BAT CDC Documents
Combined Scanning Electron Microscopy and Light Microscopy Study on the Rat Larynx
Fields
- Original File
- BATCO002
- URL
- http://outside.cdc.gov/images4/00/02/49/61/doc00001.TIF
- Company
- British American Tobacco
- Date Loaded
- 04 Mar 2003
- Author
- SMITH G
- Box
- B3230-6
Document Images
COHBI:NED SCANNING ELECTRON ,I~CRDSCOFY AND LI:GHT
REPORT NO. RD. I457 REST~rCTED
21.1. 1977
AUTHOR: G. Sm.i.ch
ISSUED BY: S.R. Evelyn
PROJECT JOB NO: 11.01.07
DISTEI.BET I0N:
Dr. S.J. Green
~Js~. Z.W. Bu4Sbes
Dr. E.&. Sm~ord
E.M. G£bb, Esq.
E.S. Wade, Esq.
K.G. Nicholls, Esq.
Herr H. Sottorf
Dr. F. Seehofer
Dr. C.J.P. de S£que£ra
Dr. D.C. Felton
Library
Cc~7 No. 1
11 11 2
" " 3, 4
fl 11
" " 6, 7, 8
" " 9, 10
" " 11
" " 12
" " 13
" " 14
" " 15, 16
COPY NO:
BAT Co LTD - MINNESOTA TOBACCO LITIGATION
¢,..m
",,C>

INDEX
HAS
INDICATED
GAP IN
BATES
RANGE
HERE

GS/CuU./46D
Ocoup ltesmazch & Development Centre,
Bricish-Amecican Tobacco Co. Ltd.,
SOUTHAMPTON.
21st J=nuary 1977
COH.BII~D S~J~gNT~qG RI.1ECTiON MICROSCOPY AND LIGHT HICRDSCOPY
STUDY ON THE RAT LALYNX
C~port ~o. RD.1457 Rast=icted)
SU~qA~
Patholosical chauses observed 4. thl rat la~mx, £ollovin8
sxposuce to dilute c£sacetCe smoke, have been evaluated using light
microscopy CL~) and scannins electroum~ctoscopy CSSM). The use of the
two techniques has allowed both squamous hyperplasia (by LM) and sqtmmous
mmCaplasia (by SEN) Co be quantified and related Co the period of
exposure to, and dilution of ciKareCte smoke.
Both types of lesion £ollov similar paths of development, with a
rapid response.to a ralativaly short exposure to dilute smoke followad
by • continued increase but mt ceduced tats.
With rmsard to the applLcatlon of both techniques in any one study,
the use of • coa~on fixative (formaldahyda) sLmpllfies autopm7 procedure
buc it would be an advantas@ to duplicate rathmr than split animal
SZ'oupI •
BAT Co LTD - MINNESOTA TOBACCO LITIGATION
O,,,

INDEX
HAS
INDICATED
GAP IN
BATES
RANGE
HERE

-2-
INTRODUCTION
The development of a sqzus mecaplasLa and ke~at£nisln~ hyperplasia
in the rat larynx in response to smoke inhalation may provide a basis
for the rapid screening of wmoke toxicity in short-term inhalation
studies. Previously, pacholosical changes in the larynx have been noted
by light microscopy after a 6-weeks exposure to dilute cisarette smoke (I).
However, examination of larynxes from animals subjected to less chart
6-weeks exposure 8uEgested that changes may have taken place earlier
in the exposure period. Details are liven below of 8erLsi LH observations
of chanses in larynKeal epithelia Ln rats exposed to smoke over 6 weeks.
Corresponding SE~ observations have already hem reported for mn/Jaals
treated in the same way (2). For ease of comparison, in this report
the new LM details and a sumnary of the complmnentary SEM ~rk from
this combined exper~nent are pretested tojtther.
Using both microscopy techniques it is possible to quantify different
smoke-induced changes on the medial aspect of the vocal cord; thickening
of the epithellmn (squamous hyperplasia) by U4 and spreadlu@ o£ the
ep~thellum (squamous metaplasia) by SEH. It is hoped that by evaluative
tissue from any one study by both these methods a thorough screening of
la~js~x tissue ~r~11 be possible and maximum information on observed
c~anSes will be made ava£1able.
It is important that in • bloassay system the preparative techniques
and method of evaluatlnS are as simple, accurate and repeatable as
possible. In this report the possibility of combintn8 lisht m£croscopy
and acanninl electron m4croscopy techniques is examined, tolether with
the £easibility of us~ comnon preparative methods,
BAT Co LTD - MINNESOTA TOBACCO LITIGATION
r,,o
0%

