Council for Tobacco Research
Biological Activity of Tobacco Smoke and Tobacco Smoke-Related Chemicals Environmental Health Perspectives Vol. 29 [St Refers to Role of Tobacco Chemicals in Biological Processes]
Abstract
MAR
Fields
- Type
- SCIENTIFIC ARTICLE
- BIBLIOGRAPHY
- Grant Number
- Gr01694
- Master ID
- 60026423-6429
- Named Person
- Environmental Health Perspectives
- Ctr
- Burke
- Dwyer, C.
- Mayer
- Saffiotti
- Swain
- Ventura, A.
- Ctr
- Author
- Benedict, W.F., Childrens Hospital Los Angeles
- Brandt, K.R., Mai
- Curren, R.D., Mai
- Henry, C.J., Mai
- Kouri, R.E., Mai
- Rude, T.H., Mai
- Schechtman, L.M., Mai
- Sosnowski, R.G., Mai
- Brandt, K.R., Mai
- UCSF Legacy ID
- thu00a00
Document Images
Ettr ir~u c tlr Per.rpectires
Vol. 29, pp. 63-69. /979 April
~ W uo/
Biological Activity of Tobacco Smoke
and Tobacco Smoke-Related Chemicals
by Richard E. Kouri,* Thomas H. Rude,* Rodger D.
Curren,'` Karen R. Brandt, ~- Ronald G. Sosnowski,*
Leonard M. Schechtman,* William F. Benedict, i and
Carol J. Henry >`
Exposure to whole cigarette smoke from reference cigarettes results in the prompt (peak activity is
6
hrs). but fairly weak (- 2 fold), induction of murine pulmonary microsomal monooxygenase activity..
This
activity can be detected by using as substrates either benzo(a)pyrene or ethoxyresoruftn, and can be
inhibited by treatment with cycloheximide or actinomycin D. Unlike the induction of pulmonary
monooxygenases following intratracheal administration of 3-methylcholanthrene, these cigarette
smoke-induced increases were not unequivocally linked to the Ah locus.
Whole smoke condensate and fractions derived from these condensates can; a) induce pulmonary
monooxygenase activity, b) inhibit benzo(a)pyrene metabolism in citro, cl be metabolized to forms
mutagenic to Salmonella typhitnurium tester strains TAI538 or TA98, d) transform C3H 10T'h cells in
ritro, and e) enhance the carcinogenicity of benzo(a)pyrene in murine pulmonary tissue. A
potentially
important observation is that whereas hepatic tissue is capable of activating whole cigarette smoke
condensate to mutagenic forms in citro, murine pulmonary tissue does not seem capable of such
activa-
tion. Although these pulmonary-derived tissue homogenates have significant AHH activity and can
metabolize Aflatoxin B. 2-aminofluorene and 7;8-dihydro-7,8-dihydroxybenzo(a)pyrene to mutagenic
forms, these homogenates fail to activate both cigarette smoke condensate and the pro-mutagen, 6-
aminochrysene. These results are discussed with reference to the concept that whole cigarette smoke
may
be both a potential "initiator" and "promotor" of lung cancer in mice, and that this latter property
may
be the most important in determining cancer risk.
Introduction
Cancer is not randomly distributed among the
human population (/ ), rather, both environmental
(2) and genetic (3-5) factors strongly influence its
occurrence. Lung cancer is a specific example of a
neoplasia whose occurrence is nonrandomly
distributed. Its incidence is often associated with
cigarette smoking (6), but the actual role that to-
bacco smoke or smoke-related chemicals play in
this association is unclear.
A potential role of tobacco smoke involves in-
teraction with those microsomally-bound mono-
' Microbiological Associates. Department of Biochemical On-
cology. 5221 River Road. Bethesda. Maryland 20016.
' Children's Hospital of Los Angeles. Los Angeles. California
90027.
oxygenases that seem important in determining sus-
ceptibility to chemically-induced cancer in model
animal systems (7. 8). These enzymes are important
because not only do they metabolize many en-
vironmental chemicals, but also naturally occurring
variations in their steady-state levels are genetically
linked with susceptibility to toxicity. mutagenesis,
and carcinogenesis induced by many of the same
chemicals (7. 9-1 / ).
Three basic questions can be addressed con-
cerning the role of tobacco smoke in cancer suscep-
tibility in man: (a) Does tobacco smoke contain
chemicals that interact with the microsomal
monooxygenases? (b) If they do interact, what are
some of the in tiru and in ritru effects? (c) Can
certain individuals or tissues within an individual be
at greater risk than others from the effects of
tobacco-related chemicals'?
