, J. Proc. 9taff Geetin s IRav
Clin. 30 (15): 319-3t4
:en informstion. The original (27 July 1953 at stica tudy o
" Assoc:atTon between SaoR:rg
and Lung Cancer. -
.ated that nicotine !s probably
2.
DeFaire, U.,'Friberg, L. and Lundmen,
T. Prever.:. Ne:.-< (<):
dies contradict
t
i 509-17 (Dec. 1975). "Concordrnce for lbrta.:t-" y a:. Syecia'_
ve s
u
persuas Reference to IsebeatdHeart Disease and Cerebrovascular Disease."
concluslons based upon ciga-
3.
DeFaire, U. Acta. Med. Scand. Suppl. 568. Stockho?n 1975.
r from the deaonstration that 1C9 pp. "Ischenic heart isease in Death Discordan: T.ins.'
L. Friedman, Y. and Rosenaan, R.H. Ty~e A Behavior ar.: Your Hea-:.
arage has virtually no tumor A.A. Xnopf, Inc. New York 1974, 2 pp
5.
Americans, and have worked
6.
onsidered opinion the bill pro-
if passed would generate sueh
7.
coopt and to corrupt most of
8.
rt.
!.~
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
Hammond, E.C., Auerbach, 0., Xirmaa, D: and Garfinkel, L.
-Arch Enviror,. Health 21 (6); 7G0-68 (Dec. 1970). "Effects of
ir:Qarette Y.ing or. ogs." .
Kreyberg, L. Histolorical T~2ina of Ltuyt Tta+ors. Internationa:
Aistological C assi.icaaor. o ureors, . Wor1d Fiealth
Crganization, Geneva, 1967, 28 pp.
Passey, P..D. Nature 219: 98-99 (6 July 1968) "Tobacco and
Tobacco Sanke tT~ ud~s7_n Erperisxntal Carcinogenesis."
Rose, C.L. and Bell, B. Predicti Lon evi: . D.C. Hea:h &
Co. Le:ing`tor., Mass. 1971. , pp
Roser.blatt, 11.8., Lisa, J.P.., Teng, P. and Beck, I. Bu!1. !;.v.
Acaj Ked. <S (6): S19-S27 (June 1969) "Validi:y of
r, Sta."
Rcserblatt, )L B.. Teng, P.K. and Kerpe, S. ProF. in Clin Ca-.t--
Vo:. 5, y; 71-8J. I.):. Arie1 Ed. Grune 8 Stratton, In--- ~~
"DiaFnostic Accuracy In Cancer as Deternined by Post Lortem Exar-
ination."
Roser.tla:t, M.B., TenQ, P., Kerpe, S. and Beck, I. Iled. Counterx'.-.:
(10): S}S9 (Oct. 1971) "Prevalence of Lung Cancer."
Thurlbeck, 1P.11., Anderson, A.E., Janis, L., IU tchell, R.S.,
Pratt, P., Restrepo, C., Ryan, S.F. and Vincent. T. A.^. Rev.
Rcao. Dis. 98: 217-228 (1968) "A Cooperative Stuuy o''er;a::.
ST-ea`rexr.aof Eay2tiysena."
Keiss, W. and Boucot, X.R. J. Air. 1bd Assoc. 21.1 (11 ): 113?-1::2
(15 Dec. 1975). "The Respiratory f ects o Cno ormett;;l lAethy:
Ether."
CTR HN 0 1479- 9

288
2/U t tUlA1/ .1 TA t
W1... C. t..-"rs, lt. P.
.
Mrn: J.111, 111S . 2.Mts.pelit, lVle.a IF
tNrrtN: lf..rlae f. 1943. tftek. Srlua, 11. eltltre.
/o*+srt C411ete. 1937. evn lav.s. ~
It. D brveN ItNicei iclrel, 11061. am 1tnN.
THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
OONFIDENTIAUTY AGREEMENT.
IUttn: Clisaje Dsiv.rctty Citales, 1N1-1f~2
4sttl.et vettl.st aN ltetitsnt~l. lstlelepr, t6.r tS{1W Deaesnsra Uttttal, t.eten, 1ti6-tp
Yatstaa Daitent t. lsthelep, /Tee Ibqltal ter 61a.e., breekllee, Mcu. 1944
4sttte.t Ltilset to tstMlet7. Deatab 1>in{-la 16atvttal, Uettee, lfta-+.1
Wtte+t is lsthetegy. Daery terl Moqltcl, Detrelt, 1K6-S0
haneas Nart Certtttca;e le t.tbe1ep (Cllouet Pathology - Psehelettc Aaaeq), 1950
4eselats I attrl.tlat, Hev t.tlrt Dascoaat 16wtttal. Locten, 1l30-3)
Ystetatt tatJtele6let, Lrvart Creer Cealuten, )watea, 1630-5)
fatAelegist, Ilattactnt.etca tte.ortsl teqtalt, {eecen, 1f3)-61
ZaWlepet, ftriPp 16trorlsl Metpltal, La Jo1ls, Celtt.rnia, 1f61-6)
Ns.elata frirecter .t Nletstoriss, lraaets Ge1.11e1d &ottital, ttw Yetk, 1163-67;
Krect.r, 1667-N '
' Kr.ecsr .t l.Wtatirles, l..os Rtll W1tta1, t.r T.rk, 116A -
Nslsttat to tstMlep, Lar.arl IWical scseel, 1fH-43, l.atrvcter tt tathelep, 1350-52,
Yeectate 1. tathelep, 1652-3), l..ctvrsr ln Nthelen, 11Y.-61.
4soefats lrotessor ot )atl.eled, leetee Oalvedlt7 icEeel of Ilet1efne, {ettet 161)-61
C1Wea1 ttetstaer .t 1aWlop., Dalv.rettT .t Ntltn Cellferola tcAeol et 11Ntctne,
Let 4{elte, 1f62- A.a.etate tratet.or et fatlwlsp, taea)ta O.Sv.rtltl. Callete ef @kytlctaea .
Sateana, t. 1
1f6)-N63, tnfesser .t 1aUeleO, 1163-M, Clteteel trefeaser of tatholop, 1361 -
Ceptsi.. tlNitel Cor1, D.tteN Ststet Art.T, 11M)-1fi6
tltlvsr ttar, Dr.eat Itsr, Creta lt Cwrrt aaV )resl.rtitl Detlt Citatton
b.v Terk CwntT IWieal feeiet7. f.T.
A.ericee Asseclstlw ot tatNletiets .N Mtteriol.jisu
C.llete et Asserlten pstheletictc
.eriteo tecutr .t Clt.icel Pathology
The Mlatechsltal feetetl
herlea fostetT of [slerit.tetsl letlrlep ,
tMV tna1.M Csncer seelet7 -
Mw RwtlaM Society .t tathele{ictt; prstldett, 1fS3-60
latnutlenal Aea1a.7 et ratMlep
INeratel iecletlet ter tqert.e.cd tflel.p and MMttlw
[ev Yerk Aealeny et Nediclne
t/e., Terk fsatr+7 of utence .
Mtv Terk tatheletleal Society: feeretary 1161-1772
Nlter. fathelelr Aneral. 11s6 - cd,ln . t. 7.1t.
Lltterlal NarJc: Aacrto.n J. et Therapa,tlet .d Cltnitsl leqertt ~
ieleattflc AJrisery AeaT.: Cevncll ter Tdxce tetsatsh N67- ; letearek Directer 1f6e-'
Artatt Cancer Tatk reree (ratheler.7 Wrkln; t-re.y), K1, 1061-1116
Cli.itA1 LaUeratM Mdserl Cse.lttre, D.1. fcAts PttArt.ent t Itea.lth, 111).
,-...' TR t iN 014800

~..
yleN Ceaewee. Mpitel, Mrt.e. 1Uet-f.t
b.e., broeklise, /tert. leri
qltel. Ntt.e, 19ttJ9
. 1tt9-so
,cSel.p ratlrletie Aaateey). 1930
1910-1)
.etw, 1910-11
x, 191)-61
,llfer~ie, 1961-61
.d ~e.rsut. rer ml, 1N)-67;
-
lert, 1961
4-N, Iatrnct.r ie raUelep, 1930-33,
71q., 193t.-61.
Sebeel of Madlttae. Metw 193)-61
kerf Califsraia Ssb+l af eWtclaa,
;7. t.llete f rtrrr/ttene & rrteeee. s. 1
:e1 rrefett.r ef ratlrl.p, 1966 -
1.tta1 Catt cit.ti.m
tieu
/
/-60
4c,.1 f,ca..~ :C7i'
~ :llnital terort.
- 11947- 74t-197{. tttt.etA MfKtef 1Mf.
1 h
Kl
Y"rt-t ef 1wl tA. 1971.
I
~9 THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
CONFIDENTIAUTY AGREEMENT.
LE~ OX HILL HOSPITAL
'N taa7 7t7 4,411, / .t0 r0ee. .et/.
'
rie.rcb 9. 1976
Soo. Saaator fdrard M. [amn.d7,
Chair~an, Subcotaictoe on
public tl.alth
Co~ittee on l.bor 6 public Welfare
DU.S. Seaate
Yaab.iagtoo, D.C.
Dear Seaator [.aoad7:
Io reapect to tbe b.oarins on S 2902, so lebruary 19, 1976. I
vou.ld respectfully raouast to Wo oacee additions to and eorrectione
of ty teatiaooy.
lasardia4 tDe e.ident tisunderataodin& about trbether or eot I
bad publiehed on the uusation of lung cancer recently, aay I noce 8
additional personal publicatiow !o the yura 1962-1973 and one nw
in press that deal 1a part or vbo11y with tbe calls of origin, the
grovth, t6s spacial borwooal activities and other futuree of lung
cancer that ma7 aid in ita diagnosia, maaage.ant and thus a better
basic uaderetaodia{ of the disaase processes. Lferencea are appended,
including d p.p.re written vith Dr. /{arjorie J. Yilliaas, present
chief of patholop , VA t)entral Office, YaabinSton. Also appended le e.publiutioo list.
If it aee.ed to appear fro. trY teetiarooy that I had contrlbuced
littls to discovering the cauae of lung cancer, perhaps that u y be
erplained by the difficulty of uaderstandinS this .yaterioue dieease.
Dr. AleLOder Laddov, a faewua lritiah tancer ruearcher, vae quoted
as sa7inj be would not choose luaS cancer ae a research topic because
it vas too co.plicated. luman eodo.etrial carciaotaa, breast cancer
and reoovaocular btpertaoaioo are aow other dia ueee to the knwledte
of which I balie.e I bave tade aignifitaot contribution.
In regard to the inquiry concerning nev publications that tend to
support the vieve I aprused, I append a list of ever 70 euch aciene-
ific and .ediul publiutiow in 1975.
So.e corractiow to tbe transcript of ty teatiaooy are also
ntb.itted.
Ci R i i i i 014801

1ea. ts.cor Llv.re K. L.cs.ey
THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
290 CONFIDENTiAUTY AGREEMENT.
IF
I r.quaat that thi. l.tt.r sod it tt.-bm-ot. 1. ..d. .p.rt of
tha b.rina record by ia..rtioo at t6e clooe ot et t.attaooy.
4rP.cttully svbaittod,
ilrldoo C. toi.r., tt.D.
DYr.ctor of Lbor.tori..
r
fC3:r
sc:(1)~a.oo.l lan{ ~oDliutien.
(2)yuDlie.tloo list
()).ddittooal tatorwe.a
(0cerr.ctieam of ttmcript
eetltr. lber.e Lon.&". ?r.a., Sobaeu Ia.tit.t.
t1' TRt iN 014802