INDEX
HAS
INDICATED
GAP IN
BATES
RANGE
HERE

-3-
MATERIALS ~D ~TnODS
,| t
The 6--pore version of the B.A.T animal exposure 8yscem yes used for
all chls work. hcs were exposed co smoke from s filter ciKareCce (354)
made from a scan~awd flue-cured blend of tobaccos. The Tlq4 deZivery of
the c£Karecce co Ohm exposure 8ysCmm gas 18.1 mg/CiK.
Ten Kroups of anlma18 were exposed co smoke ac two dilution levels,
usinK the standard 5-day mcel/~aciseCion procodure in which the duration
of exposure ks ~crommod to the full dose on d4y I. l~cails of the
groups are given in TabIe 1.
TA~-E 1
OI/YLLqE OF EXPE~~ BHOWIIqG DUR&T~ON OF EXPOSURE
FOE VARIOUS TREATMENT GqLOUPS
Exposure Period FolLowing
5-day Acclinacisttlou
(days)
1
7
14
28
42
42
Smoke DiluC£ou
(smoke:air, v/v)
L
1:8 & 1:12
1:8 & 1:12
1:8 & 1:12
1:8 & 1:12
L:8 & 1:12
1:8
(vapour phase
only)
1 8hma-mmokod and 1 coucrol ~coup ware
k£11md on each of the 5 autopsy days.
Total of 21 8~oups, 282 race.
BAT Co LTD - MINNESOTA TOBACCO LITIGATION
o%

INDEX
HAS
INDICATED
GAP IN
BATES
RANGE
HERE

-4-
There were 18 rats in each of those Stoups exposed to diluted smoke
and IZ in a group exposed to vapour phase only. Corresponding sham
smoked (12 animals per group) and cake control groups (6 animals per
group) were included for each time period, K£vins in all 21 Stoups (282
rats). Animals were k£11ed on the day follow£ng exposure, the larynxes
d£vided roughly equally for processing for either SEN or LM (see (2)
for details).
AS an additional check on processing technique, con~rol larynxes
were fixed in buffered formalin overn~ht for scanning electron microscopy.
(Gluceraldehyde is normally used but is more hasardous than formalin. )
The extent of squamou8 ep~thellum on the medial aspect of the vocal
cord mas determined by SID4 (2). Larynzes for light microscopy were cut
transversely ~o include the free edge of the vocal cords and the ventral
depression. Hmasurmmmnts were taken of maximal uniform squAmous epithelial
thickness on the medial aspect of the vocal cords, £ncludin8 the stratum
corneum i£ this was present.
OBSERVATIONS
.Light Hicroscopy
The epithelia present in the larynx sections and their relative
distribution in the sham-smoked and cage control rats wire me descrLbed
previously (3). In all control rats there was non-ciliated peeudostratifiad
column Jr and stratified squamous epLthel£um £uvestiJag the tell of the
lumen and the vocal cords.
Exposure to smoke caused squamous metaplas;- of the peeudostrat£fied
columnar cells in all rats (Table 2). This was often accompanied by the
development of a full di£ferentiated stratum corneum which increased the
BAT Co LTD - MINNESOTA TOBACCO LITIGATION
r,,o