April 1979
ASCA June 15, 1979
63
g~K,'r.r~~'~
1Z __.*_t,'~

Does Tobacco Smoke Contain
Chemicals Capable of Interacting
ith the Monooxygenase
6ystems?
Kinetics of increase of pulmonary AHH levels
in C57BL`6 (B6): DBA;?J (D2). and C3H/fCum (C3)
strains uf mice exposed to I A I cigarettes are shown
in Figure 1. Results ,ug
,gested that there were rapid
increases in pulmonary AHH activity that peaked
by 6 hr post-exposure. and that these induced en-
zymes remained at this level for at least 24 hr. The
D2 strain wus virtu,tlly nonresponsive to this smoke
expouue compared with B6 and C 3 strains: this re-
sult paralleled that found when a pulycyclic aro-
matic h_vdrucarbun (PAH). 3-methvlcholanthrene
(MC), was given intratracheally to the same strains
(see Fig. 1). However. the kinetics of induction of
pulmonary AHH by smoke are different from those
obtained when MC was used as an inducer. The
peak of activity in the. smoke induced lungs oc-
curred at 6 hr (vs. 24 hr for MC). Also the half-life of
the smoke-induced enzyme was much longer (-24
hr vs.. -4 hr): Finally, these smoke exposure condi-
tions did not induce the AHH activity in liver.
colun. and kidney (data not shown) whereas MC-
treatment did: moreover. filtered smoke (gas phase)
did not induce enzyme activity in lung. liver, or
1.0 ~
0.751-
66-
CIGARETTE SMOKE
~ 02
C3H
~ 050 ~
3 0 25 ~ ,"~--°-~+.-.o ~3 1 ~-I MCA 1200~Lug~IT1 I,
T ~ 66 p 02 ~ C3H I
_ 20 f
a r
r
toi ~
os~ s~~ ,-0
3 6 9 12 24 3 6 9 12 24
HOURS
3 6 9 12 24
FicuttE I. Pulmonary response ofC3HifCum. C57BL6Cum. and
DBA2J inbred strains of mice to MC and whole cigarette
smoke. Mice were either treated with 200 µg MCA/0?rir
gelatin-saline solution intratracheally (IT) as described previ=
owsly (12) and sacrificed at the time periods specified or ex-
posed to four cigarettes from a Walton smoking machine
employing a 2-sec puff. 10rh smoke. 30-sec exposure, and
30-sec purge (/.l). Mice were given a 2-min rest period before
exposure to the next cigarette and were sacrificed at varying
times after the fourth cigarette. Lungs were excised and fro-
zen at -70'C until assayed. AHH units are expressed as
nmole 3-OH-BP formed:mitng wet weight tissue (12). Aver-
age activity of three animals is given.
kidney tissue (data not shown). Smoke-induced
AHH in the lung was similar to MC-induced AHH.
in that both tue -capable of (1-deethylation uf
ethoxyresorulin (Table 1): see Burke and Mayer
(15) for data on MC as an inducer. Data with
ethoxyresiirufin were particularly interesting be-
cause studie, have suggested that this chemical is a
specific substrate fur the P-448 (or P,-450) cyto-
c:hrome (/6 ). This is the cytochrome that is inti-
mately associated with metabolizing hen-
zo[alpyrene (BP) and MC to cvtotoxic (17-19).
mutagenic (2). DNA-binding (?/. 22). and car-
cinogenic (y. !(/) forms. Similar to MC-induced
AHH ievels. the smoke-induced enzyme levels ttre
dependent upon in tiro protein and RNA synthesis
(see "I <tble 1).
Although tobacco smoke induced AHH activity
in the B6 strain preferentially to the D2 titrain. the
genetic basis for this difference may not be the same
ati that for the difference in AHH activity induced
by MC. Figure 2 showti that, whereas MC given
intratracheally to (B6D2) FI x D2 progeny induced
pulmonary AHH activity in approximately 501-,~
(13 29) of the mice (12. 13). no clearcut discrimina-
tion was observed in the smoke-exposed animals.
However, it may be that the inducing capacity of
cigarette smoke for pulmonary tissue is just too low
to easily evaluate its genetic regulation.
Whole.tobacco smoke can be collected bv con-
densation with the use of Dry Ice, and this cigarette
smoke condensate (CSC) or fractions derived
therefrom (23) can be evaluated for potential
biological effects. The fractionation scheme and
Table t. Effect of cycioheximide and actinomycin D on smoke-
induced BC3F, lung AHH and ethox.resorufin O-deethylase
activitv.'
reatment AHH
activity,
nmole;min-g
tissue' O-Deethylase
activity
nmoleimin-g
tissue!"