~ ~' ` - 1: ~t c%~~,ri `
-i `3
.,
--- --- - ~
.
1. IK111ae, tt.J. ead 1.C.-fam.r.. C.acer. 1942, P, 109.
2. Yillir, M.J., l.l. l.rsa eed S.C. {a..rre. Dla. Csa.c, 1963. 4A. 93.
3. 6/i11lr. Y.J. e:/ fanr.rr.. A.. J. ri.d. Le1., 19dJ, 247. 422.
d. l.med7. J.1., r.J. trut.... cmd S.C. ,om.re
Im
latl
160
1964 90
.
.
.,
,
, .
d.
7. Oou1d. I.t., 1. Uae1 aad S.C. fa..era. Caeeer, 1971, 1/, 426.
Teraai.t., J.A., S.C. fm.ar eed 1. Indera.oe. lal. Iar.at.. 1972.
26.
127.
S. larn, S.C. fatloMelop desn.l, 1973. ypletoa, 1.T., 1.109.
TNIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
291 CONFIDENTIALlTY AGREEMENT.
CTR 1iN 01T80..J+

THiS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
292 L'ANFIDENTIAUTY AGREEMENL
9
roussls>a 4tT1CUs
nayoo C. r~r., M.D.
1. lacoaa, l.L. ml tea.r., t.C.: Tfa specificity ot forvlitad prot.tn..
l. Iam+eol. 34: 3)1-3i1, 1937.
2. N.ak.ta, *V., Lsdi.b, NJ,, aad toe,.r., f.C.: Loukec7to.ta pro.otint
factor t. taflawrtory aradatN of aos. 4rob. PatL., 33: 18A-192, 1942.
73. UCot4ta, p.M., fa..ara, S.C. and Lathrop, p.D.: T%moor of earotid body
tTp. ariat&& ta the dddla ur. IrcL. Path.. 4l: 71-l1, 1967.
4. Varr.o, t. and t aa.ara, f.C.: Cltattidms aotaritta (r.gtooal il.tcta) a.
a patholeac oetity. Am. l. patL., 34: 173-501, 1948.
S. Yorrse, S. a.1 iommera, t.C.t Ciaet coll fatla.ioea la eitatrialy .ncarici..
lroc. toe. tioar. {te1. 4 tlod., : "1-"3, 1941.
6. ifarren, t. ssd io..ara, f.C.: pat3otamaata of alc.rati.e colltt.. A.. l.
path., 23: 6S7-i39, 1949.
7. fortig, 1.T. a+ed fc.:ara, i.C.: C.e.alL of oodoaotrial tarciao.a. I. ftudy
t prior b1op.to.. C.ec.r, 2: 91i-936, 1949.
. sastrs. t.C., farttl. ..T. and f.aslefr, ..: Coe.ata of atdo.atrtal
aarelaa.a. II. Cases 19 to 33 yoara old. Ca.err, 2: 957-943, 1949.
9. 1S.rt1g, 1.T., forar., l.C. a.d 1.e{loff, 1.: C.ooais of .odwtrial
carctna.a. 111. Careim.a !a .itu. Caucar, 2: 9K-971, 19i9.
10. tommar., t.C., L..loy. T.l, and Mrttj, A.?.: A atoA7 of the placocta
to pr.paae7 traatad by tllboatrol. 6.. l. OMt. i CTnoc., $a: 1010,
1949.
11. liarr.a, s. .nd se...r., s.C.: Trotoolysta ta tatoatinal di.aua.
Caatrooatorolop, 14: 322-32t, 1950.
12. Yyatt, l.p. sd ie~r., t.C.: Clronie martwr lailor., walo.claro.is
and aasra.dnllarT lematopolqL. llood. 3: 329-3t7, 1950.
13. 1ut.aeor, Y,A. o.d ic...ra, f.C.e pootpartra aado..trial h7porplasia
ia dias.tiea tr.atad v1th .tlll.atrol and pruSa.tarooa. l. Clin.
lmdecrL.o1., 10: 601-609, 1950.
14. tc...ra. S.C. and loAe.on, l.lt.: Coftaoital trieaapid atraata. A.. Naart
l., 41: 130-143. 1931.
VTR[ i i T 014804
1
I

rop, 1,D.: lusor of carotid 1~od)
atb., 44: 7e-el. 1947.
tiag sotartttU (r.tioeal tlattts) a.
475-501, 1961.
ll taclu.toos t elcatrtstaS smtaritis.
J63. 1968.
t.ts of olcsrati.o colitis. Jr. J.
r of afraootrtal cartittort. 1- stud)
1949.
t!, l.t Ooesis of .edassttial
1. C.soor, 2s 9S_7-96), 1l69.
't. 1.: Oo..ets of o.dsstrt.l
:at, 2: 9i6-971, 1949.
. ..T.yA .tsrdy of tbs plae.ata
a. J. Oist. h Cyasc.. 51: 1010.
;i1 is istartlLl dil..WS.
.arrov tailurs, .Taloselort»ia
329-347, 1930.
,artvs ss+dortrial My"rPlaaia
ed proS a t o rooo ...1. C 11s .
,ital tri.eorrtd att.sla. Ji. 91wrt
THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
23 CONFIDENTIALITY AGREEMENT,
1!. to>.rs, S.C.. Vilaoa. J.C. and S.rtnan. I.V.: L}sepEoid la.ionc se
pltosrl%.litls. J. =qar. M.d., 93: S0S-512, 1931.
16. Varraa, S., iolt; M.V, and Se.rers, S.C-: $006 aarl7 t.+clsrr afl-te
of iooistn{ radiatioo. Proc. Soc. ftap.r.-stel. 6%ad.. 77: 2td-291, 1951.
17. l+olt, M.V.. So.sr.; S.C. and Varron, y: 77.paratioo of tia.ue soctiona
for putttsti.e ldstot:b.dral itndiu. Aaat. S.oc., 112: 177-166, 1952.
16. {aamats, S.C. asd Tslob, .: 0.arian atroaal bypsrylaaia 'ln braaat caacer.
Arch. Tatb., S): 160-166, 1932.
19. Varram, S., folt, 11.V, d saOWr., t.C,: Sor cYtolofie aad biatocbr..tea1
str.di.a ef radiati.ri raaetioe. 1.. J. Clta. Tatb., 22: 411-417, 1952.
20. . 11Gtanu, S.C. aed Sett..rs, S.C.: lraa.t caacar prognosis and ovariso
eortical strorl 1n.r*laala. Swr Lt{. J. lud, 246: S90-S92, 1932.
21.
Sorts, S.C. .ad Torey, T.L.: Oaypbil pratb)rroid adaowaa, A.. J. )'acT.,
16: 673-689, 1951.
22. Ildwards, J.L. nsd Sowsrs. S.C.: ladiatton r.aettooa te parabtotic rats.
J. Lab. md C1ta. ri.d., 40: 342-354, 1951.
23. CAata, II.M. sad Sw.ats, S.C.: ilmolrtic dis w a and po17eytbssfa io
pataDiosis tatattcattae. 11ood. 7: 1005-1016, 1952.
24. 9lollsedar, d.. and Serm.rs, S.C.: Lqroatws laprosy. 1.v iat. J: ri.d.,
247: 634, 1952.
2S. ChrisNnsaa, Y.t., taefers, S.C. teed fruuldtt,&. C.[.: lffoct of soft
to.ntSes rays es tsa tabbit skis, 1.. J. iocmttemol., 63: i01-l06, 1932.
26. 1 eonssrs, S.C., Ci+uta, t.ll. d V.rr.m, S.: Y.t,rotranaplantatfoo of
h,aan eaacar. I. Irrodtatod rats. Coecsr 1los 12: 909-911, 1952.
16A. Capta, S.1/. snd Se..etrs, S.C. and Varreo, S: Saterotranrplantatioo of
ata.n aancar. 1'I: ltrsts ekaak poueb. Canest. f.ta., 12: 912-911 , 1952.
261. Sor,ars, S.C., i¢Ili.aa, l.A. and Varran. S.: ll,tatotrsnaplantetion of
b:.an eemcat. III. Cboriosllaatoie soa.Draaas of n.Eryoo.tsd . as. Cancer
taa., 12: 911-917, 1952.
CTR HN 014805

THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
294 CONFIDENTIAUTY AGREEMENT,
~
27'r lrtan~. Yi.7:. Yltetae,.I: sad le.a.ra. I:C.s IYnt+tamaa etpylexfr4l
aatarltta after aati3tstte tlorey. 1epoct at ta.e esoa, A.. ~~ ttlett.
Ott., 20: fi-73, 113i.
23. tewneara, 3,C, sad Ikl:awa, t,Ort Jlr1tt3jq ateaala.l trem a[ atta
aM Latereal ort.ea. Caaeor, 6: 317-l3l,'1133.
29. $em.re, t,C:, Iurt.r.eo. L-It, and tiarree.~19.t ia....et awlra.ee to
c1:re.tc ioaatta.l d1M4.a. 1a1. Lv.a., lt t23-Z26, 1133.
30. vat.tteld, t.0, aN loearta, f,C:t latal tir.b ruwa otyhyleceeul
.storittt La twrytcal 7.tteeta. Ye. ssrs., 1u: Y.f-232, 1953.
31. Ytlt..ua, t.,C, ad ia..rra. S,C.t ttptetea.ee et j..trtc ply"
:ete.yam7tag easear. Ma. J, Cllo. ht\., 23: 716.737, 1953.
32. tamara, t.C,t Ovartm 4te CTta. 1.. .7, htti., 71: SS-t3l, 1953.
33. fmsare, S.C.: Wocrtre elaegee after ltitalNraa.loeteary sad tatal
lody irradtattea La para/tettc ratt. J. Ir1. i Clta. Yrd., ii: 3f4-407,
1933.
34. tolt, 1t.Y osere, t,C, a.d ttetroe, ,t Ltraeocle.r eb"aa reaaltiea
tres aqoeare to toelattg radtattea aa dotKted ta trosoa-drted
ptparatleu. Lef. I+v.et., 3: o0"11, 1333.
33. ltratt, t,C OtTr. 1.{, a.d Cbto, 1,t,: 3rtoradtalraplle sreentc
leealitettoe la adult aad aulr7a.ie pttb.itt, a" eoaa.otive tlaau..
lr.c. 3oe. 1441. tol. 4 trd Mi M-23f, 1953.
36. taetrra, S.C., lolai, 1,/v, a.t Ce11ra, C.t Ovvtan iatlw.ee tyen
wr.tval ta braa.t e.eeK. Areh, i:as., 67: f16-11f, 1933.
37. tatarra, t,C. W Ca.6ard. 0,lyt Caacar sesestated vttb ovartae rtra.al
!»eryluta. t,rel. rate.. 33: 6l-4i3, 103.
33. Yart.e, t. a.d /e:a.art, f,C.: lhtlolop of roCWaal iletttt sad ulecrattve
eelttit. J. Aa. M.d. Aa.oc., 1SA: 1H-113, 1954.
39. Adeaoe, M,11 .1r, aed tmo.re, i,C,t ddartrtal oeettteattee,. A.. .7.
Obat. sad 07r.ee., 67: 1a7-1f0. 1134.
10. Cbute. t.tt,. Laotea. t.t. md jamta, 3.C,t A larorator7 o3lde.te of
t.:eaa-ty" teb.reale.U Lbaootera. M. .7, Clta. Path., I4: tt1-221,
1lM.
1. Ihrelal-3eJaa, 1.I a.A toaara, .C.t ailtar.attat.d esooortdersotd
tr.ota of aa1tta7 {leada. Arch. Otelerymo.. 31s 133-140. 1954.
CTR i[N 014806

