Bliley RJReynolds
Report Concerning Smoking and Health Issues, Prepared by RJR Managerial Employee, Requesting Legal Advice From RJR in-House Legal Counsel.
Fields
- Author
- Fackelman, E.
- Recipient
- Witt, Samuel B., III (CTR and RJR Director & Gen. Counsel)Held various executive positions for RJR and Council for Tobacco Research
Document Images
USING SACCHARIN AND DRIVING WITHOUT A SEATBELT. HOWEVER,
THEY ALSO VIEW SMOKING AS A LOT LESS RISKY THAN TAKING
ILLEGAL DRUGS OR RIDING A MOTORCYCLE WITHOUT A HELMET.
VERY IMPORTANTLY, T~EY FELT THE ~ISK THEY WERE TAKING~BY~.,~
SMOKING WAS EQUIVALENT TO SUCH THINGS AS DRINKING ALCOHOL,
LIVING IN A POLLUTED CITY, EXCEEDING THE SPEED LIMIT AND
OVEREATING. THIS SENSE OF RELATIVE RISK IS IMPORTANT
BECAUSE IT HELPS US UNDERSTAND WHY PEOPLE CONTINUE TO
..SMOKE IN SPITE~OF,.WHAT~rTHEY;~BELIEVE~CONSTITUTES"~"~'~:~~'~'~'~
OYER~HELMING EVIDENCE IN SUPPORT OF THE HEALTH CASE
AGAINST SMOKING.
(SLIDE #21)
NEXT, LET'S TURN TO A DISCUSSION OF PASSIVE SMOKE. IT IS
SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT.IN NATURE BUT CERTAINLY POSES A VERY
SIGNIFICANT PROBLEM FOR OUR INDUSTRY.
(SL I DE #22)
TWO PRIMARY POINT~ NEED TO BE MADE ABOUT PASSIVE SMOKE.-.

FIRST OF ALL, PASSIVE SMOKE IS BELIEVED BY THE MAJORITY OF
ADULTS TO BE HAZARDOUS TO NONSMOKERS. SECONDLY, THIS
BELIEF IS CONTINUING TO GROW.
(SLIDE #23)
SHOWN ON THE CHART, IS THE PERCENTAGE OF ADULTS WHO SMOKE ;.
BELIEVE THAT PASSIVE SMOKE IS HARMFUL. AS YOU CAN SEE . ... ~ .... .~,,~.
• 74% OF NONSMOKERS"~BE~IEVE'~THIS' AND~'q9~ OF SMOKERS BELIEVE !-
THE PASSIVE SMOKE MYTH. THIS BELIEF AMONG BOTH GROUPS BAS
GROWN SIGNIFICANTLY AND CONSISTENTLY SINCE 1974.
(SLIDE #24)
WHILE, PASSIVE SMOKE IS BELIEVED TO BE UNHEALTHY TO
NONSMOKERS, JUST AS IMPORTANTLY, IT'S ALSO SEEN AS
IRRITATING. IN THE STUDY, WE ASKED PEOPLE IF SMOKE FROM
OTHER PEOPLE'S CIGARETTES IS MORE A FORM OF IRRITATION TO
THE NONSMOKER RATHER THAN A HEALTH RISK. OF ALL ADULTS,
53% IN TOTAL AGREED THAT IT WAS MORE A SOURCE OF
IRRITATION. NOT"SURPRISINGLY THIS PERCENTAGE WAS HIGHER

SI S33V~d 3lqSfld N[ 9NI~OWS 9NII31~IS3~ ~Od IN3Wfl9~V
1S39N0~1S 3H1 1VH1 SI 3~3H 30VW 3~ 01 INIOd INVI~OdW[ 3H1
(gz# 3~IIS)
"S~3~OWSNON O1 S~3~OWS BO S~SI~ HIIV3H
~3A133~3~ 0NV NOIlVlI~I ~3A133~3~ 3H1 N33MI3B I17~S N3A3
17~IV3 V 33S 01 ~N31 3M 3IlHM "S~3HOWSNON ~03 9NIHIV3~8
NI 37B~0~I Q3S~V3 II ~31VDI~NI OSlV ~3H1 "H17V3H ~01 ~0~
QVB 1S~F SVM lI ~31V31QNI SIN3~NOdS3~ 3HI ~0 %gz "IW3N39
NI HIIV3H 9NIQ~V93~ SIN3WW03 31glO3dS QVH OSlV X3HI
"S~3~OWSNON Q3~3HtOBNIVqd ISgC 3~OWS tVHI gNV "S~3~OWSNON
33~93~ HgIH V ~3MOHS S3SNOdS3~ 3H1 "S~3~OWSNON Q3133~V
3~OWS 3113~V913 MOH SISVB Q3QN3-N3dO NV NO G3~SV OSlV ~B
(SZ# 3~IIS)
• S~3HOWSNON ONV S~3~OWS 9NOWV