Machine controls 0.35 <0.04
Smoke - 0.70 0.61
Smoke + saline 0.67 0.83
Smoke - propylene glycol 0.53 0.83
Smoke + cycloheximide, 500 µg/g 0.32 0.14
Smoke + actinomycin D. I µg~g 0.42 0.15
".Cycloheximide and actinomycin D were injected in-
traperitoneally (tP) in saline or in propylene glycol respective(y,
immediately before exposure to one 2A1 cigarette on a Walton
smoking machine. Methods given in legend to Fig. I. Mice were
sacrificed 6 hr after smoke exposure. Procedures were as de-
scribed by Van Cantfort and Gielen (14).
AHH units are expressed as nmole 3-OH-BP formed.min.g
wet weight of tissue. Average activity of three animals.
()-Deethylase units are expressed as nmoles resorufin
furmed. mia g wet weight of tissue according tu the procedures of
Burke and Mayer (15).
64 Environmental Health Perspectives

n
a
~
Z
a
NON-RESPONSIVE RESPONSIVE
~
i m.23 2 o.1m m
95 -0 301 i
.
' o aa o o ~
L~ o0o ao 0o e~ o 0
i
0
z
9
Z
0
o~oa,o~ooooa
.i
0.1 0.5 1.0 1.5
AHH ACTIVITY IUNITS g TISSUE'MINI
SAIt, actually inhibiting AHH levels in the lungs.
The fractions that induced AHH activity (e.g. B,a or
B,b) contained chemicals that could metabolically
compete with BP in an in ritrv assay (see Table 2).
This implies that CSC contains not only chemicals
that induce pulmonary AHH. but also chemicals
that are potential substrates for these enzymes.
What Are Some in Vitro and in .
Vil'ro Effects of Tobacco-Related
Chemicals?
Ftct:RE'_. Pulmonary response of B6D2F, x D2 progeny to (top)
MC and (bottom) whole cigarette smoke. Animals were gen-
erated and housed as described before (/2). Inoculation of
MC and smoke exposure was given as described in legend to
Figure 1. AHH activity was determined 24 hr after IT instilla-
tion of MC and 6 hr after exposure to cigarette smoke. Mean
and standard deviation is given for the MC-treated popula-
tions that are representative of the nonresponsive (0.23 -
0.10) and responsive (0.95 = 0.30) populations.
nomenclature were as described by Swain et al.
(26). Table 2 summarizes some of these effects. In-
tratracheal administration of the whole CSC and re-
constituted fractions induced a small. but signifi-
cant, increase in pulmonary AHH activity. The
CSC fractions varied in their capacity to induce
AHH activity with the fractions B,a, B,b, N.tr.r~rr
and N.,.1f the best inducers, fractions BF and WAr
weaker inducers. and fractions B,, SAr, SAF and
In Vitro Assays
The preceding section showed that tobacco smoke
contains chemicals which interact with the
monooxygenase system. This interaction can be
beneficial if it produces nonbiologically active:
polar metabolites which can be excreted from the
body. or it can be detrimental if it results in inter-
mediates with exceptional biological potency. Table
2 shows that 1 A 1 CSC fractions are metabolized bv
enzyme fractions from rat liver to forms mutagenic
to tester strains TA1538 (25. 27) of Scrlmonellu
tYp/rinurrium. and also by endogenous cellular en-
zymes to forms capable of transforming the C3H
10Ttiz cells in culture. This table also depicts the
levels of nicotine, phenols, and BP in fractions B,,.
WA,.., and N.,.tr-the fractions which contain virtu-
Table 2. Effects of fractions of tAI. cigarette smoke condensate (CSC) in various,model systems.
Fraction"
Content,
mgicig
AHH inducibility° (X)lBP
to give 50r/c
inhibition''
Mutagenesis'' Transformation''
Whole CSC 23.50 1.7 5.0 +++ +
Reconstituted CSC 23.00 1.8 - 5.2 +++ +
B,a 0.81 3.6 0.8 + + -
B,b 0.29 2.5 0.5 + + +
BF 0.95 1.5 3.0 + -
B,,. 0.36 0.5 > 10.0 - -
WA, 2.27 1.6 5.0 + + +
WAF. 1.98 1.1 2.0 -
SA, 0.39 0.5 >10.0 _
SAF. 0.78 0.3 > 10.0
SAR. 8.69 0.4 > 10.0
N.,,,,oN 1.19 2.5 3.0 _
N,,, 4.58 1.2 ND
N,s, 0.70 3.2 1.0
° Whole CSC has 21.0 mg nicotine/g, 5.70 mg phenols/g, and 0.98 µg BP/g. Reconstituted CSC has
22.0 mg nicotine/g. 5.5 mg
phenols/g, and 0.90 µg BP/g. BE has 31.0 mg nicotine/g. WAt has 41 mg phenolslg, and N,.,,, has
31.1 µg BP/g. Details given by Patel et
al. (23).