J,
tyGyj lt.tjbraoea. tarlar1KK41
rprr af ao waa, I+. ~ ftsaat.
1ot1 atMat..I e.at.cKa af alfa
1. 1933.
t.. ~.t 11aa.r.t t.riraaaa ta
223-226. 1953.
~l ...irasow ataytr7lececcal
tort, 1w 3t9-2S2, 1953.
;tea.ca of taatrts ve17M
,. . 23: 74 6-737. 1933.
J, ratf.. 29: t3)-L1S9. 19s3.
\atttdre.aloetas7 aed total
1. W. 6 Cita. YN., 24: 39"7,
:,t i.traeocioar cWgu rar.ltlr4
datactN la trMtb-ditad
1953.
:,1, t M t or ad t avarlta ar o aa tc
.tloltm aftd aa.rett.a tLaaW.
..tH, 1937.
p,j 'O."ta. tatl.e.oa .P-
7t 916-919, 1953.
/
..axtatad vith wartae aro.al
1933.
e[ rqtoa.l tlattta asl learatt..
93. 1934.
adartrial etrtftcatto.. A.,' J.
i l,C,: A 1alotatery aptdo.tt of
~ J, Cita. tatl., 34: 221-22f,
Dttfara.ttat.d eweoMldat10etd
yog., !9t 133-140. 1934.
THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
295 CONFIDENTIALITY AGREEMENT.
42. tollaadar, l., {awswtra, f,C, a.d Ortt.r.d., d,t,: ltatocUaaical aod
w1traKOlat alerosaople ttndtu of eNrooit daraatoact aod t\c cori.o
ta.obraoa. J, L..at: Der.at., 22: 335-W, 1954.
43. itraada, A., ioeeera, i,C; nd Ltra1. K t S.gtonel entarocoltttt
ta sockar apaei.l doqr, Arch. Tath., 57: 357-362, 1934.
44. tott.ara, 2,C, aad tYlaawr. Y,4, t Saaaa,nt o.obraae ehar,4et tn chronic
thyrotdttta aed .titr.tk"etd dt.aaa.a. A.. J, Clte. p.,th., 24: 43i.tto,
1934. ~
43. Itood, J,t Jr., fo17ou, 2,D., Claaon, V,},C Soawrt, S,C, an[ V_rr.n,
~1,: An axMrtatatal atud7 of t\a ralatiooaltp b.twaa t.oor ait. aM
s.b.r of 1aq aataawaa. Caecar, 7: 437-443, 1934.
46. Goddard, J,V, aod tcam.ra, i,C. Itstaod tor thrrold eall nopplo8.
L...at 3: 197-210. 1934.
i
47. Coleoel, I.?. aad tereara; i,C.: horao.ta ta asat'a ditaauc of
brwt, ~. Clco. tt, Ir., 34: ,773-7t3, 19s4.
th.
44. 1.at, A,2 Laa,diuC 1,11, aad tat.atra, S.C.: Ae:pbophtl t:mra of the
bfltapArta taduoad !a alaa y, 1131. Ca.eer l.a., 14: s97so2, 1954.
449. toeara, S.C. aad lbtaaoar, V,A,: Dtwu.l tarcteoaa of tha paocraat.
Arc6. tath., 54: 101-111, 104.
s0. sa.rra, l.C., lldwrda, ,7.1. rd Cfuke, t,V.:
aatultt.it7 lattaea of Paralioata tatozteattoe after adreaalactovy.
J, baL, aad C1t.. 1t.d., 44: 331-343, 1934.
31. iarra, f.C., Crettat, R, aad Varrcn, f,: pltrartolat alcroccop7 of
llmrralu dtaw.a. A.. J, fat1., 30: 919-939, 1934.
32. ivraar, D,D, aed fata.err, t,C.: Mrdteal tatalltpoea. Mav. 2eg. J. Mcd.,
231: 744-743, 1934.
33. lattarao., V,/ Cbata, 1,*, aad fotnara, t,C,: TraVlaatatton of E:can
trota tato eorttae..-trcatad t,,aatara. Caxcr taa 14: 4s6-tS9, 1954.
34. Oeddard, ,7,V, a.d to.acra, S.C.: l9qrotd rttoulattoo to diaDetat eallttuc.
Diabataa, 3: 3t1-3u, 1954.
3s. -r, s.C "l7, :.A, a.d Varrae, 1.1 raaeraatlt duat eypcrplaala
aed eauear. Caatroaaeatolop. 27: 629-N0, 1934.
36. tolnaa, ly aad tomart, S.C.: A douDlc psiaar7 earcloaea of the urtoary
bladdar. J, orol., 72: 1174-1177, 1934,
.
CTR Hi i 0 1480117
IeCraue to b»or-

37. loarta, t,C.s lar ayltaattooa of altcavtolat sttstoseopY to µtboto{7.
q, !t 103-101, 1954.
SI. Larm, I.tt: wd taca.ars, t.C.s Clisieopatbologic coiotataeca. All. J, C1le.
latk., 34: 1A02-160.7, 1951.
$9. farcrs, f.C Crostar, 1. and Yarrsn, f.t A atvdp of tb4 olttavtolet
~ fictooeoo7 ot ranal vaxular dis.asaa. CtrealatioL, 11s $W3, 1955.
60. Mood, ,7.f Jf., lolyeta, {,D fc.crr., S.C. mE Yarran, f,: 1 tlucnee
of pttuitary tto,rtb bormooa oo pmtb aad az.taatuta.ioreattoo of a
ttawplsatabla aau.a sarca.a. la11. Jobs "kios fosP., 96: 93-100, 1955.
61. fenaara, S.C. ud Warran, f.: Dlcarattsa eolttis la.low ls trradlatcd
tatc. As. J, Dissst. Dt.., 1:. 111, 1935.
62. Sommoar., 1.C,i trdoeriaa aboor.clltlac !a .w n vith bruct cancar. l.b.
lovast., 6: 160-174, 1953.
63. 166147. t.L., Daw , C.t. aod toaaa, t.C.t A bl.taebaaical eoaparicoo
of Prirrt tbyrold kr»arPlaa/a aM adeeo.atow Doitar. Arch. Neb., 59:
WS-K0, 1933.
M: ieetar, C,l, aad {orcr. ,,C,: Cliaieoyatbolegto Cootcr.see. Aa. .1.
Clia. Tsth., 23: 10331057, 1935.
63. feo.er., f.C., Catcc, 0. and Ooedot, t.l.t Latc racurraeea of graeuloca
call tror.. Obtt. t, C7eac., t 393-39t, 1933.
N. ioaf,ar., l,C.t Devslop..nt of recaacb at IWaaebuaetes ti..orla1 lotpitalt.
lpm, 6: 113-113, 1951.
67. Laodler, A,B., Davis, f, sad tasaar., l,C.s Ytarotrao.plaotacton
asPariacstc vith b,.ao caaccra. Cancer t.a., 16: 32-36, 1956.
6!. farker, T.C. and fosmm.r., S.C.: Adrenal eortlcal byperplatia accapao71n6
eanear. Areb. iurj., 72: 93-499, 1956.
9. oncrs, f.C.t Tetticwlar cryrrtolaaie call b7pertropbr aeea.pan7ittt
oro.tatic btpartropb7 and eaacat. A.. .1. htb., 32: 115-199, 1956.
70. io.rcrc, S.C. ,ad {alsT, R,lt.a /tailartt7 et gla.atular uitravtolat
abaor'tieaa !e diabates rllitw aed attet cortlsonc tberap7. ?roc.
004. I..Pat. 1101. A ltrd., 91: 262-263, 1936.
s
CTR HIii 014808

I
aKOtet rdttoacaqT to patkolon. 71.
ti,olo{tc eonLarance. AM. J. Cltn. 72.
,t A atudp of the ultra.tolau
a"lattoc., 11, 3i-43, 19SS. it.
S.C. aed 6lartan, t,t 2.[laeeca
1 ~ataataata.tar%attoo Of a 74,
vepbSna toep., 96: 93-100. 1933.
. colttts lastotu in irtadtated 73.
aowa With -rasat cancer. Lab. 76.
: htstocboatcal comparlloo
tow tettar. lltch. patA., 59: 77.
atbnloglt ConletaKe. Is. J. 78.
1 Late recvrr.oe* of traaulo.a 79.
1933.
ttuaaciuatta Maarntal toapttala. $0.
41.
l/tAtotraasplaetat ton
t., 76: 32-36, 1936.
:orttcsl \7perplasta aecospan7tre
ill b7partroph7 aceospan)tng
path., 32: 1I3-199, 1956.
of /1omarvlar ultrariolet
: eortisone therap7. hoc.
~6.
THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
297 L'ONFIDENSfAIlTY AGREEMENT.
toaera, S.C. and Ctrna , 1,11,: Carctso/eoasla aad alterad bott rcatttooa
to prablotlc rata.- Lrci. !'ath /1: F 306, 1956.
Sr.. osswtS.C.: Iurodocttoa to ptbolop of s+oplaattc diaeaeas. J.
/trdeat A,14 A 21-23, April. 1936.
thakbaahtr, T. ard Sr., ort.C,: Cltroaic srWrwl sedosvtrimm. Obtt. 4
t7t»e., /:I12-115, 1936.
t%oars, t,C,: laeataeot'arrbrasa., tremd aubsuncas and lrphoc7cic
aj;tetatea to attag ortaaa. J. Cetootol., 11: 251-260, 1936.
prc, #: rnd Sr., oeat.C,: -11tsltad" aac(tas taor. trasaplaot. 1u11.,
3: 1^.2-10), 1936.
Sr., oamaS.C. and Yrdsra, p,),: hthofeaeaic of po17c7stlc o.arlu . At.
J. Obat. 4 Cyoac., 72:160169, 1936. 1
sxKhtoe, C.A. sad t-Aners, t,C. :csal c-.ttsra in ahock treated with
loVarteresal (l.rtoph.d). Am. J. Clts. patl., 27:29-30, 1937.
trrr. R. and taaars, t.C.t Ilewual eawas of daath alter cardt.c
Am. itart J. 3): 2)2.2)9, 1937.
M-1.1, 1. and taosers, S.C.: tadoctist eorrelattoea in ry aden,>-
[t!:ists and chroatt t"ttc eastltta. Ass. tort., 143: )26-))), 1937.
t x-ara, t.C.: t+docrlle chaates with proatutit tarcteasa. Cascer, 10:
343-350, 1937.
I.RSbie, A,l, 3utrow , l,A, sad taer., t,C,: Cliateopatholo/te
C.oterance. t.iractor7 aatria, ataeaaflobultseala, and rediasttnal
tuwr. An. J. Clts. 1ack., 27: 444-432, 1957.
92. licMult7. J.R. aad !s rs, t.C,: Rcratoacaatbow es a aur/lwl p.thololtc
e11tle7. turt.. Cyeee. 4 06at., 10-4: 463.66/, 1957.
t). ,7ones, R.G. and S:aeers, S.C.: Clocrrular alteratt-ins in ktdw )c of
rats truced with dux7corttcasterxe. Arch. prth., 64: 34-62, 1957.
94. t:ltt. K. toonars, S.C. sad tettbvtek, t.t,: Cltateopatholotic
c xrelatiaes it rewl btopsiea from ataesttal hypertwtre pptients.
Ctrculpttoa, 16: 207-212. 1937.
/3. IYrrias, J.C. Jr. snG tatraars, S.C.: Maav7 prtdvctal h7alte to
dia-etic vomao. 4lb. Irnc.t. 6: 412-420, 1957.
lo.0a1 0 - 7s - Lo
V i i"+ i iN 014609

THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
CONFIDENTIAUTY AGREEME.N,T,
.
6. Mda.e.r, V.A., Sommocra, S.C. and SLar.an. C.: Stda..trtal b7Psrplasi.,
oedwtrial carcim.a aad oodossctrio.is Ptodreod emycrlnset.117 by
wtto{ae. Cmcar, 10: 300-309, 1957.
7. Soacrs, S.C. and tl.tal6er. Y.A.: io.t ralatie0.b.t9 to asycrta+ot.l
aodo.etrtal carctaosr. Caaccr, 10: $10-S1s. 1937.
td, Sa~ra, S.C. and ritasoar, V,A.: Indocrtoo abnot.alttics aeco.panTini
hV1&m oado.atria7 caxar. Caecar, 10: 516-321, 1937.
$9. Souttat, L.. Soaete, S.C.. IIal..n, A.S. .nd >tiersoa, C.P.: Problsw
le tba turSteal m.naSemeot of th7.ic R.ora. Aon. SurS. 146: 424-
63l, 1957.
~
90. Aart, l.V. Aed SoW.rs, S.C.: Stedocrtes aboorc.littas accorpaoPiot
bayatte cirtboais and bcpator . J. Clie. a+docriaol, 17: 1017-1029,
1957.
91. IIllriek, V.C 1..ntint, L.A. cad Sosaara, S.C.: LLett.btltt7 and
coatractilit7 ef pataerta, b>saa kaart .ucla. Lak. ls..ac., 6:
325-333, 1937.
92. Soaara, S.C.: Pbat factors to fatal ba.a lonS eaecer. Atcb. Path.,
65: 104-111, 193l.
93. 9Ntrims, J.C.. Sas>fars, S.C. and Saitbvick, t,N.: CltotcopatholoSte
eorralatioos of ran.l btopstas ta hyPartaeaioo vtth P7.loocyhritis.
Ctrculatioo, 17: 243-2Al, 193l.
94. Roafat, l.D., Sviotoo, M.V Atkinaon, R.P, and Somisrr., S.C.: Panel
/Uewsioo eo cbrontc olc.rattw colitis. A.. J. Oaatroenterol., 29:
339-373, 1935.
95. Atar, E.A. and Sommars. S.C.: tatroyarttee.al octoPtc amaio.l
.asiclc commanxicctieS with a eoetralateral solitary ktdo.7. Aeyort
of a case. J. Urol., 79: 94-95, 1958.
96. Sasafse, S.C., lrlaaa, A.S. and Saitberick, t.S.: 81ato1oSic studies
of kldooP btoya) a)actacow from Patt.ota Ktb hnerteasioo. Aa. J. Path
34: 663-713, 1935.
97. Somseara, S.C.: Coo.tttattooal aapoets of S+u trte earetro.a. Arch. Path.
66: 4i7-693, 1954.
95. Dllrtck, V.C., Laetiai, L.A. and So..ars, S.C.: OsySar coosumption
of pataortom bxat,aa heart aucla. Proc. Soc. nqar. Sio1. 6 Med., 99:
2462467, 1936.
99. StV+=a, A.E., Goddard, J.V. aad Scmmitr., S.C.: A study of the adrenal
status io QyPcrtaesioo. J. Caroeic Dia., S: Sd7-393, 1958.
CTR Hii 014810
I

TNIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
299 CONFIDENTIAUTY AGREEMENT.
100. ftlva yf. and fommert, S.C.: looal ktopa7 cAsofa .lth pk.oehra.oeyta..
A..J. tl.d.'lci., 236:700-70i, 1938.
101. [.lllcr, I.. Lsesoo, f, asd l-m.ars, f,C.t Carctaoaa a: Lt.f lo .loor
salt.ar7 flaad ducts of tl. 1or.r lip. 1a.. J. furf., 97: 79-82, 1939.
102. fcr v
atg, f.ll, sed forr., f,C,: lroaetbf.ntc cuciso.a. Arch. Ocol.rM,
i6: )K-769, 1958.
.
103. Vtlktea, l,Y, aed foasts, f,C,: Cllolcopacholofic Coelcr.ocs. lotarfascnc
ol tAc haart, cardiac tailurc 4ad loo.c, dry scaly akio. As. J. Cltn.
)atk., 31: 66-72. 1939.
104. fcamcrs, f,C.: fltuttarj call ralatioes to body statcs, l.ak. lovat.,
- 1: 368-621, 1939.
105. Coltrs, J,D. aad foa..r., i.C.: lastlial p.M+dv+aotboaa c1actct,s
aad val.ular h.art disca.c. Circulation, 19:242230, 1939.
106. for rs. S.C.: 9atbloi7 of thc f:idw7 and adrasal flaad in rclatiooship
to h»crt..aioe. Ia: "lf~p.rteaatoe" V,l.:f .+adar. Co.. 23. 1958.
107. Aadrltsakiv, C.D. and foasrt, /,C,: Crtccrta of tkp.ic caec.r anc
clietcal corralatiotu o( th7.ic tr.ors. J. Tbratic farf., 37: 2)3-290,
1959.
104. Irdroutsopoulo., D.A, a.d farrs, f,C,t hataaeopsuaal csda..criost..
Ot+.tat. 6 t.y.ac., 14: 2f3.l6t, 1939.
109. Ollrtck, V,C Latiai, " aed lo..ars, f,C.: l.rtiee aed tctaost
ta patsorta, k.:.an Daut .uscla. J, ypl. TD7ata1., 16: 367-360, 1939.
110. follaadcr, , aed fomm.rs, f.C,: CeQrcnt ca.a of lcpra.atow lcprosy,
acid-faat bacilli La apidcraic. Cana. 1kd., 2yt 630-634, 1939.
111. lfa7ar, C,t. aad forts, f.C,t 14oat tactxs tn cacteo.a ol thc
utariee ccrvi:. A.. J, 0t,atct, G C7e.c., 76: 366-392, 1939.
112. lloodvorth, J,lt.l. aad foasra, f.C.: "Ctrrhottc floacruloaclaroatt".
A raeal lcatoa usoeiatad vith blatic cirrhosic. Lah, lowat., 8:962-
978, 1939.
113. lrllcr, C.ti. and fom.ara, f.C,: '1/te thyroid status ta ralation to
artarioaclcrotic disa.sc. l,IQ, 10: 1-2, 1939.
R..r TR i i N 014611

THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
300 CONFIDENTIAUTY AGREEMENT.
114: Ssoebe;, G.C. a.A Saerre, S.C.: 9eptic beor dtatbrata .ith a ata.d
.dooocarctocfts of tb. pancrua: Coe -reqort. Oi+atrooateroleSy, 76:
167i70, 1960.
115. Sansors, S.C.: Leal aod .dremal patbolop is "attehsloo. Coon.
If.d., 24: 240-2", 1960.
116. [e117, J.V.M., par+oaa, L., prtodell, I.8. eed Set.ere, S.C.: A
VatboloSte stody in SS antopstaa after s.dteal surSery for caacer of
t!a eervi:: S.rS., 0)ooc. md 0lat., 110:421-672, 1960.
117. lollmda, A. emd Saeers,'S.C,.: A biatocbeateal st.dy of sxopoly-
.accbartdas of lqtw7 of tb. akto. Act.. D.r.a. Yaoerool. Proc. llth
2atereat. Coalr. D+i.at. 3: 407-411, 1957 ..... 1940.
115. - latkiasbao, S., aod Soeerrt's, t.C.:9ulaooary brtltne ew.branes. J. Dis.
Cklld, 99: 216-227, 1960. ,
119. pattoo, 5.1. ml Sae.ers. S.C.: tba birtopatholoSy of fnfarettoo and
otber ulcetatts dla.tac of the YopbiSus. d.. .1. C11o. path., 33:
516-524, 1940.
120. Sollaoder, A. aad S ~rs, S.C.: ltatoebalcal c.e.partsoo of Soeck's
Sareoid tttb other cvtan.oua Sr.ouloew . Arch. Ders.t. !1: 944-946, 1960.
121. Mod.ll, 0.1., fhtrro, ].D. and Soarra, S.C.: Sploao and liver in
tLe am.da of tfa n.or-6aarlaS bafrter. Arek. patb., 70: 6)-571, 1960.
122. Gra..i, J.t. aod Sa...r., S.C.: A ea.o of carcineaa of tbe lrcarc to
a 7ouy rosa with baeurtoe.atnw bypotbalaatc salformatioo. Aa. J.
SnrS., 100: 606-612, 1960.
123. Colaria, C.C.. M.dall, 0.1, s:d So..ars, S.C,: Sa7saud's disea.e and i
primary p.lnooary byp*rteo.ioo.Cisailatioo. 22: 1035-1059, 1960. ,
124. i:trpoo, C. and Sas..ra. S.C.: hataSloaarnlar cell couats aod bu.aa
lrnartaa.loo. A.. J. patb., 31: 227-241, 1961.
125. So..ers, S. . md 7brS.oe. C.: lHrpboloSic atudies eo relattooship
of py.looeptritis to byportetuloo io: "ltolop of p7elonophritie"
Little Iroro aod Co.pas7. Bostoo, 1960.
126. lit4:le7, I.L. aad Sosrrs. S.C.: 16aat cells to ronapecific ulcerative
colitis. A.. J. Ditaat. Dis., 6: 233-236. 1941.
127. So.mers, S.C. and Veremdla, J.S.: An appraisal of labotatory detersination,
of estroSaoa. Am. J. Clio. )atb., JS: 719-727, 1961.
CTR t iN 014612

all, G.t. snd So>,ers. S.C.: A
aftar radical arr{er7 for eancer of
ot., 110:423-432, 1960.
A biataeba.ical at.d7 of .acopolY-
e. Acta. Oat+at. t'.nereol. 9roc. 11th
11, 195i ..... 1960.
:Iblaooary, tr7alioe mo.braaea. J. Dia.
w bistopatbolop of tefarcttoa aed
.opb.{.u. Ai. J. Clio. lath., 33:
tistxb..ical c.o.pariaoo of ioock'e
slo.aa. Arcb. Der.at. I1: 9i4-946, 1960.
Sa...ta. S.C.: Sp1M .ed liver to
arter. Arcb. patb., m i63-f71, 1960.
ea. of carcite.a of tbe brsut to
rpocbal.o.dc aalfor+nttoo. 1.. J.
Sosrs. S.C.: tay.and'a dfsease aad r.
eclatioo. 22: 10532059, 1960.
tafla.:ruler cell couats aad bu>yn
7-241, 1961.
obolofic studies oo ralattoeabip
to: "Siolop of p3clooophritia
;960.
ut talla ia ooeapacific ulcerati..
t3-236, 1%1.
a oypraisal of laboracory aataratoatiooa
5: 319-327, 1961.
129.
130.
131.
TNIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
301 CONFIDENTIAUTY AGREEMENT.
lin, p-8 sod tom., S.C.: torr patbolosic cor:alatinoa of o.ariao
.ttommal k}p.rplaata. J. C1t,.Oadocriaol. a llitab. 21: 472 i77, 1961.
tstalaao, I.J. sad Sammaata, S. - ltopay diasaosic of pertarteritia
arodooa. Ixc.b. patL., 72: 1-7,~961.
lcdeacbi, L.C. amd Sommmarc, S,C.: Or7-ulaa fiSers to sclcro.ict
ba.aatio.ra. AreL. Detnatol., !4: 12J-130, 1961.
Lammar., S.C,: Se.s pitboloFic ceoditioaa u.ociatod with reaai snd
Mroeal bypoYtaosioa. J.A.ri.A. 278: 71$-717, 1%1.
132. priodall, G.11., Sher.an, J.O, aad Sa~ra, S.C.: Ctwth curves of bm.n
- caacar traaaplaata during aqarinsot.al cb..othatepy. 14: 1117-1121. 1961.
233. tMnria, 1.p Crasat, J.L. aad Sorra, S.C.: Ba.arteutow aalforaution
of the poytlatoral bypothala.ua. L.b. Lo.est., 11: 9-97, 1962.
134. 6ttlltar, 1t.J. amd Sommars, S,C,.: tadocriw aad certaio other chantcs
la sro with carctao.a of tbe 1JOka. Caacar. 15: 109-117, 1962.
135. Oa..., II, friodall, C.9. and Sorra, S.C.: A atud7 of ovarian
tbaoa.atoato. Califoraia Madictoe, %: 2S4-2S6, 1962.
136. ladoecbi, L.6. and Soa.ars, S.C.: O:ltalaa fibara - derail fibroou
ad Siant eall toudoo aboath tn.ots, Arch. Dest.., S: 517-529, 1962.
137. Sotrjel, [.t., aod So.ass. S.C.: 2bo alveolar epitbalial luioo of
l"athie pularoosry h..oaidaroais. 1.. J.v, of tasp. Dis., SS: 540-
SS2, 1%2.
136. iosrpl, 1<.11. aod tcsera, S.C,: Idiopathic pal.nerr7 be.oaidaroais
aod relatod rredraaa, h.. J, Mod 32: 699-}11, 1962.
139. iaimm.ra, S.C., 1leian=blt.a, l.J, oad 11Um1s7,l..L.: patholop of
diaatolic bTpartatuioo aa a pnarlitod vascular diseacc. Aa. J.
Cardiol. MaJ, 1962, 653-636.

THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
302 (DONFlDENTlAL1TY AGREEMEtiTr
160. L.a.... C. aod s.mm.r., t.C.: Qbdomatrtal ba.oatdrrin as ..idaoct
of t.atrorrbasis. 015. and 6TM., 1f: 2fA-7f2, 1%2.
r'
141. t.ysold., C.T. erd ssitbritl, 1.11. d faai.r., s.C.: lS:ci.ien
of alranal yd.e..a and ap.patb.ctc" is tba tbKSp7 of b7p.rtea.ion.
A.. J. twSrr7, 103: ifL-701, 1f62.
142. Nsr.,.1.M. aad iame.ar., f.C.: ftatv of tl.e etocardi.l .rtariolt.
la aogt.a p.csasii. 1..r. Mart J., 41: 323-3l3, 1962.
163. 2tt7neldt, C.T.'oed Le...r., f.C.s fyWatiueteer lor sloascule
aqbritia Ktb kn.rt.osiea. ArcE. .ur=., s: 3:0-313. 1962.
1". toWN.r., L.C., febbtas, C.S., taDia, D.t. .od taaact, C.T.: Chronic
nale..pbrttti, r.oa1 tubslat atroph7 and b7partaoalon. Arcb. lot.
11.d., 110: 305-310, 1941.
1145. 1lS.oaaod. J.ri.. iea.a., D. and Darr», S.C.: tor bo.t faetors
is tb. d...lopsu ef t.oal call earctoa... W.t. J. Son., Osa.
i Oraoe., 70: 2M-2tS, 1112.
166. lrnd4ton, t.M. aedSammmrr., f.C.: A soW tvucpt of t.ma1 byyart.n.io..
.1. Drolop, S!: 113-136, 1943.
147. 1w..a, 0.- hw.estala, 1.. and saIVEr:a. S.C.: A.ua..t.d .acbani.o
f otytbsopoiotit ewtrol ef ymrt.2lo.rtYlar ealla. Aa. J. M.d. Sci.,
243: 136-1/7, 1f63.
1AA. 1.ak, 1. ae1 iarr., f.C.s ta.da..trial e.ratu;r tn dYatm.is and
tbsrqT. Gba. 4 oy.a.. 21: t36-638. 1943.
149. t.aoro, d.C., Yaba. C.L. md toes., t.: A bamaqlutinatton r..etiorn
of .etban and iafusta of dtllaraot ADO od 2b trwpf. A.. !. Clin.
)atb., 3!s N2d86, 1943.
150. aarfiold, A.1. aad it..s., i.C.: TbM aff.ct of srltwtritioo on
tropie ltierroo atorat. !o tba ba.ao b7popb7.ta. Arch. t.t.h., 75:
564, 1943.
t

etrtal l:a*otLderia u e.ideace
790-79). 1962 .
aed Sotaaa, S.C.: t:eirioo
7 La tba tLer.y7 of hnartewtoo.
t of tLa t+7ocardial artertolet
64: 323-393, 1962.
9+ath.cta.y for tloaaralo-
lvrt, 4!: 390-393, 1962.
, la..atsd taa.ck, C.T.: Car'ootc
:y aad lnarcoealeo. Areb. lat.
ter., S.C.: faa bort factort
rctt,o.a. lM.t. J. fan., Obd.
mw coeeopt of taeal trn.rtaosioa.
rrt, S.C.: A enaaetad mtebaota.
Lo.arular eallt. A.. J. IMd. Set.,
i.l eorottap ia dd,ataoota .ad
1, 1963.
r, t.: A lb~l.tiaattoa rwetioe
Y0 aad q tt"a. As. J. Clta.
.Isa affoet of rlmtrlttea oa
by"b7eia. meh. Tati., 75:
/
303 THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
CONfIDENTIALITY AGREEMENT.
151. t.aaor, f.l., tah. M. aad S atm.ra, S.C,: Lvflueoea of LasulLe ther.py
aad p7alost9hritit opoo dtab.tic tla..rvloaclerotL. to ba..t.r..
Ne"b. 12: 704709, 1943.
152. torrt, S.C.: iono oadocrina tod L@mL.mlottc utactt of progno.i.
to breaat earcitwa. Act. Doioo lat. Cootra Catcar 16: 959-960, 1962.
13). tea.oa, C., lt.twrodo, A. aad tomomert, i.C.: A caaa of brau t eareiaosa
tKtS hTotA.Iaric nalfot.ation. Pat. J. aart. Ob.. 6 C7o. 71:
1K-1K, 1963.
154. 1att,.K.3.1. atad foomsara, S.C.: A ellaieo9atholojic aoal7sL of biopsy
hacL.eaa La porti.taot tloaarulaeaqDritta. Aa. J. Tath., 43: 659-475,
1963.
155. iaMoo, D.t., ldeia, P.C. ad sonsar., S.C.: Ata=la-7alenrt.ctaata.
J. fau"atk. A aq. {.as. 22: S69-ss3, 196).
136c loaaer, I.1., Iat, M.D Doealdaoo, C.V., )Iclauahlin, 1.J. and
tosuars, S.C.: Alloraa dta6,otoa La the goldea h...tcr, eti..oericetu.
Aaratoa II. Cloaeruloaelereaia aad ita reiattoe to diabcttc rewlattoo.
Di.lotaa, 13: 9-5), 1964.
157. Yilltr, 1(., 1arw, M.D. a.d fot:aprr, S.C.: t7roeatreata, aotL
diaratie lootaoeo .ocratioo aad oat call careiso." of tLa lvaj.
DLa.-of Cbott, 44: 95-99. 1963.
1Si. 9bsroa, L.f., los;btoo, C.A, aud tota,.rr, t.C.: Tbo utoetattoa of
aaatrie yttibalt.l lnMluta amd easeer. Cuero.atarolop 46:
167-272, 1966.
159. T.dl, P. a'd tonswort, f.C.: tueolar La.aatee u aprvpoattc faetor
f.a br.a.tt cazciaor. ttsts. 07a.c. Oed CMtet. 1U: 1CC6-10Cl, 1966.
160. t.e.oa, C., Le..aaala, L. a.d fommere, t.C.: ife r.oal arcvla
dausa d j:atatlomorolar body !a eirrtiwta. Arek. Lat. Mad.
112: 701-713, 1943.
161. VLlltr, M,J. aad fetaan, S.C.: LqL7soaa. Peptic olcer md 1ung
taretaa.a tritL pitaitar7 Ceooke's ealla. An. J. riad. iet., 247:
422-626, 1944.
162. te..ara, S.C. aad Dimo, T,J.: ietaiaar as wtorard r..ettoaa to
troataoat. As. Society of ClLaieal fatbolotiata, CEle.to, 1964, 67 pp.
163. lraala,, A.tt., Coatek, .C., Soarr., S.C. aed Ous., L.t.:
fatboteo,.aLa of eDronie noleoopbritia. A.. J. Path. 44: 679-705, 1964.
1K. Vrijbt, C.f., /bdmilla, G.A. arrd Qoaitrt. S.C.: fartrvtal doatb: A
eliaicopataolotieal aul7eit of 99 aaeoa. Calif. ri.d. 100: 336-339,
1fK.
165. lotmmaro,i.C.: ADmr.alitlu aee.a.ptu7ta{ earctaa.aa of the lartc
lata.tisd. DiL. Colon aed leea. 7: 262-269, 1964.
®
CTR i i i i ti..lr 1'-S' G.i ':.3

THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
304 CONFiDENTIALITY AGREEMENT.
166. teerd7, l.R.. 41111en , M-7. .od S90sweTS. S.C.: Cashing's s7ndrnee
and eaecer of Me 1m5; Pituitary Crooh. Call h7p.rplsela in pul.oo.ry
eat aall careisnu. Am. SarS., 160r 90-94, 1964.
167. iass.arr. S.C: patbology of eoaeotial b7perteaaien. C7clo. M.d. 4: 9-15
1964.
1N. 1eekls~,a.. S., itdlarp, V.p. tr., and Soasera, S.C.: Yuhonary
alv.olar eall iseluotoaat iLeir d.v.lop.eat ta Tat. Seieoce, 145:
1192-1193. 1964.
169. Nusfteld,'Apee, Ii., Tiah.r, Rdvta, 1. and Soe.rrs S.C.: Disrociation
of 6ypophTssal coet.nt and urloary eseretion of groeadotroyin in cirrhosis
ptec. Soc. R>p. 31e1. 4 M.d., 116: 14, 1022-1024, Aug,-Sept. 1964.
170. ies.ets, S,C.: polsoear7 e.ql+Tse.a, ),ealed e7ocardial infarctt and
ether dfawe correlations with rle brwt straetvre. A., J. M.d.
S ei ., 24! : S p t. 1964 . 341 s144 .
171. S o.ars, S.C., Cenick, D.C., Ralaaeaoo, G.M. sod Wta, L.S.:
patLoSeeosfs of eDtoofc y"leoopbtitte. Ae. l. path., 45:15
729-73'. 0ov. 1964.
172. priedell, C., Rette, A. ead Sealera, S.C.: Tha propiostic value of
blood eessel lavasioo and 17.pbocTttc Sofiltrataa in braaat carcinoea.
Caaear, 1S: 12, 164-1K, peb. 1965.
173. Raee.dp, l.R., Yillfaer. M.l. aod So.arrs, S.C.: Pituitary Croot.
C.11 trpperpluta ta pela»oarp eareiao.a. Aeto Ooie Contza Caaersa,
20: 1523, 1964.
174. Coeiek, R.C., Rtdtfet, M.D.. Cleason, 1.0. and Sossaers, S.C.: The
raeal lu ton io Sout. Ann. Iot. Mod., 62: 667-674, 1965.
175. Sorre. S.C.: R7partaasieo and kidney dieaua. hog. in Cardio-
vascnlar diseus. S: 210-234, Rov. 1965.
176. Raleaeaon, C.M., Soaara, S.C. and Oute, L.S.: p7alooephritis vII.
Ceparteentul ucaodtag infaction with progrusion of lesions in the
absence of Uacteria. Arch. Path., 30: 509-316, 1965.
177. Rsevaa, C. and Sotrra, S.C.: Sensitivtt7 of tbc renal sacule deass
to uriaar7 eodtu.. Proc. Soc. txp. lSel. M+d., 120: 324-326, 1965.
175. Serra, S.C.: Sbdocriea patLology of prostattc hypertrophy and
tarcieoe,a. bull. M.Y. Aced. Mad. 42: p.24a, March, 1966 (Abstract).
179. /erco.dtt, 2.T, aad Soaera, S.C.: Altered ieflateatory reaction in
aowpectfic ulcerative colttie. Arch. lot. M.d., 117: 504, April, 1966.
150, pr1.d.11, C.M., Soerra S.C CDnte, R.M, and Varren, S.: Overian
tuoori{.oaaia to !r=adiated parabiotic rats. Cax er Raa. 26: 427-c3t., 1966.
181. 9klsaner, V.A, and Samt<tere, S.C.: Rndo.etrial ebanaes after prolonger
proSesterooa and testoateroot adainistration to rabbits. Cancer g.s.
26: 474-475, March, 1%6.
182. More, S.M., 1Mrdiper, V,1. sod Sommerr, S.C.: Cholec7atitis and
atetattc artetloecleroele. Ae. l. Clia. 9ath. 45: 465-467, 1966.
Ci R i i i i 014816