HEALTH.
(SLIDE #27)
AS AN EXAMPLE, WE ASKED WHAT PEOPLE CONSIDER TO BE THE
STRONGEST ARGUMENTS FOR THE RESTRICTION AND REGULATION OF
SMOKING. THE MAJORITY OF RESPONSES WE OBTAINED RELATED TO
THE HEALTH RISK FOR NONSMOKERS. THESE ARGUMENTS ARE
UNDERSTANDABLEI:$1NCE HEALTH ITSELF IS A MORE SOCIALLY
GRACEFUL AND ARGUABLE REASON FOR RESTRICTING PUBLIC
SMOKING THAN IS THE IRRITATION FACTOR.
(SLIDE #28)
IN SUMMARY, WE'VE SEEN THAT THE PRIMARY HEALTH CASE
AGAINST SMOKING IS.GENERALLY BELIEVED BY THE PUBLIC, AND
THAT NEITHER SMOKERS NOR NONSMOKERS FEEL THEY NEED MORE
INFORMATION ON THE TOPIC. SECONDLY, WE'VE SEEN THAT
SMOKING IS BELIEVED RELATED TO BOTH SHORT-TERM AS WELL AS
LONG-TERM EFFECTS. AND FINALLY, WE HAVE FOUND THAT WHILE
THE CASE AGAINST~IGARETIES IS WIDELY BELIEVED, SMOKING IS

SEEN AS SIMILAR TO OTHER RISKS PEOPLE TAKE DURING THEIR
NORMAL DAILY ACTIVITY.
WITH REGARD TO FASSIVE SMOKE, WE'VE SEEN THAT THE BELIEF
THAT PASSIVE SMOKE IS A HEALTH HAZARD IS GROWING.
SECONDLY, PASSIVE SMOKE SERVES AS A SOURCE OF BOTH
~,I RR ITAT ION~ AND ~ HEALTH, HAZARDS~.TO~:NONSMDKERS~, AND FINALLY~~
THE HEALTH ARGUMENT RELATING TO PASSIVE SMOKE CONSTITUTES
THE STRONGEST ARGUMENT FOR THE REGULATION OF PUBLIC
SMOKING.
• , (SLIDE #~0) :~
NEXT, LET'S TURN TO THE THIRD TOPIC AREA OF TODAY'S
PRESENTATION--SOCIAL ACCEPTABILITY.
(SLIDE #31)
IT'S HARD TO OVERSTATE THE IMPORTANCE OF SOCIAL

-
ACCEPTABILITY. TO UNDERSTAND JUST HOW IMPORTANT SOCIAL
ACCEPTABILITY IS TO SMOKING ITSELF, I NEED TO REFER BACK
TO THE 1981 SEGMENTATION STUDY. IN THAT STUDY, WE
IDENTIFIED SOCIAL INTERACTION AS~.ONE 01::, AND PROBABLY.,.:TBE,
PRIMARY BENEFIT PEOPLE RECEIVE FROM SMOKING.
(SLIDE #32)
CIGARETTES ARE~ USED BY.'PEOPLE~TO MAKE THEMSELVES~FEI~~~.¢''
COMFORTABLE AROUND OTHERS. THEY ARE USED IN THOSE
SITUATIONS .WHEN THEY ARE TRYING TO MAKE FRIENDS,, AND AS A
MEANS OF FEELING MORE MATURE AND ATTRACTIVE TO OTHERS. AS
SOCIAL ACCEPTABILITY DECLINES, IT THREATENS THIS PR1MARY
BENEFIT OF SMOKING. THIS THREAT TO SOCIAL INTERACTION IS
A VERY REAL ONE, SINCE SOCIAL ACCEPTABILITY IS IN FACT
DECLINING.
(SLIDE #33)
TODAY MORE THAN EVER BEFORE SMOKERS ARE FEELING
SELF-CONSCIOUS ABOUT PUBLIC SMOKING.',~