'' AHH inducibility = effect of fractions of 1 A I CSC fractions on pulmonary AHH activity of C57BL6
Cum mice relative to a corn oil
control (12).
' BP inhibition = competitive in vitro effect of CSC fractions of BP metabolism by hepatic
microsomes from 3-methylcholanthrene-
treated C57BL6 mice (/3).
" Mutagenesis = mutagenic activity of lAl CSC fractions in Sa(nonella t.phinrurism TA 1538 in the
presence of liver microsomal
S-9 mix (24).
` Transformation = malignant transformation frequency in C3H 10T1%2 Cl. 8 cells treated with CSC
fractions (25).
April 1979 - 65

ally all of these.three chemicals. The most biologi-
cally active fractions are not those that contain the
BP or phenols. The Bla and Blb fractions have not
'-Aen analyzed for their chemical content. However,
cause of the nature of the fractionation scheme
(B,a = bases insoluble after ether, B,b = bases in-
soluble before ether), these fractions could contain
some aromatic amine-like chemicals.
A similar distribution of mutagenic activity was
found with CSC fractions from the 2A1 reference
cigarette (Table 3), and such activity was observed
to be stable even if the fractions were stored frozen
for one year. Thus, for at least two different types of
cigarettes., certain fractions of their condensates can
be metabolized to forms that are active in an in vitro
mutagenesis test system.
However, subsequent studies (Table 4) revealed a
potentially important hindrance to the extrapolation
of the foregoing studies to an in vivo situation.
Mouse pulmonary tissue preparations, under con-
ditions where BP is significantly metabolized to
3-OH-BP (see AHH levels), failed to significantly
activate either 2A1 condensate or 6-aminochrysene
(6-AC) to forms mutagenic to the TA98 tester strain.
Table 3. Mutagenesis of TA 98 with 2A1 cigarette smoke condensate (CSC) fractions."
ontent, Mutants per plate
per 250 Ecg of
sample Calculated mutants
per plate per
cigarette
Activity. %
Fraction mg/cig Expt I Expt 2 Expt I Expt 2 Expt I Expt 2
Whole CSC 40.00 133 122 21.280 19,520
Reconstituted CSC 39.50 159 148 25.122 23,284
BI° 0.60 987 1.149 2.369 2.758 11 10
BI° 0.24 3.510 5.266 3.370 5.055 16 18
Be 1.04 1.258 2,065 5.233 8.590 25 30
Bµ. 0.52 102 151 212 314 1 I
WAt 3.63 289 394 4.196 5.721 20 20
WAE 2.66 141 206 1.500 2,192 7 8
SA, 1.44 53 43 305 248 2 1
SA£ 0.88 8 14 28 49 0 0
SA 15.60 8 20 499 1.248 2 4
NM,o 2.16 65 93 562 804 3 3
NcH 9.54 57 24 2.175 916 10 3
N,..,, 1.24 80 139 397 689 2 2
° The 2A1 (low nicotine) CSC fractions were generated by Meloy Laboratories according to the
methods of Patel et al. (23) and the
,)ur plate incorporation mutagenesis assay was performed according to the methods of Kier et al.
(24).
Table 4. Capacity of TCDD-induced mouse hepatic and pulmonary S-9, and Aroclor 1254-induced rat
hepatic S-9 to activate whole
cigarette smoke condensate to form(s) mutagenic to S. typhimurium TA 98P
Compound
AHH
Survival
Mutants/
late
Source of S-9 Type /cg/plate Protein. mg .
pmole/tube° .
''/er p
(minus background)
C57BL/6 hepatic
Pour plate
2A 1
650
3.14
4929
115
AFB, 1 3.14 4929 170
Suspension 2A1 260 3.14 4929 109 61
6-AC 5 3.14 4929 102 115
C57BL/6 pulmonary
Pour plate
2A1
1300
11.5
8800
8
AFB, 25 11.5 8800 250
Suspension 2A1 1300 1.44d 1071 105 5
6-AC 125 6.90 3208 83 3
Rat hepatic
Pour plate
2A1
1300
4.43
9625
185
AFB, 1 4.43 9625 760
Suspension 2A 1 650 2.95 7371 106 83
6-AC 0.5 0.03 190 82 315
" Pour plate incorporation mutagenesis assays were performed according to the method of Kier et al.