O".
BAT Co LTD - MINNESOTA TOBACCO LITIGATION

-5-
thickness of the epithelium on the vencro-laceral surface and Ohm outer
dorsslsurface of the vocal cords. In extreme cases, Che entire lmn 4,,
secclon was invested with fully d£fferenclaced s~s cells.
Zn sev~al rats, macaplasia was incomplete ~rich foc£ of col~sm~r
cells soil1 present in the ventral region of the larynx. Examples of
t:his ~ncomplece meCaplasia occurred in most groups of smoke-exposed
anlmals and did nov appear Co be related Co exposure or Co dilution of
cigarette smoke (Table 2). The ventral depression showed no sips of
squmaous mecaplasia but there was some ~ndicaCion of coltwmar cel~
hyperplasla.
TABLE 2
S~UANOUS NZTAPLASIA OF THE EPITtELZUM LZNZNG THE LARYNGEAL LUMEN FOLLOWING EXPOSURE TO
2 DILUTIONS OF SMOKE
Exposure Period
in DaTa
1
7
14
28
42
Smoke d,
1:8
Dilutiou
TreaCsmnc
t ill
Smoked, Sham- Case
1 : 12 Smoked Control
Dilution
Number of ani:nals showinS metaplasia*
&2 vapour phase
only
919
717 (2)
8/8
SIS (1)
1o/zo (1)
o/zo
717 (2)
9/9
7/7 (2)
919 (2)
919 (1)
016 013
016 013
016 013
016 013
016 013
qigues are numbers of animals s~riq mCaplasla/uumbar
of sn~nals in group.
Fibres in parenthesis - £ucompleCe moCaplas£a.
BAT Co LTD - MINNESOTA TOBACCO LITIGATION
¢,..,m
r',,,a
",,o

BAT Co LTD - MINNESOTA TOBACCO LITIGATION
¢..m
r'~

-6-
In mnoke-exposed aninmls, chere yes invariably hypsrplasla often
with kerat£ui~at£on on the medlal ventral surfaces o£ the vocal cord,
where squamous cells are normally found. The degree of hype~plasla was
measured by 1£ght microscopy and between-group cotpar£sons made.
In both smok~-exposed groups there va~8 a rap£d increase in epithelial
th£ckness (Table 3 and ?£gure 1). A~cer the i~ttial ~ap£d Increase in
ep£thel£al thickness, no clear pattern of thanks was seen. The degree
of hyperplasLa re~ained £airly well fixed, eve~ as exposures continued.
There was no clear d£f£e~euce in response in those au~nals exposed to
smoke aC 1.8 dilutlon compared vlCh Chose 8ubjeceed eo L:12 d~luCion.
TA31~ 3
HYPER.PLA~ZA OF TIlE ,E..PZTHELZUM LINING THE I~D%A/.. ASPECT OF THE
VOCAL CORDS~ FOLLOWING EXPOSURE TO 2 DILUTIONS O~ SMOKE
Exposure Pe~£od
in Days
1
7
14
28
42
Smoked,
1:8
D:/.lut:£on
Treatment
Smoked, Sham- Cage
1:12
DiluC~ Smoked Con~ol
EpiChel£al thickness*
42 (vmpour phase
only)
.... i
28 (I0)
39 C9)
39 C7)
44 CZ3)
42 (9)
30 (ZL)
42 (6)
36 (9)
44 (8)
39 (14)
3e (9)
t9 (8)
:,3 (9)
19 (7)
20 (4)
23 (7)
14 (4)
23 (5)
26 (4)
Is (2)
23 (9)
*Yilures are mean epithelial thi~Jo~tlJ (~/l[) and (S.D.)
BAT Co LTD - MINNESOTA TOBACCO LITIGATION
cz~
r~,