(SLIDE #34)
AS SHOWN IN THE CHART, 78% OF ALL SMOKERS SAY THEY EITHER ~ • ',
D ] REC TL Y, :0 R~. I ND l REC'T L y~ SEEK,~PERM ] SS l ON~ T O- SMOKE~ ~ W HEN~THE.Y.~ ~~ -~~ ~!~
~,c~.'.~~~
, , -. ,,~ , ..... : . , ~ .
ARE INDOORS. THE TREND FOR THIS BEHAVIOR HAS INCREASED i~
QUITE SIGNIFICANTLY IN THE PAST FOUR YEARS.
(SLIDE #35)
THIS BEHAVIOR ITSELF IS A DIRECT RESULT OF BOTH SMOKERS"
AND NONSMOKERS BELIEVING THAT SMOKING IN SOCIAL SITUATIONS
IS NOT GENERALLY ACCEPTABLE. WE ASKED PEOPLE MANY
QUESTIONS REGARDING THE DEGREE TO WHICH SMOKING IS
ACCEPTABLE.
(SLIDE #36)
WE FOUND IN TOTAL THAT PEOPLE BELIEVE IHAT MOST PEOPLE
OBJECT TO OTHERS SMOKING AROUND THEM. THIS IS TRUE AMONG
BOTH SMOKERS AND NON-SMOKERS. ALSO AMAJORITY OF PEOPLE,
BOTH SMOKERS ANDNON-SMOKERS AGREED THAT YOU ARE MORE
oO

ACCEPTABLE IN TODAY'S SOCIETY IF YOU DON'T SMOKE.
FINALLY, AND QUITE SURPRISINGLY, A SIGNIFICANT PERCENTAGE
OF PEOPLE AGREED THAT PEOPLE SMOKING AROUND THEM MAKES
THEM• .. FEEL •VERY... .UNCOMFORTABLE. . .
• FIFTY. PERCENT OF NONSMOKERS
FEEL THIS WAY AND EVEN 8% OF SMOKERS AGREE WITH THIS
STATEMENT• "
(SLIDE
AS WE SAW PREVIOUSLY, NONSMOKERS' CONCERNS ABOUT SMOKING
RELATE TO BOTH THE PASSIVE SMOKE HEALTH RISK AND THE
IRRITATION AND ANNOYANCE OF SECONDARY SMOKE. WHILE THE
PASSIVE SMOKEHEALTH ISSUE IS PRETTY STRAIGHT FORWARD, IT
IS HELPFUL TO EXPLORE THE SPECIFICS OF IRRITATION AND
ANNOYANCE FURTHER.
(SLIDE
WE FOUND IN OUR RESEARCH THAT EXHALED, SIDE STREAM SMOKE
AND THE ACCOMPANYING SMELL ARE KEY IRRITATING ELEMENTS OF
CIGARETTES. WE A~KED A NUMBER OF QUESTIONS THAT DEALT

VIITH THE KINDS OF IRRITATION THAT ARE ASSOCIATED WITH
CIGARETTE SMOKE.
WE DISCOVERED THAT THE VAST MAJORITY OF PEOPLE BELIEVE
THAT CIGARETTE SMOKE MAKES THEIR'CLOTHES AND HAIR SMELL.
THEY ALSO AGREED THAT IN CONFINED PLACES CIGARETTES OFTEN
Y--~A ER."EES W T ~~-~ "~~"" ' " ....
'~'-'~'~;'MAKE THEIR THEY AGREED THAT CIGARETTE SMOKE
DOES NOT SMELL GOOD TO THEM AND THAT SMOKING OFTEN CAUSES
EXTRA HOUSE...CLEANING.
(SLIDE #4O)
THESE PROBLEMS ASSOCIATED WITH SMOKING ARE CERTAINLY NOT
NEW. THEY MUST BE.AS OLD AS THE SMOKING CUSTOM ITSELF.
(SLIDE #41)
WHAT IS NEW IS THaT MORE AND MORE ACTION IS BEING TAKEN

AGAINST SMOKING.
AS WELL AS DIRECT.
THIS ACTION IS BOTH INDIRECT IN NATURE
NONSMOKERS ARE TAKING INDIRECT ACTION IN A VARIETY OF
WAYS. 55% OF NONSMOKERS CURRENTLY DO NOT DISPLAY ASHTRAYS
IN THEIR HOMES. 52% MAY COUGH OR MAKE SOME GESTURE TO -~ ...... ,~:~ ..... !~,:.;! .....
DISCOURAGE:SMOKING AND 48%SAYTHEY MOVE AWAY WHEN SOMEONE
SMOKES AROUND THEM.
(SLIDE #43)
AS FAR AS DIRECT ACTION IS CONCERNED, WE FOUND THAT 36% OF
ALL PEOPLE HAVE ASKED SOMEONE TO PUT OUT OR NOT LIGHT UP A
CIGARETTE. I MIGHT ADD THAT THE 36% INCLUDES 42% OF
NONSMOKERS AND 24% OF SMOKERS. WITH RESPECT TO WHO'S MORE
LIKELY TO TAKE DIRECT ACTION, WE FOUND THAT STRANGERS AND
CHILDREN ARE THE MOST LIKELY GROUPS TO REQUEST THAT A
SMOKER NOT SMOKE. WEALSO FOUND THAT ADULTS BETWEEN THE
AGES OF 18-34 ARE THE MOST DEMOGRAPHICALLY ACTIVE