(24). Suspension assays
consisted of a 35 min incubation of a mixture of bacteria. S-9, and test chemicals in a buffer
composed of 3.6 mM NADPH. 4.2 mM
NADH. 3 mM MgClz, 8.1 mM NazHPO4. 1.5 mM KH2PO,. 2.7 mM KCI and 137 mM NaCl.
° As pmole 3-OH-BP formed per assay tube: total time was 35 min: 25 µg BP/ml was substrate.
* Percentage of bacteria surviving 35 min suspension relative to TA 98 alone.
d Subsequent assays with 11.5 mg protein. 8800 units AHH, and 1300 tc.g 2A 1 still showed no induced
mutants.
66 Environmental Health Perspectives

Under similar conditions both rat and mouse he-
patic tissue could activate both 6-AC and the 2A1
CSC to mutagenic intermediates. However, the
pulmonary S-9 preparations were capable of ac-
tivating aflatoxin B, (AFB,) (see Table 4), 7,8-
dihydro-7,8-dihydroxybenzo(a)-8-dio[ pyrene-7,
and 2-aminofluorene (2-AF) to mutagenic forms
(Table 5). Thus, the lung preparations were
metabolically active by some measures, but did not
activate 6-AC or CSC. That the tissue hypotheti-
cally at risk to tobacco-associated carcinogenesis
seems unable to activate the tobacco smoke con-
densate allows many interesting interpretations
which will be discussed in the last section of this
report.
In Vit;o Studies
Tobacco smoke condensate fractions have been
shown to "promote" carcinogen-initiated skin
tumors in mice (28, 29). Table 6 demonstrates that
at least some fractions from the' 2A I CSC are capa-
ble of acting synergistically with intratracheally in-
stilled BP (with or without FeLOa), resulting in a
much higher incidence of lung cancers in BC3Fl
mice; see Saffiotti (30) for discussion on use of
Fe..O in pulmonary cancer model systems. BP
alone (given every other week for 6 weeks) resulted in
only one malignant tumor by 39 weeks after treat-
ment out of a total of 82 treated animals (combining
animals,given 0.6 mg and 1.2 mg BP per treatment).
Table 5. Activation of 7,8-dihydro-7,8-dihydroxybenzo[alpyrene (7,8-diol) and 2-aminofluorene (2-AF)
by pulmonary S-9:'
Pulmonary S-9,
mg protein 2-AF.
µg/tube 7.8-diol.
µg/tube AHH.
pmole/tube° Survival,
~7e'' Mutants/
plate
6.57 25 1904 48 536
10 1925 81 668
10 1904 61 521
3.28 25 1452 52 458
10 1452 52 540
5 1680 101 627
0 25 - 82 39
10 - 84 52
6.57 0.5 1928 57 544
3.28 0.5 1680 18 338
0 1.0 - 88 76
0 0.1 - 99 84
TA 98 alone - - 100 20
" Suspension assays performed according to procedures given in Table 4.
° AHH = pmoles 3-OH-BP formed per 35 min incubation in separate tubes containing 25 fcg BP/ml as
substrate.
Percentage of viable bacteria after 35 minute assay relative to TA 98 alone.
Table 6. Evaluation of cocarcinogenic effects of 2A1 CSC and selected fractions of the condensates
on BP-initiated
lung cancers in BC3F, mice.a
Gel CSC fraction°
Treatment group saline° B,a B,b WA, N.,,o RFT SM°
No other treatment 0/118 0/37 1/47 0/28 1/40 0/68 0/50
0.6 mg Fe._O, 0/48 1/47 0/71 0/48 0/46 2/65 0/51
0.6 mg BP 1/43 10/64 5/74 14/59 19/82 4/60 13/58
1.2 mg BP 0/39 9/62 3/35 12/46 34/79 4/79 10/58 9/66
0.6 mg BP + mg FeZ0, 3/60 7/64 4/40 2/40 3/50 3/42 1/56
1.2 mg BP + 0.6 mg FeZO, 7/69 9/71 13/57 6/55 10/74 5/47 i l/50
" Groups of BC3F,/Cum female mice (8-14 weeks old) were intratracheally (IT) inoculated once every 2
weeks for a total of 6 weeks
with 0.02 ml gelatin-saline solutions of BP, FelO3, BP:FeZO, alone or in combinations with the
cigarette smoke condensate (CSC)
fractions (10 µg each). At the end of the "car.cinogen treatment" period. IT treatment with the
appropriate CSC fractions was
continued once every 2 weeks until 4 weeks prior to sacrifice. Data presented represents tumor
incidence for mice randomly sacrificed
after 26 and 39 weeks on test. The tumor types diagnosed histopathologically include alveologenic
adenocarcinomas, adenosquamous
carcinomas, squamous cell carcinomas, and squamous neoplasms. A more complete description of these
lung cancers is given
elsewhere (33).
b Data given in terms of the number of mice with lung carcinomas per the total number of animals at
risk.