(÷~t" ++'+-~"-"- "-+ ~ I''~+ t-,.,~ .)
BAT Co LTD - MINNESOTA TOBACCO LITIGATION
¢,..m
O',,,

-7-
~n many rats there was a fully dlfferentlaced stratum corneum
associated with the hyperplaeia (Table 4). Its frequency of occurrence
clmarIy fucraasad as smoke exposure continued and was always Ereater
in Chose animals subjected to the higher concentration of smoke. In
the animals exposed to smoke diluted 1:8 the proportion of rats with
kecatinizatlon of the larynx continued to increase up Co 42 days but
in those exposed to smoke at 1:12 dilution the maximum incidence of
karatinizatLon was reaehod after 28 days (¥iBure 2).
TABLE 4
KERATINISATZON ON TBE MEDIAL ASPECT OF THE VOCAL COEDS
FOLLOWING EXPOSURE TO 2 DILUTIONS OF SMOKE
TreaCnmnt
• |,
Smoked Smoked Sham- Case
i: 8 1:12 Smoked Control
Dilution D£1ucion
Number of an4m-ls show4~S k~ratlnleation*
I 2/9 (22Z) O/7 (OZ) 0/6 (OZ) 0/3 (OZ)
7 117 (14X) ].19 (11%) o/6 (o:ID o13 (OZ)
1~, 3/7 (43Z) 2/7 (29Z) 0/5 (OZ) 0/3 (0~[)
2s 4IS (soz) 4/9 (44z) o/5 (oz) o13 (oz)
42 3/4 (75Z) 4/9 (A4Z) 0/6 (Og) 013 (OX)
42 (repeat phase 1/6 (17Z) only)
*FiXates are number of Inimall lhowlng keratinisaCion/
number of animals in group end (that £ractlon as a parcmnCala).
Exposure Period
£n Days
BAT Co LTD - MINNESOTA TOBACCO LITIGATION
m
or,,,

~t.-',-rt.'w.:~ ~"~"-~..3,. ,
L
w
4>
BAT Co LTD - MINNESOTA TOBACCO LITIGATION
r,,o
Qo

-8-
Lu rats exposed to vapour phase only there was no evidence of
squamous meteplasia in the floor of the larynx and only a sliEht increase
in thickness of ep£chel£um on the vocal cords (Table 3). Only in one
rat exposed Co vapour phase was there a fully differentiated stratum
corneum. This keraC£nisation has been seen, though not co~nly, in
several control rats in prev£ou8 inhalation studies.
Scanning Electron l~croscopy
The results of this pazC of the work have been described fully in
(2) end 8unmarised in FiKure 3. &ll smoke-exposed rats showed an increase
in the extent of squamous epithelium on the medial aspect of the vocal
cord. This increase in the ~ridth of the band of 8quamous epithelium was
initially rapid and continued for up to 42 days at 8 slower rata. At each
t/Jne interval over 6 weeks the 8preedinK yes ~reater in the higher smoke
concentration Stoup and was also related Co the duration of exposure.
Rats exposed for 6 weeks to the vapour phase also showed an increase
in 8quamoue epithelium. This incre, ase , however, was less than in the
Kroups exposed to whole smoke at the same d~lution (FiKure 3).
The use of formalin rather than glutaraldehyde for SEM produced
encouraKinK results. For this type of work at low maKn~fication, it can
be used quite satimfactorilT. However, detailed work on tissue prepared
in this way would not be possible since the revised technique resulted
in some loss of cellular decaiI. Compaz4son of d~ferent procedures
showed that t~ne'for preparation of tissues may be reduced by dahydrat£nf|
material for 1 hour at IOOZ acetone rather than the acetone series
previously used.
BAT Co LTD - MINNESOTA TOBACCO LITIGATION
r,,,o