.
rra, S.C.: Cvshin{'a ayndroee
ks C.11 h7psrplaria to pul.onary
0-94, 1964.
trypertaeateo. Cycle. N.d. 4: 9-15
Sofera, S.C.: pol.ooar7
Vt.ant to rat. Sctence. 143:
.. and Sorra, S.C.: Dtetoeiatioo
ratee ef soea6ottopin in ctrrt+oata
10J2-1024, AuS.-S.pt. 196G
d alod .7ocardtal tnfarcta and
raast atrveture. A.. J. Msd.
s, C.K. and Oute, L.1.:
, 1r, J. patb., 4S:0S
.C.: 8+a prognoatic .alee of
tnfiltratas in braut carctno.a.
sra. S.C.: pitvttary Creoke
r. Aeto Oate CoatRa Caoerum,
.0. and Som.ert. S.C.: 1he
62: 667-674, 1%S.
dtaau a. Trot. La Cardie
.S .
L.1 i! pyalee.phritis VI1I
profrH/ton of leatoes in the
509-516, 1965.
it7 of the ran.l Oaeula danaa
.1. ria4., 120: ]24-)26, 1965.
prortatic bypartropb) and
,.246, March, 1966 (AD.tract).
i:ered tnflammatory raacttoe in
'loti tbd., 117: SO4, Aprtl, 1966.
R.M. and Varraa. S.: O.arian
: rats. Cascar Raa. 24: 427-4 Y., 1966.
:..trial eLn6ea aftK prolenvd
:ratton to rabbita. Caaeer Res.
ra, S.C,: Chel.e7atttLa and
i. Path. 45: 465-467, 1966.
THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
305 CONFIDENTIAUTY AGREEMENT.
16). Soaera, S.C.. priWall, C.l. and Robtnsoo, C.R.: Chrotherapy of ikmman
Cancer hansplanta with 1Ytbotrez.ta (A.atboptsrio) and Morea Ser..
Caacer, 19: 674-676, 1%6.
164. Sc%iadlar, I.M. tod Soe.ara, S.C.: Dtabettc aclero.ts ef the 2nzta5loa+rrvlar
apparatw. Lab. Lnwt., 1S: 77-N4, .i%6, May.
V
165. Sammara, S.C.: Raoal paetora in lppaztao.too. Lar7 Ford lo.p. M,.d ./ull.,
14 : 47-54 , )tarch, 1966.
186. >,rtktnSha0, S.. lete..aaa, 1.0. and Sommer.. S.C. and IleVary. V.r.: 7hospho-
lipfd eyocbaata in tbe larSa' plavoar7 al.eolar cell: lta relation to -
laS Iqrfactaeta.Ir. J. Path. 4S: 10Q7-1061, Jnea, 1966.
187. Solerq, l.l, aod Soaar.,S.C.: Oadocrtaopathy ae.ociatod vith pancraatic
caztimt.as - rr.tev of howt factors ineludin.6 hpperplasta and pooadotropie
aeti.ity. Arpale of Surlery, 164: 500-704, 1966.
1{!. L.ragh, J,l., Saalry, J.i. aad Semmer.. S.C.: Patterns of adrenal aecretion
sed urinary aeretfoe of aldooterooe and plao.a ranin aetivity in nors.:
mdhyportanai.e aubjocts. Sepplernt 1 to Cireulatton Research. volr.
71VIII ao,d T12,1-156 - 1-174, Jvee, 1966.
189. Canaoo, p.J., Sta/on. V,i., te.artini, p.L., Sonsera. S.C. and Lara6h, J.H,:
l"eruricenta in prisary and ramal bypercaeaion. M.v 1a6. J. Med., 275:
457-464, S.pte.ber, 1%6.
190. Somms.zt, S.C. aed prtodall, 0.1.: Stadtea of eareinosmeata in parabtotie
rate. Amala of Mav 7ork Acadaq of Scioncu, 125: 926-912, Jaouary, 1966.
191. [tater, S.J., S orrra, S,C., la{Saaaaa, C.D. and Cooley, i.: Re-avaluatioo
of blood .uae1 ia.sioe aa a propnoatie factor io earcioa.a of the
breast. C.oear, 19: 1215-1216, Sapte.ber, 1966.
192. ]tf.an, G.A. aed S a>.ra, S.C.: »o derolop.ant of llodSkia's disease and
17.phasaa durits anticoar.ulaant tLarapy. Ilood. 26: 416 i27,1966.
193. Semmera, S.C.: Maat ealls ard paseth eelle !a uleerative colitis.
Gastroaateroloty. S1: i61-648, 1%6.
194. 5 ommar., S.C.: patlwlop of eer.ieal eareiso.a. in "Nav C omepu in
CpnecoloSteal Oneolop" Malm..ana Sp.peeia., lS-90, 1966.
195. Sommer., S.C.: 2he stgnifteaace of mdeawtrtal h79erplasiaa. In "Nev
Coocepta in CyuecoloSical Oncolop" 6.)msimenn S7upo.it., 205-209, 1966.
196. Sommers, S,C., aed lareo.ita, 2.i.: Inflrtory raspoosee in ulcerative
colitta. l.Y. Stata J. riod., 66: 3000-)062, 1966.
197. S.oboda, A.C., Jr., xn.uor, C.tt Cible, C.It., Soamsera, S.C. and monroe, L.S.:
prollemc to tLe early diapwais of pe;tic aaopluSitia. Oestroiotut. todoacopy
pol. 1967.
196. Carnraea, J., Dtaond, L.C., Se.rra, S.C. aed Vank. R.: prevention of
induced atheroacl.ro.is by peronidaae. Science, 1S3: 1264-1267, lurch, 1967.
CTR HN 014817"

THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
306 CONFIDENTIAUTY AGREEMENT.
199. upp.7. .1.1. aad Saomeary, S.C.: l7p.rtropbiod p1as.a celle
in rallooal wtaritia. A.. ,1. DiS. Dia., 12: 465, 196).
200. l.ooa, 1. aed Sam~rs, S.C.t Calirof .utull.lalua t7pe
ta o.ar7 of a patient eritb fasiiaie. pb.aot7p.. Act. Gnetice
at Stat. 1Md., 17: 343, 1%7.
201. Coaitk, .C., paol, 6t.. tas..ety, S.C. red are, t.s.:
p:aoctieeal t.diaa is ssparts.ntal pTalooapbrttie. 21.
Cerral.tion batw.n acid saratiaa ability and aary.e bieto-
ebdalatr7. Acid tscr.tioe aod anr7.a bistoch.aistry in
- autparinantal p7aloo.pbritir..i:apbroo, : 75, 1967.
202. Oold.ebarj, I.l., blkisdl..., S. and Sosere, S.C.:
ALooar7 alv.olar laaloo. la .apotoais.d rate. Lab.
Ia+aat., 16: 961, 19i7.
203. Sonoara, S.C., lae..a, C. and L...ar, L.: Ias:u:blojit
aad ebemootbatapeotic ffacts oe bf.aa rlaoos,. \atero-
trwrplaotr. proe. Soc. 14cp. liol. aod M.d., 123: 740, 1967.
204. lxkiroao, S.. fosssra, S.C. aod Sbarvin, l.p.: L.rioee
of tha dorsal tagal aoclaus in the rupiratorp di.tr.ss
a7edro.a. Am. ,1. Clia. patb., N: 269, 1967.
205. Serra, S.C.: yata.atiaad ae.aaclatvra of pathology.
patbolo¢a at /lictobiologia, 30: 26, 1967.
206. ltraa.a, M.D., toe.rra, S.C.: M.dullar7 tyatic dieease
aad fwilia jo.aaila aaperoawpbtbisiao ti« Lc&. ,1. Med.
277: a6), 1967.
207. tl.bi, t.l.. LonS, M.L., Trirk, l.C.. II and Sa..ers, S.C.:
long-tarst aurKval in dis.a.inatad ovarian tarcioae.. Am.
.1. Obet. .ed Cpnaa., 99: 322, 1967.
206. D.ncicS, C.l., Sos.r., S.C. and QuiSlq, l.J.: Infertility
le .ala patienta with cystic fibrosis. p.diatrics, 41: 7-17,
1968.
209. Harriascoo, ,1.T., fa..ar., S.C. and Rautrar, J.p.:
Atbarwatoua saboli vitb prorraaai.s renal failure. Renal
astasiograpb7 u tha pr.babla iociting factor. Annals of
lst. liad., 68: 132-160, 196l.
210. Caaaoe. p.J.. L.wios. .l.ri., Sos,era, S.C.. Viotars, l.V. and
Lar.Sh, J.1.: LstaSlomarular call b7psrplaeia and secondary
byparaldo.taronio. (larttar' S7edro.a): A raa.aluation
of tbe patbopbpalolop. Madictaa, 47: 107-171, 1968.
C TR < <S i 014816

, S.C. and Ouaa, L.S.:
acul pYoloo.perici.. 21.
tine ability aod ooa7a+a bdato-
sotyr histoebamistrT 1o
phroo, 4: 75, 1967.
Quitlay, t.).: Intattilit7
-osi.. p.districs, 41: 7-17,
ars, S.C.. Vintors, 1.V. aod
11 fiyy.rpla.ia and aocoedarT
iror)o A reevalu.tioo
47: 107-1)1, 1964.
TTHIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
307 CONFiDENT1AUIY AGREEMENT.
211. larasA, J.l., L.diaabr, J.C.C. ..d eoarr,., t.C.: {.co.dar7 aldo.t.ranir.
and raducod plao.o raota to lrrparVarl.e di..aaa. Ttaas. Aaaoc. Ar. yk7stciaa.,
Im: 16i-1S1, 19N.
212. Kark.rtta, K., tanatar., S.C., toea.a, t..i. md 9stltr, 1{.0.: lsttcul.r
liop.y artifacca r.oalttog tevm ia0rvp.r ti.suo procutla{. J. Orol., 100:
4419, 194i.
213. ia.ats, t.C.: jg (J.lf.s. slood.ort6, .ditor) "Tettfook of p,doctia.
p.tblop" SLmI4Clsnd. H111Lr and Yilkiaa Co., ry 137-1e0, 196a.
2Ly. fosaas, S.C.: j~ "Teatbok o: lodotriaa ratbolop", J.x.s. .loodvortn,
odetot, r aa Aetieitie.s pd pqoaodocrtnf aws 2t.oTS. Vi11i.,m
aad Hilkta. Co., lalttaera 1966.
215. t,ltcLak, A., Albri{1:t, M.L. ed faasaas, i.C.: 1Lo t.oal yatAolop of
tosattia of prosoaet7. OD. ..d Oyn., ~1: S9S-407, 1966.
216. loctiniLa., S., fastssra. S.C. aa,d 1lctiar7, V.t.: Eqari.nt.l resyLrator7
distrass sysdro.a: I C.atral steaoaic .ad t~a.oral pacbf.artic tactors
ta palaaeary iaJnr7 .t nta tndaeod rLt1f lyp.rEaric or7tao and tb4 prot.cct.e
ottottU of /arbituratou sad 2ruy1o1 t~ . 1Lo1. 1.oo.t., 12: 261-261, 1%d.
217. Pa1ey, Y.I.. lf.aaat, a.J. Md Maaert. S.C.: dottctd.etal pri"rj aarcoa&
and cattieo.a of tke corrLz. Ob. and CJn. 33: 41-47, 19N.
11{. Colda:lart, t.I.. 1.ckia4lu., f.aN foaato. s.C.: tilocaryino
otisulattae of graa+ular p.aummot7ta a.cr.tioa. LaO. Is.ost. 29: 147-1Sd, 1969.
219. TSotor, S.J., lenatars, S.C., Laqroe, D.C., 1rt.dall, C.S. and Coole7, L.:
NWclaar vrada and atsoa kiottaeytowis in eacar of tbe krosat. Cancrt, 23: 570-
573, 1%9.
220. Sorr., S.C.: itiatoloeic eLugu t. txipiss:t urciao.a of tLa Draaat.
Canear, 23: $22, 1%9.
221. KarkMts, K., Y.ae..., R.J., Ttaprt,nt, ., Kalan.-Eat17, D., and Sc..er.,
S.C.: Cyprocorona acatate (=11 714) tftact eo Di.tolop and Muclaic Acid
=7etha.i tn tLe 2qtM of latiant. vitb Trootattc Carcim.a. Ia.a.t. Urol..
6:634-649, 1969.
222. ieLrartt, D.T., lnda, l J1. aed fat.on , 2.C.: Zsa tffott of yort.canl
2raaapooitioe aed l.a.l Artory ltwo.ll os tb. Ljoctioo .t i.oa1 Alloszaf:s
ta Do{.. J. Sorg. lua., 9: 4SS-440.1%9.
223. Coldoelore, ..I.. Oeldaai.rt, r.S. and Somara, S.C.: Co.qarati..
Itra.truetura of at7pieal ductal kyporpl.aia, istraduetsl carsiooss and
Safiltratlts "tal e.rtim.o of tb. 9rwt. ,f. Aator. Cancer Soc., 246:
1152-1169, 1%9.
224. (C7C) Sam.r.. S.C. aa:d Lo1.or. C.1.: tooarroat Chylow Aaeitas. P.Y.
State J. 11od., .ol., 70: 212-294, Joe. 1970.

THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
3()8 GONFIDENTIAUTY AGREEMENT.
/115. Lea{, 1/. t. .nd fo..ara, S.C.: Sta", Cradto# .a Mtatechrat.try of Ovarten
tpithalial 1Lseora: Clietcal Ob.tatrtca e.d Oyseeoloty: lt:937-954, 19-69.
v
226. Clapa F. t. d Sa..era, S.C. (CpC): tack saia, tenal Failure aad Abnorr.al
r.fwvtoa p7aloSram: tY State . Mod., Vol. 70, K9-t79, April, 1970
227. t.da, J.A , 16eA11tator, p l. rd Saa.era, S. C: Surgical Traat.ent of
t.s,o.aseular *»artonatoe: m. Arrieao J. of Sart.: 119: 374-576, 1970
~
228. t.ar, L., tam.n., i.C., trafoff, L. t. at .1: Aldo.terooi.e i.eudo-prisary
Ctrcnlatioe t.aaatcL: 27: 1-203, 1970 (tup9le..ot II)
229. S..rra, Sy C.: tf..itelficanca of tedo.etrial )typ.rplaeta sod Its Culy
Dtageosia: C)sac.leSical Oocolop : pata 129-140, lta7 1969.
230. lo..era, S. C., d T.raakta, J. A.: IIltraatructural Study ef Aldosterone-
oocr.tin~ Calla ot tDa Adraeal Certa=: Asar. J. Clie. path.: 54: 303-310,
9.opt. 1970. r
231. 0W, V. l. eed S~rt, S.C.t (C!C) t.ckackeand Aboor.al fisdinte oo Ches:
f11r :. 7. ttaca J. tbd. Vol. 70, 2692-2702, Iwv. 1970.
232. Sos,era, S. C.: "tffeeta of Ioeitint Udiatton Upon Qdoerioe Olands." Ir.
patb.lop of Irradiation, edited by C.C. tar]ta, Vtlltams and Wilkins Cc.,
Cdq. lt, Pata 409. 1970.
233. Could, V. _., Vsk, t., stnd Sommara, S. C.: Ultrastructural Observatir_s or.
lrnebial tpitb.lt.l Ryperplaaia a:.d S..mueu. fMt.pluia: Cancer, Vol. 26
o. 2 August 1971 by t3a Arr rieae Cmeer Soeiet), Ioc. 3. 5 Ltppincoct
Ca.pa.r. taSaa 426i 36.
234. Ttraakta, J.A., Sammsera, S C. eod Asdara.on, t.: Mouroaocratnr7 appearir.t ce:ls
of Vs.ao sopant.l broneb.i: Laboratory In..atitatioo 26: #1. 127-132 19':.
235. Nattarn, V, D.. tammera, S. C., sed t.aalrar. T. ?.: Oltturic acute re'...l
fallura io .alitoant hypartsoaioe: Tha A.. J. of M.d. S2: 1E7-197, 19':
236. `e~ra, EEeldon C "Adranal Clmde" !e lathole W. A. D. Andersor., ed.,
siath Witlon, C. V. Moaby Cs.qao7, St. Lwis, flu11. Vol 2, cb. 36,
p~.
1464-14l7
2)7. tas,cra, Shaldee C., "Itr7roid Claud", in patAolot7, V. A. D. Andersor., eC.,
Sixth tdttion, C. V. tbaby Co., St. Lou1a, 1971. V91 2, Ch. 34, pp.
238. 1a11a, Villta. T. Jr., taadall, tu.sall t. Jr., Saraaara, Sbaldon C., S:ac.,
Villt.. t., Larkin, trnu t C., Still, V.J.S. Menhyparcalt.ric Sarcc::
rqbropatby. ArcDtvaa of I.tarnal /lodtcina, 130, Autuat 1972, p. 265.
239. tYhta, t., tritfa, D. t Soraera, S.C., tarpatkin, ltartaret. Disse*tn.:r:
iatravu eular coagulation follevint cardiac arrest: a study of 15 pat:ra:s.
A.. J. of the lladical Sciance.. 264:33)-363, Movsber 1972.
CTR t i i i ti-.A' 14820

3
a6, cradtos .ed Ntetecbe.istry of Ovarien
ee .ed Oysoc.loty: 12: 937-934, 1969.
: laek ate, lanal Ltlur and Aknormal
M., Vol. 70, 049-t79, Arril, 1970
s,.ra, S. C : Surgical Tvoat.ent ot
.ess J. i f.rt.: 119: $74-37t, 1970
tt at ol: Aldeataroate. ?ao,do-yrLary
: (Su" l~eot /1)
adotwtriel lnoryleate end Its tarly
ps 129-140, ltey 1969.
0ltraatrvctvral.Stvdy of Aldoaterono-
: A.a . J. Clle. tatb.: 34: 303-310,
Lekaehtmd Abeorsal 11edie6s oa Chost
692-2702, Iw.. 1970.
i.dtattoe Upo Ddocrlee Clanda," la
.C. lerJle, Villi.u ead Vilkiee Co.,
. C.: 0ltrettrvetarsl OM .rvattena en
;.naoua qetqlasie: CAeeer, Vol. 23,
CeT Societ7, Ise. J. Llpytneott
Kaaeo, !.t titouro.ocr.tery a}paartat eallt
Iesetttatiee 26: /1, 127-132 1972.
sstrey! ?' P.: 0liturlc .cute roee]
e A.. J. of Ned. 52: 1t7-197, 1972.
ia latAole V, A. D. Anderton, ed.,
Louit, 1971. Vol 2, ch. 36, pp.
in 9atholop, V, A. D. Anderseo, ad.,
outa, 1971. VOL 2, Ch. 34, pp. 1431-1431
.1 I. Jr., Seat.ar., Sheldon C., Stacy,
. V,J.S. fooAyParcalcamtc Sarcold
ricls., 130, Autuat 1972, p. 2!!. -
.C., tarpackin, /{arteret. Dltes+.lnated
cardiac arretc: a etudy of 13 pattentt.
:3s3-363, Move.ber 1972.
t
240.
241.
242.
243.
TNIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
309 ('ANFIDENTIAUTY AGREEMENT..
,
D.d)l, l.urea aedjcnsers, Skcldee C. l.et.aa et twreda ta tlrat trta..ct.r
Irepaoclee. Arr J of Clie Iatk. 511164. 1973
taterrttt, t.T., tlreecr. J..tih t., Lt.dwcr, ArtLrr T., Marlkak, tichard'n.,
lis.6vy, teme t., twrjt, Sh.ldee C. "Vieerativa aod Creeulae.ceua Colttl.".
Charlw C. 71r.ea, Syrls6fteld, 211Saots, 0073.
ienltts, lurtee I., ..d S.nnetra, ik.ldee 11, Ttttorat.d .ea4raeule.cteu. a"an-
dtettta i t,lr e.arae et rotia.al tlattt.. Geatreaetcrolop 64:1020-1023, 1973.
t.e..n, SLelden C. Crwtk tatr, tyll tl.atit., .ed Itatkratleol Medcla of
M.. Cameacs. leekakl.3sp A...al. 1973, 3t109-340.
i
244. Samman, tk.ldoe C. Cerctae.e .t tidaatria. Ltereatiee.l Aead.ey of rad+-
o1.p lbaefraTh - TtR tR'Ltl~., ril1lar & Vtlklaa. V.v.rlr Tr+aa, Le Xarrland,
'vaptert 14, pp. 276-297.
245.
246.
247.
2M
249.
230.
231.
252.
233.
234.
sesrrs, L1aLdoi C. 6 L..s, Margant t., O.artam Cerctmr: 9atlwlop, Stasiat,
Crodiy, oed fr.ttasL. 1lalletla of tkr t.T. Aead..7 .f 1Wiclae, .e1.49, /10,
N.W-L69, OatNor, 1973,
twesser., L.C.A.d.r.aee,t. 1aacular aeqhdletlc ekryu ts e.enttal h7pcr
t.ulee. "p.rtmaloe: IYchamlar aad 1furSowat. Ctusa 4 Strattoo, I.c.
O« Terk, w. 163-173, 1973.
Cs.Ma, 9.J., Mehrrd, I.. Cr e, D.1., Cas.r.lla, Y.J., torr., i.C. & Lalb7.
S.C. The r.lattamahip of ky9trtasrl.e a.d r.aal tatl.ra te acl.red.rz,a
(PrKra.atv. .7stem .clsrwta) te atnatve1 ..d t'etteeal Oaer.alttiee
ot eM r..al 99111441 etre.latlee. 1W., &1-4{, /1, 1974.
MrS.r, ,t.t., 6war.rs, S.C., hitoal .d.wle, dyqlaeL, e.d clear eell
ade.ecaretee.e attar dtetk7lattlkottrol tr.aanc tn yrotnaeey. okatetrice aw
Orsocol.p, 1j:643-632, 13, t1eT 1974.
CbAea, A.1., t:.t.3t Takr.rhi d taa.ars. S.C. llatslettc dtttareecc. tn
lt.aet sereta.r ot Jar.w" a>,d A.ertaa wme.. Ceeer, &1377-1379, 6,
Jww 1974.
.
4rtaa+e, V.l., Serrs, S.C., ft7l.r, L.S., MNell, C.w., C.Ilatar, .S.,
Bctter, L.T.9. 6 0290110. L.: The 9etlrlep VerlLLes Ctoup. Staodardtt.d
9Yeas..rot ot lraaat Spoetr.. Am. J, et Clta. Path., 60:719-791, 16, D.c.1973.
tartar, t.[., lets.an, t, fesm.re. S.C. 4 6Yakor, L.A. Caaaer .t tAa
wdo,.trts. Tom. IIW.. L:41-34, July 1974.
torellts, L.I, 6 tea,ars, S.C. Dittarsettal D1aSa"ts of Olcerativc and
Qraaule.etoua Celttle ky Stpsetdoscqy, taetel LioT.7 aed Call Counte of
bctol 1Mrc.+a. Art. l. Oa.tr.rt+r.l., Ut460-449, J,ee, 1974
Prowa. L.C., tr.re. t.tt.. taeehata. t.J.. tastedtee. >'.L. 6 LVOesera. S.C.
Mtetapkyletoecal Cle.ertla+qiritt. la iersla Ndieta. .T.S.l..f tf.d..
14:2241-2243. Ma.~.r 1974.
C..ld, 9.t., 1.pre, D.t. 6 Nsaert, S.C. 1ltthaltal-Mr.e let.rsletllaj
!a beip treut Ltatws. Arck, tah.J ~OV 39d-396, #11. erv+rker 1973.
~, ~- ~1
,
t~~ . ~~~
man
®
1._ Ti`4 i iN 014B221

THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
810 CONFIDENTIALITY AGREFMENT,
155. rtakar, s.R., ,ha alotlia. l., tLrqyl,C., trallio:, p., Lowmera. S.C. anE
11ehar, l. patbologic fiedin/a frof .tba eational aurtical adjuvint breas:
Nre)act -(?rotecol Mo. 4). '1. Ob..r..tioea toocaroitg th. .ulticentric-
Sty ef Nsary aaecar.,C.ecor, 21t2t7-2Sk, 1975.
256. laarers, S.C. rd toralitt, !.L : Nircosai-ca11 eounta to ulcerative ane
Rswler.ateua oaiit.ia. Arr. J. Clta. Patk.,.63:139-365, #3. N.rcn, 19::.
237. W.ller,3. 4 t...ara,S.C.: palateant patal:Scler.d.n.e A.er. J. of
!larap. a Clte: l.pna, 1:l1-Si 1975.
238. ltelwr, [.t.. Qrelorto, l.M., 1lahar, l., Sewmera, S.C.: Tbe pathology
f ta.u iv. krwt caaear. Cacar 31:1-aS, Vol. 36, #1 for July, 1973.
25~. Sonaaara,S.C., C.artar, N.L. A/rae9cortteal poatitTadiatioo )ibro.is, A::t.
- patl-, il:L21-421, lug. 1171.
240. Tsosaktt, 7.A., fae.are, S.C., ieydar, l.W. L Sabbath, H.: X-ray sicro-
wl"ts of lqatts tsorios daporltieeu, Arch. Path., 9l:2a1-2G2, Oct.1's'_.
261. lark.r, L l., S.80-era, t.C.e'"ar, l. .aE Troe, T.L.: liatolctlc aa2
wel.arlradi.e6 dVtro.a1 rsactiona aa tadie:aa for pulnoaia in ovara
crcor, A.ar. .]. of t1S/GTN., 151:7lS-307. K, ltarch, 1975,.
262. iereltta l.I. t l.~ara f.C.: -taspoeesa.to afrus therapy to olcrrative
:calttts - Lvaiuatioe by roctal'biopry, and bistopatbolosical chantes,
~ Ler. J. Cvttro.ctyrol.; papa, Ibwwsar 1975.
261. ~ htholap Dec.mtrlt (7 wlraa), Aplotve-C.ntery-Crofts. N.T.C..
44ttM by S.C. Nmera, 1975.
0
Ci i"+. i i i i 01-[' 822

C., Tallte., P., 're. f.C. and
sbe tution.l urtte.l edJu..nt bru.C
vtrttow coocernlnj the multicentrle-
-234,1973.
.eesal-cell couate !a uleerattve and
.. tatb.,.63:339-363, /), riarcA, 1973.
lacalricl.r.der.e. A.ar. J. of
3.
. 1., fotmeer., S.C.: iLe pathology
:1-I3, Vol. 36, I1 for July, 1973.
rt1u1 roatirr.dtattoe atbroet., Arcb.
!r, 1.V. & Salbath, M.: I-rayilcre-
.oes, Arch. tatb., 91:261-2i2. Oct.1974.
1. aad boe. T.1.: 1latelattc and
is a.c l.edie.r for Protm.i. in ovarian
:3-W7, 6, March, 1975.
e.wa 2o alrv.f therapy !a .leerative
r7 1t.d bi.topatbolotlcal eLanse.,
ar+.ber 1975.
Aletentoetory-Crofta, 11.T.C.,
/
Lnclosure /3
0
311 THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
CONFIDENTIAUTY AGREEMENT.
1973 IF
Ylitio.a1 Iafer.acaa
1. 1.1. Albert, /1.T. hterooa, h:*a.A D.i. lobniaj. Ireb. br.iroe. lltb.,
1973, 30. 361-367.
i
2. Z.L. labbott, l.C. 1a11,'D:f. Coup d D.L. lyl.e.t.r. /T11, Laltb 6
Yark !a A.erica m..tLtg, bovemmbar 16-20, 1975. Yatract, 2103.
3. J. Mdoarsaveki, A. Jee,. S. l;trlk a.d Y. ttllolajes7k. ?olakl T7jod. Lak.,
1973. 34,1737-1738.
. J.1. salcbar. 1rit. J. DL. Cl,.et, 1975, 69. 267-251.
3. T. iarla and 1.C. Tot.rlf. ic.N, J. 1975, 16, 109-119.
6. T. lar/e aed 1.C. Teems.la. {ea.d.'J. laaP. Dia., 1973, 16, 120-126.
7. C. lerglund and L. filialaaan, Aeta bad. soand., 1973, lfe. 291-296.
I. Y.J. tlot and J.T. 1rammummi, h. Lamsc.t, 1975, t, 162-11i.
9. t.li. lrare, tt.C. llar.et, f.T. /.eka d L.V. Lok. Mtar., 1973, 257.
306-307.
10. t.Y. Trars, t. fal.ta d D. 1Ka*.Sstala, Jr. Came.r, 1973, 16, 1903-1911.
11. 1.1.J. liacl. L.eeet, 1973, L T97.
12. J.1.J. lael. J. Soc. Oelq. IW 1973, n, 2-10.
13. i. ltasan. .1Y(/, 1973, :33, N1-N3.
14. K. Caplim and t. leotaeatata. brlt. Ited. J., 1973, 2,' SN., J.l. Yacdooald,
lbid (1.attar to ldltor).
13. l. Ceoke and 1. Teegaoi, A..t, l.I. J. If.d., 1975, 3_, 147-13t.
16. 1. Cordq .ed f.1. Ceei.7. r. J. Carliol., 1975. U, 330 (tdlterial).
17. Do 1. Dlt. J. l.7cboaa. De.., 1973, 19, 273-27/.
18. I. Doalaeb, [.I. Mttemiu.m o.d ri.t.t. iatler+. lrit. J. Ieduat. ti.d.,
1973, 12, 16-30.
19. P. ?folae. 'iba isstaialagm of 1.' A..t. 1.2. J. IYd., 1975, 3, 2/1,
(Abstract).
20. J.I. 4ft d T. farkal. Clla. 1W., 1975. 1.196A, (Abstract).
21. B.-t. 1ark., heaeti.e lf.d., 1973, 4, 373-374.
22. 1.J. 9tickq, l.C. -C1_tt~+. D.1. 1o7oe ..d t.J. le..r.. .tYVA, 1973,
J32, (Latter to tditer).
:
t..r TR t i N 014!. s 23

THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
312 CONFIDENTIALlTY AGREEMENT,
1ec1...ra 03 Caetiawd.
.. .
23. l.J. liek.7, l.C. Clallaad, D.I. 1oyea ied I.J. forara. Laacat, 1975,
1, 40-41, (L.ttar to tditor).
24. T.D. Itarlia&. Irs. J. Publ. dta., 1976, 66. 161. (ef alao I.T.t.
l1kia., 311d, 3Sl-161; I.D.J. Ire.a, ilid, 161 n. /tarling).
23. V.C. lisds md M.V. fir.t. 1. Bag. J. ri.d., 1973, 92,
I
26: C.L. 1u1ar. ti. h+s. J. riad, 1975, 293, «-19, (Lattar to tditor),
(alae lattars tq 1.T. Iv+t.oe and C.1. VLlllaa, .I. rrioaani., S.
T.atar, V.C. iial. aad 14V. /ir.t).
27. l. loe..r, T.J. lfa+oe. P.V. YtLa7 aed J.1. lr..a.nl, Jr. /clanca, 1975,
1005-1007.
28. l. ioowe{ and J.1. 1ram..ai, Jr., Lariiee. Lu ., 1975, 9. 196-207.
29. I. tr~ac, l. C.d.rlof aad L. TriDarl. 1.. J. Ipidaraiol., 1976, 101,
16-29. .
30. "0. Nr..tie and Y. iaric. Ar4it. ia iisi)aon Lada I Tek., 1975, 26, 15-22.
31. C.L. BnDar. . U{. J. li.d., 1975, 292, 85i-I59.
32. 1.J.' Iagalft.agar. 1. La{. J. Ibd.; 1973, 293: 1319-1320.
33. C.D. J~, C. T1oGhaa, !. ol..taa. i.J. ITswki, V.T. Iimaon and
C.C. fra.. J. ira /trw, 1975, 1_, YW6.
36. 1. Jimmat, t. Tenl and M.l. le..oklatt. Sull. .T. Aead. lf.d., 1975,
Sl, 432-438.
35. .D. Utr. T.J. Ialla, If.L. lkllLta7 and P. fvidar.k7. A.. /ev. [s.p. Di..,
1973, 3. 763073.
36. V. Llo.tarko(!ar mod I. Oeeo. Arkaitard.. Iotialaad., Travaotis.d., 1975,
12. 233.
37. l. La..rgoa, L. Rsy'lar-Dr.ijooo aad J. It-?larra. Onieo ls.dlc.la du
Cam.d., 1975, 1104. 1397-1406.
38. /. Lala.ita, I. LSeltar and T.I. lio.a.. ioe. iei. 6 M.d., 1975. 9, 207-219.
J9. K.D. LMe+itt and I. Larror.. Ct.aat, 1976, 69. 6-50.
40. Y.1. l.a.aodal. A. lfuai, l. Irda17 sad C. Lit.ai. Zait.cLrilt fuer f.7cAo-
so.at. li.d. 6 lqeso.a.1., 1975, =1. 270-2a3.
41. D. Iaedbarl, T. Tboorall ..d I. Lind. J. TrTcboao.at. La.. 1975. 19.
27-32.
42. T.1. Max..o .nd C.I. Ldoe,d. r. hart J., 1975, !0, 380-3a6.
43. L l. Martia, D. LSadsal. P. D.qa.. D. /ruca, M. l.rous, I.l. Lathoni..n
sd l.T. Ibeklm. r. le.. laP. Di.., 1975. 7. 119-125.
u. l.T. rieCu13a11 and L.l. lal.a,. ri.d. J. Aust.. 1975, 2. 173-175.
t.. = i'i, t 1 N 01"C 6L"C

.d., 1973, 292, t44-/43.
/-69, (Ltt.r to lditor),
Villi..., A.1. Tri..aata, S.
.7. 1rns.ai, Jr. kiasc., 1975,
x. i.a., 1973, 9. 196-207.
6.. J. 1tpllarsiol., 1976. JA03.
j.ou lada 1 Tok., 1975. 26, 13-22.
4Si-139.
203, 1319-1320.
J. 27saoali, M.T. /iaqwe and
"6.
. lal]. .T. ". 1Md., 1973,
i P. "arak7. r. la.. l.ay. Di..,
i., ze.ialaad., Trawoti.rd., 1973,
St-?iarra. Doloo riadical du
, Soc. Sei. 4 h.d., 1975, 9_, 207-219.
76, 69. A6-S0.
S. 1.it.ai. 2.itacLritt [aar T.7cbo-
0-213.
. Ta7cbo.o.at. l.a., 1973, 19,
t J., 1973, 22. 360-36d.
truea, M. l.roua, .l. AetLouiaat.
1973, 7, 119-123.
A++.t., 1975, 2, 173-173
I
tDclo.ura /3 Continwd.
THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
313 CONFIDENTIAUTY AGREEMENT.
45. N.L. IkIlL..a7, J.V. fLa!!.r .od 1.A. li~s.,'Jr. T1a Joboa iophios Mad. -
J., 1973, 156, 37-ii.
6. .J. Ibr.rits. lo.y. ttaet., 1973, (&uvuat), ".33 6 39.
47. l.f. h
THIS DOCUMENT SUBJECT TO
314 DpNFIDENTIAUTY AGREEMENT.
N. t.[. Yall.r sd l.J. Lrtkrr. r.tvr., 1576, M, SSf-560, aad M.G.
llatoot, t.Y. 1rwn, {.T. i.e1u tad L.Y. bok. PP.S60-S61.
61. .1. tidl. JNY, 2975. jZ4, 3s0(L.tt.r to tA. tdttor).
r
70. A.t. RLe.r, LI. 1a.cL.t.J. 01sao sad D.L. traij. A.. Lndn.t. l7t.
Nwc. J., 2975 ao...ib.r), i01-J10.
71. V. Y.i." aad :.1~. leocet. JtlY, 1975. 2364. 1139-11t2.
E..r 1R t i t Z 01"1" 826