RF = reconstituted fractions.
° SM = starting material.
April 1979 67

Addition of ferric oxide (Fe,O,) with BP resulted in
8rl~ malignant tumors (30). However, treatment with
selected 2A I condensate fractions every other week
for the duration of the study (39 weeks), resulted in
significantly increased malignant lung lesions in
animals treated with both BP alone or with BP plus
Fe..O;,. The fractions alone, or with Fe.:O,,, resulted
in few malignant tumors (5 out of a total of 764
treated animals). Thus, in an in riro lung tumor
model system, the fractions seemed to have mainly
"promotor-like" activity.
Can Individuals or Tissues within
an Individual Differ in Risk to the
Effects of Tobacco-Related
Chemicals?
The answers to this question are at best complex.
The results of studies discussed in the previous sec-
tions can be somewhat difficult to reconcile. On the
one hand, tobacco smoke contains chemicals that
interact with hepatic mixed-function oxidases such
as AHH, and this metabolism generates inter-
mediates that are mutagenic and transforming in in
iitro test systems. On the other hand. CSC is not
activated to mutagenic forms by mouse-derived
pulmonary tissues in titrv. Also, CSC material does
not seem to efficiently cause lung tumors in tiru.
Many interpretations are feasible. Perhaps the lack
of activation is characteristic of mouse pulmonary
tissue alone and cannot be generalized to other
species. In point of fact, rat pulmonary tissue has
been reported to activate certain smoke conden-
sates to mutagenic forms (24). However, both rat
and human lung tissues have also failed to activate
CSC material (24. 31). and so the generality of the
activation (or lack thereof) is still not understood.
Second, the fact that hepatic tissue can activate
these condensates suggests that tobacco material
could be activated by this organ and, following that,
the tissues at risk (e.g., lung) would be exposed to
these active forms. Or third, the lung is at risk only
for the effects of those chemicals in cigarette smoke
capable of "promoting" the carcinogenic event that
may be initiated by a myriad of environmental pol-
lutants.
The first interpretation is difficult to assess be-
cause no lung cancer model animal system directly
applicable to man is currently available. However,
the kind of pulmonary lesions observed in mice fol-
lowing exposure to known chemical carcinogens,
that is, bronchogenic squamous cell carcinomas, al-
veolar adenocarcinomas, and adenosquamous car-
cinomas. resemble lesions found in man (32. 33).
Some data suggest that the liver plays a major
role in the eventual susceptibility of other organs to
chemically-induced cancers (34). However, no evi-
dence is available to suggest that lung tissue is at
risk from liver-metabolized chemicals. Evaluation
of this alternative in titu will be difficult because of
the close liver/lung relationship.
The third interpretation is particularly intriguing
and suggests that "promotion" represents the real
risk of cigarette smoke to lung tissue. This idea is
consistent with the following facts: (a) tobacco
smoke condensate is capable of "promoting"
mouse skin carcinogenesis: (b) tobacco-smoke con-
densate can "promote" lung carcinogenesis in
model animal systems (see Table 6): (c) the condi-
tions of cigarette-smoke exposure that result in the
highest risk of human lung cancer are quite similar
to those that are most promotive in animal test sys-
tems: that is, frequent and relatively prolonged
treatment: (d) the chemicals in cigarette smoke
(particulate phase) that are known initiators of car-
cinogenesis may be too low in concentration [total
= 400 ng/cigarette (35)] to- initiate significant trans-
formation in vivo. The evaluation of whole cigarette
smoke as a potential initiator and promoter of lung
cancer in the inbred strains of mice is now being
studied in our laboratory.
NOTE ADDED IN PROOF: We have recently found
that a pulmonary S-9 preparation from Aroclor
1254-induced mice is capable of weakly activating
6-AC to a bacterial mutagen with the use of a pour
plate assay (2-3-fold over background). We have still
not observed an increase in bacterial mutations using
this S-9 preparation and 2A 1 cigarette smoke con-
densate.
This study was supported in part through contracts from The
Council for Tobacco Research Inc., U.S.A.. New York. N. Y.
The authors thank Ms. A. Ventura and Ms. C. Dwyer for their
assistance in typing this manuscript.
REFERENCES
I. Lynch, H. T. Cancer Genetics. Charles C Thomas.
Springfield. III., 1978.