INDEX
HAS
INDICATED
GAP IN
BATES
RANGE
HERE

-9-
DISCUSSION
The use of two techniques for evaluating pathological changes in
the rat Larynx has allowed both metaplasia (by SEN) and hyperplas£a (by
I~) on the medial aspect of the vocal cords to be quantified.
The meCaplasia measured by SEN was related to both smoke concentration
and duration of exposure as descr£bed previously (2). Squamous me~aplas£a
on the ventro-lateral surface, as earlier experiments had 8uKKested,
occurred after e relatively short exposure and was found in all smoke-
exposed race. £t was ms characteristic that the presence of this feature
alone was sufficient for ident£ficat£on of a smoke-exposed au~mal. The
occurrence of incomplete metaplasia i.e. where loci of columnar cells
pers£sc ~n the ventro-lateral surface, does not appear to be smoke-
related. The presence of small £oc£ of columnar cells in the in£oldings
o£ the ventral surface was not sufficLent to classify a utaplasia as
incomplete. Observat£ous by SEM show such cells to be wall below the
general level of the epithelial surface end perhaps protected from the
affect of £nhelod smoks.
The deKree of hyperplas£a on the med/~l aspect o£ the vocal cord,
measured by liKht m£croscopy did not follow any obv£ous trend £ollo~.~aK
the initial, rapid thicken~ and could not clearly be related to durat£on
of exposure or smoke d£1ut£on, at least for the particular conditions
used in this study. The lesion did develop rapfdly however, and became
sv4dent after only 5 days of accl~matisation plus ono day of 'full'
exposure, fan indication of the rats' respiratory behaviour during
exposure would greatly aid interprecatlon of these observations.)
In the h~h 8moke concentration Stoups, and to loss an extent the
low concenCraClon groups, meCeplaels (by scanninK electron microscopy)
~mmm~
r~
C~
BAT Co LTD - MINNESOTA TOBACCO LITIGATION

INDEX
HAS
INDICATED
GAP IN
BATES
RANGE
HERE
.............................................................. "---'T

-10-
and h~,perplas~t (by lijht aicroscopy) £ollowmd a s~m£1er race o£ development.
For both conditions, there was a rapid response to a relatively short
exposure. This was £oZ1owed by • scabil£smcion o£ the hyperplas£a and
a continued increase in the mmtaplas£a though at • reduced rate. T~ the
"case o£ the metaplasia the explanation for the reduced rate of development
t
may thus not be the presence o£ ~ types o£ colu:mar eplthelh as was
oriK£nally thouKht (2). Tt may be chat maximum e,Yfect occurs a£ter only
4-6 weeks exposure irrespective of the epithelial involved.
The siKni££cance o£ a meal1 increase in mean Kroup epithelial
thickness £n the an~nAIs exposed to vapour phase only Ls di£££c~It to
define at present. With such small numbers per Kroup, one mn/Jnal with •
thickened epithelium (due to • stratum corneum) could puc an unfelt bias
on the nun value for epithal/2Ll thickness. It may, however, be •
8enuine reaction bearing in mind the marked Lab£11ty oF the l•rTnKeal
eplthel~s. Further york £8 needed before the contribut£on o£ vapour
phase to the changes in laryngeal structure £ollovinS smoke exposure can
be assessed adequately.
Two di££erent techniques have been used here to evaluate chansas in
the rat larynx. The study has shown thl problems of div£din8 relatively
small Stoups o£ larynx smnplts i~to Chose £or SEH and LM. Would it be
possible to split each larynx, one hal£ foe U4, the other £or
The sa4Bittal d£vlsion o£ the l•rynx may. £n fact, be dtff£cult to
s~tndaz4ise and there is • distinct llkelihood that the tissue will be
damaged during dissection. With regard to hyperplas~s on the medlal
aspect o£ the vocal cords, assuming •ccurate section£n8 the reaction to
smoke £s somet4mes not equal on both vocal co:de. Thus // one cord o~Iy
BAT Co LTD - MINNESOTA TOBACCO LITIGATION
O',,