2. Mason, T. J. Atlas of Cancer Mortality for U. S. Counties:
1950-1969. U. S. DHEW. Public Health Service NIH.
Bethesda. Md., 1975.
3. Lynch, H. T.. Guirgis. H. A.. and Albert. S. Familial associ-
ation of carcinoma of the breast and ovary. Surg. Gynecol.
Obstet. 138: 717 (1975).
4. Knudson. A. G. The genetics of childhood cancer. Cancer
35: 1022 (1975).
5. Petrakis. N. L.. and King, M. C. Genetic markers and
cancer epidemiology. Cancer 39: 1861 (1977).
68.
Environmental Health Perspectives

6. Hammond. E. C.. Garfinbel. L.. Seidman. H., and Lew.
E. A. "Tar" and nicotine content of cigarette smoke in rela-
tion to death rates. Environ. Res. 12: 263 (1976).
7. Kouri. R. E., and Nebert. D. W. Genetic regulation of sus-
ceptibility to polycyclic-hydrocarbon-induced tumors in the
mouse. In: Origins of Human Cancer. Cold Spring Harbor
Laboratories Press. Cold Spring Harbor. N. Y.. 1977.
8. Thorgeirsson. S. S., and Nebert, D. W. Genetic regulations
of the metabolism of chemical carcinogens and other foreign
compounds. Adv. Cancer Res. 25: 149 (1977).
9. Kouri. R. E.. Ratrie. H.. Ill, and Whitmire. C. E. Genetic
control of susceptibility to 3-methylcholanthrene-induced
subcutaneous sarcomas. Int. J. Cancer 13: 714 (1974).
10. Kouri. R. E. Relationship between levels of aryl hy-
drocarbon hydroxylase activity and susceptibility to 3-
methylcholanthrene and henzo(aupyrene-induced cancers in
inbred strains of mice. In: Polynuclear Aromatic Hy-
drocarbons: Chemistry. Metabolism and Carcinogenesis.
R. I. Freudenthal and P. W. Jones. Eds.. Raven Press. New
York. 1976. p. 139.
11. Kouri. R. E.. Rude. T. H.. Joglebar. R.. Dansette. P. M..
Jerima. D. M.. Attas. S. A.. Owens. 1. S.. and Nebert.
D. W. 3.3.7.8-Tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin acts as cocar-
cinogen in causing 3-methylcholanthrene-initiated sub-
cutaneous tumors in mice genetically "nonresponsive" at
the Ah locus. Cancer Res. 38: 2777 (1978).
12. Kouri. R. E.. Rude. T.. Thomas. P. E.. and Whitmire. C. E.
Studies on pulmonary aryl hydrocarbon hydroxylase activity
in inbred strains of mice. Chem.-Biol. Interact. 13: 317
(1976).
13. Kouri. R. E.. Demoise. C., and Whitmire. C. E. The signifi-
cance of aryl hydrocarbon hydroxylase enzyme systems in
the selection of model systems for respiratory car-
cinogenesis. In: Experimental Lung Cancer: Carcinogenesis
and Bioassays. E. Karbe and J. F. Park. Eds.. Springer-
Verlag. New York..1974, p. 48.
14. Van Cantfort. J.. and Gielen. J. Induction by cigarette smoke
of aryl hydrocarbon hydroxylase activity in the rat kidney
and lung. lnt. J. Cancer 19: 538 (1977).
15. Burke. M. D.. and Mayer. R. T. Ethoxyresorufin: direct
fluorometric assay of a microsomal O-dealkylation which is
preferentially inducible by 3-methylcholanthrene. Drug
Metabol. Disp. 2: 583 (1974).
16. Burke. M. D.. and Mayer. R. T. Inherent specificities of
purified cytochromes P-450 and P-448 toward biphenyl hy-
droxylation and ethoxyresorufin deethylation. Drug
Metabol. Disp. 3: 245 (1975).
17. Gelboin. H. V.. Huberman. E., and Sachs. L. Enzymatic
hydroxylation of benzo(a)pyrene and its relationship to
cytotoxicity. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. (U. S.) 64: 1188 (1969).
18. Lubet. R. A.. Brown. D. Q.. and Kouri, R. E. The role of
3-OH-benzo(a)pyrene in mediating benzo(a)pyrene-induced
toxicity and transformation in cell culture. Res. Commun.
Chem. Path. Pharm. 6: 929 (1973).
19. Wislocki. P. G.. Wood, A. W., Chang. R. L., Levin. W..
Yagi. M., Hernandez. O., Dansette. P. M.. Jerina. D. M.,
and Conney. A. H. Mutagenicity and cytotoxicity of
benzo(a)pyrene arene cixides. phenois. quinones. and dihy-
drodiols in bacterial and mammalian cells. Cancer Res. 36:
3350 (1976).
20. Felton. J. S.. and Nebert. D. W. Mutagenesis of certain ac-
tivated carcinogens in ritrn is associated with genetically
mediated increases in monooxygenases activity and cyto-
chrome P,-450. J. Biol. Chem. 250: 6769 (1975).
21. Nebert. D. W.. Boobis. A. R.. Yagi. H.. Jerina. D. M., and
Kouris. R. E. Genetic differences in mouse cytochrome P,-
450 mediated metabolism of benzo(a)pyrene in vitro and car-
cinogenic index in tivu. In: Biological Reactive Inter-
mediates. D. J. Jollow, et al.. Eds.. Plenum Press. New
York. 1977. p. 125.
1-2. NebeR, D. W.. Felton. J. S.. Kouri. R. E.. and Boobis.
A. R. Genetic differences in the binding of benzo(a)pyrene
metabolites to DNA in the mouse. In: Proceedings 3rd Inter-
national Symposium on Detection and Prevention of Cancer.
H. E. Nieburgs. Ed.. Marcel Dekker. New York. 1976. p.
120.
23. Patel. A. R.. Hag, N. Z.. Innerarity. C. L. Innerarity. L. T..
and Weissgraber. K. Fractionation studies of smoke con-
densate samples from Kentucky reference cigarettes. To-
bacco Sci. 18: 58 (1974).
24. Kier. L. D.. Yamasaki. E.. and Ames. B. N. Detection of
mutagenic activity in cigarette smoke condensate. Proc.
Natl. Acad. Sci. (U. S.) 71: 4159 (1974).
35. Benedict. W. F.. Rucker, N.. Faust. J.. and Kouri. R. E.
Malignant transformation of mouse cells by cigarette smoke
condensate. Cancer Res. 35: 357 (1975).
26. Swain. A. P., Cooper. J. E.. and Stedman. R. L. Large
scale fractionation of cigarette smoke condensate for chemi=
cal and biological investigations: Cancer Res. 29: 579 (1969).
17. Kouri. R. E.. Brandt. K.. Sosnowski. R.. Benedict. W. F.,
and Schectman. L. M. In vitro activation of cigarette smoke
condensate materials to their mutagenic forms. In: Pro-
ceedings of the Conference on Application of Short-Term
Bioassays in Fractionation and Analysis of Complex En-
vironmental Mixtures. M. Waters. Ed.. 1979.
28. Van Duuren. B. L.. Katz. C.. and Goldschmidt. B. M.
Cocarcinogenic agents in tobacco carcinogenesis. J. Natl.
Cancer Inst. 51: 703 (1973).
29. Lazar. P.. Chovrovlinkov. I. C.. Moree-Testa. P.. and
Hemon. D. Bioassays of carcinogenicity after fractionation
of cigarette smoke condensate. Biomed. 20: 214 (1974).
30. Saffiotti. U.. Montesano. R.. Sellakumar. A. R.. and Kauf-
man, D. G. Respiratory tract carcinogenesis in hamsters in-
duced by different numbers of administratiiirt of
benzo(a)pyrerie and ferric oxide. Cancer Res. 32: 1073
(1972).
31. Hutton. J. J.. and Hackney. C. Metabolism of cigarette
smoke condensates by human and rat homogenates to form
mutagens detectable by Salmuiudlu tcpkimnrrum TA 1538.
Cancer Res. 35: 2461 (1975).
32. Nettesheim. P.. and Hammons. A. S. Induction of squamous
cell carcinoma in the respiratory tract of mice. J. Natl.
Cancer Inst. 47: 696 (1971).
33. Kouri. R. E.. Rude, T. R.. Whitmire. C. E.. Henry. C. J..
Sass. B.- and Billups, L. H. Correlation of inducibility of
aryl hydrocarborr hydroxylase with susceptibility to 3-
methylcholanthrene-induced lung cancers. Submitted.
34. Kadlubar. F. F., Miller. J. A., and Miller. E. C. Hepatic
microsomal N-glucuronidation and nucleic acid binding of
N-hydroxy aryl-amines in relation to urinary bladder car-
cinogenesis. Cancer Res. 37: 805 (1977).
35. Weisburger. J. H.. Cohen, L. A.. and Wynder. E. L. On the
etiology and metabolic epidemiology of the main human
cancers. In: Origins of Human Cancer. H. Hiatt. J. D. Wat-
son. and J. A. Winsten. Eds. Cold Spring Harbor Labora-
tory Press. Cold Spring Harbor. N. Y.. 1977. p. 567.
f Apri11979 69