INDEX
HAS
INDICATED
GAP IN
BATES
RANGE
HERE

-11-
is available, 8 d£££srent set o£ measurements ~uld result as compared
w£ch whole-larwnx secc£ons.
The mall amount of work rattled ouc on us£ns formalin fixed tissue
for SEN suKKesCs chac ac the lov maKnif£cat£ous used, ic may be possible
to make use o£ a co--on £~ciCive. This ~would, for example, m~mpl~y
autopsy techniques. Zt muse be noced chac derailed hish mL~fficaCion
studies wouZd not however be pracc£cal on such tissue. Also preparative
Cecbuiques £or SEN can be s/mpli£ied by dehydrat~ in IOOZ acetone and
hoe usinK sec£es of acecone d£1uc£on~.
Zn conclusion, the rat Larynx shovs chanses Ln epicheliaZ arransemancs
(squmnous hyperplasla, squsmous meCaplasia) after short-term exposure co
smoke. Zn general, changes are related Co both exposure duration and
smoke dilution. KoCh LH and SEM techniques for assessing these responses
era useful and complement each other. However, at ch£s stase :LE both
are to be used on any study it mould be an advancaKe Co duplicate groups
o£ au£mals co alloy processing o£ individual rathnr chart divided Zarynxes.
RXFEKENCES
I.
2.
3.
BAT Keporc Bo. RD. 1328 RmsCr£cCed, 13.2.76.
BAT Report No. KD.1400 Restricted, 11.8.76.
BAT Keport No. RD.1387 Uuclass£f£ed, 30.7.76.
BAT Co LTD - MINNESOTA TOBACCO LITIGATION
O",
r',o
%0

FIB. I P,D. 1457 RF.STRIC, TED
EPITHELIAL THIGKNE,~S (~m) Oi~i THE MEDIAL A~PF.LT
VOCAL CORD
OF THE
M EAINI IIK~P
T~GK~ESS ~rr~
O I "11 lii~l~l[ OILUYION
• I:11. aI'IOKE OILU'TIQN
X ~ a4~OKED
A CA~E Gom~Q~.
~n
~Y8
ACG LI MAT ISAT ION
EXPOSURE PERIOD IN DAY8
BAT Co LTD - MINNESOTA TOBACCO LITIGATION
¢1::::
O',,

FI6. 2
KERATINISATION PER 6ROUP ON THE
im
OF THE VOCAL COR~
R~. 145"7 RES"TRICTE£)
A,SPEC.,T
(!) I : II ~IOKE DILUTION
• I" 12 ~MORE DILUTION
RATS PER GROUP WITH
FULLY DIFFmRENTIATEO
S'mATUM ¢ORNEUH "/o
BAT Co LTD - MINNESOTA TOBACCO LITIGATION
O',,
r~

FI~, ,5 RI:). 145"/ RESTRtC, T1EO
VAPLIATION lhl THE WIDTH OF THE 5QUAMOU5 EP|.THEUUP~
ON THE ME~.L ASPECT OF THE VOCAL CORI). LEVEL I.
t: S &I~,DKE DILU'TtON
I: 12 ~OKE DILUTION
X 6HAM 81vIIOHED
CAGE COl~~
V V'AFIOUIR IPHAS~ ON L~I
---AREA ABOVE. LINE IrtDIC, ATES
CILIA'rED EPlTHF.LIUM IN THE.
*NORIVlAC RAT LAR~'NX
°,'V
~TRATIFIED ~QUAMOU~
EPI'I'I-EUIJII~ WlO'TH (/.Lm)
6OO
4O0
ZOO
)AYS 0 I0 10 &O 4O V
AOCI,.IMATISATION EXPO6URE PERIOD IN OAY8 _._
C~
r~
BAT Co LTD - MINNESOTA TOBACCO LITIGATION

INDEX
HAS
INDICATED
GAP IN
BATES
RANGE
HERE

BAT Co LTD - MINNESOTA TOBACCO LITIGATION
